Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C). No.413 of 2023
1.
Arun Debnath, S/O -Late Krishna Debnath, Resident of -Village- Fulbari
Kandi, P.O- Noorpur, P.S- Kailashahar, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti
Tripura, Tripura, Age-36 years
2.
Nazmul Haque, S/o-Fazil Haque, R/o- Village- Fulbari Kandi, P.ONoorpur, P.S- Kailashahar, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti Tripura,
Tripura, Age-39 years
3.
Fatema Begum, W/o- Samsur Ali, R/o- Village- Fulbari Kandi, P.ONoorpur, P.S- Kailashahar, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti Tripura,
Tripura, Age-29 years
4.
Rubina Begum, W/o- Abdul Rashid, R/o- Village- Fulbari Kandi, P.ONoorpur, P.S- Kailashahar, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti Tripura,
Tripura, Age-34 years.
.....Petitioners
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
1.
The State of Tripura, (To be represented by the Secretary, Department of
Panchayet, Government of Tripura), New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S - New Capital Complex, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN 799010
2.
The Director, Department of Panchayet, Govt. of Tripura, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799006
3.
The DM & Collector, Unakoti District, Kailashahar, Govt. of Tripura.
4.
The District Panchayet Officer, Govt. of Tripura, Unakoti District,
Kailashahar, Govt. of Tripura,
5.
The Block Development Officer, Govt. of Tripura, Gournagar R.D Block,
Kailashahar, Unakoti Tripura
6.
Bharatiya Janata Party, represented by the President, Paitur Bazar,
Kailashahar, Unakoti District.
.....Respondents.
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
Legal reporting
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. B. Paul, Advocate.
11.12.2023
:
:
13.12.2023
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
_J_U_D_G_M_E_N_T_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners also heard Mr. M.
Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. and Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. B. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The present petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India for quashing and cancelling the impugned declarations
dated 12.06.2023 issued under Form-6B [Rule-27(4)] issued by the BDO,
Gournagar RD Block, Kailashahar, Unakoti Tripura, whereby declaring that the
petitioners have earned disqualification and ceased to be members of the
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat. Further, directing the respondents not to hold
any bye-election to fill up the panchayat seats of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat,
in consequence of the declarations made to the effect that the petitioners have
earned disqualification and ceased to be the members of Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat till disposal of the present petition.
[3]
The facts in brief are that the petitioners are an elected member of
the Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti Tripura. Out
of the 11 members of the Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat, 8 members were
sponsored by the BJP Party. Thereafter, the BDO, Gournagar RD Block issued
show cause notice to the petitioners to show cause as to why they will not be
disqualified from being member of the panchayat due to alleged violation f the
party whip. The petitioners replied that no whip was issued to them. Even
thereafter, by the impugned order dated 12.06.2023 issued by the BDO,
Gournagar RD Block, the petitioners have been declared to be disqualified to be
the member of the Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat. Thereafter, declaration also to
that effect has been issued. As there is no whip issued by the respondent No.6,
so question of violation of party whip does not arise. Without appreciating the
letter and spirit of Section-16 of the Tripura Panchayat Act, the petitioners have
been disqualified to be the member of Gram Panchayat. Against such arbitrary
decision of the respondents, the present petition has been filed.
[4]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has submitted that
the petitioners who are the duly elected members of the Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat have challenged the declarations dated 12.06.2023 issued by the
BDO, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti District, Kailashshar to the effect that the
petitioners have earned disqualification and ceased to be the members of the
Fulbarkandi Gram Panchayat. It has been purportedly held that the petitioners
have earned disqualification and resultant thereto ceased to be the members of
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat. Without serving any whip to the petitioners,
without considering the reply to the show cause notice and without making any
compliance with the mandate of Section-16 of the Tripura Panchayat Act, 1993.
[5]
On 21.02.2022, the petitioners along with three other members of
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat, lodged a complaint to the District Panchayat
Officer, Unakoti District, Kailashahar for removal of pradhan of Fulbarikandi
Gram Panchayat. In the complaint, it has been stated that the Pradhan has taken
autocratic decision in respect to selection of beneficiaries regarding distribution
of fund under Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (Urban)-PMAY (U). In the
complaint, the petitioners also protested against the corruption in respect to
construction of village road, soiling and RCC by the Pradhan the said complaint
was made under Form-2 (Rule-5(2) of Tripura Panchayat (Election of Office
Bearers) Rules, 1994.
[6]
Thereafter, vide notification dated 23.02.2022 in terms of Sub-
section-3 of Section-23 of the Tripura Panchayat Act notice were issued to all
the members of the Gram Panchayat that a meeting will be convened on
10.03.2022 in connection with no-confidence motion against Pradhan.
Thereafter, Panchayat Extension Officer was appointed as Presiding officer to
preside over the meeting. On 10.03.2022 special meeting was held for removal
of Pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayaty. In the meeting 7 memebrs voted
in favour of no confidence motion against the Pradhan and 4 members voted
against the motion. Proceedings have been recorded in the minutes of the
meeting by the DPO, Unakoti Tripura.
[7]
It has been contended that in the proceeding notice, it was
mentioned that whip has been read out but fact remains that no whip has been
read out. In the proceeding note there is no written acknowledgement of the
petitioners to the effect that whip was read out in the meeting. In the remarks
column, there is no whisper to that effect that whip was read over and served to
the petitioners. In the remark column of the proceeding of the meeting of
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat it is not mentioned that the petitioners have earned
disqualification in terms of Rule-27(1) of the Tripura Panchayat (Election of
Office Bearers) Rules, 1994.
[8]
It is mandatory that if any elected member of Gram Panchayat
votes or abstains from voting contrary to party whip, then it should be recorded
by the Presiding Officer in the Remark Column against the name of such
member. But in the proceeding of the Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat meeting
there is no such mention against the name of the each of the petitioners. Even in
the remarks column it is not mentioned that whip was served to the members
including the petitioners herein.
[9]
Mr. Barman, learned senior counsel has argued on the point that as
no action has been done in terms of the minutes of the meeting, as stated above,
on 15.03.2022 the petitioners and 3 others also submitted representation to the
District Panchayat Officer, Unakoti District, Kailashahar and prayed for issuance
of removal letter in favour of Pradhan. Thereafter, the District Panchayat
Officer, Unakoti District vide order dated 16.03.2022 in exercise of power
conferred
under
Sub Rule-6 of
Rule-5 of
the Tripura
Panchayats
(Administration) Rules, 1994 removed Sundar Mia from the office of the
Pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat under Gournagar RD Block.
[10]
Subsequently, the petitioners jointly filed writ petition being
WP(C) No.418 of 2022 challenging their disqualification vide impugned
order/declaration dated 20.04.2022 issued by the BDO, Gournagar RD Block.
This Court vide order dated 29.03.2023 allowed the writ petition by quashing
and setting aside the impugned order/declarations dated 20.04.2022 issued by
the BDO Gournagar RD Block. Thereafter a meeting of Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat was conveyed on 28.04.2023 for election of Pradhan. 11 members
participated in voting by raising their hands. Out of 11 members 7 members
voted in favour of Najmul Hoque and 4 members voted in favour of Kanu
Debnath. In the meeting, Arun Debnath, proposed the name of Najmul Hoque,
the petitioner No.2 as Pradhan and Sundor Mia, proposed the name of Kanu
Debnath as Pradhan. Thereafter, members participated in the election and
Najmul Hoque the petitioner No.2 secured and votes and Kanu Debnath secure 4
votes.
[11]
The BDO Gournagar RD Block issued memo dated 29.05.2023
against the petitioners asking them to show cause as to why they shall not be
disqualified from being members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat as per
Clause(b) Sub-Section-1 of Section-16 of Tripura Panchayat Act, 1993. In the
memorandum, it is mentioned that he presiding officer of the meeting for
election of pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat have informed that the
petitioners had voted in the voting process or acted in contrary to the direction
issued by the political party and they have become liable for disqualification
under Section-16 of the Act, 1993 and Rules-27 of Rules, 1994.
[12]
It has been further contended that each of the petitioners submitted
reply to the show cause notice on 03.06.2023. In the reply, the petitioners stated
that they have not earned disqualification. The petitioners further asserted that
no whips were issued or served upon them by the political party on or before the
meeting. The petitioners also stated that before obtaining their replies, the BDO,
Gournagar RD Block, has unilaterally decided against them, by coming to the
conclusion that the petitioners voted against the party whip. The petitioners
stated that it is unfortunate and it is against the principle of natural justice and it
is amounts to being condemned unheard. All the petitioners submitted similar
and identical reply.
[13]
From the minutes of the proceedings of the Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayet, held on 28.04.2013, reveals, that, no whip was served upon them
before the meeting. From the minutes it is found that, 8 Party whips had been
received by the District Panchayat Officer. The whips were not served upon the
Petitioners even in course of the meetings. Moreover, whip, if any, was not also
read out before commencement of the meeting. Without considering the reply to
the Show Cause Notice, more specifically without considering that no Whip was
issued and if issued, the said Whip was not served upon the petitioners, the
BDO, Gournagar RD Block, issued impugned Order, dated 12.06.2023,
disqualifying the membership of the petitioners on the alleged ground of
violation of party whip.
[14]
In the impugned Order, dated, 12.06.2023, there is no whisper as
to whether whip was issued & if issued whether such whip was served on the
Petitioners. The Petitioners in their reply to the show cause notice, categorically
asserted, that, no whip was issued & no whip was served on them. This
categorical assertion of the Petitioners have not been dealt with in the impugned
order, dated, 12.06.2023 & the BDO, Gournagar RD Block, did not consider, it
necessary to gave specific finding on such assertion of the Petitioners on the
basis of the minutes of the proceeding of the meeting of Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat, which was held on 28.04.2023. Without considering the reply to the
show cause notice, & without dealing with the specific assertion, made by the
petitioners in the reply to the show cause notice so far non issuance & non
receipt of party whip, upon the petitioners, in blatant disregard & disobedience
of the mandate of Section-16 of the Tripura Panchayat Act, the BDO, Gournagar
RD Block, issued the impugned declaration to the effect, that, the Petitioners
have earned disqualification and therefore ceased to be a member of the
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat.
[15]
Before making the impugned declarations, declaring that, the
petitioners have earned disqualifications and ceased to be a Members of the
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat, the BDO did not act in compliance with the
rigorous provisions of Section-16 of the Act, 1994. The impugned Order &
declarations, both dated, 12.06.2023, holding, that, the petitioners have earned
disqualification of their membership have been issued against the letter and spirit
of Section-16 of the Act, 1993. The petitioners do not attract any of the grounds
as enumerated under Section-16 of the Act, 1993 for earning disqualification.
Most arbitrarily & illegally, being swayed by extraneous consideration, the
BDO, the respondent No-5 has issued the impugned declarations, declaring that,
the petitioners have earned disqualification & ceased to be a member of the
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayet, Gournagar RD Block, Unakoti. The fact remains,
that, the petitioners have not earned disqualification & the petitioners have not
ceased to be members of the Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat.
[16]
The petitioners have strong prima facie case and the impugned
action of the respondents is ex-facie illegal and arbitrary. The petitioners are
very much confident, that, the writ petition will be allowed by this Court. During
the pendency of the writ petition, the respondents are required to be restrained
from holding any election to the Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayet to fill up the seats
which were held by the petitioners. The impugned Order & declarations, dated,
12.06.2023, issued by the BDO, Gournagar R.D Block declaring, that, the
petitioners has earned disqualifications under Section-16 of the Tripura
Panchayat Act, 1993 to be a members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayet, are
required to be stayed.
[17]
Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. B.
Paul, learned counsel appearing for the respondents has submitted that the
present writ petition is not maintainable because of the fact that the question
involved in this writ petition is a disputed question of fact and therefore the writ
petition of the petitioner is liable to be dismissed in limine. At the very outset,
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has contended that the petition under
consideration is not maintainable inasmuch as, the petitioners do not disclose
any cause of action relating to the failure of the state respondents to carry out
any statutory obligation and or any Constitutional obligation for which this high
prerogative writ Jurisdiction of this Court may be invoked to issue necessary
direction upon the State respondents.
[18]
It has been stated that declaration dated 12th June, 2023 had been
made in exercise of the powers conferred by Section-16 of the Tripura
Panchayat Act, 1993 read with sub Rule (2) and sub-Rule (3) of Rule 27 of the
Tripura Panchayats (Election of office Bearers) Rules, 1994. The declarations
mentioned above was made based on the proceedings regarding election of
pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat under Gournagar R.D. Block held on
28/04/2023 at 11.00 am submitted by the Presiding Officer appointed for
election of pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat under Gournagar R.D.
Block to the Director of Panchayets dated 02.05.2023 and in which the Presiding
Officer has categorically stated that " as per vote casted in Form- 05, it was
observed that" following members voted in the voting process or acted contrary
to the direction issued by the political party and liable for disqualification under
Section-16 of Tripura Panchayat Act, 1993 and Section-27 of Tripura Panchayat
(Election of Office Bearer) Rules, 1994.
[19]
For the purpose of reference, Section 16(3) of the Tripura
Panchayat, Act 1993 reads as follows:“If any question arises as to whether a member of a Gram Panchayat has
become subject to disqualification under this section, the question shall be
referred for decision of the Block Development Officer having jurisdiction
over such Gram Panchayat and his decision shall be final”.
Further, Rule-27 of the Tripura Panchayat (Election of office Bearers)
Rules, 1994 reads as follows;“27(1) In any meeting of a Gram Panchayat, or a Panchayat Samity or a
Zilla Parishad where vote is taken for election or for any other purpose, the
presiding Officer shall if his attention is drawn that any member has voted
or abstained from voting contrary to the direction of the Political Party to
which he belongs and thereby has earned disqualification under section 16
or section 76 or section 128 record the facts in the remarks column of the
record of Proceedings of the meeting, obtain clarification from such
member and then refer the question to the Block Development Officer
having jurisdiction for decision in Form-6A.”
Rule-27(4) of Tripura Panchayat (Election of office Bearers) Rule 1994
states that "if the authority as aforesaid is satisfied on the basis of the report
of the presiding officer and after making such inquiry as he may consider
necessary that any such member has become disqualified under section16
record his decision, communicate it to the Gram Panchayat and make
declaration in Form 6 B". In this particular case the proceeding report as
submitted by the presiding officer and subsequent inquiry report clearly
mentioned that during the meeting of election of Pradhan of Fulabrikandi
Gram Panchayat under Gournagar R.D. Block held on 28.04.2023 at 11.00
AM and the members had voted in the voting process or acted contrary to
the direction issued by the Political Party.
[20]
It is noteworthy to mention here that along with the show cause
reply, petitioners did not submit any substantial evidence to prove that they did
not receive the party Whip on or before the election of Pradhan of Fulbarikandi
Gram Panchayat. Therefore, the declarations dated 12.06.2023 was done in
compliance with the mandate of Section-16 of the Tripura Panchayat Act 1993
and Tripura Panchayat (Election of office Bearers) Rules-1994 and after due
consideration of the show cause reply submitted by the petitioners. It has been
further contended that the BDO Gournagar R.D. Block had issued the
memorandum dated 29.05.2023 to the petitioners asking them to show cause as
to why they should not be disqualified from members of Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat as the presiding officer of the meeting of Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat conveyed for election of Pradhan on 28.04.2023 at Fulbarikandi
Gram Panchayat at 11 AM. The presiding officer had submitted one Form-6A
and submitted that the same members earned disqualification under Section-16
of "The Tripura Panchayats Act 1993" and referred the issue of deciding the
question of their disqualification for decision under sub Section(2) or as the case
may be (3) or both Section-16 of the Act.
[21]
In the proceeding note as submitted by the presiding Officer of the
meeting for election of pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat under
Gournagar R.D. Block held on 28.04.2023 at 11 AM also mentioned that
4(Four) members had voted in the voting process or acted contrary to the
direction issued by the political party and are liable for disqualification under
Section-16 of Tripura Panchayat Act 1993 and Section-27 of Tripura Panchayat
(Election of office Bearer) Rule, 1994. Furthermore, on 29.04.2023, the District
President of the political party which sponsored the petitioners have intimated
that above mentioned four members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat had
violated the party whip and they had voted in the voting process or acted
contrary to the direction issued by the political party.
[22]
It has been further averred that in show cause reply dated
03.06.2023 the petitioners herein did not adduce any substantial evidence in
support of their claim that they were not served whips or no whips were served
upon them by the political party on or before the meeting dated 28.04.2023. The
allegation brought by the petitioners before obtaining their replies the BDO
Gournagar R.D. Block has unilaterally decided against them by coming to the
conclusion that the petitioners voted against the party whip is totally false as
petitioners had submitted their replies on 03.06.2023 and declarations were
made on 12.06.2023 and which is after giving due consideration of their replies.
[23]
Furthermore, through issuance of show cause notices to all four
members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat were given fair chance in order to
place and established their side along with sufficient evidence for consideration
on the same as a principle of Natural Justice and this was also mentioned in the
order dated 12.06.2023. It has been stated that, the Presiding Officer appointed
for election of Pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram panchayat under Gournagar R.D.
Block has clearly stated in his proceeding report that "as per vote casted in
Form-05, it was observed that following members voted in the voting process or
acted contrary to the direction issued by the political party and liable for
disqualification under Section-16 of Tripura Panchayat Act 1993 and Section-27
of Tripura Panchayat (Election of office Bearer) Rule, 1994. Therefore, from the
proceeding mentioned above, it clearly proves that all four members as
petitioners had voted in the voting process or acted contrary to the direction
issued by the political party and liable for disqualification.
[24]
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has contended that the BDO
Gournagar R.D. Block had issued the memorandum dated 29.05.2023 to the
petitioners asking them to show cause as to why they shall not be disqualified
from members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat as the presiding officer of the
meeting of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat conveyed for election of Pradhan on
28.04.2023 at Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat at 11 AM had submitted one Form
6A and brought to my notice that same members have earned disqualification
under Section-16 of "The Tripura Panchayats Act 1993" and referred the issue of
deciding the question of their disqualification for decision under sub Section(2)
or as the case may be (3) or both section 16 of the Act.
[25]
In the proceeding note submitted by the presiding Officer of the
meeting for election of Pradhan of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat under
Gournagar R.D. Block held on 28.04.2023 at 11 AM also mentioned that
4(Four) members had voted in the voting process or acted contrary to the
direction issued by the political party and liable for disqualification under
Section-16 of Tripura Panchayat Act 1993 and Section-27 of Tripura Panchayat
(Election of office Bearer) Rule 1994.
[26]
Furthermore, on 29.04.2023, the District President of the political
party which sponsored the petitioners have intimated that above mentioned four
members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat had violated the party whip and they
had voted in the voting process or acted contrary to the direction issued by the
political party. It has been contended that the declaration dated 12.06.2023 was
made in compliance with the provision of Section-16 (3) of the Tripura
Panchayat Act 1993 read with Rule-27(1) and (4) of the Tripura Panchayat
(Election of office Bearers) Rules, 1994. No steps have been taken in order to
fill up any vacant Panchyat seat or holding up of any bye-election at
Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat from office of the BDO Gournagar R.D. Block.
[27]
It has been submitted that the petitioners have suppressed the fact
that prior to the election dated 28.04.2023, the respondent had called all the
elected members of BJP Party on 22.04.2023 and there was a verbal discussion
with the elected members of Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat, nominated/
sponsored by the BJP, regarding the whip of the party to elect/ nominate Sri
Kanu Debnath for the post of Pradhan for Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat and in
that meeting, it was unambiguously disclosed to all the elected members of the
party, including the petitioners, that this time Sri Kanu Debnath will be the
candidate of BJP Party for the post of Pradhan for Fulbarikandi Gram Panchayat.
[28]
It is further stated that on that day, the petitioners openly expressed
their disagreement to the aforesaid decision of the BJP Party, on various pretext,
further expressing that they would not follow the said dictum/ whip of the party
and would not support Sri Kanu Debnath as the Pradhan for Fulbarikandi Gram
Panchayat. Being confronted with such a situation, the President of the District
and being duly authorized by the State BJP President, had no other alternative,
thereafter communicated the whip of the BJP Party, by way of registered post,
addressed to their respective residential addresses on 25.04.2023.
[29]
The Registered letters containing the written whip of the BJP
Party, in respect of the petitioners dated 25.04.2023 were returned undelivered
back to the respondent No. 6, with the postal remark that the letters were refused
by all the petitioners. The original envelops, containing the written whip of the
respondent No. 6 are annexed here with and marked as Annexure-R/8. In view
of the aforesaid facts it is more than apparent that the petitioners have willfully
and deliberately violated the whip of the BJP party. It may further be stated here
that Section-27 of the General Clauses Act specifies that when a registered letter
is sent to a recognized address and has been refused to be accepted by the
addressee it is a proper and legal service of any communication.
[30]
In view of the same, the plea of the petitioners that they were not
communicated with the whip of the BJP party, is unsustainable in all manners.
Be it pointed out that the respondent No. 6 had issued the written whip of the
BJP party on 25.04.2023 to the members of the present gram panchayat but only
the registered letters of the petitioners were refused by them and all the other 4
members had received the written communication dated 25.04. 2023.
[31]
By disagreeing with the decision of the party verbally
communicated to the petitioners on 22.04.2023 and by refusing to receive the
written communication dated 25.04.2023, sent through registered post, the
petitioners have expressed themselves that they are not willing to abide by the
whip of the BJP party and therefore there is no room for the petitioners to
challenge the disqualification on any legal footing.
[32]
The only point which has been ventilated by Mr. P. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners is that which is said to have
been issued has not been put to notice with regard to the meeting that has been
scheduled on 10.03.2022. Since, they are not aware about the said meeting, the
respondents cannot find fault with the petitioners and as such, they cannot
terminate them on the ground as they have violated the same. Hence, the said
removal needs to be set aside.
[33]
Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. B.
Paul, learned counsel appearing for the respondents has placed on record the
notice which are sent through registered post with A/D were returned as the
same were refused by the addressee with the postal endorsement. The sealed
cover which are received by the respondents were placed on record and in the
open Court the same were opened indicating that the notices which were signed
on 22.04.2023 and sent to the petitioners through RPAD wherein, the meeting
was scheduled on 28.04.2023 and on the envelop also the postal authorities have
indicated that the same is refused by the addressee on 28.04.2023.
[34]
For the purpose of reference, Section-16 of the Tripura Panchayat
Act, 1993 may be reproduced herein below:
“Disqualification on ground of defection"
"16 (1) A member of a Gram Panchayat belonging to any political party
shall be disqualified for being a member of the Gram Panchayat (a) if he has
voluntarily given up his membership of such political party or
(b) if he votes or abstains from voting in the Gram Panchayat contrary to
any direction issued by the Political Party to which he belongs or by any
person or authority authorised by it in this behalf, without obtaining in
either case, the prior written permission of such political party, persons or
authority and such voting or abstention has not been condoned by such
political party, person or authority within thirty days from the date of such
voting or abstention.
Explanation: For the purpose of this sub-section, a member of a Gram
Panchayat shall be deemed to belong to the political party, if any, by which
he was set up as a candidate for election as such member.
(2) A member of a Gram Panchayat who has been elected as such,
otherwise than as a candidate set up by any political party, shall be
disqualified for being a member of the Gram Panchayat if he joins any
political party after such election.
NOTE: For the purpose of this Section, "political party" means a political
party which has been recognised by the Election Commission of India as a
national party or as a state party of this State.
(3) If any question arises as to whether a member of a Gram Panchayat has
become subject to disqualification under this Section, the question shall be
referred for decision of the Block Development Officer having jurisdiction
over such Gram Panchayat and his decision shall be final.
(4) The proceeding under sub-section (3) shall be completed and decision
thereon shall be communicated within fifteen days from the date when any
such question has been referred.
(5) During pendency of a proceeding, no decision shall be taken by the
Gram Panchayat in any meeting for the removal or election of the Pradhan
or the Upa-Pradhan.
(6) The disqualification under this Section shall take effect from the date of
the decision of the Block Development Officer.
20. That, Rule-27 of the Tripura Panchayat (Election of Office Bearers)
Rules, 1994, reads as follows:"27.(1) In any meeting of a Gram Panchayat, or a Panchayat Samity or a
Zilla Parishad, where vote is taken for election or for any other purpose, the
Presiding officer shall, if his attention is drawn that any member has voted
or abstained from voting contrary to the direction of the political Party to
which he belongs and thereby has earned disqualification under Section- 16,
or Section-76 or Section-128 record the facts in the remarks column of the
record of proceedings of the meeting, obtain clarification from such member
and then refer the question to the Block Development Officer or as the case
may be, the District Magistrate having jurisdiction for decision in Form6A,or 12A or 17A as the case may be.
2. If the Gram Panchayat or a Panchayat Samity or Zila Parishad received a
written information from a political party or from a member that, the
member has voluntarily given up the membership of the party or the
member having been elected otherwise than as a member of political party
has joined the political party, the Pradhan or Upa Pradhan in case of Gram
Panchayat, the Chairman or Vice Chairman in case of Panchayat Samity or
Sabhadhipati or SahakariSabhadhipati in case of Zila Parishad shall refer
the question to the block Development Officer or as the case may be the
District Magistrate to decise whether such member has earned
disqualification under Section-16, or Section-76 or Section-128 in Form 6A,
12A or 17A as the case may be.
3. Every such member who is alleged to have earned disqualification by
reason of voting or abstain from voting contrary to the direction of his
political party, may submit letter or prior permission or condonation to the
Block Development Officer, or as the case may be, the District magistrate
having jurisdiction within 30 days from the date of voting and such
authority shall take up the question of disqualification only after expiry of
the said period of thirty days and decide the same within 15 days from the
expiry of the said period of thirty days.
4. If the authority as aforesaid, is satisfied on the basis of the report of the
Presiding Officer & after making such inquiry as he may consider necessary
that any such member has become disqualified under Section-16 or as the
case may be Section-76, or Section-128, record his decision, communicate it
to the Gram Panchayat concerned, or as the case may be, the Panchayat
Samity or the Zila Parishad and make declaration in Form 6B, or 12B, or
17B as the case may be, that the m ember of the Gram Panchayat, or as the
case may be, the Panchayat Samity or the Zila parishad.”
[35]
The Hon’ble Apex Court in C.C. Alavi Haji vs. Palapetty
Muhammed & Another has reiterated the said principle that presumption of
service of notice has been effected when it is sent to the correct address by
registered post. In view of the said presumption, when stating that a notice has
been sent by registered post to the address of the drawer, it is unnecessary to
further aver in the complaint that in spite of the return of the notice un-served, it
is deemed to have been served or that the addressee deemed to have knowledge
of the notice.
For the purpose of reference the same principle may be
reproduced hereunder:
“14. Section 27 gives rise to a presumption that service of notice has been
effected when it is sent to the correct address by registered post. In view of
the said presumption, when stating that a notice has been sent by registered
post to the address of the drawer, it is unnecessary to further aver in the
complaint that in spite of the return of the notice unserved, it is deemed to
have been served or that the addressee is deemed to have knowledge of the
notice. Unless and until the contrary is proved by the addressee, service of
notice is deemed to have been effected at the time at which the letter would
have been delivered in the ordinary course of business. This Court has
already held that when a notice is sent by registered post and is returned
with a postal endorsement refused or not available in the house or
house locked or shop closed or addressee not in station , due
service has to be presumed. [Vide Jagdish Singh Vs. Natthu Singh ; State of
M.P. Vs. Hiralal & Ors. and V.Raja Kumari Vs. P.Subbarama Naidu & Anr.
] It is, therefore, manifest that in view of the presumption available under
Section 27 of the Act, it is not necessary to aver in the complaint under
Section 138 of the Act that service of notice was evaded by the accused or
that the accused had a role to play in the return of the notice unserved.”
[36]
It is well settled that a notice refused to be accepted by the
addressee can be presumed to have been served on him in a case of the Apex
Court Harcharan Singh v. Shivrani, reported in (1981 (2) SCC 535) wherein, it
has been held thus:
“Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 deals with the topic-'Meaning
of service by post' and says that where any Central Act or Regulation
authorises or requires any document to be served by post, then unless a
different intention appears, the service shall be deemed to be effected by
properly addressing, pre-paying and posting it by registered post, a letter
containing the document, and unless the contrary is proved, to have been
effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary
course of post. The section thus arises a presumption of due service or
proper service if the document sought to be served is sent by properly
addressing, pre-paying and posting by registered post to the addressee and
such presumption is raised irrespective of whether any acknowledgement
due is received from the addressee or not. It is obvious that when the section
raises the presumption that the service shall be deemed to have been
effected it means the addressee to whom the communication is sent must be
taken to have known the contents of the document sought to be served upon
him without anything more. Similar presumption is raised under Illustration
(f) to Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act whereunder it is stated that the
Court may presume that the common course of business has been followed
in a particular case, that is to say, when a letter is sent by post by pre-paying
and properly addressing it the same has been received by the addreseee.
Undoubtedly, the presumptions both under Section 27 of the General
Clauses Act as well as under Section 114 of the Evidence Act are rebuttable
but in the absence of proof to the contrary the presumption of proper service
or effective service on the addressee would arise. In the instant case,
additionally, there was positive evidence of the postman to the effect that
the registered envelope was actually tendered by him to the appellant on
November 10, 1966 but the appellant refused to accept. In other words,
there was due service effected upon the appellant by refusal. In such
circumstances, we are clearly of the view, that the High Court was right in
coming to the conclusion that the appellant must be imputed with the
knowledge of the contents of the notice which he refused to accept. It is
impossible to accept the contention that when factually there was refusal to
accept the notice on the part of the appellant he could not be visited with the
knowledge of the contents of the registered notice because, in our view, the
presumption raised under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act as well as
under Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act is one of proper or effective
service which must mean service of everything that is contained in the
notice. It is impossible to countenance the suggestion that before knowledge
of the contents of the notice could be imputed the sealed envelope must be
opened and read by the addressee or when the addressee happens to be an
illiterate person the contents should be read over to him by the postman or
someone else. Such things do not occur when the addressee is determined to
decline to accept the sealed envelope. It would, therefore, be reasonable to
hold that when service is effected by refusal of a postal communication the
addressee must be imputed, with the knowledge of the contents thereof and
in our view, this follows upon the presumptions that are raised under
Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 and Section 114 of the Indian
Evidence Act.
[37]
In view of the same, this Court presumes that the notices are
served upon the petitioners as it is settled principle of law that any refusal of the
summons/notices are presumed to be served. Nowhere in the statute the period
of service of notices are specified. In absence of the same, notices which are said
to have been sent are deemed to be served.
[38]
In that view of the matter, the present petition preferred by the
petitioners stands dismissed. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if
any, shall stand closed.
B. PALIT, J
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.12.18
10:34:39 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review