Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J (2)
In The High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
Arpan Kumar Ghosh
vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Amitabrata Roy, Advocate
Ms. Dishani Kanjilal, Advocate
For the State
:
Mr. Anindya Sundar Das, Advocate
Mr. Shaunak Ghosh, Advocate (V.C)
Mr. Saumen Gayen, Advocate
Heard on
:
10.09.2026
Judgment on
:
10.09.2026
Uploaded on
:
11.09.2026
MD. SHABBAR RASHIDI, J.:1. The instant writ application has been filed by the writ petitioner
challenging an order passed by the District Inspector of Schools (SE),
Purba Bardhaman dated February 04, 2020.
2. By the impugned order, the District Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba
Bardhaman refused the prayer of the petitioner for appointment on
compassionate ground. The District Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba
Bardhaman decided the application for appointment of the petitioner
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
on compassionate ground by the impugned order dated February 4,
2020 in the following manner:“It is found that Family Income, as determined
from Gross Family Pension, is not less than
initial gross salary of Gr.-“D” Employee at the
material point of time (i.e. on the date of death of
LATE ANIL KUMAR GHOSH). So the family is not
in
extreme
financial
hardship
as
per
explanation described in Para-1 of Schedule V,
Rule
Department
&
of
School
Notification
Education
No.697-ES/S/1A-
18/08 dated 09/07/2009. So his prayer for
Appointment
under
Compassionate
Ground
cannot be considered from this end.
This is for your information.”
3. It is further submitted by the learned advocate for the petitioner that
the District Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman has gone
wrong in complying the directions contained in Para-1 of Schedule V,
Rule 20 & 21 of School Education Department Notification No.697ES/S/1S-18/08 dated 09/07/2009.
4. It is further submitted by learned advocate for the petitioner that
similar matter came up before this Hon’ble Court in MAT 1664 of
2023 (Bitasoke Mahata vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors.). He
further submits that based on ratio laid down in MAT 1664 of 2023,
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
another writ application being WPA 9213 of 2024 (Suchismita
Khatua vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors.) was decided directing
the District Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman to reconsider
the matter for appointment on compassionate ground in terms of the
order passed on January 17, 2024 in MAT 1664 of 2023.
5. Learned advocate for the petitioner further submits that the District
Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman vide the impugned memo
has erroneously refused the prayer of the petitioner for appointment on
compassionate ground by taking wrong calculation of the income of the
family of the petitioner. The District Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba
Bardhaman in issuing the impugned memo has committed the similar
error and has wrongly taken into consideration the components of
dearness allowance, medical allowance as well as house rent allowance
for the purpose of calculating the family income of the petitioner.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the order passed in
MAT 1664 of 2023 and WPA 9213 of 2024, the District Inspector of
Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman be directed to re-calculate the family
income of the petitioner for the purpose of consideration of his claim
for appointment on compassionate ground.
6. On the other hand, learned advocate for the State submits that
conducting the amounts calculated towards dearness allowance,
medical allowance and house rent allowance, the family income of the
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
petitioner is more than the gross salary of Group-‘D’ Employee at the
relevant point of time. As such, learned advocate for the State prays for
dismissal of the instant writ application.
7. The petitioner is Madhyamik Pass. He passed Madhyamik Examination
in the year 2011 and Higher Secondary in the year 2013. He also
obtained Bachelor Degree in 2016 followed by B.Ed degree.
8. Father of the petitioner Late Anil Kumar Ghosh was Assistant Teacher
of Bengali posted at Gotan Subodh Memorial High School, Purba
Bardhaman. Father of the petitioner died in harness at the age of 56
years on November 15, 2017. Upon the death of his father, the
petitioner earlier applied for appointment on the basis of died-inharness category.
9. Upon receipt of the application filed by the petitioner, the Managing
Committee of the School considered his prayer and by the resolution of
the Committee dated August 9, 2018, a proposal was signed by the
Headmaster of the School for appointment of Assistant Teacher in the
category of ‘died-in-harness’.
10. Upon receipt of such proposal, respondent no.3, District Inspector of
Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman, considered the prayer of the
petitioner and rejected the same in the category of ‘died-in-harness’ by
the impugned memo dated February 4, 2020. It was pointed out in
such memo that gross family pension of the petitioner was not less
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
than the initial gross salary of a Group-‘D’ employee at the material
point of time. In such circumstances, it was held that the family was
not in extreme financial hardship as explained in Para-1 of Schedule V
appended to Rules 20 & 21 of School Education Department
Notification No.697-ES/S/1S-18/08 dated 09/07/2009.
11. Impugned memo goes to show that for calculation of the gross family
pension, EFP- Rs.16265/-, DA- Rs.13825/-, Interim Relief- Rs.1301/-,
Medical
Allowance-Rs.300/-,
Gross
Pension
was
calculated
to
Rs.31,694/- 60% of which amounted to Rs.22348/-. The said memo
also calculated the gross initial salary of a Group-D Staff at
Rs.13990/-. On such score, the District Inspector of Schools (SE),
Purba Bardhaman, by the impugned memo, came to a conclusion that
the family pension of the petitioner was not less than the gross initial
salary of a Group-D staff as required in the Para-1 of Schedule V, Rule
20 & 21 of School Education Department Notification No.697ES/S/1S-18/08 dated 09/07/2009.
12. In the Bitasoke Mahata (supra) it was held by the High Court that
“3. On a plain reading of the said Rule, it
appears that for computation of income of the
family Provident Fund, Gratuity and 40% of the
Family Pension of the first seven year shall be
excluded. We are not referring to other portion of
the said Rule as they are not relevant for the
present purpose. The question arises whether
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
“dearness allowance and medical allowance can
be treated as part of income of such family”. The
Rule has clearly stated that if a family member
has an income earned from “any other source”
other than provident fund, gratuity and 40% of
the family pension, that could be taken into
consideration in addition to 60% of the family
pension earned by the members of the deceased
family in determining the financial hardship.
This Rule has not been amended. Unlike the
Government of West Bengal Labour Department
Circular No. 251-Emp dated 3rd December, 2013,
the total family pension per month does not
include the basic pension, dearness allowance
and medical allowance. The said scheme is
beneficial in nature and the Court should not
ordinarily read into the Rules something which
was never intended or expressly provided. The
rule has to be read plainly without importing any
word
and
in
case
of
any
ambiguity
an
interpretation favouring the applicant should be
accepted keeping in mind the object of the said
Rule.
4. On such consideration, we set aside the order
passed by the District Inspector of Schools (S.E.),
Bankura
dated
14th
November,
and
consequently the order impugned in the appeal
dated 26th July, 2023.
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
5. We direct the District Inspector of Schools
(S.E.), Bankura to consider the case of the
petitioner for compassionate appointment after
taking into consideration all other relevant facts
within a period of four weeks from the date of
communication of this order by either of the
parties after giving an opportunity of hearing to
the appellant.
6. In the event the appellant is found to be
eligible, immediate steps should be taken for his
appointment to a post commensurate with his
qualification.”
13. Similarly in Suchismita Khatua (supra),
coordinate Bench of this
Court held as follows:“10. As it appears that the Hon’ble Division
Bench of this Court has held that dearness
allowance and medical allowance cannot be
included for ascertaining family income of the
family
for
the
purpose
of
providing
compassionate appointment, accordingly, the
calculation of family income of the petitioner by
including the dearness allowance, house rent
allowance and medical allowance and arriving
at the impugned conclusion that the income of
the family is more than the salary of a Group-D
staff of the State Government does not appear to
be proper.
11. The impugned order of the District Inspector
of
Schools
(Secondary
Education),
Purba
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
Medinipur dated 24th June, 2020, accordingly,
stands set aside.
12. The District Inspector of Schools (Secondary
Education), Purba Medinipur is directed to recalculate the family income of the petitioner
strictly in accordance with law and in line with
the order passed in the matter of Bitasoke
Mahata (supra).
13. Steps shall be taken at the earliest but
positively within a period of six weeks from the
date of communication of this order.
14.
A
final
order
shall
be
passed
and
communicated to the petitioner immediately
thereafter.”
14. Apparently, in the present writ petition, the District Inspector of
Schools (S.E) while considering the prayer of the petitioner for
appointment on compassionate ground calculated the family pension of
the family of the petitioner taking into consideration the dearness
allowance and medical allowance which is not permissible in terms of
the notification of Education Department
15. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case, and
applying the ratio laid down in Bitasoke Mahata (supra) the
impugned memo dated February 4, 2020 is set aside.
16. The District Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman is directed to
re-calculate the family income of the petitioner strictly in accordance
with law and relevant notification of the Education Department as well
W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
as in line with the order passed in the matter of Bitasoke Mahata
(supra).
17. Steps shall be taken at the earliest positively within a period of six
weeks from the date of communication of this order.
18. Upon re-calculation, a fresh order shall be passed by the District
Inspector of Schools (SE), Purba Bardhaman in terms of the directions
made in this order and such decision will be communicated to the
petitioner immediately after taking such decision.
19. Upon such re-calculation, if the petitioner is found entitled for
appointment on compassionate ground, immediate steps in this regard
shall be taken by the State respondents particularly respondent No.3
positively within a period of six weeks of such decision.
20. With the aforesaid directions/observations, W.P.A. 10541 of 2020
stands disposed of.
21. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied expeditiously after complying with all necessary legal
formalities.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.)
CHC
CHINMOY CHAKRABORTY
Date: 2026.09.11 14:35:06 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review