Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
25.03.2026
Item No.02
Court No.12
CP/GB
MAT 2273 of 2025
with
CAN 1 of 2026
with
CAN 2 of 2026
Arnab Hazra & Anr.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Anindya Lahiri, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Anish Chakraborty
Mr. Subhomoy Paul
…..for the Appellants.
Mr. Amitabha Ghosh
…for the respondent/writ petitioner.
Mr. Jaharlal De
Mr. Shamim ul Bari
…for the State respondents.
CAN 1 of 2026 is an application for condonation
of delay of 59 days in filing the appeal.
Mr.
Ghosh,
learned
advocate
for
the
respondent/writ petitioner, opposes the prayer for
condonation of delay on the ground that the appellants
were all along aware of the writ proceedings.
We find from the explanations that the appellants
were unable to contact their learned advocate who was
conducting the writ proceeding on their behalf and, as
such, were unaware of the disposal of the writ petition.
Upon coming to know of the same from their learned
advocate at a later date, steps were taken to file the
appeal along with the prayer for condonation of delay.
Accordingly,
the
explanation
is
satisfactory.
The
appellants have pleaded ill-health and ailments. Under
such circumstances, we are satisfied that the delay has
been explained properly. Accordingly, the delay is
condoned.
CAN 1 of 2026 is allowed.
Let the appeal be regularized.
We have perused the stamp reporter’s report. We
are told that the Vakalatnama of the respondents was
filed
in
the
writ
petition
in
court.
Under
such
circumstances, the report may be ignored.
The appellants are aggrieved by an order dated
September 24, 2025, passed by a learned Single Judge,
wherein directions were passed that the mango tree and
the coconut tree of the appellants which have been
existing within the premises of the appellants for many
years, should be felled in order to prevent damage to the
property of the respondent no. 5. Such direction of Her
Lordship was based on four reports which were called
for one after the other from the Forest Department.
Her Lordship was of the further view that the
appellants did not have any right to plant trees that
would
cause
neighbours.
damage
to
the
structure
of
their
The concerned authority was directed to ensure
that all necessary steps were taken by the appellants so
that the structure of the respondent no. 5 would not be
damaged. The respondent authorities were further
directed to take remedial measures. As a consequence,
the forest department has asked the appellants to apply
for felling of their trees.
Mr.
Lahiri,
learned
senior
advocate
for
the
appellants, submits that the trees are the property of
the appellants. The trees have been planted within the
boundary wall of the appellants. This fact is also
available from the order impugned and the pleadings in
the writ petition. The contentions of the writ petitioner
were that, the distance between the mango and coconut
trees of the appellant and the boundary wall of the writ
petitioner’s premises were minimum, i.e., 1.1 ft. and 2.2
ft. respectively.
Mr. Lahiri submits that none of the reports filed
by the authorities would indicate that any damage had
been caused at all to the structure of the writ
petitioner/respondent no. 5. He submits that the
reports indicate that the root of the mango tree had
touched the wall of the septic tank, but there was no
visible damage. The root was growing downwards inside
the earth and not towards the septic tank. It was further
emphasised by Mr. Lahiri that the West Bengal Trees
(Protection and Conservation in Non-Forest Areas) Act,
2006, prohibited felling of trees. Permission to fell trees
could only be granted under Rule 4 of the West Bengal
Trees (Protection and Conservation in Non-Forest Areas)
Rules,
2007.
Only
if
the
tree
caused
serious
inconvenience to any local resident or posed a threat to
human life or building or property or disrupted public
services, could permission for felling be granted.
Mr. Lahiri submits that the trees have been in
existence for more than 30 years and no damage had
been caused either to the building or the life and
property of the writ petitioner. He draws the attention of
the court to the final report filed by the Range Forest
Officer, Barrackpore S.F. Range, dated September 16,
2025, which was in the nature of a communication to
the Divisional Forest Officer, 24 Parganas (North)
Division, Barasat. In the said report/communication,
the Range Forest Officer acknowledged that he was
unable to foresee the nature and direction of further
undergrowth of the roots of the trees. Trimming of the
roots would hamper the survival of the trees. However,
the roots may damage to the property in future.
It is submitted further that a writ petition could
not have been entertained with regard to the dispute
involved. Mere reports of the Range Officer, who may
not be an expert in the field, could not be the basis for
deprival of a right over the trees, which were within the
property of the appellants.
Mr.
Ghosh,
learned
advocate
for
the
writ
petitioner/respondent no.5 submits that, if the trees
caused damage to the property of the respondent no.5,
the said respondent had every right to file a writ petition
seeking directions upon the appellants to comply with
the law and also upon the respondent authorities/forest
department to ensure safety of the structure by felling
the trees, which were likely to cause damage to the
structure of the respondent no.5.
Heard the parties. The first report prepared by the
Range Officer and forwarded to the Divisional Forest
Officer on June 10, 2025 indicates that no damage was
caused by the subject trees to the writ petitioner’s
construction. The roots touched the walls of the septic
tank but no damage was visible on the surface. A
possibility of damage to the said septic tank in future
has been mentioned. In the second report prepared by
the Range Officer, Barrackpore SF Range, filed before
the
Divisional
Forest
Officer
again,
it
had
been
reiterated that the roots were entering the premises of
the writ petitioner/respondent no.5 and touched the
septic tank but, they were growing inwards into the
earth. The roots of the coconut trees were also growing
inwards, but barely touched the wall of the reservoir.
However, in both cases, no sign of visible damage either
to the septic tank or reservoir were evident and there
was no foul smell or water leakage. This indicates that
the walls of the septic tank and the reservoir were
intact.
On July 23, 2025, another report was prepared by
the
Range
Officer,
Barrackpore
SF
Range
which
indicates that although the roots of the trees were
touching the wall of the septic tank and the reservoir,
no damage either to the septic tank or the reservoir was
evident. Parties were present during such inspection by
the Range Officer. The pictures annexed to the report
show that thin roots from the mango tree had touched
the wall of the septic tank, but those roots do not visibly
appear to be destructive and our observation is also
supported by the report of the concerned authorities. In
the last report prepared by the Range Officer dated
September 16, 2025, it has been categorically stated
that the roots of the mango tree were touching the wall
of the septic tank and were growing downwards and not
towards the septic tank. The roots of the coconut tree
were touching the wall of the reservoir but, also going
downwards into the earth.
The Act of 2006 was promulgated to prevent
felling of trees in non-forest areas and to encourage and
promote
plantation
of
trees.
Conservation
and
protection of trees is the mandatory duty of the
authority under the Act. Under the Rules of 2007, felling
can be allowed when such tree can cause damage to
human life and property.
The law as it stands today is that, unless
absolutely necessary for protection of human life or
protection of a building or a property of an individual,
felling of tree is barred. None of the reports of the forest
department indicate that they had come to a conclusion
that, felling would be necessary to protect the property
of the respondent No. 5. Rather, in all the reports it has
been categorically stated that damage was not visible
and the roots although touching the wall of the septic
tank, were growing downwards and not towards the
building or the construction.
On the basis of vague reports and apprehension
that the roots may cause damage in future, a direction
to fell the trees could not have been passed. There are
no statutory infractions by the authorities, that would
give rise to a cause of action to file a writ petition. Thus,
the order impugned is set aside. All the said order are
set aside.
However, as a citizen, the appellant has a
fundamental duty to ensure that his neighbour is not
caused any inconvenience on account of the trees and
as such, the trees will be kept adequately trimmed and
dressed, so that they do not disturb the daily living of
the respondent no.5. With regard to the worry as to
what would happen in future if there is further damage
to the septic tank and water reservoir, we are of the view
that a writ petition cannot be futuristic. In any event,
apprehension cannot be a cause of action to maintain a
writ petition. The dispute appears to be private in
nature.
The respondent authorities have clarified that the
law prohibits felling and only a person who owns the
trees can approach the authority for permission to fell
the trees, if such felling is necessary to protect the life
and property of any individual. The issue raised by the
writ petitioner is to be finally adjudicated in an
appropriate proceeding on the basis of evidence. Expert
opinion from a civil engineer and a botanist would be
required to assess the nature of the roots, the probable
damage that the roots can cause, the nature of the
construction
and
the
extent
of
damage
such
construction might suffer.
Under such circumstances, this enquiry is not
possible in a writ proceeding. We leave it open to the
writ petitioner to take steps, in accordance with law,
before the appropriate forum.
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of. The
connected application being CAN 2 of 2026 is also
disposed of.
Parties are directed to act on the basis of the
server copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review