Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.242 of 2025
1. Apu Bhowmik,
Son of Bidhan Bhowmik, Resident of Abhanga, Kamalpur,
Dhalai, Tripura, Pin-799286 (Age-35 years)
2. Dhiptano Das,
Son of Dipak Das, Resident of Kishoreganj, P.O.-Kishoreganj,
P.S.-Kakraban, Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799105 (Age-30 years)
3. Mitan Podder,
Son of Pulin Behari Podder, Resident of Khowaria, Nabinagar,
Bishalgarh, Sepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102 (Age-36 years)
4. Amit Basak,
Son of Late Bibhishan Basak, Resident of Ananda para,
P.O. & P.S.-Sabroom, South Tripura,
Pin-799145, (Age-35 years)
5. Sanjoy Rudrapal,
Son of Sushil Chandra Rudrapal, Resident of Radhapur,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura, Pin-799254 (Age-34 years)
6. Mitan Das,
Son of Krishna Chandra Das, Resident of West Howaibari,
P.O.-Howaibari, P.S.-Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura,
Pin-799205 (age-38 years)
------ Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary,
Education(School) Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S-New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Secretary, Education (School) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Director of Elementary Education, Tripura,
Shiksha Bhawan, Office Lane, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799001.
4. Teachers’ Recuitment Board, Tripura
To be represented by the Chairman,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
5. The Chairman,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
6. The Member Secretary,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
7. The Controller of Examinations,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
8. National Council for Teacher Education
To be represented by the Chairperson,
National Council for Teacher Education,
Office Address at National Council for Teacher Education,
G-7, Sector-10, Dwarka Near Metro Station,
New Delhi, Pin-110075
9. The Member Secretary,
National Council for Teacher Education
Office Address at National Council for Teacher Education,
G-7, Sector-10, Dwarka Near Metro Station,
New Delhi, Pin-110075
------ Respondents
Along with
WP(C) No.243 of 2025
Mithu Paul Deb,
Wife of Sri Samir Deb,
Resident of Halhali, Kamalpur, Dhalai, Tripura (Age-44 years)
------ Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary,
Education(School) Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S-New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Secretary, Education (School) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Director of Elementary Education, Tripura,
Shiksha Bhawan, Office Lane, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799001.
4. Teachers’ Recuitment Board, Tripura
To be represented by the Chairman,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
5. The Chairman,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
6. The Member Secretary,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
7. The Controller of Examinations,
Teachers’ Recruitment Board Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
8. National Council for Teacher Education
To be represented by the Chairperson,
National Council for Teacher Education,
Office Address at National Council for Teacher Education,
G-7, Sector-10, Dwarka Near Metro Station,
New Delhi, Pin-110075
9. The Member Secretary,
National Council for Teacher Education
Office Address at National Council for Teacher Education,
G-7, Sector-10, Dwarka Near Metro Station,
New Delhi, Pin-110075
10. National Institute of Open Schooling
To be represented by the Secretary,
National Institute of Open Schooling, A-24/25,
Institutional Area, Sector-62, NOIDA,
Gautam Budh Nagar District, Uttar Pradesh, Pin-201309.
------ Respondents
WP(C) No.242 of 2025
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Mandeep Kalra, Adv,
Mr. Arijit Bhowmik, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.,
WP(C) No.243 of 2025
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Mandeep Kalra, Adv,
Mr. Arijit Bhowmik, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.,
Ms. Pinki Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
06.02.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
27.02.2026
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Since common questions of law and facts are involved in both
the writ petitions, so, both the writ petitions are disposed of by this
common judgment.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Mandeep Kalra appearing on
behalf of the petitioners in both the writ petitions. Also heard Learned
Addl. G.A., Mr. Mangal Debbarma appearing on behalf of the Staterespondents in WP(C) No.242 of 2025 and Learned Addl. G.A., Mr.
Karnajit De appearing on behalf of the State-respondents in WP(C)
No.243 of 2025 and further heard Learned Counsel, Ms. Pinki
Chakraborty vice Learned Counsel, Mr. Milan Laskar appearing on
behalf of the respondent No.10 in WP(C) No.243 of 2025.
3.
Brief facts of both the petitions are summarized below:
In WP(C) No.242 of 2025
The petitioners in WP(C) No.242 of 2025 were working
as teachers in private and unaided schools of Tripura. They were
untrained teachers and were in service when NCTE (National Council
for
Teacher
Education)
issued
a
special
recognition
order
on
22.09.2017 permitting NIOS(National Institute of Open Schooling) to
conduct an 18 months’ D.El.Ed(ODL) course for in-service teachers.
Thereafter, the petitioners took admission in D.El.Ed course for the
year 2017-19 sessions and continued teaching while undergoing
training. They appeared in the final examination held in the month of
March, 2019 and completed the course within the stipulated period
fixed by NCTE. The marksheets in favour of the petitioners was issued
on several dates, however, NIOS later clarified that the result was
declared on 22.05.2019. The petitioners thereafter qualified in the
Teachers’ Eligibility Test and became eligible for recruitment. On
12.12.2024, TRBT (Teacher Recruitment Board Tripura) issued a
notification for recruitment of Under Graduate Teachers prescribing
Senior Secondary, D.El.Ed and T-TET(Tripura-Teachers’ Eligibility
Test) as essential minimum qualifications. The petitioners applied for
the said post within the prescribed time i.e. within 10.01.2025 and
participated in document verification process which was held on
20.02.2025 but when the final selection list was published on
03.04.2025, their names were not included in the said list. Aggrieved
by the arbitrary decision of the authority, the petitioners have filed
this writ petition challenging the action of the authority.
In WP(C) No.243 of 2025
In WP(C) No.243 of 2025, the petitioner Smt. Mithu Paul
Deb was appointed as an Assistant Teacher in a private school on
05.01.2017 and continued her service upto 30.04.2023. While
working
as
an
Assistant
Teacher,
she
joined
D.El.Ed
training
introduced by NCTE on 22.09.2017 for untrained in-service teachers
to undergo the 18 months’ D.El.Ed.(ODL) course through NIOS. She
took admission in the D.El.Ed course for the year 2017-19 sessions
and continued her teaching duties along with her studies. She
appeared in the final examination conducted in March, 2019 and
completed the course and her marksheet was issued on 07.02.2022
but NIOS later clarified that the result was declared on 22.05.2019.
She later on qualified the T-TET and applied for recruitment pursuant
to the notification dated 12.12.2024 issued by TRBT for Graduate
Teacher post. She submitted her application within the prescribed
time i.e. within 10.01.2025 and qualified the examination and
thereafter appeared for document verification process on 20.02.2025
but when the final selection list was published on 03.04.2025, her
name was not considered/published in the said list. So, being
aggrieved by the decision of the authority, she filed the present writ
petition seeking relief.
4.
Submission of common argument of the petitioners in
both the writ petitions:
Learned Counsel, Mr. Mandeep Kalra appearing on
behalf of the petitioners in WP(C) No.242 of 2025 submitted that all
the petitioners have/had been served as Assistant Teacher/Graduate
Teacher at different schools. The name of the petitioners with the
period of service they rendered and the names of schools are
mentioned hereinbelow:
Sl.
No.
1.
Name of
petitioner
Apu Bhowmik
2.
Dhiptano Das
3.
Mitan Podder
4.
Amit Basak
5.
Sanjoy
Rudrapal
Mitan Das
6.
Period of
Service
01.02.2013 to
till date
01.08.2017 to
till date
11.09.2016 to
04.06.2019
06.01.2014 to
till date
11.06.2013 to
till date
05.04.2016 to
till date
Name of School
Janthum English Medium H.S. School
Gurukul Shikhya Niketan (English
Medium) School
Ananda Marga School, Bishalgarh
Dhamma Dipa School
Tripureswari Shishu Mandir
G-Next Model School
Learned Counsel further submitted that the petitioner of
WP(C) No.243 of 2025 performed her duties as an Assistant Teacher
at Dr. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan Vidyamandir School, Halhali, Dhalai,
Tripura with effect from 05.01.2017 to 30.04.2023.
4.1.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners at the time of
hearing first of all drawn the attention of the Court referring the
notification dated 23.08.2010 issued by NCTE whereby the NCTE has
prescribed the minimum qualification for a person to be eligible for
appointment as a teacher in Classes-I-VIII refers to clause (n) of
Section 2 of the Right of children to free and Compulsory Education
Act, 2009, with effect from the date of this notification.
For
the
sake
of
convenience,
the
notification
is
mentioned herein below:
NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 23rd August, 2010
F.No.61.03/20/2010.NCTE/(N&C)In exercise of the powers conferred by Sub-section(1) of
Section 23 of the Right of Children to free and Compulsory
Education Act, 2009 (35 of 2009) and in pursuance of
Notification No.S.O. 750 (E) dated 31 March, 2010 issued
by the Department of School Education and Literacy
Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of
India, the National Counsel for Teacher Education (NOTE)
hereby lays down the following minimum qualifications for
a person to be eligible for appointment as a teacher in class
I to VIII in a school referred to in clause (n) of Section 2 of
the Right of Children to free and Compulsory Education Act,
2009, with effect from the date of this Notification1. Minimum Qualifications
i-Classes I-V
(a) Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50%
marks and 2-year Diploma in Elementary Education (by
whatever name known)
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 45%
marks and-2 year Diploma in Elementary Education (by
whatever name known), in accordance with the NCTE
(Recognition Norms and Procedure) Regulations 2002
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50%
marks and 4-year Bachelor of Elementary Education
(b.Ei.Ed)
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50%
marks and 2-year Diploma in Elementary Education
(Special Education)
AND
(b) Pass in the Teacher eligibility Test (TET) to be
conducted by the appropriate Government in accordance
with the Guidelines framed by the NCTE for the purpose.
(ii) Classes VI-VIII
(a) BA/B.Sc and 2 year Diploma in Elementary Education
(by whatever name known)
OR
BA/B.Sc with at least 50% marks and 1 year Bachelor in
Education (B.ed)
OR
BA/B.Sc with at least 45% marks and 1 year Bachelor in
Education
(B.ed),
in
accordance
with
the
NCTE
(Recognition norms and Procedure) Regulations issued
from time to time in this regard.
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50%
marks and 4 Year Bachelor in Elementary Education
(b.Ei.Ed)
OR
Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50%
marks and 4 year (BA/B.Sc, Ed or B.A Ed/BSc.Ed.)
OR
BA/B.Sc with at least 50% marks and 1 year B.Ed (Special
Education)
AND.
b) Pass in the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) to be conducted
by the appropriate Government in accordance with the
Guidelines framed by the NCTE for the purpose.
2. Diploma/Degree Course in Teacher Education- for the
purposes of this Notification a diploma/degree course in
teacher education recognized by the National Council for
Teacher Education NCTE only shall be considered. However,
in case of Diploma in education (Special Education) and
B.ed (Special Education) a course recognized by the
Rehabilitation Course of India (RCT) only shall be
considered.
3. Training to be undergone- A person
(a) with BA/B.Sc. with at least 50P/0 marks and B.Ed
qualification shall also be eligible for appointment for class
1 to V upto 1 January, 2012, provided he undergoes after
appointment an NCTE recognized 6 month special program
in Elementary Education.
(b) with D.ed (Special Education) or B.Ed (Special
Education). Qualification shall undergo, after appointment
as NCH; recognized 6 month special programme in
Elementary Education.
4. Teacher appointment before the date of this NotificationThe following categories of teachers appointment for
classes I to VIII prior to date of this Notification need not
acquire the minimum qualifications specified in para (1)
above.
a. A Teacher appointed on or after the 3rd September 2001
i.e. the date on which the NCTE (Determination of Minimum
Qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools)
Regulations 2001 (as amended from the time) came into
force, in accordance with that Regulation.
Provided that a teacher of class I to V possessing B.Ed
qualification or a teacher possessing B.ed (Special
Education) or D:Ed (Special Education) qualification shall
undergo an NCTE recognized 6 month special programme
on elementary education.
b. A teacher of class I to V with B.Ed qualification who has
completed a 6 month Special Basis teacher Course (Special
ETC) approved by the NCTE.
c-A teacher appointed before the 3rd September 2001, in
accordance with the prevalent Recruitment Rules.
5. Teacher appointed after the date of this notification in
certain cases- Where an appropriate Government or local
authority or a school has issued an advertisement to
initiate the process of appointment of teacher prior to the
date of this notification, such appointment may be made in
accordance with the NCTE (Determination of Minimum
Qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools)
Regulations 2001 (as amended from time to time).
HASIB AHMAD, Member Secy
(ADVTIII/4/131/10-Exty)
4.2.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel for the petitioners in both
the writ petitions drawn the attention of the Court to the relevant part
of the communication dated 03.08.2017 written by Addl. Secretary,
Ministry of Human Resource Development to all the Secretaries of the
State wherein it was mentioned that in pursuance of the amendment
to the Section 23(2) of RTE Act, training of untrained elementary
teachers in Government/Government aided/unaided private schools
has been extended till 31st March, 2019 by the Parliament and this will
be the last chance to acquire the requisite minimum professional
qualifications. Any teacher in the aforementioned schools, who does
not have the minimum qualifications mandated under the RTE Act,
2009, would not be allowed to continue in-service beyond 1st April,
2019, and procedure for dismissal shall be initiated against such
teachers. It was further mentioned in the said communication that the
State Coordinator will enter the database of untrained in-service
teachers (in private and Govt. schools) on the portal especially
prepared by NIOS for this purpose and this portal will also be utilized
to monitor the progress of training in each State/UT with further
observation that for teachers in Private Schools, a Certificate from the
Principal would be taken to ensure that the teacher is serving in the
School and these certificates will be collected by the State/UT.
Referring the said communication, Learned Counsel submitted that it
was the responsibility of the State Coordinator to maintain the
database of the untrained in-service teachers. For the sake of
convenience, the relevant portion of the said communication dated
03.08.2017 is mentioned herein as under:
“
*
*
*
*
This is regarding training of untrained in-service
elementary teachers in the Govt./ Govt. Aided/UnaidedPrivate Schools. It is apprised that the Amendment to the
Section 23(2) of the RTE Act to extend the period for such
training to 31st March, 2019 has been passed by the
Parliament.
2. Further, it is reiterated that this will be the last chance
to
acquire
the
requisite
minimum
professional
qualifications. Any teacher in the aforementioned schools,
who does not have the minimum qualifications mandated
under the RTE Act, 2009, would not be allowed to continue
in-service beyond 1st April, 2019, and procedure for
dismissal shall be initiated against such teachers.
3.
*
*
*
*
ix. State Coordinator will enter the entire database of
untrained in-service teachers [in Private and Govt. schools)
on the portal especially prepared by NIOS for this purpose.
This portal will also be utilized to monitor the progress of
training in each State/UT.
x. For teachers in Private Schools, a Certificate from the
Principal would be taken to ensure that the teacher is
serving in the school. These certificates will be collected by
the State/UT.”
4.3.
Learned Counsel also submitted that the Government
accordingly provided the names of untrained in-service teachers.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel also drawn the attention of the Court the
Gazette notification dated 10.08.2017 published by Ministry of Law
and Justice regarding the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory
Education (Amendment) Act, 2017 wherein in para No.2, it has been
specifically mentioned as under:
“2. In the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory
Education Act, 2009, in section 23, in sub-section (2), after
the proviso, the following proviso shall be inserted,
namely:"Provided further that every teacher appointed or in
position as on the 31st March, 2015, who does not
possess minimum qualifications as laid down under
sub-section
(1),
shall
acquire
such
minimum
qualifications within a period of four years from the
date of commencement of the Right of Children to Free
and Compulsory Education (Amendment) Act, 2017.".”
4.4.
Again, Learned Counsel drawn the attention of the Court
referring another communication written by the Deputy Secretary to
the Government of India, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Department of School Education & Literacy to the Chairperson, NCTE
wherein in para No.3(II), it was specifically provided as under:
“3. To ensure the above training through NIOS, NCTE is
directed to provide following relaxations under Section 29
of the NCTE Act:
*
*
*
*
II. The D.El.Ed course will be from 3rd October, 2017 to
31st March, 2019. The duration of the course will be for
18 months. As the D.El.Ed. programme is of two year
duration, NCTE shall allow subsuming of 6 months
internship period within the duration of the proposed
Online course through the SWAYAM portal as all the
teachers are in-service and are already teaching.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that it
was the decision of the Government of India that the D.L.Ed. course
will be from 3rd October, 2017 to 31st March, 2019. The duration of
the course will be for 18 months but as the D.El.Ed. programme is of
two years duration, NCTE shall allow subsuming of 6 months
internship period within the duration of the proposed online course
through the SWAYAM portal as all the teachers are in-service and are
already teaching. Learned Counsel further submitted that herein the
case at hand, all the teachers were in-service on that relevant point of
time and accordingly, they took admission in the D.El.Ed programme
of 18 months with subsuming 6 months internship period as per the
direction of the Government.
4.5.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel submitted that the said
programme of 18 months duration with 6 months subsuming
internship was recognized by the NCTE and in this regard, a letter was
communicated by the Member Secretary, NCTE to The Regional
Director, Northern Regional Committee, NCTE wherein in para
No.3(ii), it was specifically recognized that any provision related to
the duration of the programme so as to reduce it to 18 months
instead of 2 years and the requirement of 6 months internship to be
subsumed within the duration of 18 months. The relevant portion of
the communication is mentioned herein as under:
3.
*
*
*
(ii) Any provision related to the duration of the
programme so as to reduce it to 18 months instead of 2
years and the requirement of 6 months internship to be
subsumed within the duration of 18 months;
4.6.
Thereafter, the NCTE by a notification dated 22nd
September, 2017 issued one recognition order which is mentioned
hereinbelow:
TO BE PUBLISHED IN GAZETTE OF INDIA PART-III, SECTION-IV
File No. NRC/NCTE/NIOS/Recognition/275th(Part-3) Meeting/2017
Dated:22 SEP 2017
RECOGNITION ORDER/182459-61
WHEREAS, the matter of recognition of the Project
Proposal of National Institute of Open Schooling
(NIOS) Noida for D.EL.Ed. (ODL) programme through
SWAYAM Portal of MHRD for training of in-service
untrained teachers was considered by NRC and NRC
overserved as follows:AND WHEREAS, the NCTE has received directions under
Section-29 of the NCTE Act, 1993 from the Ministry of
Human Resource Development vide their letters no.1115/2017-EE-10 dated 21.08.2017 and 04.09.2017. The
project proposal for recognition of Diploma in
Elementary Education (D.El.Ed) programme through
ODL mode has been submitted by National Institute of
Open Schooling (NIOS) to NCTE Headquarter). The
proposal is for conducting on-line D.El.Ed. programme
through the SWAYAM portal of the Ministry of HRD for
the in-service untrained teachers at elementary level
working
in
Government/Government-aided
and
unaided private schools in the country.
AND WHEREAS, the said project proposal has been
considered by an expert committee constituted by
NCTE vide order dated 19.09.2017. The Committee
considered the project and found that the NIOS is
adequately prepared to conduct the programme and
the curriculum proposed therein meets the requirement
of the D.El.Ed. (ODL) programme of NCTE.
AND WHEREAS, In view of above mentioned directions
of the Ministry of Human Resource Development under
Section-29 of the NCTE Act, 1993 and after considering
the recommendation of the Eexpert Committee,
Chairperson NCTE in exercise of his powers under
clause 12 of the NCTE (Recognition Norms and
Procedure) Regulations, 2014, granted relaxation vide
NCTE Hqrs letter No. NCTE-Regul011/166/2017US(Regulation) -HQ dated 21/09/2017 & letter dated
22.09.2017 to the following provisions in the NCTE
Regulations-2014 for ensuring that the directives of the
MHRD for implementing the amendment to the RTE Act,
2009 are duly fulfilled.
I. Any provision related to on-line submission of the
application on NCTE Application portal;
II Any provision related to the duration of the
programme so as to reduce it to 18 months instead
of 2 years and the requirement of 6 months
internship to be subsumed within the duration of 18
months;
III. Any requirement of minimum eligibility for
admission to D.El.Ed programme, ie 50% marks in
class 12, to the extent that those who do not fulfill
this requirement shall be allowed to take provisional
admission to the programme subject to their
acquiring 50% marks belore completion of the
D.El.Ed. programme of NIOS.
IV. Any provision in the Regulations to enable NIOS
to administer the programme through SWAYAM
Portal of MHRD;
V. Any provision prescribing the number and nature
of study centers to enable NIOS to cater around lakh
untrained teachers,
VI. Allow NIOS to operate study centres manned by
staff (academic and others) as per instructions of
MHRD to enable NIOS to complete the training of inservice teacher numbering around 11 lakh by
31.03.2019.
VII Any provision in Regulations restricting the
intake capacity in D.EL.Ed. (OOL) programme to
enable NIOS to train the any required number of
untrained teachers.
VIII. Since almost all the states and union territories
of the country are involved in the exercise of training
untrained teachers, there shall be no requirement of
seeking no objection certificates from individual
States/UTs.
IX. Besides the above relaxation, NRC may also
consider
imposing
a
condition
of
regular
inspection/monitoring of the programme through a
mechanism of inspection of centers by senior NIOS
personnel or any agency deployed for the purpose,
on random basis during the entire duration of the
project, so as to cover all states at least once every 9
months. Report of such inspections must be
submitted to the MHRD.
AND WHEREAS, After having considered all the above
facts and figures, the NRC considered the case in its
275th (Part-3) decided that recognition be granted to
the National Institute of Open Schooling (NIOS), Noida
for D.El.Ed. (ODL) programme through SWAYAM Portal
of MHRD for training of in-service untrained teachers
under Section 14 of NCTE, Act, 1993 and clause 7(16)
of NCTE Regulations, 2014 subject to fulfilling the
following conditions.
I. The duration of the said programine shall be 18
months instead of 2 years including the 6 months
internship.
II. The requirement of minimum eligibility for
admission to D.EL.Ed. programme, i.e. 50% marks in
class 12, to the extent that those who do not fulfil this
requirement shall be allowed to take provisional
admission to the programme subject to their acquiring
50% marks before completion of the D.El.Ed.
programme of NIOS;
III. NIOS to administer
SWAYAM Portal of MHRD;
the
programme
through
IV. NIOS shall operate study centres manned by staff
(academic and others) as per instructions of MHRD to
enable NIOS to complete the training of in-service
untrained teachers numbering around 11 lakh by
31.03.2019 all over India.
V. There shall be no restriction to the number and
nature of study centres to enable NIOS to train the
required number of untrained teachers
VI. The intake
maximum 100.
capacity
at
each
centre
shall
be
VII. Regular inspection/monitoring of the programme
shall be conducted through a mechanism of inspection
of centers by senior NIOS personnel or any agency
deployed for the purpose, on random basis during the
entire duration of the project, so as to cover all states
at least once every 9 months. Report of such
inspections must be submitted to the MHRD.
VIII. This programme shall be only for those in-service
untrained teachers in Govt./Govt. Aided/Private
unaided Schools appointed on or before 10/08/2017.
IX. All the provisions in the NCTE Act & Regulations,
2014 other than those relaxed under clause 12 of NCTE
Regulations, 2014, will be applicable.
NOW THEREFORE, in exercise of the powers vested
under Section 14(3)(a)/15(3)(a) of the NCTE Act,
1993, the Northern Regional Committee hereby grants
recognition to National Institute of Open Schooling
(NIOS) Noida, U.P. under clause 7(16) of NCTE
(Recognition Norms & Procedure) Regulations, 2014
for D.El.Ed. (ODL) programme through SWAYAM Portal
of MHRD for training of in-service untrained teachers
subject to fulfillment of the conditions mentioned
above.
By order
(Satish Gupta)
Regional Director(I/C)
The Manager,
Govt. of India Press,
Department of Publications, (Gazette Section)
Civil Lines, Delhi-110054
Copy to:1. The Chairman,
National Institute of Open Schooling,
A-24-25, Institutional Area, Sector-62,
Noida-201309, Uttar Pradesh.
2. The Secretary,
Department of School Education and Literacy,
Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001
3. The US (EDP),
National Council for Teacher Education,
Hans Bhawan Wing-II, I,
Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi-110 002.
4. Computer Section of NRC, NCTE, Jaipur for upload
the same on NRC website.
5. Institution file (concerned)
6. Guard file
Regional Director(I/C)
Referring the
said order, Learned Counsel
further
submitted that in view of the directions of the Ministry of Human
Resource Development under Section 29 of NCTE Act, 1993 and after
considering
the
recommendation
of
the
Expert
Committee,
Chairperson, NCTE in exercise of his power under Clause 12 of the
NCTE (Recognition Norms and Procedure) Regulations,2014 granted
relaxation vide NCTE Hqrs letter dated 21.09.2017 and 22.09.2017 to
the provisions in the NCTE regulations, 2014 for ensuring that the
directives of the MHRD for implementing the amendment to the RTE
Act, 2009 are duly followed. In the said order, it was specifically
mentioned
that
any
provision
related
to
the
duration
of
the
programme so as to reduce it to 18 months instead of 2 years and the
requirement of 6 months internship to be subsumed within the
duration of 18 months and it was also mentioned in para No.(v) that
any provision prescribing the number and nature of study centres to
enable NIOS to cater to around 11 lakh untrained teachers and in
para No.(vi), it was mentioned to allow NIOS to operate study centres
manned by staff (academic and others) as per instructions of MHRD to
enable NIOS to complete the training of in-service teacher numbering
around 11 lakh by 31.03.2019. Learned Counsel further submitted
that within the said period all the teachers completed the D.El.Ed
programme and in the said order, it was also mentioned that the
programme shall be only for those in-service untrained teachers in
Government/Government-aided
and
unaided
private
schools
appointed on or before 10.08.2017 and by the said order, the NCTE
granted recognition to NIOS to conduct programme through SWAYAM
portal of MHRD for training of untrained in-service teachers subject to
fulfillment of the condition mentioned above and accordingly, all the
writ petitioners performed the relevant courses.
4.7.
Learned Counsel also submitted that in this regard the
NIOS also published one open public advertisement wherein it was
mentioned that the course is approved by NCTE & MHRD. Anyone with
this qualification can apply for job anywhere in India. It was also
mentioned that Government of India has given an opportunity to all
untrained
Elementary
school
teachers
teaching
in
Government/Government aided and private school to classes I to VIII
to get D.El.Ed by March 31st, 2019. Based upon the advertisement
across
the
country
apart
from
the
petitioners
so
many
persons/untrained teachers got admitted and completed the course by
31st March, 2019.
4.8.
Learned Counsel thereafter referred few judgments of
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. Firstly, Learned Counsel drawn the
attention of the Court to the judgment of Hon’ble the Supreme Court
of India reported in (2025) 6 SCC 808 [titled as Vishwanath vs.
State of Uttarakhand & Ors. dated 05.03.2025] wherein in para
Nos.1, 15, 16, 21 and 22, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“1. By way of this application, the applicants have
approached this Court for a direction on the respondent to
permit the applicants who are holding the 18 months'
DElEd qualification from the National Institute of Open
Schooling (“NIOS”) under the Open and Distance Learning
(“ODL”) mode to participate in the ongoing counselling
process and to subsequently be appointed to the vacant
posts in the ongoing recruitment.
15. This Court had further clarified vide paras 3 and 4 of
the order dated 10-12-2024 passed in RP (C) Diary No.
4961 of 2024 titled as Viswanath v. State of Uttarakhand
[Viswanath v. State of Uttarakhand, 2024 SCC OnLine SC
4937] , as under: (SCC OnLine SC)
“3. However, to avoid any confusion, we again clarify
that the 18 months diploma obtained by such
persons, who were in employment as on 10-8-2017
and who have completed the diploma course of 18
months, would be treated as valid diploma holders
for the purpose of applying in other institutions or for
promotional avenues.
4. Needless to state that the clarification will be
effective from the date of pronouncement of the
judgment under review.”
16. The grievance of the applicants herein is that though
they are eligible as per the original judgment of this Court
dated 28-11-2023 [Jaiveer Singh v. State of Uttarakhand,
(2024) 15 SCC 227 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1584] and the
clarification
dated
10-12-2024,
inasmuch
as
the
advertisement in the State of Uttarakhand is dated 29-52024, that is, after the judgment was delivered on 28-112023 [Jaiveer Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, (2024) 15 SCC
227 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1584] , the State of Uttarakhand
is not considering their claim.
21. No doubt that, this Court has upheld the 2012 Rules
framed by the State Government, vide the judgment dated
28-11-2023 [Jaiveer Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, (2024)
15 SCC 227 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1584] . However, at the
same time, this Court had clarified that such of the
teachers, who were already in employment as on 10-82017, would be entitled to the benefit of one-time scheme
provided by the Government of India. This Court had held
that such of the teachers who have completed the diploma
course of 18 months would be treated as valid diplomaholders for the purpose of applying in other institutions or
for promotional avenues.
22. Indisputably, the “other institutions” would
include the schools run by the State Governments.”
also
Referring para No.14 of the aforesaid judgment, Learned
Counsel drawn the attention of the Court that the Hon’ble Apex Court
in the said judgment specifically observed/clarified that 18 months
diploma obtained by such persons, who were in employment as on
10.08.2017 and who have completed the diploma course of 18
months, would be treated as valid diploma holders for the purpose of
applying in other institutions or for promotional avenues and this will
be effective from the date of pronouncement of the judgment under
review and referring para No.20, Learned Counsel further submitted
that Hon’ble the Apex Court further clarified that the teachers who
were already in employment as on 10th August, 2017, would be
entitled to the benefit of One Time Scheme provided by the
Government of India and the teachers who have completed the
diploma course of 18 months would be treated as valid diploma
holders for the purpose of applying in other institutions or for
promotional avenues. Learned Counsel thereafter submitted that
inspite of the direction of the Hon’ble Apex Court, the respondentauthority did not consider/publish the name of the petitioners of both
the writ petitions in the final selection list, although they possessed
the requisite qualification and had qualified in the examination.
4.9.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel drawn the attention of the
Court to the RTI made by some of the petitioners to the NIOS and
pointed out that the following questions were put to NIOS through RTI
for clarification:
1. Is 2017-19 NIOS D.El.Ed course is completed by 31st
March, 2019 or not?
2. Does the certificate issued on 22.05.2019 implies that
our course was completed by 31.03.2019 or on 22.05.2019
although our last exam regarding NIOS D.El.Ed was held on
mid March 2019?
In reply under RTI, the NIOS gave the following reply on
24.07.2025:
Answer in respect of point No.1: Yes
Answer in respect of point No.2: NIOS conducted
D.El.Ed
programme
for
in-service
untrained
elementary teachers working at elementary level in
Govt./Govt. aided/private unaided school across
India as per the direction of Ministry of Education and
recognition by NCTE. As per MoE and NCTE guidelines
all the activities related to D.El.Ed have been
completed
by
31.03.2019
including
the
final
examinations.
The date of result declaration of D.El.Ed. (Online)
Examination held in March, 209 was 22.05.2019.
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that all
the petitioners have completed their final examination by 31.03.2019
but the certificates of NIOS were issued on 22.05.2019, so, there was
no confusion to that. But the respondent-authority ignoring the
guidelines of NCTE and MoE most arbitrarily rejected the candidature
of the petitioners and inspite of qualifying the examination as per
requirement rules, intentionally did not mention their names in the
final selection list.
4.10.
Learned Counsel also submitted that as per the direction
of MHRD, a memorandum dated 19.08.2017 was issued by the
Additional Secretary to the Government of India, Education(School)
Department, Directorate of Elementary Education, Government of
Tripura which also acknowledged the said fact that the time limit of
training
of
untrained
in-service
Government/Government-aided/unaided
teachers
private
school
in
the
has
been
extended upto 31.03.2019 by an amendment to Section 23(2) of RTE
Act, 2009 as the last chance and by the said memorandum dated
19.08.2017, also issued necessary instructions in this regard which
was also within the knowledge of the respondent-authority.
For the sake of convenience, the relevant part of
memorandum dated 19.08.2017 are mentioned herein below:
“
*
*
*
All concerned Govt., Govt. aided and unaided Private
Schools should upload the data of untrained in-service
teachers under their control by 18 August 2017
positively.
The Nodal Officer appointed by the NIOS for Tripura is
Dr.
Piyush
Prasad.
His
contact
no
is
03612650541/2651201
3. All in-service untrained teachers are therefore asked to
acquire the minimum academic and professional
qualification as prescribed by the NCTE within the
stipulated timeline i.e 31/03/2019.
4. In view of the above, all District Education Officers, the
Principal Officer, TTAADC are requested to instruct all
Inspector of School and Principals/ Administrators /
Head Teachers of the Government, Govt aided and
Private Schools in respective jurisdiction to ensure
compliance of this instruction by all concerned.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
inspite of having all the requisite qualification the respondentauthority has intentionally deprived the petitioners to their legitimate
right which compelled the petitioners to file this present writ petitions
seeking redress.
4.11.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel for the petitioners in both
the writ petitions drawn the attention of the Court to the order dated
10.12.2024 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported
in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 4937 [titled as Viswanath & others vs.
State of Uttarakhand & others] wherein in para Nos.3 and 4,
Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“3. However, to avoid any confusion, we again clarify that
the 18 months diploma obtained by such persons, who
were in employment as on 10.08.2017 and who have
completed the diploma course of 18 months, would be
treated as valid diploma holders for the purpose of applying
in other institutions or for promotional avenues.
4. Needless to state that the clarification will be effective
from the date of pronouncement of the judgment under
review.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel further reiterated
that Hon’ble the Supreme Court by the said order further clarified that
months
diploma
obtained
by
such
persons,
who
were
in
employment as on 10.08.2017 and who have completed the diploma
course of 18 months, would be treated as valid diploma holders for
the purpose of applying in other institutions or for promotional
avenues and the clarification will be effective from the date of
pronouncement of the judgment under review. But inspite of clear
direction of the Hon’ble Apex Court, the respondent-authority failed to
consider the case of the present petitioners and drop their names
from the final selection list at the time of declaration of merit list.
4.12.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel further submitted that the
said fact also has been clarified by the Central Administrative
Tribunal,
New
Delhi
in
a
order
dated
26.03.2025
in
case
No.O.A./555/2025(Delhi) [Appointment] with M.A./650/2025
Exemption
along
with
O.A./957
Recruitment
wherein
the
relevant part observed as under:
“He draws attention to Clause (v) of the affidavit, which as
per the applicant is travelling beyond the directions of the
permission granted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. He
submits that as per this clause, the experience as a Primary
Teacher is being sought whereas there was no such
direction of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Further, he
submits that out of 100 candidates who were in the merit
list, only 99 have been called, leaving one Mr. Gajendra
Lanjewar. There is no reason or explanation afforded by
the KVS in their short affidavit as to why the one candidate
has not been called.”
4.13.
Learned Counsel in support of his submission further
drawn the attention of the Court to another order of the Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
dated
03.06.2025
passed
in
connection
with
Transfer Petition (Civil) Nos.1204-1206 of 2025 [titled as
Milon Basumatary and others Vs. State of Assam and others]
along with Transfer Petition (Civil) No.1096 of 2025 wherein
Hon’ble Supreme Court specifically gave the following direction/order
in respect of State of Assam:
“
ORDER
These transfer petitions have been preferred by petitioners,
who have preferred writ petitions before the High Court
seeking appointment to the post of Assistant Teacher on
the strength of 18 month Diploma in Elementary Education
(D.El.Ed.) course conducted by the National Institute of
Open Schooling through Open Distance Learning (ODL)
mode.
The basic proclaim was the order passed by this Court on
28.11.2023 in the matter of "Jaiveer Singh v. The State of
Uttarakhand and Others:(2024) 15 SCC 227” and the
clarification issued by this Court from time to time.
Mr. Ankit Roy, learned standing counsel appearing for the
State of Assam fairly submits at the outset that similar writ
petitions preferred by other candidates remain pending and
those have been decided by High Court granting reliefs
similar to the ones(illegible) which the present petitioners
have prayed for.
Learned counsel appearing for the State of Assam prays for
sending the matter back to the High Court. However,
considering that the similarly placed petitioners have
admittedly been granted relief, which they had prayed for,
it would be unnecessary to relegate the petitioners to the
High Court. Therefore, we dispose of the present petitions
by allowing the writ petitions preferred by the petitioners
in terms of the order passed by the High Court in other writ
petitions preferred by similarly situated candidates.
In addition, it is directed that since the petitioners have
already participated in the counseling, they shall be issued
appointment
orders/letters
based
on
their
merit
position/result of the counseling. This may be done within
a period of three months.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.”
4.14.
Lastly, Learned Counsel referred another order of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 08.10.2025 passed in connection with
Transfer petition(C) Nos.1995-1997 of 2024 [titled as Adarsh
Kumar Srivastav and others Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh] along
with other connected Transfer petitions [Transfer petition(c)
No.1052 of 2025 and Transfer petition(c) Nos.1404-1406 of
2025] wherein in Transfer petition(c) No.1052 of 2025 and
Transfer petition(c) Nos.1404-1406 of 2025 at para Nos.3, 4 and
5, Hon’ble the Apex Court gave the following observation:
“3. The sole ground on which they were denied
appointment was that they did not possess the diploma of
two years.
4. In that view of the matter, the transfer petitions are
allowed.
5. The respondent(s)-State(s) are directed to issue
appointment to the petitioners within a period of three
months from today.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
inspite of specific orders of Hon’ble the Supreme Court, the
respondent-authority most arbitrarily dropped the names of the
petitioners from the final selection list for which they were compelled
to seek redress to this Court.
Finally, Learned Counsel urged for allowing the writ
petition with a
direction to
the respondent-authority
to
issue
appointment orders in favour of the petitioners within a short period.
5.
Both the writ petitions have been contested by the State-
respondents by filing their counter affidavit. The State-respondents in
the counter affidavit denied the assertions of the petitioners in both
the writ petitions. In para Nos.3, 4 and 5, the State-respondents have
asserted the following facts and prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition:
“3. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India by a judgment
passed in Jaiveer Sing and Others V/S The State of
Uttarkhan had given relaxation of 18 Months diploma in
Elementary Education (for short D.El.Ed) as one time
window to the in-service teachers provided this 18 months
D.EL.Ed course must be completed prior to 1st April, 2019.
But the Petitioner completed 18 months Diploma Course on
07.02.2022 i.e after 1st April, 2019. In para 42 of the said
Judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court has stated as follows:
"That leaves us with the reliance placed by the learned
counsel for NCTE on the judgment of this Court in the
case of Ram Sharan Maurya (Supra). There can be no
doubt that NCTE, as an expert body, has a right to
prescribe the minimum qualifications. In the present
case itself, by notification dated 23rd August 2010 and
29th July, 2011, NCTE has done so. As already discussed
hereinabove, recognition order dated 22nd September
2017 only provides a window for inservice teachers to
complete their course prior to 1 st April, 2019. As such,
the said judgment does not apply to the present case."
Copy of the Judgment (Jaiveer Singh and Others V.S The
State of Uttarkhand) is annexed hereto and marked as
Annexure R/1.
4. That, subsequently, a review petition was filed for
reviewing the said judgment. In the order passed in the
Review Application the Hon'ble Supreme Court has again
clearly stated that 18 months Diploma course relaxation
was provided as an one time window only for in candidates.
The operative part of the said order dated 10/12/2024 is
as follows:
"2. We have already clarified in the judgment under
review that the one time scheme was provided solely to
safeguard the interests of those teachers who were
employed as on 10.08.20217. We are, therefore, not
inclined to entertain the present review petitions as well
as miscellaneous applications.
3. However, to avoid any confusion, we again clarify
that the 18 months diploma obtained by such persons,
who were in employment as on 10.08.2017 and who
have completed the diploma course of 18 months, would
be treated as valid diploma holders for the purpose of
applying in other institutions or for promotional
avenues"
Copy of the Order dated 10.12.2024 is annexed hereto and
marked as Annexure R/2.
5. That, the Petitioner is not entitled for recruitment in the
post of Graduate Teacher because of the fact that 18
months Course was allowed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
only as one time relaxation for in service teachers only and
the Petitioner was not an inservice teacher. From TRBT
Application Acknowledgment for T-TET Paper II Session
2021 it has become clear that the Petitioner did not submit
any No Objection Certificate to TRBT and also the petitioner
stated "NO" against the column "Whether she was
employed".
Copy of TRBT Application Acknowledgment for T-TET Paper
II Session 2021 is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure
R/3.”
6.
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Addl. G.A., Mr.
Karnajit De appearing on behalf of the State-respondents has drawn
the attention of the Court to the recruitment rules for the post of
Graduate Teacher (For class VI-VIII) under the Education (School)
Department
dated
notified
vide
No.F.1(1-1)-DEE/ESTT/2020(L-6)/8637
23.03.2021(Annexure-R/4)
and
submitted
that
as
per
recruitment rules in point No.7 at clause(a), Graduation and 2 years
Diploma in Elementary Education (by whatever name known) was
fixed as essential minimum qualification for the post of Graduate
Teacher(class VI-VII). It was further submitted by Learned Addl. G.A.
that in both the writ petitions, the petitioners have not challenged the
recruitment rules.
Furthermore, the petitioner Mithu Paul Deb at the time of
application to TRBT (Annexure-R/3) in the relevant column mentioned
that she was not in service. So, Learned Addl. G.A. submitted that the
petitioner Mithu Paul Deb was not entitled for recruitment to the post
of Graduate Teacher because of the fact that 18 months course was
allowed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India as One Time
Relaxation for in-service teachers and the petitioner at the time of
application was not serving and thus, her candidature was rightly
refused by the authority and she was not entitled to get the
appointment.
7.
Learned Addl. G.A. further drawn the attention of the Court
referring one judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
reported in (2024) 15 SCC 227 [titled as Jaiveer Singh and
others vs. The State of Uttarakhand and others] wherein in para
Nos.48 and 53, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“48. Assuming for a moment that the 18 months' DElEd
Diploma by NIOS through ODL mode is equivalent to the 2
years' Diploma in Elementary Education recognised under
the Notifications of NCTE dated 23-8-2010 and 29-7-2011,
the next question that has to be answered is, can the State
be prohibited from prescribing the minimum qualifications
which is higher than that. A similar question arose for
consideration in S. Satyapal Reddy v. State of A.P. [S.
Satyapal Reddy v. State of A.P., (1994) 4 SCC 391 : 1994
SCC (L&S) 914] , wherein this Court observed thus: (SCC p.
396, para 7)
“7. … The Governor has been given power under the
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution, subject to any
law made by the State Legislature, to make rules
regulating the recruitment which includes prescription
of qualifications for appointment to an office or post
under the State. Since the Transport Department under
the Act is constituted by the State Government and the
officers appointed to those posts belong to the State
service, while appointing its own officers, the State
Government as a necessary adjunct is entitled to
prescribe qualifications for recruitment or conditions of
service. But while so prescribing, the State Government
may accept the qualifications or prescribe higher
qualification but in no case prescribe any qualification
less than the qualifications prescribed by the Central
Government under sub-section (4) of Section 213 of the
Act.”
[emphasis supplied]
53. That leaves us with the reliance placed by the learned
counsel for NCTE on the judgment of this Court in Ram
Sharan Maurya [Ram Sharan Maurya v. State of U.P.,
(2021) 15 SCC 401 : (2024) 1 SCC (L&S) 576] . There can
be no doubt that NCTE, as an expert body, has a right to
prescribe the minimum qualifications. In the present case
itself, by Notifications dated 23-8-2010 and 29-7-2011,
NCTE has done so. As already discussed hereinabove,
recognition order dated 22-9-2017 only provides a window
for in-service teachers to complete their course prior to 14-2019. As such, the said judgment does not apply to the
present case.”
Referring the same, Learned Addl. G.A. submitted that the
observation made by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in the aforenoted
case does not cover the case of the present petitioner namely Smt.
Mithu Paul Deb and other petitioners of the connected writ petition.
8.
Learned Addl. G.A. further drawn the attention of the Court
that from the marksheet (Annexure-2), it will transpire that the result
was declared on 07.02.2022, which was beyond the stipulated period
and as such, on the basis of that marksheet of NIOS, she is not
entitled to get any protection. Similarly, other petitioners are not
entitled to get any protection as they are also in the same footing like
Mithu Paul Deb and prayed for dismissal of the writ petitions.
9.
The respondent No.8-NCTE also filed counter affidavit. In para
Nos.4, 5, 6, 7 and 8, it has been stated as under:
“4. That your humble deponent respectfully submits that,
by virtue of the 2017 Amendment Act, a Second Provision
was inserted into Sub-Section (2) of Section 23 of the RTE
Act, with retrospective effect from 1st April 2015. This
provision mandates that every teacher appointed or
holding a position as on 31st March 2015, who does not
possess the minimum qualifications specified under SubSection (1), shall acquire such minimum qualifications
within a period of four years from the date of
commencement of the 2017 Amendment Act.
Further, it is submitted that in exercise of the powers
conferred under Sub-Section (1) of Section 23 of the RTE
Act, the Central Government authorized Respondent No. 8,
the NCTE, as the academic authority to prescribe the
minimum qualifications for eligibility for appointment as a
school teacher. Accordingly, the NCTE issued a notification
dated 23rd August 2010, prescribing the minimum
qualifications required for the recruitment of teachers.
A copy of the Notification dtd.23.08.2010 is annexed
herewith and marked as ANNEXURE-A.
5. That your humble deponent begs to state that thereafter,
the Central Government, in exercise of its powers under
Section 29 of the National Council for Teacher Education
Act, 1993, issued a direction recognizing the National
Institute of Open Schooling (NIOS). Accordingly, a
recognition order dated 22.09.2017 was issued by the
Northern Regional Committee of the National Council for
Teacher Education, exercising its powers under Sections
14(3)(a) and 15(3)(a) of the NCTE Act, as well as Clause
7(6) of the NCTE (Recognition Norms and Procedure)
Regulations, 2014. This order granted recognition to the
D.El.Ed. programme-an 18-month course including a 6month internship-for untrained teachers appointed on or
before 10th August 2017.
A copy of the recognition order dtd.22.09.2017 is
annexed herewith as ANNEXURE-B.
6. That your humble deponent begs to state that the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jaiveer Singh and Others Vs. The
State of Uttarakhand and Others vide judgment dated
28.11.2023 had stated:
"41. In view of what has been held by this Court
hereinabove, we find that the High Court erred in
holding that 18 months Diploma conducted by NIOS
through ODL mode is equivalent to the 2 years regular
Diploma, particularly so, when there was no material
placed on record to even remotely hold that such a
qualification was recommended by the Expert Body
NCTE."
On the contrary, the communication dated 6th
September 2019 of NCTE, the directives of MHRD so
also the recognition order dated 22nd September 2017
clearly go on to show that the 18 months Diploma was
provided as a onetime window to the in-service
teachers to acquire the minimum qualifications
between the 2017 Amendment Act and the outer limit
of 1st April, 2019. In our considered view, the High
Court has totally erred in holding that the 2 years
Diploma is equivalent to 18 months Diploma."
7. That your humble deponent further begs to state that
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Viswanath & others V/S The
State of Uttarakhand in Review Petition of 2024 (Dairy NO.
4961 of 2024) in Civil Appeal No.7872 of 2023 vide order
dated 10.12.2024 again clarified about the 18 months
D.El.Ed obtained from NIOS which is quoted below:
"2. We have already clarified in judgment under review
that the one-time scheme was provided solely to
safeguard the interest of those teachers who were
employed as on 10.08.2017. We are, therefore, not
inclined to entertain the present review petitions as
well as miscellaneous applications.
3. However, to avoid any confusion, we again clarify
that the 18 months diploma obtained by such persons,
who were in employment so on 10.08.2017 and who
have completed the diploma course of 18 months,
would be treated as valid diploma holders for the
purpose of applying in other institution or for
promotional avenues".
8. Your humble deponent respectfully submits that the
NCTE, by its letter bearing F.No. NCTE-Reg1011/166/2017US (Regulation)-HQ dated 27.01.2025, has forwarded the
order dated 10.12.2024 of the Hon'ble Supreme Court to all
Secretaries/Commissioners of the Education Departments
of the States and other concerned authorities for necessary
compliance, along with a copy of the said order dated
10.11.2024.
A copy of the letter dtd.10.12.2024 is annexed
herewith and marked as ANNEXURE-C”
10.
Similarly, the respondent No.10 filed their counter affidavit
and in para Nos.4 and 6, the said respondent submitted as under:
“4. That, with reference to paragraph 5 of the Writ Petition,
the petitioner has correctly stated that the petitioner has
successfully completed the Diploma in Elementary
Education (D.El.Ed.) for the Session 2017-19 but
categorically denies baseless allegations that due to
administrative delays the result was declared on
07.02.2022. The petitioner has erroneously asserted that
the result of the Diploma in Elementary Education
(D.El.Ed.) for the Session 2017-19, for which the
examination was conducted in March 2019 and petitioner
was a learner, and result was declared on 22.05.2019. The
date mentioned on the marksheet represents the actual
date on which the result document was printed. When a
result or admission record is corrected, upgraded, or
revised, the date on the updated result documents may
differ from the original. In such cases, after incorporating
the requested corrections and issuing the revised
document to the learner, thus the marksheet reflects the
actual date of printing of the result.
It is hereby clarified that the date of declaration of
results for the D.El.Ed. for Session 2017-19 in which the
petitioner was a learner was indeed 22.05.2019, and the
date mentioned 07.02.2022 as shown in the marksheet
pertains solely to the date of printing of the marksheet.
6. That, with reference to paragraph 21 and 22 of the Writ
Petition, these are matters of records and anything
contrary thereto is denied and disputed by the respondents
No.10. I, beg to state and reiterate my submissions as
made above that, the result declaration of D.EL.Ed.
examination held in March 2019 was declared on the
22.05.2019. The Respondent No. 10 also would again like
to clarify and state that the date 07.02.2022 indicated in
the marksheet is the actual date of printing of marksheet.
The Notification regarding the clarification of the
declaration of result date issued by competent authority of
Respondent no 10 with office reference по. F.7104/2018/NIOS/EVAL./D.EL.ED/V-003 Dated 05-01-2024
is annexed with this affidavit as ANNEXURE No.C/1.”
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the said
respondent submitted that the petitioners in both the writ petitions
performed their courses within the stipulated period i.e. within
31.03.2019 although their result was declared on 22.05.2019 and it
was further clarified that “07.02.2022” indicated in the marksheet is
the actual date of printing of the marksheet.
11.
In WP(C) No.242 of 2025, all the petitioners prayed for
appointment for the post of Under Graduate teacher(UGT) and in
WP(C) No.243, the sole petitioner prayed for appointment for the post
of Graduate Teacher(GT). For the sake of convenience, the reliefs
sought for by the petitioner(s) are mentioned herein below:
In WP(C) No.242 of 2025
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
consider the names of the Petitioners for recruitment to the post
of Under Graduate Teacher (UGT), holding them eligible and
qualified for such recruitment.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to include
the names of the Petitioners in the recommended list for
recruitment to the post of Under Graduate Teacher (UGT),
published vide Notification, dated 03.04.2025 (supra) &
consequently, re-publish said List by including the names of the
Petitioners therein.
AND
Call for the records pertaining to the instant Writ Petition from
the custody of the Respondents and to make the rule absolute.
AND
After hearing both the parties pass order/orders as this Hon'ble
High Court considers to be fit and proper.
AND
For this act of kindness, your humble Petitioners, as in duty
bound, shall ever pray.
In WP(C) No.243 of 2025
(i) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to
consider the name of the Petitioner for recruitment to the post of
Graduate Teacher (GT), holding her eligible and qualified for such
recruitment.
(ii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a
Writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other order/orders
shall not be issued whereby directing the Respondents to include
the name of the Petitioner in the recommended list for
recruitment to the post of Graduate Teacher (GT), published vide
Notification, dated 03.04.2025 (supra) & consequently, re-publish
said List by including the names of the Petitioner therein.
AND
Call for the records pertaining to the instant Writ Petition from
the custody of the Respondents and to make the rule absolute.
AND
After hearing both the parties pass order/orders as this Hon'ble
High Court considers to be fit and proper.
AND
For this act of kindness, your humble Petitioner, as in duty bound,
shall ever pray.
12.
I have heard the parties at length and perused the documents
annexed with the writ petition filed by the petitioners as well as the
counter affidavits along with the documents submitted by the
contesting respondents. After hearing the parties, the crux question to
be decided by this Court in both this writ petition will be as follows:
“Whether the NIOS D.El.Ed diploma conducted by the petitioners
in both the writ petitions can be treated as equivalent to 2 years
diploma as per the recruitment notification dated 12.12.2024
published by TRBT?”
To substantiate the aforesaid point, both the parties have
submitted their contentions supported by documents.
13.
It was the case of the petitioners that in pursuance of the
direction of the Hon’ble Apex Court, the teachers who were already in
employment as on 10.08.2017 would be entitled to the benefit of One
Time Scheme provided by the Government of India and the teachers
who have completed the Diploma course of 18 months would be
treated as valid diploma holders for the purpose of applying in other
institutions or for promotional avenues. It was also the case of
petitioners that all the petitioners of WP(C) No.242 of 2025 and
WP(C) No.243 of 2025 were in employment on 10.08.2017 and they
have completed their courses by 31.03.2019 and the result was
declared on 22.05.2019 but in the marksheet of the candidates,
07.02.2022 was mentioned which indicated the actual date of printing
of the marksheet. So, referring the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court as discussed earlier and also the recognition order of NCTE and
other communications, Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted
that they are entitled to employment for the posts they applied for in
pursuance of the notification dated 12.12.2024 issued by TRBT for the
post of Under Graduate Teachers and Graduate Teachers. It was also
submitted that inspite of issuing of advertisement all the posts could
not be filled up and a considerable number of posts are still lying
vacant. So, the petitioners of both the writ petitions are entitled to get
the employment since they have fulfilled the recruitment criteria and
could qualify the examination but their candidatures were not
considered by the authority. It was further submitted that the
contesting respondent No.8 in both the writ petitions and respondent
No.10-NIOS in WP(C) No.243 of 2025 also admitted the case of the
petitioners.
14.
On the contrary, it was the case of the State-respondents that
recruitment rule does not permit the case of the petitioners and the
petitioner of WP(C) No.243 of 2025 was not in employment and in the
application format, she mentioned that she was out of employment
and as such, she is not entitled to get any employment in this case. In
WP(C) No.242 of 2025, Learned Addl. G.A., Mr. Mangal Debbarma
also reiterated the same submission made by Mr. Karnajit De,
Learned Addl. G.A. in WP(C) No.243 of 2025. It was the further stand
of the State-respondents that 18 months diploma obtained through
NIOS by the petitioners cannot be treated as equivalent to 2 years
diploma and furthermore, the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in
Jaiveer
Singh(supra)
does
not
support
the
case
of
the
petitioners. Furthermore, as per recruitment notification, there was no
such condition precedent that on the date of application for the posts
to be applied for, the candidate should be in employment.
15.
I have gone through the judgment referred by the parties. By
order
dated
10.12.2024
in
Viswanath(supra),
Hon’ble
the
Supreme Court has very specifically mentioned that 18 months
diploma obtained by such persons, who were in employment as on
10.08.2017 and who have completed the diploma course of 18
months, would be treated as valid diploma holders for the purpose of
applying in other institutions or for promotional avenues and that
clarification itself shows that Hon’ble the Supreme Court granted one
time window to the in-service untrained teachers to acquire the
minimum
qualifications.
Since
the
present
petitioners
were
in
employment on 10.08.2017 and as such, the stand of the Staterespondents that the 18 months D.El.Ed course completed by the
present petitioners cannot be treated as valid and also cannot be
sustained in the eye of law. Furthermore, since the NCTE by
recognition order dated 22.09.2017 has acknowledged the said
D.El.Ed course through NIOS in respect of in-service untrained
teachers at elementary level working in government/government
aided and unaided private schools in the country and the same has
been acknowledged by the Government of India, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, as such, there is no such scope on the part of
the State-respondents to take a different stand. In this regard as
already stated, a communication was forwarded by Deputy Secretary
to the Government of India, Ministry of Human Resource Development
to the Chairperson, NCTE wherein it was specifically mentioned that
regarding training of untrained in-service elementary teachers in the
Government/Government
aided/unaided
private
schools,
an
amendment to Section 23(2) of the RTE Act to extend the period for
such training to 31st March, 2019 has been passed by the Parliament.
It was further stated that NIOS will be only singular organization
responsible for conducting the online D.El.Ed programme through
SWAYAM portal for all in-service untrained teachers and the tentative
number of in-service untrained teachers was around 11 lakhs and the
NIOS was to complete all the academic activities by 31st March,2019.
It was further mentioned that the D.El.Ed course will be from 3 rd Oct,
2017 to 31st March, 2019. The duration of the course will be for 18
months. As the D.El.Ed. programme is of 2 years, NCTE shall allow
subsuming 6 months internship period within the duration of the
proposed Online course through SWAYAM portal as all the teachers
are in-service and are/were already teaching.
Also,
from
the
contents
of
the
communication
dated
03.08.2017, it is very much specific that the decision was taken by
the Parliament after amendment of Section 23(2) of the RTE Act
regarding extension of training till 31st March, 2019. Since the
petitioners fulfilled all the criteria and undergone training within the
stipulated period as desired by NCTE, so, in the considered opinion of
this Court, the respondent-authority cannot take a different stand
ignoring the guidelines and decision of the Government of India as
well as the NCTE being the sole academic authority to formulate
academic guidelines for appointment of teachers across the country.
16.
Situated thus, there was no such scope on the part of the
respondent authority not to include the names of the petitioners in
the final selection list as qualified/selected for appointment to the
posts of Graduate and Undergraduate teachers.
17.
In the result, both the writ petitions filed by the petitioners
are hereby allowed. The respondent-authority is hereby asked to
include the name of the petitioners in the recommended list dated
03.04.2025 for recruitment to the post of Graduate Teacher and
Under Graduate Teachers for which the petitioners have applied,
within a period of 6(six) weeks from the date of passing of this
judgment/order.
With this observation, both the writ petitions stand disposed
of.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2026.03.05
16:16:44 -08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review