The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, this court’s considered opinion is that impugned judgments passed by the courts below are 11:41:29 AM well reasoned and based on appreciation of oral and documentary evidence available record. The findings recorded by both the courts below are concurrent finding of fact. The appellant has failed to show that how the finding of facts recorded by the courts below are illegal, perverse and based on no evidence.
13. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Hari Narayan Bansal Vs. Dada Dev Mandir Prabandhak Sabha (Barah Gaon) Patam, reported in (2015) 16 SCC 540 empowers this Court to finally dispose of this appeal without framing the substantial questions of law at the admission stage itself. The observation made by Hon'ble Supreme Court is reproduced hereinbelow :“In our opinion, a substantial question of law is not required to be framed if the High Court decides to dismiss the second appeal at an admission stage. Only in a case where the second appeal is admitted or is decided finally by allowing the same, a substantial question of law is required to be framed by the High Court. In the instant case, no substantial question of law was involved in the second appeal and therefore, the High Court had rightly dismissed the second appeal at the admission stage by passing the impugned order. We, therefore, see no reason to entertain this Petition.”
14. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, in the considered opinion of this court, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in the present second appeal. Accordingly, the second appeal sans merit and is hereby dismissed at the admission stage itself.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA
PRADESH
AT INDOR E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 12 th OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 555 of 2020
BETWEEN:ANNAPURNA W/O LAXMIKANT JOSHI R/O SENDHWA AT PRESENT
PS HARSUD (CHHNERA) KHANDWA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI PANKAJ AJMERA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT) .
AND
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
1.
DEVIKANT S/O VINAYAKRAV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 51
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS DEVI AHILYA MARG
SENDHWA BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
LAXMIKANT S/O VINAYAKRAV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 59
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: DEVI AHILYA MARG,
SENDHWA DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
SURYAKANT S/O VINAYAKARV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 63
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: DEVI AHILYA MARG,
SENDHWA DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
AASHUTOSH S/O VINAYKRAV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 67
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: DEVI AHILYA MARG,
SENDHWA DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
RAJIVLOCHAN S/O VINAYAKARV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 65
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: DEVI AHILYA MARG,
SENDHWA DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
SOMIKANT S/O VINAYAKRAV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 49
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: DEVI AHILYA MARG,
SENDHWA DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
7.
CHANDRAKAN S/O VINAYKRAV JOSHI, AGED ABOUT 61
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O: DEVI AHILYA MARG,
SENDHWA DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
8.
SUNANDA BAI W/O KIRANKUMAR KHODE, AGED ABOUT 57
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSE WORK R/O: KHODE COLONY,
BISTAAN ROAD, KHARGONE DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
9.
MRIDULA W/O SADANAND KHODE, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSE WORK R/O: SANAWAD ROAD,
KHARGONE DISTRICT KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
The present second appeal under section 100 of the C.P.C has
been preferred by the defendant/appellant Annapurna against the
judgment and decree dated 16.12.2019 passed by Ist Additional
District Judge, Badwani in RCANo.39A/2017 arises out of the
judgment and decree dated 27.01.2016 passed by Civil Judge, Junior
Division, Sendhwa, district Badwani in Civil Suit No.09A/2014 by
which
trial
Court
respondent/plaintiff
has
decreed
for
declaration,
the
suit
filed
possession,
by
the
permanent
injunction and mesne profit against the appellant.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that respondent/plaintiff filed a civil
suit for declaration of title, possession and permanent injunction and
mesne profit regarding property admeasuring 23ft. x 18.6 ft.
Plaintiff has pleaded that they are legal heirs of Vinayak Rao and
Vastala Joshi and their mother Vatsala Joshi was the sole owner of
the disputed house. Defendant/appellant who is wife of Laxmikant
Joshi on 17.02.2011 has illegally occupied the disputed house as she
is the Assistant Sub Inspector at police station Harsood. Plaintiff
further pleaded that they made various complaints to the police
authority for removal of the defendant from the house but all in vain.
Hence, plaintiff filed the suit for possession, permanent injunction
and means profit.
3.
Defendant/appellant filed written statement and denied the
material allegations made in the plaint and contended that defendant
has acquired title over the suit property by way of adverse
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
possession in the year 2007 as defendant is in the possession of the
suit property since 1995.
4.
Trial Court framing issues and recording evidence of the
parties decreed the suit of the respondents/plaintiff which was
affirmed by the first appellate Court on 16.12.2019.
5.
Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment and decree passed
by the courts below, appellant/defendant has filed this appeal and
submitted that impugned judgment and decree passed by both the
courts below is contrary to law, evidence and facts on record and is
liable to be set aside. The findings of the courts below in respect of
the suit property are perverse and illegal. The Courts below have
erred in not considering that defendant is in hostile possession of the
disputed property since 1995 and has acquired title by way of
adverse possession and plaintiff has not taken any action for removal
of the defendant from the disputed property. Hence, submitted that
impugned judgment and decree passed by the courts below is bad in
law and prayed for admission of this appeal on the substantial
questions of law as framed in the appeal.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused the
record.
7.
Appellant/defendant’s counsel argued that they accrued their
title by way of adverse possession and trial court has committed
error in not considering this fact.
8.
The law with regard to perfecting title by adverse possession is
well settled. A person claiming title by adverse possession has to
prove three "necks" - nec vi, nec clam and nec precario. In other
words, he must show that his possession is adequate in continuity in
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
publicity and in extent. The adverse possession must be adequate in
continuity, in publicity and extent and a plea is required at the least to
show when possession becomes adverse so that the starting point of
limitation against the party affected can be found.
9.
In the case of Ravinder Kaur Grewal and others Vs. Manjit
Kaur and others reported in 2019(2) RN 129 (SC), it has been held
that:“48. The statute does not define adverse possession, it
is a common law concept, the period of which has been
prescribed statutorily under the law of limitation
Article 65 as 12 years. Law of limitation does not
define the concept of adverse possession nor anywhere
contains a provision that the plaintiff cannot sue based
on adverse possession. It only deals with limitation to
sue and extinguishment of rights. There may be a case
where a person who has perfected his title by virtue of
adverse possession is sought to be ousted or has been
dispossessed by a forceful entry by the owner or by
some other person, his right to obtain possession can
be resisted only when the person who is seeking to
protect his possession, is able to show that he has also
perfected his title by adverse possession for requisite
period against such a plaintiff.
49. Under Article 64 also suit can be filed based on
the possessory title. Law never intends a person who
has perfected title to be deprived of filing suit under
Article 65 to recover possession and to render him
remediless. In case of infringement of any other right
attracting any other Article such as in case the land is
sold away by the owner after the extinguishment of his
title, the suit can be filed by a person who has
perfected his title by adverse possession to question
alienation and attempt of dispossession.
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
50.
Law of adverse possession does not qualify only
a defendant for the acquisition of title by way of adverse
possession, it may be perfected by a person who is filing a
suit. It only restricts a right of the owner to recover
possession before the period of limitation fixed for the
extinction of his rights expires. Once right is extinguished
another person acquires prescriptive right which cannot be
defeated by re-entry by the owner or subsequent
acknowledgment of his rights. In such a case suit can be
filed by a person whose right is sought to be defeated.”
10.
There is acquisition of title in favour of plaintiff though it is
negative conferral of right on extinguishment of the right of an owner
of the property. In the present case, it is
undisputed that
respondent/plaintiffs are title holder of the disputed house and it is also
undisputed
that
appellant/defendant
is
wife
of
the
plaintiff
no.2/respondent No.2. Appellant resided in the house as a wife of
respondent No.2. Considering the judgments of the courts below it
was found that appellant did not adduce substantive evidence before
the trial Court that her title accrued by way of adverse possession. It is
settled principle that question of possession is a question of fact. Both
the courts below on appreciation of oral and documentary evidence on
record declined to accept that appellant’s possession was hostile and
uninterrupted.
11.
So considering the oral and documentary evidence produced by
both the parties before the trial court was based on well reasons and
both the courts have given concurrent finding that appellant has failed
to prove adverse possession and perfected the title over the suit
property.
12.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, this court’s considered
opinion is that impugned judgments passed by the courts below are
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
well reasoned and based on appreciation of oral and documentary
evidence available record. The findings recorded by both the courts
below are concurrent finding of fact. The appellant has failed to show
that how the finding of facts recorded by the courts below are illegal,
perverse and based on no evidence.
13.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Hari Narayan Bansal Vs.
Dada Dev Mandir Prabandhak Sabha (Barah Gaon) Patam,
reported in (2015) 16 SCC 540 empowers this Court to finally
dispose of this appeal without framing the substantial questions of law
at the admission stage itself. The observation made by Hon'ble
Supreme Court is reproduced hereinbelow :“In our opinion, a substantial question of law is not
required to be framed if the High Court decides to
dismiss the second appeal at an admission stage. Only in
a case where the second appeal is admitted or is decided
finally by allowing the same, a substantial question of
law is required to be framed by the High Court. In the
instant case, no substantial question of law was involved
in the second appeal and therefore, the High Court had
rightly dismissed the second appeal at the admission
stage by passing the impugned order. We, therefore, see
no reason to entertain this Petition.”
14.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, in the considered
opinion of this court, no substantial question of law arises for
consideration in the present second appeal. Accordingly, the second
appeal sans merit and is hereby dismissed at the admission stage
itself.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
hk/
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/19/2024
11:41:29 AM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review