The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. For the foregoing discussion, it is clear that all the ingredients of offence under section 471 RPC are not satisfied in the present case. The charge against the petitioner is, therefore, groundless. The petitioner, as such, was entitled to be discharged.
16. For all what has been said, analysed and discussed hereinabove, the impugned order passed by the learned trial Magistrate, whereby charges have been framed against the petitioner, is not sustainable in law. Accordingly, the impugned challan and the proceeding emanating therefrom are quashed. The petition stands disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU, KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on 29.09.2026
Pronounced on 07.10.2026
Uploaded on 07.10.2026
Whether the operative part
or full Judgment is pronounced: Full
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Ankush Sharma
Through: Mr. Achal Sharma, Adv.
Q
Vs
.…. Respondent(s)
U. T. of J&K and another
Through: Mr. Pawan Dev Singh, Dy.AG
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner, through the medium of present petition, has challenged
charge sheet/challan arising out of FIR bearing No. 08/2016 dated
30.01.2016 for offences under sections 420, 467, 468 & 471 RPC of Police
Station, Akhnoor, which is stated to be pending before the court of learned
Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Akhnoor.
2.
As per case of the prosecution, the petitioner had participated in the special
recruitment drive for the post of constable in Jammu and Kashmir Police,
District Jammu for the candidates belonging to Tehsil Akhnoor, which was
conducted on 28th/29th of August, 2011 by the recruitment board of the
Police Department. The name of the petitioner figured in the list of 173
candidates selected during the recruitment process. The petitioner is stated to
have produced before the competent authority his certificates including the
certificate of his being a Permanent Resident of the J&K State. Upon
verification of the said certificate, the same was found to be fake. A
complaint in this regard was made by the Senior Superintendent of Police,
Jammu as the basis of which, aforesaid FIR came to be registered.
3.
During the course of investigation, it was found that mother of the petitioner
had entered into wedlock with one Sh. Ram Parshad Sharma, who is a
resident of Ganga Nagar, Rajasthan. It was also found that the maternal
grandmother of the petitioner, Smt Shanti Devi was not having any son,
therefore, she brought the petitioner to her house. It was further found during
the course of investigation that Smt. Shanti Devi bequeathed all her property
to her daughter, Kamla Devi, mother of the petitioner and she adopted the
petitioner as her son. The investigation revealed that Smt. Shanti Devi had
approached Patwari, namely, Ravi Singh and with his connivance, she had
managed to procure a fake Permanent Resident Certificate in favour of the
petitioner, who at the relevant time was aged only 13 years. This fake
Permanent Resident Certificate was produced by the petitioner before the
competent authority at the time of his recruitment as constable in the J&K
Police in the year 2011. After the investigation of the case, offences under
sections 420, 467, 468 & 471 RPC were found established against the
petitioner, his maternal grandmother, Smt Shanti Devi and Patwari Ravi
Singh. Smt Shanti Devi, maternal grandmother of the petitioner is stated to
have died in the year 2015, whereas Patwari-Ravi Singh is stated to have
died in the year 2010.
4.
It appears that the challan was committed by the Judicial Magistrate 1st
Class, Akhnoor to the court of learned Principal Sessions Judge, Jammu.
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
After it was found that offence under section 471 RPC only is made out
against the petitioner, the learned Sessions Judge, Jammu sent back the
challan to the Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Akhnoor.
5.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned challan on the ground that no
offence is made out against him even if, the allegations made in the charge
sheet are taken to be true at their face value. It has been contended that as per
the investigation conducted by the Investigating Agency, the petitioner has
not been found involved in commission of forgery of the Permanent Resident
Certificate. Neither there is any evidence on record to show that he had the
knowledge that the Permanent Resident Certificate, which he produced
before the competent authority was fake, because he was a minor boy at the
time of preparation of the Permanent Resident Certificate.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the
case.
7.
As is clear from the findings arrived at by the Investigating Agency during
the course of investigation, the petitioner was only 13 years of age at the
time when the Permanent Resident Certificate was prepared. There is no
evidence on record to show that the petitioner was involved in the process of
forgery of the certificate in question. It is clearly stated in the challan that the
certificate in question was forged by the maternal grandmother of the
petitioner, namely, Smt Shanti Devi in connivance with the Patwari, namely,
Ravi Singh. Both of them have passed away. Thus, the offence of forgery is
not made out against the petitioner nor it can be stated that he had connived
with other two accused in connection with preparation of the forged
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
Permanent Resident Certificate as he was only 13 years of age at the relevant
time.
8.
However, there is material on record of the charge sheet to show that the
petitioner did produce this forged certificate before the selection authority at
the time of his selection. The question that arises for consideration is whether
offence under section 471 RPC which makes the act of using as genuine a
forged document a punishable offence, is made out against the petitioner. In
order to find an answer to the aforesaid question, it would be necessary to
have a look at the provisions contained in section 471 RPC, which reads as
under:
“Using as genuine a forged document or electronic recordwhoever fraudulently or dishonestly uses as genuine any document
or electronic record which he knows or has reason to believe to be
a forged documents or electronic record, shall be punished in the
same manner as if he had forged such document or electronic
record”
9.
From a plain reading of the aforesaid provision, it is clear that for
constituting an offence under section 471 RPC, the following ingredients
have to be fulfilled:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
10.
The documents is a forged one,
Accused used the documents as genuine,
Accused knew or had reasons to believe that it was a
forged document, and
Accused used it fraudulently or dishonestly, knowing
or having reason to believe that it was a forged
document.
Coming to the facts of the present case, the document, which was produced
by the petitioner before the selection authority, is a forged document. The
said fact stands established from the material collected by the Investigating
Agency. There is also material on record to show that the petitioner has used
the said document as genuine. The only question that remains to be
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
determined is as to whether the accused/petitioner knew or had reason to
believe that it was a forged document.
11.
The Supreme Court in the case of A. S. Krishanan v. State of Kerala,
(2004) 11 SCC 576 has, while discussing the essential ingredients of section
471 IPC, which is in pari materia with section 471 of RPC, explained the
expressions „knowledge‟ and „reason to believe‟ in the following manner:
"Under the IPC, guilt in respect of almost all the offences is
fastened either on the ground of "intention" or "knowledge" or
"reason to believe". We are now concerned with the expressions
"knowledge" and "reason to believe". "Knowledge" is an
awareness on the part of the person concerned indicating his state
of mind. "Reason to believe" is another facet of the state of mind.
"Reason to believe" is not the same thing as "suspicion" or "doubt"
and mere seeing also cannot be equated to believing.
"Reason to believe" is a higher level of state of mine. Likewise
"knowledge" will be slightly on higher plane than "reason to
believe". A person can be supposed to know where there is a direct
appeal to his senses and a person is presumed to have a reason to
believe if he has sufficient cause to believe the same. Section 26
IPC explains the meaning of the words "reason to believe" thus:
-"Reason to believe": A person is said to have 'reason to
believe' a thing, if he has sufficient cause to believe that thing but
not otherwise."
In substance what it means is that a person must have reason to
believe if the circumstances are such that a reasonable man would,
by probable reasoning, conclude or infer regarding the nature of
the thing concerned. Such circumstances need not necessarily be
capable of absolute conviction or inference; but it is sufficient if
the circumstances are such creating a cause to believe by chain of
probable reasoning leading to the conclusion or inference about the
nature of the thing. These two requirements i.e. "knowledge" and
"reason to believe" have to be deduced from various circumstances
in the case."
12.
Learned counsel for the respondents has contended that the petitioner knew
that his Permanent Resident Certificate was a forged document. It is being
contended that inference can be drawn from the fact that the father of the
petitioner being a resident of Rajasthan, the petitioner had reason to believe
that he is not a permanent resident of the J&K State. It is being contended
that in the face of these facts, the petitioner had the knowledge or he had the
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
reason to believe that the document which he had produced before the
selection authority was forged in nature.
13.
The aforesaid contention of the learned counsel for the respondents appears
to be attractive but when the material on record is carefully analysed in light
of the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in the afore-quoted judgment,
the same turns out to be baseless. There is evidence on record in the shape
of statements of PWs Smt. Kamala Devi, mother of the petitioner, Rattan
Singh and Naseeb Singh to show that the petitioner was taken in adoption by
his maternal grandmother, Smt. Shanti Devi. There is also evidence on
record to show that the petitioner has all along resided at Akhnoor with her
maternal grandmother. Thus, the material on record tends to show that the
petitioner was brought up by his maternal grandmother, who was the
permanent resident of the J&K State as her son. In the face of this evidence
on record, there was no reason for the petitioner to entertain any doubt about
his being a permanent resident of the Jammu and Kashmir State.
14.
In the face of this situation, it cannot be stated that the essential ingredient of
offence under section 471 RPC with regard to the knowledge or reasonable
belief of the petitioner that the document in question was a forged one, is
satisfied in the instant case. The petitioner was a minor boy aged 13 years at
the time of preparation of the certificate in question and he was taken in
adoption by his maternal grandmother, who was a permanent resident of the
J&K State, therefore, the petitioner had no reason to doubt the genuineness
of the certificate which he produced before the selection authority.
15.
For the foregoing discussion, it is clear that all the ingredients of offence
under section 471 RPC are not satisfied in the present case. The charge
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
against the petitioner is, therefore, groundless. The petitioner, as such, was
entitled to be discharged.
16.
For all what has been said, analysed and discussed hereinabove, the
impugned order passed by the learned trial Magistrate, whereby charges have
been framed against the petitioner, is not sustainable in law. Accordingly, the
impugned challan and the proceeding emanating therefrom are quashed. The
petition stands disposed of.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
Jammu
07.10.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Rakesh Kumar
2026.10.07 14:35
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM(M) No. 399/2022
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review