Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ABUJAM
SURJIT
SINGH
Digitally signed
by ABUJAM
SURJIT SINGH
Date:
2023.04.28
14:15:36
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
1. Dr. Anju Devi Loukham aged about 46 years old W/o,
Rajkumar Roshan a resident of Sagolband Sayang Pukhri
Mapal, P. O. Imphal & P.S Lamphet, Manipur-795001.
……. Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Science
(JNIMS), Porompat, Imphal East, Manipur, represented by its
Director of JNIMS, P. O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East,
Manipur-7950005.
2. The Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur/Chairman of
Selection of Selection Committee JNIMS, Porompat, Imphal
East, Manipur having its office at Old Secretariat (South
Block), P. O & P.S. Imphal, West, Manipur-795001.
3.
The
Commissioner
(Health),
/
Secretary
Health,
Government of Manipur having its office at Old Secretariat
(South Block), P. O & P.S. Imphal, West, Manipur-795001.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 1
4. The Principal Secretary/Commissioner (Department of
Personnel & Administrative Reforms), Government of
Manipur, its Old Secretariat P. O & P.S. Imphal, West,
Manipur-795001.
5. The Medical Council of India represented by its
Secretary, having it office at Pocket No.14, Sector-8,
Dwarka Phase -1, New Delhi-10077.
6.
Dr. Ruma Sarkar aged about 51 years, W/o Professor
Ch. Pritam Kumar Singh, a resident of Singjamei Chirom
Leikai, Chingamathak, Imphal West District, Manipur,
795001.
……Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. T. Momo, Adv.,
For the Respondents
:
Mr. S. Nepolean, GA & Mr. Y.
Mr. Nirmolchand, Sr. Adv.
Mr. BR. Sharma, Sr. PCCG
A
Date of hearing &
:
reserving Judgment & Order :
19.04.2023
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 2
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1].
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner for
issuance of a writ of certiorarified mandamus to quash (i) the
impugned DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 thereby
holding the DPC for appointment to the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis in Jawaharlal
Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences (JNIMS), Manipur as illegal
since the petitioner was the only eligible Assistant Professor for
promotion when the vacancy in the said lone post arose in the
financial year 2018-2019; (ii) the appointment order dated
20.12.2019 whereby appointing the sixth respondent on the
impugned DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 with effect
form 15.10.2019 and to direct the respondent JNMIS to hold a
review DPC for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in
the Department of Radio Diagnosis in accordance with the
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 and to appoint the petitioner to
the post of Associate Professor.
[2].
Brief facts are as follows:
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 3
On 6.3.2007, the petitioner was initially appointed as
Assistant
Professor
in
Tripura
Medial
College
and
Dr.
B.R.Ambedkar Memorial Teaching Hospitaland she continued to
work in the said Medical College till 27.1.2011. Thereafter, she
applied for the post of Senior Resident in the Department of
Radio-Diagnosis, JNIMS as there was no post of Assistant
Professor and, accordingly, she resigned from the said post so
as to enable her to join in the new appointment.
After
resignation from Tripura Medical College and Dr. B.R.Ambedkar
Memorial Teaching Hospital, the petitioner was appointed as
Senior Resident in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis, JNIMS.
She continued to discharge her duties in the said post of Senior
Resident till she was regularly appointed to the post of Assistant
Professor on direct recruitment by an order dated 31.8.2015
along with other four candidates, including the sixth respondent.
2.1. As per the guidelines of the Medical Council of India,
the
past
services
in
the
permitted/approved/recognized
equivalent
post
colleges
can
in
be
the
MCI
taken
into
consideration for counting eligibility criteria for promotion to the
next higher post and in this regard several other incumbents
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 4
also received such benefits in JNIMS and, as such, similar relief
is entitled to receive by the petitioner for counting her past
service for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis in JNIMS. In this regard, the
petitioner also preferred representation dated 30.1.2019 for
counting her past services.
In case, the past services of the
petitioner is counted, as per the guidelines of the MCI, she has
more than 5 years post PG teaching experience and as on July
2019, she had completed 7 years 9 months as an Assistant
Professor in the subject of Radio-Diagnosis.
In the event the
past services of the petitioner is counted, her case for promotion
could have been considered on completion of 5 years’ service
counting together her past service render at Tripura Medial
College and Dr.B.R.Ambedkar Memorial Teaching Hospital and
JNIMS.
However, the same was not yet considered by the
competent authority.
2.2. The sixth respondent filed W.P.(C) No.670 of 2019
praying for directing the respondents to initiate process for
promotion to the post of Associate Professor, Radio-Diagnosis by
considering
all
Assistant
Professors,
Radio-Diagnosis
from
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 5
31.8.2019 under Rule 8(2) of the JNIMS Service Rules, 2015
and further praying to direct the respondents not to fill up the
lone vacant post of Associate Professor, Radio-Diagnosis by
invoking Rule 13 by superseding all the Senior Assistant
Professors, Radio-Diagnosis.
On 29.8.2019, the petitioner’s
husband submitted a representation to the competent authority
and same was not considered till date.
2.3. According to the petitioner, it is the guideline of the
Government of Manipur to convene DPC at regular annual
intervals as per the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 to
draw panels which could be utilized on making promotion
against the vacancies occurring during the course of a year.
Holding of DPC need not be delayed or postponed on the ground
that Recruitment Rules for the post are being revised/amended.
2.4. Since the respondent authorities have failed to
consider the representation dated 30.1.2019, the petitioner has
filed W.P.(C) No.700 of 2019 directing the first respondent to
consider her case for promotion to the post of Associate
Professor. When the said writ petition was taken up for hearing,
a
prayer
was
made
to
consider
and
dispose
of
the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 6
representations dated 30.1.2019 and 29.7.2019 along the with
representation dated 29.8.2019 preferred by the petitioner’s
husband and also reserve one post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis, which was then lying vacant in
the JNIMS. During the pendency of the said writ petition, the
petitioner came to know that the DPC for promotion to the post
of Associate Professors are likely to be considered, the petitioner
filed M.C.No.250 of 2019 and by the order dated 24.9.2019,
thisCourt, directed not to declare the result of the DPC.
2.5. While so, the petitioner came to know that promotion
orders dated 15.10.2019 were issued in favour of some of the
Associate Professors in the Department of Anesthesiology and
Medicine etc., wherein it has been mentioned that the DPC for
the post of Associate Professor were held on 16.9.2019 and
26.9.2019 including the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis in JNIMS along with other
eligible persons, who became eligible only on 31.8.2019 which is
highly discriminatory and arbitrary in nature as the case of the
petitioner alone should have been considered for such promotion
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 7
insofar as the post of Associate Professor in the Department of
Radio-Diagnosis is concerned.
2.6. The petitioner was certified to have entered in the
Indian Medical Registrar as an MBBS and registered in the
Assam Medical Council as on 27.4.2001 and she was further
qualified to as MD (Regio-Diag./Radio Diag and Imaging),
U.Rajiv Gandhi health Sciences in 2006. By the order dated
19.9.2019, W.P.(C) No.670 of 2019 filed by the sixth respondent
was dismissed as withdrawn.
Thereafter, the sixth respondent
has filed W.P.(C) No.892 of 2019 praying for a direction on the
respondents to afford promotion to the post of Associate
Professor,
Radio-Diagnosis.
The
petitioner
also
preferred
W.P.(C) No.896 of 2019 to quash the impugned DPC as illegal
and for a direction on the first respondent to consider the case
of the petitioner for promotion to the post of Associate Professor
in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis.
2.7. By the order dated 27.11.2019, W.P.Nos.896, 700 and
892 of 2019 were disposed of by permitting the respondent
JNIMS to declare the result of the DPC meeting dated 16.9.2019
and 26.9.2019 with liberty to the petitioner to approach the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 8
Court, if aggrieved by any findings of the DPC. On the basis of
the
impugned
DPC
held,
the
appointment
order
dated
20.12.2019 was issued in favour of the sixth respondent.
Challenging the DPC and the appointment order issued in favour
of the sixth respondent, the petitioner has filed this writ petition.
[3].
The
first
respondent
JNIMS
filed
affidavit-in-
opposition stating that the DPC had considered all the eligible
Doctors who were within the zone of consideration and had
recommended the sixth respondent for appointment to the post
of Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis vide
order dated 20.12.2019 and, as such, there is no illegality or
irregularity in the DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 and the
consequential appointment order dated 20.12.2019 issued in
favour of the sixth respondent.
[4].
The sixth respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition,
inter alia, stating that since the post became vacant on
3.1.2019, the date of determining the eligibility for filling up of
the post will be 1.10.2019.
The DPC was held after following
due procedures and in fact, DPC was held not only for Radiology
Department, but also for all other Departments in JNIMS where
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 9
vacancies occurred. It is stated that the petitioner joined JNIMS
in downgrade post as Senior Resident after resigning from the
post of Assistant Professor in Tripura Medical College and Dr.
Bram Teaching Hospital.
But there was post of Assistant
Professor in JNIMS and the petitioner also appeared in the open
competition for direct recruitment for the post of Assistant
Professor, but the petitioner was not selected. The profile view
of the petitioner downloaded from the website shows that the
petitioner was relieved on 10.10.2019 from Tripura Medical
College and Dr. Bram Teaching Hospital.
4.1. It is also stated that the petitioner appeared in the
open competition for Senior Resident on 21.2.2011 and despite
her experience as Assistant Professor in Tripura Medical College
and Dr. Bram Teaching Hospital, the sixth respondent was
selected vide order dated 14.3.2011, however, after four
months, the writ petitioner being in the waiting list, she was
appointed as Senior Resident vide order dated 14.3.2011 junior
to the sixth respondent.
4.2. It is stated that open recruitment and promotion are
of two different entities with different procedures. In promotion,
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 10
DPC examined merit, seniority etc.
As such the experience
alleged to be gained by the petitioner in some other private
college is immaterial in the matter of promotion in JNIMS. The
procedure and requirement in the matter of promotion in JNIMS
is already laid down in the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014.
The prayer for initiating process for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor with effect from 31.8.2019 made in W.P.(C)
No.670 of 2019 was solely on the ground that all the five
Assistant Professors in the Department of Radiology become
eligible for the post of Associate Professor with effect from
31.8.2019, which includes the petitioner also.
Being a PG
teacher is not a requirement for determining the eligibility to
become an Associate Professor and the sixth respondent is also
eligible to be a PG teacher as per the latest MCI guidelines.
The
sixth respondent being senior most in terms of merit, age,
emolument of pay etc., got promoted on the recommendation of
the DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 and the sixth
respondent is also a qualified Assistant Professor eligible for
promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the Department
of Radiology. Thus, prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 11
[5].
Assailing the impugned DPC dated 16.9.2019 and
26.9.2019 held for the post of Associate Professor in the
Department
of
Radio-Diagnosis
in
JNIMS,
Manipur
and
appointing the sixth respondent as Associate Professor in the
Department
of
Radio-Diagnosis
appointment
order
dated
in
JNIMS
20.12.2019
vide
impugned
pursuant
to
the
recommendation of the impugned DPC, the learned counsel for
the petitioner submitted that in the DPC held on 16.9.2019 and
26.9.2019, the case of other candidates, including the sixth
respondent, who became eligible after 31.8.2019 was wrongly
considered along with the petitioner in violation of the Office
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 as the other candidates including
the sixth respondent were not eligible to be considered for
appointment
to
the
post
of
Associate
Professor
in
the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis on the vacant seat which arose
on 3.1.2019 due to promotion of Dr. O.Heramot Singh,
Associate Professor on promotion to the post of Professor which
falls within the financial year of 1st April, 2018 to 31st March,
2019.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 12
[6].
The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that
the other candidates including the sixth respondent only became
eligible to be promoted to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis on or after 31.8.2019, therefore,
they will be only considered for appointment to the post of
Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis
against any vacancy which arises in the financial year of 1st
April, 2019 to 31st March, 2020.
Thus, the respondent
authorities had illegally and arbitrarily considered the case of the
candidates including the sixth respondent along with the
petitioner by ignoring the relevant rules and regulations in the
DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019.
[7].
The
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
further
submitted that treating the petitioner equally with the other
candidates including the sixth respondent who became eligible
only after 31.8.2019is violative of the equality clause enshrined
under Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, inasmuch as
the respondent authorities have treated unequals as equals,
which is not permissible in law.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 13
[8].
Adding further, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that since the petitioner as per the guidelines of the
MCI, being lone eligible person, her case is required to be
considered for promotion to the post of Associate Professor,
Radio-Diagnosis as the vacancy falls in the month of January,
2019 and no other person should be considered for the said
vacancy. Thus, a prayer has been made to quash the impugned
DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 and the consequential
appointment order dated 20.12.2019 issued in favour of the
sixth respondent. To fortify his submissions, the learned counsel
relied upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
cases of Major General H.M. Singh v. UoI, (2014) 3 SCC 670 and
Ajay Kumar Shukla and others v. Arvind Rai and others, (2021)
SCC Online SC 1195.
[9].
Per contra, drawing this Court’s attention to the
JNIMS Service Rules, 2015, MCI Minimum Qualification for
Teachers in Medical Institutions Regulations, 1998 and the Office
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014, the learned senior counsel
appearing for the respondents 1 to 4 submitted that the
Department has to calculate the vacancies financial year-wise
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 14
for reporting to the DPC. For example, when there is more than
one vacancy to be considered by the DPC for promotion, the
Department has to calculate the vacancies year-wise so that the
DPC could prepare the select panel or the recommended list
year-wise.
[10].
The learned senior counsel would submit that for the
purpose of determining the eligibility of a candidate/officer for
promotion to the next higher post, the crucial date should be 1st
October.
In other words, it is submitted that the 1st October
would mean the 1st October of the particular year of the vacancy
which arose for holding the DPC.
In the instant case, the
vacancy which arose for consideration by the DPC was of
3.1.2019. Therefore, the candidate to be considered by the DPC
was those candidates who became eligible by 1.10.2019 because
the right to be considered for promotion of those candidates who
became eligible prior to the vacancies arose i.e. 2.1.2018 to
2.1.2019 would be deprived of consideration for promotion to
the next higher post.
[11].
Elaborating
further,
the
learned
senior
counsel
submitted that the vacancy which arose on 3.1.2019 is to be
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 15
considered financial year-wise i.e. March, 2018 – March, 2019
and the crucial date for determining the eligibility is fixed on
1.10.2018 and in that event the fundamental right of the
candidates to be considered by the DPC who became eligible
prior to the vacancy arose i.e. 2.10.2018 to 2.1.2019 would be
deprived of. Therefore, the purpose of determining the eligibility
of a candidate in the present case should be those candidates
who became eligible on or before 1.10.2019.
Therefore, the
instant writ petition is misconceived and, as such, the same is
liable to be dismissed.
[12].
Secondly,
the
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
respondents 1 to 4 argued that the petitioner could not raise the
issue which had already been raised in the earlier round of
litigation and no relief has been granted by this Court. In fact,
this Court in the earlier round of litigation, after hearing the
parties at length, was pleased to dispose of the writ petitions by
permitting the JNIMS to declare the result of the DPC held on
16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019. Therefore, the relief claimed by the
petitioner in the earlier two writ petitions for consideration of her
case alone for promotion to the next higher post of Associate
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 16
Professor against the vacancy which arose on 3.1.2019 has not
been granted and, as such, it shall be deemed to have been
rejected by this Court.
[13].
Thirdly, the learned senior counsel submitted that in
the earlier writ proceedings, this Court granted liberty to the
petitioner to approach this Court if aggrieved by any finding of
the DPC.
Therefore, the petitioner cannot now u-turn and
question and challenge the eligibility of the other candidates
including the sixth respondent who have been considered by the
DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019. In other words, the only
liberty granted by this Court to the petitioner to approach this
Court again was limited to the finding of the DPC.
Therefore,
the petitioner instead of filing the present writ petition, she
ought to have filed writ appeal challenging the order dated
27.11.2019 passed in W.P.(C) No.896
petitions.
of 2019 and connected
Arguing so, the learned senior counsel prayed for
dismissal of the writ petition. In support, the learned senior
counsel placed reliance upon the decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the cases of M.V.Thimmaiah v. UPSC, (2008)
2 SCC 119 and SBI v. Ram Chandra Dubey, (2001) 1 SCC 73.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 17
[14].
Supporting the impugned DPC and the subsequent
appointment order issued in favour of the sixth respondent, the
learned counsel for the sixth respondent submitted that the
petitioner
is
the
junior
most
Assistant
Professor
(Radio-
Diagnosis) and the sixth respondent being senior most Assistant
Professor, the DPC recommended his name rightly. The crucial
date of eligible officer should be the 1st October, 2019 and all
the five Assistant Professors, including the petitioner and the
sixth respondent was considered by the DPC. The petitioner was
fully aware of the fact and situation applied for the said DPC and
filed the present writ petition after she was not selected for the
post of Associate Professor, Radio-Diagnosis.
[15].
The learned counsel for the sixth respondent further
submitted that the petitioner’s claim for counting her service as
Assistant Professor in a private medical college having different
pay scale, before joining in JNIMS on regular service as Senior
Resident on 30.7.2011 is not proper. She did not claim anything
of her past service in the said private medical college at the time
of promotion to the post of Assistant Professor in JNIMS. She
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 18
only claimed for past service in the private medical college at
the time of promotion to the post of Associate Professor, which
is not tenable in the eye of law.
[16].
The
learned
counsel
next
submitted
that
the
petitioner has failed to implead the other three Assistant
Professors who are senior to her and considered by the same
DPC.
If the claim of the petitioner is granted, it will cause
adverse consequences for the other three senior Associate
Professors. Therefore, there is no reason to interfere with the
DPC held for promotion to the post of Associate Professor,
Radio-Diagnosis.
The claim of the petitioner is defective and
devoid of merit. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the
writ petition.
In support, the learned counsel relief upon the
decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of
Meghalaya Electricity Board and others v. Thuleshwar Barbaruah
and others, (2008) 1 SCC 671; R.B.Desai and another v.
S.K.Khanolker and others, (1999) 7 SCC 54 and Union of India
v. Sadhana Khanna (SMIT), (2008) 1 SCC 720.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 19
[17].
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
[18].
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the DPC
held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019, the case of other candidates
including the sixth respondent who became eligible after
31.8.2019 was wrongly considered along with the petitioner in
violation of the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014, as the
other candidates, including the sixth respondent, were not
eligible to be considered for appointment to the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis of JNIMS on the
vacant seat which arose on 3.1.2019 due to promotion of Dr.
O.Heramot Singh, Associate Professor on promotion to the post
of Professor which falls within the financial year of 1st April 2018
to 31st March, 2019.
The sixth respondent and the other
candidates only became eligible to be promoted to the post of
Associate Professor on or after 31.8.2019. Therefore, they will
be only considered for appointment to the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis against any
vacancy which arises in the financial year of 1st April, 2019 to
31st March, 2020.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 20
[19].
The aforesaid grievance of the petitioner has been
refuted by the official respondent by contending that for the
purpose of determining the eligibility of
a candidate for
promotion to the next higher post, the crucial date should be 1st
October of the particular year of the vacancy which arose for
holding the DPC. In the instant case, the vacancy which arose
for consideration by the DPC was of 3.1.2019.
Therefore, the
candidate to be considered by the DPC was those candidates
who became eligible by 1st October, 2019. Because, the right to
be considered for promotion of those candidates who became
eligible prior to the vacancies arose i.e. 2.10.2018 to 2.1.2019
would be deprived of consideration for promotion to the next
higher post.
Therefore, for the purpose of determining the
eligibility of a candidate in the instant case should be those
candidates who became eligible on or before 1.10.2019.
[20].
Since the petitioner contended that the Office
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 stipulates that DPC may be
convened every year if necessary on a fixed date i.e. 25th
January or April, it would be appropriate to quote hereunder the
frequencies at which DPCs should meet stated in paragraph 3 of
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 21
the
Office
Memorandum
dated
15.5.2014
issued
by
the
Department of P&AR (Personnel Division), Government of
Manipur:
“3. Frequencies at which DPCs should meet
The DPCs would be convened at regular annual
intervals to draw panels which could be utilized
on
making
promotion
against
the
vacancies
occurring during the course of a year, DPCs may
be convened every year if necessary on a fixed
date e.g. 25th January or April. Holding of DPC
meetings need not be delayed or postponed on
the ground that recruitment rules for a post are
being revised/amended. A vacancy shall be filled
in accordance with the recruitment rules in fore
on the date of vacancy, unless rules made
subsequently
have
been
expressly
given
retrospective effect.”
[21].
Thus, it is clear from the above paragraph 3 of the
Office Memorandum, the DPC should be held 25th January or
April according to the convenience of the competent authority.
As per paragraph 4(B) of the Office Memorandum dated
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 22
15.5.2014, the calculation of vacancies has been stated as
under:
“B. Calculation of vacancies:
4.2.
For
preparation
of
a
Select
panel,
Departments may calculate the vacancies (for
reporting to DPC) financial year-wise unless the
relevant RR specifies otherwise.”
[22].
As per paragraph 4(C) of the Office Memorandum,
the crucial date for determining eligibility has been stated as
under:
“C. Crucial date for determining eligibility:
4.3 The crucial date for determining the eligibility
of
Officers
for
promotion
would
be
as
per
applicable RRs of the Serve/Post. If the RRs are
silent, the crucial date for this purpose would be
1st October.”
[23].
Rule 8 of the JNIMS Service Rules, 2015 states
method of recruitment.
Rule 8(2) stipulates recruitment by
promotion as under:
“(2) Recruitment by promotion:
(i) Recruitment by promotion to any Grade of the
Service shall be made on the recommendation of
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 23
duly
constituted
Departmental
Promotion
Committee for the respective grades.
(ii) The Departmental Promotion Committee shall
forward to the President a list of candidates, in
order of merit, of the officers recommended for
promotion, taking into account the actual number
of vacancies and vacancies likely to arise during
the next twelve months.
(iii) The list shall be valid until the next selection
for the same Grade or specified post takes place
or a period of twelve months from the date of
selection, whichever is earlier.
Provided that the aforesaid period of twelve
months may be extended by the President for a
further period not exceeding six months.
Provided further that, in respect of a person
against whom disciplinary proceedings under the
CCS (CCA) Rules, as adopted in the Government
are in progress, the recommendation of the
Selection Board shall be kept under sealed cover
to be opened only at the conclusion of the
proceedings and such person shall not be
appointed until he is exoneration from the
charges as a result of the proceedings.
(iv) The qualification for promotion shall be as
specified in sub-rule (3) of Rule 9.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 24
(v) The selection for inclusion in the list shall be
based on merit and suitability in all respects for
appointment to the Grade with due regard to
seniority.
(vi) The Selection board shall, ordinary, assess
suitability on the basis of records of performance
of the officers.
Provided that it shall be open to the Selection
Board to interview the officers and to give such
weightage as they deem fit for the performance
at the interview.
Provided further that if the interviews are held it
shall be open to the Selection Board to co-opt
subject experts to assist it.”
[24].
Rule 9 states qualifications and eligibility.
Sub rule
(5) of Rule 9 provides as under:
“(5) Every vacancy in the grade of Associate
Professors
and
Professors
shall
be
filled
by
promotion from amongst eligible and serving
Assistant Professors and Associate Professors of
JNIMS respectively as per the MCI and DCI
norms. If no eligible serving Assistant Professors
and Associate Professors of JNIMS are available,
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 25
recruitment through open direct recruitment shall
be applied.”
[25].
The Minimum Qualifications for Teachers in Medical
Institutions Regulations, 1998 (amended upto 8th June 2017)
issued by the Medical Council of India lays down criteria for
appointment to the post of Associate Professor, Radio-Diagnosis
as under:
Post
Associate
Professor
(5
year Post PG
experience)
[26].
Academic
Qualification
A post graduate
qualification
MD/MS
in
the
concerned subject
and as per TEQ
Regulations
Teaching & Research Exp.
As
Assistant
Professor
in
subject for 4 years in a
permitted/approved/recognized
experience with the 2 Research
Publication in Indexed Journals
as
1st
Author
or
as
corresponding author.
In the present case, for the vacancy which arose for
consideration by the DPC was of 3.1.2019.
However, the
respondent authorities have taken 1st October, 2019 as crucial
date for determining the eligibility for consideration of promotion
to the post in question. In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
first respondent, it has been stated as under:
“4. …. Further, it is submitted that the DPC had
considered all the eligible Doctors who were
within
the
zone
of
consideration
and
had
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 26
recommended the Private Respondent No.6 for
appointment to the post of Associate Professor in
the Department of Ratio Diagnosis vide order
dated 20.12.2019 and as such, there is no
illegality or irregularity in the DPC held on
16.09.2019
and
consequential
26.09.2019
appointment
and
order
the
dated
20.12.2019. ….”
[27].
At this juncture, it would be necessary to quote the
proceedings
of
the
impugned
DPC
hereunder
for
ready
reference:
“PROCEEDINGS OF THE DEPARTMENTAL PROMOTION
COMMITTEE 3 MEETING FOR PROMOTION TO THE
POST OF ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR IN THE DEPARTMENT
OF RADIO DIAGNOSIS, JNIMS, HELD ON 16.09/2019 AND
26/09/2019 IN THE OFFICE CHAMBER OF CHIEF
SECRETARY, MANIPUR WITH CHIEF SECRETARY,
MANIPUR IN THE CHAIR
Members of the DPC:1.Dr.J.Suresh Babu, Chief Secretary, Manipur - Chairman
2.V.Vumlunmang, Principal Secretary
- Member
(Health & F.W.), Govt. of Manipur
3.Vice Chancellor, Manipur University
Member
(Absent)
4.Prof.Th.Bhimo Singk, Director JNIMS
Member
Secretary
5.Prof.S.Subhaschandra (Subject Expert)
- Member
2. There are 3 (three) sanctioned posts of Associate Professor
in Department of Radio Diagnosis. 1 (one) regular vacancy
post of Associate Professor is available as on 26.09.2019.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 27
3. Rules 9(5) of the JNIMS Service Rules, 2015 provides that,
every vacancy in the grade of Associate Professors shall be
filled by promotion from amongst eligible and serving
Assistant Professors of JNIMS who fulfills MCI norms, failing
which by direct recruitment.
4. Minimum Qualifications for Teachers in Medical Institutes
Regulations, 1998, MCI (amended upto August 2017), provides
the requirements of academic qualifications, teaching and
research experience for being appointed as Associate
Professor are as below:Post
Academic
Qualification
Associate
A post graduate
Professor
(5 qualification
year Post PG MD/MS in the
experience)
concerned subject
and as per TEQ
Regulations
Teaching & Research Exp.
As Assistant Professor in
subject for 4 years in a
permitted/approved/recognized
experience with the 2 Research
Publication
in
Indexed
Journals as 1st Author or as
corresponding author.
5. As per Final Seniority list of Assistant Professor in the
Department of Radio Diagnosis notified vide Notification
No.01/290/Seniority/JNIMS/2015 (Pt II), dated 20.09.2019 and
Reports of the Screening Committee dated 16.08.2019 & dated
20.09.2019, 4 (four) out of5 (five) Assistant Professors are
eligible for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio Diagnosis as under:Sl.
No.1
Name
of
the Date
of
Assistant Professor appointment
to Assistant
Professor
1.
DR.
RUMA 31.08.2015
Teaching
Experience (as
Asst. Prof.) as
on the date of
DPC
for
promotion to
the post of
Associate
Professor
4 yrs. 1 month
Remark of the
Screening
Committee on
Publication
Eligible
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 28
SARKAR
2.
DR.
KHUMANTHEM
31.08.2015
4 yrs. 1 month
Eligible
3.
DR.
OKRAM 31.08.2015
PUSPARANI DEVI
4 yrs. 1 month
Eligible
4.
DR. ANJU DEVI 31.08.2015
LOUKHAM
yrs.
months
11 Eligible
6. The DPC after due assessment of the eligible candidates on
the basis of the JNIMS Service Rule, 2015, MCI norms,
Vigilance Clearance ACRs etc. recommended DR. RUMA
SARKAR, Assistant Professor for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Radio Diagnosis.”
[28].
It is clear from the facts narrated above, the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis,
JNIMS became vacant with effect from 3.1.2019 due to
promotion of one Dr. O.Heramot Singh, Associate Professor on
promotion to the post of Professor in JNIMS, which is the
financial year i.e. 1st April 2018 to 31st March, 2019.
the
competent
authority
has
failed
to
follow
However,
the
Office
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 while taking into consideration
the crucial date.As per paragraph 3, the competent authority
ought to have held the DPC on 25th January or April. However,
despite the vacancy available on 3.1.2019, the DPC was not held
during the financial year 2018-2019. The petitioner was found
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 29
to be eligible as on 1st October, 2018 as she possessed
necessary requisites as prescribed by the Medical Council of
India Rules.
Since the post in question became vacant with
effect from 3.1.2019, the case of the petitioner ought to have
been considered by the competent authority for the said vacancy
which arose in the financial year i.e. 1st April, 2018 to 31st
March, 2019.
[29].
If we take into consideration the case of the
petitioner, we find that as per the guidelines of the MCI, the
petitioner has more than 5 years PG teaching experience and as
on July, 2019, she had completed 7 years 9 months as an
Assistant Professor in the subject of Radio-Diagnosis.
On a
perusal of the DPC proceedings, it is clear that this has not been
clearly discussed and considered by the DPC in its proceedings.
[30].
As stated supra, the vacancy which arose for
consideration by the DPC was of 3.1.2019. On a perusal of the
materials produced by the parties, it is seen that on 31.1.2019,
the Dean Academic, JNIMS, Porompat, informed the petitioner
that in order to declare her as a recognized P.G. Teacher of
Manipur University, Imphal, she must submit her relevant
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 30
documents.
Thereafter, the University vide its letter dated
25.2.2019 addressed to the Director, JNIMS, informed the list of
recognized P.G. Teachers and in the said letter the name of the
petitioner appeared at Serial No.10 and no other Assistant
Professors of the Department of Radio-Diagnosis were appearing
in the said list, which means that other Assistant Professors
were not eligible as on 25.2.2019 as P.G. Teacher of JNIMS,
except the petitioner. Therefore, it is clear that at the relevant
point of time, the petitioner alone is the Assistant Professor
serving in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis, who is eligible to
be considered for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in
the Department of Radio-Diagnosis.
[31].
That apart, the competent authority considered the
case of other eligible persons for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis
without considering the case of the petitioner in the DPC held on
16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019, which is also in violation of paragraph
4G of the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014, which reads
thus:
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 31
“G. preparation of year-wise panels by DPC where
they have not met for a number of years.
5.9 Where for reasons beyond control,
the DPC could not be held in a year (or
Years), even though the vacancies arose
during that year (or years), the first DPC
that meets thereafter should follow the
following procedures:(a)
Determine
the
actual
number
of
regular vacancies that arose in each of
the
previous
preceding
and
years(s)
immediately
the
number
actual
of
regular vacancies proposed to be filled in
the current year separately.
(b) Consider in respect of each of the
years those Officers only who would be
within the field of choice with reference to
the vacancies of each year starting with
the earliest year onwards.
(c) Prepare a “Select List” by placing the
select list of the earlier year above the
one for the next year and so on.”
[32].
In the light of the above provisions, when this Court
examines the case of the petitioner, it is clear that in the DPC
held on 16.09.2019 and 26.9.2019 the case of other candidates
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 32
including the sixth respondent who became admittedly eligible
after
31.8.2019
was
wrongly
considered
along
with
the
petitioner who according to the respondent authorities got 7 yrs.
11 months teaching experience at the relevant point of time, in
violation of the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 as the
other candidates including the sixth respondent were not eligible
to be considered for appointment to the post of Associate
Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis on the vacant
seat which arose on 3.1.2019, which falls within the financial
year of 1st April, 2018 to 31st March, 2019.
Therefore,
contention of the official respondents that for the purpose of
determining the eligibility of a candidate should be those
candidates who became eligible on or after 31.8.2019 is not
acceptable and the competent authority erred in arriving at such
a conclusion.
That apart, as stated above, there is no proper
reasoning given in the DPC for not considering the petitioner for
promotion to the post in question.
[33].
It is also the say of the respondent authorities that
the issue raised herein was already raised by the petitioner in
his earlier round of litigation in W.P.(C) No.700 of 2019, wherein
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 33
the petitioner has also filed MC.No.250 of 2019 and, this Court
by the order dated24.9.2019, directed the respondents not to
declare the result of the DPC for the post of Associate Professor.
Subsequently, the sixth respondent and others have filed
W.P.(C) No.892 of 2019 to issue direction on the respondents to
announce the result of the DPC that held its meeting on
16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 and the petitioner has also filed
W.P.(C) No.896 of 2019 challenging the proceedings of the DPC
held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019. Arguing so, the learned
senior counsel for the respondents 1 to 4 submitted that the
issue already attained finality by the common order of this Court
dated 27.11.2019 and, therefore, the petitioner once again
cannot question the proceedings of the DPC in question.
[34].
On a perusal of the order of this Court dated
27.11.2019 passed in W.P.(C) Nos.896, 700 and 892 of 2019, it
is true that the aforesaid writ petitions were disposed of by this
Court.
However, in paragraph 6, this Court held as under:
“[6] The factual aspect involved in the three writ
petitions
being
paragraphs,
this
projected
in
Court
Court
is
the
aforesaid
is
of
the
considered opinion that it would serve no purpose
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 34
to any of the parties if the result of the DPC that
held its meeting on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019 is
kept in a sealed cover till date.
In that view of the matter, the respondent
authorities/JNIMS are permitted to declare the
result of the DPC that held its meeting on
16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019.
Liberty is also granted to the petitioner in W.P.(C)
No.700 of 2019 and W.P.(C) No.896 of 2019 to
approach this Court if aggrieved by any findings
of the DPC.
With the above directions, these writ petitions are
dispose of.
Interim order passed in MC (WP(C) No.250 of
2019 stands vacated.”
[35].
The respondent authorities issued the impugned
appointment order dated 20.12.2019 in favour of the sixth
respondent pursuant to the DPC held on 16.9.2019 and
26.9.2019, the petitioner again challenged the proceedings of
the DPC and the appointment order.
Since this Court in the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 35
earlier round of litigation granted liberty to the petitioner to
approach this Court if aggrieved by any findings of the DPC, the
petitioner was right in challenging the DPC proceedings and its
consequential appointment order issued in favour of the sixth
respondent.
Therefore,
the
contention
of
the
official
respondents as well as the private respondent that if the
petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated 27.11.2019 passed in
W.P.(C) No.700, 892 and 896 of 2019, she ought to have filed
writ appeal is unacceptable and this Court is of the view that the
present writ petition is very well maintainable. That apart, on a
reading of the entire order dated 27.11.2019, it is clear that this
Court has not dealt with the merits of the DPC and, in fact, it
has observed as under in paragraph (5):
“[5] ….
In
the
absence
proceedings
of
of
any
declaration
of
the
DPC,
this
cannot
Court
the
comprehend on what grounds the petitioner is
challenging the proceedings of the DPC in WP(C)
No.896 of 2019.”
[36].
This Court is of the view that n the earlier round of
litigation this Court has not delved into the merits of the DPC
and liberty was granted to the petitioner to challenge the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 36
findings of the DPC, if aggrieved by the petitioner.
Thus, it is
clear that pursuant to the said liberty granted by this Court, the
petitioner is now before this Court. Therefore, the writ petition
filed by the petitioner questioning the impugned DPC is very well
maintainable and the non-filing of the writ appeal
against the
order dated 27.111.2019 canvassed by the respondents would
no way affect the present writ petition.
By placing reliance upon the decisions of the Hon’ble
[37].
Supreme Court in the case of M.V.Thimmaiah, supra, the
learned counsel for the respondent authorities submitted that
this Court cannot sit as an appellate authority to examine the
recommendation of the Selection Committee like the Court of
appeal and, therefore, taking into account the overall aspects of
the
matter, the
DPC
considered
the
name of
the
sixth
respondent for promotion to the post of Associate Professor.
Therefore, there is no necessity to interfere with it.
In M.V.Thimmaiah, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
[38].
Court held:
“19. So far as the allegation of mala fide against
Shri B.S. Patil is concerned, he was not impleaded
as a party. Therefore, the allegation of mala fide
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 37
could not be entertained by the Tribunal. As such,
the allegation of mala fide against Shri B.S. Patil
could not be taken into consideration and rightly
so, by the High Court as well as by the Tribunal.
The allegation of mala fide is very easy to be
levelled and it is very difficult to substantiate it,
specially in the matter of selection or whoever is
involved in the decision-making process. People
are prone to make such allegations but the courts
owe
a
duty
to
scrutinise
the
allegation
meticulously because the person who is making
the allegation of animus does sometimes bona
fidely or sometimes mala fidely due to his nonselection. He has a vested interest. Therefore,
unless the allegations are substantiated beyond
doubt, till that time the court cannot draw its
conclusion. Therefore, we reject the allegation of
mala fide.
…
“21. Now, comes the question with regard to the
selection
of
the
candidates.
Normally,
the
recommendations of the Selection Committee
cannot be challenged except on the ground of
mala fides or serious violation of the statutory
rules. The courts cannot sit as an Appellate
Authority to examine the recommendations of the
Selection Committee like the court of appeal. This
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 38
discretion
has
been
given
to
the
Selection
Committee only and courts rarely sit as a court of
appeal to examine the selection of the candidates
nor is the business of the court to examine each
candidate
connection,
and
record
learned
its
opinion.
In
this
Senior
Counsel
for
the
appellants has taken us through various following
decisions of this Court …..
22. Keeping in view the ratio laid down by this
Court in several decisions, now we shall examine
the argument of learned Senior Counsel for the
appellants which had been addressed. But we
may at the very outset observe that the Court
while considering the proceedings of the Selection
Committee does not sit as a court of appeal.
Courts have limited scope to interfere, either
selection is actuated with mala fide or statutory
provisions have not been followed. In the present
case, 39 candidates were examined
by the
Selection Committee for being recommended for
appointment to IAS. The selection process took
place
between
24-11-2003
and
28-11-2003
whereby the Selection Committee scrutinised the
service records of the individual candidates and
interviewed them and the Selection Committee
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 39
selected those candidates who were found to be
having outstanding merit and ability.
…
29. It is also contended that the marking given by
the
Selection
Committee
was
arbitrary.
The
grievance was that confidential report of Shri S.
Daya Shankar for the year 2000-2001 was not
available and in case of Shri R. Ramapriya, the
confidential report for the year 1997-1998 was
not available. Yet the reports of Shri S. Daya
Shankar was assessed to be outstanding and Shri
R. Ramapriya was assessed to be very good
without there being any basis for it. This was
found by the Tribunal to be patently arbitrary. It
is the selection process and what prevailed with
the
Committee
after
review
of
the
annual
confidential reports of all these officers cannot be
dilated in writing. When the Selection Committee
sits and considers the candidature of both the
officers and in case of both the officers, looking at
the 5 years' annual confidential reports, one is
found to be overall outstanding and the other is
found to be overall very good, this marking of the
Selection Committee cannot be interfered with in
extraordinary jurisdiction or even by the Tribunal.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 40
30. We fail to understand how the Tribunal can sit
as an Appellate Authority to call for the personal
records and constitute Selection Committee to
undertake this exercise. This power is not given
to
the
Tribunal
and
it
should
be
clearly
understood that the assessment of the Selection
Committee is not subject to appeal either before
the Tribunal or by the courts. One has to give
credit to the Selection Committee for making
their assessment and it is not subject to appeal.
Taking the overall view of ACRs of the candidates,
one may be held to be very good and another
may
be
held
to
be
good.
If
this
type
of
interference is permitted then it would virtually
amount that the Tribunals and the High Courts
have started sitting as Selection Committee or act
as an Appellate Authority over the selection. It is
not their domain, it should be clearly understood,
as has been clearly held by this Court in a
number of decisions. Our attention was invited to
a decision of this Court in R.S. Dass [1986 Supp
SCC 617 : (1987) 2 ATC 628] wherein at para 28
it was held as follows: (SCC pp. 638-39)
“28. … It is true that where merit is the
sole basis of promotion, the power of
selection becomes wide and liable to be
abused with less difficulty. But that does
not
justify
presumption
regarding
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 41
…..
arbitrary
exercise
of
power.
The
machinery designed for preparation of
select list under the regulations for
promotion to all-India service, ensures
objective and impartial selection. The
Selection Committee is constituted by
high-ranking responsible officers presided
over by Chairman or a member of the
Union Public Service Commission. There is
no reason to hold that they would not act
in fair and impartial manner in making
selection. The recommendations of the
Selection Committee are scrutinised by
the State Government and if it finds any
discrimination in the selection it has
power to refer the matter to the
Commission with its recommendations.
The Commission is under a legal
obligation
to
consider
the
views
expressed by the State Government along
with the records of officers, before
approving the select list. The Selection
Committee and the Commission both
include
persons
having
requisite
knowledge, experience and expertise to
assess the service records and ability to
adjudge the suitability of officers. In this
view we find no good reasons to hold that
in the absence of reasons the selection
would be made arbitrarily. Where power
is vested in high authority there is a
presumption that the same would be
exercised in a reasonable manner and if
the selection is made on extraneous
considerations, in arbitrary manner the
courts have ample power to strike down
the same and that is an adequate
safeguard against the arbitrary exercise
of power.”
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 42
[36].
Therefore, in view of a catena of cases,
courts normally do not sit as a court of appeal to assess
ACRs and much less the Tribunal can be given this power
to constitute an independent Selection Committee over
the statutory Selection Committee. The guidelines have
already been given by the Commission as to how ACRs to
be assessed and how the marking has to be made. These
guidelines take care of the proper scrutiny and not only
by the Selection Committee but also the views of the
State Government are obtained and ultimately the
Commission after scrutiny prepares the final list which is
sent to the Central Government for appointment. There
also it is not binding on the Central Government to
appoint all the persons as recommended and the Central
Government can withhold the appointment of some
persons so mentioned in the select list for reasons
recorded. Therefore, if the assessment of ACRs in respect
of Shri S. Daya Shankar and Shri R. Ramapriya should
have been made as “outstanding” or “very good” it is
within the domain of the Selection Committee and we
cannot sit as a court of appeal to assess whether Shri R.
Ramapriya has been rightly assessed or Shri Daya
Shankar
has
been
wrongly
assessed.
The
overall
assessment of ACRs of both the officers were taken; one
was found to be “outstanding” and the second one was
found to be “very good”. This assessment cannot be
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 43
made subject of court's or Tribunal's scrutiny unless
actuated by mala fide.
….
39. It was also pointed out that in the case
of Shri N. Sriraman and Shri K. Ramanna Naik,
the
Selection
Committee
downgraded
their
reports from “outstanding” to “very good” yet
they were selected. Similar is the case with Shri
K.L. Lokanatha who has not been selected.
Likewise the Selection Committee upgraded the
assessment for the year 2001-2002 from “very
good” to “outstanding” yet he could not be
selected. Therefore, this is also the process of
selection
and
the
Selection
Committee
is
constituted by the Commission and headed by the
member of the Commission, we have to trust
their assessment unless it is actuated with malice
or apparent mistake committed by them. It is not
the case of pick and choose, while selection has
been made rationally. The selection by expert
bodies unless actuated with malice or there is
apparent error should not be interfered with.
Lastly, the High Court considered the case of the
two candidates who were eliminated by the
Selection Committee and their cases were not
sent to the Commission for selection to the IAS
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 44
cadre. The High Court found that this was the
selection process by the Screening Committee
headed by the Chief Secretary and these persons
were
not
found
more
meritorious
to
be
recommended for appointment. This assessment
of the Screening Committee was found by the
High Court to be proper and there was nothing on
record to show that the candidates who were
shortlisted were not meritorious.”
[39].
It is settled that normally the recommendation of the
Selection Committee cannot be challenged except on the ground
of mala fides or serious violation of the statutory rules. In the
case on hand, the impugned DPC was not in conformity with the
MCI guidelines, the JNIMS Service Rules, 2015 and the Office
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 as the sixth respondent who had
not become eligible for promotion against the vacancy which
arose in financial year 2018-2019 i.e. period from 1.4.2018 to
31.3.2019 was given promotion ignoring the fact that the
petitioner who was the sole person eligible for promotion against
the said vacancy. In view of the aforesaid proved fact, it is to
be held that there is male fide and serious violation of the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 45
relevant rules in holding the impugned DPC in respect of the
ineligible persons considered along with the petitioner and
selected an ineligible person leaving the petitioner.
[40].
Since the respondent authorities considered the
name of the petitioner as eligible candidate for promotion to the
post
of
Associate
Professor
by
taking
into
account
the
contribution of the petitioner’s services as an Assistant Professor
at Tripura Medical College and Dr. B.R.Ambedkar Memorial
Teaching which is recognized by the Medical Council of India, the
argument of the learned counsel for the sixth respondent that
the petitioner was initially appointed to the post of Senior
Resident in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis, JNIMS on
30.7.2011 and on the other hand, the sixth respondent was
appointed initially to the post of Senior Resident on 14.3.2011
and the sixth respondent is senior to the petitioner and for the
above reason while promoting the sixth respondent and the
petitioner
to
the
post
of
Assistant
Professor,
the
sixth
respondent was placed above the petitioner at Serial No.1,
cannot be countenanced.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 46
[41].
The further argument of the learned counsel for the
sixth respondent that as per paragraph 4.3 of the Office
Memorandum dated 15.5.2014, the crucial date of determination
of eligible officer should 1st October of the year. As the vacancy
occurred on 3.1.2019, the crucial date for determining the
eligibility of the officers shall be 1st October, 2019 and there was
no vacancy available for the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis before 1.10.2018. In view of the
discussions held supra, the argument of the learned counsel for
the sixth respondent that the crucial date of eligible officer
should be 1st October, 2019 cannot be accepted, as it is also the
admitted case of the sixth respondent that DPC may be
convened every year, if necessary on a fixed date i.e. 25th
January or April.
However, the learned counsel for the sixth
respondent contended that the word “may” in conjoin reading
with the word “if necessary” indicates discretionary in nature
and not mandatory and there is no hard and fast rule that DPC
should be held immediately on the availability of vacancies. This
Court has already held that the promotion against the vacancy
in question was arisen in the financial year 2018-2019 i.e. the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 47
period from 1.4.2018 to 31.3.2019.
Ignoring the aforesaid
factual aspects and the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014
and also the relevant recruitment rules, the DPC has considered
the name of the sixth respondent for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis.
Thus, it is clear that the sixth respondent and others, who were
ineligible at the relevant point of time were considered as
eligible by the DPC for promotion to the post of Associate
Professor. On the other hand, the petitioner proved that she is
the lone person eligible to be considered for promotion to the
post of Associate Professor, Department of Radio-Diagnosis,
which fell vacant on 3.1.2019.
In Major General H.M. Singh VSM, supra, the Hon’ble
[42].
Supreme Court held:
“28. The question that arises for consideration is,
whether the non-consideration of the claim of the
appellant would violate the fundamental rights
vested in him under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution
of
India.
The
answer
to
the
aforesaid query would be in the affirmative,
subject to the condition that the respondents
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 48
were desirous of filing the vacancy of LieutenantGeneral, when it became available on 1.1.2007.
The factual position depicted in the counteraffidavit reveals that the respondents indeed were
desirous of filling up the said vacancy.
above view of the matter,
In the
if the appellant was
the seniormost serving Major-General eligible for
consideration (which he undoubtedly was), he
most definitely had the fundamental right of
being promoted if he was adjudged suitable.
Failing which, he would be deprived of his
fundamental right of equality before the law, and
equal protection of the laws, extended by Article
14 of the Constitution of India.
We are of the
view that it was in order to extend the benefit of
the fundamental right enshrined under Article 14
of the Constitution of India, that he was allowed
extension in service on two occasions, firstly by
the Presidential Order dated 29.2.2008, and
thereafter, by a further Presidential Order dated
30.5.2008. The above orders clearly depict that
the aforesaid extension in service was granted to
the appellant for a period of three months (and
for a further period of one month), or till the
approval of the ACC, whichever is earlier. By the
aforesaid orders, the respondents desired to treat
the appellant justly, so as to enable him to
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 49
acquired the honour of promotion to the rank of
Lieutenant-General (in case the recommendation
made in his favour by the Selection Board was
approved by the Appointments Committee of the
Cabinet, stands affirmed).
authorities
in
depriving
The action of the
the
appellant
due
consideration for promotion to the rank of the
Lieutenant-General
would
have
resulted
in
violation of his fundamental right under Article 14
of the Constitution of India. Such an action at the
hands of the respondents would unquestionably
have been arbitrary.”
In Ajay Kumar Suhkla, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme
[43].
Court held:
“37. This
Court,
time
and
again,
has
laid
emphasis on right to be considered for promotion
to be a fundamental right, as was held by K.
Ramaswamy, J., in the case of Director, Lift
Irrigation
Corporation
Ltd. v. Pravat
Kiran
Mohanty6 in paragraph 4 of the report which is
reproduced below:
“4… There is no fundamental right to
promotion, but an employee has only
right to be considered for promotion,
when it arises, in accordance with
relevant rules. From this perspective in
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 50
our view the conclusion of the High Court
that the gradation list prepared by the
corporation is in violation of the right of
respondent/writ petitioner to equality
enshrined under Article 14 read with
Article 16 of the Constitution, and the
respondent/writ petitioner was unjustly
denied of the same is obviously
unjustified.”
38. A
Constitution
Bench
in
case
of Ajit
Singh v. State of Punjab7, laying emphasis on
Article 14 and Article 16(1) of the Constitution of
India held that if a person who satisfies the
eligibility and the criteria for promotion but still is
not considered for promotion, then there will be
clear
violation
of
his/her's
fundamental
right. Jagannadha Rao, J. speaking for himself
and Anand,
CJI.,
Venkataswami,
Pattanaik,
Kurdukar, JJ., observed the same as follows in
paragraphs 21 and 22 and 27:
“21 : Articles 14 and 16(1) : is right to
be
considered
for
promotion
a
fundamental right
22 : Article 14 and Article 16(1) are
closely connected. They deal with
individual rights of the person. Article 14
demands that the “State shall not deny to
any person equality before the law or the
equal protection of the laws”. Article
16(1) issues a positive command that
“there shall be equality of opportunity for
all citizens in matters relating to
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 51
employment or appointment to any office
under the State”.
It has been held repeatedly by this
Court that clause (1) of Article 16 is a
facet of Article 14 and that it takes its
roots from Article 14. The said clause
particularises the generality in Article 14
and identifies, in a constitutional sense
“equality of opportunity in matters of
employment and appointment to any
office under the State. The word
“employment” being wider, there is no
dispute that it takes within its fold, the
aspect of promotions to posts above the
stage of initial level of recruitment. Article
16(1) provides to every employee
otherwise eligible for promotion or who
comes within the zone of consideration, a
fundamental right to be “considered” for
promotion. Equal opportunity here means
the right to be “considered” for
promotion. If a person satisfies the
eligibility and zone criteria but is not
considered for promotion, then there will
be a clear infraction of his fundamental
right to be “considered” for promotion,
which is his personal right.
“Promotion based on equal opportunity
and seniority attached to such promotion
are facets of fundamental right under
Article 16(1)
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx
27. In our opinion, the above view
expressed in Ashok Kumar Gupta and
followed in Jagdish Lal and other cases, if
it is intended to lay down that the right
guarantee to employees for being
“considered” for promotion according to
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 52
relevant
rules
of
recruitment
by
promotion (i.e. whether on the basis of
seniority or merit) is only a statutory right
and not a fundamental right, we cannot
accept the proposition. We have already
stated earlier that the right to equal
opportunity in the matter of promotion in
the sense of a right to be “considered” for
promotion is indeed a fundamental right
guaranteed under Article 16(1) and this
has never been doubted in any other case
before Ashok Kumar Gupta right from
1950.”
39. This
Court
in Major
General
H.M.
Singh,
VSM v. UOI8, again reiterated the legal position,
i.e. right to be considered for promotion as a
fundamental right enshrined under Article 14 and
Article 16 of
the Constitution
of
India.
The
relevant extract from paragraph 28 is reproduced
below:
“28. The question that arises for
consideration is, whether the nonconsideration of the claim of the appellant
would violate the fundamental rights
vested in him under Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India. The answer to
the aforesaid query would be in the
affirmative, subject to the condition that
the respondents were desirous of filling
the vacancy of Lieutenant-General, when
it became available on 1-1-2007. The
factual position depicted in the counteraffidavit reveals that the respondents
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 53
indeed were desirous of filling up the said
vacancy. In the above view of the matter,
if the appellant was the senior most
serving
Major-General
eligible
for
consideration (which he undoubtedly
was), he most definitely had the
fundamental right of being considered
against the above vacancy, and also the
fundamental right of being promoted if he
was adjudged suitable. Failing which, he
would be deprived of his fundamental
right of equality before the law, and equal
protection of the laws, extended by
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. We
are of the view that it was in order to
extend the benefit of the fundamental
right
enshrined
under
Article 14 of
the Constitution of India, that he was
allowed extension in service on two
occasions, firstly by the Presidential Order
dated 29-2-2008, and thereafter, by a
further Presidential Order dated 30-52008. The above orders clearly depict
that the aforesaid extension in service
was granted to the appellant for a period
of three months (and for a further period
of one month), or till the approval of the
ACC, whichever is earlier. By the
aforesaid orders, the respondents desired
to treat the appellant justly, so as to
enable him to acquire the honour of
promotion to the rank of LieutenantGeneral (in case the recommendation
made in his favour by the Selection Board
was approved by the Appointments
Committee of the Cabinet, stands
affirmed). The action of the authorities in
depriving the appellant due consideration
for promotion to the rank of the
Lieutenant-General would have resulted
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 54
in violation of his fundamental right under
Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
Such an action at the hands of the
respondents would unquestionably have
been arbitrary.”
40. If the seniority list is allowed to be sustained
then the engineers who are more meritorious in
the Mechanical and Civil streams than the Junior
Engineers of the Agricultural stream would be
deprived of their right of being considered for
promotion and in fact their right would accrue
only
after
all
the
Junior
Engineers
of
the
Agricultural stream selected in the same selection
are granted promotion. For these reasons also the
seniority list in question must go.”
[44].
Thus, it is clear that if a person who satisfies the
eligibility and the criteria for promotion but still is not considered
for promotion, then there will be clear violation of his/her's
fundamental right.
As stated supra, in the case on hand, the
denial of promotion to the petitioner violates her right, which
had accrued to her.
[45].
On over all analysis of the respective cases put forth
by the parties, this Court reiterated that the respondents have
completely misread the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014,
particularly paragraph 4.3 as the said paragraph does not
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 55
speaks of vacancy year. As stated supra, paragraph 4.2 of the
said Office Memorandum states that the preparation of a Select
Panel and the Department may calculate the vacancies for
reporting
to
DPC
financial
year-wise
unless
the
relevant
recruitment rules specified otherwise. Paragraph 4.3 states that
the crucial date for determining the eligibility of officers for
promotion would be as per applicable recruitment rules of the
service. If the recruitment rules are silent, the crucial date for
this purpose would be 1st October. Since the petitioner who had
already qualified to be considered for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor as on 1.10.2018 and the vacancy for one
post of Associate Professor had arose in the financial year 20182019, the petitioner being the only Assistant Professor who was
qualified for promotion to the post of associate Professor in the
said financial year, as she had fulfilled all the eligibility criteria
as per the Minimum Qualifications for Teachers in Medical
Institutes
Regulations,
and
she
should
have
been
considered against the said vacancy which arose in the said
financial year. Thus, it is a fit case to review the impugned DPC.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 56
[46].
At this juncture, it is relevant to mention that
paragraph 10 of the Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 states
review DPCs.
For proper appreciation, paragraph 10 of the
Office Memorandum dated 15.5.2014 is extracted hereunder:
“10 Review DPCs:
The proceeding of any DPC may be reviewed only
if the DPC has not taken all material facts into
consideration or if material facts have not been
brought to the notice of the DPC or if there have
been grave errors in the procedure followed by
the DPC. Thus, it may be necessary to convene
Review
DPCs
to
rectify
certain
unintentional
mistakes, e.g.:(a)Where eligible persons were omitted to be
considered; or
(b)Where ineligible persons were considered by
mistake; or
(c)Where the seniority of a person is revised with
retrospective effect resulting in a variance of the
seniority list placed before the DPC, or
(d)Where
some
procedural
irregularity
was
committed by a DPC; or
(e)Where adverse remarks in the CRs were tone
down or expunged after the DPC had considered
the case of the Officer.”
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 57
[47].
As stated supra, it is a clear case of ineligible person
was considered by mistake, apart from procedural irregularity
committed by the impugned DPC.
[48].
It is apposite to note that pending writ petition, the
petitioner filed MC (WP) No.4 of 2021 to direct the respondents
1 to 4 not to conduct any DPC meeting for promotion to the post
of Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis in
JNIMS without the leave of the Court contending that another
post of Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis
in JNIMS is likely to become vacant due to upcoming promotion
of Khaidem Mani Singh, Associate Professor to the post of
Professor
in
the
Department
of
Radio-Diagnosis
and
the
respondent authorities notified the time scale promotion scheme
for teacher of J.N.Institute of Medical Sciences Rules, 2020 (for
short, “TSP Rules”) on 18.12.2020, which are applicable to the
regularly appointed Assistant Professors and Associate Professor
of JNIMS. Therefore, in the light of the said development, there
is a strong possibility that another DPC proceedings will be held
for promotion to the post of Associate Professor due to the
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 58
vacancy. In the event that if a DPC for promotion to the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis is
conducted during the pendency of the writ petition, the
petitioner will be again denied a chance for promotion to the
post of Associate Professor.
[49].
Opposing
the
miscellaneous
case,
the
first
respondent filed affidavit stating that there is only one post of
Professor in Radio Diagnosis Department, JNIS and it is
presently holding by Prof. Dr. Okram Heramot and, as such,
there is no vacant post of Professor in the Department of Radio
Diagnosis.
Accordingly, the question of holding any DPC for
appointment on promotion to the post of Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis does not arise at the moment.
Consequently, there will be no
DPC for appointment on
promotion to the post of Associate Professor in Radio-Diagnosis
Department in the near future and, as such, the contention of
the petitioner does not arise and the relief sought by the
petitioner in the miscellaneous case is not sustainable.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 59
[50].
The sixth respondent filed affidavit opposing the
application stating that the idea of vacancy coming up in the
Radiology
Department
alleged
by
the
petitioner
in
the
miscellaneous case is a wild imagination as any promotion and
there is no increase in the total number of faculty.
If the
petitioner is eligible and senior enough in the common seniority
list of JNIMS, she too will be promoted and benefitted.
[51].
Since the first respondent themselves stated that
there will be no DPC for appointment on promotion to the post of
Associate Professor in Radio-Diagnosis in JNIMS in the near
future, the question of stopping the DPC for promotion to the
post of Associate Professor in the Department of JNIMS as
alleged by the petitioner does not arise.
Therefore, recording
the statement of the first respondent that there will be no DPC
for appointment on promotion to the post of Associate Professor
in Radio-Diagnosis in JNIMS, MC (W) No.4 of 2021 is closed.
[52].
It is to be pointed out that on 4.3.2020 when the
writ petition was taken up, this Court passed the following
interim order:
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 60
“Heard Mr. T.Momo, learned counsel for the
petitioner.
Mr. Suraj, learned counsel appearing for the
JNIMS has produced the records as directed by
this Court.
Mr.
Y.Nirmolchand,
learned
senior
counsel
appearing for the private respondent. Mr. Suraj,
learned counsel for the JNIMS, Mr. B.R.Sharma,
learned counsel for respondent No.5 are allowed
one week’s
time to file their respective counter
affidavits.
List on 20.03.2020.
The appointment of private respondent No.6 shall
be subject to the outcome of this writ petition.”
[53].
As
stated
supra,
when
there
is
a
procedural
irregularity in the conduction of the impugned DPC and ineligible
person was considered by mistake, the same can be rectified by
conducting a review DPC by the competent authority.
In the
case on hand, this Court held that the sixth respondent who is
an ineligible person at the relevant point of time was considered
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 61
for promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the
Department of Radio-Diagnosis and also there appears to be
irregularity committed by the DPC.
[54].
In the aforesaid situation, the learned counsel for
the petitioner argued that as per Rule 14 of the JNIMS Service
Rules,
2015,
a
supernumerary
post
can
be
created
for
adjustment of the petitioner or the sixth respondent either of the
regular post and the supernumerary post. This Court finds some
force in the said submission made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner.
[55].
Rule 14 of the JNIMS Service Rules, 2015 provides
as under:
“14. Supernumerary Posts:
(1) In case of exigencies, the President in
consultation with the Governing Council may
create
such
supernumerary
posts
for
a
period as specified.
(2) Such supernumerary posts so created shall
stand
abolished
as
soon
as
the
term
of
appointment of the person appointed against such
post is terminated, until and unless the president
in consultation with Governing Council decides to
continue.
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 62
(3) Further the posts of Professor filled on
contract basis by persons after retirement be
treated
as
supernumerary,
subject
to
the
condition that they stand abolished after their
tenure is completed.”
(emphasis supplied)
[56].
In view of the above and in the interest of justice,
this Court is of the view that the petitioner and the sixth
respondent may both be adjusted in either of the regular post
and
the
supernumerary
post
and
in
order
to
create
a
supernumerary post a review DPC needs to be conducted, for
which, the matter is required to be remitted back to the
respondent authorities for passing orders in this regard, as the
appointment of the sixth respondent on promotion to the post of
the Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis in
JNIMS is subject to the result of the writ petition as per the
interim order of this Court.
[57].
For all the reason stated above, the writ petition is
allowed. The impugned DPC held on 16.9.2019 and 26.9.2019
thereby holding the DPC for appointment to the post of
Associate Professor in the Department of Radio-Diagnosis in
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 63
JNIMS, Manipur and the consequent appointment order dated
20.12.2019
whereby
appointing
the
sixth
respondent
on
promotion to the post of Associate Professor in the Department
of Radio Diagnosis, JNIMS with effect from 15.10.2019 on the
recommendation of the impugned DPC held on 16.9.2019 and
26.9.2019 are set aside.
The matter is remitted back to the
respondent authorities for conducting a review DPC to create a
supernumerary posts of Associate Professor in the Department
of Radio-Diagnosis to adjust the petitioner and the sixth
respondent in either of the regular post and the supernumerary
post to be created by the respondent authorities to give quietus
to the issue.
There will be no order as to costs.
FR/NFR
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
Ab. Surjit
WP(C) No. 56 of 2020
Page 64
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review