The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In the case on hand, the wife has been keeping away from the company of the husband for the past more than 20 years and there is no chance of reunion. The emotional bond had become dry, and the warmth of their matrimonial relationship went increasingly missing and the marriage between the parties was dead. In such circumstances, if a decree of divorce is not granted, the parties would be forced to endure unnecessary suffering, misery and emotional distress. Therefore, while concurring with the Family 2025:KER:30481 ..9.. Court in its finding on the particular nature of cruelty alleged, we are of the opinion that on the other findings supra, a decree for divorce is liable to be granted.
13. Next is regarding the wife's claim for enhancement of maintenance. The wife alleged that she is unemployed and the amount of ₹1,500/- granted by the Family Court in MC No. 32 of 2007 is not sufficient to meet her expenses. Therefore, she sought enhancement of maintenance to ₹5,000/- per month, claiming that the husband being a government employee was earning around ₹30,000/- per month. However, the husband contended that the wife has income from her properties as well as from taking tuition. He further contended that he had the responsibility of taking care of his aged father and also the elder son, studying in 8th standard. On a perusal of the records, there is lack of evidence regarding the wife’s income. The husband has failed to prove the same. The amount of ₹1,500/- might not be enough to meet the expenses. The fact that the husband is taking care of his children and the aged father, also cannot be ignored. Considering the afore facts and circumstances, we hold that it would be just and reasonable if the monthly maintenance to the wife is enhanced to ₹2,500/- per month 2025:KER:30481 ..10.. from the date of filing MC No.138 of 2013 till March, 2025, and thereafter @ ₹3,000/- from April, 2025 onwards. Accordingly, the appeal and the revision petition are disposed of, as follows: a)Mat. Appeal No.172 of is allowed and the impugned judgment and decree of the Family Court are …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..1..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 19TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 172 OF 2014
JUDGMENT DATED 20.11.2013 IN OP NO.764 OF 2008 OF FAMILY COURT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
JOSE T., AGED 40 YEARS, S/O. M.THANKAYYAN, MUDANJARA
CHARUVILA PUTHEN VEEDU, NARANI, KUNNATHUKAL P.O.,
NEYYATTINKARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADVS. SRI.C.S.MANILAL
SRI.S.NIDHEESH
RESPONDENT/COUNTER PETITIONER:
ANITHA S., D/O. SATHYANESAN, THUNDUVILA PUTHEN VEEDU,
MEKKOLA, DHANUVACHAPURAM NEYYATTINKARA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 504.
BY ADVS. R.V. Sreejith
G.MAHESWARY(K/1688/2001)
T.RINI(K/1194/2000)
HARIGOVIND S.NAIR(K/933/2022)
NIDHIN KRISHNA(K/1164/2004)
ANAKHA BABU(K/324/2023)
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
02.04.2025 ALONG WITH RPFC.309/2015, THE COURT ON 09.04.2025
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..2..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 19TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RPFC NO. 309 OF 2015
ORDER DATED 12.05.2015 IN MC NO.138 OF 2013 OF FAMILY COURT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
REVISION PETITIONER/PETITIONER:
ANITHA, AGED 30 YEARS
THUMPUVILA PUTHEN VEEDU, MEKKOLLA, DHANUVACHAPURAM
P.O.
BY ADVS. R.V. Sreejith
G.MAHESWARY(K/1688/2001)
T.RINI(K/1194/2000)
HARIGOVIND S.NAIR(K/933/2022)
NIDHIN KRISHNA(K/1164/2004)
ANAKHA BABU(K/324/2023)
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
JOSE, MUDATHARA, CHARUVILA PUTHEN VEEDU, NARANI,
KUNNATHUKAL P.O. 695014.
BY ADVS. SRI.C.S.MANILAL
SRI.S.NIDHEESH
THIS REV.PETITION(FAMILY COURT) HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING
ON 02.04.2025 ALONG WITH Mat.Appeal.172/2014, THE COURT ON
09.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..3..
JUDGMENT
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, J.
Mat. Appeal No. 172 of 2014 is filed by the husband against
the judgment of the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, dismissing
OP No. 764 of 2008 for divorce.
2. RP(FC) No.309 of 2015 is filed by the wife against the
impugned order of the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, rejecting
her claim for enhancement of maintenance in MC No.138 of 2013.
3. Since the issues arose from the very same cause of action
and the parties are the same, the cases are heard together and
being disposed of by this judgment. For sake of convenience, the
parties are referred to as, “husband” and “wife”.
4.
The
marriage
between
the
parties
was
solemnized
on
18.10.2000. Two children were born in the wedlock. According to
the husband, his wife suspected him of having relationships with
other women from the early days of their marriage. The husband
alleged that the wife never joined him for visiting his relatives
or
attending
marriages.
She
is
a
quarrelsome
lady
and
made
allegations that he has an illicit relationship with his brother’s
wife, which caused much pain and agony to him. The wife is a
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..4..
postgraduate and the husband is an under graduate. She used to
stay away from the matrimonial home and after delivery of the
first child, she was brought back with the intervention of close
relatives and friends. It is also his allegation that the wife did
not attend his mother’s funeral. After the birth of the second
child in 2003, she left the matrimonial home and they have been
living separately since 10.08.2004. The husband filed a petition
for
restitution
of
conjugal
rights
in
2007,
which
was
later
withdrawn since the wife did not show any interest to join him.
Hence, the husband sought a divorce.
5. The wife, on the other hand, contended that she was
treated with cruelty demanding more dowry and also the husband
used to mock her, saying that she is not fair. The wife denied the
allegations
of
having
accused
her
husband
of
having
illicit
relationships with other women. However, she did not deny the
specific allegation that her husband had an illicit relationship
with husband’s brother's wife, Latha. The wife contended that
after the delivery of the second child, the husband was reluctant
to take her back to the matrimonial home. He never took her along
with
him.
After
the
second
delivery,
the
husband
got
an
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..5..
appointment as Police Constable and thereafter, he used to harass
her saying that she is not a good match for him. The brother’s
wife, Latha, used to interfere with their family matters and make
life miserable. The wife expressed her willingness to reside with
the husband in his quarters and not in the matrimonial home.
6. The Family Court dismissed the divorce petition filed by
the husband finding that the mental cruelty alleged by the husband
against the wife was not proved. Challenging this, the husband is
in appeal.
7. The wife filed MC No. 138 of 2013 claiming enhanced
maintenance to her and to the younger child. She alleged that she
is not having any income. The elder son is with the husband and
the
younger
one
is
with
her.
She
claimed
that
she
is
an
undergraduate and had taken tuitions on earlier occasions, but
stopped
after
getting
married,
whereas
the
husband,
a Police
Constable, earns a monthly salary of around ₹30,000/-. In an
earlier proceeding as MC No.32 of 2007, maintenance was granted @
₹1,500/- per month to the wife and @ ₹1,000/- per month to the
younger
son.
In
the
present
proceedings,
maintenance @ 5,000/- each to both.
she
sought
enhanced
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..6..
8. The husband contended that the wife abandoned the elder
son and the husband; and they have been living separately since
2004. He also contended that the wife is having landed properties
with 150 yeilding rubber trees therein and is earning ₹250/- per
day. It was further contended that the wife is taking private
tuitions for SSLC and plus two students and is earning ₹5,000/per month. The husband sought for a dismissal of the petition,
contending that he has to take care of his aged father and the
elder son, who is studying in the 8th standard; and his net salary
is below ₹15,000/-. The Family Court, though granted enhanced
maintenance to the younger child @ ₹5,000/- per month, declined
the same to the wife. Challenging this, the wife has come up with
RP(FC) No.309 of 2015.
9. We have heard the learned counsel on either side.
10.
Firstly,
we
shall
consider
the
appeal
filed
by
the
husband against the dismissal of his prayer for dissolution of the
marriage. The marriage between the parties, the birth of two
children in their wedlock and the fact that the elder son is with
the husband are all admitted. The husband raised an allegation
that, even during the initial days of marriage, the wife was
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..7..
quarrelsome and had a tendency to suspect him of having illicit
relationships with other women, which caused him severe mental
agony and distress. He also contended that his wife used to mock
him for having only a pre-degree qualification at the time of
marriage and that she refused to accompany him to functions. The
wife, on the other hand, submitted that it was the husband, who
treated her with cruelty. She also denied the allegation that she
used to suspect him of having relationships with women other than
his
brother's
wife,
Latha.
No
satisfactory
evidence
has
been
adduced by the husband to prove the allegation of cruelty meted
out by the wife other than his own evidence as PW1.
11. It is an admitted fact that from 2004 onwards, the
parties are living separately. Their elder son is with the husband
and the younger one is with the wife. During the course of
hearing, it was submitted before this Court that the younger son
also joined the company of the husband. It is also a fact that
though the husband filed a petition for restitution of conjugal
rights in 2007, it was withdrawn. The wife has not filed any
petition
seeking
restitution
of
conjugal
rights.
This
itself
reveals that the wife does not wish to join the company of the
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..8..
husband. For the past more than 20 years, there has been no
cohabitation. Thus, it is clear that the matrimonial bond between
the parties has come to an end and the husband-wife relationship
has ceased to exist. We feel that it is time for them to part ways
and
move
on
with
their
lives.
In
Shilpa
Sailesh
v.
Varun
Sreenivasan [2023 SCC OnLine SC 544], it has been held that where
there is irretrievable breakdown of marriage, then, dissolution of
marriage is the only solution. In a recent decision of the apex
court in Rajib Kumar vs. Sushmita Saha [2023 LiveLaw (SC) 727], it
has
been
held
that
keeping
the
parties
together
despite
irretrievable breakdown of marriage amounts to cruelty on both
sides.
12. In the case on hand, the wife has been keeping away from
the company of the husband for the past more than 20 years and
there is no chance of reunion. The emotional bond had become dry,
and the warmth of their matrimonial relationship went increasingly
missing and the marriage between the parties was dead. In such
circumstances, if a decree of divorce is not granted, the parties
would
be
forced
to
endure
unnecessary
suffering,
misery
and
emotional distress. Therefore, while concurring with the Family
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..9..
Court in its finding on the particular nature of cruelty alleged,
we are of the opinion that on the other findings supra, a decree
for divorce is liable to be granted.
13. Next is regarding the wife's claim for enhancement of
maintenance. The wife alleged that she is unemployed and the
amount of ₹1,500/- granted by the Family Court in MC No. 32 of
2007 is not sufficient to meet her expenses. Therefore, she sought
enhancement of maintenance to ₹5,000/- per month, claiming that
the
husband
being
a
government
employee
was
earning
around
₹30,000/- per month. However, the husband contended that the wife
has income from her properties as well as from taking tuition. He
further contended that he had the responsibility of taking care of
his aged father and also the elder son, studying in 8th standard.
On a perusal of the records, there is lack of evidence regarding
the wife’s income. The husband has failed to prove the same. The
amount of ₹1,500/- might not be enough to meet the expenses. The
fact that the husband is taking care of his children and the aged
father, also cannot be ignored. Considering the afore facts and
circumstances, we hold that it would be just and reasonable if the
monthly maintenance to the wife is enhanced to ₹2,500/- per month
Mat.Appeal No.172/2014 & 309/2015
2025:KER:30481
..10..
from the date of filing MC No.138 of 2013 till March, 2025, and
thereafter @ ₹3,000/- from April, 2025 onwards.
Accordingly,
the
appeal
and
the
revision
petition
are
disposed of, as follows:
a)Mat.
Appeal
No.172
of
is
allowed
and
the
impugned
judgment and decree of the Family Court are set aside. The
marriage between the parties solemnized on 18.10.2000 will
stand dissolved by a decree of divorce. No costs.
b)RP(FC) No.309 of 2015 is partly allowed and the impugned
order of the Family Court is modified to the extent of
granting to the wife enhancement of maintenance @ ₹2,500/per month from the date of filing MC No.138 of 2013 till
31.03.2025, and thereafter, @ ₹3,000/- from 01.04.2025.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
bka/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review