Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 14th March, 2018
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Appellants
: 1.
Smt. Anita Tamang,
W/o Late Nima Tamang alias Passang Tamang,
2.
Master Topzor Tamang,
S/o Late Nima Tamang alias Passang Tamang,
3. Master Palzor Tamang,
S/o Late Nima Tamang alias Passang Tamang,
Appellants are residents of:West Rongyek PW, Bhusuk Road,
Near Rongyek School , Dechiling,
Tathangchen, Shyari G.P.U., Rongyek,
Post Office : Raj Bhawan,
Police Station: Gangtok,
East Sikkim,
Pin No.- 737102.
versus
Respondent
:
The Branch Manager,
New India Assurance Company Limited,
Gangtok Branch, Tibet Road,
Below Old Sadar Police Station,
Post Office and Police Station : Gangtok
East Sikkim,
Pin No. – 737101.
Application under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Ajay Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa, Advocates for the
Appellants.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate for the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Dissatisfied
with
the
Judgment
dated
30.05.2017,
passed by the learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim
at Gangtok (hereinafter „Claims Tribunal‟), in MACT Case No. 42 of
2015, dismissing the Claim Petition seeking compensation of
Rs.2,22,300/- (Rupees two lakhs, twenty-two thousand and three
hundred) only, on account of the death of the husband of Appellant
No. 1 and father of the Appellants No. 2 and 3, the instant Appeal
has been preferred.
2.
For the purposes of the instant matter, the ground
raised is that the deceased was known by the names of Nima
Tamang alias Passang Tamang, while his father was known both as
Karma Tamang and Dil Bahadur Tamang. As per the Appellants, this
is evident from the fact that the name of the deceased was recorded
as Passang Tamang, son of Late K. Tamang in his Driving Licence
(Exhibit-13), in the Authorisation letter bearing his photograph
(Exhibit-19) and in the Report of the Motor Vehicles Inspector
(Exhibit-20). While in the Death Certificate of the deceased, his
name has been reflected as Nima Tamang, son of Late Dil Bahadur
Tamang, Resident of Changu, Gangtok, Sikkim (Exhibit-21), as also
in the Final Report submitted by the Investigating Officer (Exhibit23). The Voter‟s Identity Card of the Appellant No.1, bears the name
of the deceased her husband, as Nima Tamang (Exhibit-25), so does
her Certificate of Identification (Exhibit-26). The Certificate of
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
Identification of the Appellant No.2 reveals his father‟s name to be
Nima Tamang, son of Karma Tamang (Exhibit-27) and his School
Transfer Certificate also bears his father‟s name as Nima Tamang
(Exhibit-28). The Birth Certificate of the Appellant No.2 reveals his
father‟s name to be Nima Tamang (Exhibit-29) as also the
Certificate of Identification of the Appellant No.3 (Exhibit-30), his
Birth Certificate (Exhibit-31), Admit Card (Exhibit-32). Besides, the
Aadhar Card of the deceased bears the details of his name as Nima
Tamang and his father‟s name as Dil Bahadur Tamang (Exhibit-33).
A comparison of the photograph affixed on the Driving Licence of
the deceased and his Aadhar Card, clearly reveal them to be of one
and the same person. The Voter‟s Identity Card of the deceased
bears his name Nima Tamang, son of Late Dil Bahadur Tamang
(Exhibit-34),
as
also
his
PAN
Card
and
the
Certificate
of
Identification. Therefore, in view of all of the above documents, it is
clear that the deceased had and was known by two names which
were used interchangeably, as countenanced by the documents
furnished before the learned Claims Tribunal. Hence, the learned
Claims Tribunal erred in rejecting the Petition of the Claimants
despite relevant facts of the name of the deceased being placed
before it.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent, repelling the
arguments of the Appellant canvassed that no proof by way of
witnesses was put forth before the learned Claims Tribunal to
establish the fact that Nima Tamang and Passang Tamang were one
and the same person. Mere furnishing of documents does not suffice
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
to establish the interchangeability of names of the person as
contended. That, no error manifests in the conclusion of the learned
Claims Tribunal dismissing the Claim Petition filed by the Appellants.
4.
The Appellants also filed a Petition under Order XLI Rule
27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, read with Section 151 and
Section 107(1)(b)(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, being I.A.
No. 1 of 2017. It was submitted by learned Counsel for the
Appellants that the Claim Petition before the learned Claims Tribunal
was filed under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which
is benevolent legislation. The only shortfall on the part of the
Appellant was failure to establish by any witness that Nima Tamang
and Passang Tamang were one and the same person and his father
was also known as Dil Bahadur Tamang and Karma Tamang. That,
the Appellants seek to produce the area Panchayat to prove the
above facts, hence the Petition. This was objected to by the
Respondent on grounds that it was filed belatedly, apart from which
the Petition requires no consideration having failed to satisfy the
conditions required under the provision invoked.
5.
The opposing arguments of the parties were heard
in extenso and careful consideration given. I have perused the
evidence, the
documents on record
and also
the
impugned
Judgment.
6.
The facts before the learned Claims Tribunal were that
the deceased was a driver by profession, aged about 57 years, at
the time of accident, with a monthly income of Rs.3325/- (Rupees
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
three thousand, three hundred and twenty-five) only. He was
driving a Tata Sumo passenger vehicle bearing No. SK 01-T-1533
registered in the name of the Claimant No.1/Appellant No.1 herein,
on 17.1.2015. At around 14:30 hours, at Changu Commercial
Complex, under the jurisdiction of the Sherathang Police Station,
the vehicle with passengers while proceeding towards Gangtok, met
with an accident and careened off twenty feet below the road. The
deceased
succumbed
to
his
injuries
on
the
spot
while
the
passengers escaped with minor injuries. The Sherathang Police
Station accordingly registered Sherathang Police Station Case No.
02/2015 dated 17.1.2015, under Section 279/337/338/304 „A‟ of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and the autopsy of the deceased was
conducted at STNM hospital. The Insurance Policy of the vehicle
extending from 17.8.2014 to the midnight of 16.8.2015 was valid on
the date of the accident and the claimant had also paid a sum of
Rs.50/- (Rupees fifty) only, on account of legal liability to the Driver.
The total compensation claimed was Rs.2,22,300/- (Rupees two
lakhs, twenty-two thousand and three hundred) only.
7.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Respondent
denied
and
disputed the claims of the Appellants, primarily on the ground that
the driver of the vehicle who died in the accident was Passang
Tamang, son of K. Tamang, as evident from his Driving Licence, FIR,
Inquest Report and Challan forwarding the dead body for postmortem and not Nima Tamang, son of Dil Bahadur Tamang. That,
no records exist to indicate that he also went by the name Nima
Tamang or that his father was also known as Karma Tamang. That,
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
the deceased had no connection with the Claimants who have in fact
put forth a fallacious story of two names for one person as detailed
above, to defraud the Opposite Party/Respondent (herein). The
other grounds raised were that the compensation claimed was
excessive and it was denied that the deceased had an income.
8.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned
Claims Tribunal framed one Issue.
“Whether the Claimants are entitled to the
compensation claimed? If so, who is liable to
compensate them?”
9.
After consideration of the evidence and documents on
record, the learned Claims Tribunal concluded that the Claimants
have failed to establish that Passang Tamang, son of Late K.
Tamang and Nima Tamang, son of Dil Bahadur Tamang are the
names of one and the same person who was the deceased. That,
the Claimants have further failed to establish that the deceased who
died in the motor accident was indeed the husband of the Claimant
No.1 and the father of the Claimants No.2 and 3.
10.
The Petition of the Appellant filed under Order XLI Rule
27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 was taken up along with the
hearing of the main Appeal, in view of the observation of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin and
Another1, wherein it was held in Paragraph 52 as follows;
“52. Thus, from the above, it is crystal clear that an
application for taking additional evidence on record at
an appellate stage, even if filed during the pendency
(2012) 8 SCC 148
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
of the appeal, is to be heard at the time of the final
hearing of the appeal at a stage when after
appreciating the evidence on record, the court
reaches the conclusion that additional evidence was
required to be taken on record in order to pronounce
the judgment or for any other substantial cause. In
case, the application for taking additional evidence on
record has been considered and allowed prior to the
hearing of the appeal, the order being a product of
total and complete non-application of mind, as to
whether such evidence is required to be taken on
record to pronounce the judgment or not, remains
inconsequential/inexecutable and is liable to be
ignored.”
11.
This stand was reiterated in A. Andisamy Chettiar vs. A.
Subburaj Chettiar2, wherein it was observed as follows;
“16. In Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin and another
[(2012) 8 SCC 148], this Court has held as under:―
“49. An application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC is to
be considered at the time of hearing of appeal on
merits so as to find out whether the documents
and/or the evidence sought to be adduced have any
relevance/bearing on the issues involved. The
admissibility of additional evidence does not depend
upon the relevancy to the issue on hand, or on the
fact, whether the applicant had an opportunity for
adducing such evidence at an earlier stage or not, but
it depends upon whether or not the appellate court
requires the evidence sought to be adduced to enable
it to pronounce judgment or for any other substantial
cause. The true test, therefore is, whether the
appellate court is able to pronounce judgment on the
materials before it without taking into consideration
the additional evidence sought to be adduced.
………………..........................……..........................”
12.
This Court is aware and conscious that Section 163A of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, has been incorporated by the
legislature in the Statute under the welfare scheme to provide
benefits to the family of the injured persons falling within the
income group extending up to Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand)
only, per annum. Compensation under this provision is to be in
AIR 2016 SC 79
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
accordance with the Second Schedule which is a structured formula
and is a benevolent legislation.
13.
It is indeed trite law that the conditions laid down under
Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 are to be
fulfilled if the said law is to be applied. From the provision of Order
XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which is not being
reproduced herein to avoid prolixity, it is clear that the parties are
not entitled to
produce
additional
evidence
whether
oral or
documentary, in the Appellate Court but for the three different
situations which are enumerated in the provisions. In other words,
the Appellate Court cannot issue an order to fill the lacuna in the
evidence of the parties who has failed to succeed before the learned
Trial Court. However, considering the spirit of Section 163A of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and it being a settled position of Law that
it is not necessary in a proceeding under the Motor Vehicles Act to
go by any rules of pleadings or evidence [See Raj Rani and Ors. V.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and Ors. : (2009) 13 SCC 654] and for a just
decision in the matter, without delving into the merits of the case, I
deem it appropriate to remand the matter to the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok, for the limited purpose of
allowing the Appellants to furnish evidence as sought hereinabove
with regard to the names of the deceased and his father. Thereafter,
the learned Claims Tribunal shall proceed in accordance with law.
14.
The impugned Judgment of the learned Claims Tribunal
is accordingly set aside.
M.A.C. App. No. 8 of 2017
Smt. Anita Tamang & Others v. The Branch Manager, New India Assurance Company Limited
15.
It is hereby ordered that MACT case be readmitted to its
original Number in the Register of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
East Sikkim at Gangtok and all necessary steps be completed within
six months.
16.
Appeal is disposed of accordingly.
17.
Copy of this Judgment be transmitted to the learned
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok, for
information and compliance.
18.
In the circumstances, no order as to costs.
19.
Records be remitted forthwith.
Sd/(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
14.3.2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review