The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. 01.2024 (Annexure-40) proposing her punishment of termination from service and also asked her to submit representation, if any. She submitted her representation accordingly and the Disciplinary Authority finally issued Memorandum on 29.01.2024(Annexure-42) imposing penalty of termination from service in accordance with the provisions of Sl. 34, 39 and 40 of the list III, under Chapter V of the Service Conduct Rules, 2019 of the Society for Tripura Medical College & Dr. BRAM Teaching Hospital. [26] In view of above, according to Ld. Sr. Counsel, Mr. Roy Barman, the petitioner was compelled to withdraw her writ petition No.WP(C)796 of 2023 on 02.02.2024 with a liberty to file a fresh writ petition. The petitioner thereafter, preferred appeal before the appellate authority i.e. the Chairman of the said Society(TMC) which was dismissed vide order dated
12. 07.2024(Annexure-48). Now, challenging the said termination order and also the order of the appellate authority, the present writ petition is filed. [27] Ld. Sr. Counsel Mr. Roy Barman addresses his argument on the following points:- i) that, despite leave granted to the petitioner, she was not allowed to adduce evidence on her behalf; ii) that, despite submission of her representation against the proposed punishment, Disciplinary Authority most illegally, without application of mind, issued the memorandum dated 29.01.2024(Annexure42), terminating her from service observing that she did not submit any representation against the proposed punishment. Therefore, according to learned senior counsel, it is apparent that her representation was not taken into consideration by the Disciplinary Authority which caused serious prejudice to the petitioner and it amounts to violation of statutory rights; iii) that, the Inquiring Committee did not give any finding on facts in true sense rather, they narrated the facts itself and without any reasoning observed that the charges were proved against her; iv) that, against the articles of charge, no statement of imputation of misconduct were supplied to the petitioner; v) that, the appellate authority’s order was also lacking of any application of mind and reasoning. vi) that, the CEO himself was the Disciplinary Authority, who was the complainan…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 527 OF 2024
1.
Anindita Bhoumik,
W/o Dr. Shibabrata Naha, R/o Bardowali, P.O. & P.S. A.D. Nagar,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN: 799003, Age-40 years.
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The Society for Tripura Medical College & Dr. BR Ambedkar
Memorial Teaching Hospital, (To be represented by its Chief
Executive Officer) at Hapania, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799014.
2.
The Chairman,
Society for Tripura Medical College & Dr. BR Ambedkar Memorial
Teaching Hospital, at Hapania, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN799014.(The Appellate Authority).
3.
The Chief Executive Officer,
Society for Tripura Medical College & Dr. BR Ambedkar Memorial
Teaching Hospital at Hapania, P.S. Amtali, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799014.
4.
Prof. Dr. Arindam Datta, Principal, TMC, Chairman,
5.
Prof. Dr. Jayanta Kr. Poddar, Member,
6.
Prof. Dr. Shib Sekhar Datta, Member,
[The Respondent Nos. 4, 5 & 6 are appointed as Inquiry Committee, vide
Memorandum, dated 31.10.2023, issued by the CEO, TMC & Dr. BRAM
Teaching Hospital at Hapania.]
Address:- O/o the Society for Tripura Medical College & Dr. BRAM Teaching
Hospital at Hapania, P.S. Amtali, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799014.
7.
Sri Swapan Saha,
The Chief Executive Officer, O/o the Society for Tripura Medical
College & Dr. BRAM Teaching Hospital at Hapania, P.S. Amtali, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799014.
....…..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
Date of hearing & Date of
delivery of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting :
: 22.01.2026
YES
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Ld. Sr. Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman assisted by Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee, Learned Counsel for the petitioner.
[2]
Also heard Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Ld. Sr. Counsel, assisted
by Mr. S. Saha, Learned Counsel for the respondents.
[3]
The petitioner on her initial appointment joined in the post of
physiotherapist on 02.05.2006 in Tripura Medical College and Dr. BR
Ambedkar Memorial Teaching Hospital, Agartala (for short ‘TMC’).
[4]
The petitioner allegedly made a remark that ‘without purchasing
new machine, the bribe seeker OSD has given order to private organization
without tender! Dumbfounded outsourcing unfortunate singer Banik is yelling’
and posted the same in the Facebook platform.
[5]
Based on the same, a notice to show cause was issued on
20.05.2021(Annexure-3) by the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of said TMC
to the petitioner with further allegation that her father on receipt of the
information about the incident, made a courtesy visit at his own and met with
the CEO and expressed his displeasure about the conduct of his daughter.
But after departure of her father, the petitioner herself entered into the
chamber of said CEO, charged him arrogantly in presence of others and also
threatened him to face consequences even after repeated denial by the CEO
that he did not call her father, rather, her father paid a courtesy visit. She
was therefore, asked to show cause as to why appropriate action as per
provision of the Service Conduct Rules, 2019 of the Society for Tripura
Medical College & Dr. BRAM Teaching Hospital should not be taken against
her.
[6]
She gave reply to the said notice by denying those allegations.
[7]
The department thereafter, decided to hold an enquiry against
her and accordingly issued memorandum dated 27.07.2021(Annexure-5)
framing 4 numbers of articles of charges against her. First two charges were
mainly concerning the said Facebook post and the other two charges were
centering round her alleged misconduct and insubordination.
[8]
The
petitioner
thereafter,
filed
WP(C)
No.529
of
challenging the said initiation of enquiry and vide judgment dated
09.02.2022, the High Court quashed the charge No. 1 and 2, but, allowed
the other two charges to be continued with.
[9]
After the order was passed by the High Court, the Disciplinary
Authority engaged one Shri Narayan Debbarma, General Manager (HR) of
that society as Inquiry Authority to which the petitioner objected challenging
his impartiality on the ground that he was involved in the said affairs. Said
prayer being declined, she approached the High Court again by filing WP(C)
No. 318 of 2023 and vide order dated 17.10.2023, the High Court disposed
of the matter on the submission from the side of the respondents that they
were ready to change the Inquiry Officer.
[10]
Accordingly, the society constituted an Inquiring Committee
consisting of 3 persons vide memorandum dated 31.10.2023(Annexure-16)
and said Committee proceeded with the enquiry.
[11]
Said Committee fixed the date of enquiry on 15.11.2023 when
the petitioner was asked to submit the preliminary statement and also asked
to disclose the name of Defense Assistant, if any, who should not be an
advocate.
[12]
In the preliminary statement, the petitioner denied the charges
and also disclosed the name of her Defense Assistant to be one Samaresh
Paul, retired employee of District Judiciary. She also submitted her
preliminary statement in writing.
[13]
The Inquiring Committee, thereafter, fixed the next date on
28.11.2023 for examination of PWs and on 23.11.2023, the petitioner
submitted a petition asking them to supply the information as to which of the
witnesses will be examined on that particular day.
[14]
On the next day itself, the Committee by holding an
unscheduled meeting, rejected the said prayer observing that already list of
witnesses were supplied to her. As per said list of witness, according to Ld.
Sr. Counsel, Mr. P. Roy Barman, there were 4 numbers of witnesses cited
therein.
[15]
On 28.11.2023, said 4 witnesses were present but the petitioner
sought adjournment on the ground that elder brother of the Defense
Assistant was sick and was hospitalized. As it appears, the Committee was
not satisfied with the said ground of adjournment, but, ultimately shifted the
date to 05.12.2023 for the ends of justice.
[16]
On 29.11.2023, she submitted another petition stating that
during that period she will be on leave and prayed for rescheduling the date.
[17]
On 05.12.2023, said 4 witnesses were present and again the
Inquiring Committee shifted the date to 14.12.2023 and on the previous day
of said date, the petitioner filed another petition before the said Committee
asking for supplying her 3 (three) additional documents. On 14.12.2023,
when said 4 witnesses were present, the Committee rejected the said prayer
on the ground that additional document sought under Sl. No. B was not
available and regarding another document under Sl. No. A, it was observed
that no such document (call details of Phone No.94361220669) was there
with the Disciplinary Authority. Regarding the document under Sl. No. C, it
was observed that said document contained in a CD, was already supplied
to the AO.
[18]
On that day again, the Inquiring Committee re-fixed the date for
examination of PWs on 16.12.2023 and on 16.12.2023 itself again the
petitioner submitted another petition for adjourning the proceeding for 15
days on the ground that against the said decision of Inquiring Committee for
non furnishing of documents, she would challenge the same before the High
Court.
[19]
On 16.12.2023, said 4 witnesses were also again present but,
AO was absent. Her prayer for adjournment on that day was declined and
the Committee examined those 4 witnesses and fixed the date on
19.12.2023 for submission of defense statement by the petitioner and to
submit list of her witnesses, if any.
[20]
On 19.12.2023, AO was absent. Considering the previous
conduct of the petitioner, the Committee decided to close the chapter of
examination of defence witnesses and fixed the next date on 26.12.2023 for
submission of prosecution argument.
[21]
On 23.12.2023, the petitioner submitted a petition informing that
she already filed a writ petition bearing No. WP(C) 796 of 2023 and next date
of said writ petition was fixed on 02.02.2024 and therefore, she prayed for
keeping the Departmental Proceeding in abeyance at least till 02.02.2024.
She also informed that she was granted leave with station leave permission
w.e.f 26.12.2023 to 30.12.2023 and therefore, she could not be available on
26.12.2023.
[22]
The Inquiring Committee on 26.12.2023 turned down her said
prayer. Said Committee on the basis of the submission of the presenting
officer observed that she was very much available at the station and was
avoiding her participation in the hearing of the case. The Committee further
observed that it had not received any direction from the High Court and
therefore, they decided to go ahead and fix the next date on 29.12.2023 for
submission of defence argument.
[23]
On the previous day of 29.12.2023, another petition was
submitted by the petitioner to the said Committee that already she was
granted station leave permission with leave to remain out of station w.e.f
26.12.2023 to 30.12.2023. According to the petitioner, she was on that day
out of station and to prove the same she also submitted air ticket to the
Inquiring Committee. Ultimately, she again requested the Committee not to
sit on 29.12.2023. Copy of Boarding Pass is also submitted by the petitioner
in this case to show that on 24.12.2023, she boarded in the flight to go to
Kolkata.
[24]
Ld. Sr. Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman, submits that thereafter no
date was further shifted. The Committee submitted the report on 11.01.2024
with the findings that charges framed against the petitioner were proved
beyond doubt.
[25]
The Disciplinary authority i.e. CEO issued the memorandum on
12.01.2024 (Annexure-40) proposing her punishment of termination from
service and also asked her to submit representation, if any. She submitted
her representation accordingly and the Disciplinary Authority finally issued
Memorandum on 29.01.2024(Annexure-42) imposing penalty of termination
from service in accordance with the provisions of Sl. 34, 39 and 40 of the list
III, under Chapter V of the Service Conduct Rules, 2019 of the Society for
Tripura Medical College & Dr. BRAM Teaching Hospital.
[26]
In view of above, according to Ld. Sr. Counsel, Mr. Roy Barman,
the petitioner was compelled to withdraw her writ petition No.WP(C)796 of
2023 on 02.02.2024 with a liberty to file a fresh writ petition. The petitioner
thereafter, preferred appeal before the appellate authority i.e. the Chairman
of the said Society(TMC) which was dismissed vide order dated
12.07.2024(Annexure-48). Now, challenging the said termination order and
also the order of the appellate authority, the present writ petition is filed.
[27]
Ld. Sr. Counsel Mr. Roy Barman addresses his argument on the
following points:-
i) that, despite leave granted to the petitioner, she was not
allowed to adduce evidence on her behalf;
ii) that, despite submission of her representation against the
proposed
punishment,
Disciplinary
Authority
most
illegally,
without
application of mind, issued the memorandum dated 29.01.2024(Annexure42), terminating her from service observing that she did not submit any
representation against the proposed punishment. Therefore, according to
learned senior counsel, it is apparent that her representation was not taken
into consideration by the Disciplinary Authority which caused serious
prejudice to the petitioner and it amounts to violation of statutory rights;
iii) that, the Inquiring Committee did not give any finding on facts
in true sense rather, they narrated the facts itself and without any reasoning
observed that the charges were proved against her;
iv)
that, against the articles of charge, no statement of
imputation of misconduct were supplied to the petitioner;
v) that, the appellate authority’s order was also lacking of any
application of mind and reasoning.
vi) that, the CEO himself was the Disciplinary Authority, who
was the complainant himself and therefore, there was every likelihood of
bias;
vii) that, the Disciplinary Authority proceeded with the inquiry in
a hasty manner to the prejudice of the petitioner despite the fact that the
previous writ petition bearing No. WP(C) No.796 of 2023 was pending.
viii) that copy of Inquiry Report was not furnished to the
petitioner to enable her to give proper representation their against.
[28]
Therefore, finally, Ld. Sr. Counsel prays for allowing the writ
petition by quashing the termination order.
[29]
Learned senior counsel, Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya for the
respondents submits that actually no station leave permission was granted to
the petitioner and the Presenting Officer also vehemently objected to the
said prayer submitting that she did neither seek station leave permission nor
any such permission was granted to her for leaving the station. According to
learned senior counsel, Mr. Bhattacharya, the petitioner was throughout noncooperating with the Inquiring Committee and was trying to delay the inquiry
proceeding by this or that means.
[30]
This Court has considered the submissions of learned counsel
of both sides and has gone through the relevant materials placed in the
record.
[31]
It appears that on 16.12.2023, the Presenting Officer was
present with four numbers of witnesses and the petitioner was absent and
she submitted a petition for adjournment. She at that time already filed one
writ petition before the High Court against certain decisions of the Inquiring
Committee. On that day, the Committee examined the four witnesses of the
prosecution side and fixed the next date very shortly on 19.12.2023 for
submission of defence statement by the AO and also to submit list of
defence witnesses, if any. On 19.12.2023, the petitioner was absent without
taking any step and therefore, on the basis of submission of the Presenting
Officer that she was very much available in the station, and also taking note
of her previous conduct, the Inquiring Committee closed the chapter of
adducing evidence from the side of the petitioner and accordingly, fixed the
next date on 26.12.2023 for submission of prosecution argument. Thereafter
at that stage, no scope was also further given for hearing the defence side.
Thus, it appears that from 19.12.2023 to 26.12.2023 the Inquiring Committee
proceeded with the matter in a very hasty manner though earlier on several
occasions they granted adjournments very liberally to the petitioner. They
even did not fix any date for recording evidence of defence side.
[32]
In view of above, it appears to the Court that the Inquiring
Committee at least ought to have given a reasonable scope to the petitioner
to adduce her evidence, if any, and also to participate in the hearing
thereafter in accordance with the Rules.
[33]
It also appears that a specific plea was taken by the petitioner
by her letter dated 23.12.2023 to the Inquiring Committee that she was
granted leave with station leave permission w.e.f. 26.12.2023 to 30.12.2023.
The Inquiring Committee in their order dated 26.12.2023 noted an oral
objection raised by the Presenting Officer in this regard that no such
permission was granted to her but did not further enquire or decide the said
matter whether she was at all granted station leave permission or not, rather,
unilaterally believed the oral submission of the Presenting Officer that she
was very much available in the station. On the other hand, from the side of
the petitioner, copy of one boarding pass has been submitted to show that
on 24.12.2023 she had already left for Kolkata by IndiGo Airways at 11:00
hours.
[34]
In view of above said position of record, the order of the
Committee passed on 26.12.2023 appears to be unreasonable and arbitrary.
Such conduct of the said Committee has also violated the principles of
natural justice for depriving her from adducing evidence and also from
participating in the hearing thereafter.
[35]
Learned senior counsel, Mr. Roy Barman, though submits that a
scope may be given to the petitioner to cross-examine the witnesses of the
prosecution but, record shows that already sufficient opportunities were
given to the petitioner earlier to participate in the phase of recording of
evidence of the prosecution side and nothing is found that the Inquiring
Committee exercised their discretion arbitrarily. Therefore, such submission
is not accepted.
[36]
In view of above, the final decision of the Inquiring Committee
and consequently the decision of Departmental Authority dated 29th January,
2024 and 12th July, 2024 [Annexure 42 & 48 to the writ petition] respectively
are hereby quashed. The Inquiring Committee is directed to fix a date afresh
for adducing evidence by the writ petitioner and finally take a reasoned
decision in this regard giving a reasonable opportunity to the petitioner of
being heard. The Inquiring Committee shall try to complete the enquiry within
two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
[37]
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant writ
petition stands disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed.
JUDGE
SANJAY GHOSH
sanjay
Date: 2026.01.28 18:26:36 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review