Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
06.05.2026
Sl. No.99
Ct. No.14
gd
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
WPA 27964 of 2025
Animesh Sarkar
versus
State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Pulakesh Bajpai
…for the Petitioner.
Mr. Pratik Dhar, ld. Sr. Adv.
Ms. Madhurima Sarkar
…for Madrasah Service Commission.
1.
By the present writ petition the petitioner seeks
direction
upon
the
particularly
West
Commission
(hereinafter
respondent
Bengal
authorities,
Madrasah
referred
to
Service
as
the
‘Commission’) to recast the panel for the post of
Assistant Teacher for Classes XI and XII, SubjectPhysics (PG), Category-General Bengali Medium in 7 th
State Level Selection Test, 2023 (in short ‘SLST’).
2.
The petitioner contends that he completed Masters in
Physics from Kalyani University on 2 nd September,
2021 with 67.19% marks in total. The petitioner
appeared in the 7th SLST for the post of Assistant
Teacher for Classes XI and XII, Subject-Physics (PG),
Category-General Bengali Medium. At the time of
making application the petitioner was pursuing B.Ed.
Course which was completed by the petitioner on 8 th
December, 2023. The petitioner was successful in the
written examination and call letter for interview was
issued to him on 28th December, 2024. On the date
fixed the petitioner appeared with all his testimonials,
which
were
verified
and
also
re-verified
on
a
subsequent date. The petitioner obtained 48.50
marks out of 90 marks in the written examination as
per
the
final
answer
key
published
by
the
Commission. The marks given to the petitioner in the
interview is unknown to him. The marks obtained by
the second empanelled candidate of 42.55 marks out
of 100 marks including the marks in the interview is
lesser than the marks obtained by the petitioner in
the written examination itself apart from interview.
However, the name of the petitioner did not figure in
the final panel published by the Commission for the
said post. Being aggrieved by the said action of the
respondent authorities particularly the Commission
the petitioner has preferred the present writ petition.
3.
Mr. Pulakesh Bajpai, learned advocate appearing for
the petitioner submits that the petitioner was allowed
to
participate
in
the
different
stages
of
the
recruitment process. At the time the petitioner filled
in the application for 7 th SLST for the post of
Assistant Teacher for Classes XI and XII, he was
pursuing B.Ed. Course. By dint of the Notification
dated 12th June, 2023 the petitioner was allowed to
participate in the examination being a pursuing
candidate of B.Ed course. Therefore, at the final stage
of the examination the candidature of the petitioner
cannot be cancelled on a flimsy ground that on the
last date of the application the petitioner did not
complete the B.Ed. Course, for the simple reason that
the petitioner was allowed by the Commission itself
being a pursuing candidate of B.Ed course to
participate in the examination. The Commission
cannot retract from its own action. In the written
examination the petitioner secured second highest
marks. The second empanelled candidate having
lesser
marks
than
the
petitioner
has
been
empanelled. As the petitioner has gone through
different stages of the examination, a legitimate
expectation has accrued in favour of the petitioner
and hence he should be considered for appointment
of post of Assistant Teacher for Classes XI and XII
Subject-Physics
(PG)
Category-General
Bengali
Medium. He seeks for appropriate orders recasting
the panel for the said post of Assistant Teacher in 7 th
SLST.
4.
Mr. Pratik Dhar, learned Senior advocate appearing
for the Commission submits that although the
petitioner was permitted to appear in the examination
being a pursuing B.Ed. candidate and call letter for
interview was also issued to him, however, that was a
mistake on the part of Commission in doing so. As
per the eligibility criteria the petitioner ought to have
possessed B.Ed. qualification on the last date of
application. The facts clearly reveal that on the last
date of application the petitioner was not having the
B.Ed. qualification. It is settled proposition of law that
the candidates selected must be qualified as on the
last date of application for the posts in question or on
the date mentioned in the advertisement/notification
for the purpose. In the present case at hand the
information guidelines clearly specifies that one has
to possess the qualification on the last date of
application. Since the petitioner did not possess the
required qualification on the said date, as such he is
ineligible to be considered for the said post. To
buttress his contention, he relies on the following
decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court.
(a) Rekha
Chaturvedi
(Smt)
versus
University
of
Rajasthan & Ors reported in 1993 Supp (3) SCC 168.
(b) Ashok
Kumar
Sharma
&
Ors.
versus
Chander
Shekhar & Ors. reported in (1997) 4 SCC 18.
(c) Bhupinderpal Singh & Ors. versus State of Punjab &
Ors.reported in (2000) 5 SCC 262.
Further a mistake can always be corrected by
following the due process of law and no right accrues
in favour of a candidate derived from a mistake in the
advertisement or a wrong appointment. Article 14 of
the Constitution does not envisage negative equality.
If the State committed the mistake, it cannot be
forced to perpetuate the same mistake. In support of
his contention, he relies on the following decisions:
(a)
State of U.P. and Others versus Rajkumar Sharma
and Others reported in (2006) 3 SCC 330.
(b) Union of India and Others versus Narendra Singh
reported in (2008) 2 SCC 750.
(c) Union of India versus S.R. Dhingra and Others
reported in (2008) 2 SCC 229.
5.
Upon hearing the learned advocates for respective
parties, the only issue which falls for consideration is
whether the petitioner’s candidature ought to have
been considered for empanelment to the post of
Assistant Teacher for Classes XI and XII SubjectPhysics (PG) Category-General Bengali Medium or not
in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
6.
In order to examine the aforesaid issue, it would be
profitable to note that as per the information
guidelines for 7th SLST (AT) 2023 the eligibility for
selection of Post Graduate Teachers for Classes XI
and XII is Post Graduate in concerned subject with
45% marks with B.Ed. before 29 th July, 2011. The
information guidelines in Clause 16 of the Note
specifies that the qualification will be as on last date
of
application.
As
per
Notification
no.
MSC/Notice/05/2023 the last date of application was
extended till 19th June, 2023. Indisputably the
petitioner passed B.Ed. on 8th December, 2023 and,
therefore, he did not possess the requisite B.Ed.
qualification on the last date of application i.e. 19 th
June, 2023. The question which crops up at this
juncture is whether the petitioner who was successful
in written examination and was also called for
interview can claim his right to empanelment in the
said
post
in
circumstances.
the
recruitment
process
in
such
7.
In order to deal with the above question, it would be
profitable to reproduce the observation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in its decisions as hereunder.
8.
In Rekha Chaturvedi (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held as follows:
“10. The contention that the required qualifications
of the candidates should be examined with
reference to the date of selection and not with
reference to the last date for making applications
has only to be stated to be rejected. The date of
selection is invariably uncertain. In the absence of
knowledge of such date the candidates who apply
for the posts would be unable to state whether they
are qualified for the posts in question or not, if they
are yet to acquire the qualifications. Unless the
advertisement mentions a fixed date with reference
to which the qualifications are to be judged,
whether the said date is of selection or otherwise, it
would not be possible for the candidates who do
not possess the requisite qualifications in praesenti
even to make applications for the posts. The
uncertainty of the date may also lead to a contrary
consequence, viz., even those candidates who do
not have the qualifications in praesenti and are
likely to acquire them at an uncertain future date,
may apply for the posts thus swelling the number
of applications. But a still worse consequence may
follow, in that it may leave open a scope for
malpractices. The date of selection may be so fixed
or manipulated as to entertain some applicants and
reject others, arbitrarily. Hence, in the absence of a
fixed
date
indicated
in
the
advertisement/notification inviting applications
with reference to which the requisite qualifications
should be judged, the only certain date for the
scrutiny of the qualifications will be the last date
for making the applications. We have, therefore, no
hesitation in holding that when the Selection
Committee in the present case, as argued by Shri
Manoj Swarup, took into consideration the requisite
qualifications as on the date of selection rather
than on the last date of preferring applications, it
acted with patent illegality, and on this ground
itself the selections in question are liable to be
quashed. Reference in this connection may also be
made to two recent decisions of this Court in A.P.
Public Service Commission, Hyderabad v. B. Sarat
Chandra [(1990) 2 SCC 669 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 377 :
(1990) 4 SLR 235 : (1990) 13 ATC 708] and District
Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare
Residential School Society, Vizianagaram v. M.
Tripura Sundari Devi [(1990) 3 SCC 655 : 1990 SCC
(L&S) 520 : (1990) 4 SLR 237 : (1990) 14 ATC 766] .
11. However, for the reasons which follow, we are
not inclined to set aside the selections in spite of
the said illegality. The selected candidates have
been working in the respective posts since
February 1985. We are now in January 1993.
Almost eight years have elapsed. There is also no
record before us to show as to how the Selection
Committee had proceeded to weigh the respective
merits of the candidates and to relax the minimum
qualifications in favour of some in exercise of the
discretionary powers vested in it under the
University Ordinance. If the considerations which
weighed with the Committee in relaxing the
requisite qualifications were valid, it would result in
injustice to those who have been selected. We,
however, feel it necessary to emphasise and bring
to the notice of the University that the illegal
practices in the selection of candidates which have
come to light and which seem to be followed
usually at its end must stop forthwith. It is for this
purpose that we lay down the following guidelines
for the future selection process:
A. The University must note that the qualifications it
advertises for the posts should not be at variance
with those prescribed by its Ordinance/Statutes.
B. The candidates selected must be qualified as on
the last date for making applications for the posts
in question or on the date to be specifically
mentioned in the advertisement/notification for the
purpose. The qualifications acquired by the
candidates after the said date should not be taken
into consideration, as that would be arbitrary and
result in discrimination. It must be remembered that
when the advertisement/notification represents
that the candidates must have the qualifications in
question, with reference to the last date for making
the applications or with reference to the specific
date mentioned for the purpose, those who do not
have such qualifications do not apply for the posts
even though they are likely to acquire such
qualifications and do acquire them after the said
date. In the circumstances, many who would
otherwise be entitled to be considered and may
even be better than those who apply, can have a
legitimate grievance since they are left out of
consideration.
C. When the University or its Selection Committee
relaxes the minimum required qualifications, unless
it
is
specifically
stated
in
the
advertisement/notification
both
that
the
qualifications will be relaxed and also the
conditions on which they will be relaxed, the
relaxation will be illegal.
D. The University/Selection Committee must
mention in its proceedings of selection the reasons
for making relaxations, if any, in respect of each of
the candidates in whose favour relaxation is made.
E. The minutes of the meetings of the Selection
Committee should be preserved for a sufficiently long
time, and if the selection process is challenged until
the challenge is finally disposed of. An adverse
inference is liable to be drawn if the minutes are
destroyed or a plea is taken that they are not
available.
9.
In Ashok Kumar Sharma (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme
Court observed as hereunder:
“6. The review petitions came up for final hearing on
3-3-1997. We heard the learned counsel for the
review petitioners, for the State of Jammu & Kashmir
and for the 33 respondents. So far as the first issue
referred to in our Order dated 1-9-1995 is concerned,
we are of the respectful opinion that majority
judgment (rendered by Dr T.K. Thommen and V.
Ramaswami, JJ.) is unsustainable in law. The
proposition that where applications are called for
prescribing a particular date as the last date for
filing the applications, the eligibility of the candidates
shall have to be judged with reference to that date
and that date alone, is a well-established one. A
person who acquires the prescribed qualification
subsequent to such prescribed date cannot be
considered at all. An advertisement or notification
issued/published calling for applications constitutes
a representation to the public and the authority
issuing it is bound by such representation. It cannot
act contrary to it. One reason behind this proposition
is that if it were known that persons who obtained
the qualifications after the prescribed date but before
the date of interview would be allowed to appear for
the interview, other similarly placed persons could
also have applied. Just because some of the persons
had applied notwithstanding that they had not
acquired the prescribed qualifications by the
prescribed date, they could not have been treated on
a preferential basis. Their applications ought to have
been rejected at the inception itself. This proposition
is indisputable and in fact was not doubted or
disputed in the majority judgment. This is also the
proposition affirmed in Rekha Chaturvedi v.
University of Rajasthan [1993 Supp (3) SCC 168 :
1993 SCC (L&S) 951 : (1993) 25 ATC 234] . The
reasoning in the majority opinion that by allowing
the 33 respondents to appear for the interview, the
recruiting authority was able to get the best talent
available and that such course was in furtherance of
public interest is, with respect, an impermissible
justification. It is, in our considered opinion, a clear
error of law and an error apparent on the face of the
record. In our opinion, R.M. Sahai, J. (and the
Division Bench of the High Court) was right in
holding that the 33 respondents could not have been
allowed to appear for the interview.”
10. In Bhupinderpal Singh (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held as follows:
13. Placing reliance on the decisions of this Court in
Ashok Kumar Sharma v. Chander Shekhar [(1997)
4 SCC 18 : 1997 SCC (L&S) 913 : JT (1997) 4 SC
99] , A.P. Public Service Commission v. B.
SaratChandra [(1990) 2 SCC 669 : 1990 SCC (L&S)
377 : (1990) 13 ATC 708 : (1990) 4 SLR 235] ,
District Collector and Chairman, Vizianagaram
Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M.
Tripura Sundari Devi [(1990) 3 SCC 655 : 1990
SCC (L&S) 520 : (1990) 14 ATC 766 : (1990) 4 SLR
237] , Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan
[1993 Supp (3) SCC 168 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 951 :
(1993) 25 ATC 234 : JT (1993) 1 SC 220] , M.V.
Nair (Dr) v. Union of India [(1993) 2 SCC 429 : 1993
SCC (L&S) 512 : (1993) 24 ATC 236] and U.P.
Public Service Commission U.P., Allahabad v.
Alpana [(1994) 2 SCC 723 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 742 :
(1994) 27 ATC 101 : JT (1994) 1 SC 94] the High
Court has held (i) that the cut-off date by reference
to which the eligibility requirement must be
satisfied by the candidate seeking a public
employment is the date appointed by the relevant
service rules and if there be no cut-off date
appointed by the rules then such date as may be
appointed for the purpose in the advertisement
calling for applications; (ii) that if there be no such
date appointed then the eligibility criteria shall be
applied by reference to the last date appointed by
which the applications have to be received by the
competent authority. The view taken by the High
Court is supported by several decisions of this
Court and is therefore well settled and hence
cannot be found fault with. However, there are
certain special features of this case which need to
be taken care of and justice be done by invoking
the jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution
vested in this Court so as to advance the cause of
justice.
11. Bearing in mind the aforesaid proposition of law as
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is
manifest that in order to be eligible the petitioner
ought to possess the requisite qualification on the last
date of examination as provided in Clause 16 of Note
of the information guidelines. As the petitioner did not
possess B.Ed. qualification as per requirement on the
last date of application, he became ineligible to
participate in the recruitment process.
12. Admittedly the petitioner was permitted by the
Commission to appear in the written examination as
a pursuing candidate of B.Ed course and was also
called for interview. At this stage, the question arises
whether any right accrues to the petitioner in such
circumstances, when he was ineligible to participate.
Placing reliance on the decisions of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Rajkumar Sharma (supra), Narendra Singh
(supra) and S.R. Dhingra (supra) Mr. Dhar, learned
Senior advocate appearing for the Commission fairly
submitted that although such action of permitting the
petitioner to appear in the examination and then
issuing call letter for interview was an error on the
part of Commission yet mistake can always be
corrected and no right accrues in favour of a
candidate
derived
from
a
mistake
in
the
advertisement.
13. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Narendra Singh (supra)
has held that mistakes are mistakes and they can
always be corrected by following due process of law.
In Rajkumar Sharma (supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court
in Paragraph no. 15 observed that even if in some
cases appointments have been made by mistake or
wrongly that does not confer any right on another
person. Article 14 of the Constitution does not
envisage negative equality, and if the State committed
the mistake, it cannot be forced to perpetuate the
same mistake. Further, in S.R. Dhingra (supra) the
Hon’ble Apex Court held that it is well settled that a
mistake does not confer any right to any party and
can be corrected. Therefore, as the petitioner was
ineligible to participate in the examination hence
permitting the petitioner to appear in the examination
and thereafter issuing call letter for interview was an
error on the part of Commission. Be that as it may,
bearing in mind the above principles of law as settled
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, such mistake can be
corrected by the Commission and no right accrues in
favour of the petitioner entitling him to appointment.
Thus,
the
action
of
the
Commission
in
not
empanelling the petitioner in the said post cannot be
called in question. Hence, the writ petition falls short
of merit.
14. In light of the above discussion, the writ petition
being WPA 27964 of 2025 stands dismissed.
15. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
16. All connected applications, if any, stand disposed of.
17. There shall be no order as to costs.
18. All concerned parties shall act in terms of the copy of
the order duly downloaded from the official website of
this Court.
19. Urgent Photostat certified copy of the order, if applied
for, be given to the parties on compliance of all
necessary legal formalities.
(Bivas Pattanayak, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review