Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.02.24 17:08:06 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 528 of 2020
Anilkumar Singh, aged about 30 years, S/O Amu
Singh of Lairen Kabi, P.O. Lamsang Bazar & P.S.
Lamsang, Imphal West District, Manipur -Pin:
759146 at present posting at GC, CRPF, Imphal,
having ASI/Min No.105044952.
……Petitioner
-Versus-
1.
Union of India represented through its Home
Secretary (Ministry of Home Affairs), North Block,
Government of India, New Delhi – 110001.
2.
The Director General of Police, CRPF CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110 003.
3.
The IGP, M&N Sector, CRPF, P.O. Imphal, P.S.
Patsoi, District- Imphal West, Manipur-795 113
4.
The DIGP(Adm), M&N Sector, CRPF, P.O. Imphal,
P.S. Patsoi, District- Imphal West, Manipur-795 113
……. Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. K. Roshan, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma,
Sr. PCCG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
01.02.2023.
Date of Judgment & Order
24.02.2023
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
::
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash the Signal dated 20.4.2020, 14.7.2020, 28.7.2020 and the
impugned order dated 24.9.2020, as they are issued in violation
of the Standing Order No.03/2016 and directing to complete the
petitioner’s tenure in GC, CRPF, Imphal under the North East
Zone.
2.
Heard Mr. K. Roshan, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma, learned Sr. PCCG for
the respondents.
3.
Assailing the impugned transfer order, Mr. K.
Roshan, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
petitioner was initially appointed in the CRPF with effect from
27.9.2010 as Head Constable and was posted in GC,
Bhubaneswar till 2013 and from there, he was transferred to 32
Bn. Subsequently, he was transferred and posted at GC, Imphal
from 22.8.2015. In the year 2019, while he was in GC, Imphal
and while he was working at GC, Imphal, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of Assistant Sub-Inspector on 24.1.2019.
While the petitioner serving as ASI, the respondents issued
Signal dated 20.4.2020 effecting summer chain transfer of 14
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |3
ASI, including the petitioner thereby transferring him to 87 Bn at
Jiribam.
4.
The learned counsel further submitted that since the
petitioner has not completed the normal tenure of 3 years as ASI
in GC, Imphal and since his mother suffering from Psychosis
NOS and also his wife gave birth to a girl child, a representation
was submitted by him on 30.7.2019. By the order dated
14.7.2020, the representation of the petitioner was rejected and
directed the petitioner to report at 87 Bn by 15.7.2020 positively
and the respondents have also issued relieving order dated
28.7.2020, thereby relieving him from GC, Imphal with effect from
31.7.2020 and to report at 87 Bn.
5.
Mr. K. Roshan, the learned counsel for the
petitioner further submitted that the case of petitioner is covered
by Paras 7(A)(a) and 7(C)(c) of the Standing Order. Aggrieved
by the order dated 28.7.2020, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C)
No.461 of 2020 and this Court, in its order dated 20.8.2020,
disposed of the said writ petition giving liberty to submit a fresh
representation to the authorities concerned within a period of 10
days and on receipt of the representation, the authorities were
directed to consider such representation. He would submit that
pursuant to the order dated 20.8.2020, the petitioner submitted a
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |4
representation on 21.8.2020 seeking to cancel the transfer and
posting Signals of the petitioner directing him to report at 87 Bn
in consideration of the stipulations laid down in the Standing
Order No.03/2016.
However, by the impugned order dated
24.09.2020, the said representation was rejected by the
respondent authority arbitrarily.
Challenging the same, the
present writ petition has been filed. Thus, a prayer has been
made to set aside the impugned orders and allow the petitioner
to serve at GC, Imphal.
6.
Per contra, Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma, the
Sr.PCCG for the respondents submitted that as per the
conditions stipulated in his appointment letter, it was clearly
highlighted that the appointment carries the liability to serve in
any part of India or outside country. He submits that the transfer
in CRPF is a policy matter and orders are being issued by
transferring authorities taking into consideration of all aspects
like vacancy/exigencies of services in various offices/tenure of
individuals etc.
7.
The learned Sr. PCCG further submitted that since
the petitioner had completed more than his normal tenure of 3
years at GC, Imphal with effect from 23.8.2015 to 31.5.2020,
nomination of the petitioner along with other similar incumbents
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |5
Within Sector Transfer-2020 was forwarded to IGP M7N Sector.
Thereafter, the IGP, M&N Sector had issued Summer Chain
Transfer-2020, vide Signal dated 20.4.2020, wherein the
petitioner was transferred from GC Imphal to 87 Bn, CRPF.
When the petitioner submitted a representation dated 2.7.2020
for deferment of his transfer for one year, the same was rejected
vide order dated 14.7.2020. Aggrieved by the transfer to 87 Bn,
the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.461 of 2020 and pursuant to
the order of this Court in W.P.(C) No.461 of 2020, the IGP M&N
examined the case of the petitioner and, finally, rejected the
representation of the petitioner as devoid of merits by issuing a
speaking order dated 24.9.2020.
8.
The learned Sr. PCCG urged that the contention of
the petitioner that the period prior to promotion to the post of ASI
(Min) at GC, Imphal cannot be counted while computing the
tenure is purely baseless and that the case of the petitioner is not
covered under Para 7(C)(c) of the Standing Order. Similarly Para
7(A)(a) referred by the petitioner clearly states transfer of officials
who have completed/completing prescribed tenure in soft area
and hard area. Since the petitioner has already completed more
than 4 years at GC, Imphal against the prescribed tenure of 3
years, he was transferred to 87 Bn. Therefore, there is no merit
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |6
in the claim made by the petitioner.
Thus, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the writ petition.
9.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
10.
The petitioner challenged the impugned transfer
order alleging that the same is in violation of Para 7(A)(a) and
Para 7(C)(c) of the Standing Order No.03/2016. Paras 7(A)(a)
and Para 7(C)(c) of the Standing Order are quoted hereunder for
ready reference:
“7. TYPES OF TRANSFER.
A) Summer Chain Transfer.
(a)
Summer Chain Transfer will cover the
cases of the following categories of
officers/officials:(i)
Transfer
cases
of
officers/
officials who have completed/
completing prescribed tenure in
a
particular Zone/Sector or
station/area/region/NCR as on
prescribed cut of date.
(ii)
Transfer
cases
of
officers/
officials who have completed/
completing prescribed tenure in
soft areas and hard areas.
(iii)
Transfer cases of officers /
officials who have not completed
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |7
/completing prescribed tenure in
soft areas and hard areas as on
prescribed
cut-off
date
yet
requested for transfer on various
grounds as defined in transfer
policy.
(iv)
Other transfer cases as per para
7(C)(a) to (g).”
“C. Other Transfers.
….
c) The transfer of an officer/official on
extreme medical ground will be considered
on
administrative
feasibility
and
other
provisions of the transfer policy. Transfer on
extreme medical grounds will be considered
on merit only if the official or his immediate
family members are suffering from any of the
following diseases.
1. Cancer
2. Paralytic Stroke
3. Renal failure
4. Coronary artery disease/Thalassemia
5. Parkinson’s disease
6. Motor-neuron disease.
…..”
11.
The petitioner was initially appointed as Head
Constable in CRPF with effect from 27.9.2010 and was posted at
GC, BBSR till 2013. From there, he was transferred to 32 Bn.
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |8
While working at 32 Bn. from 2.10.2013, the petitioner was
transferred to GC, Imphal on 22.8.2015. While the petitioner was
working as HC in GC, Imphal, he was promoted to the post of
ASI (Min) vide order dated 24.1.2019. While working as such,
the petitioner was transferred to 87 Bn at Jiribam vide order dated
20.4.2020. On a perusal of the order dated 20.4.2020, it is seen
that the transfer was made as per the recommendation of the
Departmental Transfer Committee and approved by the
competent authority.
12.
As could be seen from the records, it is clear that
the petitioner completed more than 4 years at GC Imphal with
effect from 23.8.2015. As rightly argued by learned Standing
Counsel
for
the
respondents,
Summer
Chain
Transfer
application of the officials are considered by the Department
whose normal tenure are completed in a particular place/ unit/
office/ sector/zone etc. and not with reference to the rank which
he is holding. Thus, the competent authority was right in counting
the tenure period of the petitioner from 23.8.2015. In view of the
above, the plea of the petitioner that the period prior to promotion
to the post of ASI (Min) cannot be counted while computing the
tenure is highly baseless. In this regard, it is pertinent to mention
that as per Para 7(b)(a)(ii), an official on release on promotion be
permitted to continue in the same office, if he has not completed
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
Page |9
the tenure. In such cases, the tenure in hard/soft areas will be
continued. Here, in the case on hand, since the petitioner had
already completed more than 4 years in GC Imphal against the
prescribed period of 3 years, the respondent authority was right
in transferring the petitioner from GC Imphal to 87 Bn CRPF.
13.
Coming to the medical ground on which the
petitioner sought to set aside impugned transfer order is
concerned, it is to be pointed out that earlier on 2.7.2020 the
petitioner requested for deferment of his posting for one year on
the ground that his wife was taking care of his little baby
completing 11 months along with his mother who was suffering
from Psychosis NOS at his parental home and need his presence
for proper care of his baby as well as medical treatment of his
mother. After examining the representation, the IGP M&N Sector
rejected the case of the petitioner. Now after three years, the
petitioner cannot seek for the same ground to set aside the
impugned transfer order. In view of the above, the retention
sought for by the petitioner on medical ground at GC Imphal is
also baseless. Only after considering the case of the petitioner
and in the light of the order dated 20.8.2020 passed in W.P.(C)
No.461 of 2020, the impugned rejection order came to be passed
by the respondent authority and, this Court, finds any infirmity in
it.
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
P a g e | 10
14.
At this juncture, it is to be pointed out that the
petitioner’s initial appointment as HC in GC Bhubaneswar comes
under Odisha Sector. He was transferred from GC Bhubaneswar
to 32 Bn, Loktak, which is his home State. Since the petitioner
was appointed under Odisha Sector, Para 14 of the Standing
Order No.3/2016 is not covered the case of the petitioner, as GC
Imphal is under Manipur and Nagaland Sector and the petitioner
has been transferred in SCT-2020 of Manipur and Nagaland
Sector.
15.
It is reiterated that as per the transfer policy
envisaged in Standing Order, normal tenure at GC Imphal is 3
years and the petitioner had already completed more than his
normal tenure at GC Imphal. The transfer order of the petitioner
from GC Imphal to 87 Bn issued in SCT-2020. Therefore, the
orders dated 20.4.2020 and 24.9.2020 are proper and they have
been issued in accordance with the Standing Order.
16.
At this juncture, by drawing this Court’s attention to
Para 15 of the Standing Order, the learned Standing Counsel for
the respondents submitted that Para 15 clearly mentions that a
Government Servant holding a transferable post has no vested
right to remain posted at one place or the other and also further
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
P a g e | 11
reiterated that no Government servant or employees has legal
right for being posted at any particular place.
17.
Transfer of an employee is an administrative
prerogative power vested with the competent authority. It is for
the competent authority to decide how and where to post the
personnel for effective administration. The petitioner, being an
employee of an uniformed service, has to abide by the
administrative orders, more specifically, of transfers.
18.
Intervention in administrative transfers will not only
cause inconvenience to the administration, but also amounts to
preventing opportunity of other employees to come over to their
native places. Administrative transfer policies are implemented in
the interest of the Department, more so, in the uniformed
services, in order to maintain discipline and good conduct.
Periodical transfers of uniformed personnel are highly essential.
19.
It is not for the Courts to interfere or exercise the
power of judicial review in the matter of transfers. Only on
exceptional circumstances i.e. to say, in the event of violation of
any statutory rules, the power of judicial review can be exercised
and not otherwise. Violation of certain guidelines/instructions
given in the form of Circulars or Orders, will not confer any legal
right on the employees. In other words, the Circulars and Orders
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
P a g e | 12
of the Government with regard to the guidelines issued for
implementing transfers will not confer any right on the
employees. Certain concessions are provided in order to make
the
employees
more
accommodative
and
for
effective
functioning of the administration. Thus, it is for the competent
authorities to consider all these aspects in respect of the personal
grievances of the employees, while effecting transfers. Such
being the legal principles on transfers, this Court is of the
undoubted opinion that the administrative transfers cannot be
challenged by way of writ petition and this Court has to be
conscious, while exercising the judicial review against the orders
of administrative transfers.
20.
A Government servant holding a transferable post,
especially, a person serving in a disciplined service, has no
vested right to remain posted at one place or the other and he is
liable to be transferred from one place to the other. Transfer
orders issued by the competent authority do not violate any of his
legal right. Even if a transfer order is passed in violation of
executive instructions or orders, the Courts ordinarily should not
interfere with the order, instead, the affected party should
approach the higher authorities of the Department. If Courts
continue to interfere with day-to-day transfer orders issued by the
Government and its sub-ordinate authorities, there will be a
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
P a g e | 13
complete chaos in the administration, which would not be
conducive to public interest. The Courts need not overlook these
aspects while interfering with the orders of transfers.
21.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of S.C.
Saxena v. Union of India and Others, (2006) 9 SCC 583, has
observed that Government servant in the matter of transfer
should first report/join for work where he is transferred.
22.
It is settled that the Courts should not interfere with
a transfer order which are made in public interest and for
administrative reasons unless the transfer orders are made in
violation of any mandatory statutory rules or on the ground of
mala fide. At the cost of repetition, it is pertinent to mention that
a Government servant holding a transferable post has no vested
right to remain posted at one place or other, he is liable to be
transferred from one place to another.
23.
The scope of interference by this Court in regard to
members of Armed Forces is far more limited and narrow.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court
is of the view that the impugned transfer of the petitioner was
made after considering the Standing Order No.03/2016 as also
other material documents. Therefore, there is no merit in the writ
petition and, accordingly, the same is liable to be dismissed.
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
P a g e | 14
24.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed. There will
be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No.528 of 2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review