Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.401 of 2024
Anil Plantation Pvt. Ltd.
…..Petitioner
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
State of Tripura and 2 Others
For Petitioner(s)
…..Respondents
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. S. S. Debnath, Advocate.
Mr. D. S. Kunwar, Advocate.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
29.11.2024
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard Mr. S. S. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India for issuing a direction to the respondents to withdraw/revise
the order dated 30.09.2023 passed by the respondent No.2 in case No.
14/Rev/P.Secy/2023 or quash them by this Court by an appropriate writ.
[3]
The facts in brief are that the State (respondent) was remiss in
interpreting the implications of Section-136 and 178 of the T.R.R. & L.R. Act,
1960 and going under a wrong perception issued the letter dated 05.12.1975 though
there is no scope to wrongly understand and under such wrong understanding both
provisions under Section-136 and 178 was applied in respect of same land for the
Tea Garden. In fact, it will be evident that both provisions are not applicable in
respect of the rights of an intermediary (Talukder) and Rights of an ordinary
Raiyat. Since, the petitioner was a intermediary prior to the enforcement of the Act
of 1960, he would be guided by the provisions of Chapter-XI (Section-136) and as
such Section-178 of the Act withdrawing the Exemption is not applicable. The
order dated 05.12.1975 and the orders of the respondent No.2 is completely bad
and contrary to law.
[4]
In view of above and having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the parties, this Court is of the view that the impugned proceeding dated
September, 2023 needs to be set aside by remanding back the matter to the
respondents i.e. Principal Secretary, Revenue for re-examining the matter in its
entirety and pass a speaking order after affording reasonable opportunity to the
petitioner and this exercise shall be completed as expeditiously as possible.
[5]
This Court in earlier round of litigation observed that the land in the
State of Tripura belongs to the State. The petitioner has not filed any document to
show that he is the owner of the land and purchased the extent of land i.e. 758.93
acres and since there is no legal entitlement and title deed placed on record, it
cannot be simply considered that the petitioner is the owner of the land in question.
Insofar as, the 1975 proceeding and the exemption are concerned, unless the
government looks into the grass root level of the matter, declaration of title and
possession and under what capacity the petitioner is in possession, it may not be
just and proper to consider whether the subject land is surplus or entitled for any
exemption.
[6]
However, in the event, if the petitioner establishes his ownership and
title upon the subject land, the petitioner will be entitled for all the benefits under
the law. In such event, if the petitioner fails to prove the title, it is needless to
observe that the large extent of land is belonging to the State.
[7]
It is seen from the record and after hearing, this Court is of the
opinion that the petitioner is not an intermediary and does not fall within the said
definition and he has not placed any record before this Court to show that he has
been assigned with any land by the concerned Talukdar or he is the owner. At one
point of time, he argues that he is the owner of the property and on the other point
he advanced argument being an intermediary. So it becomes necessary to find out
the owner of the land and under what capacity the petitioner is claiming the right
over the land. Since, the respondent authorities do not go into the grass-root of the
case; it becomes necessary for reexamining the matter in its entirety. For the
purpose of clarity, let us discuss the relevant Sections relating to the facts and
circumstances of the present case in hand:
Part-IV
Chapter XI- Acquisition of Estate and of Rights of Intermediaries Therein
133. Definitions-In this part(a) “Estate” means lands included under one entry in any of the general
registers of revenue-paying and revenue-free lands and includes(i) Revenue-free lands not entered in any register, and
(ii) A part of, or a share in, an estate;
(b) “Homestead” means a dwelling house together with any courtyard,
compound, garden, or outhouse and includes any out-buildings used for
purposes connected with agriculture and any family graveyard, library, office,
guesthouse, grain store, latrines, boundary walls, tanks, wells or places of
worship appertaining to such dwelling house;
(c) “Intermediary” means a person who holds in an estate the right, title or
interest of a talukdar and includes(i) A person who holds land either revenue-free or at a concessional rate, and
(ii) A tenure holder;
(d) “Tenant” means a person who cultivates or holds the land of an
intermediary under an agreement, express or implied, on condition of paying
therefore rent in cash or in kind or delivering a share of the produce and
includes a person who cultivates or holds land of an intermediary under the
system generally known as “bhag”, “adhi” or “barga” and the term “subtenant” shall be construed accordingly;
(e) “Tenure holder” means a person who has acquired from an intermediary the
right to hold lands for the purpose of collecting rents or bringing them under
cultivation by establishing tenants thereon.
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
134. Notification vesting estates in the State. (1) As soon as may be after the
commencement of this Act, the #[State Government] may, by notification in
the Official Gazette, declare that, with effect from the date specified in the
notification (hereinafter referred to as the vesting date), all estates situated in
any area or areas and all rights, title and interest of every intermediary in such
estates shall vest in the Government free from all encumbrances.
(2) Every notification under sub-section (1) shall also be published in such
other manner as may be prescribed.
(3) The publication of a notification in the manner provided in sub-sections (1)
and (2) shall be conclusive evidence of the notice of declaration to the
intermediaries whose interests are affected by such notification.
135. Consequences of a notification under Section-134Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force or in
any agreement or contract, express or implied, with effect from the vesting
date(a) Each estate to which the notification relates and all rights, title and interest
of intermediaries in such estate shall vest in the government free from all
encumbrances, including(i) Rights in hats, bazars, ferries, forests, waste lands, abadi sites, fisheries, tolls
and other interest;
(ii) Rights in any building other than a dwelling house or in any part of such
building, used primarily as office or cutcherry for collection of rent;
(b) All grants and confirmation of title to the estate and rights therein made in
favour of an intermediary shall cease and determine;
(c) Any building used for educational or charitable purposes and held by the
intermediary shall vest in the government for those educational or charitable
purposes;
(d) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, every tenant holding any land
under an intermediary shall hold the same directly under the government as a
raiyat thereof [or as a non-agricultural tenant thereof, as the case may be] and
shall be liable to pay to the Government land revenue equal to the rent payable
by him to the intermediary on the vesting date, subject to a maximum of the
value of one-eighth of the gross produce, which value shall be determined in
the manner prescribed.
Provided that the tenant shall become the owner of any building or structure
constructed on such land at the expense of the intermediary on payment of such
compensation to the intermediary as is equivalent to its market-value on the
vesting date, which value shall be determined in accordance with the rules
made in this behalf;
(e) All arrears of land revenue, local rates, cesses and other dues lawfully
payable to the Government by the intermediary on the vesting date in respect of
the estate shall, without prejudice to any other mode of recovery, be
recoverable by deduction from the compensation payable to the intermediary.
(f) All rent and other dues in respect of the estate for any period after the
vesting date which, but for this Act, would be payable to an intermediary shall
be payable to the Government, and any payment made in contravention of this
clause shall not be valid discharge of the person liable to pay the same.
(g) Where under any agreement or contract made before the vesting date, any
rent, cess, local rate or other dues for any period after the said date has been
paid to or compounded or released by an intermediary, the same shall,
notwithstanding such agreement or contract, be recoverable by the Government
from the intermediary, and may, without prejudice to any other mode of
recovery, be realized by deduction from the compensation payable to the
intermediary.
136. Rights of intermediary to certain lands-(1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in sections 134 and 135, an intermediary
shall, subject to the provisions of sub-section(2), be entitled to retain with
effect from the vesting date(a) Homestead, buildings and structures together with the lands appurtenant
thereto in the [possession] of the intermediary other than buildings vested in
the government under Section-135.
(b) Lands under the personal cultivation of the intermediary;
(c) Lands in which permanent rights have not already accrued to a tenant under
any custom, agreement or law and which have been leased by an intermediary
who, both at the commencement of the lease and on the vesting date, was a
person under disability;
(d) Lands held by the intermediary as mortagagor which are subject to
usufructuary mortgage and are under the personal cultivation of the mortgagee.
(e) Lands comprised in orchards or used for the purpose of live-stock breeding,
poultry farming, or dairy farming, which are in the occupation of the
intermediary;
(f) So much of the lands comprised in a tea garden, mill, factory or workshop
as in the opinion of the [State Government] is required for such tea garden,
mill, factory or workshop.
(2) An intermediary who is entitled to retain possession of any land under subsection (1) shall hold such land directly under the Government from the vesting
date as a raiyat thereof [or as a non-agricultural tenant thereof, as the case may
be] and be liable to pay therefore land revenue at full rate applicable to similar
lands in the locality.
137. Collector to take charge of estates, etc., vested in the Government-(1)
The Collector shall take charge of estates and interests of intermediaries which
vest in the government under section-135.
(2) For the purpose aforesaid, the Collector may, by written order served in the
prescribed manner, require any intermediary or other person in possession of
any such estate or interest to give up such possession by a date to be specified
in the order (which shall not be earlier than sixty days from the date of service
of the order) or to delivery by that date any documents, registers or records,
connected with the management of such estate or interest which are in his
custody or to furnish a statement in the prescribed form in respect of such
estate or interest.
(3) The Collector or any other officer authorized by him in this behalf may take
such steps or use such force as may be necessary to enforce compliance with
the order and may also enter any building or place for the purpose of taking
possession of the documents, registers or records referred to in sub-section(2).
(4) An intermediary shall be entitled to make inspection of any documents,
registers or records which have been delivered to or taken possession of by the
Collector, to make notes therefrom or to have certified copies thereof granted
to him. No fees shall be charged for making inspection or for making notes, but
fees may be charged, according to the prescribed scale, for the grant of certified
copies.
(5) Notwithstanding in this section shall be deemed to authorize the Collector
to take possession of –
(a) Any land or of any right of an intermediary therein, which may be retained
by the intermediary under section 136, or
(b) Any religious institution or any building connected therewith.”
[8]
On perusal of records and upon hearing the submissions made at the
Bar, this Court is of the view that the petitioner company herein neither has
established their locus in terms of claiming ownership nor has shown that they are
in possession. They have been unable to make out their case to prove that they are
an „intermediary‟ or „raiyat‟ or they have any rights to be claimed as an
intermediary to certain lands. Since the earlier proceedings of the Government
such as, the Gazette Notification dated 22.03.1963 and order dated 04.12.1975 of
the Commissioner of Revenue etc. & Secretary to the Government of Tripura have
attained finality and relief claimed therein for retaining and restoring was rejected
and the proceedings which are under challenge in this writ petition also follow on
the same footing.
[9]
Nowhere in the pleadings the petitioner could establish his ownership
right upon the land in question and also his locus standi. No documents are filed in
support of their claim. Nowhere in the pleadings, the petitioner made any attempt
to say that the petitioner is an intermediary or raiyati under TLR & LR Act. Except
reiterating the sections of the Act and discussing and interpreting the same, there is
no specific assertion made by the petitioner about his title & locus standi.
[10]
With the above observation, the present petition stands disposed of by
remanding back the matter to the concerned authority for fresh adjudication. As a
sequel, miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall stands closed.
T. Amarnath Goud, J
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review