Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A.S. No.385 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON : 17.03.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 23.06.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.V. KARTHIKEYAN
And
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.RAJASEKAR
A.S. No.385 of 2026
1. A. Ammasiammal (Died)
2. N. Padmanabhan
3. Maithili
4. Vasuki
5. N. Chandrasekaran
... Appellants
(Appellants 2 to 5 brought on record as LRs
of the deceased sole Appellant, viz., A. Ammasiammal,
vide Court order dated 15.11.2017 made in M.P.No.1/2024
in A.S. (SR) Nos.110224, 110226, 126869 of 2003
and 126862 of 2003)
-vs1. The Special Tahsildar,
Land Acquisition,
Salem-Karur Broad Gauge,
Railway Line Project,
Rajaram Nagar, Salem-7.
2. The Deputy Chief Engineer,
(Construction),
Salem- Karur Broad Gauge
Railway Line Project, Salem – 636 005.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
... Respondents
A.S. No.385 of 2026
Prayer: This appeal is filed under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, to set
aside the lower Court Judgment and Decree of the learned Additional District Judge
& Fast Track Court No.I, Salem in L.A.O.P. No.64 of 2002, dated 31.01.2003.
For Appellants
: Mr. P. Jagadeesan
For R1
: Mr. G. Nanmaran
(Special Government Pleader)
For R2
: Mr. M. Vijay Anand
(Standing Counsel for Railway)
*******
JUDGMENT
[Judgment made by K. RAJASEKAR, J.]
This appeal is filed challenging the Judgment and Decree of the learned
Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No.I, Salem in L.A.O.P. No.64 of
2002, dated 31.01.2003, for enhancement of compensation for the lands acquired
for Salem – Karur Railway Line Project.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred herein according
to their litigative status and rank before the Tribunal. The brief facts leading to
filing of this appeal are as follows:
2.1
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
On the requisition from the Indian Railways, for laying BG Railway
A.S. No.385 of 2026
line between Salem and Karur, the Tamil Nadu State Government had approved a
draft notification u/s 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1874 and published in the
Tamil Nadu Government Gazette on 21.011999, thereby acquired lands situated at
Para Nattamangalam Village in Salem Taluk and District. The Lands acquired are
classified as agricultural land, as per the revenue records. The Land Acquisition
Officer (hereinafter LAO), who is the first respondent herein, after enquiry, fixed
the compensation towards the lands acquired from the appellant herein as
Rs.1,14,490/- by an Award in 3/1999-2000 dated 19.07.1999.
2.2.
Aggrieved over the quantum of compensation, the land owners/
claimants filed original petitions, seeking enhancement of compensation before the
Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No.I, Salem (Land Acquisition
Tribunal). Before the Tribunal, the claimants were examined as C.W.1 to C.W.3 and
Exs.C.1 to C.14 were marked and on the side of the respondents, R.W.1 and R.W.2
were examined and Exs.R.1 to R5 were marked.
Though the claimants have
demanded Rs.150/- per square feet as compensation, the Land Acquisition Tribunal,
after examining the witnesses and documents placed on record and after elaborate
enquiry, fixed Rs.10/- per square feet i.e., Rs.4,36,000/- per acre or Rs.10,76,920/per hectare, as just compensation. Further, the Tribunal has also ordered 30%
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
solatium and other compensations under various heads along with applicable
interest. Aggrieved over the compensation awarded by the Additional District Judge
& Fast Track Court No.I, Salem (Land Acquisition Tribunal), the claimant has
preferred this appeal suit, for enhancement. The respondent have not filed any
separate appeal.
3.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf of appellants/ claimants
submitted that the compensation fixed for the lands acquired, by the Tribunal is only
Rs.10/- per square feet, which is very minimal. He also submitted that the Court
below failed to appreciate the evidence placed on record in fixing the market value
of the lands acquired and further, the Court below has fixed only Rs.10,000/- as
severance compensation, which is also very minimal. He further submitted that
deduction of 50% of the compensation value towards development charges is
exorbitant, the Court below also failed to appreciate that on the north, west and
south of P.Nattamangalam Village, Amani Kondalampatty Village is situated and the
lands thereon have all infra structures such as road, electricity, etc., hence deduction
of 50% of the value as development charges is high exorbitant. He also submitted
that the lands acquired from the Amani Kondalampatty Village for the very same
railway project, a Division Bench of this Court in judgment dated 16.07.2009 in
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
batch of appeals in A.S.No.430 of 2007, has determined the compensation for the
acquired lands as Rs.100/- per square feet, similarly the lands acquired in this case
is surrounded by this Amani Kondalampatti village. He prays that Rs.75/- per
square feet may be fixed as compensation and prays to enhance the compensation
fixed by the Tribunal.
4.
The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the first
respondent selected a data land for fixing the compensation for the acquired lands,
which are similar in nature in all aspects, compared to the acquired lands. Further
the acquired lands are only agricultural land and do not have any building
potentiality, as alleged by the claimant.
He also submitted that there is no
developed residential area or commercial establishments near the acquired lands and
based on the categorical guidelines prescribed in the Act, the market value of the
lands were fixed, hence prays to dismiss the appeal.
5.
We have considered the submissions made on both sides and perused
the materials available on record:
6.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A Division Bench of this Court, while deciding the market value for
A.S. No.385 of 2026
the lands acquired for the very same Railway Line Project from the Amani
Kondalampatti Village, Salem Taluk in A.S.No.430 of 2007 dated 16.07.2009 has
fixed the uniform rate of Rs.100/- per square feet and also while deciding the cost
deducted towards development charges has held in paragraph No.11 as follows:
“11. We are not able to sustain the argument of the learned
counsel for the second respondent, that the enhancement of Rs.25/- over
and above the value of the land in SI.No.476, because SI.No.476 was sold
on 15.04.1998, but the 4(1) notification is dated 23.02.1999. Hence,
therre must be some escalation in the price of the house sites. As per
Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, the value has to be determined by
taking into consideration the market value of the land on the date of
publication of the notification under Section 4(1) of the Act. As the date
of the notification under Section 4(1) of the Act is nearly one year after
the date of sale of land under SI.No.476, the enhance of Rs.25/-, in our
view, would reflect the fair market value. If that be so, we are of the view
that the determination of the value of the land at Rs.125/- per sq.ft., is a
fair market value of the land and it cannot be regarded as on the higher
side. An attempt was made to contend that no amount was deducted from
the value determined towards development charges, by relying on the
Supreme Court decision in the cases of Basavva vs. Spl. Land Acquisition
Officer, (1996) 9 SCC 640 and Land Acquisition Officer, Kammarapally
Village vs. Nookala Rajamallu, AIR 2004 SC 1031. Here again, we are
not able to concur with the argument. The public purpose for which the
land was acquired in the present case is for formation of railway track
from Salem to Karur, which require no development except strengthening
the track land and laying the rail track. It is apt, we think to quotet
certain observations made by the apex Court in the case of Nelson
Fernandes vs. Special land Acquisition Officer, 2007 (9) SCC 447:
“We are not, however, oblivious of the fact that normally
1/3rd deduction of further amount of compensation has to be
directed in some cases. However, the purpose for which the land
acquired must also be taken into consideration. In the instant
case the land was acquired for the construction of new B.G. line
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
for Konkan Railway. This Court, in Hasanali Khanbahi & sons
vs. State of Gujarat, (1995) 2 SCC 422 and Land Acquisition
Officer vs. Nookala Ramamallu, 2003 (12) SCC 334 had, noticed
that where lands are acquired for specific purposes deduction by
way of development charges is permissible. In the instant case,
acquisition is for laying a railway line. Therefore, the question of
development charges thereof would not arise.”
But the Reference Court has not taken into consideration the largeness of
the area which has been acquired, while arriving at the value with
reference to small piece of land in SI.No.476. The extent of lands sold by
document dated 15.04.1998 in S.No.476 is 398 sq.m., (4187 sq.ft),
whereas the land acquired is an extent of 2.01.0 hectares. Hence,
definitely certain percentage in the value has to be deducted towards the
largeness of the area acquired.”
7.
This Court recently in A.S.Nos.599 of 2017 (batch) dated 02.03.2026
and A.S.No.611 of 2017 (batch) dated 09.06.2026 and, while deciding the
compensation for the lands acquired for the very same railway line project from the
Keeranoor village and Komarapalayam village, respectively has followed the
comparison method and fixed the compensation value for the acquired lands, based
on the proximity of the adjoining villages. The Apex Court in Special Land
Acquisition Officer V. Karigowda and others reported in [(2010) 5 SCC 708], has
approved the above method and held that the purpose for which land is acquired and
the valuation in the adjoining villages also can be considered. In paragraphs 75 to
77 the Supreme Court held as follows:
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
“75. It is a settled principle of law that lands of adjacent
villages can be made the basis for determining the fair market value of
the acquired land. This principle of law is qualified by clear dictum of
this Court itself that whenever direct evidence i.e., instances of the same
villages are available, then it is most desirable that the Court should
consider that evidence. But where such evidence is not available Court
can safely rely upon the sales statistics of adjoining lands provided that
instances are comparable and the potentiality and location of the land
is somewhat similar. The evidence tendered in relation to the land of
the adjacent villages would be a relevant piece of evidence for such
determination. Once it is shown that situation and potential of the land
in two different villages are the same then they could be awarded
similar compensation or such other compensation as would be just and
fair.
76. The cases of acquisition are not unknown to our legal
system where lands of a number of villages are required for the same
public purpose or different schemes but on the commonality of purpose
and unite development. The parties are expected to place documentary
evidence on record that price of the land of adjoining villages has an
increasing trend and the Court may adopt such a price as the same is
not impermissible. Where there is commonality of purpose and common
development, compensation based on statistical date of adjacent
villages was held to be proper. Usefully, reference can be made to the
judgments of this Court in Kanwar Singh vs. Union of India and Union
of India vs. Bal Ram.
77. In this regard we may also make a reference to the
judgment of this Court in Kanwar Singh vs. Union of India where sale
instances of the adjacent villages were taken into consideration for the
purpose of determining the fair market value of the land in question and
their comparability, potential and acquisition for the same purpose was
hardly in dispute. It was not only permissible but even more practical
for the Courts to take into consideration the sale statistics of the
adjacent villages for determining the fair market value of the acquired
land.”
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
8.
In this case, it is also submitted that the lands, which were acquired
herein are situated at P. Natamangalam village and this village is surrounded by the
Amani Kondalampatti village on three sides, thereby it has been established that the
acquired lands for the very same railway line project are from the same region,
though the name of the villages are different. The Division Bench of this Court in
A.S.No.430 of 2007 (batch) dated 16.07.2009 had determined the value for the
lands situated at Amani Kondalampatti village as Rs.100/- per square feet and in
this appeal, the claimants/ appellants herein claim Rs.75/- per square feet as
compensation towards the acquired lands situated at P.Natamangalam village. We
have also perused the village map produced and there is no dispute regarding the
fact that, this village is adjacent village of Amani Kondalampatti, the respondents
have paid the compensation to the land owners of Amani Kondalampatti, as
determined by this Court and same reached its finality. Hence, we are of the view
that it is reasonable and permissible to modify the market value of the land fixed by
the Tribunal to uniform rate of Rs.75/- per square feet.
9.
The Tribunal has also ordered 50% of the value of compensation
towards development charges, this Court in A.S.No.430 of 2007 dated 16.07.2009
has held that, deduction of 50% of the value towards development charges for the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
lands acquired for laying a railway line is not proper. We are of the view that 50%
of the value of compensation, deducted towards development charges, ordered by
the Tribunal is liable to be cancelled.
10.
The Tribunal has also taken note of the fact that, some of the lands are
entitled to severance compensation and accordingly, the Tribunal has fixed
severance compensation as Rs.10,000/- for the extent of 0.10.05 hectares. This
Court in “The Special Tahsildar (LA), Salem vs. V.K. Periyasami and another” in
A.S.Nos.599 to 609 of 2017 (batch) vide judgment dated 02.03.2026, while
deciding the compensation for the severed lands in Keeranoor village for the very
same railway line project has determined the value of the land as Rs.25/- per square
feet and severance compensation as Rs.10 lakhs per hectare. In proportion to the
above compensation fixed, we are of the view that fixing the severance
compensation for the present lands (i.e.,) in this case as Rs.30 lakhs per hectare
(Rs.12.14 lakhs per acre) would be appropriate. Accordingly, the appellant herein is
entitled for enhanced compensation in the same proportion for his land i.e., 0.10.5
hectares.
11.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
As observed in the earlier paragraph, the market value for lands is
A.S. No.385 of 2026
enhanced to uniform rate of Rs.75/- per square feet. Similarly, in proportion to the
above compensation fixed, the severance compensation is also hereby enhanced in
proportion to the lands acquired from the appellant herein to Rs.3,15,000/- (Rupees
Three lakhs and Fifteen Thousands only). Further, the 50% deduction towards the
value of compensation towards development charges is hereby cancelled. As far as
the compensation awarded by the Tribunal under various other heads and the
interest rates are hereby confirmed. The respondents herein are directed to deposit
the enhanced compensation along with interest to the credit of L.A.O.P. No.64 of
2022 on the file of the learned Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No.I,
Salem, within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
12.
In the result, this appeal is allowed. Consequently, connected civil
miscellaneous petition, if any stands closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
(C.V. KARTHIKEYAN, J.) (K. RAJASEKAR, J.)
23-06-2026
Index : Yes/No
Internet: Yes/No
Speaking order/Non-Speaking order
stn
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No.385 of 2026
C.V. KARTHIKEYAN, J.
AND
K.RAJASEKAR, J.
stn
To
1. The Additional District Judge & Fast Track Court No.I, Salem.
2. The Special Tahsildar,
Land Acquisition,
Salem-Karur Broad Gauge,
Railway Line Project,
Rajaram Nagar, Salem-7.
3. The Deputy Chief Engineer,
(Construction),
Salem- Karur Broad Gauge
Railway Line Project, Salem – 636 005.
4. The Section Officer,
V.R. Section,
High Court of Madras.
Pre-delivery Judgment made
in A.S. No.385 of 2026
23-06-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review