Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
Present :
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
Amarnath Mandal
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Sanjay Saha
Mr. Lal Ratan Mondal
Mr. Probal Sarkar
Mr. Sk. Kiran
Ms. Indrani Mukherjee
For the State in
WPA 28310 of 2025
:
Mr. Suddhadev Adak
For the State in
WPA 28891 of 2024
:
Mr. Santanu Kumar Mitra
Mr. Subhabrata Das
For the State in
WPA 31085 of 2024
:
Mr. Ansar Mondal
Ms. Sreelekha Bhattacharya
For the Municipality
:
Mr. Md Sarwar Jahan
Mr. Sayantan Hazra
Mr. Subrata Ghosh
Ms. Shalini Sen
Ms. Sahina Parvin
Mr. Emrul Kayes
Heard on
:
11.03.2026
Judgment on
:
11.03.2026
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
Raja Basu Chowdhury, J (Oral):
1.
By consent of the parties, the three writ petitions, all filed by the
petitioner are taken up for consideration together.
2.
The proceedings emanate from an order passed by the Hon’ble
Division Bench of this Court in a Public Interest Litigation, being WPA
(P) 13 of 2024 dated 18th January, 2024, whereby the Hon’ble Division
Bench of this Court taking note of the submissions of elected members
of the Murshidabad Municipality
and the allegation that despite a
decision taken by the municipality in its meeting held on 12th
September, 2023 to investigate and conduct an enquiry with regard to
certain tenders the same had not been concluded and that the
respondents therein were in the process of compromising the issue,
directed the Director of Local Bodies, Government of West Bengal to
appoint an officer who shall immediately conduct an enquiry into the
matter and thereafter proceed to take action in accordance with law.
3.
The records would reveal that in furtherance to the above, the
Director of Local Bodies by a communication in writing dated 13 th
December, 2024 had directed the Chairman, Murshidabad Municipality
to initiate a disciplinary proceeding against certain employees including
the petitioner herein, who at the relevant point of time was discharging
his function as Sub-Assistant Engineer of the municipality.
4.
In the interregnum, however, the Chairman of the municipality
had issued a show cause calling upon the petitioner to respond as to
why legal action shall not be taken against petitioner for the petitioner
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
having been involved in the illegalities and irregularities which resulted
in loot of public money amounting to Rs.2,91,41,305.61.
5.
Without responding to the aforesaid show cause, or waiting for
the outcome thereof, the petitioner had approached this Court by way
of a writ petition being WPA 28891of 2024, inter alia, challenging the
show cause notice dated 25th November, 2024.
6.
Records would also reveal that in furtherance to the notice dated
13th December, 2024 issued by the Director of Local Bodies, the
petitioner was placed under suspension vide memo dated 18th
December, 2024, issued by the Chairman of the said municipality.
7.
Challenging the order of suspension, a writ petition, being WPA
31085 of 2024 was filed. Subsequently, on 27th November, 2025 a
notice was issued intimating that a disciplinary proceeding has been
initiated against the petitioner in terms of the West Bengal Municipal
Employees’ (Classification, Control, Appeal and Conduct) Rules, 2010
(hereinafter referred to as the “said rules”). Since, by such time, the
petitioner had already reached the age of superannuation, challenging
the
aforesaid
initiation
of
disciplinary
proceeding
post
his
superannuation on 30th September, 2025, a writ petition being WPA
28310 of 2025 was filed.
8.
Mr. Saha, learned advocate representing the petitioner has drawn
attention of this Court to the said rules and would submit that the said
rules do not authorize initiation or continuation of disciplinary proceeding
beyond the date of superannuation. In support of his aforesaid
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
contention he has placed reliance on the judgment delivered by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Dev Prakash Tewari v. Uttar
Pradesh Cooperative Institutional Service Board, Lucknow & Ors.,
reported in (2014) 7 SCC 260. Reliance has also been placed on the
judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in the
case of Dilip Kumar Banerjee v. State of West Bengal & Ors.,
reported in 2024 SCC Online Cal. 11859.
9.
Mr. Jahan, learned advocate representing the municipality would
submit that this matter pertains to financial embezzlement at the
behest of the petitioner. A proceeding had been initiated on the basis of
the directives issued by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in a
Public Interest Litigation in furtherance to the resolution dated 12 th
September, 2023. According to him, the petitioner is involved in the
financial embezzlement and loot of public money. He would submit that
criminal proceedings have also been initiated against the petitioner and
the same is being investigated by the CID at present.
10.
Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective
parties, I am of the view that the primary issue that requires
consideration is whether consequent upon the petitioner having
superannuated from service i.e. on 30th September, 2025, the
municipality could have initiated any disciplinary proceeding on 27th
November, 2025. The same is important having regard to the fact that
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
the master-servant relationship between the petitioner and the
municipality came to an end by then.
11.
Independent of the above, the petitioner has not only challenged
the show-cause notice but also the order of suspension. In the instant
case, the petitioner claims that the initiation of the disciplinary
proceeding was on the basis of the notice dated 27th November, 2025,
however, in the instant case, the fact that the petitioner was put under
suspension in contemplation of disciplinary proceeding in furtherance
to the memo issued by the Director of Local Bodies dated 13th
December, 2024 cannot be overlooked.
12.
Be that as it may, to consider the above aspect it is necessary to
consider the scope and powers of the disciplinary authority to put a
delinquent under suspension. Rule 4 of the said rules provide for the
conditions for placing an employee under suspension. To morefully
appreciate the same, the relevant rule is extracted hereinbelow:“Rule 4. Conditions for placing an employee under
suspension.
“(1) The appointing authority may place an employee under
suspension,(a) Where a disciplinary proceeding or departmental enquiry
against him is contemplated or is pending; or
(b) Where in the opinion of the appointing authority, he has
engaged himself in activities prejudicial to the interest of the Local
Body or the State or the country; or
(c) Where a case against him in respect of any criminal offence is
under investigation or trial.
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
(2) The procedure, which is being followed for criminal charges
against a Government employee, may identically be followed in
case of a municipal employee.
(3) A municipal employee who is placed under suspension or be
deemed to be under suspension in the circumstances mentioned in
sub rule (1) shall irrespective of the circumstances which lead to,
or resulted in suspension be entitled to subsistence allowance
during the period of suspension.
(4) An employee against whom a proceeding has been commenced
on a criminal charge but who is not actually detained in custody
(e.g. a person released on bail) may be placed under suspension
under clause (c) of sub-rule (1) by an order made by the appointing
authority. If the criminal charge is related to the official position of
the employee or involves any moral turpitude on his part,
suspension shall be ordered under this sub-rule, unless there are
exceptional reasons for not adopting such a course.
(5) An employee who is detained in custody for a period exceeding
forty eight hours under any law providing for preventive detention
or as a result of a proceeding either on a criminal charge or
otherwise, shall be deemed to have been suspended, by an order
of the appointing authority, with effect from the date of his
detention and shall remain under suspension until further orders.
An employee who is undergoing a sentence of imprisonment shall
also be dealt with in the same manner, pending, a decision on the
disciplinary action to be taken against him.
(6) (i) Where a penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory
'retirement
from
service
imposed
on
an
employee
under
suspension; or
(ii) a disciplinary proceeding pending against an employee under
suspension is set aside in appeal or on review under these rules
and the case is remitted for further enquiry or action or with any
directions, the order of his suspension shall be deemed to have
continued in force,-
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
(a) in the case where the penalty of dismissal, removal or
compulsory retirement from service had been imposed, on and
from the date of the order imposing such penalty, and
(b) in the case where the disciplinary action was pending, on and
from the date of order placing the employee under suspension,
and in either case; the order of suspension shall remain in force
until further orders.
(7) Where a penalty of dismissal, removal or compulsory
retirement from service imposed on a employee under suspension
or a disciplinary proceeding pending against an employee under
suspension is set aside or declared or rendered void in
consequence of or by a decision of Court of Law and the
disciplinary authority, on a consideration of the circumstances of
the case, decides to hold a further inquiry against the employee on
the allegations on which the penalty was originally imposed or the
disciplinary proceeding was originally started, the employee shall
be deemed to have been placed under suspension by the
appointing author with effect from the date on which the order
imposing the penalty of dismissal, removal compulsory retirement
from service was made or where the disciplinary proceeding
pending, from the date on which the employee was originally
placed under suspension
An order of the suspension made or deemed to have been made
under this sub-rule shall continue force until it is modified or
revoked by the authority competent to do so.”
13.
Having regard to the above and since a departmental enquiry was
contemplated against the petitioner at the relevant point of time in
furtherance to the notice issued by the Director of Local Bodies dated
13th December, 2024, the right of the municipality to place the
petitioner under suspension cannot be doubted. The suspension order
has been passed by the Chairman of the municipality who is the
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
appointing authority as also the disciplinary authority and as such the
order of suspension does not suffer from any illegality. On such
ground, this Court is not inclined to interfere with the order of
suspension dated 18th December, 2024.
14.
Insofar as issuance of show case notice is concerned, the show
cause was issued obviously in furtherance to the order passed by the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court. Going by the aforesaid although,
the petitioner has attempted to make out a case that the municipality
had made up its mind, while issuing the show-cause, however, from the
tenor of the same it is clear that the observations made in the show
cause were only tentative and no conclusion had been reached at that
stage. The petitioner was obliged to respond to the show cause. On
such ground no interference is called for.
15.
Coming back to the issue whether the disciplinary proceedings
can be initiated or continued against the petitioner after the petitioner
having reached the age of superannuation, I find that the rules do not
expressly provide for the scope for initiation of disciplinary proceeding
beyond the date of superannuation. Admittedly, in this case, the
petitioner had reached the age of superannuation though at the
relevant point of time he was kept under suspension. It is also an
admitted position that at that stage the municipality was only
contemplating disciplinary proceeding and no disciplinary proceeding
had actually been initiated. Initiation of disciplinary proceeding was
effected vide letter dated 27th November, 2025. On 27th November,
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
2025, the petitioner had already reached the age of superannuation
and the master-servant relationship had snapped. On such ground and
in absence of any rule authorizing initiation of disciplinary proceeding
and in absence of any master-servant relationship which is the
foundation for disciplining a delinquent employee, the initiation of
proceeding after the date of superannuation becomes a non-starter.
The judgment delivered in the case of Dev Prakash Tewari (supra) and
in the case of Dilip Kumar Banerjee support the above proposition of
law. This apart the disciplinary proceeding had been initiated by a
person other than the disciplinary authority. Though Mr. Jahan by
placing the resolution adopted by the Board of Councillors dated 16 th
September 2025 would submit that the Executive Officer was
empowered to initiate disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner,
however, having regard to the rules not conferring any power to
delegate, I am of the view ordinarily delegation of such power was not
possible.
However,
since
such
issue
may
not
be
a
relevant
consideration in the light of the observation made hereinabove, no
decision is rendered thereon.
16.
In the light of the above, the disciplinary proceeding initiated
against the petitioner cannot be sustained and are declared to be nonstarter and non est and consequentially quashed. All consequences
shall follow.
17.
WPA 28310 of 2025
With
WPA 28891 of 2024
With
WPA 31085 of 2024
The aforesaid order shall however not interfere with the rights of
the municipality to proceed against the petitioner in the criminal
proceedings, especially when the disciplinary proceeding has been
declared to be non est on technical ground.
18.
With the above observations and directions, the writ petition is
disposed of.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
made available to the parties upon compliance of requisite formalities.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
SB
A.R. (Court)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review