The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. For all the reasons aforesaid, the order impugned dated May 27, 2025 passed under Section 270AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (pertaining to assessment year 2023-24) is set aside. The Assessing Officer concerned shall revisit the petitioners‟ application for grant of immunity, strictly in accordance with law and pass appropriate order upon affording an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
24. With the above observations, WPA 28765 of 2025 stands disposed of. No costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Before:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE OM NARAYAN RAI
WPA 28765 of 2025
Amalgam Steel Private Limited & Anr.
versus
The Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors.
For the Writ Petitioners
: Mr. Abhrajit Mitra, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Saurabh Bagaria
Mr. Piyush Agarwal
Ms. Shivangi Thard
Ms. Shrivalli Kajaria
For the Respondents
: Mr. Aryak Dutt
Ms. Sukanya Dutta
Ms. Riya Kundu
Hearing concluded on
:
09.01.2026
Judgment on
:
09.01.2026
Om Narayan Rai, J.:
1.
This writ petition mounts challenge to an order dated May 27, 2025
passed under Section 270AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 thereby rejecting
the petitioner no.1‟s (hereafter “the petitioner”) application seeking
immunity from penalty under Section 270A of the said Act of 1961.
2.
Briefly stated, the facts relevant for the purpose of adjudication of the
present writ petition are that the petitioner filed its Return of Income
under Section 139 of the said Act of 1961 on October 26, 2023 declaring a
total income of rupees „NIL‟. The same was processed under section 143
and intimation under Section 143(1) of the said Act of 1961 was issued on
November 29, 2023. The petitioner‟s case was subjected to scrutiny
assessment and an order of assessment under Section 143 (3) of the said
Act of 1961 was passed on March 28, 2025 raising a demand of
Rs.10,49,79,418/-.
3.
The petitioner then filed an application for rectification under Section 154
of the said Act of 1961 thereby seeking rectification of the scrutiny
assessment order. While the petitioner‟s application for rectification was
pending, a notice under Section 270A of the said Act of 1961 was issued
to the petitioners on March 28, 2025 thereby calling upon the petitioner to
show cause as tow why an order imposing penalty shall not be passed
against it for “Under-reporting of income”.
4.
Upon receipt of the said notice, the petitioner filed an application under
Section 270AA of the said Act of 1961, on April 9, 2025 in the prescribed
form (Form 68) seeking immunity from imposition of penalty under
Section 270A of the said Act of 1961 for the assessment year 2023-24. In
the said application, the petitioner, inter alia, highlighted that the
petitioner had sought for rectification of the scrutiny assessment order
and that the petitioner reasonably believed that upon rectification of the
said order, no demand would be subsisting inasmuch as the petitioner did
not have taxable income.
5.
While the petitioner‟s said application for immunity was pending, the
petitioner‟s application for rectification was allowed by an order dated May
1, 2025 thereby determining the final tax demand as „NIL‟.
6.
Subsequently, on May 27, 2025, the petitioner‟s application seeking
immunity under the Section 270AA of the said Act of 1961 was rejected by
the Assessing Officer observing as follows:
“In response thereof, the assessee company applied for
immunity from penalty u/s 270AA of the Act in Form 68 on
09/04/2025.
In this regard, an opportunity was given to the assessee
vide notice u/s 270AA dated 08.05.2025 requesting the
assessee to submit its reply / explanations or to appear either
personally or through a duly authorized representative on
13.05.2025 and present their case alongwith corroborative
documentary evidence.
However, no compliance was made by the assessee in
response to the said notice.
The conditions laid down in section 270AA of the Income
Tax Act also do not fulfil, as such the prayer for granting
immunity is not maintainable.
Accordingly, assessee's prayer for grant of immunity from
imposition of penalty u/s 270A of the Income Tax Act for the
A.Y. 2023-24 is hereby rejected.”
7.
Assailing the said order, the petitioner filed an appeal before the
Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). The said appeal was rejected by an
order
dated
October
3,
holding
that
the
appeal
was
not
maintainable. It is thereafter that the petitioners have approached this
Court by filing the instant writ petition.
8.
Mr. Mitra, learned senior advocate appearing for the petitioners submits
that the order impugned is impeachable on several grounds. It is
submitted that the order impugned has been passed without considering
the petitioner‟s application seeking immunity. It is further submitted that
no reason has been assigned as to why has the petitioner‟s request for
grant of immunity been declined and as to why has the Assessing Officer
held that the petitioner‟s prayer for immunity is „not maintainable’.
9.
Mr. Mitra invited the attention of this Court to an order No. 106 of 202526 dated May 22, 2025 issued by the Director General of Income Tax (Inv.)
and submitted that the incumbent in the seat of Assessing Officer who
passed the order impugned on May 27, 2025 had been transferred from
the said seat to DDIT (Inv.) Headquarters & Administration, Kolkata by an
order dated May 22, 2025 and as such the said person did not have
jurisdiction to pass any order on the petitioners‟ application seeking
immunity on May 27, 2025 (i.e. on the date of the order impugned).
10.
It is further pointed out that the penalty proceeding which had been
initiated against the petitioner by issuance of notice under Section 270A of
Income Tax Act, 1961 was dropped by the relevant revenue officer by an
order dated September 29, 2025 upon taking into consideration the fact
that the scrutiny assessment order that had been passed against the
petitioner stood rectified resulting in a “Nil” demand.
11.
Mr. Mitra has relied on a judgment of the Hon‟ble Delhi High Court in the
case of Schneider Electric South East Asia (HQ) Pte. Ltd. vs. Asst.
Commissioner of Income Tax International Taxation Circle 3(1)(2)
and Others 1in support of his contention that rejection of an application
seeking immunity should be informed by reasons.
12.
Mr.
Dutt,
learned
Senior
Standing
Counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents/ revenue authorities submits that the petitioner‟s application
for immunity is not available either in physical records of the revenue
authorities or on the relevant portal of the revenue authorities. It is
further submitted that the petitioner‟s application has been rejected since
the Assessing Officer found that the petitioner‟s case did not fulfil the
requirements for grant of immunity under Section 270AA of the said Act of
1961.
13.
Heard learned advocates appearing for the respective parties and
considered the material on record.
14.
It is not in dispute that the scrutiny assessment order passed against the
petitioner has been rectified by an order dated May 01, 2025 thereby
determining the tax payable/refundable as rupees „NIL‟.
15.
Although it has been submitted by Mr. Dutt that the petitioner‟s
application seeking immunity is neither available with the physical
records of the respondents/ revenue authorities nor available on the
portal, yet, it is evident from the order impugned dated May 27, 2025, (an
extract of the relevant portion whereof has already been reproduced
hereinabove), that the petitioner had indeed applied for immunity from
penalty under Section 270AA of the said Act of 1961 in Form 68 on April
9, 2025. Such application along with the print out of Form 68 forms
Annexure „P-6‟ to the writ petition (at pages 77 to 79 thereof).
16.
In such view of the matter, it cannot be said that no application was filed
by the petitioner seeking immunity. In the said application the petitioner
(2022) 1 High Court Cases (Del ) 792
has, in support of its contention that it has satisfied the conditions
required for grant of immunity in terms of Section 270AA of the said Act of
1961 stated as follows:
“3.0 Sec 270AA of the Act provides that the Assessing Officer may
grant immunity from imposition of penalty under sec 270A of
the Act provided the following conditions are met:
4.0
17.
a)
Demand determined in the order is being duly paid:
It may be stated that against the order passed under
section 143(3) dated 28-03-2025, the company has filed
rectification petition under section 154 dated 07-04-2025.
Once the order under sec 143(3) is rectified by your
kindself, there will be no taxable income in case of the
company for the instant assessment year and hence, no
consequential demand payable for the said assessment
year. Copy of the petition filed under sec 154 is enclosed
herewith and marked as Annexure-2.
b)
No Appeal is being filed against the order - In the
instant case, the company has decided not to file an
appeal against the captioned order
c)
Application in Form 68 is filed within one month
from the end of the month in which the order has
been received - The Company had filed the application in
Form 68 on 09-04-2025 which is well within the
prescribed timeline.
d)
Proceedings for penalty under section 270A had not been
initiated under the circumstances referred to in subsection (9) of the said section 270A.”
On perusal of above, It is seen that the company satisfies all
the conditions prescribed in Sec 270AA for grant of immunity
from imposition of penalty under sec 270A of the Act.”
Thus the petitioner has sought to demonstrate that it has satisfied all the
conditions required for grant of immunity. Such application appears to
have been filed within the time specified in Section 270AA of the said Act
of 1961. The same therefore ought to have been considered by the
Assessing Officer in the right earnest while passing an order under Section
270AA of the said Act of 1961.
18.
Section 270 AA of the said Act of 1961 is extracted hereinbelow:
“270AA. (1) An assessee may make an application to the
Assessing Officer to grant immunity from imposition of
penalty under section 270A and initiation of proceedings
under section 276C or section 276CC, if he fulfils the
following conditions, namely:(a)
the tax and interest payable as per the order of
assessment or reassessment under sub-section
(3) of section 143 or section 147, as the case
may be, has been paid within the period
specified in such notice of demand; and
(b)
no appeal against the order referred to in clause
(a) has been filed.
(2) An application referred to in sub-section (1) shall be
made within one month from the end of the month in which
the order referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1) has been
received and shall be made in such form and verified in
such manner as may be prescribed.
(3) The Assessing Officer shall, subject to fulfilment of
the conditions specified in sub-section (1) and after the
expiry of the period of filing the appeal as specified in
clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 249, grant
immunity from imposition of penalty under section
270A and initiation of proceedings under section 276C
or section 276CC, where the proceedings for penalty
under section 270A has not been initiated under the
circumstances referred to in sub-section (9) of the said
section 270A.
(4) The Assessing Officer shall, within a period of one
month from the end of the month in which the application
under sub-section (1) is received, pass an order accepting or
rejecting such application:
Provided that no order rejecting the application shall be
passed unless the assessee has been given an opportunity
of being heard.
(5) The order made under sub-section (4) shall be final.
(6) No appeal under [section 246 or] section 246A or
an application for revision under section 264 shall be
admissible
against
the
order
of
assessment or
reassessment, referred to in clause (a) of sub-section
(1), in a case where an order under sub-section (4) has
been made accepting the application.]”
19.
Sub-section 3 of Section 270AA reads in mandatory terms. A meaningful
reading thereof makes it clear that once an assessee satisfies the
conditions mentioned in the earlier limbs of the said section, the
Assessing Officer would be bound to grant immunity to such assesse.
20.
The order impugned dated May 27, 3035 could not have been passed
without disclosing the basis for the conclusion as to why was (is) the
petitioner not entitled to immunity and which of the conditions mentioned
in Section 270AA of the said Act of 1961 the petitioner has failed to fulfil.
There is no indication in the order impugned as to how have the
petitioner‟s contention in its application for immunity been dealt with.
21.
It is now well settled that reasons are live links between the narrative and
the directive and that an order without reasons can also be treated as a
nullity. Since the order impugned dated May 27, 2025 does not evince any
application of mind to the matter by the Assessing Officer concerned and
it does not cite any reason on the basis of whereof the ultimate conclusion
has been arrived at, therefore, the same cannot withstand judicial
scrutiny.
22.
In fact Schneider Electric South East Asia (HQ) Pte. Ltd. (supra) cited
by the petitioners also emphasises on reasons being provided in the order
declining immunity.
23.
For all the reasons aforesaid, the order impugned dated May 27, 2025
passed under Section 270AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (pertaining to
assessment year 2023-24) is set aside. The Assessing Officer concerned
shall revisit the petitioners‟ application for grant of immunity, strictly in
accordance with law and pass appropriate order upon affording an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
24.
With the above observations, WPA 28765 of 2025 stands disposed of. No
costs.
25.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties on urgent basis after completion of necessary formalities.
(Om Narayan Rai, J.)
Sws.M. AR(Ct.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review