The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In the aforesaid circumstances, we are unable to uphold the findings of the learned Single Judge in declining to exercise jurisdiction in the matter. When the relevant enactments confer upon the authority to grant parole on the ground of “sufficient cause,” the adequacy and sufficiency of the reasons cited for either granting or refusing parole become amenable to judicial review in a writ proceeding. The Court is well within its jurisdiction to examine whether the order of rejection is founded on valid, relevant, and legally sustainable grounds, or whether it is vitiated [ AIR 2017 SC 4986], by consideration of extraneous, irrelevant, or mala fide reasons. Accordingly, in an appropriate case where an application for parole made under the provisions of the Act or the Rules framed thereunder is rejected on grounds that are manifestly extraneous or irrelevant, the High Court, in the exercise of its extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, is empowered to interfere and issue appropriate directions. Such intervention, however, is warranted only in cases where the impugned decision is demonstrably arbitrary, unreasonable, or unsupported by material evidence. In view of the discussion above, the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No. 707 of 2019 is set aside. This Writ Appeal will stand allowed. There will be a direction to the compete…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:2837
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. V. BALAKRISHNAN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 553 OF 2025
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED IN WP(Crl.) NO.839 OF 2024
OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER IN WP(CRL):
AMAL NISHAM
AGED 38 YEARS
W/O MUHAMMED NISHAM, ADAKKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
FLAT NO 1073, TOPAS SHOBA CITY, THRISSUR,
PIN - 680553
BY ADVS.
BEJOY JOSEPH P.J.
M.RAMESH CHANDER (SR.)
GOVIND G. NAIR
BALU TOM
BONNY BENNY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS IN WP(CRL):
THE STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
DEPARTMENT OF HOME, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PRISONS & CORRECTIONAL
SERVICES, PRISONS HEAD QUARTERS, POOJAPURA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM – 695012., PIN - 695012
THE SUPERINTENDENT CENTRAL PRISON &
CORRECTIONAL HOME, VIYYUR, PIN - 680010
BY ADVS. SRI.C.K.SURESH, SPL. GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
03.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
JUDGMENT
Raja Vijayaraghavan V., J.
This
appeal
is
preferred
challenging
the
judgment dated
25.02.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge rejecting the prayer
sought by the petitioner for granting parole to the husband of the
appellant, a convict prisoner, undergoing his life sentence at the Central
Prison and Correctional Home, Viyyur.
2.
The learned Single Judge, took note of the adverse police
report submitted by the Assistant Commissioner of Police, District Special
Branch, Thrissur City, and the Inspector of Police, Viyyur Police Station,
and came to the conclusion that the refusal to grant parole was in order.
3.
Sri. Ramesh Chander, the learned Senior counsel appearing
for the appellant, submitted that the husband of the appellant is presently
undergoing life imprisonment pursuant to his conviction in Crime No. 173
of 2015 of the Peramangalam Police Station and has been continuously
serving his sentence since 2015. During the last ten years of incarceration,
he was granted interim bail by this Hon'ble Court only on a few occasions.
He was first granted interim bail for two months, from 21.01.2019 to
21.03.2019. Subsequently, he was granted interim bail for eight days from
11.08.2020, which was extended by order dated Ext.P4 till 15.09.2020.
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
Thereafter, by order dated Ext.P5, he was granted leave for three days,
from 20.03.2021 to 24.03.2021. Other than the aforementioned instances,
the convict has not availed parole or leave. It is further submitted that due
to his involvement in minor skirmishes at the Central Prison and
Correctional Home, Thavanur, the convict was transferred to the Central
Prison and Correctional Home, Viyyur, on 15.09.2023. Significantly, no
disciplinary action whatsoever has been initiated against him post-transfer.
It is further submitted that the Probation Officer has furnished a
favourable report and recommended the grant of leave in accordance with
the relevant Rules. However, parole was denied owing to an adverse
police report. The only reason stated in the report is the existence of
ongoing business and property disputes between the convict and his
siblings and an apprehension that his release may lead to a law and order
situation. The learned counsel points out that for the settlement of
business and property disputes between himself and his siblings,
arbitration proceedings have already been initiated by the prisoner and
the matter is currently pending before the Arbitral Tribunal. The personal
presence of the convict is essential to give necessary instructions to his
counsel and to adduce both oral and documentary evidence. Finally, it is
submitted that, on all previous occasions when the convict was released
on interim bail pursuant to directions issued by this Hon'ble Court, there
was no incident whatsoever that could be termed as objectionable, and
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
the convict has not engaged in any criminal activity during such periods of
release.
4. Sri. C.K. Suresh Kumar, the learned Government Pleader, has
opposed the submissions. He would point out that the convict was
transferred to the Central Prison owing to his misbehaviour towards the
jail officers and for having in his possession prohibited substances. Minor
punishments were also imposed which included forfeiture of remission for
up to 15 days. It is further submitted that a favourable police report is a
condition precedent for the grant of parole. He would point out that the
convict has anger issues, and his release may lead to a conflict with his
siblings and, in all likelihood, a law and order situation.
5.
We have considered the submissions advanced and have
perused the records.
6.
There is no dispute that the convict has been undergoing life
imprisonment from 2015 onwards. He has been granted parole only for a
few days on three occasions.
7.
The appellant is the wife of the convict and her prayer in the
Writ Appeal was for releasing her husband on parole for a period of 30
days.
8.
Section 36 of the Kerala Prisons and Correctional Services
(Management) Act, 2010 speaks about the Rights of prisoners. It says
that subject to the provisions of any law for the time being in force and
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
conditions as may be prescribed, all prisoners shall have the right, (a) to
live with human dignity; (b) to be entitled for adequate diet, health and
medical care, hygienic living conditions and proper clothing; (c) of
communication which includes contacts with his family members and
other persons in such manner and subject to such condition, as may be
prescribed; (d) of access to due process of law, including legal service and
legal aid; (e) to protection against unlawful aggression on his person or
against imposition of ignominy in any manner not authorised by law; (f) to
protection against unreasonable discrimination; (g) to protection against
punishment or hardship amounting to punishment, except through
procedure established by law and with due opportunity of defence; (h) of
being informed of the amenities and privileges of prisoners admissible
under the law.
9.
Section 73 of the Act deals with the release on Parole. The
said provision reads as follows:
Section 73:
Release on Parole:
The State Government may, subject to such
conditions as may be prescribed, release on parole for such
period as it may deem necessary, any convicted prisoner in
case of any serious illness or death of any member of the
prisoner's family or of any of his nearest relatives or for any
other sufficient cause.
10.
Chapter XXX Rule 397 of the Kerala Prison and Correctional
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
Services (Management) Rule, 2014 provides for two types of parole. One
is ordinary parole, and the other one is extraordinary parole. The ordinary
paroles are provided for various reasons and in the manner as provided
under Rule 397. Rule 397(B) provides that in a calendar year, the convict
is entitled to 60 days of normal parole. It shall not be less than 15 days
and not more than 30 days at a time. Rule 400 deals with extraordinary
leave which may be granted in the three specific emergent situations
mentioned therein. Hence, extraordinary leave can be granted only for the
reason mentioned therein. A prisoner will be entitled to ordinary leave for
a period of 60 days in a calendar year. If the parole application is rejected,
an appeal is permissible under Rule 404 to the specified authorities.
11.
In the case on hand, the Probationary Officer has given a
favourable report, but his request has been denied on the basis of an
adverse police report. The police report only speaks about some dispute
between the convict and his siblings. There is no reason to disbelieve the
submission of the learned Senior Counsel, who based on documents,
which were handed over, submits that the convict has got the matter
referred to an Arbitration Tribunal and the said proceedings are pending.
An individual who has ventured to settle his disputes with his siblings by
recourse to legal remedies need not take law into his own hands to gain
an advantage.
12.
We also note that the Probationary Officer, after getting
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
inputs from all concerned has given a favourable report. The report of the
Probationary Officer has to be given due weight as it is an independent
and professional assessment of the facts and circumstances.
13.
In the case on hand, the request for parole for 30 days was
rejected solely on the ground of an adverse report submitted by the
police. The said report, which has been placed before us, merely states
that if the convict is released on parole, there is a likelihood of a law and
order situation arising due to an ongoing dispute between the convict and
his siblings. On one hand, we have a convict who has already undergone
ten years of incarceration and who, by virtue of the provisions of the
Kerala Prisons and Correctional Services (Management) Act, is entitled to
be considered for parole. On the other hand, his siblings—who are at
liberty and enjoying all the freedoms guaranteed to citizens—are shown as
the persons who may be at the receiving end if parole is granted, even if
it is for a short duration. In our considered view, it is incumbent upon the
law enforcement authorities to take proactive steps to ensure that no such
law and order situation arises. The possibility of untoward incidents can be
effectively curtailed by strictly monitoring the situation and keeping both
parties under observation during the parole period. Stringent and carefully
framed conditions can also be imposed to ensure that the convict does not
overstep legal or geographical boundaries or engage in any altercation
with his siblings. It is for the police to ensure that the convict’s release is
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
peaceful and uneventful. It must be remembered that a convict, literally
speaking, is to remain in prison for the entire period of his sentence or, in
the case of a life convict, for the rest of his natural life. It is in this solemn
context that parole must be seen as a temporary reprieve—an opportunity
not only to address personal or familial obligations but also to maintain
essential social ties. Even those undergoing imprisonment must be
allowed to breathe the air of freedom, albeit briefly, provided they have
exhibited
consistently
good
conduct
during
incarceration
and
demonstrated a genuine inclination towards reformation and reintegration.
We find that after the convict was transferred to the Viyyur prison on
15.09.2023, no disciplinary action was initiated against him. The broader
objectives of rehabilitation and redemption must be afforded due
significance, for the ultimate goal of punishment is not mere retribution
but the transformation of individuals into law-abiding members of society.
14.
In Babulal Das v. State of West Bengal1, the Apex Court
had held that the Courts in India have generally favoured the view that
prisoners who have been incarcerated or kept in prison without trial for a
long time, should be released on parole to maintain unity of family. The
Apex Court went on to observe that calculated risks by release for short
periods may, perhaps, be a social gain, the beneficial jurisdiction being
wisely exercised.
[(1975) 1 SCC 311]
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
15.
In Asfaq v. State Of Rajasthan And Others2, the Apex
Court while highlighting the distinction between parole and furlough
observed as under:
15. A convict, literally speaking, must remain in jail for
the period of sentence or for rest of his life in case he is a life
convict. It is in this context that his release from jail for a short
period has to be considered as an opportunity afforded to him
not only to solve his personal and family problems but also to
maintain his links with society. Convicts too must breathe fresh
air for at least some time provided they maintain good conduct
consistently during incarceration and show a tendency to
reform
themselves
and
become
good
citizens.
Thus,
redemption and rehabilitation of such prisoners for good of
societies
must
receive
due
weightage
while
they are
undergoing sentence of imprisonment.
16.
In the aforesaid circumstances, we are unable to uphold the
findings of the learned Single Judge in declining to exercise jurisdiction in
the matter. When the relevant enactments confer upon the authority to
grant parole on the ground of “sufficient cause,” the adequacy and
sufficiency of the reasons cited for either granting or refusing parole
become amenable to judicial review in a writ proceeding. The Court is well
within its jurisdiction to examine whether the order of rejection is founded
on valid, relevant, and legally sustainable grounds, or whether it is vitiated
[ AIR 2017 SC 4986],
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
by consideration of extraneous, irrelevant, or mala fide reasons.
Accordingly, in an appropriate case where an application for parole made
under the provisions of the Act or the Rules framed thereunder is rejected
on grounds that are manifestly extraneous or irrelevant, the High Court, in
the exercise of its extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution, is empowered to interfere and issue appropriate directions.
Such intervention, however, is warranted only in cases where the
impugned
decision
is
demonstrably
arbitrary,
unreasonable,
or
unsupported by material evidence.
In view of the discussion above, the judgment passed by the
learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No. 707 of 2019 is set aside. This Writ
Appeal will stand allowed. There will be a direction to the competent
among respondents to pass orders granting parole to Sri. Mohammed
Nisham, the husband of the appellant, for a period of 15 days on such
conditions that the authority may deem fit and proper.
sd/RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V.
JUDGE
sd/P.V.BALAKRISHNAN
JUDGE
PS/3/4/2025
Writ Appeal No.553/2025
APPENDIX OF WA 553/2025
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1
A TRUE COPY OF THE CLAIM STATEMENT FILED
BEFORE THE ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL IN AR 175/2020
DATED 09.12.2024
Annexure A2
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE SOLE
ARBITRATOR IN AR 175/2023 DATED 11.06.2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review