Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 17th APRIL, 2023
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Appellants
:
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
versus
Respondents
:
Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Ms. Pritima Sunam, Ms. Tashi Doma Sherpa and Ms. Pema Dechen
Bhutia, Advocates for the Appellants.
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Rachhitta Rai,
Advocate for Respondent No.1.
Mr. Sunil Baraily, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) for Respondent
No.2.
None appears for Respondent No.3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, West Sikkim, at
1.
Gyalshing (for short, “Learned Claims Tribunal”), settled three
issues for determination in MACT Case No.06 of 2019 (Smt. Aita
Maya Gurung and Others vs. Shri Ratna Kumar Pradhan and
Others), in a Claim Petition filed by the Appellants, seeking
compensation of Rs.29,34,800/- (Rupees twenty nine lakhs, thirty
four thousand and eighty) only, on account of the death of Ratna
Man Gurung, husband of Appellants No.1 and 2 and father of
Appellants No.3 and 4;
The issues settled for determination were;
(i)
Whether the deceased was earning a monthly salary of
Rs.23,975/- at the time of the accident and whether the
claimants are entitled to the compensation as claimed in the
petition (Onus on claimants).
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
(ii)
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
Whether the documents of the vehicle as well as the driver
were valid and effective at the time of accident (Onus on
claimants and opposite parties).
(iii)
Whether the claimants are entitled to relief(s).
While deciding issue no.1, the Learned Claims Tribunal
2.
concluded that the deceased was earning Rs.23,975/- (Rupees
twenty three thousand, nine hundred and seventy five) only, at the
time of accident. However, with regard to the second part of the
issue,
as
to
whether
the
Claimants
are
entitled
to
the
compensation claimed, it was observed that the matter being
similar to issue no.3, would be dealt along with that issue.
(i)
Issue no.2 was decided in favour of the Claimants.
While deciding issue no.3, the Learned Claims Tribunal opined that
the claim petition was filed belatedly on 30-08-2019 under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter, “M. V. Act,
1988”), read with Rule 247 of the Sikkim Motor Vehicles Rules,
1991, when the accident had occurred on 17-09-2010, with no
explanation furnished by the Claimants for the delay. It was further
observed that the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019, came
into force with effect from 09-08-2019, vide which sub-section (3)
was inserted in Section 166 of the M. V. Act, 1988, which lays
down that no application for compensation shall be entertained,
unless it is made within six months of the occurrence of the
accident. That, the claim petition was filed “6 years 9 months and
7 days” after the accident and the petition being thus barred by
limitation, was consequently dismissed and the Claimants denied
compensation.
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
3.
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
Learned Counsel for the Appellants-Claimants assails
only this finding of the Learned Claims Tribunal, on grounds that
the accident took place on 17-09-2010, whereas the amendment
was inserted on 09-08-2019 and vide the Notification dated 25-022022 of the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, the 1st day
of April, 2022, was the appointed date by the Central Government
on which the amendment, viz., Section 166(3) of the M. V. Act,
1988, would come into force.
That, as the amendment was not
enforced on the date of accident or for that matter even on the
date of Judgment, the findings of the Learned Claims Tribunal on
the issue of limitation is erroneous and hence, be set aside.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 and 2 had
no objection to the arguments advanced and conceded that the
amendment to Section 166 of the M. V. Act, 1988, by insertion of
sub-section (3) came into force only on 01-04-2022.
5.
Respondent No.3 herein, who was the Opposite Party
No.3 (Insurance Company), before the Learned Claims Tribunal
was proceeded ex parte vide Order dated 25-03-2022 on their nonappearance before the Learned Claims Tribunal. The said Order
thus obtained finality as it was not assailed at any point of time.
The Respondent No.3 chose to remain absent before this Court
also, despite due service of notice and was proceeded ex parte.
6.
The submissions of Learned Counsel for the parties
have been given due consideration. All documents on record, the
evidence and the impugned judgment have been carefully perused.
7.
The only question for consideration before this Court is;
Whether the Learned Claims Tribunal was correct in concluding
that the claim petition was barred by limitation in view of the
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
amendment to Section 166 of the M. V. Act, 1988, by insertion of
sub-Section (3). This provision is extracted hereinbelow for easy
reference;
“166. Application for compensation.—(1) ………
(2)
…………………………………..
(3)
No application for compensation shall be
entertained unless it is made within six months of the
occurrence of the accident.
(4)
……………………………………
(5)
………………………………….”
The amendment was inserted by an Act 32 of 2019,
8.
Section 53(iii) [w.e.f. 1-9-2019, vide S.O. 3147(E), dated 30th
August, 2019]. Earlier, sub-section (3) to Section 166 of the M. V.
Act, 1988, was omitted by Act 53 of 1994, Section 53 (w.e.f. 1411-1994).
9.
Notification dated 25-02-2022 of the Ministry of Road
Transport and Highways, provides as follows;
“………………………………………………
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 25th February, 2022
S.O. 895(E).—In exercise of the powers
conferred by sub-section (2) of section 1 of the Motor
Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019 (32 of 2019), the
Central Government hereby appoints the 1st day of
April, 2022 as the date on which the following
provisions of the said Act shall come into force,
namely:—
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Sections
Section 50;
Section 51;
Section 52;
Section 53;
Section 54;
Section 55;
Section 56;
Section 57; and
Section 93;
………………………………………”
[emphasis supplied]
Hence, the amendment in Section 166 by insertion of subsection (3) was to come into effect only from 01-04-2022, which
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
was the appointed day, in terms of the Notification of the relevant
Ministry (supra), dated 25-02-2022.
The Chhattisgarh High Court in Mukesh Patle vs.
10.
Shailendra Verma and Others
held on 20-01-2021 that although the
legislature had proposed the amendment in Section 166 of the M.
V. Act, 1988, however Section 53 was yet to be enforced.
It may relevantly be stated here that in Assistant Excise
11.
Commissioner,
Another
Kottayam
and
Others
vs. Esthappan Cherian and
the Supreme Court was considering the amendment of
Rule 13 of the Kerala Abkari Shops Departmental Management
Rules, 1972.
It was held therein that an amendment is
prospective. The relevant Paragraph is extracted hereinbelow;
“16. There is profusion of judicial authority on the
proposition that a rule or law cannot be construed as
retrospective unless it expresses a clear or manifest
intention, to the contrary. In CIT v. Vatika Township
(P) Ltd. [CIT v. Vatika Township (P) Ltd., (2015) 1 SCC 1] this
Court, speaking through a Constitution Bench,
observed as follows : (SCC pp. 21-22, paras 28-29)
“28. Of the various rules guiding how a
legislation has to be interpreted, one established
rule is that unless a contrary intention appears, a
legislation is presumed not to be intended to have
a retrospective operation. The idea behind the
rule is that a current law should govern current
activities. Law passed today cannot apply to the
events of the past. If we do something today, we
do it keeping in view the law of today and in force
and not tomorrow's backward adjustment of it.
Our belief in the nature of the law is founded on
the bedrock that every human being is entitled to
arrange his affairs by relying on the existing law
and should not find that his plans have been
retrospectively upset. This principle of law is
known as lex prospicit non respicit : law looks
forward not backward. As was observed
in Phillips v. Eyre [Phillips v. Eyre, (1870) LR 6 QB 1], a
retrospective legislation is contrary to the general
principle that legislation by which the conduct of
mankind is to be regulated when introduced for
the first time to deal with future acts ought not to
change the character of past transactions carried
on upon the faith of the then existing law.
2021 SCC OnLine Chh 466
(2021) 10 SCC 210
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
29. The obvious basis of the principle
against retrospectivity is the principle of “fairness”,
which must be the basis of every legal rule as was
observed in L'Office Cherifien des Phosphates
v. Yamashita-Shinnihon Steamship Co. Ltd. [L'Office
Cherifien des Phosphates v. Yamashita-Shinnihon Steamship Co. Ltd.,
(1994) 1 AC 486 : (1994) 2 WLR 39 (HL)] Thus, legislations
which modified accrued rights or which impose
obligations or impose new duties or attach a new
disability have to be treated as prospective unless
the legislative intent is clearly to give the
enactment a retrospective effect; unless the
legislation is for purpose of supplying an obvious
omission in a former legislation or to explain a
former legislation. We need not note the
cornucopia of case law available on the subject
because aforesaid legal position clearly emerges
from the various decisions and this legal position
was conceded by the counsel for the parties. In
any case, we shall refer to few judgments
containing this dicta, a little later.” [emphasis supplied]
12.
Considering the legal position as held in Assistant Excise
Commissioner, Kottayam
(supra) and the actual position in the
instant Appeal viz; that the accident occurred on 17-09-2010 when
the amendment by insertion of sub-section (3) to Section 166 of
the M. V. Act, 1988, was yet to be effectual, I am of the considered
opinion that the Learned Claims Tribunal made an erroneous
interpretation of Section 166(3) of the M. V. Act, 1988, under an
incorrect belief that the amendment had been enforced on 19-082019.
Consequently, the finding in issue no.3 of the impugned
Judgment deserves to be and is accordingly set aside.
13.
Considering that the accident occurred on 17-09-2010
and that the findings of the Learned Claims Tribunal on the first
part of issue no.1 and the finding in issue no.2 are unassailed, as
considerable time has elapsed from the time of accident, for the
ends of justice, “just compensation” as postulated in Section 168 of
the M. V. Act, 1988, is being computed by this Court. Relevantly,
it is noticed that there is no contest put forth by any party with
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
regard to the age of the deceased said to be „53‟, as per the claim
petition and hence obtains finality.
Appositely, it may be mentioned that while considering
(i)
addition of amount to the actual income of the victim by way of
future prospects, in Sarla Verma (Smt) and Others vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation and Another
the Supreme Court held as follows;
“24. In Susamma Thomas [(1994) 2 SCC 176 :
1994 SCC (Cri) 335] this Court increased the income by
nearly 100%, in Sarla Dixit [(1996) 3 SCC 179] the
income was increased only by 50% and in Abati
Bezbaruah [(2003) 3 SCC 148 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 746] the
income was increased by a mere 7%. In view of the
imponderables and uncertainties, we are in favour of
adopting as a rule of thumb, an addition of 50% of
actual salary to the actual salary income of the
deceased towards future prospects, where the
deceased had a permanent job and was below 40
years. (Where the annual income is in the taxable
range, the words “actual salary” should be read as
“actual salary less tax”). The addition should be only
30% if the age of the deceased was 40 to 50 years.
There should be no addition, where the age of the
deceased is more than 50 years. Though the evidence
may indicate a different percentage of increase, it is
necessary to standardise the addition to avoid
different yardsticks being applied or different methods
of calculation being adopted. Where the deceased was
self-employed or was on a fixed salary (without
provision for annual increments, etc.), the courts will
usually take only the actual income at the time of
death. A departure therefrom should be made only in
rare and exceptional cases involving special
circumstances.”
[emphasis supplied]
The Supreme Court thus held that there would be no addition
towards future prospects where the age of the deceased is more
than 50 years of age.
This was upheld in the ratio of Reshma
Kumari and Others vs. Madan Mohan and Another .
(ii)
Limited
However, subsequently, in National Insurance Company
vs. Pranay Sethi and Others5 the Supreme Court held as
extracted hereinbelow;
“58. The controversy does not end here. The
question still remains whether there should be no
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2013) 9 SCC 65
(2017) 16 SCC 680
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
addition where the age of the deceased is more than
50 years. Sarla Verma [Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC
121 : (2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 770 : (2009) 2 SCC (Cri) 1002] thinks
it appropriate not to add any amount and the same
has been approved in Reshma Kumari [Reshma
Kumari v. Madan Mohan, (2013) 9 SCC 65 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ)
191 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 826]. Judicial notice can be taken
of the fact that salary does not remain the same.
When a person is in a permanent job, there is always
an enhancement due to one reason or the other. To
lay down as a thumb rule that there will be no
addition after 50 years will be an unacceptable
concept. We are disposed to think, there should be
an addition of 15% if the deceased is between the
age of 50 to 60 years and there should be no addition
thereafter. Similarly, in case of self-employed or
person on fixed salary, the addition should be 10%
between the age of 50 to 60 years. The aforesaid
yardstick has been fixed so that there can be
consistency in the approach by the tribunals and the
courts.”
[emphasis supplied]
On the anvil of the decision, in Pranay Sethi (supra)
considering the age of the victim (53), it is essential to add 15%
towards Future Prospects in the award to be computed.
14.
Further, the Supreme Court while allowing payment of
compensation to major, married and earning sons of the deceased,
in National Insurance Company Limited vs. Birender and Others6, held
as follows;
“14. It is thus settled by now that the legal
representatives of the deceased have right to apply
for compensation. Having said that, it must
necessarily follow that even the major married and
earning
sons
of
the
deceased
being
legal
representatives
have
a
right
to
apply
for
compensation and it would be the bounden duty of
the Tribunal to consider the application irrespective
of the fact whether the legal representative
concerned was fully dependent on the deceased and
not to limit the claim towards conventional heads
only. The evidence on record in the present case
would suggest that the claimants were working as
agricultural labourers on contract basis and were
earning meagre income between Rs 1,00,000 and Rs
1,50,000 per annum.
In that sense, they were
largely dependent on the earning of their mother and
in fact, were staying with her, who met with an
accident at the young age of 48 years.”
[emphasis supplied]
(2020) 11 SCC 356
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
Consequently, I am of the considered opinion that the
15.
following compensation will serve as “just compensation” which
stands calculated as follows;
Annual income of the deceased
Rs. 2,87,700.00
(Rs.23,975/- x 12)
Add 15% of Rs.2,87,700/- as Future Prospects
(+)
Rs. 43,155.00
Rs. 3,30,855.00
Less 1/4th of Rs.3,30,855/-
(-)
Rs.
82,714.00 (rounded off)
[Deducted from the said amount as expenses
that the deceased would have incurred towards
himself had he been alive]
Net yearly income
Multiplier to be adopted „11‟
Rs. 2,48,141.00
Rs.27,29,551.00
(Rs.2,48,141/- x 11)
[The age of the deceased at the time of death was
„53‟ and the relevant multiplier as per Judgment of
of Sarla Verma (supra) is „11‟]
Add Funeral Expenses
(+)
Rs.
15,000.00
(+)
Rs.
15,000.00
(+)
Rs.
80,000.00
(+)
Rs.
80,000.00
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra)]
Add Loss of Estate
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra)]
Add Loss of Spousal Consortium
(Rs.40,000/- x 2)
[@ two wives of the deceased, in terms of the
Judgment of Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Nanu Ram and Others : (2018) 18 SCC 130 ]
Add Loss of Parental Consortium
(Rs.40,000/- x 2)
[@ two sons of the deceased, in terms of the
Judgment of Magma General Insurance (supra)]
Total
=
Rs.29,19,551.00
(Rupees twenty-nine lakhs, nineteen thousand, five hundred and fifty one) only.
The Insurance Company shall pay the compensation
16.
computed supra to the Appellants No.1, 2, 3 and 4 in the following
manner;
(i)
35%, each, of the awarded amount to be paid to the
Appellants No.1 and 2 being widows of the deceased;
(ii)
15%, each, of the awarded amount to be paid to the
Appellants No.3 and 4 being the sons of the deceased.
17.
The Claimants-Appellants shall be entitled to simple
interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount with effect from
the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the Learned Claims
Tribunal, i.e., 30-08-2019, until its full realisation.
MAC App. No.02 of 2022
Aita Maya Gurung and Others
18.
vs. Ratna Kumar Pradhan and Others
The Insurance Company is directed to pay the awarded
amount to the Claimants-Appellants within one month from today,
failing which it shall pay simple interest @ 12% per annum from
the date of filing of the Claim Petition, till full realisation. Amounts,
if any, already paid by the Insurance Company to the ClaimantsAppellants, shall be duly deducted from the awarded amount.
19.
Appeal disposed of accordingly.
20.
No order as to costs.
21.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Claims
Tribunal for information, along with its records.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
17-04-2023
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review