The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. The Director of Education (S), Govt. of Manipur, Lamphelpat, Imphal West, Manipur, Pin-795004.
3. The Principal Accountant General, Manipur. (…impleaded as respondent No. 3 as per order dated 02-08-2022 in MC(WP(C)) No. 202 of 2022) … Respondents HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH For the petitioner :: Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, Advocate For the respondent :: Mr. Th. Vashum, GA and Mr. S. Samarjeet, Sr. panel counsel. 21-08-2024 21-10-2024 :: Date of hearing Date of judgment & order :: JUDGMENT & ORDER [1] Heard Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner; Mr. Th. Vashum, learned GA appearing for the respondents No. 1 and 2 and Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned senior panel counsel appearing for the respondent No. 3. WP(C) No. 745 of 2019 Contd…/- [2] In the present writ petition, the petitioner is praying for issuing a direction to the respondents to allow the petitioner to enjoy pension and other pensionary benefits for the service rendered by him as Hindi Graduate Teacher in the Department of Education (S), Government of Manipur, along with interest at the rate 18% per annum. [2] There is no dispute with regard to the facts of the present case. The petitioner was initially appointed as Hindi Graduate Teacher on adhoc basis for a period of six months in the Department of Education (S), Government of Manipur. The period of adhoc service of the petitioner was extended by the Government from time to time by issuing various orders and the petitioner continued to…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
`IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Shri Ahanthem Kunjo Singh, aged about 67 years, S/o Late A.
Iboton Singh, resident of Ningthoukhong Awang Ward No. 14,
P.O., P.S. & District Bishnupur, Manipur, Pin – 795126.
... Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Manipur through the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner/ Secretary, Education (S), Govt. of Manipur,
Secretariat, Imphal, Manipur, Pin – 795001.
2. The Director of Education (S), Govt. of Manipur, Lamphelpat,
Imphal West, Manipur, Pin-795004.
3. The Principal Accountant General, Manipur.
(…impleaded as respondent No. 3 as per order
dated 02-08-2022 in MC(WP(C)) No. 202 of 2022)
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the petitioner
::
Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, Advocate
For the respondent
::
Mr. Th. Vashum, GA and Mr. S.
Samarjeet, Sr. panel counsel.
21-08-2024
21-10-2024
::
Date of hearing
Date of judgment & order ::
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. Sh. Athoi Singh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner; Mr. Th. Vashum, learned GA appearing for the respondents
No. 1 and 2 and Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned senior panel counsel
appearing for the respondent No. 3.
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[2]
In the present writ petition, the petitioner is praying for issuing
a direction to the respondents to allow the petitioner to enjoy pension
and other pensionary benefits for the service rendered by him as Hindi
Graduate Teacher in the Department of Education (S), Government of
Manipur, along with interest at the rate 18% per annum.
[2]
There is no dispute with regard to the facts of the present case.
The petitioner was initially appointed as Hindi Graduate Teacher on
adhoc basis for a period of six months in the Department of Education
(S), Government of Manipur. The period of adhoc service of the
petitioner was extended by the Government from time to time by issuing
various orders and the petitioner continued to render service as a Hindi
Graduate Teacher. While the petitioner was rendering service as a Hindi
Graduate Teacher on adhoc basis, the Government of Manipur
formulated a scheme for regularization of all the adhoc services of the
employees under the Manipur Government by issuing an Office
Memorandum dated 31-05-1986. In the said Office Memorandum, it is,
inter alia, provided that those adhoc employees who were appointed
upto 31-12-1984 and continued to work in their respective posts till the
issuance of the said Office Memorandum and who fulfilled the requisite
qualifications should be regularized w.e.f. 24-05-1986.
[3]
Pursuant to the issuance of the said Office Memorandum, the
then Director of Education (S), Government of Manipur, issued an order
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[3]
dated 30-08-1986 appointing the petitioner along with other persons
temporarily on regular basis to the posts of Hindi Graduate Teacher with
effect from 24-05-1986.
After rendering about 17 years of regular service as a Hindi
Graduate Teacher, the petitioner submitted an application dated
01-01-2004 to the Zonal Education Officer, Zone-IV, Bishnupur,
Government of Manipur, requesting to allow him to take voluntary
retirement from service w.e.f. 01-01-2004. After submitting the said
application for taking voluntary retirement, the petitioner came to know
that he has not completed 20 years of regular service for taking voluntary
retirement from service unless the period of adhoc service rendered by
him prior to his regular appointment is counted. Accordingly, the
petitioner submitted a representation dated 30-01-2004 to the Director
of Education (S), Government of Manipur, requesting to link up the
period of adhoc service rendered by him as regular service and the
request made by the petitioner was allowed by the Director of Education
(S) by issuing an order dated 02-03-2004 thereby regularizing the period
of adhoc service of the petitioner w.e.f. 26-10-1983 to 23-05-1986 for
pensionary and other service benefits.
[4]
After regularizing the period of adhoc service rendered by the
petitioner prior to his regular appointment, the Director of Education (S)
allowed the petitioner to retire voluntarily from service w.e.f. 01-04-2004
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[4]
by issuing an order dated 23-03-2004. Thereafter, the authorities of the
Government allowed the petitioner to withdraw a sum of Rs. 66,482/- as
unutilized Earned Leave salary, Rs. 9,828/- as Group Insurance and also
the General Provident Fund credited to the petitioner’s account.
When the proposal along with relevant documents for allowing
the petitioner to enjoy pension and other pensionary benefits were
furnished by the Government to the Office of the Accountant General
(A&E), Manipur, the Senior Accounts Officer/ Pension, Office of the
Accountant General (A&E), Manipur, wrote a letter dated 09-02-2005 to
the Special Secretary (DP), Government of Manipur, requesting to clarify
about the acceptability of regularisation of the adhoc service of the
petitioner. In response to the said letter, the Under Secretary (DP),
Government of Manipur, wrote a letter dated 29-12-2005 to the
Accountant General (A&E) stating that the Director of Education (S) is
not competent to regularize the adhoc service of the petitioner and that
the adhoc service of the petitioner from 26-10-1983 to 23-05-1986 does
not count towards qualifying service for pensionary benefits.
[5]
Having been aggrieved, the petitioner filed a writ petition being
WP(C) No. 296 of 2006 in the Guwahati High Court, Imphal Bench, with
a prayer to direct the respondents to release the pension and other
pensionary benefits of the petitioner. The said writ petition was disposed
of by a Judgement and Order dated 08-05-2006 by giving directions to
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[5]
the State respondents to take appropriate decision on the question or
query made by the Senior Accounts Officer/ Pension under his letter
dated 09-02-2005 within a period of two months from the date of receipt
of a certified copy of the said Judgment and Order and thereafter, to take
up prompt and expeditious steps for payment of retirement benefits, if
entitled to the petitioner.
[6]
On receiving a copy of the aforesaid Judgement and Order,
the Office of the Senior Deputy Accountant General (A&E), Manipur,
wrote a letter dated 15-06-2006 to the Joint Secretary (PC), Government
of Manipur, stating that as the Government has clarified that the Director
of Education (S) is not competent to regularize the adhoc service of the
petitioner and that as the adhoc service of the petitioner from 26-10-1983
to 23-05-1986 does not count towards qualifying service for pensionary
benefits, the length of qualifying service of the petitioner is less than 20
years and as such, allowing the petitioner to retire on voluntary grounds
under Rules 48-A of the Manipur Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1977
was not acceptable. Accordingly, the pension papers and related
documents along with Service Book of the petitioner were returned to
the Government.
[7]
On having knowledge about returning of his Service Book as
well as the papers relating to payment of his pension by the Office of the
Accountant General, Manipur, on ground of non-completion of 20
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[6]
years qualifying service, the petitioner submitted a representation dated
10-01-2007 to the Director of Education (S), Government of Manipur,
requesting for cancelling/ reviewing/ recalling the order dated
23-03-2004, by which the petitioner was allowed to retire from service
voluntarily, so that the petitioner can resume his duties as Hindi
Graduate Teacher till he attained the age of superannuation.
Instead
representation
of
considering
submitted
by
the
and
disposing
petitioner,
the
of
the
above
Commissioner
(Education/S), Government of Manipur, issued an order dated
30-03-2007 cancelling the order dated 02-03-2004 issued by the
Director of Education (S) allowing the regularization of adhoc service
of the petitioner w.e.f 26-10-2023 to 23-05-1986.
[8]
Consequent upon issuance of the aforesaid cancellation
order dated 30-03-2007, the petitioner submitted an application dated
18-04-2007 to the Commissioner/ Secretary, Education (S), Government
of Manipur, requesting for cancelling the order dated 23-03-2004 issued
by the Director of Education (S) allowing the petitioner to retire voluntarily
from service so as to enable the petitioner to continue his service as
Hindi Graduate Teacher till he attained the age of superannuation. In
connection with the said application submitted by the petitioner, the
Director of Education (S) wrote a letter dated 16-11-2007 to the
Secretary Education (S), Government of Manipur, suggesting for
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[7]
cancelling the irregular order dated 23-03-2004 allowing the petitioner to
retire voluntarily from service and to allow the petitioner to rejoin service
as Hindi Graduate Teacher. The Director also suggested that the period
of petitioner's absence from 01-04-2004 till the date of his joining his
service may be treated as being on EOL and the period of service
thereafter may be counted for considering his qualifying service.
[9]
When no action was forthcoming from the authorities of the
Government in connection with his request for cancelling the irregular
order allowing him to retire voluntarily from service, the petitioner again
submitted an application dated 14-05-2013 to the authorities of the
Government reiterating his earlier request and in connection with the
subsequent application, the Direction of Education (S) again wrote a
letter dated 10-06-2013 to the Deputy Secretary Education (S),
Government of Manipur, requesting to consider the request made by the
petitioner and to convey the decision of the Government on humanitarian
ground as the petitioner's date of retirement on superannuation falls in
the month of February, 2017.
Despite the repeated request made by the petitioner to cancel
his voluntary retirement order dated 23-03-2004 and to allow him to
continue to render his service as a Hindi Graduate Teacher and despite
the repeated recommendations made by the Director of Education (S) to
the Government of Manipur for cancelling the voluntary retirement order
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[8]
of the petitioner and to allow him to rejoin service as a Graduate Teacher,
the competent authorities of the Government refused to take up any
action for cancelling the aforesaid voluntary retirement order of the
petitioner dated 23-03-2004 and to allow the petitioner to rejoin his
service. In the meantime, the date of retirement of the petitioner on
attaining the age of superannuation has already lapsed after the end of
February, 2017 and as such, there is no possibility of allowing the
petitioner to rejoin his service at this point of time.
[10]
The stand taken by the respondents in their counter affidavit
is that the period of regular service rendered by the petitioner w.e.f.
24-05-1986 upto 23-03-2004, i.e., the date of order for voluntary
retirement issued by the Director of Education (S), Government of
Manipur, is less than 20 years and as such, the said voluntary retirement
order is contrary to the provisions of Rule 48-A of the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972. The further stand taken by the
respondents is that the Administrative Department consulted the
Department of Personnel two times with regard to the proposal for
cancellation of the voluntary retirement order of the petitioner and that
the Department of Personnel did not agree with such proposals on the
ground that there is no specific rules/O.M. which allow for revocation of
voluntary retirement order and the reinstatement of already retired
Government employee and that the Finance Department also agreed
with the views taken by the Department of Personnel and as such,
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[9]
the writ petitioner has no legal right to claim for payment of pensionary
benefits.
[11]
The admitted position of fact in the present case is that the
petitioner submitted an application dated 30-01-2004 to the Director of
Education (S), Government of Manipur, requesting for linking up the
period of his adhoc services w.e.f. 26-10-1983 to 23-05-1986 as regular
service so as to enable him to retire voluntarily from service on
completion of 20 years of service. Acting on the said application, the
Director of Education (S), Manipur, issued an order dated 02-03-2004
regularising the period of adhoc service rendered by the petitioner w.e.f.
26-10-1083 to 23-05-1986 so that the petitioner can take voluntary
retirement from service on completion of 20 years of regular service.
Thereafter, the Director of Education (S) issued another order dated
23-04-2004 allowing the petitioner to retire voluntarily from service
w.e.f. 01-04-2004. Subsequently, on an objection being raised by the
Office of the Accountant General, the Commissioner of Education (S),
Government of Manipur, issued an order dated 30-03-2007 cancelling
the order dated 02-03-2004 issued by the Director of Education (S)
allowing the regularisation of adhoc services of the petitioner thereby
rendering the period of regular service of the petitioner to less than
20 years.
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[10]
[12]
It is on record that even before the issuance of the aforesaid
cancellation order dated 30-03-2007, the petitioner requested the
authorities of the Government to recall/ review/ cancel his voluntary
retirement order so as to enable him to continue as Hindi Graduate
Teacher and even though the petitioner repeatedly requested the
Government to cancel his voluntary retirement order, the authorities of
the Government refused to cancel the petitioner’s voluntary retirement
order only on the ground that there is no specific rule/ O.M. which
allows for revocation of voluntary retirement order and reinstatement of
an already retired Government employee, that too, despite having
knowledge that the petitioner’s voluntary retirement order was contrary
to the provisions of Rules 48-A of the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1972.
[13]
Under Rule 48-A(1) of the CCS(Pension) Rules, it is, inter alia,
provided that at any time after the Government servant has completed
20 years’ qualifying service, he may, by giving notice of not less than
three months in writing to the appointing authority, retire from service. In
the present case, at the time of taking the decision for issuing the order
for cancelling the regularization order issued by the Director of Education
(S), the Commissioner of Education (S) had already knowledge about
the fact that after issuing the said cancellation order, the length of service
rendered by the petitioner on regular basis will be less than 20 years and
as such, the voluntary retirement order of the petitioner issued by the
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[11]
Director of Education (S) cannot be sustained as the same is contrary to
the provisions of Rule 48-A of the CCS (Pension) Rules. Despite having
such knowledge and despite the repeated request made by the petitioner
and the recommendations made by the Director of Education (S) for
cancelling the petitioner’s voluntary retirement order so as to enable
the petitioner to continue in service till he attained the age of
superannuation, the Commissioner/ Secretary of Education (S) quite
surprisingly refused to cancel the said voluntary retirement order. In my
considered view, such action of the authorities is a classic example of
callousness and total non-application of mind.
[14]
Since the Government has refused to revoke or cancel the
voluntary retirement order of the petitioner, it shall be deemed that the
Government has allowed the petitioner to retire from service voluntarily
and the petitioner cannot be deprived or denied from receiving his
pensionary benefits especially when the petitioner has rendered more
than seventeen years regular service.
In view of the above factual position, this court did not find any
reason for refusing to grant the relief claimed by the petitioner in the
present petition. Accordingly, the respondents are directed to complete
the process for payment of petitioner’s pensionary benefits and to pay
the same to the petitioner as early as possible. It is made clear that the
whole process including the payment of pensionary benefits to the
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
[12]
petitioner should be completed within a period of three months from
today. In the event of failure to comply with the directions given by this
court within the stipulated period, the total amount of pension due
payable to the petitioner shall carry an interest @ 12 per cent per annum
from the date the said pension was due payable to the petitioner till the
actual date of payment.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is
disposed of. Parties are to bear their own cost.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
WP(C) No. 745 of 2019
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review