Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 9th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 937 of 2020
BETWEEN:AGRAWAL MOTORS PROPRIETOR KANKARD PVT. LTD
DIRECTOR NEERAJ AGRAWAL S/O NARESH CHANDRA
AGRAWAL THROUGH AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE
VIKRAM SINGH S/O R.L. SINGH SANDARSAN
BUILDING, PANNA NAKA, SATNA, TEHSIL RAGHURAJ
NAGAR, DISTRICT SATNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(MS.DEEPIKA RATHI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT)
AND
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
1.
SMT. MUNNI BAI W/O LATE NANURAM, AGED
ABOUT 46 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE
SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR VIKAS NAGAR,
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
MANISH S/O LATE NANURAM CHAUHAN, AGED
ABOUT 29 YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR R/O:
SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR VIKAS NAGAR
DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
JAGDISH S/O LATE NANURAM CHAUHAN, AGED
ABOUT 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR R/O:
SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR VIKAS NAGAR
DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
MEENA W/O RAJESH SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 28
YEARS, R/O: 29, KSHTRAPATI NAGAR , INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
ANURADHA D/O LATE NANURAM CHAUHAN,
AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NOTHING
R/O: SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR VIKAS NAGAR
DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
HEERA BAI W/O LATE RAMESHCHANDRA, AGED
ABOUT 57 YEARS, R/O: SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR
VIKAS NAGAR
PRADESH)
DISTRICT DEWAS
(MADHYA
7.
MANOHAR S/O KISHANLAL MALVIYA, AGED
ABOUT 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION: DRIVER R/O:
MENDAKI DHAKAD , PS BNP, HOUSE NO. 69 , GALI
NO. 1 DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
8.
NATIONAL
INSURANCE
COMPANY
LTD.
ADDRESS- 7, STATION ROAD, AADARSH NAGAR,
ITAWA DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI NAVNEET KISHORE VERMA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENTS NO.1 TO 5)
(SHRI SUDHIR DANDWATE, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENT NO.8)
MISC. APPEAL No. 267 of 2020
BETWEEN:-
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
1.
SMT MUNNIA BAI W/O LATE NANURAM, AGED
ABOUT 46 YEARS, SHANKAR NAGAR NEAR VIKAS
NAGAR DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
MANISH S/O LATE NANURAM CHAUHAN, AGED
ABOUT 29 YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR R/O: 29,
KSHTRAPATI
NAGAR,
INDORE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
3.
JAGDISH S/O LATE NANURAM CHAUHAN, AGED
ABOUT 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR R/O: 29,
KSHTRAPATI NAGAR , INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
4.
MEENA W/O RAJESH SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 28
YEARS, R/O: 29, KSHTRAPATI NAGAR , INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
ANURADHA D/O LATE NANURAM CHAUHAN,
AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NOTHING
R/O: SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR VIKAS NAGAR
DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
HEERA BAI W/O LATE RAMESHCHANDRA, AGED
ABOUT 57 YEARS, R/O: SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR
VIKAS NAGAR DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(SHRI NAVNEET KISHORE VERMA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
APPELLANTS)
AND
1.
MANOHAR S/O KISHANLAL MALVIYA, AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION: DRIVER
MENDAKI DHAKAD PS BNP HOUSE NO. 69 GALI
NO. 1 DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
AGRAWAL MOTORS, PROPRIETOR KANKARD
PRIVATE LIMITED, DIRECTED NEERAJ S/O
NARESHCHANDRA AGRAWAL, AGED ABOUT 36
YEA R S , R/O: SANDARSAN BUILDING PANNA
NAKA , SATNA, TEHSIL RAGHURAJ NAGAR,
DISTRICT SATNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
NATIONAL
INSURANCE
COMPANY
LTD.
ADDRESS- 7, STATION ROAD, AADARSH NAGAR,
ITAWA DISTRICT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MS. DEEPIKA RATHI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT
NO.2).
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR SHARMA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENT NO.3)
T h is appeal coming on for orders this day, t h e cou rt passed the
following:
ORDER
As both these appeal arise out of the same award, these are being
decided by common order.
2. M.A.No.937/2020 has been filed by the owner of the offending vehicle
on account of exonerating him from the liability to pay compensation amount
and M.A.No.267/2020 has been filed by the claimants on account of
inadequacy of compensation and seeking enhancement the amount of
compensation.
3.
Both these appeals are filed under Section 173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 arising out of the award dated 07.11.2019 passed by
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
MACT, Dewas in claim case No. 214/2018.
4.
The date of accident, negligence is not in dispute, however, the
findings recorded by the Claims Tribunal in this regard are not in question.
5.
The owner of the offending vehicle filed M.A.No.937/2020 on the
ground that the Tribunal did not consider the fact that at the time of accident
deceased was sitting in the capacity of co-driver because trailer had to go to
distant place so there is need of another driver also, therefore deceased was
sitting in the capacity of driver. It is further submitted that Tribunal erred in
considering the fact that deceased should not be considered as gratuitous
passenger as the deceased was not sitting in the vehicle by hiring it or in the
form of passenger whereas he was sitting in the capacity of driver.
6.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the Insurance Company
supported the impugned award and contended that Claims Tribunal has rightly
found that deceased was sitting as gratuitous passenger on the offending vehicle
so Tribunal has rightly exonerated the Insurance Company.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant has relied on the judgment in the
case of Manuara Khatun and others Vs. Rajesh Kumar Singh and others
decided on 21.02.2017 in Civil Appeal No.3047 of 2017 and stated that
even though deceased was gratuitous passenger, the Apex Court directed the
Insurance Company to pay the claimants and then recover from owner and
driver. He also relied on the judgment in the case of New India Assurance
Co.Ltd Vs. Thiru Murugan decided on 05.01.2017 in C.M.A.No.3661 of
2013 of Madras High Court in which the Court held that passenger travelling in
the vehicle is also third party. The Madras High Court relied on the decision of
the Full Bench of this Court in the case of Jugal Kishore and another Vs.
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
Ramlesh Devi and others reported in 2004 ACJ 297. In the case of Bhav
Singh Vs. Smt. Savirani and others reported in 2008 ACJ 1043 it is held
that mere fact that a passenger is a third party would not fasten liability on the
issuer unless such liability arises out under Section 147 of the Act or under the
terms and conditions of insurance policy.
8. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the
record of the Claims Tribunal it is found that appellant was unable to prove that
deceased was second driver of the offending vehicle. Considering the evidence
of the Insurance Company it reveals that Insurance Policy Ex.D-1 is a transit
risk policy for the period from 29.08.2017 till completion of the travel. No
premium was received for passenger, cleaner or labour. As per the appellant’s
own case and as per the evidence of eye witness Arjun Singh and as per the
police papers, it is crystal clear that at the time of accident deceased Nanuram
was sitting at the mudguard of chasis, which means that he was travelling in
it.He was not employed as a driver; therefore,the Tribunal has rightly assessed
that he was travelling as a gratuitous passenger in the offending trailer. He was
not third party. The deceased was neither second driver nor was third party
therefore he was travelling in the offending vehicle by sitting on the mudguard of
trailer. It can be said that he was travelling on the chasis which was goods trailer
as a gratuitous passenger. So the Claims Tribunal rightly held that he was
gratuitous passenger at the time of accident and plying in violation of the
insurance policy condition, therefore, the Tribunal rightly exonerated the
Insurance Company.
9.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the Tribunal has rightly
exonerated the Insurance Company. Hence, this Court does not call for any
interference in the impugned award of the Tribunal. Hence, M.A.No.937/2020
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
stands dismissed.
10. The appellants/claimants have filed M.A.No.267/2020 on account of
inadequacy of compensation and seeking enhancement of the compensation
amount.
11.
As per the finding of the Tribunal, on account of death of Nanuram
compensation has been allowed accepting his earning as Rs.6,000/- per month
with total compensation of Rs.6,50,800/- with 6% interest.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants submits that
compensation as awarded by the Tribunal accepting earning of Rs.6,000/- per
month is inadequate, looking to the fact that he was working as truck driver
accepting earning as Rs.18,000/- per month and adding future prospects
applying adequate multiplier, reasonable amount of compensation amount may
be allowed.
13.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent contended
that claims Tribunal has rightly awarded the compensation and argued in
support of the finding recorded by the Claims Tribunal.
14.
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of
the record, it is found that claimants have been unable to prove the pay
certificate Ex.P-14 before the Tribunal. only filed pay slip Ex.P-14, but it was
not duly proved by the person who issued it. The appellants were unable to
prove any back account of the deceased by which he received Rs.18,000/- per
month. In this regard, the Tribunal has not committed any error in rejecting the
pay slip of the deceased.
15.
The accident is of the year 2017 and in that year the driver of the
city of Dewas had earning of Rs.6,000/-. So, the Tribunal has rightly held the
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
income of the deceased as Rs.6,000/-. In this regard, the finding of the Tribunal
is upheld by this Court.
16. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the date of birth of
the deceased is 09.09.1968 and date of accident is 02.09.2017 and according to
this, age of the deceased at the time of accident is 49 years. The Tribunal has
committed error in considering the age of the deceased at the time of accident
as between 51-55 years.
17. On perusal of the record of the Tribunal it is found that according to
Ex.P-15, driving licence of the deceased, the date of birth of deceased is
09.09.1968 and accident took place on 02.09.2017. So according to this age of
the deceased was 49 years at the time of accident. So the Tribunal has
committed error in holding the age of the deceased between 51-55 years.
Hence, in the considered opinion of this Court, the age of the deceased at the
time of accident was 49 years.
18.
In the case of National Insurance Company Limited
Vs.
Pranay Sethi and others, (2017) 16 SCC 680 the Apex Court held that when
the age of the deceased is between 46-50 years, then multiplier is 13.
19.
Learned counsel for the appellants also submitted that the Tribunal
has committed error in adding 10% with regard to future prospects. In the case
of Pranay Sethi (Supra), where deceased was self-employed or on a fixed
salary, an addition of 25% as future prospects, where the age of the deceased
was between 40-50 years. In this case, deceased was 49 years, hence, 25%
must be added towards future prospects in place of 10%. The Tribunal has
rightly deducted 1/3rd of the income for personal expenses because sons of
deceased are employed. So Tribunal has committed error in not giving
consortium to the sons, daughters and mother of the deceased. Appellant no.1
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
is wife of the deceased, appellants no.2 and 3 are sons of deceased, appellants
no.4and 5 are daughters of the deceased and appellant no.6 is the mother of the
deceased. So, they are entitled to get consortium under the head of spouse and
parental consortium. Hence, under the head of Consortium appellants are
entitled to get Rs,2,40,000/-.
20.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, considering the facts and
circumstances of the case, the compensation amount awarded by the Tribunal
is on the lower side which is enhanced as under:
Loss of dependency
Loss of Consortium
Loss of estate
Funeral expenses
Total Amount
21.
Rs.6,000/- Rs.2,400 (40% FP) =
Rs.8,400/- per month x 12 x 13=
Rs.13,10,400/Rs.2,40,000/Rs.15,000/Rs.15,000/Rs.15,80,400/-
Thus, the just and proper amount of compensation in the instant
case is Rs.15,80,400/- as against the award of the Tribunal of Rs.6,50,800/-.
Accordingly, the appellant is entitled to an additional sum of Rs.9,29,600/- over
and above the amount which has been awarded by the Tribunal.
22.
The appellant has valued the appeal only to the extent of
Rs.2,00,000/- and paid the Court fee accordingly, however, for the remaining
amount of Rs.7,29,600/- the Court fee shall be paid by the appellant within a
period of one month and thereafter the amount shall be released by the
Insurance Company on receiving the certificate. In case the certificate has not
been filed before the Insurance Company up to a period of three months, the
claimants shall not be entitled to receive the interest on the enhanced amount of
compensation.
23.
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
In the result, the appeal is partly allowed by enhancing the
compensation amount by a sum of Rs.9,29,600/-. The enhanced amount shall
bear interest at the same rate as awarded by the Tribunal. The other findings
recorded by the Tribunal shall remain intact.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
RJ
Signed by: REENA JOSEPH
Signing time: 18-01-2024
15:47:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review