Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:20907-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No.358 of 2026
----Afsar Jawed, S/o Md. Naseem Haider, Ticket No.96278,
Temporary Workman of Respondent No.3, M/s Tata Motors Ltd.,
Jamshedpur Plant, R/o-Q. No.-13, A-Road, Bari Nagar, P.O.Telco Works, P.S. Telco, Jamshedpur, East Singhbhum, Pin Code831004.
.......... Appellant.
-Versus1. The Secretary, Department of Labour, Employment and Training,
Government of Jharkhand, Nepal House, Ranchi, Jharkhand.
2. The Deputy Labour Commissioner, Sitaramdera, East Singhbhum,
Jharkhand.
3. Tata Motors Ltd., Jamshedpur, through its Managing Director,
Bombay House, 24 Homi Mody Street, Mumbai and having its
plant at Telco, Jamshedpur, East Singhbhum, Jharkhand.
.......... Respondents.
----CORAM :
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellant :
Mr. Akhilesh Shrivastava, Advocate
[Through V.C.]
Ms. Neha Priya, Advocate
For the Res. Nos.1 & 2: Mrs. Niharika Mazumdar, A.C. to A.G.
----Order No.03
Date: 15.07.2026
1.
Heard Mr Akhilesh Shrivastava for the appellant and Mrs Niharika
Mazumdar, learned A.C. to A.G. for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2.
2.
This appeal challenges the learned single Judge’s order dated 28th
August, 2024 dismissing the petitioner’s W.P.(L) No.2784 of
2024.
3.
In W.P.(L) No.2784 of 2024, the appellant had challenged the
Deputy Labour Commissioner’s order dated 30th September, 2023
because it had failed to grant the appellant relief of back wages
and other reliefs claimed by the appellant.
4.
Mr Shrivastava submitted that the Bombay High Court, in similar
facts, had granted relief to the workmen of the 3rd respondent,
i.e., Tata Motors Limited and the adjudication in such decision
2026:JHHC:20907-DB
would equally apply to the appellant’s case. He submitted that
there was no necessity for the appellant to approach the Labour
Court or to raise any industrial dispute with regard to his claims.
5.
Mr Shrivastava pointed out that the learned single Judge, in
paragraph no.6 of the impugned order, has quoted paragraph
no.10 of the order dated 15th June, 2023, disposing of appellant’s
earlier W.P.(L) No.1616 of 2023, and, based thereon, denied
relief to the appellant. He points out that there was nothing in
paragraph no.10 based upon which relief could have been denied
to the petitioner (appellant herein).
6.
Mr Shrivastava submitted that the appellant was employed on a
temporary basis with the 3rd respondent from 2007 to 2nd
November, 2022. He further submitted that, although the
appellant holds a law degree and obtained registration with the
Jharkhand State Bar Council on 10th November, 2012, the
appellant has not practised before any Court of Law, and the
Vakalatnamas were filed only after November, 2022, when the
appellant was not in the service of the 3rd respondent.
7.
We have considered the contentions of Mr Shrivastava; however,
we regret that we are unable to accept them.
8.
In the first place, we cannot accept the argument that the
appellant, after obtaining his law degree and registration with the
Jharkhand State Bar Council, being registration no.268 of 2012
effective from 10th November, 2012, has not actually practised in
the Courts and, therefore, should be held as a workman with the
3rd respondent during the overlapping period.
2026:JHHC:20907-DB
9.
The learned single Judge in paragraph no.8 has referred to the
Vakalatnamas signed by the appellant and filed in the Civil Court
at Jamshedpur with regard to specific case numbers. These are
factual findings and at least nothing is placed on record in this
appeal to contradict them. In any event, in a Letters Patent
Appeal against the dismissal of a writ petition, this Court would
be very slow in interfering with such findings of fact.
10.
Be that as it may, we refer to the appellant’s earlier W.P.(L)
No.1616 of 2023 in which the appellant had sought for a writ of
mandamus inter alia against Tata Motors Limited to treat the
appellant and other similarly situated workers in the category of
temporary workmen for being recognized as permanent workmen
and formally reinstate them from the respective dates of their
completion of 240 days and to pay them all back wages with
interest at the rate of 18% together with all consequential
benefits.
11.
Such relief was not granted by the learned single Judge of this
Court in the order dated 15th June, 2023 by which the writ petition
came to be disposed of. Paragraph nos. 15 and 16 of this order
dated 15th June, 2023 are relevant and, therefore, the same are
transcribed below for the convenience of reference: “15. This Court is of the considered view that the argument of
the petitioner that a mandamus can be issued upon the
respondent no.3 on the basis of the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Bombay High Court is not sustainable in the eyes of
law. The judgment passed by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court
was arising out of adjudication done by the concerned Labour
Court with regards to the establishments falling within the
jurisdiction of Hon’ble Bombay High Court and in the present
2026:JHHC:20907-DB
case there has been no adjudication with regard to the claim
of the petitioner which requires consideration /adjudication
upon nature and conditions of employment of the petitioner
and such issues cannot be straightaway decided under writ
jurisdiction and no such mandamus can be issued upon
respondent no.3 who is admittedly not a state within the
meaning of Article 226 of the Constitution of India. This Court
is of the considered view that the grievance of the petitioner
requires adjudication on facts and law and upon consideration
of the fact it is still to be seen as to the whether the
establishment of respondent No.3 in the State of Jharkhand, in
which, the petitioner claims to have been working is identically
placed as that of the establishment which were subject matter
of consideration before the Hon’ble Bombay High Court after
the factual scrutiny was done by the labour courts. In the
aforesaid circumstances, this court is not inclined to grant relief
to the petitioner as has been prayed for in this writ petition. It
further appears from the order passed in Special Leave
Petitions arising out of the aforesaid judgement passed by
Hon’ble Bombay High Court that certain questions of law was
kept open.
16. In view of the aforesaid findings, this Court is of the view
that the relief as sought for by the petitioner in this writ petition
is not maintainable. Consequently, no such relief can be
granted under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.”
12.
One of the contentions raised by the appellant was that a writ of
mandamus should be issued to the 3rd respondent, which, in fact,
does not even meet the definition of the State under Article 12 of
the Constitution of India, as laid down by the judgment of the
Bombay High Court. This contention, now pressed in this appeal,
was squarely raised and rejected by the learned single Judge in
her order dated 15th June, 2023, disposing of W.P.(L) No.1616 of
2023. This is evident from paragraph no.15, which we have
quoted above.
2026:JHHC:20907-DB
13.
Mr Shrivastava, however, points out that in paragraph no.17
directions were issued to the Deputy Labour Commissioner,
Sitaramdera, Sakchi, Jamshedpur to examine the appellant’s
grievance and dispose of the appellant’s petition by taking it to
its logical end and passing a reasoned order.
14.
Though such a direction was issued, that does not mean that any
of the contentions of the appellant were accepted by the learned
single Judge in her order dated 15th June, 2023. In fact, in
paragraph no.15 of the said order, the learned single Judge in no
uncertain terms opined that she was of the considered view that
the grievance of the appellant requires adjudication on facts and
law and upon consideration of the fact it is still to be seen as to
whether the establishment of the 3rd respondent in the State of
Jharkhand, in which the appellant claims to have been working is
identically placed as that of the establishment which was the
subject matter of consideration before the Bombay High Court
after the factual scrutiny was done by the Labour Courts.
15.
Since the appellant has virtually raised the same contention this
time in a different packaging, the learned single Judge rightly
rejected it vide the impugned order. We do not think that any
ground for interference is made out against the learned single
Judge’s order based on such a contention.
16.
The Deputy Labour Commissioner has limited jurisdiction, and on
perusing the order dated 30th September, 2023, we do not think
that the Deputy Labour Commissioner has either exceeded
jurisdiction or failed to exercise the jurisdiction that was vested
2026:JHHC:20907-DB
in him, given the provisions under which the appellant had
approached the Deputy Labour Commissioner.
17.
The learned single Judge has considered the matter from
different perspectives and has found that no case was made out
to interfere with the Deputy Labour Commissioner’s order. We do
not think that this conclusion or the reasoning by which it is
reached is vitiated by any actual or legal error warranting
interference in this appeal.
18.
Accordingly, we dismiss this appeal without any order for costs.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
15th July, 2026
Sanjay/Rohit
Uploaded on 17.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review