Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 991/2022
Aditi Chakraborty, wife of Sri Supriya Chakraborty, resident of ‘Mira
Villa’, Bhattapukur, PO-A.D. Nagar, PS-West Agartala, District-Dhalai
Tripura, aged about 52 years.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary, Education Department, Government of Tripura, having his
office at Secretariat Building, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, POKunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799006.
3.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, POKunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN799006.
4.
The Director of School Education, Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Shiksha Bhavan, Office
Lane, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, District-West Tripura.
…..Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
08.09.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has prayed
for granting her regular pay scale on completion of 5(five) years of service from
the initial date of her joining along with other consequential benefits. The
petitioner has also challenged the Memorandum dated 22.09.2022 issued by the
Director, Secondary Education, Tripura whereby and whereunder the petitioner
was denied of getting the benefit of regular pay scale since she did not posses
professional qualification i.e. B.Ed as per NCTE norms.
2.
Facts:
2.1.
In pursuance of an advertisement published on 14.07.2006, the
petitioner had undergone a selection process for the post of Post Graduate
Teachers(for short, PGT). The petitioner though was found to be eligible, she
was not considered for appointment. The petitioner under compelling
circumstances had filed a writ petition bearing no.WP(C) 320/2007 before the
High Court inter alia praying for directing the respondents to issue offer of
appointment in her favour. While disposing of the said writ petition, this Court
found the petitioner being discriminated and directed the respondents to appoint
the petitioner as PGT vide judgment and order dated 24.01.2017(Annexure 1 to
the writ petition).
2.2.
In pursuance of the said judgment and order, the Director,
Secondary Education issued offer of appointment in favour of the petitioner on
27.06.2017 and consequently, she joined her service on 05.09.2017.
2.3.
It is pertinent to mention herein that as per policy of the
Government, initial appointment of the petitioner was on fixed pay basis for
5(five) years. It is also the policy of the Government that after the expiry of
5(five) years such employees would get the benefit of regular pay scale
prescribed for the post he/she holds.
2.4.
The petitioner has completed fixed term of 5(five) years on
05.09.2022. She has prayed for granting her regular pay scale prescribed for the
post of PGT, but the respondent/Director, Secondary Education under Memo
dated 22.09.2022(Annexure 4 to the writ petition) had not acceded to her request
for granting regular pay scale on the ground that as per NCTE norms she must
acquire professional qualification i.e. B.Ed., which is mandatory for teachers, and
the petitioner was requested to acquire professional qualification within 3(three)
years from the date of issuance of the said Memorandum dated 22.09.2022. The
petitioner has challenged the said impugned Memorandum.
2.5.
The petitioner wanted to know through RTI application dated
10.01.2022 as to how her service conditions would be regulated. The reply given
by the Information Officer may be extracted hereunder in tabulated form:
Sl.
No.
ii)
iii)
iv)
Question
Reply/documents
Kindly
inform
the
rules,
regulations, criteria or pre
condition for regularization of
service of the Post Graduate
Teacher appointed under the
Recruitment Rules was in force in
the year 2007 and the Recruitment
Rules was in force in the year
2017.
As per Memo. No. F.20(3)-GA(P&T)/96
dated 15/12/2001 of the G.A (P&T)
Department Govt. of Tripura all GroupC & Group-D posts which are not
required to be filled by the selection
through the T.P.S.C may be on fixed pay
basis
&
Memo.
No.F.10(2)FIN(G)/05/Part-I dated 16/10/2007 of
the Finance Department, Govt. of
Tripura “such Fixed pay employees on
completion of 05(five) years of service
will be provided regular pay scale.”
As per Memo. No.F.20(3)-GA(P&T)/96
dated 15/12/2001 of the G.A (P&T)
Department Govt. of Tripura all GroupC & Group-D posts which are not
required to be filled by the selection
through the T.PS.C may be on fixed pay
basis
&
Memo.No.F.10(2)FIN(G)/05/Part-I dated 16/10/2007 of
the Finance Department, Govt. of
Tripura “such Fixed pay employees on
completion of 05 (five) years of service
will be provided regular pay scale.”
The appointment was made on the
Recruitment Rules No.F.25(1)-E/70(EC)
dated 26/01/1971 of this Department.
The terms and condition of appointment
(vide No.F.1(1-46)-SE-E(NG)/2017-556
dated 27/06.2017) are follows:1. The appointment is purely on
temporary basis for a period of
1(one) year and will not confer
any title to continuation for
further
period/permanent
appointment.
2. The
appointment
may
be
terminated at any time by a
month’s notice given by either
side, namely, the appointee or the
appointing authority, without
assigning any reason. The
appointing authority, however,
reserves the right to terminate the
services
of
the
appointee
forthwith or before the expiration
of the stipulated period of notice
by making payment of a sum
equivalent to the pay and
Kindly
inform
the
decision/criteria/condition setup
by
the
Directorate
for
regularization of service of Post
Graduate
Teacher
(Bengali)
appointed (vide No.F.1(1-46)SE/E(NG)/2017
dated
27.06.2017) in pursuance of the
order of the Hon’ble High Court
of Tripura in connection with the
case no. W.P(C)-320 of 2007
passed on 24.01.2017.
Kindly inform said appointment
(vide
No.F.1-(1-46)-SEE(NG)/2017-556
dated
27.06.2017) was made on the
basis of which recruitment rules
and which terms and condition,
rules and regulations, condition
shall
be
applicable
for
regularization of the service.
allowance for the period of notice
or the unexpired portion thereof.
3. The appointment carries the
liability with the appointee to
serve in any part of the State of
Tripura. The appointee should
not submit any representation for
change of place of posting within
a period of 5(five) years
4. Other conditions of service will
be governed by the relevant rules
and orders in force from time to
time.
5. The appointee shall have to
undergo any training, if required
by the Government. The services
of the appointee falling to
successful completion of the
training even in three chances
shall be liable to termination.
The condition for regularization of
service same as reply number III.
2.6.
The respondents have jointly submitted counter affidavit to the writ
petition stating inter alia that under NCTE Regulations dated 12.11.2014, and in
view of the Recruitment Rules framed by the Government of Tripura vide
Notification dated 05.09.2016, the petitioner must possess/acquire professional
qualification i.e. B.Ed. for having the benefit of regular pay scale.
3.
I have heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. M.
Debbarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the respondents-State.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner:
4.1.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has submitted that the plea of the
respondents that the petitioner must acquire professional qualification i.e. B.Ed.
for getting the benefit of regular pay scale is devoid of merit since the service
conditions of the petitioner would be regulated by the Recruitment Rules dated
26.01.1971 and neither under the NCTE Regulation, 2014 nor the Recruitment
Rules, 2016 framed by the Government of Tripura. Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel has further argued that the petitioner though was appointed in the year
2017 but that cannot be treated as base year for extending the benefit of regular
pay scale under the Recruitment Rules dated 05.09.2016 since the newly framed
rule cannot have retrospective effect to regulate the service condition of the
petitioner for the reason that she was supposed to be appointed in the year 2007
when other similarly situated persons were appointed discriminating the
petitioner forcing this court to interfere and to pass a direction upon the
respondents to appoint her in the post of PGT under the respondents. The next
argument of learned senior counsel is that the service conditions of the petitioner
would be governed by Recruitment Rules, 1971 where there was no stipulation
of having professional qualification i.e. B.Ed. Learned senior counsel has drawn
my attention to the RTI reply where it was categorically stated that “as per Memo
No.F.10(2)-FIN(G)/05/Part-I dated 16.10.2007 of the Finance Department of
Tripura” such fixed pay employees on completion of 5(five) years of service will
be provided regular pay scale. Furthermore, in reply to the query mentioned in
point no.(iv), it was specifically replied that the appointment of the petitioner was
made on the basis of Recruitment Rules No.F.25(1)-E/70(EC) dated 26/01/1971
issued by Secretary, Government of Tripura. It is also stated in the said reply that
the appointees, like the petitioner have to undergo training, if required by the
Government.
5.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents-State:
5.1.
On the other hand, Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA has advanced
his submissions on the basis of the statements made by the respondents in their
counter affidavit. Learned Addl. GA has wholly bent upon the stand taken up by
the Director of Secondary Education, Government of Tripura under Memo dated
22.09.2022. Learned Addl. GA has further drawn my attention to the Memo
dated 31.12.2022 where „No Objection Certificate(NOC)‟ was issued in favour
of the petitioner for pursuing B.Ed. course within 2(two) years duration in the
academic session 2023-24 without hampering normal school duties. However, it
is also stated in the said Memo dated 31.12.2022 that the service of the petitioner
may be utilized in the morning shift of any school nearby, where her college is
situated.
6.
I have considered the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel
appearing for the parties.
7.
Before adverting to the merit of the case, the question falls for
consideration is that whether the NCTE Regulations, 2014 and the Recruitment
Rules, 2016 framed by the Government would be applicable to govern the
service conditions of the petitioner or whether her service conditions would be
regulated by Recruitment Rules, 1971.
8.
Now, coming to the merits of the case, in the instant case, it is clear
that though the petitioner was appointed in the year 2017 but she was supposed
to be appointed in the year 2007 when other similarly situated persons were
appointed in the post of PGT under the respondents. The petitioner was
succeeded in the selection process but she was not considered to be appointed as
PGT under the respondents at that initial point of time. The petitioner was
compelled to approach this Court. Upon hearing the learned counsel for the
parties, this Court had directed the respondents to appoint the petitioner as PGT
vide judgment and order dated 24.01.2017. It is pertinent to mention herein that
the petitioner had filed the earlier writ petition in the year 2007 itself which was
registered as WP(C) No.320 of 2007. It was no fault of the petitioner that the writ
petition had been disposed of in the year 2017. In pursuance to the said judgment
and order, the respondents appointed the petitioner as PGT.
9.
In the opinion of this Court, in this situation, the service conditions
of the petitioner should be governed by the Recruitment Rules, 1971, and not by
the Recruitment Rules, 2016. I am in agreement with the submission of learned
senior counsel for the petitioner that she was supposed to be appointed in the
year 2007 when the Recruitment Rules, 1971 was in force.
10.
I have noticed that there is no stipulation of any condition that a
teacher must acquire professional qualification like B.Ed. under the Recruitment
Rules, 1971. Furthermore, I am not pursuaded by the submission of learned
Addl. GA that the terms and conditions mentioned in Recruitment Rules, 2016
would be applicable in case of the petitioner for extending the benefit of regular
pay scale. The inclusion of possession of professional degree for extending the
benefit of regular pay scale has been introduced for the first time under
Recruitment Rules, 2016. As such, this service condition under Recruitment
Rules, 2016 will not be applicable in case of the petitioner since it is settled
principle of law that the vested right acquired under certain rules cannot be taken
away by subsequent rules.
11.
Moreover, in the Recruitment Rules, 2016 it is specifically
mentioned that the rule will come into force from the date of the notification,
which is evident from the NCTE Notification dated 12.11.2014. Similarly, in the
notification dated 05.09.2016 framing the Recruitment Rules, 2016 it is
categorically stated that the said rule would come into force on the date of its
publication in the official gazette.
12.
That apart, the selection made in the year 2007 under the
advertisement dated 14.07.2006 will not be governed by a subsequent
recruitment rules. The conditions of service of the petitioner will be governed by
the conditions mentioned in the advertisement published on 14.07.2006 for the
post of PGT, under which the petitioner appeared and became successful in the
selection process.
13.
Learned Addl. GA has failed to justify that the advertisement
notification dated 14.07.2006 contained the stipulation of possession of
professional qualification i.e. B.Ed. for selection to the post of PGT.
14.
In N.T. Devin Katti & Ors. vs. Karnataka Public Service
Commission & Ors., (1990)3 SCC 157, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held that
candidates who apply, and undergo written or viva voce test acquire vested right
for being considered for selection in accordance with the terms and conditions
contained in the advertisement, unless the advertisement itself indicates a
contrary intention. Generally, a candidate has right to be considered in
accordance with the terms and conditions set out in the advertisement as his
right crystallises on the date of publication of advertisement, however he has no
absolute right in the matter. If the recruitment Rules are amended retrospectively
during the pendency of selection, in that event selection must be held in
accordance with the amended Rules. Whether the Rules have retrospective effect
or not, primarily depends upon the language of the Rules and its construction to
ascertain the legislative intent. The legislative intent is ascertained either by
express provision or by necessary implication; if the amended Rules are not
retrospective in nature the selection must be regulated in accordance with the
rules and orders which were in force on the date of advertisement.
Determination of this question largely depends on the facts of each case having
regard to the terms and conditions set out in the advertisement and the relevant
rules and orders. Lest there be any confusion, we would like to make it clear that
a candidate on making application for a post pursuant to an advertisement does
not acquire any vested right of selection, but if he is eligible and is otherwise
qualified in accordance with the relevant rules and the terms contained in the
advertisement, he does acquire a vested right of being considered for selection in
accordance with the rules as they existed on the date of advertisement. He
cannot be deprived of that limited right on the amendment of rules during the
pendency of selection unless the amended rules are retrospective in nature.[SCC
p 165 para 11]
15.
Reference may also be taken from the cases of Gopal Krushna Rath
vs. M.A.A. Baig(Dead) by Lrs. & Ors., (1999)1 SCC 544 paras 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 and
7; Public Service Commission, Uttaranchal vs. Jagdish Chandra Singh Bora &
Anr., (2014) 8 SCC 644 paras 17-28; Prakash Chand Meena & Ors. vs. State of
Rajasthan & Ors., (2015) 8 SCC 484 paras 2-10; and Chandraprakash
Madhavrao Dadwa & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., (1998) 8 SCC 154 paras
50(2) and 50(10).
16.
In the instant case, what I find is that the petitioner had undergone
through the process of selection in the year 2006 in pursuance of the
advertisement published in the year 2006. She made herself eligible and qualified
for selection for the post of PGT under the respondents but she was not
considered and arbitrarily was deprived of appointment. She filed writ petition
where this Court directed the respondents to appoint her in the post of PGT. In
such a situation, the appointment of the petitioner in the post of PGT in the year
2017 is inconsequential because she was made herself eligible for selection in the
post of PGT in pursuance of the selection process exercised in the year 2006 by
the respondents. Had she been appointed in the year 2007 or at least, before the
introduction of Recruitment Rule, 2016, the question which has been raised now
by the respondents i.e. requirement of professional qualification i.e. B.Ed. would
not have been raised.
17.
It is clear and explicit that Recruitment Rules, 1971 did not lay
down any criteria of possessing of professional qualification i.e. B.Ed. to make a
candidate eligible for appointment to the post of PGT. Requirement of acquiring
B.Ed. degree has only been incorporated under the NCTE Regulations, 2014
followed by the Recruitment Rules, 2016 framed by the respondents-State, which
came into force with effect from the date of their notification. It is not the case
here that any amendment of recruitment rules was carried out during the
selection process which was exercised in the year 2006.
18.
In the above conspectus, in my opinion, the service conditions of the
petitioner cannot be governed by the conditions contained in the Recruitment
Rules, 2016 issued by the Joint Secretary, Directorate of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura.
19.
As a sequitor, the respondent i.e. Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura has committed serious error of law in issuing the Memo
dated 22.09.2022 asking the petitioner to acquire professional qualification i.e.
B.Ed. as a condition precedent to extend the benefit of regular pay scale in favour
of the petitioner.
20.
Accordingly, the respondents are directed to extend the benefit of
regular pay scale to the petitioner with effect from the date she completed 5(five)
years of service on fixed pay as per government policy. In other words, the said
benefit shall be given to the petitioner w.e.f. 05.09.2022 since the period of
5(five) years fixed pay service was ended on 04.09.2022. The entire exercise
shall be completed within a period of 3(three) months from the date of receipt of
a copy of this order including the arrears of pay as indicated here-in-above.
21.
In the result, the instant writ petition stands allowed in the above
terms.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
SANJAY
GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2023.09.15
16:03:19 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review