Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RFA NO. 491 OF 2005
AGAINST THE DECREE & JUDGMENT DATED 31.07.2004 IN OS NO.126
OF 1995 OF SUB COURT, PATHANAMTHITTA
APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS NOS.1,2,7 & 8:
*1
ABRAHAM, S/O.CHACKO,
CHIRATTAVAYALIL HOUSE, IDAKKUNNAM MURI, MUNDAKKAYAM
VILLAGE, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PRESENT ADDRESS: ABRAHAM,
S/O. CHACKO, HOUSE NO.X/712, PLOT NO.12, VRINDAVANAM,
RANNI TALUK.(DIED)
**2
SAJI MATHEW, S/O. MATHEW
CHARUVIL VEEDU, KOCHUKOICKAL, KUMARAMPEROOR,
VADAKKEKARA MURI, CHITTAR SEETHATHODE VILLAGE,
RANNI TALUK.(DIED)
T.M. VARGHESE S/O. T.K. MATHEW
THALAKUNNEL, MANIYAR, VADASSERIKARA.
T. ABRAHAM, S/O. THOMAS
CHIRATTUVAYALIL, MANIYAR, VADASSERIKARA VILLAGE.
PODIYAMMA,
WIFE OF LATE T.ABRAHAM,AGED 68 YEARS, CHIRATTUVAYALIL,
MANIYAR, VADASSERIKKARA VILLAGE, RANNI TALUK,
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689672.
BINU A,
SON OF LATE T.ABRAHAM, CHIRATTUVAYALIL, MANIYAR,
VADASSERIKKARA VILLAGE, RANNI TALUK. PATHANAMTHITTA
DISTRICT, PIN-689679.
RAJU A, SON OF LATE T.ABRAHAM, CHIRATTUVAYALIL,
MANIYAR, VADASSERIKKARA VILLAGE, RANNI TALUK.
PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT, PIN-689679.
REJI A,
SON OF LATE T.ABRAHAM, CHIRATTUVAYALIL, MANIYAR,
VADASSERIKKARA VILLAGE, RANNI TALUK. PATHANAMTHITTA
DISTRICT, PIN-689679.
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
(*LEGAL HEIRS OF THE DECEASED FIRST APPELLANT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDL.A5 TO A8 VIDE ORDER DATED 20.03.2025
IN IA.2/2023 IN MJC.96/2023 IN RFA.491/2005)
SUSAN @ MANJU, W/O.SAJI MATHEW, CHARUVIL HOUSE,
CHIRAKADAVIL, VADASSERIKKARA.P.O,
PATHANAMTHITTA, PIN-689662.
SHONE, S/O.SAJI MATHEW,
CHARUVIL HOUSE, CHIRAKADAVIL,
VADASSERIKKARA.P.O, PATHANAMTHITTA-689662.
SHAN, S/O.S/O.SAJI MATHEW,
CHARUVIL HOUSE, CHIRAKADAVIL,
VADASSERIKKARA.P.O, PATHANAMTHITTA-689662.
(**LEGAL HEIRS OF THE DECEASED SECOND APPELLANT ARE
IMPLEADED AS ADDL.A9 TO A11 VIDE ORDER DATED 20.03.2025
IN I.A.3/2024 IN MJC.96/2023 IN RFA.NO.491/2005.)
BY ADVS.
A.A.MOHAMMED NAZIR
denizen komath
S.SANTHOSH KUMAR
RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFF & DEFENDANT NOS.3, 5 AND 6:
AJITHA JAYAKUMAR, W/O.JAYAKUMAR,
RESIDING AT JAYANIAS, T.C.NO.23/927, VALIYASALE WARD,
CHANGANAZHASSERY VILLAGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
P.SYAMALAKUMARI
JYOTHIS, KALAVAYAL MURI, VELINALOOR VILLAGE,
OYOR, KOTTARAKARA.
K. GEETHA, W/O. LATE ANIL CHANDRAN,
JYOTHIS, OYOOR, KOTTARAKARA TALUK.
ANAGHA, D/O. LATE ANIL CHANDRAN OF
-DO- -DO-. (MINOR REPRESENTED BY MOTHER AND GUARDIAN
ADDL.5TH DEFENDANT).
BY ADV SHRI.M.V.S.NAMPOOTHIRY FOR R1
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
03.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
“C.R”
A. BADHARUDEEN, J.
================================
R.F.A.No.491 of 2005-B
================================
Dated this the 3rd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
Aggrieved by the decree and judgment dated 31.07.2004 in
O.S.No.126/1995 on the files of Sub Court, Pathanamthitta, defendants
1, 2, 7 and 8 have filed this appeal arraying plaintiff and defendants 3,
5 and 6 as respondents. During pendency of this appeal, the 1 st and 2nd
appellants died and the legal representatives of the 1 st appellant got
arrayed as additional appellants 5 to 8 and the legal representatives of
the 2nd appellant got arrayed as additional appellants 9 to 11.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants as well as the
learned counsel appearing for the 1st respondent in detail. Perused the
verdict under challenge.
3. Parties in this appeal will be referred to as `plaintiff’ and
`defendants’ hereafter for easy discussion.
4. Short facts: Plaintiff filed this suit for declaration of her title
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
over plaint schedule property on the strength of settlement deed
No.3390/1986, marked as Ext.A1. Recovery of possession was sought
for on the allegation that while the plaintiff had been possessing and
enjoying the plaint schedule property on the strength of Ext.A1
settlement deed, during the month of December, 1994 the defendants
trespassed upon the property and took possession of the same after
executing Ext.A3 partition deed and Exts.A4 and A5 sale deeds.
5. Defendans 1 and 2 filed written statement and raised
contention that the total extent of property was 1 acre and 44 cents and
out of which 27 cents were acquired by the Government for Kallada
Irrigation Project. According to defendants 1 and 2, the plaint schedule
property having an extent of 1.17 cents was owned and possessed by
one Ramachandran till his death on 03.01.1991 and after his death, the
property devolved upon defendants 3 and 4, who are the widow and
son of Ramachandran, and in turn defendants 1 and 2 obtained title
over the same on the strength of Exts.A4 and A5 sale deeds dated
09.11.1994, executed by defendants 3 and 4. Right of the plaintiff was
denied contending the settlement deed as a false document.
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
6. The 3rd defendant filed written statement separately,
supporting the contentions raised by defendants 1 and 2 and asserted
title over the plaint schedule property being the successor of
Ramachandran.
Although the 4th defendant did not file written
statement, the legal-heirs of the 4th respondent impleaded as additional
defendants Nos.5 and 6 filed a separate joint written statement in tune
with the contentions raised by defendants Nos.1 to 3.
7. On scrutiny of the pleadings as set forth, the trial court
recorded evidence after raising necessary issues. PWs 1 to 5 were
examined and Exts.A1 to A14 were marked on the side of the plaintiff.
DW1 to DW4 were examined and Exts.B1 to B3 were marked on the
side of the defendants. Apart from that, Exts.C1, C2, Xl, X2 and X3
were marked as court exhibits.
8. Finally the trial court found that the plaintiff perfected title
over the plaint schedule property on the strength of Ext.A1 settlement
deed and accordingly the same was declared and suit was decreed by
granting the relief of recovery of possession of the property and also
granting prohibitory injunction restraining the defendants from
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
executing any document in respect of the property and the building to
any third party. The plaintiff was allowed to realise arrears of damages
for use and occupation of the building @ Rs.600/- per annum and
mesne profit of Rs.1,000/- per annum from 09.11.1994 till date of
giving vacant possession also was granted with costs. The said verdict
is under challenge.
9. The learned counsel for the contesting defendants argued at
length to convince this Court that Ext.A1 settlement deed was not
proved and the extent shown in Ext.A1 as 4 acre 44 cents as against 1
acre 44 cents itself would show the falsity of the document. Further,
the status of defendants 1 and 2 as bona fide purchasers is being
projected to protect their right over the property ignoring Ext.A1
settlement deed, on the strength of Exts.A4 and A5 sale deeds executed
in favour of defendants 1 and 2 by defendants 3 and 4 after partitioning
the property as per Ext.A3 partition deed.
10.
Whereas the learned counsel for the plaintiff
submitted that even though the extent of property shown as item No.1,
the plaint schedule property herein, is wrongly described as 4 acre 44
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
cents instead of 117 cents (23 + 94), the same would not help
defendants 3 and 4 to claim right over the property which is covered by
Ext.A1 settlement deed. It is also pointed out by the learned counsel
for the plaintiff that in Ext.A1 settlement deed, item No.2 property was
also included and the same has been in possession and enjoyment of
the plaintiff on the strength of Ext.A1 settlement deed, for which no
challenge is raised by the defendants. Therefore, the finding of the trial
court regarding genuineness of Ext.A1 settlement deed, which
conferred title upon the plaintiff in relation to the plaint schedule
property, is only to be confirmed.
11.
Having addressed the rival contentions, the points
arise for consideration are:
(i) Whether the finding of the trial court holding Ext.A1
settlement deed as a valid document, whereby the plaintiff perfected
title over the plaint schedule property is wrong?
(ii)Whether the plaintiff proved the execution of Ext.A1
settlement deed to perfect the title over the plaint schedule property?
(iii)
Can it be held that defendants 3 and 4, being legal
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
heirs of deceased Ramachandran suceeded him to claim right over the
plaint schedule property?
(iv)
Whether the claim put forward by defendants 1 and 2
as bona fide purchasers is liable to succeed?
(v)
Whether the decree and judgment would require
interference?
(vi)
Reliefs and costs.
12.
Together, points (i) to (vi) are being considered:
As far as Ext.A1 settlement deed is concerned, the contention
raised by defendants 1 and 2 as well as defendants 3 and 4 is that the
same is a concocted document and Ramachandran did not create such a
document and he never intended to gift the plaint schedule property to
the plaintiff. In order to prove Ext.A1, plaintiff herself mounted the
box and given evidence in support of Ext.A1 after filing affidavit in
lieu of chief examination. The original title deed, viz. settlement deed
No. 3390/1986, was let in by PW1 in evidence.
Apart from the
evidence of PW1, PW3-the document writer who wrote Ext.A1 also
was examined. In fact, nothing extracted during cross examination of
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
PW1 and PW3 to disbelieve their version in the matter of execution of
Ext.A1 by Ramachandran in favour of the plaintiff including 2 items of
property, out of which item No.1 is now in dispute and no dispute is
raised as far as item No.2 covered by Ext.A1. PW3 further given
evidence that one of the attestors to Ext.A1 settlement deed expired six
months back and another attestor died in the year 1993.
In the
judgment of the trial court, production of death certificates of the two
attesting witnesses along with I.A.No.781/2004 and 784/2004 was
discussed. But the trial court dismissed those petitions but believed the
evidence of PW3 to the effect that the attesting witnesses were no
more. In fact, no serious dispute raised from the other side as far as the
death of the attesting witnesses are concerned. Therefore, the available
witness, the document writer, was examined.
13.
In the decision reported in [2025 KHC OnLine 281 :
2025 KHC 281 : 2025 KER 15982 : 2025 KLT OnLine 1441],
Gopinath K.I.V. v. K.I.V. Vimala, this Court considered the question
as to whether it is mandatory to examine one among the attesting
witnesses in a settlement deed or a gift deed to prove its execution and
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
in paragraph 10 this Court observed as under:
“xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
It is true that as per Section
68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, (for short, ‘the
Evidence Act’, hereinafter) if a document is required by
law to be attested, it shall not be used as evidence until
one attesting witness at least has been called for the
purpose of proving its execution, if there be an attesting
witness alive, and subject to the process of the Court and
capable of giving evidence. Proviso to Section 68 would
say that, it shall not be necessary to call an attesting
witness in proof of the execution of any document, not
being a Will, which has been registered in accordance
with the provisions of the Indian Registration Act, 1908,
unless its execution by the person by whom it purports to
have been executed is specifically denied. Thus, it shall
not be necessary to examine an attesting witness in proof
of the execution of a gift deed other than a Will which is
duly registered under the Indian Registration Act, 1908,
unless its execution by the person by whom purports to
have been executed is specifically denied. It is true that as
per Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (for
short, ‘the TP Act’ hereinafter), it has been provided that
for the purpose of making a gift of immovable property,
the transfer must be effected by a registered instrument
signed by or on behalf of the donor, and attested by at
least two witnesses. In fact, Section 123 would apply in
relation to gift deeds. When a document executed as
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
settlement deed having the trappings of a gift deed, though
there is slight difference between gift deed and settlement
deed, even if these terms are used interchangeably, then
also, the same has to be attested by at least two witnesses.
Reading Section 68 of the Evidence Act, 1872, in
juxtaposition with Section 123 of the TP Act also, there is
no legal mandate that one among the attesting witnesses
shall be examined to prove a settlement deed or a gift
deed when there is no specific denial of the execution of
the same by the person by whom purports to have been
executed the same. However, when there is a dispute as to
the gift deed or settlement deed without specifically
denying the execution, then also, examination of one
among the attesting witnesses is not mandatory. However,
when there is specific denial inasmuch as the execution of
a settlement deed or a gift deed, it shall be necessary to
call an attesting witness to examine so as to prove the
same and therefore, examination of one among the
attesting witnesses in such case is mandatory.”
14.In the instant case, the available witness, the document writer,
was examined to prove Ext.A1 and his evidence not at all shaken
to
disbelieve him. It is to be noted that the 3 rd defendant, who claimed
to be the wife of Ramachandran, admitted that the marriage was earlier
divorced, but according to the 3rd defendant, she was remarried by
Ramachandran.
Admittedly, the 4th defendant
is
the
son
of
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
Ramachandran.
Ext.A1 was executed
on 28.07.1986 and thereafter
Ramachandran died only on 03.01.1991. In fact, even though Ext.A1 is
a settlement deed, the essentials to complete the gift as mandated under
Section 122 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (`T.P Act’ for short
hereafter) would apply in cases of settlement deed also even though
there is a slight difference between gift deed and settlement deed even
if these terms are used interchangeably. The essentials to constitute a
valid gift is no more res integra as held in [(2007) 13 SCC 210],
Asokan v. Lakshmikutty, wherein the Apex Court on an interpretation
of Section 122 of the T.P Act and held as under in paragraphs 13 and
14:
“13.
The definition of “gift” contained in Section
122 of the Transfer of Property Act provides that the essential
elements thereof are:
1. the absence of consideration;
2. the donor;
3. the donee;
4. the subject-matter;
5. the transfer; and
6. the acceptance.
14. Gifts do not contemplate payment of any consideration
or compensation. It is, however, beyond any doubt or dispute that
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
in order to constitute a valid gift, acceptance thereof is essential.
We must, however, notice that the Transfer of Property Act does
not prescribe any particular mode of acceptance. It is the
circumstances attending to the transaction which may be relevant
for determining the question. There may be various means to prove
acceptance of a gift. The document may be handed over to a donee,
which in a given situation may also amount to valid acceptance.
The fact that possession had been given to the donee also raises a
presumption of acceptance.”
15.
In a latest decision of the Apex Court reported in
[2024 KHC OnLine 6696 : 2024 KHC 6696 : 2025(1) KHC SN 8 :
2024 INSC 965 : 2024 KLT OnLine 2950], Naresh Kumari v.
Chameli in paragraphs 13 and 14 the Apex Court held that, under TPA
a valid gift can be made without giving immediate possession to the
donee as has been held by this Court in Renikuntla Rajamma v.
K.Sarwanamma [2014 KHC 4466] where it was held that Section 123
of TPA supersedes Hindu Law and delivery of possession is not an
essential requirement for the gift to be valid under provisions of TPA.
Nevertheless, in Punjab and in all other places of North India where
Mitakshara law was applicable, gift of land usually was accompanied
by handing over possession to the donee, as there was no purpose of
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
enjoying land without being in its possession. In other words, in cases
governed by Hindu Law, possession is an extremely important
ingredient where validity of the gift is to be determined. Since TPA
was not in force, delivery of possession which has been done in the
present case has an important bearing.
16.
In Renikuntla Rajamma (D) by LRs. v. K. Sarwanamma
[2014 KHC 4466 = (2014) 9 SCC 445], while dealing with Sections 122 and 123
of the Act, the Apex Court held thus:
“11. xxxxx xxxxx A conjoint reading of Sections 122
and 123 of the Act makes it abundantly clear that “transfer
of possession” of the property covered by the registered
instrument of the gift duly signed by the donor and attested
as required is not a sine qua non for the making of a valid
gift under the provisions of Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
17.
Thus in the instant case specific case of the plaintiff
is that she got title and possession over the plaint schedule property on
the basis of Ext.A1 settlement deed and she has been residing in
Thiruvananthapuram.
She received 2 letters from her neighbour
marked as Exts.A10 and A11, regarding occupation of the building by
defendants 3 and 4 on the strength of partition deed and subsequent
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
sale deeds executed without the knowledge of the plaintiff. This is the
cause of action for filing the present suit which has been stated in the
plaint.
18.
In this matter, once Ext.A1 settlement deed is found
to be genuinely executed on proof of the same, it was proved to be
accepted by the plaintiff so as to complete the transaction.
The
production of the original gift deed in her possession by the plaintiff
before the court is the vital evidence to prove the acceptance.
Therefore, whether the 3rd defendant is the wife of Ramachandran or 4 th
defendant is the son of Ramachandran are matters of no relevance since
nothing has been left by Ramachandran to be succeeded by them as he
had transferred the entire plaint schedule property and other items of
property as per Ext.A1 in favour of the plaintiff. It is true that in
Ext.A1, the extent of property described is something more than the
plaint schedule description. But the same in no way would affect the
right of the plaintiff to get the available property covered by Ext.A1.
19.
Having addressed the points in the above context, it
has to be held that the plaintiff perfected title over the plaint schedule
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
property on the basis of Ext.A1 settlement deed and defendants 3 and 4
would not succeed upon the same. Therefore, they could not execute a
partition deed and subsequent sale deeds in favour of defendants 1 and
2. Therefore, the trial court rightly granted decree in favour of the
plaintiff.
20. The specific contention of defendants 1 and 2 is that they are
bona fide purchasers for valid consideration. While addressing the
status of bona fide purchasers the matter to be addressed is the vigil to
be taken by buyer/buyers while purchasing a property.
Normally,
when a party proposes to sell an immovable property, the buyer would
enquire about the liability of the property by getting an encumbrance
certificate. If an encumbrance certificate was obtained in this case, the
encumbrance in the form of Ext.A1 settlement deed could very well be
found. Thus the inference is that defendants 1 and 2 even did not care
to verify the encumbrance certificate before purchasing the property or
if they obtained an encumbrance certificate, they had purchased the
property after having knowledge regarding the encumbrance in the
form of Ext.A1, with the risk of encumbrance in the property. If so,
2025:KER:28702
RFA.NO.491/2005-B
they could not be held as bona fide purchasers in any manner. In such
view of the matter the said contention also must fail as rightly found by
the trial court. Thus on re-appreciation of evidence, this appeal is
found to be meritless and the same deserves dismissal with cost of the
plaintiff.
21.
In the result, this appeal stands dismissed. It is
ordered that the plaintiff is entitled to get her cost in the appeal, to be
realised from the respondents.
22.
All the interlocutory applications pending shall stand
dismissed and all the interim orders shall stand vacated.
Registry shall forward a copy of this judgment to the
jurisdictional court for information and further steps.
Sd/-
(A.BADHARUDEEN, JUDGE)
rtr/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review