The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Consequently, both criminal revisional applications (C.R.R. 4680 of 2022 and C.R.R. 842 of 2023) succeed and are hereby allowed.
17. The entire proceeding relating to Complaint Case No. 1286 of 2022 pending before the learned Judicial Magistrate, 9th Court, Alipore, South 24 Parganas, including the order of cognizance dated 19.05.2022 and the summoning order dated 14.07.2022, along with all consequential orders, are hereby quashed and set aside qua both petitioners (Mr. Abhishek Kapoor and Bittu Chowdhury).
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
D/L – 3-4
16/09/2026
Court No.42
S.Kundu
CRR 4680 of 2022
With
CRAN 15 OF 2026
Abhishek Kapoor
Vs.
Kabir Suman
With
CRR 842 of 2023
With
CRAN 12 of 2026
Bittu Roy Choudhury
Vs.
Kabir Suman
Mr. Sandipan Ganguly, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Apalak Basu
Ms. Smita Mukherjee
Mr. Zoeb Cutelrywala
Ms. Soheli Bose
…for the petitioner in CRR 4680 of 2022.
Mr. Apalak Basu
Mr. Navneet Sewak
…for the petitioner in CRR 842 of 2023.
1. At the very threshold, when these matters were called
for hearing, this Court records its anguish regarding
the persistent and deliberate absence of the Opposite
Party
no.
2(complainant),
who
despite
several
opportunities, notices and ample latitude granted by
this Court, as evidenced from the orders dated
10.04.2023,
03.07.2023,
30.11.2023,
31.01.2025,
11.06.2026 and lastly on 29.07.2026 wherein this
Court has recorded that it has exhausted all measures
to compel appearance of the opposite party no.2 in the
matters, as such, in view of the lackadaisical approach
of the O.P. No. 2 and long pendency, this Court
proceeds to hear and decide the matters ex-parte
against
the
O.P.
No.
on
the
basis
of
the
comprehensive materials-on-record and the sound
legal submissions of the Mr. Sandipan Ganguly, the
learned counsel for the petitioners.
2. These two revisional applications under Section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure are taken up together
for analogous hearing and disposal as they emanate
from the selfsame criminal proceeding pending before
the Judicial Magistrate, 9th Court, Alipore.
3. The petitioners seek the quashing of the entire
proceeding being Complaint Case No. 1286 of 2022,
including the order of cognizance dated 19.05.2022
passed
by
the
learned
Additional
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate, Alipore, and the subsequent summoning
order dated 14.07.2022 passed by the learned Judicial
Magistrate, 9th Court, Alipore, whereby process under
Sections 499, 500, and 34 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860, was issued against them.
4. The factual backdrop reveals that on 27.01.2022 at
about 1:30 PM, a telephonic call was made by Bittu
Chowdhury, reporter attached to Republic Bangla
(petitioner in C.R.R. 842 of 2022), to the opposite party
no. 2, Sri Kabir Suman, concerning a news reaction
regarding late Sandhya Mukherjee. Annoyed by the
call, the opposite party no. 2 reacted with intemperate
language, uninhibitedly hurling a torrent of common
Bengali
slangs
and
expletives.
Subsequently,
on
29.01.2022, the opposite party no. 2 published a long
Facebook
apology
admitting
outburst.
Following
the
to
his
intemperate
circulation of
the
audio
recording of the said verbal dialogue, a legal notice was
issued, replies were exchanged, and the learned
Magistrate ultimately took cognizance and issued
summons. While the reporter (Bittu Chowdhury) is
directly accused of recording and circulating the
conversation, Mr.
Abhishek Kapoor
(petitioner in
C.R.R. 4680 of 2022), the Senior Executive Editor /
Editor-in-Chief, Republic Media Network, has been
roped
in
personally
and
vicariously
despite
the
admitted and uncontroverted position that no such
programme, news segment, or audio recording was ever
aired, broadcasted, or telecasted by Republic Bangla or
any channel of the Republic Media Network.
5. Mr. Ganguly has forcefully and meticulously argued
that the criminal prosecution is legally stillborn as the
foundational
ingredients
of
the
penal
offence
of
defamation under Section 499 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 are conspicuously absent. Section 499
defines defamation as making or publishing any
imputation concerning any person with intent to harm,
or knowing or having reason to believe that such
imputation will harm their reputation. Learned senior
counsel submits that an "imputation" pre-supposes an
active assertion, allegation, or attribution originating
from the accused, it can never encompass the passive
recording,
exposure,
or
dissemination
of
the
complainant's own unedited words spoken in his own
voice. A person cannot be said to defame another by
truthfully reproducing or capturing what that very
person has himself uttered in an uninhibited outburst.
6. This core principle stands authoritatively settled by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in Jawaharlal Darda & Ors. v.
Manoharrao Ganpatrao Kapsikar & Anr. [(1998) 4 SCC
112], wherein the Supreme Court held that if the
publication is a true and faithful account of what has
transpired and does not contain any independent,
malicious or fabricated imputation by the accused, the
essential ingredients of defamation under Section 499
of the IPC are completely missing, and the criminal
prosecution cannot be sustained.
7. The same line of reasoning has been consistently
echoed by this Court in Samik Ghosh and Ors. v. State
of West Bengal & Anr. (2022 SCC OnLine Cal 3610)
and Afshan Meerza v. The State of West Bengal & Anr.
(2022 SCC OnLine Cal 4126), wherein it was reaffirmed
that faithful reporting or reproduction without editorial
malice does not constitute the offence of defamation.
8. Furthermore, Mr. Ganguly has heavily relied upon
Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC, which explicitly
stipulates:
"Explanation 4.—No imputation is said to harm a
person's
reputation,
unless
that
imputation
directly or indirectly, in the estimation of others,
lowers the moral or intellectual character of that
person, or lowers the character of that person in
respect of his caste or of his calling, or lowers the
credit of that person or causes it to be believed
that the body of that person is in a loathsome
state, or in a state generally considered as
disgraceful."
9. As expounded by this Court in M/s. Pataka Industries
(Pvt.) Ltd. v. The State of West Bengal & Ors. (CRR 3277
of 2008 decided on 07.10.2013), a person cannot be
defamed in his own eyes, and the statutory threshold
mandates that the imputation must lower reputation in
the estimation of others.
10. A perusal of the initial deposition of the O.P. No.
2/complainant under Section 200 Cr.P.C. reveals a total
void
of
any
independent
third-party
witness
who
deposed that the moral or intellectual character of the
opposite party no. 2 was lowered in their estimation. In
the absence of any foundational witness testimony, the
charge of defamation under Sections 499 & 500 of the
IPC fails to cross the legal threshold.
11. Addressing the mechanical nature of the orders
impugned, Mr. Ganguly has demonstrated that the
cognizance order dated 19.05.2022 was passed by the
learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate by merely
filling out or signing a printed pro forma, which runs
diametrically counter to Rule 183 of the Calcutta High
Court Criminal (Subordinate Courts) Rules, 1985, and
the mandate of this Court in Sharmistha Chowdhury &
Anr. v. The State of West Bengal & Ors. (2017 SCC
OnLine Cal 9902), wherein it was reinforced that
orders requiring exercise of judicial discretion and the
final order shall be recorded by a Magistrate in his own
hand or typed by him.
12. Moreover, the summoning order dated 14.07.2022
suffers
from
fatal
procedural
and
substantive
illegalities. Firstly, it has been issued mechanically
against a vague designation ("The Editor - Republic
Bangla") and reporter without reflecting any application
of judicial mind to ascertain individual roles or specific
culpability
regarding
applicability
of
the
offence
charged thereunder. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Sharad Kumar Sanghi v. Sangita Rane [(2015) 12 SCC
781] and JM Laboratories and Ors. v. State of Andhra
Pradesh & Anr. (2025 SCC Online SC 208) has
cautioned that the order of the Magistrate summoning
the accused must reflect that he has applied his mind
to the facts of the case and the law applicable thereto
and when the accused are persons holding high
corporate or editorial positions, the summoning order
must contain specific allegations demonstrating their
individual active participation, failing which is an
abuse of process.
13. Compounding these glaring illegalities, the learned
Magistrate completely bypassed the mandatory presummoning inquiry mandated under Section 202 of
the
Cr.P.C.
The
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India, Ministry of Law
&
Ors.
[(2016)
SCC
221]
has
authoritatively
underscored that the amended Section 202 Cr.P.C.
casts a mandatory obligation on the Magistrate to
postpone the issuance of process and conduct an
inquiry or direct an investigation when the accused
resides beyond the territorial jurisdiction, specifically
to filter out false, vexatious, or harassing complaints
against persons residing at far-off places.
14. It is an undisputed position of record that the
petitioners reside beyond the territorial jurisdiction of
the learned Magistrate at Alipore, as such, the shortcut
adopted by the trial court completely defeats the
legislative wisdom and mandate of Section 202 Cr.P.C,
thus, is not legally tenable.
15. Upon a holistic synthesis of the statutory provisions,
the undisputed facts, the continuous flow of arguments
advanced by the learned senior counsel for the
petitioners, and the ratio decidendi of the binding
precedents cited herein, this Court is firmly of the view
that the continuation of Complaint Case No. 1286 of
2022 against both petitioners is an egregious abuse of
the process of law and a travesty of justice.
16. Consequently, both criminal revisional applications
(C.R.R. 4680 of 2022 and C.R.R. 842 of 2023) succeed
and are hereby allowed.
17. The entire proceeding relating to Complaint Case No.
1286 of 2022 pending before the learned Judicial
Magistrate, 9th Court, Alipore, South 24 Parganas,
including the order of cognizance dated 19.05.2022
and the summoning order dated 14.07.2022, along
with all consequential orders, are hereby quashed and
set aside qua both petitioners (Mr. Abhishek Kapoor
and Bittu Chowdhury).
18. The interim order, if any, stands vacated.
19. Pending applications (CRAN 15 of 2026 in C.R.R. 4680
of 2022 and CRAN 12 of 2026 in C.R.R. 842 of 2023)
are also disposed of accordingly.
20. There shall be no order as to costs.
21. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be given to the parties upon compliance with
requisite formalities.
(Uday Kumar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review