Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 14
15.10.2026
Court No.24
SD
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
WPA 30672 of 2026
Abeda Khatoon & Anr.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Bikram Banerjee
Mr. Sudipta Dasgupta
Ms. Sagarika Goswami
Mr. Saikat Sutradhar
… for the Petitioners.
Mr. Lokenath Chatterjee, JSC
Ms. Sneha Chatterjee
Mr. Indranil Roy, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharyya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Sunit Kumar Roy
1.
… for the State.
… for SSC.
Affidavit of service filed in Court today be kept
with the records.
2.
The
petitioners
are
untainted
in-service
candidates who participated in 2nd SLST.
They seek
benefit of reservation in the Other Backward Classes
(OBC) category.
3.
The petitioners contend that the Commission is
permitting editing of the application form of the
candidates relying on the West Bengal School Service
Commission (Selection for Appointment to the Posts of
Assistant Teachers for Upper Primary Level of Classes
[except Work Education and Physical Education],
Classes IX-X and Classes XI-XII) Rules, 2025.
4.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court on November 26,
2025 passed in Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No.
46049/2025 [Bibek Paria & Ors. vs. The State of West
Bengal & Ors.], made it clear that ‘the High Court shall
also be mindful of the fact that the untainted candidates
in the past selection were allowed to sit for the selection
tests to be held afresh and their candidature cannot be
adversely affected by application of the new Rules’.
5.
The case made out by the petitioners is that
when initially in the year 2025 the School Service
Commission provided option to update the subcategory details, the petitioner did update the category
and the sub-category details in the application form
within the time limit stipulated by the Commission.
6.
The sub-category in which they belong was
earlier included in the list of OBC prior to 2010 and
even after the Gazette notification was published on
August 7, 2026. The petitioners belong to OBC
category since birth.
7.
By notification dated August 19, 2026 published
by the Commission, it was notified to all concerned to
update the OBC sub-category details between August
20, 2026 and August 25, 2026 failing which the
candidature would automatically be treated under the
General category.
8.
By a further notice dated September 7, 2026, the
editing window stood extended from September 10,
2026 to September 12, 2026.
9.
The petitioners submit that since sub-category of
the petitioners was already edited in the year 2025 in
terms of the earlier notification of the Commission, the
petitioners did not opt for editing the sub-category
once again.
10.
The petitioners apprehend that if they are not
permitted the benefit of reservation, then they may
lose their service.
11.
In support of the submission that the State
ought to prevent indirect discrimination the judgment
delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court on September
4, 2025 in SLP (Civil) No.27139 of 2024 in the matter
of Shreya Kumari Tirkey v. State of Jharkhand &
Ors. has been relied upon.
12.
It has been submitted that the act of the
authority in publishing repeated notices for updating
the sub-category of a candidate is misleading and at
the same time ambiguous. The candidates are left
confused and are not aware as to how many times a
candidate
would
be
required
to
update
his/her
category and sub-category details.
13.
Prayer has been made to direct the Commission
to treat the petitioners in the OBC category in
accordance with the sub-category disclosed by the
petitioners in the application made by the petitioners
pursuant to the notice of the Commission dated July
30, 2025 and grant the benefit of reservation.
14.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the School
Service Commission opposes the submission made by
the petitioners.
He submits that no case has been
made out by the petitioners that the sub-category as
disclosed earlier has to be treated as the proper subcategory of the candidates.
15.
All along the case made out by the petitioners is
that they were unable to update the sub-category
within the stipulated time period.
16.
Candidates
participating
in
a
competitive
examination ought to have been diligent and acted in
terms of the notices published by the recruiting
authority from time to time.
17.
There are several candidates who may have
missed the opportunity to update the sub-category
details within the stipulated time period.
If any
relaxation is given to the petitioners, then the same
would
amount
to
discrimination
with
the
other
candidates.
18.
It has been contended that it is practically
impossible to ascertain the sub-category from the
applications where the candidates have failed to
update their category details in terms of the notice
issued by the Commission.
19.
It has also been contended on behalf of the
Commission that the writ petition would not be
maintainable as the petitioners failed to approach the
authority for redressal of the grievances prior to filing
the writ petition.
20.
The Commission prays for dismissal of the writ
petition.
21.
Upon hearing the respective submissions made
on behalf of all the parties and on perusal of the
materials on record, it appears that, admittedly, the
candidates updated the sub-category pursuant to the
earlier notice issued by the Commission in the year
2025.
22.
It is also a fact that when the sub-category
details were directed to be updated in the year 2025,
the SLP filed by the State before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court challenging the Division Bench order passed by
this Court with regard to the OBC reservation issue
was pending consideration.
23.
After the State Government took a decision to
withdraw the appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
and abide by the direction passed by the Hon’ble
Division Bench of this Court, a fresh notification was
published
by
the
Backward
Classes
Welfare
Department in the Gazette by striking down 113
classes out of the enlisted 179 classes from the OBC
category by retaining only 66 of them as was there in
the notification published in the year prior to 2010.
24.
In view of the legal complications which arose in
the State as regards reservation in the OBC category,
the candidates had to update their category and subcategory details on more than one occasion.
25.
The authority published notice on August 19,
2026 requesting all concerned candidates to specify
their sub-category (in case of OBC), failing which they
would be treated as unreserved (General) category
candidates.
The sub-category of the petitioners was
admittedly
included
in
the
Gazette
notification
prevailing in the year 2010 and also included in the
list published in 2026.
26.
There is no doubt with regard to the OBC status
of the candidates. It is only that the candidates failed
to update their sub-category within the window
prescribed for editing by the Commission.
27.
The contention of the Commission that it is
practically impossible to ascertain the sub-category
details of the OBC category candidates who did not
update their sub-category pursuant to the notification
dated August 19, 2026 and September 7, 2026 cannot
be brushed aside lightly.
28.
It has also been pointed out that public notice in
four local newspapers was published to bring it to the
notice of all concerned, the requirement of updating
the sub-category details of the candidates. Despite the
aforesaid
notifications
and
public
notices,
the
candidates failed to update the sub-category status.
29.
As the subject recruitment process is supposed
to be concluded within a stipulated time period framed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Commission would
be required to take all effective steps to ensure that the
process is over in terms of the mandate of the Supreme
Court.
30.
The submission of the petitioners that the
repeated notices published by the Commission are
ambiguous and confusing cannot be accepted.
31.
The submission of the petitioners that the
candidates got confused by the mandate in the notice
dated 19th August, 2026 that the candidates who failed
to update their sub-category details in terms of the
notification would be treated as unreserved (general)
category as the same was updated in the earlier
occasion also cannot be accepted. The petitioners
thought that as the sub-category was already updated
earlier and there is no change in the OBC status of the
petitioner, accordingly, the editing was not done again.
32.
The previous update was done in the year 2025
pursuant to the notice issued by the Commission in
July 2025. The subsequent notification to update on
19th August, 2026 was issued only after the State
published the fresh OBC category classes. The same
would certainly require fresh updating. The previous
updating of the candidates was in the OBC category
either ‘A’ or ‘B’.
Right now there is only the OBC
category, bereft of the category ‘A’ or ‘B’.
33.
Despite all the above, it appears that the sub-
category of the candidates is still now retained in the
OBC category published by the State. The candidates
did update the category at one point of time pursuant
to the notice issued by the Commission.
34.
As the candidates were born in the OBC category
accepted by the State, the benefit of reservation ought
not to be taken away only because the candidates
failed to update their sub-category details when such
option was provided for the second time.
35.
From the notice published by the Commission
on September 7, 2026, it appears that the Commission
took note of the various requests made from the
candidates, who failed to update their sub-category
details
within
the
stipulated
time
period.
The
Commission only for the purpose of enabling the
genuine OBC candidates to update their category
details again opened the editing window for three days.
36.
As the petitioners claim to be genuine OBC
candidates, accordingly, the Court grants leave to the
petitioners to make a formal application before the
Commission by October 22, 2026 annexing earlier
reservation certificate, the updated application already
filed by the petitioner in 2025 and the present category
details before the Commission. The application shall
be made both in the offline and in the online mode.
37.
If the authority finds that the candidates are
genuine OBC category candidates, then a decision may
be taken by the Commission to permit the candidates
to avail the benefit of reservation.
38.
It is made clear that this order will not create a
right in favour of the candidates to get the benefit of
reservation.
It
is
merely
a
request
upon
the
Commission to ascertain the OBC status of the
candidates; and if the candidates are actually found to
be genuine OBC candidates and had already updated
the sub-category details on an earlier occasion, then
the benefit of reservation may be granted to them.
39.
The Commission shall keep in mind that the
petitioners are untainted in-service candidates and
they lost their job in view of the order passed by the
Court.
They ought not to be put in any adverse
position in line with the dictate of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the matter of Bibek Paria (supra).
40.
A decision shall be taken by the Commission
within ten working days after opening of the office after
the ensuing Laxmi Puja.
41.
The writ petition stands disposed of.
42.
Parties to act on the basis of the server copy of
this order duly downloaded from the official website of
this Court.
43.
Certified server copy of this order, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all
requisite formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review