Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
2024:KER:58721
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
TUESDAY, THE 30TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 8TH SRAVANA, 1946
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 23.05.2024 INEP NO.53/2022 IN ARC NO.758
OF 2019 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/SUB COURT/COMMERCIAL COURT,
PAYYANNUR
PETITIONER/RESPONDENT:
ABDURAHMAN.M.,AGED 56 YEARS
S/O RUKHIYA, ANJILLATH HOUSE,
OPP.OLD POST OFFICE, KUNHIMANGALAM AMSOM DESOM,
ANDAM KOVVAL, .P.O. KUNHIMANGALAM,
KANNUR-, PIN - 670309
BY ADV K.RAJESH SUKUMARAN
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
PAYYANNUR URBAN CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD NO. C 1556
PAYYANNUR AMSOM, PAYYANNUR TALUK. P.O. PAYYANNUR,
KANNUR- REP. BY ITS SECRETARY., PIN - 670307
BY ADV MAHESH V RAMAKRISHNAN
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 30.07.2024, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
“CR”
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
.................................................................
O.P.(C) No.1319 of 2024
.................................................................
Dated this the 30th day of July, 2024
JUDGMENT
The above original petition has been filed seeking to set aside
Ext.P3 order dated 23.05.2024 in E.P.No.53 of 2022 in ARC No.758 of 2019
on the file of the Subordinate Judge’s Court, Payyannur.
2.
Short facts necessary for the disposal of the original
petition are as follows: Petitioner is the respondent/judgment debtor in
E.P.No.53 of 2022 on the file of the Subordinate Judge’s Court, Payyannur
and the respondent herein is the petitioner/decree holder in the said
execution petition. In execution of the award of the Assistant Registrar of
Co-operative Societies (General), Payyanur dated 20.06.2019 in ARC
No.758 of 2019 respondent filed E.P.No.53 of 2022 before the Court of
Subordinate Judge, Payyannur. As per the execution petition, the total
award amount along with interest comes to Rs.11,56,511/- and the mode of
assistance of the court required are as follows:
i.
The mortgaged property shown in the schedule below
may be proclaimed, sold and the sale proceeds may be paid over to the
petitioner towards the decree amount.
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
ii.
Notice under Rule 37 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil
Procedure (in short, “CPC”) may be issued to the respondent and also a
warrant of arrest under Rule 38 and they may be detained in civil prison for
the realisation of the decree amount.
3.
The petitioner contended that as per the execution
petition, the first prayer is to sell the mortgaged property of the petitioner
measuring an extent of 4.45 Ares (11 cents) in re-survey no.9/3 of
Payyannur amsom, Kavvayi desom of Payyannur Taluk, which has been
mortgaged with the bank at the time of availing the loan. A detailed counter
statement was filed by the petitioner in the execution petition contending
that the entire property need not be sold and only a portion of the property
need be sold so as to fulfil the decree debt as the property is situated in the
middle of the town and is having a value of more than Rs.5,00,000/- per
cent. It is the case of the petitioner that the execution court did not consider
the counter statement and without proceeding with the sale of the
mortgaged property passed Ext.P3 order dated 23.05.2024 issuing warrant
of arrest, that too without conducting an enquiry under Rule 40(1) of Order
XXI CPC and without proving the means of the judgment debtor. The
contention of the petitioner is that issuance of Ext.P3 order whereby arrest
warrant was issued against him is in violation of the provisions of the CPC
and also the judgment of this Court in Anilkumar v. Divya, 2023 (5) KHC
341. The petitioner would contend that in Anilkumar’s case cited supra it
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
was categorically held that the execution court cannot invoke the remedy
under Clause (c) of Section 51 CPC by issuing arrest warrant against the
judgment debtor without exhausting the remedy under Clause (b) of Section
51 CPC by the sale of movable or immovable property if any available. So,
on the basis of the same, the first contention of the petitioner is that before
issuing arrest warrant, the execution court ought to have proceeded with
the sale of movable or immovable property and only thereafter the court
could have resorted to the arrest and detention of the judgment debtor in
civil prison. Secondly, it is contended that before issuing arrest warrant as
per Ext.P3, the procedures as contemplated in Rule 40(1) of Order XXI CPC
have not been followed.
4.
The respondent entered appearance through counsel
and contended that as regard the first contention of the petitioner that the
execution court can proceed against the person of the judgment debtor only
after proceeding against the property of the judgment debtor is not correct
and he relies on the judgments in Shyam Singh v. Collector, District
Hamirpur, U.P. and others, 1993 KHC 1018, Leelakumari v. Shikha and
others, 2018 (4) KHC 155 and Anjengo Coir Mattings v. Indian Overseas
Bank, 1996(1) KLT 506 in support of his contentions.
5.
I have heard the rival contentions of both sides.
6.
Let me consider the first contention raised by the
learned counsel for the petitioner on the strength of the judgment in
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
Anilkumar’s case cited supra that the proceedings under Clause (c) of
Section 51 CPC could be initiated only after exhausting the remedy as
provided under Clause (b) of the said Section. Section 51 CPC dealing with
the power of the court to enforce execution reads as follows:
“51.
Powers of Court to enforce execution
Subject to such conditions and limitations as may be prescribed, the court
may, on the application of the decree-holder, order execution of the
decree(a) by delivery of any property specifically decreed;
(b) by attachment and sale or by the sale without attachment of
any property;
(c) by arrest and detention in prison for such period not
exceeding the period specified in section 58, where arrest and detention is
permissible under that section;
(d) by appointing a receiver; or
(e) in such other manner as the nature of the relief granted
may require:
PROVIDED that, where the decree is for the payment of
money, execution by detention in prison shall not be ordered unless, after
giving the judgment-debtor an opportunity of showing cause why he
should not be committed to prison, the court, for reasons recorded in
writing, is satisfied(a) that the judgment-debtor, with the object or effect of
obstructing or delaying the execution of the decree,(i) is likely to abscond or leave the local limits of the
jurisdiction of the Court, or
(ii) has, after the institution of the suit in which the
decree was passed, dishonestly transferred, concealed, or removed any
part of his property, or committed any other act of bad faith in relation to
his property, or
(b) that the judgment-debtor has, or has had since the date of
the decree, the means to pay the amount of the decree or some
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
substantial part thereof and refuses or neglects or has refused or
neglected to pay the same, or
(c) that the decree is for a sum for which the judgment-debtor
was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account.
Explanation : In the calculation of the means of the judgment-debtor for
the purposes of clause (b), there shall be left out of account any property
which, by or under any law or custom having the force of law for the time
being in force, is exempt from attachment in execution of the decree.”
(underline supplied)
This Court in Anilkumar’s case cited supra has entered a finding that the
entire scheme of Section 51 CPC clearly postulates the procedure to be
taken one after another in execution of a decree and Clause (b) of Section
51 CPC specifies the procedure to be applied in execution of a decree for
payment of money by the sale of property either with attachment or without
attachment. The subsequent provision, Clause (c) deals with yet another
method of execution by arrest and detention of judgment debtor and it is
included as a succeeding provision just after the normal method of
execution of a money decree by the sale of property of judgment-debtor
under Clause (b) and therefore held that when other alternatives are
available by way of sale of immovable property or other properties which are
under attachment and available for execution, there is no occasion to resort
to Clause (c) of Section 51 overriding Clause (b). Paragraph 3 of the said
judgment reads as follows:
“3. The entire scheme of Section 51 C.P.C. clearly postulates the procedure
to be taken one after another in execution of a decree. The clause (b) to
Section 51 C.P.C. specifies the procedure to be applied in execution of a
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
decree for payment of money by the sale of property either with attachment
or without attachment. The subsequent provision, clause (c) deals with yet
another method of execution by arrest and detention of judgment debtor. It
was included as a succeeding provision just after the normal method of
execution of a money decree by the sale of property of judgment-debtor
under clause (b), presumably as a precaution not to deprive the personal
liberty of a person guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution, unless
there is sufficient grounds for his arrest and detention in civil prison. Hence, it
is not permissible to bypass the normal method of execution by sale of
property under clause (b) so as to invoke clause (c) for the arrest and
detention of judgment-debtor. The court may order execution of a decree by
adopting clauses (a) to (e) attached to the main Section viz.,(a) by delivery of
any property specifically decreed (b) by attachment and sale or by sale
without attachment of any property (c) by arrest and detention in prison for
such period not exceeding the period specified in Section 58, where arrest
and detention is permissible under that Section (d) by appointing a receiver
or (e) in such other manner as the nature of the relief granted may require.
The entire scheme of Section 51 C.P.C. hence would show that the court
cannot exhaust the remedy under clause (c) by issuing warrant of arrest
against the judgment-debtor without exhausting clause (b) of Section 51 by
the sale of movable or immovable property, if any available. The principle
behind it is succinctly summarized by the Apex Court in Jolly George
Varghese and Another v. The Bank of Cochin [(1980) 2 SC 360]. The noble
principle under Article 21 of the Constitution that no person shall be deprived
of his life or personal liberty except according to the procedure established
by law is for protecting a person from being arrested and detained in prison
unnecessarily and it should be always in accordance with any of the
procedure established by law, which stands for and requires strict
compliance of its mandate and procedure. There cannot be any kind of
dilution since it is guaranteed under the Constitution, but with the abovesaid
exception, which requires strict adherence of both the mandate and
procedure and conditions to be satisfied under any of the law in force so as
to deprive the personal liberty of a particular person. In short, no warrant of
arrest or coercive steps can be initiated against the judgment-debtor, when a
property is available for sale by way of an attachment before judgment or at
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
the execution. The availability of any other method of execution of decree of
money either in part or in whole would exclude the extreme steps of
execution by arrest and detention till such property was completely
proceeded against or the property has become not available for execution for
any other valid reasons. When other alternatives are available by way of
immovable property or other properties which are under attachment and
available for execution, there may not be any occasion to resort to clause (c)
to Section 51 overriding clause (b). Further, the proviso attached to Section
51 C.P.C. deals with the restrictions imposed in issuing a warrant of arrest,
which can be issued on satisfaction of clause (a), (b) or (c) attached to that
proviso and would come into play only when clause (c) to Section 51 was
taken as a method of execution. Hence, it is not permissible to issue warrant
of arrest at the execution of a money decree under the premise of proviso
attached to Section 51 C.P.C. so as to prevent likelihood of absconding or
leaving the local limits of jurisdiction with the intent either to obstruct or to
delay the execution of the decree at the stage when the matter falls under
clause (b) of Section 51 C.P.C.. Necessarily, there is no scope for issuing a
warrant of arrest at the stage of clause (b) i.e. the sale of movable or
immovable property of judgment-debtor and till the completion of that stage,
no coercive steps either by issuance of warrant of arrest or detention in
prison can be resorted to. Further, a warrant of arrest that can be issued for
furnishing security or to show cause at the trial stage under Rule 1 of Order
XXXVIII C.P.C. cannot be extended to in an execution proceedings of a
decree for payment of money, except as stated above. In short, in order to
exhaust the method of execution by arrest and detention of the judgmentdebtor, it must be satisfied as a condition precedent that no other method of
recovery of the decree amount in execution is available. The mandate of
issuance of notice and the doctrine of 'no means' and 'lack of bonafides'
though relevant in the determination of issue under Rule 37 of Order XXI
C.P.C. r/w proviso attached to Section 51 C.P.C., may not have any
application with respect to a property which is available for attachment and
sale, which would otherwise fall under clause (b) of Section 51 C.P.C.. In
that stage or during the pendency of procedure under clause (b) for the sale
of movable or immovable property, no warrant of arrest against the
judgment-debtor can be issued.”
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
7.
On the contrary it is the contention of the learned
counsel for the respondent that the said finding in Anilkumar’s case cited
supra is contrary to the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
regarding the execution of a decree and also settled position of law as per
the judgments cited supra in support of his contentions.
8.
Order XXI Rule 30 CPC reads as follows:
“30. Decree for payment of money
Every decree for the payment of money, including a decree for
the payment of money as the alternative to some other relief, may be
executed by the detention in the civil prison of the judgment debtor, or by the
attachment and sale of his property, or by both.”
(underline supplied)
Order XXI Rule 21 CPC is also relevant for consideration which reads as
follows:
“21. Simultaneous execution
The court may, in its discretion, refuse execution at the same
time against the person and property of the judgment-debtor.”
As per Order XXI Rule 30 CPC every decree for payment of money may be
executed by detention in the civil prison of the judgment debtor or by
attachment and sale of his property, or by both. The issue regarding the
simultaneous invocation of both the methods for execution of the decree
was considered by the Apex Court in Shyam Singh‘s case cited supra,
paragraph 11 of the said judgment reads as follows:
“11. It has been said the difficulties of a litigant "begin when he has obtained
a decree". It is a matter of common knowledge that far too many obstacles
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
are placed in the way of a decree holder who seeks to execute his decree
against the property of the judgment debtor. Perhaps because of that there is
no statutory provision against a number of execution proceedings continuing
concurrently. S.51 of the Code gives an option to the creditor, of enforcing
the decree either against the person or the property of the debtor; and
nowhere it has been laid down that execution against the person of the
debtor shall not be allowed unless and until the decree holder has exhausted
his remedy against the property. O.21, R.30 of the Code provides that "every
decree for the payment of money, including a decree for the payment of
money as the alternative to some other relief, may be executed by the
detention in the civil prison of the judgment debtor, or by the attachment and
sale of his property, or by both".
Considering the provisions of Order XXI Rule 30 CPC and the provisions of
Order XXI Rule 21 and the judgment in Shyam Singh‘s case cited supra, a
Division Bench of this Court in Leelakumari’s case cited supra has held as
follows:
“6. We shall first deal with the contention regarding the legality of initiation
of simultaneous proceedings for execution of the decree. Order 21 Rule
30 of the Code reads as under:
“30. Decree for payment of money - Every decree for the
payment of money, including a decree for the payment of
money as the alternative to some other relief, may be
executed by the detention in the civil prison of the judgment debtor, or by the attachment and sale of his property, or by
both."
Order 21 Rule 21 of the Code states as follows:
“21. Simultaneous execution.- The Court may, in its
discretion, refuse execution at the same time against the
person and property of the judgment-debtor."
A bare perusal of the provision contained in Order 21 Rule 30 of the Code
would reveal that simultaneous execution of a decree for payment of
money, including a decree for the payment of money as the alternative to
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
some other relief, against the property and person of the judgment-debtor
is permissible.
7. In Shyam Singh vs Collector, District Hamirpur : 1993 Supp (1) SCC
693, the Apex Court has held as follows:
“It has been said the difficulties of a litigant "begin when he
has obtained a decree". It is a matter of common knowledge
that far too many obstacles are placed in the way of a decree
holder who seeks to execute his decree against the property
of the judgment debtor. Perhaps because of that there is no
statutory
provision
against
a
number
of
execution
proceedings continuing concurrently. Section 51 of the Code
gives an option to the creditor, of enforcing the decree either
against the person or the property of the debtor; and nowhere
it has been laid down that execution against the person of the
debtor shall not be allowed unless and until the decree holder
has exhausted his remedy against the property”. (emphasis
supplied)
Therefore, there can be no doubt with regard to the position of law that
the decree holder is entitled to simultaneously proceed against the person
and property of the judgment debtor.
(underline supplied)
This Court in Anjengo Coir Mattings’s case cited supra has also upheld
the said proposition of law and held that there is no bar in law to proceed
simultaneously against the person and property of judgment-debtor in
execution of a decree.
9.
In view of the provisions of law as stated above and the
judgments cited supra, I am of the opinion that the view taken in
Anilkumar’s case cited supra that proceedings under Clause (b) and (c) of
Section 51 CPC cannot be initiated simultaneously is not the correct
proposition of law and the same has been rendered without considering the
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
decision laid down in Shyam Singh’s case and Leelakumari’s case cited
supra.
10.
However, it is also to be noted that Order XXI Rule 21
CPC, which deals with simultaneous execution, gives the court discretion to
refuse execution at the same time against a person and property of the
judgment debtor as the principle underlying the above provision is to
prevent harassment of judgment debtor by the decree holder under the
guise of execution of the decree. The court has to exercise such discretion
considering the facts and circumstances of each case. The petitioner will be
at liberty to appraise the court that such special circumstance exists in the
present case so as to invoke the provisions of Order XXI Rule 21 CPC,
which if raised, shall be duly considered by the execution court in
accordance with law.
11.
The next aspect to be considered is the contention of
the petitioner that the procedure as contemplated under Order XXI Rule
40(1) CPC has not been followed before the issuance of Ext.P3 order. A
perusal of Ext.P3 order would reveal that it is a cryptic order without
assigning any reasons and without considering any of the contentions of the
petitioner in his counter statement. Ext.P3 order is extracted below:
“Arrest batta paid. Issue warrant of arrest. Return of warrant.30.07.2024.”
12.
A perusal of Ext.P3 order reveals that the court has not
recorded in writing the reasons for reaching a conclusion that the judgment
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
debtor has sufficient means to pay the decree debt and he had wilfully
evaded payment of the same. Going by Section 51 CPC when the decree is
for payment of money, execution by detention in prison shall not be ordered
unless after giving the judgment debtor an opportunity to show cause why
he should not be committed to prison and the court for reasons recorded in
writing, is satisfied that the judgment debtor has or had since the date of
decree the means to pay the amount of the decree or some substantial part
thereof and refuses or neglects or has refused or neglected to pay the
same. Likewise, Order XXI Rule 40 CPC also provides for the procedure to
be followed by the court on the appearance of the judgment debtor in
obedience to notice or after arrest, the court shall proceed to hear the
decree-holder and shall take all such evidence as may be produced by him
in support of his application for execution and shall then give the judgment
debtor an opportunity of showing cause why he should not be committed to
civil prison. A similar issue was considered by this Court in Leelakumari’s
case cited supra, the relevant portion of which reads as follows:
“13. A close reading of Clause (b) of the proviso to Section 51 of the Code
reveals that before passing an order for detention of the judgment-debtor in
prison, the Court, for reasons recorded in writing, shall be satisfied that the
judgment-debtor has, or has had since the date of the decree, the means
to pay the amount of the decree or some substantial part thereof and that
he refuses or neglects or has refused or neglected to pay the same. The
burden of proving the means of the judgment-debtor to pay the decree debt
is on the decree holder. If there is prima facie material on record regarding
the means of the judgment debtor, it is for the judgment debtor to prove
otherwise because he is in a better position to know his assets. On a
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
reading of the proviso to Section 51 of the Code it is evident that the court
shall be not only satisfied with regard to the means of the judgment-debtor
to pay the decree debt or a substantial part of it but it has also to record in
writing the reasons for reaching such satisfaction.
14. In the present case, the order dated 21.04.2018 passed by the
execution court shows that the court was satisfied that the judgment-debtor
had sufficient means to pay the decree debt and that he had wilfully
evaded payment of the same. However, the court has not recorded in
writing the reasons for reaching the said conclusion. True, it is a case in
which the first and the second judgment-debtors did not file any objection
to the application E.A.No.33 of 2017. It appears that they did not raise any
plea of no means. It is also true that they did not adduce any evidence
during the enquiry in the execution petition. However, it will not enable the
court to dispense with the requirement under the proviso to Section 51 of
the Code to record reasons in writing for arriving at a conclusion regarding
the means of the judgment-debtor and his refusal or neglect to pay the
decree debt. It is a case in which the decree holder was examined as PW1
and she has given evidence regarding the means of the first and the
second judgment-debtors to pay the decree debt. She was also crossexamined by the judgment-debtors. The execution court has not stated
anything in its order dated 21.04.2018 regarding the evidence of PW1 or
the challenge made by the judgment-debtors to such evidence in the cross
examination. In short, the order dated 21.04.2018 passed by the execution
court is not a speaking order stating the reasons for arriving at the
conclusion regarding the means of the judgment-debtors to pay the decree
debt.
15. It is incumbent upon the courts to pass speaking and reasoned orders.
Giving reasons for conclusions is an essential element of administration of
justice. Reasons are the links between the material, the foundation for their
erection and the actual conclusions. They would also demonstrate how the
mind of the maker was activated and actuated and their rational nexus and
synthesis with the facts considered and the conclusions reached (See
Krishna Swami v. Union of India:AIR 1993 SC 1407). Judicial orders must
be supported by reasons recorded in them. While deciding an issue, the
court is bound to give reasons for its conclusion. It is the duty and
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
obligation of the court to record reasons. Giving of reasons has always
been insisted upon as one of the fundamentals of sound administration of
the justice-delivery system, to make it known that there had been proper
and due application of mind to the issue before the court and also as an
essential requisite of the principles of natural justice. Recording of reasons
for a decision is an essential attribute of judicial and judicious disposal of a
matter by a court. It is the only indication to know about the manner and
quality of the exercise undertaken. Reasons shall be given for reaching a
conclusion so as to reflect application of mind by the court. Reason
introduces clarity in an order. Reasons substitute subjectivity with
objectivity.
Absence
of
reasons
renders
an
order
indefensible/
unsustainable particularly when the order is subject to further challenge
before a higher forum. Reasons ensure transparency and fairness in
decision making (See Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin : (2012) 8 SCC
148).”
(underline supplied)
A perusal of Ext P3 order reveals total lack of reasoning and therefore the
same is a non-speaking order.
In view of the above facts and circumstances, though the
contention raised by the petitioner relying on AnilKumar’s case cited supra
is repelled, for non-compliance with the procedures as contemplated in
Section 51 as well as Order XXI Rule 40 CPC, I am inclined to interfere with
Ext.P3, which is a cryptic order passed without assigning any reasons.
Accordingly, Ext.P3 order dated 23.05.2024 in E.P.No.53 of 2022 is set
aside with a consequential direction to the execution court to reconsider the
matter in the light of the observations made above and after giving sufficient
opportunity to the decree-holder and judgment debtor to substantiate their
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
case strictly in accordance with the provisions of Section 51 and Order XXI
Rule 40 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
Accordingly, the original petition is disposed of.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
cks
OP(C) NO. 1319 OF 2024
2024:KER:58721
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1319/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P 1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE EXECUTION PETITION,
EP 53/2022 IN ARC 758/2022 ON THE FILE OF
THE COURT OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE,
PAYYANNUR.
Exhibit P 2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER STATEMENT
FILED BY THE PETITIONER HEREIN IN EP
53/2022 IN ARC 758/2019 ON THE FILE OF
THE COURT OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE,
PAYYANUR.
Exhibit P 3
THE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
23.05.2024 IN EP 53/2022 ON THE FILE OF
THE COURT OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE,
PAYYANNUR.
Exhibit P 4
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT REPORTED IN
2023(5)KHC 341 BY THIS HONBLE COURT.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review