Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:16891
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MAT.APPEAL NO. 357 OF 2016
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 04.02.2016 IN OP NO.12 OF 2014 OF
FAMILY COURT, VATAKARA
----APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
ABDULLA,
S/O.ANDRU HAJI, AGED 30, THAZHE PUTHOYOTTIL HOUSE,
VANIMEL P.O., VADAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
AYISHA,
W/O.ANDRU HAJI, AGED 52, THAZHE PUTHOYOTTIL HOUSE,
VANIMEL P.O., VADAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
BY ADV SRI.ABDURAHIMAN VAYALIL PEEDIKAYIL
M. MUHAMMED SHAFI
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
BAREERA,
D/O.AHMMAD, 21 YEARS, OTHAYOTH THAZHA KUNIYI HOUSE,
P.O.KADAMERI, VADAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT-673 101.
BY ADVS.
SMT.KAVERY S THAMPI
SRI.K.M.SATHYANATHA MENON
THIS
MATRIMONIAL
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
ON
28.02.2025, ALONG WITH CO.93/2016, MAT. APPEAL NO.567/2016, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:16891
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
CO NO. 93 OF 2016
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 04.02.2016 IN OP NO.12 OF 2014 OF
FAMILY COURT, VATAKARA
----CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENT:
BAREERA,
D/O. AHMMAD, OTHAYOTH THAZHA KUNIYIL HOUSE,
P.O.KADAMERI, VADAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT-673 101.
BY ADVS.
SRI.K.M.SATHYANATHA MENON
SMT.KAVERY S THAMPI
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS:
ABDULLA,
S/O. ANDRU HAJI, THAZHE PUTHOYOTTIL HOUSE,
VANIMEL P.O., VADAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT-673 506.
AYISHA,
W/O. ANDRU HAJI, THAZHE PUTHOYOTTIL HOUSE,VANIMEL P.O.,
VADAKARA TALUK, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT-673 506.
BY ADV SRI.ABDURAHIMAN VAYALIL PEEDIKAYIL
THIS
CROSS
OBJECTION
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
ON
28.02.2025, ALONG WITH Mat.Appeal.357/2016 AND CONNECTED CASE, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:16891
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MAT.APPEAL NO. 567 OF 2016
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 04.02.2016 IN OP NO.13 OF 2014 OF
FAMILY COURT, VATAKARA
----APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
ABDULLA, S/O ANDRU HAJI,
AGED 30,
THAZHE PUTHOYOTTIL HOUSE, VANIMEL P.O., VADAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DIST.
BY ADVS.
SRI.ABDURAHIMAN VAYALIL PEEDIKAYIL
SRI.M.MUHAMMED SHAFI
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS:
BAREERA,
D/O. AHMMAD, 21 YEARS, OTHAYOTH THAZHA KUNIYIL HOUSE,
P.O. KADAMERI, VADAKARA TALUK. KOZHIKODE- DIST-673 101.
MUHAMMED RISWAN,
S/O. ABDULLA (MINOR), REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER,
BAREERA, D/O. AHMMAD 21 YEARS,
OTHAYOTH THAZHA KUNIYIL HOUSE, P.O. KADAMERI,
VADAKARA TALUK,
KOZHIKODE DIST-673 101.
BY ADVS.
SMT.KAVERY S THAMPI
SRI.K.M.SATHYANATHA MENON
THIS
MATRIMONIAL
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
ON
28.02.2025, ALONG WITH Mat.Appeal.357/2016 AND CONNECTED CASE, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:16891
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
&
Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 28th day of February, 2025
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
Mat Appeal No.357 of 2016 is by the wife, and the
cross objection therein is by the husband and his mother
respectively, challenging the part of the decree against
them in an Original Petition filed for return of gold
ornaments. Mat Appeal No.567 of 2016 is filed by the
husband, challenging the decree for past maintenance.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
hereinafter referred to as “the husband”, “the mother”,
and “the wife”.
3. According to the wife, at the time of marriage
she was provided with 56 sovereigns of gold ornaments.
She was provided with 10 and ¼ sovereigns of gold
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 2 :-
ornaments as Mahar. All the ornaments were taken by the
husband without leaving anything to wear even during the
social visit and on festivals. Subsequently she was
returned 2.5 sovereigns of gold ornaments. After the
delivery of a child her father again provided her with
12 sovereigns of gold ornaments. The parties fell apart.
The original petition was filed seeking return of 63.75
sovereigns of gold ornaments or its value.
4. The husband filed a counter statement wherein
the claim of the wife that she had 56 sovereigns of gold
ornaments at the time of marriage was denied. It was
contended that she had only very small quantity of gold
ornaments. The allegation that all the gold ornaments
were taken by the husband was denied. It was contended
that the entire gold ornaments of the wife was always
with her. The claim that after the delivery of the child
the
wife
was
provided
ornaments
by
her
contended
that
with
father,
the
wife's
was
sovereigns
also
father
of
gold
It
was
pledged
denied.
had
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 3 :-
sovereigns of gold ornaments with the Apollo Gold at
Vadakara.
He
prayed
for
dismissal
of
the
Original
Petition.
5. The Family Court found that there is no direct
evidence
with
regard
to
the
quantity
of
gold
that
belonged to the wife. It was observed that the husband
admitted that the wife had 40.5 sovereigns of gold
ornaments. A decree was accordingly granted for return
of the same.
6. With regard to the claim for past maintenance,
though the claim was for three years, the Family Court
granted a decree for only six months. Though the claim
was for ₹ 6,000/- for the wife and ₹ 2,000/- for the
child who was aged less than one and a half years, the
decree was for ₹ 4,000/- and ₹ 2,000/- respectively for
the wife and the child. The learned counsel for the
husband submits that the husband is not very serious
with regard to the challenge against the same.
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 4 :-
7. We have heard learned counsel on either side.
8. With regard to the quantity of gold ornaments,
no documentary evidence is available on record. In the
written statement, the fact that the wife was possessed
of some gold ornaments is not denied. The claim is that
the quantity is less. It is also stated that the wife
claimed the quantity to be 40.5 sovereigns. He has not
disputed such claim of the wife.
9. Ext.A1 is the certified copy of the complaint
filed by the husband before the Judicial First Class
Magistrate's
Court,
against
his
in-laws,
alleging
illegal detention of his wife and child. Therein at
paragraph 6 it is stated thus :“(6) വവിവവാഹ സമയതത്ത് 3--വാ-ാം എതവിർ കകവിക്കുണവായവിരുന്ന 40 1/2 പവൻ
സസ്വർണവാഭരണങ്ങളവിൽ 25 പവൻ സസ്വർണവാഭരണങ്ങൾ 1--വാ-ാം എതവിർ കകവിയുടട
ആവശശ്യതവിനുവവണവി 3--വാ-ാം എതവിർ കകവിടയ ഉപവയവാഗവിചത്ത് വടകര അവപവാവളവാ
വഗവാൾഡത്ത് എന്ന സവാപനതവിൽ വചത്ത് അതവിടന്റെ അന്നടത സ-ാംഖശ്യയുടട പലവിശ
വവാങ്ങവിടയടുക്കുന്നതവിവലകത്ത്
എഗവിടമന്റെത്ത്
ഉണവാക്കുകയു-ാം
ആയതത്ത്
3--വാ-ാം
എതൃകകവിയവിൽ നവിന-ാം 1--വാ-ാം എതവിർകകവി കകപറവിടകവാണവിരവിക്കുന്നതവായവി
ഹരജവികവാരനത്ത് മനസവിലവാകവാൻ കഴവിഞവിരവിക്കുന.”
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 5 :-
Therefore, even according to the husband, the wife had
40.5 sovereigns of gold ornaments. His claim is that,
from
out
of
the
said
quantity,
sovereigns
were
pledged by her father at one Apollo Gold Jewellery Shop
at
Vadakara.
In
the
said
background
it
could
be
concluded that the wife had 40.5 sovereigns of gold
ornaments at the time of marriage.
10. With regard to the pledging of 25 sovereigns of
gold
ornaments
by
the
father
with
the
Apollo
Gold
Jewellery, an application was filed as IA 681/2015 to
direct the Manager of the Apollo Gold
Jewellery to
produce the documents relating to the pledging of gold
ornaments by the wife or her father. The manager filed a
statement
to
the
effect
that
there
is
no
such
transaction. Therefore, the claim of the husband with
regard
to
the
pledging
of
sovereigns
ornaments by the wife's father fails.
of
gold
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 6 :-
11. With regard to the claim for the remaining
quantity of gold, there is no evidence. The learned
counsel for the wife would argue that, the wife in her
oral evidence has deposed with precision the details of
the gold ornaments and hence there is no reason to
disbelieve her. According to the counsel, her evidence
is to be accepted and the quantity of the gold ornaments
as claimed by her is to be upheld. However, it is to be
noticed that, as PW1 it was her definite case that the
ornaments were purchased from a particular jewellery
shop, in connection with the marriage. She could have
produced some documents or examined some person from the
shop to prove the said fact. On the failure to do so, we
are unable to uphold her claim regarding the quantity of
the gold ornaments solely relying on the oral evidence.
Hence we are in agreement with the finding of the Family
Court
that
the
wife
had
40.5
sovereigns
of
gold
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 7 :-
ornaments with her at the time of marriage.
12. Even according to the wife 2.5 sovereigns of
gold ornaments were returned to her. It is only probable
that the wife must have been in possession of ornaments
for her daily wear which would approximately be around 5
sovereigns. After making such deductions the remaining
quantity could be rounded off to 33 sovereigns. The
decree of the Family Court is liable to be modified
accordingly.
13. The learned counsel for the husband would argue
that there is no evidence with regard to the entrustment
and misappropriation. The Family Court has proceeded as
if in Ext.A1 the husband admitted about the entrustment
and
misappropriation
of
gold
by
the
husband.
The
relevant statements in Ext.A1 could at best be taken
only as admission regarding the quantity of the gold
ornaments
and
not
regarding
entrustment
or
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 8 :-
misappropriation,
it
is
argued.
While
we
are
in
agreement with the learned counsel on such contention,
we do notice that it is the definite case of the wife
that a week after the marriage the husband had required
her to hand over all the gold ornaments to his mother.
As PW1 she has vouched to such statement. It is the case
of the husband that whatever gold ornaments the wife had
is with her. It is difficult to believe that at the
matrimonial home, the wife had kept 40 sovereigns of
gold ornaments in her exclusive possession. With regard
to entrustment, it would be very difficult to secure
evidence. In the normal course of events, it is very
improbable that the wife would have kept the ornaments
with herself.(See Bexy Michael v. A.J.Michael [2010 (4) KHC 376)],
Pankajakshan Nair v. Shylaja & Anr. [2017 (1) KHC 620], Rajesh P.P. & Anr. v.
Deepthi P.R. [2021 (4) KLT 455]). The Family Court has, on the
evidence, chosen to accept the evidence of the wife with
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 9 :-
regard to entrustment. No material is brought to our
notice to dislodge the said finding. Hence the same
calls for no interference.
14.
The
wife
has
filed
a
cross
objection
challenging the decree of the Family Court insofar as it
did not grant decree for the entire quantity of the gold
ornaments as claimed by her. We have already declined
such
claim.
Yet
another
ground
on
which
the
cross
objection is filed is with regard to the value of the
gold ornaments. The Family Court has directed return of
the gold ornaments or its value which the Court fixed at
₹ 20,000/- per sovereign. The Court could not have fixed
such value since the value is a fluctuating one. The
wife
is
entitled
to
the
value
at
the
time
of
realisation. [See: Syamini S. Nair & ors. v. Sreekanth. R (2022(3) KHC 145),
Vipin Kumar v. Remyamol (2023 SCC OnLine Ker 7675)] .
The cross
objection is liable to be allowed to the said extent.
Mat. Appeal No.357 of 2016 &
Cross Objection No.93 of 2016,
& Mat. Appeal 567 of 2016
2025:KER:16891
-: 10 :-
Resultantly, Mat Appeal 357 of 2016 is allowed in
part. The quantity of the gold ornaments liable to be
returned will stand re-fixed at 33 sovereigns. The Cross
Objection filed therein will stand allowed to the extent
of allowing the wife to realise the market value of the
sovereigns
realisation.
of
gold
ornaments
at
Mat.
Appeal
No.567
of
the
time
will
of
stand
dismissed. Parties to bear their respective costs.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review