Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.104419 OF 2025 (CPC)
BETWEEN:
ABDULKHADAR S/O. MOHAMMADHANIF KOLUR,
AGE. 57 YEARS, OCC. COMPANY SERVICE,
R/O. 5498, OSCAR, PETERSON BLVD,
MISSISSAUGA, ONTARIA STATE,
CANADA NOW RESIDING AT KHADAR
MANZIL VALVEKAR PLOT, KESHWAPUR
HUBBALLI-580009, TQ. HUBBALLI, DIST. DHARWAD.
…APPELLANT
(BY SMT. PALLAVI A.PACHHAPURE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
MOHAMMADFAROOK
S/O. MOHAMMADALI YATNATTI,
AGE. 50 YEARS, OCC. PRINTING BUSINESS,
R/O. 3211, MICROGRAPHICS PRINTING PRESS,
WARD NO.6, GUGGARI PET, ILKAL,
TQ. ILKAL, DIST. BAGALKOT-587101.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. SANTOSHKUMAR G.RAMPUR, ADVOCATE)
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER ORDER
43 RULE (1) R/W SECTION 104 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE,
1908, PRAYING TO, SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 25.09.2025
PASSED ON I.A. NO.1 IN O.S. NO.219/2025 BY THE COURT OF
SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, HUNGUND AND THE I.A. NO.1 FILED
BY THE PLAINTIFF FOR GRANT OF TEMPORARY INJUNCTION NOT TO
ALIENATE AND NOT TO ENCUMBER THE SUIT SCHEDULE PLOTS TILL
THE DISPOSAL OF THE SUIT, MAY KINDLY BE GRANTED, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL, COMING ON FOR
ORDERS, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI
CORAM:
ORAL JUDGMENT
Aggrieved by the order passed on I.A.No.I in O.S.
No.219/2025 dated 25.09.2025 by the Senior Civil Judge &
J.M.F.C., Hungund, the plaintiff is before this Court. The plaintiff
had filed the suit for declaration that he is the owner of the suit
Schedule ‘A’ plots, to restrain the defendant by permanent
injunction and not to interfere with the peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the suit Schedule ‘A’ plots. In the said suit, I.A.
No.I
is
filed
seeking
injunction
restraining
the
respondent/defendant from alienating the Schedule ‘A’ plots.
2.
It is the specific case of the plaintiff that, he migrated
to Canada in the year 2002 and has been working there as
Structural Engineer and his wife is also working as a Data
Analyst in Canada since 2006. They are drawing a salary of
₹6,75,000/- and ₹1,75,000/- respectively. The plaintiff’s sister is
married to the defendant, who is a permanent resident of Ilkal
town and he is running a printing press and having hand to
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
mouth source of livelihood from the income of printing press. As
the plaintiff is having enough resources, he wanted to purchase a
land at Ilkal town and also felt it safe to invest in land at Inkal.
The plaintiff had decided to purchase land and started sending
money to the joint account of his sister and brother-in-law from
the month of November, 2010, by instructing the defendant to
search for a suitable land near Ilkal town. The plaintiff had
already purchased 4 acres of land in the industrial area of Ilkal,
which was sold by him in two strips of 2 acres each in the year
2012 and 2022 respectively and had enough money in addition
to his service to invest in new land and for its development. The
defendant suggested the plaintiff to purchase the land in the
defendant’s name, as the plaintiff was residing in Canada and it
was practically inconvenient for him to acquire the land in his
own name. Further, post-sale activities such as conversion of the
land from agricultural to non-agricultural use, obtaining layout
approvals from the competent authorities, and undertaking and
supervising infrastructure development works for the formation
of plots required continuous local presence. As the plaintiff had
trust in the defendant, the property was purchased in the name
of the defendant on 13.08.2012. It is the case of the plaintiff
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
that, he had paid an amount of Rs.68,80,000/- to the defendant
out of his and his wife's joint account with ICICI Bank. The entire
sale consideration of the land under sale deed dated 13.08.2012
has been paid out of the amount invested by the plaintiff from
his account and his wife's account. The plaintiff used to come to
India and also used to look at the developments. He has also
paid the supervision fee of Rs.11,33,470/- and the entire
development works are being executed at the costs of the
plaintiff. It is the case that the plaintiff had invested more than
Rs.1,00,00,000/- through his account and his wife's account for
the period between 01.01.2013 and 03.04.2025. The plaintiff has
produced the extract of the statement of Bank accounts of his
wife and himself. The developmental works were undertaken
with the money that was sent by the plaintiff. 70% of the suit
Schedule ‘A’ plots are released for sale by the CMC Authorities.
The defendant has devised a plan to sell the said plots on his
own,
falsely
propagating
claiming
such
ownership
claims
to
thereof,
prospective
and
has
begun
purchasers.
The
intervention of the elders has not yielded any fruits. Hence, the
plaintiff is constrained to file a suit.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
3.
In response to that, the defendant had filed his
written statement. It is the case of the defendant that, he has
purchased the property in the year 2012. After lapse of 13 years,
that too after entire land is developed, the plaintiff is seeking to
declare him as owner, which is clearly barred by the law of
limitation and the plaintiff has not approached the Court with
clean hands and he is not entitled for temporary injunction. It is
the case that the defendant has repaid the amount to the
plaintiff that was borrowed from time to time, except some
balance
amount.
But,
the
plaintiff
did
not
question
the
repayment of the amount. He accepted the payment made by
the defendant. It is stated that the plaintiff, being a greedy
person, considering how the lands have become valuable, has
come up with this suit. The plaintiff has no material evidence to
prove his ownership. As such, he is not entitled for injunction
and the defendant being a true owner of the property is entitled
to sell the property. It is also stated that, the plaintiff is an
interest-free lender, as he is the brother of the defendant's wife.
The defendant has denied all the averments made by the plaintiff
and it is stated that the plaintiff is habitual in filing false cases on
respondent, his family and friends and for his every false case,
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
respondent has contested in hope of winning, as false would
never win.
4.
The Trial Court by order impugned rejected I.A. No.I
filed by the plaintiff seeking injunction by restraining the
defendant from alienating the suit Schedule ‘A’ plots. While
dismissing the application, the Trial Court has observed that, the
sale deeds show that the defendant is the absolute owner of the
property, thus, the temporary injunction cannot be granted
against the true owner of the property and the plaintiff has to
prove that, he has advanced the amount only for the purpose of
purchasing the land and conversion of the land into plots,
otherwise, the plaintiff will not succeed in the case. Further, if
this application is allowed, the defendant will be put to untold
hardship which cannot be compensated in terms of money and
on the other hand, if this application is not allowed, no harm will
be caused to the plaintiff. The Trial Court had considered the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of JAYDAYAL
PODDAR AND ANOTHER Vs. MST. BIBI HAZRA AND ORS.1, relied
upon by the plaintiff with regard to the benami transactions. The
Court has come to the conclusion that, at this stage, it cannot
AIR 1974 SC 171
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
look into the said judgment. The Court has also come to the
conclusion that, the plaintiff has not established prima facie case
and the plaintiff is not entitled to the equitable relief of
temporary injunction, as the balance of convenience has not
tilted in his favour in respect to the suit property, therefore, the
application came to be rejected.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/plaintiff
submits that, additional evidence is filed before this Court under
Order
XLI
Rule
of
CPC,
wherein,
all
the
WhatsApp
conversation between the parties are placed, which clearly shows
that the amount that is given to the defendant is for the purpose
of purchasing the property and the property is purchased with
the money belonging to the Plaintiff and now as an afterthought,
the defendant denied the title of the plaintiff to the suit Schedule
property. It is submitted that, if the defendant sells away the
entire property, the purpose of filing suit itself will be frustrated
and in fact, by placing the account details before the Court and
even the acceptance of the defendant in the written statement
clearly shows that the plaintiff has lent the money to the
defendant for purchase of the property. It is submitted that, the
Trial Court had failed to understand and interpret what are the
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
ingredients for grant of injunction and without any basis, the
Trial Court has held that, no prejudice would be caused to the
plaintiff. It is submitted that, in the facts and circumstances of
the case, the plaintiff is entitled for injunction as sought for.
6.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent/
defendant submits that, as there is no prima facie title in favour
of the plaintiff, the balance of convenience does not lie with the
plaintiff, nor would any irreparable loss be caused to him if the
Court had dismissed the application. The plaintiff has failed to
establish that he is entitled for any relief from the Court. There is
no document to show that, at the behest of the plaintiff, the
property is purchased by the defendant. There is no dispute
about the fact that the defendant has lent the money and in fact,
out of Rs.1,00,00,000/-, Rs.50,00,000/- and odd is already paid
to the plaintiff and he is ready to pay the remaining amount. The
plaintiff has a remedy for recovery of money or any other relief
which he is entitled, but he is not entitled for declaration of title.
Further, it is submitted that, they have not sought for recovery
of possession. Without seeking for the recovery of possession,
they are not entitled for relief. It is submitted that, if any
purchase is made during the pendency of the proceedings,
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act will take care of the
subsequent sales. It is submitted that, the respondent is the true
owner of the property and there cannot be an injunction against
the true owner. The Trial Court, considering all these aspects,
had rightly rejected the application. He further submits that the
petitioner, without making any factual basis for these WhatsApp
conversations, at this stage, he cannot file these documents by
way of additional evidence. Relying on order dated 11.02.2025
passed by
the
Co-ordinate
Bench
of this Court
in W.P.
No.106017/2024 at paragraph Nos.8 and 9 it is submitted that,
the defendant is not entitled for any relief from this Court.
Paragragh Nos.8 and 9 of the said order read thus:
“8. Thus, in conclusion, the Trial Court was right in
holding that no prima facie case has been made out
by the plaintiffs and that the balance of convenience
lies in favour of the defendants. Furthermore, though
the defendants being the owners under a registered
sale deed, a true owner cannot be injuncted from
dealing with the properties.
9. Be that as it may, any alienation of the properties if
effected by the defendants would be subject to the
principle of lis pendens under section 52 of the
Transfer of Property Act. Since the suit is one for
declaration of title and cancellation of sale deeds, no
injunction can be granted.”
7.
Then relying on the judgment of the Delhi High Court
in the case of EARTHZ URBAN SPACES PVT LTD Vs. RAVINDER
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
MUNSHI & ORS dated 09.10.2025 at paragraph Nos.18, 19 and
20 it is submitted that, the injunction cannot be granted.
Paragragh Nos.18, 19 and 20 of the said order read thus:
18. Senior counsels for the defendants have placed
reliance on the judgment of a Coordinate Bench of this
Court in Santokh Singh v. Shagun Farm Pvt. Ltd., 2017
SCC OnLine Del 6844. Paragraphs 25 and 26 of the said
judgment read as under:
“25. The genesis of the judgment in Vinod
Seth supra was the prejudice suffered by the
defendant in a suit for specific performance of an
Agreement of Sale of immovable property even in
the absence of any restraint order against him,
due to applicability of the principle of lis pendens
and
which
virtually
makes
the
property
inalienable or unencumberable at market rates
and with no measure left to compensate the
defendant in the event of the plaintiff in the suit
for specific performance ultimately failing. The
costs of the suit even if awarded to the defendant
in such a situation were not found sufficient to
compensate the defendant. Supreme Court in
Vinod Sethi held that a Court is justified in taking
a view that on material till then on record, the
likelihood of the plaintiff succeeding in the suit or
securing any interim relief against the defendant
is remote and to exempt the suit property from
the operation of Section 52 of the Transfer of
Property Act so that the defendant would have the
liberty to deal with the property in any manner
inspite of the pendency of the suit. I have in Rajiv
Maira v. Apex Apartments Pvt. Ltd. (2013) 138
DRJ 464 so exempted the property subject matter
of that proceedings and SLP (C) No. 5920/2014
preferred
thereagainst
was
dismissed
on
24th March, 2014.
26. I am, for the reasons here after appearing,
of the view that chances of the plaintiffs
succeeding in this suit for specific performance
are remote and there would be no way to
compensate the defendant for the prejudice
caused from applicability of Section 52 of the
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
Transfer of Property Act during the pendency of
the suit which though has to be put to trial.”
19. Taking into account the conduct of the plaintiff
in the aforesaid case, the court observed that the
doctrine of lispendens will not apply to the property
that was subject matter of the suit and the defendant
therein would be free to deal with the property.
Counsel for the plaintiff submits that the aforesaid
judgment was passed prior to the amendment of the
Specific Relief Act in 2018 and therefore, would not
apply to the present case. I do not agree. The
observations of the aforesaid judgment would be
squarely applicable to the facts of the present case, on
account of the following factors:
(i) The transcripts of the WhatsApp messages filed
on behalf of the plaintiff do not establish any
oral agreement between the parties.
(ii) The transcripts of the WhatsApp messages of
27th April, 2021 have been selectively extracted
in the plaint and material parts thereof, have
been deliberately omitted so as to mislead the
court.
(iii) The case of an ‘Oral Agreement to Sell’ has
been set up only for the first time in the plaint.
In the legal notice sent on behalf of the
plaintiff to the defendants, the case was
completely based on the MoU dated 2nd June,
2021.
(iv) A perusal of the aforesaid MoU clearly show
that it is not a binding agreement between the
parties and therefore, cannot be enforced in a
court of law.
(v) No proof of payment of any amount to the
defendants has been produced on behalf of the
plaintiff. The cheque bearing no. 001082
amounting to Rs. 2 lakhs wrongly records the
name of the defendant no. 3.
20. Taking into account the aforesaid, I am of the view
that the likelihood of the plaintiff succeeding in the
present suit is remote and therefore, it is a fit case to
exempt the suit property from the operation of Section
52 of the Transfer of Property Act during the pendency
of the suit. Great prejudice would be caused to the
defendants if upon issuance of summons in the suit, the
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
doctrine of lispendens is applied in respect of the suit
property.”
8.
Then, he also relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of IQBAL AHMED (DEAD) BY LRS.
AND ANOTHER Vs. ABDUL SHUKOOR2 at paragraph No.8 which
reads as follows:
“8. In our opinion, before undertaking the exercise of
considering whether a party is entitled to lead additional
evidence under Order XLI Rule 27(1) of the Code, it would
be first necessary to examine the pleadings of such party
to gather if the case sought to be set up is pleaded so as to
support the additional evidence that is proposed to be
brought on record. In absence of necessary pleadings in
that regard, permitting a party to lead additional evidence
would result in an unnecessary exercise and such
evidence, if led, would be of no consequence as it may not
be permissible to take such evidence into consideration.
Useful reference in this regard can be made to the
decisions in Bachhaj Nahar Vs. Nilima Mandal and Anr., AIR
2009 SC 1103 and Union of India Vs. Ibrahim Uddin and
Anr., (2012) 8 SCC 148. Thus, besides the requirements
prescribed by Order XLI Rule 27(1) of the Code being
fulfilled, it would also be necessary for the Appellate Court
to consider the pleadings of the party seeking to lead such
additional evidence. It is only thereafter on being satisfied
that a case as contemplated by the provisions of Order XLI
Rule 27(1) of the Code has been made out that such
permission can be granted. In absence of such exercise
being undertaken by the High Court in the present case,
we are of the view that it committed an error in allowing
the application moved by the defendant for leading
additional evidence.”
9.
In response to the above, learned counsel appearing
for the plaintiff submits that, they have already taken steps for
2025 INSC 1027
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
amending the prayer seeking recovery of possession. Further it is
submitted that, the application filed under Order XLI Rule 27 of
CPC placing the additional evidence can be considered by this
Court. She has relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of SANJAY KUMAR SINGH Vs. THE STATE OF
JHARKHAND3 at paragraph No.4 which reads as follows:
“4. It is true that the general principle is that the
appellate court should not travel outside the record of
the lower court and cannot take any evidence in
appeal. However, as an exception, Order 41 Rule 27
CPC enables the appellate court to take additional
evidence in exceptional circumstances. It may also be
true that the appellate court may permit additional
evidence if the conditions laid down in this Rule are
found to exist and the parties are not entitled, as of
right, to the admission of such evidence. However, at
the same time, where the additional evidence sought to
be adduced removes the cloud of doubt over the case
and the evidence has a direct and important bearing on
the main issue in the suit and interest of justice clearly
renders it imperative that it may be allowed to be
permitted on record, such application may be allowed.
Even, one of the circumstances in which the production
of additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC by
the appellate court is to be considered is, whether or
not the appellate court requires the additional evidence
so as to enable it to pronouncement judgment or for
any other substantial cause of like nature. As observed
and held by this Court in the case of A. Andisamy
Chettiar v. A. Subburaj Chettiar, reported in (2015) 17
SCC 713, the admissibility of additional evidence does
not depend upon the relevancy to the issue on hand, or
on the fact, whether the applicant had an opportunity
for adducing such evidence at an earlier stage or not,
but it depends upon whether or not the appellate court
requires the evidence sought to be adduced to enable it
to pronounce judgment or for any other substantial
cause. It is further observed that the true test,
2022 Live Law SC 268
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
therefore is, whether the appellate court is able to
pronounce judgment on the materials before it without
taking into consideration the additional evidence
sought to be adduced.”
10.
Relying on this, she submits that the Court can
consider this application and take the additional evidence on
record.
11.
Having heard the learned counsels on either side,
perused the material on record. The plaintiff has filed a suit for
declaration of title and injunction and according to him, he is the
owner of the property. The undisputed facts in this case establish
that, the property was purchased using funds sent by the
plaintiff to the defendant. According to the defendant, he has
taken an interest-free loan from the plaintiff. The aspect of
lending the money is an undisputed fact. The issue to be
established during the course of the trial is whether the amount
was paid for the purpose of purchasing the property in the name
of the plaintiff, or whether it was paid for the benefit of the
defendant. WhatsApp conversations are placed before this Court
by way of additional evidence, which, at this stage, this Court is
not inclined to take into consideration. In the background of this
factual matrix, if the plots i.e. the suit Schedule property are
sold, it would cause irreparable loss to the plaintiff. Prima facie,
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
the plaintiff could establish that he has been sending the money
to the defendant. The defendant also accepts the same and it is
submitted that, he is ready to give back the money, but there is
no agreement between the plaintiff and him to purchase a
property in his name. According to defendant, half of the money
is already repaid to the plaintiff. This Court, in light of the
admitted facts and the arguments advanced by both parties, is of
the view that the plaintiff has made out a case for grant of
interim injunction. Although Section 52 of the Transfer of
Property Act addresses the transactions that take place during
the pendency of the suit, that alone cannot be a ground to deny
the plaintiff the relief of injunction. It will not take away the
Court’s power to grant injunction to preserve the subject matter
of the suit property. It amounts to creating further litigation,
which is not in the interest of the parties. In light of the pleading
and admission by the defendant with regard to the payment
received from the plaintiff, this Court is of the view that the
plaintiff has made out a prima facie case and balance of
convenience lies in his favour and if the injunction is not granted,
irreparable loss would cause to him. As far as application for
additional evidence is concerned, during the course of evidence,
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:490
MFA No. 104419 of 2025
HC-KAR
the plaintiff can place it before the Trial Court, subject to the law
of evidence and relevancy, the Trial Court will consider the same.
12.
In view of the above, this Court is passing the
following:
ORDER
(i) Accordingly,
the
miscellaneous
first
appeal
is
allowed.
(ii) The order dated 25.09.2025 on I.A. No.I in O.S.
No.219/2025 passed by the Senior Civil Judge &
JMFC., Hungund is set-aside and I.A. No.I in O.S.
No.219/2025 filed by the plaintiff is allowed.
(iii)
The Registry shall return the documents that are
filed before this Court under Order XLI Rule 27 of
CPC.
(iv)
The parties are at liberty to raise all the issues
before the trial Court.
(v) All I.As. in this miscellaneous first appeal shall
stand closed.
SD/JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI
RH/ CT: UMD/ List No.: 1 Sl No.: 28
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review