The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In the case at hand, succeeded in establishing that respondent/husband made the life of the petitioner miserable by cruelty of conduct and therefore she is entitled to get a decree for dissolution of marriage as rightly Mat.A No.711 of 2020 held by the learned Family Court. Hence, we find no reason to interfere with the decree of divorce granted by the Family Court, Tirur. Accordingly, the Mat.Appeal is dismissed. Parties shall suffer their respective costs. Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN Sd/M.B.SNEHALATHA ab
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27408
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 711 OF 2020
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 18.09.2020 IN OP NO.474 OF
2017 OF FAMILY COURT, TIRUR
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
ABDUL JALEEL PARAKKAL
AGED 39 YEARS
S/O KUNHUTTY, PARAKKAL HOUSE, KAKKIDIPPURAM,
ALANKODE P.O.PONNANI TALUK, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT
BY ADVS.
C.M.MOHAMMED IQUABAL
SMT.ANJALI G.KRISHNAN
SMT.N.S.SOUMYA MOL
SRI.P.ABDUL NISHAD
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
SAFOORA, AGED 23 YEARS
D/O.SIDHEEQUE MUSLIYAR, KOOLI PARAMBIL HOUSE,
POTHANOOR AMSOM, NARIPARAMBA DESOM, KALADI
VILLAGE, NARIPARAMBA P.O.PONNANI TALUK, MALAPPURAM
DISTRICT, PIN-679 573.
SRI K J SAJI ISAAC
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
24.3.2025, THE COURT ON 28.03.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN & M.B.SNEHALATHA, JJ.
------------------------------------------Mat.Appeal No.711 of 2020
------------------------------------------Dated, this the 28th March 2025
JUDGMENT
M.B.Snehalatha.J
Appellant/husband calls in question the legality, propriety
and correctness of the judgment and decree of the Family Court,
Tirur in O.P.No.474/2017, by which it granted a decree in favour
of respondent/wife for dissolution of her marriage with the
appellant.
2. Parties in this appeal shall be referred to by their rank
in O.P.No.474/2017 as petitioner and respondent.
3. Petitioner/wife filed the petition seeking dissolution of
her marriage with the respondent which was solemnized on
15.3.2015 on the ground that after the marriage, while they were
residing together, respondent/husband subjected her to cruelty.
Her case is that respondent is a sexual pervert, who used to
assault her while having sex with her. Her further case is that out
of the 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh given
to
her
from
her
house,
the
respondent
and
in-laws
misappropriated her 15 sovereigns of gold ornaments and
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
thereafter the respondent again harassed her demanding to bring
cash from her parents. Respondent subjected her to cruelty and
found fault with her in everything she did.
4. On 9.1.2017 petitioner was thrown out from the
matrimonial home demanding her to bring ₹50,000/- from her
parents. Due to the cruelty of the respondent/husband, petitioner
do not want to continue the marital relationship with him which
has been irretrievably broken.
5. Respondent/husband denied the allegations regarding
the
cruelty
and
also
denied
the
allegation
regarding
misappropriation of gold ornaments. He also denied the case of
the petitioner that he is a sexual pervert. According to him,
petitioner quarrelled with him on the ground that he failed to
reach her paternal home on the Bakrid day in the year 2015. He
sought for dismissal of the petition seeking divorce.
6. After trial, the learned Family Court granted a decree
of dissolution of marriage, which is under challenge in this appeal
filed by the husband.
7. The point for consideration is whether the impugned
judgment and decree needs any interference by this Court.
8. Parties
are Muslims. The marriage is admitted.
Petitioner/wife approached the Family Court, seeking dissolution
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
of marriage on the ground of cruelty. Petitioner who was
examined as PW1 has testified that she was given 20 sovereigns
of gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh from her house. According
to her, her father entrusted the amount of Rs.1 lakh to the father
of the respondent on the next day of the marriage itself.
Her
further version is that respondent and her in-laws used to ill treat
her by alleging that the gold ornaments and cash brought by her
is less. Her further version is that respondent took her 15
sovereigns of gold ornaments within one month of her marriage
for discharging his liabilities. According to her, her husband found
fault with everything she did and he even used to verbally abuse
her for consuming food from his house.
She has also testified
that respondent is a sexual pervert and he is a sadist who finds
sexual pleasure from inflicting pain on her and he used to assault
her while having sex with her. According to her, the respondent
continuously harassed her in her matrimonial home. Her further
version is that on 9.1.2017, respondent demanded her to bring
₹50,000/- from her house and when she expressed her inability to
bring such amount from her parents, respondent harassed her by
saying that he will marry another beautiful lady who can bring
more gold and cash. The specific case of the petitioner is that due
to the unbearable harassment, meted out from the respondent,
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
she had to leave her matrimonial home on 9.1.2017 and
thereafter she is residing at her parental house.
9. Respondent who was examined as RW1 has denied the
allegations of cruelty and misappropriation of gold. According to
him, he has not harassed her either mentally or physically.
10.
The
specific
case
of
the
petitioner
is
that
respondent/husband treated her with cruelty and made her
marital life miserable by his cruel conduct and behaviour. This
Court finds no reason to disbelieve the version of the petitioner
that the respondent subjected her to cruelty.
11. Mental cruelty refers to the conduct that causes
emotional trauma such as verbal abuse or insult, harassment
including dowry demand.
Cruelty is a well recognized ground for
divorce under various personal laws in India.
It includes both
physical and mental cruelty inflicted by one spouse on the other
making cohabitation unbearable. Cruelty by the husband is a valid
ground for divorce under Section 2(viii)(a) of the Dissolution of
Muslim Marriage Act, 1939.
12. In Litty Mary John v. Manoj K.Varghese (2024 KHC
OnLine 693) the Division Bench of this Court (One of us was in the
said Bench) held as follows:
“11. A single, overarching definition of "cruelty"
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
is impractical and ineffective, as it can manifest in various
forms and shapes - it may be perceived differently in
different situations. What constitutes cruelty often differs
from person to person, situation to situation, as it is
subjective and depends on the perception of the individual
experiencing it.
12. The concept of cruelty indubitably is
inherently subjective - it being inevitable - since what one
person considers cruel, may not be perceived the same
way by another. This subjectivity arises from individual
differences in values, experiences, and sensitivity. For
instance, an action that causes emotional distress to one
person, might be perceived as trivial or inconsequential by
someone else. These varying perceptions make it difficult
to establish a universal definition of "cruelty", as it relies
heavily on the individual's personal interpretation and
emotional response to the behaviour in question.
13.
Though "Matrimonial cruelty" unfortunately
has sometimes been perceived "part and parcel" of
marriage, it has - more than often - evaded precise
connotation. A spouse who has endured it for years whether due to being silenced by the other spouse or
their family, gas lighted, or unaware that it constitutes
"cruelty" - may lack the courage to speak out about the
horrific experiences she/he has faced within the four walls
of their shared household. When they finally do muster
the courage, the complaining spouse frequently finds
themselves under intense scrutiny, facing questions about
their background, the frequency of such incidents, and
whether the other spouse is otherwise ideal in other
aspects of the marriage and so on. This is applicable more
pointedly in the case of a woman in a matrimonial
relationship.”
13.
Courts have leaned towards granting relief of
divorce when the wife faces neglect, indifference and emotional
distress even if there is no outright violence. If neglect,
humiliation or lack of affection makes cohabitation unbearable,
courts can grant divorce. This flexible approach ensures that
justice is served based on the realities of marriage rather than
rigid definitions. Forcing incompatible partners to stay together
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
would cause more harm to both parties. The marriage between
the spouses is no longer viable and the relationship had
essentially ended as the same has irretrievably broken and
therefore there is no need to continue the agony of a mere status
of husband and wife.
14.
It is also her case that the husband subjected
her to cruelty by misappropriating her gold ornaments and thus
prevented her from exercising her legal right over it and therefore
she is entitled to get a decree for dissolution of marriage on that
ground also.
15.
Inasmuch as there is no relief for return of gold
ornaments in the Original Petition, the Family Court has not
rendered
any
finding
as
to
whether
the
husband
has
misappropriated the gold ornaments as contended by the wife. In
the said circumstances, we make it clear that we have not
rendered
any finding on the
respondent
in
the
question as to whether
O.P/husband
misappropriated
the
her
gold
petitioner/wife
has
ornaments. The said issue is left open.
16.
In
the
case
at
hand,
succeeded in establishing that respondent/husband made the life
of the petitioner miserable by cruelty of conduct and therefore she
is entitled to get a decree for dissolution of marriage as rightly
Mat.A No.711 of 2020
held by the learned Family Court.
Hence, we find no reason to
interfere with the decree of divorce granted by the Family Court,
Tirur.
Accordingly, the Mat.Appeal is dismissed.
Parties shall suffer their respective costs.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/M.B.SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
ab
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review