Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 08
Regular Cause List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP (C) No. 1954/2023
Abdul Hamid Sheikh (60 Years),
S/O Mohammad Yousuf Sheikh
R/O Vilagam Ramhal, Handwara,
District Kupwara.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Shabir Ahmad Shah, Advocate vice
Mr Sheikh Manzoor, Advocate
V/S
1. UT of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through its Chief Secretary,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar/ Jammu.
2. Jammu & Kashmir Forest Development Corporation Ltd.,
Through its Managing Director, Silk Factory Road,
Rajbagh, Srinagar.
3. Chief General Manager (P&P),
Forest Development Corporation,
Srinagar.
4. General Manager (North),
Circle Sopore, Baramulla.
5. Divisional Manager,
Extraction Division,
Zangil, Kupwara.
6. Mr Bilal Ahmad Mir,
Divisional Manager,
Extraction Division,
Zangali, Kupwara.
… Respondent(s)
Through: Ms Nadiya Abdullah, Assisting Counsel vice
Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG for R-1 to 5; and
Mr Gulzar Ahmad Bhat, Advocate with
Ms Maria, Advocate for R-6.
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
Clubbed With:
(i) WP (C) No. 90/2021:
Abdul Hamid Sheikh (58 Years),
S/O Mohammad Yousuf Sheikh
R/O Vilagam Ramhal, Handwara,
District Kupwara.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Shabir Ahmad Shah, Advocate vice
Mr Sheikh Manzoor, Advocate
V/S
1. J&K Forest Development Corporation (FC),
Through its Managing Director,
Silk Factory Road, Rajbagh, Srinagar.
2. General Manager (North),
J&K Forest Development Corporation,
Sopore, Baramulla.
3. Mr Bilal Ahmad Mir,
Divisional Manager FDC,
Extraction Division,
Zangali, Kupwara.
… Respondent(s)
Through: Ms Nadiya Abdullah, Assisting Counsel vice
Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG for R-1 to 2; and
Mr Gulzar Ahmad Bhat, Advocate with
Ms Maria, Advocate for R-3.
(ii) CCP (S) No. 420/2024 in WP (C) No. 1954/2023:
Abdul Hamid Sheikh (60 Years),
S/O Mohammad Yousuf Sheikh
R/O Vilagam Ramhal, Handwara,
District Kupwara.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Shabir Ahmad Shah, Advocate vice
Mr Sheikh Manzoor, Advocate
V/S
1. Chaturbhujja Behera (IFS), Managing Director,
Jammu & Kashmir Forest Development Corporation Ltd.,
Silk Factory Road, Rajbagh, Srinagar.
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
2. Mohammad Rafiq Khan,
Chief General Manager (P&P),
Forest Development Corporation,
Srinagar.
3. Mohammad Hafeez Mir,
General Manager (North),
Circle Sopore, Baramulla.
4. Bilal Ahmad Mir,
Divisional Manager,
Extraction Division,
Zangali, Kupwara.
… Respondent(s)
Through: Ms Nadiya Abdullah, Assisting Counsel vice
Mr Mohsin-ul-Showkat Qadri, Sr. AAG for R-1 to 3; and
Mr Gulzar Ahmad Bhat, Advocate with
Ms Maria, Advocate for R-4.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(ORDER)
15.09.2026
WP (C) No. 1954/2023:
01.
The Petitioner, through the medium of this Petition filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, while pleading that he, as an
employee of the Respondent-Forest Development Corporation, after
rendering more than 25 years of unblemished service, attained
superannuation on 31st of March, 2022, has challenged JKFDCL Order No.
20 of 2023 dated 14th of January, 2023, whereby an amount of ₹94,958/was ordered to be recovered from his retiral benefits, seeking quashing of
the said Order, directing the Respondents to expunge the adverse entries
made in his service book with red ink by the Respondent No.6, to command
them to release the annual increments of the Petitioner and time bound
promotion, including the arrears of salary and retiral benefits accrued in his
favour.
02.
Pursuant to notice having been issued, the Respondents No. 1
to 6 filed Objections to the Petition, pleading therein that a Committee
constituted by the office of Divisional Manager, Ext. Division, Zangli, vide
Order No. 2204/DM/FDC/Z dated 16th of March, 2021, for physical
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
verification of various CTSDs depots, reported that there was a shortfall in
Manzgam Sawn, Tarthpora, Dalhama and Cillgam CTSDs; that the
Petitioner (Field Worker) remained on various posts, but from 2016 to 11 th
of March, 2020 was working as Incharge CTSDs and also Incharge Range
Clerk of Sale Range Magam and Kehmil, during which period shortfall was
found against the said official; that on the verbal directions of the then
Managing Director, FDCL, during a review meeting held at head office
Srinagar, the Petitioner was transferred from Sales Range to Ext. Range
North, Lolab vide Order dated 11th of May, 2022; that the Divisional
Manager, Zangli directed the Petitioner to report to his new place of posting
at an earliest through various communications/ notices, but the Petitioner
did not join the new place of posting and remained absent from duty for a
long time, as was reported by Range Officer Sales, Kehmil and Ext. Range
North Lolab; that the Petitioner did not handover the charge of CTSDs to
his successor from 11th of May, 2020 to 20th of February, 2021, as a result,
in those 10 months, the sale proceedings suffered badly in Sales Range
Kehmil and the Petitioner behaved against the interests of the Corporation.
03.
It has been further pleaded that the Petitioner approached this
Court by way of a Writ Petition [WP (C) No. 1081/2020] and the Court
disposed of the said Writ Petition with a direction to the Respondent No.3
to consider the representation, if any, made by the Petitioner against his
order of transfer, within a period of one month from the date of receipt of
the Order; that due to absence of the Petitioner from duty w.e.f. 11 th of
May, 2020 to 13th of January, 2021, when his whereabouts were also not
known, his salary was not disbursed for the period he remained absent from
duty; that the Managing Director, taking cognizance of the matter,
transferred the Petitioner vide Order dated 11th of February, 2021, directing
him to report to Ext. Range North, Lolab, with a direction to the Divisional
Manager, Zangli to release the withheld salary of the official only after he
joins the new place of posting; that, in compliance to the said transfer
Order, the Petitioner joined in Ext. Range North, Lolab on 14th of January,
2021, i.e., after a lapse of eight months, and his salary was released as
directed by Managing Director, FDCL.
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
04.
It has been alleged that concealing the fact that he had earlier
filed WP (C) No. 90/2021 with the prayer to release the withheld salary
before this Court, which was still pending for final disposal, the Petitioner
filed another Writ Petition before this Court with the same cause of action;
that in the meanwhile, it was ordered that there was shortfall of 15 logs, i.e.,
226.88 cfts DKF, against the Petitioner which cost to ₹94,958/- at AAY
rates applicable to CTSDs, which is recoverable from him against the
shortfall of timber in various CTSDs under his control; that the Petitioner
retired from service upon reaching the age of superannuation on 31st of
March, 2022 and the retiral benefits were pending for some time in the
office of the concerned Division due to non-availability of NDCs from
various postings held by the Petitioner during his active service and he had
concealed the fact that, after receiving NDCs from postings, including Sales
Range Kehmi, the leave salary and gratuity case of the Petitioner was
submitted by the concerned Division vide Office No. 1181/DM/FDC/Z
dated 30th of June, 2022, to the concerned quarters for further necessary
action.
05.
It is next stated by the Respondents that, on the representation
moved by the Petitioner against the action initiated by the concerned
Divisional Manager for forfeiting of annual increments and the entries in
the service book of the Petitioner, the authorities issued Order No. 20 of
2023 dated 14th of January, 2023, to the following effect:
“1. To release withheld increments in favour of the exofficial for the year 2020 and 2021 which has been unauthorized
forfeited by Divisional Manager Zangli by exercising power beyond
his competence and these entries made in the service book are
treated as expunged;
2. The Divisional Manager shall process the case of the exofficial for payment of retiral benefits/ dues accruing after
retirement; and
3. To recover the cost of shortfall of 15 logs=226.88 cfts of
DKF timber amounting to ₹94,958/- at AAY rates applicable in
CTSDs from dues accruing after retirement.”
06.
It has been pleaded that the case of the Petitioner was settled in
respect of Gratuity and Leave Salary to the tune of ₹10,25,302/- sanctioned
vide JKFDCL Order No. 116 of 2023 dated 25th of March, 2023 and same
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
was released in his favour, besides an amount of ₹94,958/- was ordered to
be recovered against the shortfall of 15 logs established by the concerned
Division from the Petitioner.
07.
The Respondent No.6, in his affidavit, in compliance of the
directions of this Court, vide Order dated 4th of August, 2023 read with
Order dated 10th of October, 2025, stated that the matter which has been
agitated by the Petitioner in his Writ Petition has been already settled by the
competent authority by virtue of JKFDCL Order No. 20 of 2023 dated 14 th
of January, 2023; that the amounts due to the Petitioner have been released
in favour of the Petitioner and the adverse entries have been expunged from
the service book of the Petitioner; that the Petitioner had not approached the
Court with clean hands, inasmuch as, he had filed the present Writ Petition
in concealment of the material fact as regards filing of WP (C) No. 90/2021
and had wrongly pleaded in this Petition, at Paragraph No.17, that he had
not filed any other Writ Petition on the same cause of action, as such, he
had deliberately and intentionally suppressed the facts before this Court;
that the Petitioner retired from service upon reaching the age of
superannuation on 31st of March, 2022 and his retiral benefits were
withheld awaiting No Demand Certificates/ No Objection Certificates from
various postings held by the Petitioner during his active service and, as soon
as the formalities were completed, the Petitioner’s case was settled in
respect of gratuity and leave salary which were sanctioned vide JKFDCL
Order No. 116 of 2023 dated 25th of March, 2023 and released in favour of
the Petitioner.
08.
Learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents submits that
on consideration of the matter by the Respondents, the competent authority
had released the withheld increments of the Petitioner for the years 2020
and 2021, which had been unauthorizedly forfeited by the Divisional
Manager, Zangli by exercising power beyond his competence, the adverse
entries made in his Service Book were also treated as expunged and the
Divisional Manager was directed to process the case of the Petitioner for
payment of retiral benefits/ dues accruing after retirement, subject to the
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
recovery of an amount of ₹94,958/- as cost of shortfall of 15 logs from the
retirement dues accrued to the Petitioner.
09.
Heard and considered.
10.
On consideration of Order No. 20 of 2023 dated 14 th of
January, 2023 passed by the Respondents, it is clear that the pleas raised by
the Petitioner in his Petition have been addressed as the adverse remarks
were expunged from his service record and the retiral benefits were ordered
to be released in his favour, including the withheld increments and arrears
thereof.
11.
Insofar as the recovery of the amount is concerned, it is
apparent from the record produced by the Respondents that the RespondentCorporation had suffered a loss to the tune of ₹94,958/- for shortfall of 15
logs and the Petitioner has not placed on record anything in support of his
contention that this loss suffered by the Corporation was not, in any
manner, attributable to him, when he was controlling the concerned CTSDs,
during the relevant period of shortfall.
12.
Viewed thus, the grievances projected by the Petitioner in this
Petition have been redressed, as such, the present Petition is disposed of at
this stage holding that the reliefs sought with regard to release of withheld
increments and the retiral benefits have been granted. It is further held that
there is no reason to warrant any interference with regard to the recovery of
the amount of ₹94,958/- from the Petitioner, which is also stated to have
been recovered from his retiral benefits/ arrears.
13.
Writ Petition is, thus, disposed of on the above terms, along
with CM(s) pending therewith.
WP (C) No. 90/2021:
14.
In this Petition, the Petitioner had sought a direction upon the
Respondents to release the withheld salary of the Petitioner forthwith and
allow him to perform his duties as Field Worker in the Office of Divisional
Manager, Zangli, Kupwara. Besides, the Petitioner also seeks direction
upon Respondents No. 1 and 2 to proceed against Respondent No.3 by
WP (C) No. 1954/2023 c/w
WP (C) No. 90/2021
CCP (S) No. 420/2024
conducting a departmental enquiry for misappropriation and embezzlement
of funds in the Corporation.
15.
Having regard to the fact that the Petitioner has since retired
from service on reaching the age of superannuation, coupled with the
decision rendered in the subsequent Petition filed by the Petitioner, being
WP (C) No. 1954/2023, as aforesaid, this Petition has been rendered
infructuous and shall stand disposed of accordingly, along with any CM(s)
pending therewith.
CCP (S) No. 420/2024:
16.
Through the medium of this Contempt Petition, the Petitioner
alleges violation of interim Order dated 4th of August, 2023 passed in WP
(C) No. 1954/2023.
17.
Since, the Writ Petition, out of which the aforesaid interim
Order emanates, has been finally disposed of, therefore, no further
proceedings are required to be conducted in this Contempt Petition.
18.
Viewed thus, this Contempt Petition, not warranting any
further proceedings and the Order sought to be implemented having been
complied with, has been rendered infructuous. Accordingly, the
proceedings are dropped and the Contempt Petition is closed.
19.
Registry to place a copy of this Order on all the three
connected files.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 15th, 2026
“TAHIR”
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review