Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 98
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No.836/2025
Reserved on: 05.08.2026
Pronounced on: 12.08.2026
Uploaded on: 12.08.2026
Operative part or
full judgment: Full
1. Abdul Gani S/O Ahmdo Bhatt
2. Mohd. Sharief, S/O Ahmedo Bhatt
3. Mehboob, S/O Abdul Gani
4. Yasir, S/O Mohd. Sharief
5. Naseer Ahmed S/O Mohd. Sharief
6. Safoora Begum W/O Mohd. Sharief
All R/O Nacha, Ganotha Assar,
Tehsil Assair District Ddoa.
…....Petitioners
Through: Mr. N A Gatoo, Advocate.
Vs.
1.
2.
3.
Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir
through Senior Superintendent of Police
(SSP) Doda.
SHO Police Station, Assar,
District Doda.
Mohd. Ashraf S/O Mohd. Ibrahim
R/O Nacha, Ganotha Assar,
Tehsil Assar, District Doda.
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, GA for R-1&2.
None for R-3.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
This petition under Section 528 of BNSS, 2023 has been filed by the
petitioners, seeking quashment of FIR No. 0025/2025 dated 11.08.2025, for
commission of offences punishable under Sections 3(1)(iii), 3(1)(v) and 3(1)(x) of
the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989,
registered at Police Station Assar, at the instance of respondent No.3, alleging
false implication, as such, abuse of process.
CRM(M) No. 836/2025
2.
Brief facts, containing necessary details, as pleaded by the petitioners, in
their petition are that on 09.07.2025, a trivial altercation took place between the
petitioners 3, 4, and 5, who had gone to a park in Ramgarh for picnic, with
complainant and his family members; that later at about 5.00 PM, the complainant
and his family members came to the shop of the petitioner No.1, situated in the
main market of Bagger (Ramgarh), where, petitioners 3, 4 and 5 were also present,
assaulted them with lathis, stones and a toka causing serious injuries, who were
thereafter taken to PHC Assar for medical treatment; that petitioner no.1, who
happens to be father of petitioner no.3 and uncle of petitioners 4 and 5, on the
same evening, lodged a written complaint regarding the incident; that the SHO
concerned, after taking cognizance of the matter, registered the case vide FIR
No.0019/2025 dated 09.07.2025 under Sections 109/190, 126(2), 115(2),
125/191(2), 352/351(2), 324(4)/191(3) of BNS and Section 4/25 of the Arms Act
against Asif, Danish, Arif, Jaffer, Imtiaz, Jameel, Latif and Akhter; that the said
accused approached the court of learned District Judicial Mobile Magistrate
(Traffic) Doda, by way of applications for grant of bail, who, vide common order
dated 29.07.2025, granted bail, subject to the conditions enumerated therein.
3.
Further allegation is that after lapse of one month of the incident, respondent
no.3, along with his family members, approached the Senior Superintendent of
Police (SSP), Doda and submitted a written complaint seeking lodging of an FIR
against the petitioners for the same incident that occurred on 09.07.2025; that
pursuant to said complaint lodged by the respondent No.3/complaint, the
impugned FIR was registered against the petitioners for commission of offences
punishable under Sections 3(1)(iii), 3(1)(v), and 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Casts
and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, against the petitioners.
CRM(M) No. 836/2025
4.
In the afore-stated factual background and aggrieved of the aforesaid FIR,
present petition has been filed by the petitioners, seeking its quashment, assailing
the same on following grounds:
(i)
that the impugned order is bad both on facts and law;
(ii)
that the impugned FIR is a counter blast to earlier FIR lodged by the
petitioners;
(iii)
that the impugned FIR is a clear abuse of the process of law;
(iv)
that the impugned FIR has been lodged to wreak vengeance and
harass the petitioners and to tarnish their image in the society; and
(v)
that the allegations made in the impugned FIR do not prima facie
disclose a cognizable offence, therefore, same be quashed.
5.
Pursuant to notices, status report stand filed on 23.04.2026 by respondents
no.1 and 2, stating, inter alia, that on 11.08.2025, respondent No.3/complainant
lodged a written complaint alleging therein that on 09.07.2025 at 5.00 PM, when
their children went to a local shop to purchase items, Abdul Gani Bhatt with around
10 other individuals abused them with caste based slurs; that petitioner No.3 took a
butcher knife from the shop and attempted to attack the children; that petitioners
removed the clothes of one Asif Hussain Bakerwal S/O Akhter Hussain and beat,
slapped and abused him because of he being a Bakerwal and emitting foul stench,
and he was admitted to GMC Doda for two days; that petitioner No.6, who works
as a cook at Govt. Middle School Necha also passed caste remarks and preached
them not to attend the school, being Bakerwals and also humiliated them by saying
they are bad smelling; that on the complaint lodged by respondent No.3, impugned
FIR was lodged against the petitioners and the investigation got entrusted to Dy.
SP, DAR District Doda; that during investigation, the IO visited the place of
occurrence and prepared the site plan, recorded the statements of eye witnesses U/S
CRM(M) No. 836/2025
180 BNSS through eSakshya app, who corroborated the contents of the complaint;
that, the IO further recorded the statements of 17 independent witnesses, some of
them belonging to the Scheduled Tribe category, who did not corroborate the
statements of the eye witnesses recorded earlier; that the statements of 08
complainants/witnesses, whose signatures are appended on the written complaint
were also recorded, which claimed no knowledge that the complaint contains
allegations attracting provisions of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989; that with regard to same incident, FIR
No.19/2025 U/Ss 126(2), 115(2), 191(2), 352, 351(2), 324(4), 191(3) BNSS has
been registered at the instance of the petitioners against the complainants/victims;
that as per statements of independent witnesses, offences under the provisions of
the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
have not been proved, however, statement of 15 complainants/witnesses are yet to
be recorded.
6.
Respondent No.3, despite service, has chosen not to contest the matter, as
neither there is any representation on his behalf nor any reply has been filed,
though some counsel had appeared on his behalf earlier.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioners would argue that the impugned FIR
lodged by the complainant against the petitioners is sheer abuse of process of
law, as is evident from the status report submitted by Investigating Officer
before this court; that the impugned FIR has been lodged by the complainant as
a counter blast to the FIR lodged at the behest of the petitioners; that the
allegations made in the impugned FIR are only to tarnish the image of the
petitioners in the society. Lastly, it is prayed that the writ petition be allowed
and the impugned FIR be quashed.
CRM(M) No. 836/2025
8.
Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, learned Government Advocate appearing for the
respondents 1 and 2, argued that the petitioners have raised disputed questions of
facts which are serious triable allegations, which cannot be adjudicated upon by
this Court, under its extraordinary jurisdiction. He further submits that power of
quashing a criminal proceeding should be exercised very sparingly and with
circumspection and that too in the rarest of rare cases. He further submits that the
present case does not fall within any of the exceptional categories laid down in
Bhajan Lal’s case warranting interference; that the complaint discloses commission
of cognizable offences; that the contentions raised by the petitioners cannot be
examined in proceedings under Section 528 BNSS, so as to appreciate evidence,
determination of credibility of witnesses and adjudication of disputed facts are
matters exclusively within the domain of trial court; that the status report filed by
the Investigating Officer, perusal whereof, would show that the investigation is still
going on as statements of as many as 15 independent witnesses are yet to be
recorded and efforts are being made to do the needful at the earliest. Lastly, it is
prayed that the writ petition be dismissed.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their submissions and
perused the file.
10.
Respondent No.3 moved a complaint to SSP Doda, with regard to an
incident/occurrence, which was reported to have taken place on 09.07.2025. On
the basis of that complaint, a case was registered vide impugned FIR. It appears
that FIR would not have been lodged at the local Police Station, as a case had
been registered against the complainant’s family members, at the instance of
petitioner no.1, vide FIR No.19/2025 dated 09.07.2025 U/Ss 109/190, 126(2),
115(2), 125/191(2), 352/351(2), 324(4)/191(3) of BNS and Section 4/25 Arms
CRM(M) No. 836/2025
Act at P/S Assar, and that became the reason for respondent No.3/complainant
to approach SSP of the District, for taking cognizance of his complaint.
11.
As per the status report filed by the respondents, the investigation of the
case registered vide impugned FIR has been assigned to Dy. SP, DAR Doda,
and that all the eye witnesses, whose statements were recorded, had
corroborated the contents of the complaint, however, it was claimed that he had
recorded statement of 17 independent witnesses, who did not corroborate the
statement of the eye witnesses recorded earlier and that the statements of the 8
witnesses, including the complainants whose signatures were appended on the
written complaint are yet to be examined; that offences alleged are not proved
and that statements of 15 witnesses are yet to be recorded.
12.
It appears from the status report that the investigating officer, who is
considerably at a senior position, has some other ideas, so as to screen the
alleged culprits, as otherwise, it is not the number of witnesses that matters but it
is the quality of the evidence and the statement of the witnesses, who may have
been present at the place of occurrence and, particularly, those who have
supported the complainants version should have been believed, so as to finalize
the investigation.
13.
It is very surprising that the investigation of the case registered on
11.08.2025 has not been completed till now, which suggests that the
investigating officer may not be impartial and may have been proceeding to help
the accused as against the complainant party who belong to vulnerable, weak
and underprivileged class, for whose protection, the Scheduled Cates and
Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, has been promulgated by
the Parliament.
CRM(M) No. 836/2025
14.
The contention that there was delay in lodging the FIR on 11.08.2025
with regard to an alleged occurrence having taken place on 09.07.2025, it
appears that despite the efforts of the complainant, the FIR was not registered at
the local police station which compelled the complainant to approach the SSP
Doda with his grievances, therefore, the delay if any cannot be attributable to the
complainant, so as to give any benefit to the accused for seeking quashing of the
FIR on this ground.
15.
Coming to the other contention that complainant and his relatives are also
accused in FIR No.19/2025 registered with regard to the same incident having
taken place on 09.07.2025 also gives strength to the allegation of the
complainant that an occurrence did take place, as such, on this count, as well, no
ground made out to seek quashment of FIR.
16.
Before parting with the order, with a view that a fair treatment is afforded
to the complainant as well as to the accused, SSP Doda and CJM Doda are
directed to supervise the investigation of the case and to ensure that
investigation is carried out, in accordance with law. Copy of this order shall be
forwarded to the SSP Doda and also to learned CJM Doda for compliance.
17.
For the foregoing reasons, the petition is found to be without any merit
and substance and is liable to be dismissed.
(
) (M.A Chowdhary)
Judge
Jammu:
12.08.2026
Raj kumar
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
Raj Kumar
2026.08.12 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
document
CRM(M)
No. 836/2025
Yes/No.
Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review