Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 220 of 2020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 09-04-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S. SOUNTHAR
SA No. 220 of 2020 and
CMP No.4545 of 2020
1. A.S.Muthusamy, S/o.Sundarasamy Gounder,
Agasthilingampalayam,
Kangayam Taluk.
2. Thilagavathy, W/o.Late Kumarasamy,
Agasthilingampalayam,
Kangayam Taluk.
3. Narmatha, W/o.Jeevanantham,
15, Kathir Nagar,
D.S.K.Hospital Opposite Near,
Kangayam Road, Kaspa Tiruppur Town,
Tiruppur Taluk, Tiruppur District.
4. Suresh, S/o.Lae Kumarasamy,
Kangayam Village,
Agasthilingampalayam, Kangayam Taluk.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. The District Collector
Collector Office, Tiruppur.
2. The Tahsildar
Tahsildar Office, Dharapuram.
3. The Conservator Of Forest,
Kangayam.
4. The Ranger,
Forest Department, Thalavaipattinam.
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
Second Appeal filed under Section 100 of CPC to set aside the
Prayer:
judgment and decree passed in AS.No.20 of 2015 dated 14.02.2018 on the file
of the Subordinate Judge, Dharampuram, confirming the judgment and decree
passed in OS.No.268 of 2006 dated 26.03.2015 on the file of the District Munsif
Court, Dharapuram.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.P.Navaneetha Krishnan
For Respondent(s):
Mr.A.Anandan, Government Advocate
for R1 to R4.
JUDGMENT
The unsuccessful plaintiffs in a suit in O.S.No.268 of 2006 are the
appellants herein.
2. The plaintiffs/appellants filed a suit for declaration of title and recovery
of possession of the suit property. The said suit was dismissed by the Trial
Court and the appeal filed by the plaintiffs was also dismissed by the first
appellate court. Aggrieved by the concurrent findings of the courts below, the
plaintiffs have preferred the present second appeal.
3. The plaintiffs 1 and 2 are the sons of Sundarasamy Gounder and the
plaintiffs 3 to 5 are wife and children of the deceased 2 nd plaintiff, namely
A.S.Kumarasamy respectively.
__________
Page2 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
4. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the suit property is situated in survey
No.368 in Thlavaipattinam Villagee with an extent of 15 acres 89 cents and the
same was originally belonged to the grand father of plaintiffs 1 and 2 , namely
Sundarappa Gounder.
It is the further case of the plaintiffs that the said
Sundarappa Gounder’s only son was Sundarasamy Gounder, the father of the
plaintiffs 1 and 2 and their family left the village long back to eak out their
livelihood. However, they exercised control over the suit property through an
agent called Chinnasamy Gounder. After death of Sundarappa Gounder and his
son Sundarasamy Gounder, the plaintiffs inherited the suit property and as such
they are entitled to the same. It is further pleaded by the plaintiffs that the
respondents 1 and 2 without enquiry, included the suit property as a forest land
and now, the respondents 3 and 4 have been in possession and enjoyment of the
suit property as a forest land. Since the suit properties are inherited properties
of the plaintiffs, the suit has been laid seeking declaration of title and recovery
of possession.
5. The respondents 3 and 4/defendants 3 and 4 filed a written statement
and resisted the suit by denying the title of the plaintiffs and their predecessor in
interest. It was the case of the contesting defendants that the suit property has
been in possession and enjoyment of the forest department as protected forest
for the past 117 years along with the properties situated in survey Nos.333 and
328, as per the notification issued by the government in the gazette dated
__________
Page3 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
05.05.1893. The defendants 3 and 4 further stated that the suit property has been
in their direct possession and enjoyment and the plaintiffs never exercised any
right over the same and hence, they prayed for dismissal of the suit.
6. Before the Trial Court, the first plaintiff was examined as PW1 and 5
documents were marked as Ex.A1 to Ex.A5. On the side of the defendants, a
forest officer was examined as DW1 and 4 documents were marked as Ex.B1 to
Ex.B4.
7. The trial court, on appreciation of evidence available on record, came
to the conclusion that the plaintiffs failed to establish their title and entitlement
of possession over the suit property and dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the
same, the plaintiffs filed an appeal in A.S.No.20 of 2015 on the file of
Subordinate Judge, Dharapuram. Before the first appellate court, the plaintiffs
filed an application for reception of additional evidence and it was allowed by
marking the survey and settlement register as Ex.A6, and Field map survey
No.368 as Ex.A7. The first appellate court, based on Ex.A6, came to the
conclusion that originally the suit property was allotted in the name of
Sundarappa Gounder, however, the plaintiffs failed to establish their
relationship with Sundarappa Gounder and dismissed the first appeal.
Challenging the concurrent findings of the courts below, the appellants have
filed the present second appeal.
__________
Page4 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
8. Pending second appeal, the appellants/plaintiffs filed a petition in CMP
No.4545/2020 under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC seeking reception of additional
documents in, viz., the death certificate of father of plaintiffs 1 and 2, namely,
Sundarasamy Gounder and legal heirship certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder
as additional evidence.
9. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the first appellate
court dismissed the appeal filed by the plaintiffs/appellants mainly on the
ground that the plaintiffs failed to establish their relationship with Sundarappa
Gounder. He further submitted that the death certificate of father of plaintiffs
1 and 2 and the legal heirship certificate of their father would establish that the
father of 1st and 2nd plaintiffs, namely Sundarsamy Gounder was son of
Sundarappa Gounder and the plaintiffs are sons of Sundarasamy Gounder.
Therefore, according to the learned counsel for the appellants/plaintiffs, the
additional documents produced by the plaintiffs proved the relationship of the
plaintiffs with original owner Sundarappa Gounder and in such circumstances,
there may not be any impediment for the court to grant declaration of title and
recovery of possession in favour of the plaintiffs.
10. It is seen from the additional documents filed by the appellants that
the death certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder was dated 13.10.2005. Likewise,
the legal heirship certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder was dated 01.02.2006.
__________
Page5 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
Therefore, it is clear that the above said documents were received by the
plaintiffs/appellants even prior to the filing of the suit. In the written statement
filed by the defendants, the relationship of the plaintiffs with Sundarasamy
Gounder was specifically denied and inspite of the same, the plaintiffs failed to
produce the said documents before the trial court. Likewise, before the first
appellate court, the appellants filed an application seeking reception of
additional documents i.e. survey and settlement register pertains to the suit
property and field map survey No.368. However, the appellants have not
established that, inspite of due diligence, they could not have filed the death
certificate and legal heirship certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder before the first
appellate court. The failure of the appellants to file these two documents before
the trial court as well as the first appellate court would establish that the
plaintiffs failed to exercise due diligence at the time of trial and also before the
first appellate court. However, the documents filed by the plaintiffs are issued
by the competent officials and there is no dispute with regard to the genuineness
of the same. Further, the reception of documents will also enable the court to
decide the controversy involved in the second appeal in a more comprehensive
way. Therefore, this court is inclined to allow the said application in CMP
No.4545 of 2020 by invoking its power under Order 41 Rule 27(b) of CPC.
11. Accordingly, the death certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder is
ordered to be marked as Ex.A8 and the legal heirship certificate of the
Sundarasamy Gounder is ordered to be marked as Ex.A9.
__________
Page6 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
12. It is seen from the plaint averments that the plaintiffs categorically
admitted that their family left the suit village long back to eke out their
livelihood.
The first plaintiff, while examining himself as PW1, has
categorically admitted that the suit property is a protected forest and the same
has been in possession and enjoyment of the forest department.
He also
admitted that his grand father left the suit village in the year 1911 to earn
livelihood. He further stated that till the death of his father, he was not aware
that the suit property belonged to their family. He also stated that neither he not
his father paid any tax to the government in respect of the suit property. The
relevant portions of his evidence are extracted below.
,t;tHf;fpy ;
Fwpg;ghf
vd;d
ghpfhuk ;
nfl;Ls;nsd ;
bjhpahJ/
tHf;Fr ; brhj;J
bjhd;W
bjhl;L
3.
vd;W
vdf;Fj;
gpujpthjpfspd;
RthjPdj;jpy ; cs;sJ vd;why ; rhpjhd;/????????????????????????????????????????????
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
jhth
brhj;J
jw;nghJ
jkpH;ehL
fhg;g[f;fhL vd;why; rhpjhd;/
tdj;Jiwf;Fg ;
fle;j 117 tUl';fshf jhth brhj;J
tdj;Jiwapd ; RthjPdj;jpy ; cs;sJ
vd;why ; mJgw;wp
Mz;L
tpl;L
vd ; jhj;jh
jhth
ghj;jpag;gl;l
brhj;ij
vdf;F
g";rk ; gpiHf;f
1991k;
btspna
brd;Wtpl;lhh;/??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
vd ; jfg;ghdhh; ,wf;Fk ; tiuapYk ; mtUf;F jhth brhj;J ghj;jpag;
gl;oUe;jJ
vdf;Fj ;
fhyj;jpnyh
ehd ;
vd;why ;
,y;iy/
bjhpahJ/
vd ;
jfg;gdhh ;
jhth
brhj;jpw;F
,t;tHf;fpy ;
jhth
thp
brhj;J
fhyj;jpnyh.
Vd;
brYj;jpa[s;nsdh
vdf;Fg ;
ghj;jpag;
gl;lijf;fhl;l ehd; tUtha; Mtz';fs; Vjk; xg;g[tpj;Js;nsdh vd;why;
,y;iy.
__________
Page7 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
13. A perusal of the evidence of PW1 especially his admission, would
categorically established that the 1st and 2nd plaintiffs’ grand father Sundarappa
Gounder left the suit village in the year 1911. The plaintiffs have not produced
any acceptable evidence to show that the plaintiffs’ family exercised control
over the suit property after 1911. The PW1 also categorically admitted that the
suit property has been enjoyed by the forest department as protected forest.
Therefore, it is clear that the defendants are in possession and enjoyment of the
suit property for more than statutory period i.e. from 1911 till the date of suit as
protected forest. The plaintiffs never exercised any kind of right over the suit
property after 1911. In such circumstances, only based on the revenue records
i.e. Ex.A6, the plaintiffs cannot claim that they established their title over the
suit property and seek declaration of title over the property and recovery of
possession of the same. The plaintiffs have not produced any title documents to
prove their right over the suit property. Mere entry of 1 st and 2nd plaintiffs’ grand
father’s name in the revenue records is not sufficient to establish their title,
when the plaintiffs themselves admitted that they failed to exercise control over
the suit property for more than 100 years i.e. from the year 1911. In such
circumstances, both the courts below rightly appreciated the evidence available
on record and negatived the prayer for declaration of title and consequential
relief of recovery of possession. I do not find any perversity in the findings
reached by the courts below.
__________
Page8 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
14. Accordingly, the second appeal stands dismissed, as no substantial
question of law arising for consideration. There shall be no order as to costs.
CMP No.4545 of 2020 is allowed and Death Certificate and Legal Heirship
certificate of Sundarasamy are marked as Ex.A8 and Ex.A9 respectively.
09-04-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
MST
Plaintiffs side documents:
Ex.A8 13.10.2005
Death certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder
Ex.A9 01.02.2006
Legal Heirship certificate of Sundarasamy Gounder.
To
1. The Subordinate Judge, Dharampuram.
2. The District Munsif Court, Dharapuram.
__________
Page9 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 220 of 2020
S.SOUNTHAR, J.
MST
SA No. 220 of 2020
09-04-2026
__________
Page10 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review