The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In the case on hand, the applicants had not stated valid reasons and the reasons that the plaintiffs un- necessarily filing the suit against the defendants and for full-fledged trial and for proper appreciation of facts, the examination of plaintiffs 2 & 3 is very essential, are not sufficient to invoke provisions of Order XVI Rule 14 CPC,. Already the original plaintiff was Page7 of 9 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis A No. 6349 of 2025 examined as a witness and the applicants being the defendants have also crossexamined the said witnesses and now the case is posted for examination of defendants’ side evidence. At this stage, without completing their evidence, the defendants, without assigning any reasons, are not entitled to compel the parties to appear and to give evidence. Therefore, this application has no merits and deserves to be dismissed.
12. Accordingly, this application is dismissed. 23-02-2026 Page8 of 9 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis A No. 6349 of 2025
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A No. 6349 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 23-02-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
A No. 6349 of 2025
in
C.S.No.713 of 2019
1.A.Gowri Bai
No.11, 2nd Street, Bharathi Nagar, T.Nagar, Ch-17
2.A.Jaishankar
No.11, 2nd Street, Bharathi Nagar, T.Nagar, Ch-17
..Applicant(s)
Vs
M.K.Chandran (Deceased),
1.M.C. Chandra Kumar,
N.No.109, Iyyamudali Street, Chintadripet, Ch-2
2. M.C.Banugopan
Flat No.F-4, No.80-82, Nattu Subaraya Street,
Mylapore, Ch-4
3. M.C.Mageshwar
Flat No.F-4, No.80-82, Nattu Subaraya Street,
Mylapore, Ch-4
4. Sampoornam
Flat No.7, Nehru Street, Choolaimedu, Ch-94
5.M.K.Kathirvelan( deceased)
6..Arul Jothi
No.14/13, Rajiv Gandhi Street, Muthulakshmi
Nagar, Chitlapakkam, Ch-64
7. Annaporani
No.271/3, Mudhaliyar Thottam, Old
Suramangalam, Salem-636 005
__________
Page1 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
8. Sampoorani
Flat No.7, Nehru Street, Choolaimedu, Ch-94
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER: This petition has been filed seeking to issue summons to the 2nd and
3rd plaintiffs and examine them as witnesses.
For Applicant(s):
Mr.R.Suresh Kumar for M/S.K.M. Vijayan &
Associates
For Respondent(s):
Mr.P.N.George Grahan for
M/s.Devadasan and Sagar
ORDER
This application has been filed by the applicants to issue summons to the
second and third plaintiffs and examine them as witnesses.
2.The main suit is filed for partition and declaration, to declare the
settlement deeds as null and void.
3.According to the applicants, they are the defendants 1 & 2.
The
deceased plaintiff filed the suit for partition as against the defendants and during
the pendency of the suit, the original plaintiff died and his sons were impleaded
as the plaintiffs 2 & 3. Already the evidence of plaintiffs’ side was closed and
now the case is posted for defendants’ side witnesses. During the pendency of
__________
Page2 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
the suit, the first plaintiff died on 07.10.2025 and thereafter, the second and the
third plaintiffs were impleaded as parties. The applicants/defendants claimed
that though they had acquired the property through valid transactions, but they
were put to unnecessary sufferings by the plaintiffs under the guise of the
present suit. Therefore, the examination of the plaintiffs 2 & 3 is very essential
for full-fledged trial and for proper appreciation of the facts of the case. The
examination of the second and third plaintiffs is very relevant to bring out all
the earlier claims of the plaintiffs by filing the suit with false averments.
Therefore, the second and the third plaintiffs have to be examined as witnesses
and summons have to be issued to them.
4.The respondents filed a counter, denying all the allegations levelled in
the affidavit filed in support of the application and that the application is not
maintainable. The second plaintiff has not produced any authorisation from the
first plaintiff to file the application. In fact, after examination of plaintiffs’ side
witnesses, the case was posted for defendants’ side evidence.
The first
defendant also filed the written statement and the same was adopted by the
second defendant. The person, who sworn to the affidavit, was examined as
DW1 without obtaining any leave from the Court. After examination of DW1
and at the stage of continuance of cross examination, the original plaintiff died
and thereafter, the plaintiffs 2 & 3 were impleaded. In the meanwhile, the
fourth defendant also died and thereafter, steps have been taken and now the
__________
Page3 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
matter is posted for cross examination of DW1. At this stage, the present
petition is filed. Already the original plaintiff was examined as PW1 and all the
questions put to him by the defendants, were answered by him. After the
examination of PW1, he died on 07.10.2023. The other plaintiffs and the
defendants are children of the first plaintiff.
The petitioners should have
examined the first defendant as a witness to cull out the truth. Without doing
so, they have chosen to file this application to examine the plaintiffs 1 and 2 as
witnesses. They cannot compel the second and the third plaintiffs to examine as
witnesses and only in order to harass the respondents, they are attempting to fill
up the lacunae under the guise of present application, which is impermissible.
Therefore, this petition is liable to be dismissed.
5. This Court heard both sides and perused the records.
6.In this case, it is admitted fact that already the plaintiffs’ side evidence
was closed. Now the case is posted for examination of DW1 and the chief was
completed and the matter was adjourned for continuation of cross examination
of DW1. At this stage, the applicants have filed the application to examine the
plaintiffs 2 and 3 as witnesses. As per Order 16 Rule 14 of CPC, the Court has
power to summon the witnesses where the Court thinks it necessary to examine
any person other than a party to the suit and not called as a witness by the party
to the suit, to give evidence or to produce any document in his possession. In
__________
Page4 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
the case on hand, the applicants who are the defendants in the suit filed, the
application to summon the plaintiffs 2 and 3 as witnesses. Therefore, it is for
the Court to decide whether the examination of
the plaintiffs 2 and 3 is
necessary or not. The applicants have not stated any valid reasons to invoke the
power under Order 16 Rule 14 CPC. At this juncture, it is relevant to refer
Order 16 Rule 21 CPC which allows a party to a suit to summon another party
to appear as a witness, to give evidence, or to produce documents and when
summoned, the same provisions regarding witness attendance, expenses and
penalties apply to the party. In the case on hand, already the plaintiffs’ side
evidence was closed and the original plaintiff was examined as PW1 and he was
subjected to cross examination. Thereafter, the original plaintiff died and the
plaintiffs 2 and 3 were added as parties and they stepped into the shoes of the
original plaintiff. Once the original plaintiff was examined as witness, there is
no need to examine the other plaintiffs who stepped into the shoes of the
original plaintiff.
More over, the reasons assigned by the applicants are not
sufficient to invoke power under Order XVI Rule 14 of C.P.C,. Further, the
defendants have not completed their evidence and only after completing the
evidence of defendants’ side if any valid grounds available, the Court can
consider whether examination of particular person is necessary or not.
Therefore, the defendants are not entitled to compel the plaintiffs 2 and 3 for
their examination as witnesses.
__________
Page5 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
7. At this juncture, the learned counsel appearing for the applicants relied
on a judgment of this Court in the case of V.K.Periasamy @ Perianna Gounder
Vs. D. Rajan reported in 2001 (2) MLJ 235 wherein, this Court held that the
inclusion of provision under Order 16 Rule 21 CPC itself shows that there may
be situations where a party may be called upon by another to give evidence as
the
witness.
If there are very good reasons, the Court may exercise its
discretion in favour of the party, seeking permission. In the case on hand also
the applicants being the defendants, have filed this application to examine the
plaintiffs 2 and 3 as witnesses. But they have not stated any valid reasons to
examine the plaintiffs 2 & 3 as witnesses. Therefore, the said case law will not
be applicable to the present facts of the case.
8.At the same time, the learned counsel for the respondent relied upon the
judgments viz, (i) D.Babu Vs. K.A.Dinachandran in CRP(PD) No.3929 of
2012 (ii) Jortin Antony and Others
Vs. Padmanabha Dasa Marthanda
Varma and Others reported in AIR 2000 Kerala 369, (iii)Buddharaju
Suryanarayana Raju Vs. Gugilla Gandadhara Sastry in CRP Nos.1337 &
1348 of 2019 and (iv) Kaliaperumal Vs. Pankajavalli and Others, (Madras)
reported in 1999(1) LW 660.
9.On a careful perusal of the aforesaid judgments, it is clear that under
Order 16 Rule 21 of CPC, the plaintiff seeking to compel opposite party to be
__________
Page6 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
examined as witness, such practice is dis-approved by the Courts and the Privy
Council and a party cannot, as a matter of right, compel the opposite party to be
summoned or examined as a witness.
10. Further, it is clear that the power of Order 16 Rule 14 CPC should be
an exception particularly when a party decides to call his adversary as a witness
and merely because it is permissible when facts and circumstances of the case
did not warrant such action, the Court need not to exercise discretion in that
direction. Under Order 16 Rule 14 CPC, the plaintiffs cannot as a matter of
force include defendants in his schedule of witnesses. It is for the Court to
decide such necessity and then to compel a party to give evidence in exercise of
power under Order 16 Rule 14 CPC. Therefore, it is clear that the Court has
power to summon the witnesses including the parties to the proceedings when
they were not already examined as witnesses by a party to the suit. To exercise
such power, the Court first to form an opinion that it is necessary to examine
such person to give evidence.
11. In the case on hand, the applicants had not stated valid reasons and
the reasons that the plaintiffs un- necessarily filing the suit against the
defendants and for full-fledged trial and for proper appreciation of facts, the
examination of plaintiffs 2 & 3 is very essential, are not sufficient to invoke
provisions of Order XVI Rule 14 CPC,. Already the original plaintiff was
__________
Page7 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
examined as a witness and the applicants being the defendants have also crossexamined the said witnesses and now the case is posted for examination of
defendants’ side evidence. At this stage, without completing their evidence, the
defendants, without assigning any reasons, are not entitled to compel the parties
to appear and to give evidence. Therefore, this application has no merits and
deserves to be dismissed.
12. Accordingly, this application is dismissed.
23-02-2026
DN
__________
Page8 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A No. 6349 of 2025
P.DHANABAL J.
DN
A No. 6349 of 2025
in C.S.No.713 of 2019
23-02-2026
__________
Page9 of 9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review