Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 22-04-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE C.V. KARTHIKEYAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.RAJASEKAR
AS No.847 of 2018
1. A.Angappa Gounder (died)
2. A.Velusamy
3. A.Balusamy
4. A.Velliangiri
S.K.Palanisamy (died)
5. P.Velumani
6. P.Selvanayaki
7. P.Sasikala
8. P.Rukmani
9. E.Poovathal
10.Devi
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. V.Gurusamy (died)
2. A.Muthusamy
3. M.Gokulapriya
__________
Page1 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
4. G.Vijayalakshmi
5. V.G.Janani
6. G.Ashwin
Appellants 9 and 10 and Respondents 2 & 3 are
brought on record as L.Rs.of the deceased 1st
Appellant (A.Angappa Gounder) vide Order of
Court dated 18.03.2021 made in C.M.P.No.5007 of
2021.
R1 died. R4 to R6 are brought on record as LRs of
deceased R1, vide Order of Court, dated
18.11.2024 made in CMP.Nos.25743, 25746 and
25748 of 2024.
..Respondent(s)
Appeal against the judgment and decree dated 22/12/2017 made in
O.S.No.473/2006 on the file of II Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Tiruppur.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.N.Manokaran
For Respondent(s):
Mr.T.Gowthaman,
Senior Counsel,
for Dr.S.Kanagapriya
for R4 to R6
R-1 died
No appearance for R2 & 3
JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by C.V.Karthikeyan J.)
The defendants in O.S.No.473 of 2006 on the file of II Additional District
Court, Tiruppur, aggrieved by the judgment, dated 22.12.2017, by which
judgment, the relief sought for specific performance was granted, have filed this
appeal.
__________
Page2 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
2. The suit in O.S.No.473 of 2006 had been filed by the respondent –
V.Gurusamy, who died pending this appeal. His legal representatives have been
brought on record. In the plaint, he claimed that the properties mentioned in the
schedule to the plaint belonged to the first defendant – A.Angappagounder,
which properties had been allotted to him under a partition deed, dated
07.06.1958. In the partition deed, the said properties had been described as
‘Schedule-C’. The second, third and fourth defendants, namely, A.Vellusamy,
A.Ballusamy and A.Vellingiri are the three sons of the first defendant. It had
been contended that the defendants 1 to 4 had offered to sell the suit properties
to the plaintiff for a total consideration of Rs.66,65,000/- and thus the
agreement was reduced into writing on 09.10.2003. It was further contended
that an advance of Rs.1,00,000/- had been paid at the time of agreement.
3. It was also contended that on 04.12.2003, detailed terms of the
agreement were further written down and the plaintiff and the first, second and
third defendants had signed in the said agreement. On that day, a further
advance of Rs.15,50,000/- had been paid by the plaintiff. It was received by the
first, second and third defendants on their behalf and on behalf of the fourth
defendant, who was not present on 04.12.2003 and who did not also sign in the
agreement of sale. Subsequently, the fourth defendant came on 23.12.2003 and
affirmed the terms of the agreement, dated 04.12.2003, and signed in the
agreement on 23.12.2003. It had been further contended that copies of the title
deeds had been handed over to the plaintiff.
__________
Page3 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
4. The object of the plaintiff was to convert the land, which was the
subject matter of the agreement, into house sites to form a layout and sell them
to third parties. It was further contended that possession had also been handed
over by the defendants 1 to 4 and permission was also granted to convert the
lands into house sites to form layout, which was also named as ‘VGV Sri
Garden’.
It was also contended that the plaintiff was doing construction
business and was carrying on construction in the adjacent village to the suit
property. It was stated that the plaintiff thereafter made improvements in the
portion of the property by levelling the land and by removing unwanted earth
and made the land fit for conversion into house sites.
5. It was further contended that the defendants 1 to 4 did not come
forward to perform their part of the agreement. It was also contended that the
plaintiff had agreed to pay the balance sale consideration of Rs.50,15,000/- on
or before 04.03.2005. A further advance of Rs.3,50,000/- had been paid
subsequent to the agreement and another advance of Rs.35,000/- had been paid
to the third defendant on 26.06.2004. The plaintiff, therefore, contended that a
total advance of Rs.20,35,000/- had been paid. The plaintiff contended that he
was ready and willing to pay the balance sale consideration and to deposit the
same into court.
6. The plaintiff, thereafter, issued a notice on 24.02.2005 to the
defendants 1 to 4, stating that he would wait at the Sub Registrar’s Office,
Avinashi, on 01.03.2005, at about 11.00 A.M., and called upon the defendants
__________
Page4 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
to come and execute the sale deed. But, however, the defendants 1 to 4 did not
come over to Sub Registrar’s Office even on 02.03.2005, though a telegram to
that effect had been issued. It had been contended that a notice had been issued
by the defendants 1 to 4 on 03.03.2005 stating that they were ready to complete
the transaction on 09.03.2005 after receiving the balance of sale consideration.
The said notice was received by the plaintiff only on 09.03.2005 at 02.00 P.M.
and immediately the plaintiff had gone to Sub-Registrar’s Office and waited for
the defendants 1 to 4 there. The plaintiff then issued a reply on 09.03.2005 on
the same day, complaining about the violation of the terms of the notice by the
defendants 1 to 4. Thereafter, the defendants 1 to 4 again issued a notice on
19.03.2005. It had been contended that the defendants had violated the terms of
the agreement.
7. The plaintiff had also lodged a police complaint on 16.03.2005 before
Annuparpalayam Police Station. It was also stated that further disputes had
arisen between the parties, necessitating proceedings to be issued under Section
145 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It had been contended that the plaintiff
thereafter came to know that the defendants 1 to 4 had conveyed the property by
way of two sale deeds, dated 11.08.2005, for a sum of Rs.2,51,000/- and
Rs.3,61,800/- in favour of the fifth defendant. It was contended that the said sale
deeds were null and void and not binding on the plaintiff. It was also stated that
the fifth defendant was not a bonafide purchaser for valuable consideration and
he had not purchased the property in good faith. The plaintiff further contended
__________
Page5 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
that the defendants were aware that the plaintiff had made improvements over
the property. It was stated that the plaintiff was in possession of the property
and therefore entitled to the benefit under Section 53-A of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, to protect his possession. It was under these circumstances
that the suit had been filed, seeking specific performance of the agreement of
sale entered into between the plaintiff and the defendants 1 to 4 on receipt of
balance sale consideration of Rs.46,30,000/- and for a direction to register the
sale deed in favour of the plaintiff or in the alternative to pay to the plaintiff the
advance amount received together with interest and also costs of the suit.
8. The second defendant had filed a written statement, which was also
adopted by the defendants 1, 3 and 4. It had been contended that the agreement,
which had been purportedly entered into between the plaintiff on the one hand
and the defendants 1 to 4 on the other hand was not a registered agreement and
therefore no relief could be claimed on the same. It was also contended that the
property was ancestral property allotted to the first defendant under a deed of
partition, dated 07.06.1958. It was further stated that one of the daughters
namely Easwari died on 27.11.1999 and on her demise 1/8th share in the suit
property devolved on her husband Muthusamy and minor daughter Gokila
Priya. It had been contended that the daughters had not joined in the agreement
with the plaintiff.
9. It was also stated that the plaintiff had entered into the agreement only
for commercial purpose and therefore time was essence of the contract, and
__________
Page6 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
there was delay and latches on the part of the plaintiff. It was further contended
that possession was never handed over to the plaintiff and averments to that
extent were not correct. It was also contended that the defendants 1 to 4
continued to be in possession of the suit schedule property. The averment of the
plaintiff that he had made improvements in the suit property was also denied
and on the other hand it was contended that the defendants 1 to 4 raised crops in
the suit land. It had been stated that since the plaintiff did not come forward to
pay the total sale consideration within the time stipulated, the advance paid by
him was liable to be forfeited. With respect to the notices said to have been
issued by the plaintiff, a contrary stand was taken by the defendants and it was
contended that they had not received the notices issued by the plaintiff and on
the other hand they had issued a notice to the plaintiff and that it was the
plaintiff, who had not come forward to complete the registration formalities. It
had been contended that the property was sold to the fifth defendant and that it
was a bonafide transaction. They, accordingly, contended that the suit should be
dismissed.
10. During the pendency of the suit, the subsequent purchaser, namely,
the fifth defendant died, necessitating his legal heirs to be brought on record as
defendants 6 to 9. The sixth defendant filed a separate written statement and it
was adopted by the defendants 7 to 9.
11. In the written statement, the sixth defendant contended that the suit
was not maintainable and was barred under Section 17 (1) A of the Registration
__________
Page7 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
Act, as the agreement, dated 04.12.2003, was not a registered document. It was
contended that the fifth defendant, under whom the defendants 6 to 9 derived
title to the suit property, was a bonafide purchaser of the suit property, without
notice or knowledge of the earlier agreement in favour of the plaintiff. It was
stated that there were other co-sharers in the property and, in the absence of
their consent, the defendants 1 to 4 entered into the agreement of sale and,
therefore, the agreement entered by the plaintiff with the defendants 1 to 4 with
regard to the suit property was not valid or enforceable and, therefore, the
plaintiff could not seek enforcement of the agreement of sale. It had also been
stated that though reply notice had been issued by the defendants on
09.10.2006, the suit had been filed after 19 months from the date of refusal by
the defendants to perform their part of the agreement. It was further contended
that the suit should be dismissed on account of delay and laches. The contention
of the plaintiff that he was always ready and willing to perform his part of the
contract with the defendants 1 to 4 was denied and disputed. Thus, the said
defendants claimed that the suit should be dismissed.
12. The plaintiff filed a reply statement, reiterating the facts stated in the
plaint. It was very specifically contended that the receipt, dated 09.10.2003, and
sale agreement, dated 04.12.2003, were admissible documents. It was stated
that the plaintiff was in possession of the property and that the sale in favour of
the fifth defendant was neither bonafide nor for valuable consideration.
Accordingly, it was prayed that the suit should be decreed as prayed for.
__________
Page8 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
13. On the basis of the aforementioned pleadings, the learned trial Judge
had framed the following issues :
1. Whether the plaintiff is in possession of the suit property as per the
receipt dated 09.10.2003 and regular agreement dated 04.12.2003 ?
2. Whether there is delay and laches on the part of the plaintiff in
performing the agreement ?
3.Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of specific
performance ?
4. To what relief, the plaintiff is entitled ?
14. During the course of trial, the plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1
and he also examined one other witness as P.W.2. The plaintiff marked Exs.A-1
to A-75 on his side. On the side of defendants, the second defendant examined
himself as D.W.1 and the seventh defendant examined herself as D.W.2. The
defendants marked Exs.B-1 to B-3 on their side. Exs.C-1 to C-12 were also
marked as Court Documents. The receipt dated 09.10.2003 was marked as
Ex.A-1 and the agreement dated 04.12.2003 was marked as Ex.A-2. Notices
exchanged between the parties were also marked as documents. The plaintiff
also marked the Electricity Board Receipts and other documents relating to
possession. The sale deeds in favour of the fifth defendant, dated 11.08.2005,
were marked as Ex.A-24 and Ex.A-25. An Advocate Commissioner was
appointed during the course of trial and his report and sketches were marked as
Ex.C-1 and C-2.
__________
Page9 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
15. On the basis of the evidence adduced, the learned trial Judge, with
respect to the first and second issues, namely, whether the agreement was
enforceable, and whether the plaintiff was in possession of the suit property and
whether there was delay on the part of the plaintiff in performing the agreement,
examined the partition deed, by which the property had been allotted to the first
defendant under Ex.A-3, dated 07.06.1958, and came to the conclusion that
since the property had been allotted under the partition deed, it should be
considered only as acquired property of the first defendant and therefore his
legal heirs – defendants 2 to 4 had a right and share over the property. It was
further observed that the fifth defendant was the father-in-law of the fourth
defendant, which fact had been admitted by D.W.1 in his evidence. It was also
noted that an advance of Rs.20,35,000/- had been paid in the year 2003 towards
a total sale consideration of Rs.66,65,000/- and that in the year 2005, the fifth
defendant had purchased the properties for Rs.6,13,300/-. The learned trial
Judge held that the said document could not be said to have been executed in
good faith and for bonafide consideration.
16. The evidence of the defendants was also considered. The learned trial
Judge held that the sale deed in favour of the fifth defendant was not a bonafide
document. With respect to the allegation by the defendants that the plaintiff had
deliberately delayed in performing his part of the agreement, the learned trial
Judge was of the opinion that no such evidence was culled out during the cross
__________
Page10 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
examination of P.W.1. In view of the said reasons, the issues were answered
that the plaintiff could not be held to have delayed the performance of the
agreement and it was therefore held that the agreement could be enforced by
order of the Court. Holding as above, the relief of specific performance was
granted.
17. Questioning the said judgment and decree and the directions issued,
the defendants have filed the present appeal.
18. Mr.N.Manokaran, learned counsel for the appellants, took the court
through the facts of the case and the exhibits A-1, A-2, A-8 and A-9, which had
been attested by P.W.2 as a witness. He was an employee of the plaintiff. It was
contended that the suit had been filed on 14.10.2006, though the plaintiff based
a claim on the agreement of sale in the year 2003. It was contended that under
Ex.A-1 and also under Ex.A-2, the property had been described as ancestral
property. It was specifically contended that the agreement was an unregistered
one and it had been cancelled subsequently. It had been stated that after
termination of the agreement, the plaintiff had instituted the suit after nearly 1
year and 7 months. It was contended that the agreement was to put up house
sites and therefore the object was commercial in nature and hence time was the
essence of the agreement. It was also contended that the advance said to have
been paid on 26.06.2004 was paid only to the third defendant. The notice
under Ex.A-10 had been returned and refused.
__________
Page11 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
19. The learned counsel argued that the property was sold on 11.08.2005
and it was contended that the plaintiff had not come to the court with clean
hands and deliberately delayed in coming to the court and seeking specific
performance. The learned counsel was emphatic in his submissions that the
appeal should be allowed and the judgment and decree of the trial court set
aside. He also took the court to the terms of the agreement under Ex.A-2, which
very specifically stated that if there is non-performance within the time fixed,
the agreement could not be enforced and that the appellants herein/defendants
were not liable to execute the sale deed.
20. The above argument was disputed by Mr.T.Gowthaman, learned
Senior Counsel for the respondents. It was contended by the learned Senior
Counsel that the agreement of sale had been admitted and total consideration of
66,65,000/- was also admitted, so also the payments of the advance amounts. He
contended that the fifth defendant remained ex parte during his life time and
only after his death, the defendants 6 to 9 filed their written statement. It was
contended that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to pay the balance sale
consideration
and,
in
that
connection,
notice
was
issued
by
the
respondent/plaintiff. It was argued by drawing attention to the notice that the
plaintiff had been to the office of the Sub-Registrar, Avinashi, and documents
evidencing that fact were also produced during trial. It was also contended that
there were continuous correspondences by the plaintiff to the defendants
seeking performance of their part of the agreement. It was stated that the
__________
Page12 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
plaintiff was in possession of the properties and therefore delay could not be
attributed to the plaintiff. The learned Senior Counsel further contended that
continuous talks were in progress between the parties.
It was stated that
substantial amount had been paid as advance and, therefore, the plaintiff could
not be faulted for any delay in enforcing his rights under the agreement. He
urged dismissal of the appeal.
21. We have carefully considered the arguments advanced and also
perused the material records.
22.
The
points
which
arise
for
consideration
are
:
(i) Whether the agreement, dated 04.12.2003, is enforceable? ;
(ii) Whether there was any delay, as alleged by the defendants/appellants
herein, on the part of the plaintiff / respondent herein, in performing the
agreement?;and
(iii) Whether the plaintiff / respondent herein, was ready and willing to
perform his part of the agreement with respect to part of the balance sale
consideration ?
23. Since the evidence overlaps, all the points are taken up for
consideration together.
24. The parties would be referred to in the same nomenclature as they
deserved in the plaint, which would indicate that the appellants were referred to
as the defendants and the respondent as the plaintiff.
__________
Page13 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
25. The suit in O.S.No.473 of 2006 was laid by the plaintiff, seeking
specific performance of an unregistered agreement, dated 04.12.2003. Even
earlier to that particular agreement, a receipt under Ex.A-1 was issued on
09.10.2003 by the plaintiff. This document is not in dispute. Under the said
document, which had been signed by the defendants 1 to 4, it had been very
specifically stated that the property had been allotted to the first defendant under
a partition deed of the year 1958 and that the property had flowed down by way
of ancestral succession and that the property was agreed to be conveyed at the
rate at Rs.15,500/- per cent for total consideration of Rs.66,65,000/-. A sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- was received by the defendants from the plaintiff as advance, and,
on receipt of the same, the signatories, namely, the defendants 1 to 4 handed
over the possession of the suit property to the plaintiff. It had also been stated
that the balance sale consideration should be paid on or before 17.11.2003. It
was also stated that a further advance of Rs.16,41,250/- should be paid by the
plaintiff.
26. Thereafter, the parties entered into Ex.A-2, which was the agreement
of sale. It was dated 04.12.2003. This again had been entered into by the
defendants 1 to 4. In the said agreement, they stated that even earlier, they had
received an advance of Rs.1,00,000/- and that they had received a further
advance of Rs.15,50,000/-, under this agreement. This indicated, a total advance
of Rs.16,50,000/- had been paid. The plaintiff was entitled to sub-divide the
__________
Page14 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
land into plots and form a layout and in pursuance of that objective, possession
had been handed over. It was also stated that the plaintiff could seek approval
for layout and that relevant documents had been handed over. Title deeds had
also been handed over to the plaintiff.
27. The time was also specifically mentioned, which was 04.03.2005, by
which date the entire transaction should be completed. It was further stated that
if there was failure on the part of the plaintiff, the advance amount paid by him
would be forfeited and the entire documents handed over would be returned
back. It was also stated that the patta passbook and the original document were
to be handed over. It must be mentioned that the defendants had handed over
copies of the documents. The agreement had been attested by two witnesses,
who were the same witnesses who attested Ex.A-1. However, the name of the
person, who prepared the document, had been kept blank. This document is
again not in dispute.
It is on the basis of this document that specific
performance was sought in the suit.
28. Thereafter, further advances had been paid by the plaintiff to the
defendants. An advance of Rs.3,50,000/- was paid on 24.04.2004 under Ex.A-8
and a further advance of Rs.3,35,000/- was paid to the third defendant on
26.06.2004 under Ex.A-9. Then notices started emanating. The plaintiff issued
the first notice to the defendants on 24.02.2005. It must be kept in mind that
time for performance of the agreement under Ex.A-2 was given as 04.03.2005.
A pre-suit notice had been issued by the plaintiff on 24.02.2005 under Ex.A-10,
__________
Page15 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
calling upon the defendants 1 to 4 to come over to the Sub Registrar’s Office,
Avinashi, on 01.03.2005. Exs.A-11 to A-14 were the returned covers of the
said notice. The notice, dated 24.02.2005, had been returned as ‘refused’ by the
defendants on 28.02.2005. The date of refusal was 28.02.2005. The
endorsement of the Postman is also very clear that the addressees refused to
receive the notices. Thereafter, on 03.03.2005, the defendants 1 to 4 issued a
notice under Ex.A-15.
29. At this juncture, it must be stated that they earlier refused to receive
the notice issued by the plaintiff on 28.02.2005 and after about three days they
had issued the notice on 03.03.2005 under Ex.A-15, calling upon the plaintiff to
get the sale deed registered on 09.03.2005 on payment of balance sale
consideration of Rs.46,65,000/-.
30. It is the case of the plaintiff that this notice was received by him only
on 09.03.2005, on which date the plaintiff issued a reply notice under Ex.A-16.
The plaintiff claimed that earlier he had issued a notice, calling upon the
defendants to come over to the Sub Registrar’s Office, Avinashi, to register the
sale deed. He had also caused a telegraphic notice on 02.03.2005 and waited for
a long time at the office of the Sub-Registrar’s Office, Avinashi. It was further
contended that the defendants had not come over, but the plaintiff was waiting
at the Office of Sub-Registrar, Avinashi.
31. The exchange of notices reveals two certain facts ; (i) The plaintiff
had caused a notice prior to the date mentioned in the agreement for completion
__________
Page16 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
of agreement of sale and (ii) the notices had been refused to be received by the
defendants 1 to 4.
32. Thereafter, both sides again issued notices, calling upon the other side
to come over to execute the sale deed. It must be pointed that the consideration
had been determined at the rate per cent at Rs.15,500/- and the total
consideration was Rs.66,65,000/-. Even when the notices were being exchanged
between the plaintiff on the one hand and the defendants 1 to 4 on the other
hand, Ex.B-1 notice came to be issued by the daughters of the first defendant
and the sisters of the defendants 2 to 4, claiming a share in the property and
seeking partition and separate possession. Once a dispute had arisen within the
family of the defendants with respect to the title of the property, naturally, the
plaintiff, having paid a substantial amount as advance, would have to await the
resolution of such dispute. It is seen that a police complaint was also given by
the plaintiff, claiming that he was in possession. This said document had been
marked as Ex.A-60. This was dated 16.03.2005. In the meanwhile, a rejoinder
to the notice had been issued by the defendants 1 to 4 to the plaintiff. The
rejoinder to the notice was marked as Ex.A-17, dated 19.03.2005. Under that
notice, the defendants terminated the agreement and sought return of originals
of the partition deed and patta passbook, which had been given under Exs.A-3
and A-4 respectively.
33. Immediately thereafter, within five months, the defendants sold the
property to the fifth defendant. The sale deeds of the said transactions had been
__________
Page17 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
marked as Ex.A-24 and A-25, both of which were dated 11.08.2005. Those sale
deeds had been executed by Angappa Gounder/first defendant, his first son
A.Balusamy on his behalf and on behalf of his minor daughter; his second son
A.Velusamy on his behalf and on behalf of his minor daughter; and his third son
A.Vellingiri also on his behalf and on behalf of his minor children.
34. Very significantly, it had been claimed by the defendants that the
property was ancestral property. The daughters of the first defendant/sisters of
the defendants 2 to 4 had issued a notice under Ex.B-1 even earlier on
09.03.2005, claiming a share in the property and also title to a portion of the
property. They had however not come forward to execute the sale deed under
Exs.A-24, dated 11.08.2005. Another sale deed was also executed on the very
same day under Exs.A-25 again in favour of the fifth defendant. That was also
executed only by the first defendant and the defendants 2 to 4 on their behalf
and also on behalf of their minor children. Once again, the daughters did not
join the sale deed.
35. This only indicates that the claim of the daughters for a share of the
property was only to avoid the agreement of sale being enforced by the plaintiff
as against the defendants 1 to 4 or to protract that particular aspect. More
significantly, under Ex.A-24, the total sale consideration was Rs.2,50,000/- and
under Ex.A-25, the total sale consideration was Rs.3,60,000/-. This would
indicate that for a total sale consideration of Rs.6,10,000/-, the entire property,
which had been earlier agreed to be sold to the plaintiff for a consideration of
__________
Page18 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
Rs.66,65,000/-, had been conveyed. By no stretch of imagination, could the
consideration be termed as adequate consideration. The trial Judge was also of
the opinion that the documents were sham documents created to defeat the
rights of the plaintiff.
36. It is also to be noted that the fifth defendant had been impleaded in
the suit, but, he did not even participate in the proceedings. It is to be further
noted that the fifth defendant was the father-in-law of the fourth defendant.
37. All these facts, namely, refusal of the notices by the defendants, the
notices issued by the daughters of the first defendant seeking share in the
property, the sale deeds executed by the defendants 1 to 4 avoiding the
daughters in the family to the fifth defendant, the consideration under the sale
deeds being extremely inadequate and the purchaser/fifth defendant being the
father-in-law of the fourth defendant, and avoiding participating in the judicial
proceedings would only indicate that the defendants had deliberately avoided
performance of the agreement of sale and had put an effective spoke on the
plaintiff proceeding further with the execution of the sale deed and obtaining
registration of the sale deed.
38. Further, the proceedings under Section 144 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure would also show that a dispute had arisen regarding the possession of
the property. The plaintiff had very specifically stated that he had been
permitted to enter upon the property for the purpose of forming a layout and to
do excavation and development of the property. He also claimed the rights as a
__________
Page19 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
person in possession of the property. If such possession had never been given,
there was no necessity for the plaintiff to invoke the proceedings under Section
144 of Cr.P.C. An F.I.R. had also been registered by the revenue authorities.
39. Learned counsel for the appellants pointed out that the suit had been
instituted nearly after one year and seven months from the date of cancellation/
termination of the agreement by the defendants.
40. But, the supervening circumstances, namely, the daughters of first
defendant issuing notice seeking partition and share in the property; the police
complaint being lodged relating to possession and the sale of the property to the
fifth defendant on 11.08.2005 and yet another police complaint being lodged
under Ex.A-62 on 12.10.2006 would all go to show that the plaintiff had a
reasonable cause and valid explanation for waiting to institute the suit. The suit
could never be termed as having been filed beyond the period of limitation, as it
was filed within the period of limitation.
41. Article 54 of the Limitation Act,1963, prescribes a three-year
limitation period for filing a suit for specific performance of a contract. The
three-year period begins from the date fixed for performance, or if no date is
fixed, from the date the plaintiff has notice of refusal to perform. In this case,
the date of refusal was 09.03.2005. The suit was filed on 14.10.2006, well
within the period of limitation.
42. With respect to the issue of readiness and willingness, it is to be noted
that the plaintiff had paid Rs.20,35,000/- nearly one-third of the total
__________
Page20 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
consideration as advance out of the total consideration of Rs.66,65,000/-. An
endorsement in this regard had also been made by the defendants. There is no
specific denial of non-receipt of such advance amounts by the defendants.
43. Learned counsel for the appellants placed reliance upon a decision of
a Division Bench of this Court in T.R.Murugesan v. S.Balakrishnan & Others,
(2018) 6 CTC 56, wherein, four months’ delay was frowned upon. In this case,
various supervening circumstances had been created by the defendants and we
hold the plaintiff could not be faulted for the delay in instituting the suit. At any
rate, again, it must be reiterated that the suit had been instituted within the
period of limitation.
44. Learned counsel for the appellants also laid stress on the fact that the
agreement having been terminated by the defendants, relief should have been
sought with respect to such termination. In this connection, reliance had been
placed on a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in K.S.Manjunath and
Others v. Moorasavirappa Muttanna Chennappa Batil and Others, Civil
Appeal Nos.13507-13508 of 2025, dated 10.11.2025, wherein, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had dismissed the failure to challenge the legality and validity of
termination of agreement for sale in the suit.
45. But, however, we must point out that the plaintiff had issued the first
notice, calling upon the defendants to come over to the Sub-Registrar’s Office,
Avinashi, to execute the sale deed. The defendants had refused to receive that
particular notice. Thereafter, there had been further exchange of notices and
__________
Page21 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
only finally on 09.03.2005, the defendants 1 to 4 had issued a
terminating the agreement.
notice,
Subsequently, they themselves had sold the
property to the fifth defendant. In the intervening period, the daughters of the
first defendant had issued a notice seeking partition of the property and claiming
a share in the property. In view of these facts, the notice for termination could
only be said to have been issued to avoid performance of the agreement and to
prevent the plaintiff from seeking enforcement of the agreement. The said
notice lacked bonafide, which was evident by the subsequent conduct in
conveying the property to the fifth defendant, who was none other than the
father-in-law of the fourth defendant and who remained ex parte during the
pendency of the proceedings. Further, the plaintiff had sought an overdraft
facility from the bank under Exs.A-72, covering the entire sale consideration,
but could not utilise the overdraft owing to the fact that the property had already
been sold to the fifth defendant and the daughters of the first defendant had
raised a claim of share in the property and there were exchange of notices,
which manifestly indicated that the defendants were protracting their obligation
to the performance of the agreement. It is also to be noted that the plaintiff had
deposited the entire balance sale consideration before the trial Court,
immediately after the pronouncement of the judgment.
46. In view of these reasons, we hold that the learned trial Judge had
correctly appreciated the evidence particularly with respect to the lack of
bonafide on the part of the defendants, which was reflected by the conveyance
__________
Page22 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
of the property to the fifth defendant for an extremely inadequate consideration
and when the agreement was subsisting and also owing to the fact that the
plaintiff had also paid substantial part of the sale consideration to the
defendants, coupled with the fact that the agreement was never in dispute.
47. This Appeal Suit is dismissed, confirming the judgment and the
decree of the trial Court. No costs.
(C.V.K.,J.) (K.R.S.,J.)
22-04-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking order
DIXIT
To
1.II Additional District Judge,
Tiruppur.
2.V.R.Section,
High Court,
Madras.
__________
Page23 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1782
AS No.847 of 2018
C.V.KARTHIKEYAN, J.
AND
K.RAJASEKAR, J.
DIXIT
AS No. 847 of 2018
22-04-2026
__________
Page24 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review