The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Writ appeal is disposed of accordingly.” In view of the Judgment of the Division Bench of this Court (supra) and considering that the challenge in the instant Appeal is on the exact same issue, as already extracted hereinabove, the position of this Court is no more res integra thereto. No further discussion need ensue on this matter. The Order dated 27-06-2022, of the Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax, Gangtok Division, is consequently set aside.
8. Writ Petition accordingly stands disposed of in terms of the decision of this Court in WA No.02 of 2024 (Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India and Others). ( Meenakshi Madan Rai ) Judge 11-08-2025 ds/sdl Approved for reporting : Yes
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:93
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 11th August, 2025
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.10 of 2024
:
Petitioner
Zydus Wellness-Sikkim
versus
Respondents
:
The Assistant Commissioner,
Central Goods and Service Tax and Others
Application under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Mayank Jain, Mr. Mukesh M. Patel and Mr. Hissay Gyaltsen,
Advocates for the Petitioner.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of India for the
Respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner is aggrieved by the Order dated 27-06-
2022, of the Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service
Tax, Gangtok Division, vide which it was inter alia ordered that the
taxpayer
had
claimed
budgetary
support
of
Rs.59,44,977/-
(Rupees fifty nine lakhs, forty four thousand, nine hundred and
seventy seven) only, however, on verification it is found that the
eligible budgetary support payable is in the negative and hence,
the taxpayer is not eligible for the budgetary support claim
amount.
2.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner invited the attention
of this Court to the Judgment of the Division Bench of this High
Court in WA No.02 of 2024 (Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs.
Union of India and Others). It was contended that the Division Bench
had discussed and disposed of the same issue in the matter and
2025:SHC:93
WP(C) No.10 of 2024
Zydus Wellness-Sikkim vs. The Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax and Others
had directed the Respondent to consider the claims of the
Petitioner from July, 2017 to September, 2017 on the same terms
as was considered by the concerned authority in light of the Order
of the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh dated 28-022023, rendered in Coromandel International Ltd. vs. Union of India and
Others .
Hence this Petition be disposed of in terms of the
Judgment of this Court (supra).
3.
Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India submits that
she has no objection to the submissions advanced by Learned
Counsel for the Petitioner in view of the above cited Judgment of
this High Court.
4.
Considered submissions.
5.
The Division Bench of this High Court, in WA No.02 of
2024 (Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India and Others),
dated 15-05-2025 was considering the Judgment of the Learned
Single Judge in WP(C) No.02 of 2023 (Glenmark Pharmaceuticals
Limited vs. Union of India and Others), dated 06-05-2024, vide
which, the Order dated 01-03-2022 of the Respondent No.3, was
upheld and the Writ Petition dismissed.
The attention of the
Division Bench had been drawn to the Judgment of Coromandel
International Ltd. (supra).
6.
Having given due consideration to the submissions
advanced, this Court in the WA (supra), observed inter alia as
follows;
“8.
In Coromandel International Ltd. (supra)
the order dated 02- 02-2021, passed by respondent
no.3 therein (the adjudicating authority), rejecting
the claim of the concerned petitioner, under
budgetary support scheme, notified vide Notifications
no. F.No.10(1)/2017-DBA-II/NER, dated 05-10-2017,
SRO 519 dated 21- 12-2017 and SRO 521 dated 2112-2017 was assailed. The petitioner sought for a writ
of mandamus directing the respondents to allow the
2023(74) GSTL 208 (J & K and Ladakh) = MANU/JK/0166/2023
2025:SHC:93
WP(C) No.10 of 2024
Zydus Wellness-Sikkim vs. The Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax and Others
budgetary support to it, by calculating the same on
the quantum of cash tax paid through cash ledger
account, on monthly basis, instead of adopting the
calculations on quarterly basis. The petitioner had
applied for reimbursement by way of budgetary
support for the period, January 2020 to March 2020
and April 2020 to June 2020 before the Central Tax
Authorities. The petitioner contended that, the
adjudicating authority illegally and arbitrarily rejected
the reimbursement under budgetary support, on the
ground, that the petitioner had closing balance of
input tax credit lying unutilized at the end of quarter
and had reduced the budgetary support arbitrarily to
the extent of the closing balance of input tax credit
that remained unutilized at the end of the quarter.
The petitioner dissatisfied with the order of rejection
was before the High Court. The High Court took into
consideration the departmental clarification dated 2604-2022 (supra) and inter alia ordered as follows;
“6. Having heard Learned Counsel
for the parties and perused the material
on record, we are of the view that,
issuance of clarification by the Finance
Department, UT of Jammu and Kashmir,
has necessitated revisiting of claim of the
petitioner by the Adjudicating Authority.
7. In view of the above, these
petitions are disposed of by providing as
under:
The impugned order passed by
respondent No.3 is quashed and the
mattes remanded to respondent No.3 to
reconsider the entire issue having regard
to the clarification issued by the
Department of Finance, UT of Jammu
and Kashmir Bearing No.FD-ST/29/202203,
dated
26-4-2022
and
pass
appropriate orders on merits.”
(i)
In this context for the purposes of this
appeal, we may relevantly refer to clause 5.4 of the
Notification dated 05-10-2017, of the Department of
Industrial Policy and Promotion, Ministry of Commerce
and Industry, Government of India, which reads as
follows;
“5.4
Budgetary support under this
scheme shall be worked out on quarterly
basis for which claims shall be filed on a
quarterly basis namely for January to
March, April to June, July to September
& October to December.”
(ii)
Reverting to the clarification dated 2604-2022, indeed we are fully aware and conscious of
the fact that it was in relation to budgetary support
scheme for the then State of Jammu and Kashmir
under the Jammu and Kashmir Goods and Services
Tax Act, 2017. Nonetheless, the matter pertained to a
similar issue as in the instant petition, concerning
budgetary support and claims to be filed. The
rationale for the clarification was that the industrial
units were paying taxes on monthly basis, by filing
2025:SHC:93
WP(C) No.10 of 2024
Zydus Wellness-Sikkim vs. The Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax and Others
monthly GSTR – 3B returns; consequently the
reimbursement amount should be calculated on
monthly basis although reimbursement would be on a
quarterly basis. The petitioner herein also canvassed
that the returns under the GST are filed on monthly
basis, therefore, the same rationale ought to be
applied in the instant matter. We are inclined to agree
with the arguments advanced by the petitioner, while
also taking into consideration the Circular dated 1001-2019 of the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and
Customs, Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Government of India, wherein it was inter
alia considered at paragraphs 5 and 6 as follows;
“5. …………………………………………………
An issue regarding difficulty in
verification for the refund claim was
raised by Chief Commissioner (Shillong).
As per the procedure in place, an
assessed files monthly returns under the
GST whereas the refund application is for
the quarter.
6. Accordingly, it was decided that
in the table annexed to the refund
application month wise details may be
attached. This would enable speedier and
more accurate verification of the refund
claims.”
As the Circular (supra) also envisages month-wise
details it stands to reason that claims could be raised
accordingly.
9.
We are not in agreement with the
submissions of Deputy Solicitor of India for the
respondents no.1 and 2, who was of the view that
even though there was compliance of the order of the
High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh directing
the adjudicating authority to take steps in terms of
the clarification dated 26-04-2022, yet clarification
issued subsequently by the DPIIT, Nodal Central
Agency, dated 21-09-2023, is to be given more
weightage over and above the order of the High
Court, which proposition by itself is preposterous and
untenable.
10.
It is relevant also to notice that the
doctrine of judicial comity or amity, requires the Court
not to pass an order which would be in conflict with
another order passed by a competent court of law. In
India Household and Healthcare Ltd. vs. LG Household and
Healthcare Ltd. [(2007) 5 SCC 510] the Supreme Court
observed that;
“19. A court while exercising its
judicial function would ordinarily not pass
an order which would make one of the
parties to the lis violate a lawful order
passed by another court.”
The above judgment was taken note of and
considered by one of us (Biswanath Somadder) in
Nirendra Kumar Saha & Ors. vs. Steel Authority of India
Ltd. and Ors. [(2009) 2 CHN 306 = (2009) 2 Cal LT 367 = 2009 SCC OnLine
Cal 619]
2025:SHC:93
WP(C) No.10 of 2024
Zydus Wellness-Sikkim vs. The Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and Service Tax and Others
(i)
In Yashita Sahu vs. State of Rajasthan and
Others [(2020) 3 SCC 67] the Supreme Court observed as
follows;
“19. We are of the considered
view that the doctrine of comity of courts
is a very healthy doctrine. If courts in
different jurisdictions do not respect the
orders passed by each other it will lead
to contradictory orders being passed in
different jurisdictions. No hard-and-fast
guidelines can be laid down in this
regard and each case has to be decided
on its own facts. We may, however,
again reiterate that the welfare of the
child will always remain the paramount
consideration.
11.
In light of the foregoing discussions, the
impugned judgment dated 06-05-2024 of the learned
single Judge of this Court as also the order dated 0103-2022 passed by the respondent no.3 are set aside.
12.
The respondent no.3 is directed to
consider the claims of the petitioner from July, 2017
to September, 2017, on the same terms as was
considered by the concerned authorities in the light of
the order of the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and
Ladakh dated 28-02-2023, rendered in Coromandel
International Ltd. (supra).
13.
7.
Writ appeal is disposed of accordingly.”
In view of the Judgment of the Division Bench of this
Court (supra) and considering that the challenge in the instant
Appeal
is
on
the
exact
same
issue,
as
already
extracted
hereinabove, the position of this Court is no more res integra
thereto.
No further discussion need ensue on this matter. The
Order dated 27-06-2022, of the Assistant Commissioner, Central
Goods and Service Tax, Gangtok Division, is consequently set
aside.
8.
Writ Petition accordingly stands disposed of in terms of
the decision of this Court in WA No.02 of 2024 (Glenmark
Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India and Others).
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
11-08-2025
ds/sdl
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review