Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No.304/2025
Reserved on: 14.09.2026
Pronounced on: 17.09.2026
Uploaded on: 17.09.2026
Operative part or full judgment: Full
Zubair Altaf Sheikh
(Through his wife Nafeeza Zubair)
S/O Mohammad Altaf Sheikh
R/O 90-Feet Soura,
District Srinagar.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. S.R.Hussain.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K
through Principal Secretary to Govt.
Home Department,
Civil Sectt. Srinagar.
2. District Magistrate,
Srinagar.
3. Superintendent Central Jail,
Jammu.
…Respondent(s)
Through: Sr.AAG Mohsin Qadri with
Assisting Counsel Haris Khan.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner, through his wife, has called in question the
detention
Order
12.09.2025
passed
No.DMS/PSA/40/2025
by
the
respondent
dated
No.2-District
Magistrate, Srinagar (hereinafter referred as ‘detaining
Page |2
authority’),
whereby
the
detenue
was
placed
under
preventive detention in exercise of the powers conferred
under the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978
(for short, "the Act"), with a view to prevent him from
acting in any manner prejudicial to the ‘security of the
State’.
2. The case set up by the petitioner is that the detention
order is vitiated on account of non-application of mind,
reliance upon stale and irrelevant material, non-supply of
material relied upon by the detaining authority, vagueness
of the grounds of detention and failure to afford the
detenue an effective opportunity to make a representation
against his detention; that a case vide FIR No. 15/2022
under Sections 13, 18, 23, 39 UA(P) Act and Sections 201
IPC, 7/25 I.A Act, at Police Station Bemina, had earlier
been registered against the detenue; that the detenue was
arrested in connection therewith and was subsequently
admitted to bail on 26.09.2022; that thereafter an order of
detention under the Public Safety Act came to be passed
against him on 30.09.2022; that the said order of
detention was challenged before this Court in WP(Crl) No.
707/2022 and was ultimately quashed by this Court vide
judgment dated 03.04.2024; that notwithstanding the
quashing of the earlier detention order the very same FIR
of the year 2022 has again been relied upon as one of the
grounds for passing the impugned detention order in the
Page |3
year 2025; that the incident forming the basis of the FIR
is, thus, almost three years old and has no proximate or
live link with the necessity of detaining the detenue in the
year 2025; that the detenue had been working as a Store
Manager
with
Blinkit
Commerce
Private
Limited,
Gurugram, NCR Delhi; that this specific assertion made on
behalf of the detenue has remained un-rebutted by the
respondents; that the allegation that the detenue was
indulging in activities prejudicial to the ‘security of the
State’ is rendered doubtful, particularly when the material
relied upon by the detaining authority does not disclose
any specific overt act attributable to him, during the
relevant period.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner, while reiterating the
grounds urged in the petition, has drawn the attention of
the
Court
21.05.2025,
to
the
Beat
04.06.2025
Books/Patrol
and
Books
04.08.2025,
dated
which,
according to the learned counsel, constitute material relied
upon by the authorities but were not supplied to the
detenue; that withholding such material has seriously
impaired the constitutional right of the detenue to make
an effective representation against his detention; that the
allegation that the detenue was an "OGW" or was involved
in motivating youth to join separatist groups is couched in
general and vague terms; that no particular incident, date,
place, person or specific activity has been disclosed so as
Page |4
to enable the detenue to understand the precise nature of
the allegations, so as to effectively controvert the same.
4. Learned Counsel appearing for the respondents, exadverso, has opposed the petition and submitted that the
impugned detention order is not founded merely upon the
FIR of the year 2022; that the earlier PSA order had been
quashed by this Court on 03.04.2024, whereas the
present detention order has been passed on the basis of a
fresh dossier containing more material and fresh inputs
received through discreet sources; that the dossier for the
present
detention
was
prepared
and
submitted
on
08.08.2025 and that the material collected, thereafter,
was considered by the competent authorities; that the
discreet information revealed the involvement of the
detenue in activities aimed at motivating youth to join
separatist groups and that such activities constitute a
serious threat to the security of the State; that the
reference to FIR No. 15/2022 was not intended to
constitute the sole basis of the present detention but was
incorporated in the grounds merely to place before the
detaining authority the antecedents of the detenue.
5. Heard and considered the rival submissions and perused
the detention record produced by the respondents.
6. Before examining the individual grounds of challenge, it
would be apposite to reiterate that preventive detention is
an extraordinary measure and is qualitatively different
Page |5
from punitive detention. The object of preventive detention
is not to punish a person for what he has done in the past,
but to prevent him from acting in a prejudicial manner in
future. The Supreme Court in Sama Aruna v. State of
Telangana,
(2018)
SCC
150,
emphasised
the
necessity of a live and proximate link between the past
conduct of the detenue and the imperative need for his
detention. The Court held that where the link between the
prejudicial activity and the necessity for detention has
snapped by passage of time, the detention order cannot be
sustained. This principle was reiterated and explained in
Khaja Bilal Ahmed v. State of Telangana, (2020) 13
SCC 632, wherein the Supreme Court held that the
satisfaction of the detaining authority must be based upon
relevant material which is not stale and has a live link with
the satisfaction recorded. The Court further held that
previous criminal activities may be relied upon only where
they have a direct nexus with the immediate need to detain
the individual; stale incidents, in the absence of a clear
causal connection, cannot furnish the basis for preventive
detention.
7. In the present case, it is not disputed that FIR No.
15/2022 relates to an incident of the year 2022. The
detenue was granted bail on 26.09.2022. The earlier
detention order dated 30.09.2022, founded upon the said
background,
on being challenged,
was subsequently
Page |6
quashed
by
this
Court
on
03.04.2024
in
WP(Crl)
No.707/2022. The impugned detention order in the
present case, however, has been passed in the year 2025
and the dossier is stated to have been submitted on
08.08.2025. Thus, an incident which formed the basis of
the earlier preventive detention in the year 2022 has again
been brought into the picture after a considerable lapse of
time.
8. It is true that merely because an earlier detention order
has
been
quashed,
the
detaining
authority
is
not
precluded from passing a subsequent detention order if
fresh material has subsequently come into existence and
such
material
independently
satisfies
the
statutory
requirements. However, the subsequent order must stand
on its own legs and must disclose a live and proximate
nexus between the alleged prejudicial activity and the
imperative necessity of detention. In Sushanta Kumar
Banik v. State of Tripura, (2022) 1 SCC 416, the
Supreme Court reiterated that the underlying principle in
cases of preventive detention is the existence of a "live and
proximate link" between the grounds of detention and the
confirmed purpose of detention. Unexplained delay can
snap such link and render the subjective satisfaction
vulnerable.
9. In the case on hand, the respondents seek to overcome the
staleness of FIR of 2022 by relying upon discreet
Page |7
information and other material allegedly gathered in 2025.
This Court has carefully examined whether the said fresh
material discloses any specific and proximate prejudicial
activity attributable to the detenue.
10.
The allegation that the detenue was an over ground
worker "OGW" of LeT/TRF banned outfits and had been
motivating youth to join separatist groups, however,
remains substantially general in character. The grounds of
detention do not disclose with sufficient specificity the
particular acts allegedly committed by the detenue, the
dates and places of such activities, the identity or
particulars of the persons allegedly motivated by him, or
any
other
continuing
concrete
circumstance
involvement
in
such
demonstrating
activities.
A
his
mere
description of a person by a particular label, without
particulars of the acts which constitute the alleged
prejudicial conduct, cannot by itself furnish an adequate
basis
for
preventive
detention.
The
constitutional
requirement is that the grounds must be sufficiently
specific
to
enable
the
detenue
to
understand
and
effectively meet the allegations.
11.
Another significant circumstance is that the detenue
was working as a Store Manager at Gurugram, Delhi. The
assertion that he was in Delhi in connection with his
employment has remained un-rebutted. Petitioner has
placed on record documents in support of his assertion of
Page |8
being in Gurugram NCR Delhi, having received wages for
the period regarding which discreet reports were made
foundational basis to pass impugned detention order.
While employment at another place cannot, by itself,
negate
allegations
of
prejudicial
activity,
it
was
nevertheless a relevant circumstance which required due
consideration by the detaining authority, while assessing
whether there existed a continuing and immediate threat
warranting preventive detention.
12.
the
The record also assumes significance in the context of
earlier
detention.
The
earlier
PSA
order
dated
30.09.2022 was quashed by this Court on 03.04.2024.
The said judicial development was a material circumstance
which necessarily required consideration while assessing
the present detention. The detaining authority could not
mechanically
revive
the
earlier
narrative
without
demonstrating how the subsequent material overcame the
effect of the passage of time and established a fresh and
continuing threat.
13.
Article 22(5) of the Constitution mandates that the
grounds on which the detention order has been made shall
be communicated to the detenue as soon as may be and
that he shall be afforded the earliest opportunity of making
a representation against the order. The right to make a
representation necessarily means a right to make an
effective representation. In M. Ahamedkutty v. Union of
Page |9
India, (1990) 2 SCC 1, the Supreme Court held that
where documents are referred to or relied upon in the
grounds of detention, the grounds are not complete
without such documents and failure to supply the same
can amount to denial of the constitutional right to make
an effective representation.
14.
In the present case, the petitioner has specifically
identified
the
Beat
Books/Patrol
Books
dated
21.05.2025, 04.06.2025 and 04.08.2025 as material
relied upon by the authorities but not supplied to the
detenue. If these documents formed part of the material
considered by the detaining authority in arriving at its
subjective satisfaction, the detenue was entitled to their
copies.
The
respondents
have
not
satisfactorily
demonstrated that the said documents were either not
relied upon or were duly supplied to the detenue.
15.
The distinction between a document merely referred
to and a document relied upon is well settled. The former
may not invariably require supply; the latter does. Where
the material has influenced the subjective satisfaction and
is necessary for the detenue to meet the allegations, nonsupply thereof strikes at the very root of the right
guaranteed by Article 22(5). The prejudice in the present
case is apparent. Without access to the Beat/Patrol Books,
the detenue could not have effectively verified the entries
allegedly relating to his movements or activities, nor could
P a g e | 10
he have controverted the manner in which the said
material was being used against him.
16.
This Court is unable to accept the submission of
learned counsel for the respondents that the earlier FIR
was merely referred to as an antecedent. An antecedent
can undoubtedly be referred to for a limited purpose, but
where the antecedent is relied upon as a circumstance
supporting the conclusion that the detenue continues to
pose a threat to the ‘security of the State’, it must have a
live and proximate nexus with the present necessity of
detention. The Supreme Court in Khaja Bilal Ahmed
(supra) has made it clear that previous criminal activities
may have relevance where they indicate a continuing
tendency or inclination to act prejudicially but in the
absence of a clear causal connection, stale incidents
cannot be relied upon to establish the probability of future
prejudicial activity.
17.
In the present case, the FIR of 2022, viewed against
the subsequent quashing of the earlier PSA detention
order, the passage of nearly three years, the unrebutted
assertion
regarding
the
detenue's
employment
at
Gurugram, and the absence of specific contemporaneous
acts attributable to him, cannot by itself furnish the
requisite live link.
18.
The respondents have also relied upon the Screening
Committee report. There can be no quarrel with the
P a g e | 11
proposition that the opinion of the Screening Committee
may constitute relevant material for consideration by the
competent authority. However, the mere fact that the
Screening Committee has recommended detention cannot
cure an otherwise infirm detention order. The ultimate
subjective satisfaction must itself be based upon relevant,
proximate and legally sustainable material. Similarly, the
fact that the present dossier contains more material than
the dossier considered at the time of the earlier detention
does not, by itself, answer the constitutional objection.
What matters is the quality, specificity and proximity of
the material and whether the detenue was supplied the
material necessary to make an effective representation.
19.
Preventive detention cannot become a substitute for
ordinary criminal law. Nor can the extraordinary power of
preventive detention be exercised merely because the
authorities entertain a general apprehension regarding a
person's antecedents. There must be material from which
a rational prognosis of future prejudicial conduct can be
made.
20.
In the present case, the material relied upon by the
respondents, when examined cumulatively, does not, in
the considered view, establish the requisite live and
proximate
link
between
the
past
conduct
and
the
imperative necessity of detaining the detenue in the year
2025. More importantly, the non-supply of the Beat/Patrol
P a g e | 12
Books, formed part of the relied-upon material, has
deprived the detenue of the opportunity to effectively
controvert the material relied upon against him. This
constitutes a substantive infraction of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India.
21.
This Court is not required to sit in appeal over the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority. Judicial
review in preventive detention matters is limited and the
Court does not substitute its own opinion for that of the
detaining authority. Nevertheless, where the satisfaction is
founded on stale or irrelevant material, where the live and
proximate link has snapped, or where the constitutional
safeguards have not been complied with, the detention
order cannot be permitted to withstand. The law is also
well settled that where an irrelevant or legally untenable
ground has materially contributed to the subjective
satisfaction, the Court cannot speculate as to whether the
detaining
authority
would
have
reached
the
same
conclusion had such ground not been considered. This
principle finds expression in the Constitution Bench
decision in Shibban Lal Saksena v. State of Uttar Pradesh,
AIR 1954 SC 179, and has been consistently followed in
preventive detention jurisprudence.
22.
In the facts of the present case, this Court is satisfied
that the impugned detention order suffers from the
following infirmities:-
P a g e | 13
(i)
reliance upon the stale antecedent of FIR No.
15/2022 without demonstrating a sufficient live
and proximate nexus with the necessity for
detention in 2025;
(ii)
failure to satisfactorily demonstrate specific and
contemporaneous prejudicial activities attributable
to the detenue;
(iii)
general
and
vague
allegations
regarding
the
detenue being an "OGW" and allegedly motivating
youth to join separatist groups;
(iv)
failure to satisfactorily deal with the material
circumstance that the detenue was working as a
Store Manager at Gurugram, Delhi, an assertion
which has remained un-rebutted;
(v)
failure to demonstrate due consideration of the fact
that
the
earlier
PSA
detention
order
dated
30.09.2022 had been quashed by this Court on
03.04.2024;
(vi)
non-supply of the Beat Books/Patrol Books dated
21.05.2025, 04.06.2025 and 04.08.2025, relied
upon for arriving at the subjective satisfaction,
thereby impairing the detenue's right to make an
effective representation under Article 22(5); and
(vii) the cumulative failure of the material to establish a
live and proximate link between the alleged past
P a g e | 14
conduct and the imperative necessity of preventive
detention.
23.
Consequently, the subjective satisfaction recorded by
the detaining authority cannot be sustained in law.
24.
For the foregoing reasons, the petition succeeds and
is allowed. The detention Order No. DMS/PSA/40/2025
dated 12.09.2025 passed by respondent No.2-District
Magistrate, Srinagar under the Jammu and Kashmir
Public Safety Act, 1978, directing detention of the detenue
herein, is hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to
release the detenue forthwith from preventive detention, if
his custody is not required in connection with any other
case(s).
25.
Scanned detention record, as produced by learned
counsel for the respondents, is directed to be returned to
him.
26.
The petition stands disposed of as indicated above.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Srinagar
17.09.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable: Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review