The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. Accordingly, the gradation lists, tentative or otherwise, prepared by the Social Welfare Department of the State in which any of the private respondents figure ahead of the writ petitioners are set aside and the relevant Department is directed to prepare a fresh gradation list wherein the writ petitioners will all figure ahead of the private respondents herein. In terms of seniority, the writ petitioners will always be regarded as senior in the post of CDPO than all the private respondents and the inter-seseniority, if at all relevant will be as follows: the first petitioner, the second petitioner, the fourth petitioner, the third petitioner, the fourth respondent, the fifth respondent and, finally, the sixth respondent.
21. To the extent, the notification of November 25, 2009 is found to be at variance with the rule that has been recognised and enunciated herein, such office memorandum of November 25, 2009 is set aside and the State is required to reconsider the matter and issue an appropriate notification in tune with the law as declared.
22. Accordingly, WP (C) No.394 of 2021 succeeds as indicated above. MC (WPC) No.129 of 2021 is disposed of.
23. The writ petitioners will be entitled to costs assessed at Rs.25,000/- to be paid by the respondent employer. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.394/2021 with
MC (WPC) No.129/2021
Date of order: 09.11.2022
Zanera R. Marak & ors
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioners
:
For the Respondents :
Mr. A.S. Siddiqui, Sr.Adv with
Mr. A.G. Momin, Adv
Mr. K. Khan, Sr.GA with
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl.Sr.GA
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv for R/4-6
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The writ petition complains of the private respondents being
placed ahead of the writ petitioners in the gradation list prepared by the
Social Welfare Department of the State where the writ petitioners and the
private respondents are employed.
2.
The impugned tentative gradation list of officers under the Social
Welfare Department has been prepared as on January 1, 2022 and is
found at pages 170 to 179 of the compilation filed by the petitioners. It is
pointed out by the private respondents that the challenge in the writ
petition is to the gradation list that was prepared on January 1, 2021.
However, since a subsequent tentative gradation list of officers has been
prepared by the relevant Department, it is the later gradation list which is
taken into account for the purpose of the present proceedings.
3.
The tentative gradation list of January 1, 2022 places the private
respondents Nos.4 and 5 above all the petitioners in the gradation list
pertaining to Grade-II officers. The private respondent No.6 has also been
placed above the two other writ petitioners. It is necessary to see the
relevant extract from the tentative gradation list:
“Sl.
No.
Name
Date of
Birth
Date of
Appointment
1.
Smti. Rica Bareh (respondent No.4)
26.2.1979
7.8.2008
2.
Shri Evershine Tariang (respondent
No.5)
15.10.1979
7.11.2008
3.
Smti. Zanera R. Marak (petitioner No.1)
30.11.1982
2.6.2008
4.
Smti. Madonna Onasis T. Sangma
(petitioner No.2)
15.2.1983
2.6.2008
5.
Smti. Olivia C. Nongbri (respondent
No.6)
14.8.1978
7.11.2008
6.
Shri Siddhartha S. Koch (petitioner
No.4)
28.3.1978
2.6.2008
7.
Smti. Norimchi A. Sangma (petitioner
No.3)
22.12.1980
2.6.2008”
4.
According to the State, the gradation list has been prepared in
terms of an office memorandum of November 25, 2009. A copy of such
office memorandum is appended to one of the affidavits filed by the State.
The essential part of the memorandum provides as follows:
“It is noted that appointment is normally made on the basis of the
recommendation of the M.P.S.C./D.S.C. On account of
application of the Reservation Policy, some candidates who are
lower in the merit list could have been appointed earlier than
those higher in the merit list. As such, if actual date of joining is
taken into consideration, the position may appear anomalous
since the inter se seniority has to be maintained as per the merit
list of the M.P.S.C./D.S.C. as per normal standing principles.
In order to avoid any anomalies in this matter, it has been decided
that in such cases, a notional date of appointment may be fixed
for such candidates who are appointed later than some other batch
mates who, though lower in the M.P.S.C./D.S.C. list, get
appointment earlier because of application of the Reservation
Policy. This notional date should be the date of joining of the last
appointed candidate from the merit list who has, however, been
appointed earlier because of application of the Reservation
Policy. This notional date would be taken into consideration
while determining the seniority in the amalgamated seniority
list.”
5.
Ordinarily, the rule is that when several appointees are issued
letters of appointment in course of the same exercise and at the end of the
same selection process, notwithstanding the dates of appointment which
may vary because of reasons of convenience or clerical issues, in the inter
se gradation list, the position of the appointees in order of merit has to be
maintained. The rule also recognises that if two candidates secure the
same marks and rank, the elder of the two is allotted the higher gradation
post between the two.
6.
Oftentimes, when a recruitment process is initiated, a list of
successful candidates is prepared and, after taking in candidates
corresponding to the number of vacancies, the remainder are kept on a
waiting list for a period say a year or so to fill up any casual vacancies
that may arise within such period. This exercise is undertaken so that the
time-consuming and expensive process of recruitment does not have to
be repeated each time if there is a casual vacancy which may arise all of
a sudden because of death, resignation or dismissal.
7.
It is the State’s avowed stand, inter alia, at paragraph 4 of its
affidavit affirmed on April 18, 2022 that as at September 14, 2007 there
were nine vacancies in the post of Child Development Project Officer. It
was in such circumstances that the State Public Service Commission was
requested to conduct the selection process and recommend appropriate
names. Such exercise was undertaken by the Meghalaya Public Service
Commission and, by a letter dated September 13, 2007, which appears at
page 11 of the same affidavit filed by the State, a list of 12 candidates in
order of merit was forwarded to the Social Welfare Department of the
State.
8.
Paragraph 4 of the State’s affidavit of April 18, 2022 goes on to
indicate how the calculations were made based on the reservation policy
of the State to consider the cases of the 12 persons who had figured in the
merit list forwarded by the MPSC. It must be kept in mind that at the
relevant point of time, there was no roster system put in place for
appointments to be made in accordance therewith. A completely
erroneous process had been adopted till earlier this year under which
every recruitment exercise was taken as a one-off process and the
allotment of candidates as per the reservation policy was confined to that
recruitment process itself. Pursuant to orders passed by this Court earlier
this year, such completely flawed process has now been abandoned and
the roster system has been adopted.
9.
However, what has to be seen is how the petitioners and the
private respondents were appointed and whether the appointments given
to all seven of them can be regarded as part of the same process.
10.
As per the details indicated at paragraph 4 of the said affidavit
filed by the State, upon applying the reservation policy, it was discovered
that one of the successful candidates from the general or unreserved
category could be appointed, whereas four posts were to go to the Khasi
and Jaintia category, three posts to the Garo category and one post to the
other scheduled castes and tribes category. The arithmetic was
completely flawed, but that is besides the point.
11.
What is undeniable is that as at September 14, 2007, nine
vacancies had arisen in the post of CDPO and the recruitment exercise
was conducted to fill up such nine posts. The four petitioners herein were
all appointed with five others on June 2, 2008 as would be evident from
a notification of such date which appears at page 102 of the petitioners’
compilation.
12.
The State’s affidavit of April 18, 2022 indicates how substantial
time was lost in obtaining police verification reports in respect of the nine
candidates who had been selected out of the merit list of the 12 published
by the State Public Service Commission. However, paragraph 6 of such
affidavit clearly states that the nine candidates were appointed under the
notification of July 2, 2008. With the appointment letters being issued,
the process of recruitment against the nine vacancies in the post of CDPO
was completed.
13.
Paragraph 7 of the State’s affidavit of April 18, 2022 goes on to
say that the fourth respondent herein was appointed to join a post that fell
vacant on or after July 8, 2008. Indeed, the letter of appointment issued
to the fourth respondent was on August 7, 2008. The fifth and sixth
respondents were appointed subsequently by a notification of November
7, 2008. There is no dispute pertaining to the dates of appointment.
14.
A minor point is raised by the petitioners to the effect that by the
time the fifth and sixth respondents were appointed, the validity of the
original list submitted by the State Public Service Commission had
expired and it was only after the expiry of the period of validity that the
State purported to validate the time so that other appointments from the
original list could be made. The perceived aberration on the part of the
State on such count does not appear to be any anomaly at all and there
does not appear to be any error in the private respondent Nos. 4, 5 and 6
having been appointed since their names figured in the original list of
September 13, 2007 as furnished by the State Public Service
Commission. Further, the validity of a waiting list can be extended to
even beyond a year as long as it does not appear to be arbitrary or
designed to cause prejudice to any person. In this case, the period of
validity may have been extended to beyond a year, but no further
recruitment process had been initiated in the interregnum.
15.
Thus, it is evident that the private respondents were not given any
appointment against the initial nine vacancies that arose in the year 2007
but they figured in the list of 12 candidates recommended by the State
Public Service Commission on September 13, 2007 and they were
appointed against casual vacancies which arose after the writ petitioners
and five others had already been appointed on June 2, 2008.
16.
There is no doubt that two of the private respondents secured
higher position in order of merit than all the writ petitioners herein and
the sixth respondent secured a position higher than the third and fourth
petitioners. In the usual course, if all the petitioners and the private
respondents had been appointed together as a part of the same exercise or
recruitment process, there is no doubt that the gradation list extracted
above would have held good. However, when it is the admitted position
that the writ petitioners herein were appointed earlier in point of time than
the private respondents and not against the vacancies that had arisen for
which the recruitment exercise was undertaken, the fact that some of the
private respondents fared better than some of the writ petitioners would
have no bearing in preparing the inter se gradation list.
17.
Indeed, no inter se gradation list involving the petitioners and the
private respondents was called for. An inter se gradation list is required
when several candidates are appointed to the same post in one process. If
candidates A and B are appointed earlier than candidates C and D and the
two sets of appointment do not cover the original vacancies for which the
selection process was conducted, A and B will always have to be regarded
as senior to C and D in the entry-level post.
18.
The cardinal principle in such regard is that seniors always stand
ahead in queue than juniors and it is only when several persons are
appointed on the same day or by the same exercise that an inter se
gradation list is called for. Ordinarily, the person in public employment
appointed earlier becomes senior to a person appointed later, irrespective
of age, merit or other considerations. The only scenario in which the inter
se gradation list is called for is when several appointments are made on
the same day or as a part of the same appointing or recruitment process.
19.
In this case, the appointment given to respondent No.4 was not a
part of the posts that felt vacant in 2007 for which the State Public Service
Commission was required to undertake the selection process. Similarly,
the appointments given to the respondent Nos.5 and 6 were against
vacancies that arose subsequent to the writ petitioners herein and five
others having been appointed. In such a situation, it did not matter that
the private respondents may have fared better than the writ petitioners in
the selection process that was conducted by the State Public Service
Commission. The matter is covered by the ordinary rule of seniority
going by the date of appointment.
20.
Accordingly, the gradation lists, tentative or otherwise, prepared
by the Social Welfare Department of the State in which any of the private
respondents figure ahead of the writ petitioners are set aside and the
relevant Department is directed to prepare a fresh gradation list wherein
the writ petitioners will all figure ahead of the private respondents herein.
In terms of seniority, the writ petitioners will always be regarded as senior
in the post of CDPO than all the private respondents and the inter-seseniority, if at all relevant will be as follows: the first petitioner, the
second petitioner, the fourth petitioner, the third petitioner, the fourth
respondent, the fifth respondent and, finally, the sixth respondent.
21.
To the extent, the notification of November 25, 2009 is found to
be at variance with the rule that has been recognised and enunciated
herein, such office memorandum of November 25, 2009 is set aside and
the State is required to reconsider the matter and issue an appropriate
notification in tune with the law as declared.
22.
Accordingly, WP (C) No.394 of 2021 succeeds as indicated
above. MC (WPC) No.129 of 2021 is disposed of.
23.
The writ petitioners will be entitled to costs assessed at
Rs.25,000/- to be paid by the respondent employer.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
09.11.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review