Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No.281 of 2017
Date or Hearing: 25.08.2026
Date of Decision: 10.09.2026
1. Meghalaya College Teachers Association,
(A Registered society representing the Teachers serving
in colleges receiving Grants-in-Aid from the Government
of Meghalaya) through its AMBERA, Lamavilla,
Lumdiengri Police Station, Dsitrict East Khasi Hills,
Shillong-793002.
2. Mr. Prashanta Sarkhel Joint Secretary, Meghalaya
College Teachers Association, Upper New Colony,
Laitumkhrah, East Khasi Hills District,
Shillong-793003.
…..Petitioners
-VERSUS1. The State of Meghalaya, represented by the
Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Education Department, Shillong Meghalaya.
2. The Director of Higher and Technical Education,
Meghalaya, Shillong, Meghalaya.
3. The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner II,
Sub Regional Office, North Eastern Region,
Laitumkhrah Police Point, Shillong-793003.
4. Governing Body of St. Anthony's College,
represented by its Secretary, St. Anthony's College,
Bomfyle Road, Shillong-793001.
5. Governing Body of St. Edmund's College,
represented by its Secretary, St. Edmund's College,
Laitumkhrah, Shillong-793003.
6. Governing Body of St. Mary's College represented
by its Secretary, St.Mary's College,
Laitumkhrah, Shillong-793003.
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
7. Governing Body of Shillong College,
Represented by its Secretary,
Shillong College, Boyce Road,
Laitumkhrah, Shillong-793003.
8. Governing Body of Shillong Commerce College,
represented by its Secretary, Shillong Commerce
College, Boyce Road, Laitumkhrah,
Shillong-793003.
9. Governing Body of College of Teacher Education
(PGT) Shillong, represented by its secretary,
College of Teacher Education (PGT),
Boyce Road, Laitumkhrah, Shillong-793003.
10.Governing Body of Synod College,
Represented by its Secretary, Synod College,
Jaiaw, Shillong-793002.
11.Governing Body of Seng Khasi College,
Represented by its Secretary, Seng Khasi
College, Jaiaw, Shillong-793002.
12.Governing Body of Sankardev College,
represented by its Secretary, Sankardev
College, Bishnupur, Shillong-793004.
13.Governing Body of Lady Keane College,
represented by its Secretary, Lady Keane
College, Shillong-793001.
14.Governing Body Union Christian College,
represented by its Secretary, Union Christian
College, Barapani, Umiam, Ri-Bhoi District,
Shillong-793122.
15.Governing Body of Ri-Bhoi College,
Represented by its Secretary,
Ri-Bhoi College, Nongpoh, Ri-Bhoi District,
Shillong-793102.
16.Governing Body of Nongstoin College,
Represented by its Secretary, Nongstoin College,
West Khasi Hills District, Nongstoin- 793119.
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
17.Governing Body of Don Bosco College,
Represented by its Secretary, Don Bosco College,
West Garo Hills District, Tura-794001.
18.Governing Body of Mendipathar College,
Represented by its Secretary, Mendipathar
College, Mendipathar-794112.
…..Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. K. Paul, Sr.Adv with
Ms. R. Dutta, Adv
Ms. K. Decruse, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Mr. J.N. Rynjah, GA (R:1-2)
Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, Adv (R:3)
Mr. D.M. Rani, Adv.vice
Mrs. P.D.B. Baruah, Sr.Adv (R:4-5)
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Per. B. Bhattacharjee, Judge:
1.
This writ petition was filed by the petitioners in the year 2017 seeking
implementation of the Meghalaya Non-Government School and College
Employees Centralised Provident Fund Act, 1969 (in short, the 1969 Act) in
respect of teachers of deficit grant-in-aid colleges in the State. A Division
Bench of this Court vide Judgment and Order dated 01.11.2018 disposed of
the writ petition by issuing certain directions to the respondent authorities.
The said Judgment and Order was challenged by the State-respondents in
Civil Appeal Nos. 5778-5779 of 2022 before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. By
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
Order dated 24.08.2022, the Hon’ble Supreme Court partially allowed the
appeals and remanded the matter back to this High Court for consideration of
the grievance of the petitioners with respect to non-implementation of the Act
of 1969. The petitioners were allowed to amend the writ petition and the
State-respondents were granted opportunity to file their counter. It was made
clear in the order that the remand should be only to consider the
implementation of the 1969 Act, and the Provident Fund Scheme framed
thereunder, if any, and the High Court on the basis of the pleading (even after
the amendment) to consider which part of the 1969 Act/Scheme framed
thereunder has not been complied with by the State and/or to what extent the
same are not complied with.
2.
After the remand, the writ petition was listed before this Court on
10.10.2022 when the petitioners were granted time to file amended writ
petition. On 21.10.2022 the amended writ petition came to be filed on behalf
of the petitioners. The State-respondents filed their affidavit-in-opposition in
response to the amended writ petition. Thereafter, several orders passed by
this Court reveal that there were efforts to resolve the dispute between the
parties. A Trust was created and a Draft Scheme was prepared by the State
and the same was handed over to the petitioners for their response/suggestion.
On 02.09.2025, taking notice of the fact that the Board of Trustees for the
Centralised Provident Fund Scheme of the State Government had been
reconstituted on 21.07.2025 and the new pension scheme covering employees
who joined prior to 01.04.2010 was more or less finalised, this Court directed
that the said scheme should be presented to the Board which should approve
the Pension Scheme together with its Portfolio Manager by 15.11.2025 and
notify the same by 20.11.2025.
3.
On 15.12.2025, this Court on the basis of the submissions made on
behalf of the petitioners and the state respondents, directed the State to
complete the finalisation of the Scheme and to notify the Pension Scheme
positively within four weeks. Again, by order dated 09.03.2026, it was
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
directed that the notification should be issued within ten days positively. On
19.03.2026 a notification dated 18.03.2026 was placed before the Court and a
submission was made by the learned Advocate General that the same was
issued in compliance with the orders of this Court. However, the learned
Senior counsel representing the petitioners prayed that he may be allowed to
put in objection on the ground that same was not in compliance with the
directions of this Court. Thereafter, an objection to the notification dated
18.03.2026 was filed on behalf of the petitioners on 02.04.2026. The state
respondents, on being allowed, filed their reply to the objection on
01.06.2026.
The matter, thereafter, proceeded for hearing and both the
petitioners and the State-respondents filed their respective written notes of
argument.
4.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel appearing for the petitioners,
submits that the Meghalaya Non-Government School and College Employees
Centralised Provident Fund Scheme, 2026 (in short 2026 Scheme) has not
been framed within the statutory frame work of the Act of 1969. He refers to
the orders dated 06.09.2023, 05.11.2024, 02.09.2025 and 15.12.2025 of this
Court and submits that instead of completing the exercise already undertaken
pursuant to the aforesaid orders, the State-respondents reconstituted the Board
of Trustees and introduced a completely different Scheme by the Notification
dated 18.03.2026. He submits that the 2026 Scheme departs from the 2023
Scheme and the framework which had been under consideration before this
Court. According to him, the 2026 Scheme proceeds upon an NPS-based
defined contribution structure bringing within its ambit the categories of
employees who had been treated separately during the entire course of the
proceedings which is impermissible. He submits that the State could not have
deviated from the Court-directed process and introduced an entirely different
Scheme. He contends that merger of two distinct categories of employees who
joined service prior to 01.04.2010 and those joined on or after 01.04.2010 by
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
adopting an NPS-based defined contribution framework under one common
Scheme is totally arbitrary and illegal.
5.
The
learned
Senior
counsel
further
contends
that
repeated
reconstitution of the Board of Trustees during subsistence of the tenure of the
first Board was aimed at unsettling the statutory process which was
proceeding in the right direction in tune with the Draft Scheme of 2023. He
submits that subsequent introduction of 2026 Scheme after appointment of
SBI Mutual Fund as Portfolio Manager on the basis of the Draft Scheme of
2023 amounts to a deviation from the Court-directed process and hence,
cannot be treated valid in the eye of law. The power to constitute the Board of
Trustees u/s 4 of the 1969 Act, he submits, cannot be construed as conferring
unfettered jurisdiction upon the State to repeatedly displace a subsisting
Board in order to restart the statutory process whenever the State sought to
alter the outcome. He submits that the distinction between two sets of
employees who joined before 01.04.2010 and on or after 01.04.2010 has
remained a consistent feature of the proceeding and was recognised in the
orders passed by this Court could not have been overlooked by the State while
formulating the 2026 Scheme. The Draft Scheme of 2023 having been
developed pursuant to the Court-supervised process, he submits, could not
have been replaced to render the earlier orders of the Court ineffective and
nugatory.
6.
The learned Senior counsel next contends that the 2026 Scheme
introduces a fundamentally different mechanism for accumulation, investment
and ultimate disbursement of retirement benefits in utter disregard to the
provision of the 1969 Act which provides for a Centralised Provident Fund
for employees and contemplates the administration of such fund through the
Board of Trustees. He submits that the State while exercising delegated power
u/s 4 of the 1969 Act, could not have altered the essential character of the
statutory framework by introducing NPS architecture in the 2026 Scheme in
place of the Centralised Provident Fund mandated by the parent Act.
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
According to the Senior counsel, the introduction of mechanism with regard
to record keeping, fund management and annuity related functioning in the
2026 Scheme is also in contravention of the statutory role of the Board of
Trustees and therefore, cannot be said to be in compliance with the provisions
of the 1969 Act. He, thus, submits that since the State-respondents have failed
to complete the process as per direction of this Court, the 2026 Scheme is
liable to be interfered by this Court.
7.
Mr. A. Kumar, learned Advocate General appearing for the State-
respondents submits that since this matter is taken up on remand by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, the scope of the present proceeding cannot be
converted into a fresh or enlarged adjudication. He submits that the scope of
the remand as per the order of the Apex Court has been expressly confined to
two questions, viz. (i) which provision of the 1969 Act or any Scheme framed
thereunder has not been complied with by the State and (ii) to what extent
such non-compliance subsists and amendment to the pleadings was permitted
within the confines of the remand, not for enlarging its scope. He submits that
the 1969 Act has been implemented by the State and the Scheme
contemplated thereunder has been framed. He submits that the Centralised
Provident Fund has been created and operationalised, the Board of Trustees
has been duly constituted and reconstituted in response to objections received
from stakeholders and Bye-Laws of the Board were approved and registered
on 26.04.2025 and hence, the original grievance of the petitioners has ceased
to exist. The limited terms of remand by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, he
submits, stands answered in view of the constitution of the Board, registration
of Bye-Laws, appointment of the Portfolio Manager and issuance of the
Notification dated 18.03.2026 of the 2026 Scheme by the State. He submits
that the jurisdiction of a court on remand is co-extensive with and
circumscribed by the terms of remand and that the court cannot travel beyond
the mandate expressly conferred upon it and supports his submission by
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
placing reliance on the decision of Shivshankara v. H.P.Vedavyasa Char,
2023 13 SCC 1.
8.
The learned AG further submits that the Draft Scheme of 2023 has no
statutory status or binding force as it was never notified under the 1969 Act
and the petitioners, as such, cannot claim any vested or accrued right by virtue
of the Draft Scheme. He submits that the Objection Affidavit dated
02.04.2026 does not contend that any part of the 1969 Act remains
unimplemented, nor identify any surviving issue arising within the scope of
the remand. He submits that nothing has been pointed out by the petitioners to
project any conflict between the 1969 Act and the 2026 Scheme. The Draft
Scheme of 2023, he argues, cannot constitute the benchmark for testing the
validity of the 2026 Scheme. The learned AG contends that the petitioners are
trying to enforce something which is not provided in the Act of 1969 and by
placing reliance on the judgment of B. Premanand v. Mohan Koikal, (2011) 4
SCC 266, submits that a requirement conspicuously absent from the statutory
text cannot be judicially introduced. He submits that the objection of the
petitioners to the composition of the Board, investment framework and other
issues are not supported by law and requires no consideration by this Court.
The learned AG also rebuts the claim of the petitioners with regard to the
Court-directed proceedings and submits that at no stage any direction was
issued requiring the State to secure the petitioners consent as a precondition
for finalising the Scheme.
9.
The learned AG argues that if the petitioners seek to challenge the 2026
Scheme, the same must be done by instituting appropriate proceeding.
According to him, a mere disagreement with the mechanism adapted in the
Scheme does not constitute non-implementation of the provisions of the
parent Act. He, therefore, submits that challenge to the 2026 Scheme cannot
be made by filing Objection Affidavit, nor the scope of the remand can stand
expanded by such affidavit. He refers to the decisions of Ajay Kumar Jain v.
State of U.P. 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3677, Mandar Deshpande, in re, 2020
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
SCC OnLine SC 758 and Sachin Kashyap v. Sushil Chandra Srivastava,
(2021) 19 SCC 758 and contends that a miscellaneous application founded
upon a fresh cause of action having only remote connection with the main
proceeding is not maintainable. Further, the writ petition having been filed for
a particular cause with a particular prayer cannot be expanded to cover within
its ambit all the issues which may be of general or public importance. He,
thus, submits that no surviving issue remains for adjudication in the present
proceeding and prays that the writ petition may accordingly be disposed of.
10.
Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No.3 has not made any submission as no relief has been claimed against the
said respondent. Similarly, no submission has been made by Mr. D.M. Rani,
learned counsel appearing vice Mrs. P.D.B. Baruah, learned Senior counsel
appearing for the respondent Nos. 4 & 5.
11.
Heard the arguments advanced on behalf of the rival parties and also
perused the materials on record.
12.
The reconsideration of the present writ petition by this Court has been
necessitated by the direction contained in the Order dated 24.08.2022 passed
in Civil Appeal Nos.5778-5779 of 2022 by which the Apex Court was pleased
to interfere with the earlier Judgment and Order dated 01.11.2018 of this
Court and the matter was remanded back for consideration of the issues
indicated in the order. The relevant paragraph of the Order dated 24.08.2022
reads as under: “12. The matters are remanded to the High Court to consider the
grievance on behalf of the original writ petitioners with respect to
non-implementation of the Meghalaya Act, 1969 and the Provident
Fund Scheme under the aforesaid Act, if any. To that extent, it will be
open for the original writ petitioners to amend the writ petitions to
which it will be open for the State to file the counter. However, it is
specifically made clear that the remand shall be only to consider the
implementation of the Meghalaya Act, 1969 and the Provident Fund
Scheme framed thereunder, if any, only and the High Court on the
basis of the pleadings (even after the amendment) to consider which
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
part of the Act 1969/scheme framed under the Meghalaya Act, 1969
has not been complied with by the State and/or to what extent the
same are not complied with. Only for the aforesaid purpose, the
matters are remanded to the High Court. The High Court to finally
decide and dispose of the writ petitions, on reman, within a period of
six months from the date of receipt of the present order.”
13.
Read in the above light, it is clear that the scope of the remand was
confined to the grievance of the petitioners with respect to nonimplementation of the 1969 Act and the Provident Fund Scheme under the
Act. To that extent, the petitioners were allowed to amend the writ petition
with liberty to the State to file counter. It was specifically made clear that the
remand shall only be for the purpose of consideration of the implementation
of the 1969 Act and the Provident Fund Scheme, if any, framed thereunder.
Further, the High Court was asked to consider on the basis of the pleadings
(even after the amendment) which part of the 1969 Act/Scheme framed under
the Act has not been complied with by the State and the extent of noncompliance thereof.
14.
In order to ascertain whether the 1969 Act was implemented or not and
whether the 2026 Scheme was framed under the Act, it would be appropriate
to look into the provision of Section 4 of the 1969 Act which is reproduced
below: “4. (1) The State Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, frame a scheme to be called “The Meghalaya NonGovernment School and College Employees Centralised Provident
Fund Scheme” to be administered by a “Board of Trustees” to be
constituted by the Government under the Scheme.
(2) A Scheme framed under the provisions of sub-section (1) may
provide for all or any of the matters specified in the Schedule.”
15.
Section 4 (1) of the 1969 Act empowers the State Government to frame
a Scheme to be administered by a Board of Trustees constituted by the
Government under the Scheme. The provision does not stipulate any mode or
manner in which the Scheme has to be framed. Section 4 (2) read with the
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
schedule to the 1969 Act empowers the State Government to determine the
modalities and the matters pertaining to the Scheme. The objection dated
02.04.2026 filed by the petitioners in the present case does not contend that
the 2026 Scheme has not been framed in exercise of the powers conferred
under the 1969 Act, nor there is any averment that the Scheme does not
operate within the contours of the Act. The nature of objection raised by the
petitioners with regard to the architecture, investment and operational
mechanism and other designed features of the 2026 Scheme does not establish
non-implementation of the 1969 Act and hence, travels beyond the scope of
the remand in terms of the Order dated 24.08.2022 of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
16.
In the case of Shivshankara (supra), at paragraph 13 the Apex Court
observed: “13. Before proceeding with the matter further, we think it
appropriate to consider the impact of such an order of remand as it
would certainly deconvolute consideration of this appeal. There can
be no doubt with respect to the settled position that the court to
which the case is remanded has to comply with the order of remand
and acting contrary to the order of remand is contrary to law. In
other words, an order of remand has to be followed in its true
spirit…”
From the above, it is obvious that normally a Court should not travel
beyond the specific terms and direction of a remand order issued by a superior
Court. Falling outside the defined scope of remand is ordinarily not
permissible except when there is a statutory compulsion or no decision can be
rendered by remaining within the confines of the scope of remand.
17.
With regard to the contention of the petitioners that the State has
deviated from the Court-directed process and introduced an entirely different
Scheme, we have perused the relevant orders of this Court including the
orders dated 06.09.2023, 05.11.2024, 02.09.2025 and 15.12.2025 referred by
the learned Senior counsel for the petitioners. We do not find any order or
2026:MLHC:1004-DB
direction of this Court regarding adaptation of any particular modality or
mechanism in respect of framing of the Provident Fund Scheme by the State
Government. The orders indicated above were passed from time to time on
the basis of the submissions made by the parties for ensuring progress towards
framing of an appropriate Scheme in accordance with law.
18.
For the reasons stated above, we are not inclined to entertain the
objection filed by the petitioners. The issuance of notification dated
18.03.2026 notifying the 2026 Scheme under the 1969 Act projects
substantial compliance of the terms of remand of the matter by the Apex
Court. Hence, there remains no further issue to be adjudicated in the present
writ petition.
19.
We make it clear that we have not gone into the merits of the objection
raised on behalf of the petitioners with regard to the architecture, investment
and operational mechanism and other designed features of the 2026 Scheme.
The petitioners shall have the liberty to challenge the Scheme by instituting
appropriate proceeding, if so advised.
20.
With the above, the writ petition stands disposed of.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
JUDGE
(H.S.Thangkhiew)
JUDGE
Meghalaya
10.09.2026
“Shrity,PS”
CH MOMIN
Date: 2026.09.10 16:04:53 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review