Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CM(M) No. 138/2024
CM No. 2509/2024
CM No.5544/2025
Reserved on: 11.09.2026
Pronounced on: 18.09.2026
Uploaded on: _______________
Operative part or full judgment - Full
Zahoor Ahmad Dar
S/O Ghulam Mohammad Dar,
R/O Munawara Abad, Srinagar
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. Irshad Ahmad with
Adv. Umaiya Zehra.
Vs.
1. Mymoona
W/O Shakeel Ahmad Dar
R/O Munawara Abad, Srinagar
2. Shahid Ahmad Dar
3. Suhail Ahmad Dar
4. Masrat Jan
S.No. 2 & 3, Sons/LRs of Shakeel Ahmad Dar
S.No.4, Daughter/LR of Shakeel Ahmad Dar
All residents of Munawara Abad, Srinagar.
…Respondent(s)
Through: Adv. A.M.Mir.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A.CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The instant petition under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India has been filed by the petitioner herein assailing
order dated 12.02.2024 passed by the learned 3rd
Page |2
Additional Munsiff, Srinagar in a civil original suit titled
Shakeel Ahmad Dar (dead) through legal heirs Vs. Zahoor
Ahmad
Dar,
whereby
the
application
filed
by
the
respondent as plaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 CPC
seeking amendment of the plaint, has been allowed.
2. Briefly stated, the case of the petitioner is that the
respondent/plaintiff instituted a suit for ejectment of the
petitioner
from
the
suit
shop
and
for
permanent
injunction; that the petitioner had taken the shop
measuring 8' x 17' situated at Munawarabad, Srinagar on
rent pursuant to a rent deed executed on 27.08.2011 and
registered on 04.10.2011; that the petitioner was put into
exclusive possession of the shop pursuant to the said rent
deed and acquired rights and interest in respect thereof;
that
during
the
respondents/plaintiff
pendency
of
filed
application
an
the
suit,
the
seeking
amendment of the plaint; that the amendment, inter alia,
sought incorporation of the relief of monthly mesne profits
at
the
rate
of
Rs.50,000/-,
besides
consequential
amendments in various paragraphs of the plaint, the
valuation clause and the prayer clause.
3. The
said
application
was
opposed
by
the
petitioner/defendant on the ground that the written
statement had already been filed; that the plaintiff was
seeking to introduce a new case by way of amendment;
that the application was intended to delay the proceedings;
Page |3
that the plaintiff was not entitled to seek eviction in view of
the defense set up by the petitioner as defendant in the
written statement.
4. The learned Trial Court, after considering the rival
submissions, allowed the application. The Trial Court
noticed that the application for amendment had been filed
when the trial had not commenced; that the proviso to
Order VI Rule 17 CPC was, therefore, not attracted; and
that
the
proposed
amendment
was
necessary
for
determining the real questions in controversy between the
parties.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner herein, while assailing
the impugned order, reiterated the grounds taken in the
petition and would argue that the amendment sought by
the plaintiff-respondent was not a mere formal amendment
but sought to materially enlarge the scope of the suit. It
was argued that the plaintiff, having instituted the suit
and having allowed the proceedings to progress, could not
subsequently introduce a claim which was otherwise
available to him from the very inception. Learned counsel
would further argue that the proposed amendment would
cause prejudice to the petitioner and that the learned Trial
Court had failed to properly appreciate the objections
raised by the petitioner.
6. Learned Counsel appearing for the respondents, exadverso, opposed the petition and supported the impugned
Page |4
order. Learned counsel would submit that the petitioner
had not approached this Court with clean hands and had
attempted to mislead the Court by suppressing and
misrepresenting material facts. It was submitted that the
factual aspects of the suit, the pleadings and the
documents relied upon by the parties were before the
learned Trial Court and had been duly considered; that no
ground,
whatsoever,
is
made
out
for
invoking
the
supervisory jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India.
7. It was specifically submitted that the trial of the suit had
not commenced, as the issues were yet to be framed, and
consequently the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC had no
application; that the learned Trial Court had rightly
proceeded to examine whether the proposed amendment
was necessary for determining the real questions in
controversy between the parties. Furthermore, the learned
Trial Court had exercised the jurisdiction vested in it
under Order VI Rule 17 CPC after hearing both sides and
recording reasons for allowing the amendment.
8. Learned Counsel for the respondents further argued that
the proposed amendment does not alter the basic nature
or character of the suit. The suit continues to be one for
ejectment of the petitioner from the suit premises and for
consequential reliefs. It was pointed out that the plaintiff
had already referred in the plaint to the notices issued to
Page |5
the petitioner and to the demand of mesne profits, but had
inadvertently not incorporated an express prayer in that
regard. The proposed amendment, therefore, according to
learned counsel, merely seeks to bring the consequential
relief in conformity with the factual pleadings already
forming part of the suit. Learned counsel also submitted
that no prejudice would be caused to the petitioner by
allowing
the
amendment,
as
he
would
have
full
opportunity to file an amended written statement and
contest the claim on merits.
9. The question as to whether the plaintiff is actually entitled
to mesne profits, the rate thereof and the period for which
such profits may be claimed, according to learned counsel,
are matters to be determined by the Trial Court on the
basis of evidence and cannot be adjudicated at the stage of
considering the amendment application. It was further
contended that the petitioner himself has taken a stand
with regard to expiry of the period stipulated under the
rent deed and, therefore, the question whether the
petitioner is entitled to continue in possession is itself a
matter which has to be adjudicated upon in the suit.
Learned counsel submitted that such disputed questions
cannot be made the basis for refusing an otherwise
permissible amendment.
10. Lastly, learned counsel for the respondents contended
that
the
impugned
order
neither
suffers
from
any
Page |6
jurisdictional error, nor perversity or patent illegality,
warranting
interference
under
Article
of
the
Constitution. This Court, in exercise of supervisory
jurisdiction, cannot substitute its own view for that of the
Trial Court merely because another view may also be
possible. Dismissal of the petition was accordingly prayed
for.
11.Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the material
available on record and considered the matter.
12. The controversy which falls for consideration is whether
the learned Trial Court was justified in allowing the
application for amendment of the plaint under Order VI
Rule 17 CPC.
13. Order VI Rule 17 CPC confers power upon the Court to
allow either party to alter or amend his/her pleadings at
any stage of the proceedings, in such manner and on such
terms as may be just, and all such amendments are
required to be allowed as may be necessary for the purpose
of determining the real questions in controversy between
the parties. The proviso places a restriction on allowing an
amendment after commencement of trial unless the Court
is satisfied that, despite due diligence, the party could not
have raised the matter before commencement of trial. In
the present case, the learned Trial Court has recorded a
categorical finding that the trial had not commenced. The
record, as noticed by the Trial Court, showed that the
Page |7
matter was still at the stage preceding commencement of
trial as the issues had not been framed. In such
circumstances, the embargo contained in the proviso to
Order VI Rule 17 CPC would not come into play.
14. The next question is whether the proposed amendment is
necessary for determining the real controversy between the
parties. A perusal of the pleadings, as noticed by the
learned Trial Court, shows that the main dispute between
the parties relates to the petitioner's occupation of the suit
shop
unauthorizedly,
after
expiry
of
the
period
of
lease/rent deed and the respondent/plaintiff's claim for
recovery of possession thereof. The plaintiff had already
referred to the notices issued to the petitioner and had
asserted his entitlement to claim mesne profits on account
of the alleged continued occupation of the premises. The
proposed incorporation of the relief of mesne profits,
therefore, cannot at this stage be said to introduce an
altogether new and foreign ‘cause of action’. The relief
sought, by way of amendment, arises out of the same
transaction and the same subject matter which already
forms the basis of the suit.
15. Equally, the merits of the claim for mesne profits cannot
be examined while deciding an application under Order VI
Rule 17 CPC. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to mesne
profits, whether the claimed rate of Rs.50,000/- per month
is justified, and the period for which such relief can legally
Page |8
be granted are all questions which would remain open for
adjudication by the learned Trial Court in accordance with
law.
16. The objection regarding prejudice to the petitioner also
does not appear to have any substance. The petitioner
would have an opportunity to file an amended written
statement and contest the amended pleadings. Any
defense available to him in law would remain open. The
amendment, therefore, does not appear to cause such
prejudice as cannot be compensated or addressed by
granting appropriate opportunity to the petitioner.
17. It is also relevant that the power under Article 227 of the
Constitution is supervisory in nature. The High Court does
not ordinarily interfere with an interlocutory order merely
because it may take a different view from the one taken by
the subordinate Court. Interference is warranted where the
subordinate Court has acted without jurisdiction, failed to
exercise jurisdiction vested in it, or has acted in a manner
resulting in manifest illegality or perversity.
18. It is an admitted case that issues were yet to be framed in
the case, when the respondent as plaintiff moved the Trial
court seeking permission to amend his suit. Plaintiff being
‘dominus litis’ has control over his claims and choice of
parties, however, the right to amend the plaint, not being
an absolute right remains subject to judicial discretion
under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC. Continuous cause of
Page |9
action allows amendment of plaint, without fresh suit. It
would be profitable to extract the governing provisions of
Order VI Rule 17 of CPC, for the sake of understanding,
as under:“The Court may at any stage of the
proceedings allow either party to alter or
amend his pleadings in such manner and
on such terms as may be just, and all
such amendments shall be made as may
be
necessary
for
the
purpose
of
determining
the
real
questions
in
controversy between the parties :
Provided
that
no
application
for
amendment shall be allowed after the
trial has commenced, unless the Court
comes to the conclusion that inspite of
due diligence, the party could not have
raised
the
matter
before
the
commencement of trial.”
19. The Apex Court in Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal Vs. K.K.Modi
reported as (2006) 4 SCC 385, observed that this Rule 17
of Order VI of CPC declares that the court may, at any
stage of the proceedings, allow either party to alter or
amend his pleadings in such a manner and on such terms
as may be just. It also states that such amendments
should be necessary for the purpose of determining the
real question in controversy between the parties. The
provision enacts that no application for amendment
should be allowed, after the trial has commenced, unless
the court comes to the conclusion that inspite of due
diligence the party could not have raised the matter, for
which amendment is sought before the commencement of
the trial.
P a g e | 10
20. As already noticed hereinabove, the trial of the suit
between the parties had not commenced, as issues were
yet to be settled in the case, therefore, it was the stage
where
amendment
could
be
allowed.
Moreover,
the
petitioner as defendant has not been able to point out that
with the amendment having been allowed, in the plaint,
the nature of the suit shall not be changed, so as to
prejudice the rights of the defendant (petitioner herein).
21. In the present case, the learned Trial Court has
considered the application, the objections filed by the
petitioner and discussing the provisions of Order VI Rule
17 CPC, recorded reasons for allowing the amendment.
The view taken by the learned Trial Court cannot be said
to be one which is either without jurisdiction, perverse or
illegal.
22. For the foregoing reasons, this Court finds no ground to
warrant any interference in exercise its supervisory
jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
The impugned order dated 12.02.2024 passed by the
learned 3rd Additional Munsiff, Srinagar, in the aforestated
backdrop, does not suffer from any jurisdictional error,
perversity or patent illegality warranting interference.
23. Accordingly, the instant petition along-with pending
application(s)
is
dismissed
and
the
order
dated
P a g e | 11
12.02.2024 is upheld. Interim direction dated 03.05.2024
shall also stand vacated.
24. It is, however, made clear that the observations made
herein are confined strictly to the question of amendment.
Nothing contained in this order shall be construed as an
expression of opinion on the merits of the respective claims
and defenses of the parties. The petitioner shall be at
liberty to file an amended written statement, if so required,
and all questions relating to the plaintiff's entitlement to
ejectment, mesne profits, the rate and period thereof, and
all other issues arising between the parties shall be
decided by the learned Trial Court independently and in
accordance with law.
25. The learned Trial Court shall proceed with the suit
expeditiously.
26. A copy of this order shall be forwarded to the Trial court,
for information.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Srinagar
18.09.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review