Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
Reserved on: 09.02.2026
Pronounced on : 13.02.2026
Uploaded on : 13.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Younis Ali
….Petitioners
Through:-
Mr. P.N. Bhat, Advocate.
V/s
UOI & Ors
…..Respondents
Through:-
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Sumant Sudan, Advocate.
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present
petition, has sought a direction upon respondents No. 2 to 5 to
conduct fresh review medical examination of the petitioner
from
an
independent
Medical
Board
of
Ophthalmology
Department of Government Medical College Hospital, Jammu
or any other Board.
02.
The brief facts of the case are that an advertisement
notification came to be issued by respondent No. 6 (Staff
Selection Commission) on 24.11.2023, inviting applications for
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
recruitment of Constable (GD) in Central Armed Police Forces
(CAPFs), SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles.
03.
Pursuant
to
the
aforesaid
advertisement
notification, the petitioner submitted his application for being
considered for appointment to the advertised posts. He was
assigned Roll No. 1004023773 and was asked to appear for the
examination on 28.10.2024. The petitioner is stated to have
passed PTS and PET and he is also stated to have undergone
the process of document verification successfully.
04.
On
29.10.2024,
detailed
medical
examination
(DME) of the petitioner was conducted but he was found
suffering from Myopia, Squint and Knock Knee and as such
declared unfit for the post.
opportunity
to
undergo
Accordingly,
the
petitioner
He was, however, given an
review
medical
underwent
examination.
review
medical
examination on 05.11.2024 and this time, he was cleared of
Myopia and Knock Knee but was found to be suffering from
presence of Squint in his right eye and was found unfit. The
petitioner
got
himself
examined
by
the
Ophthalmology
Department of Government Medical College Hospital, Jammu
where the doctor, after examining him, found that there is no
evidence of Squint in his right eye.
05.
The petitioner has challenged the impugned action
of the respondents in rejecting his candidature on the grounds
that he does not suffer from the disability, which has been
pointed out by the Review Medical Board and this fact has
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
been
certified
by
the
Ophthalmology
Department
Government Medical College Hospital, Jammu.
of
It has been
contended that the action of the respondents is patently illegal
and arbitrary.
Therefore, the Review Medical Examination
report dated 05.11.2024 deserves to be quashed. According to
the petitioner, he has been casually examined by the doctors
at the time of his first medical examination and also at the
time of review medical examination.
Therefore, the said
reports cannot be relied upon.
06.
The respondents, in their reply, have admitted the
factual aspects of the case so far as they relate to reasons for
rejection of the petitioner are concerned.
It has been
submitted that there is no provision of third medical
examination
as
per
the
existing
medical
policy.
The
respondents have relied upon the directions issued by MHA
vide U.O No. I-45023/10/2005-Pers-II dated 24.08.2005
which provides that no appeal against the decision of the
Review Medical Board can be entertained.
It has been
submitted that as per the provisions contained in the
advertisement notification, the petitioner cannot be appointed
as Constable (GD) in the Central Armed Police Force because
he has been declared as medically unfit.
07.
The respondents have submitted that because
fitness of a soldier is the paramount requirement in a force, as
such, the petitioner cannot claim selection after having been
declared as unfit.
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
It has been further submitted that the
petitioner has been examined by the specialist and experienced
doctors, who are fully conversant with the requirements of the
organization, therefore, their opinion cannot be discarded.
08.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
09.
The main ground on which the petitioner is seeking
direction for constitution of a fresh medical board for fresh
examination of the petitioner is that the petitioner was
examined by the specialists in Ophthalmology Department of
Government Medical College Hospital, Jammu and they have
declared that he does not suffer from Squint in his right eye. A
copy of the Out Patient Card to support this assertion has
been placed on record by the petitioner.
10.
The question that arises for determination is as to
whether on the basis of the opinion recorded by the doctor on
the Out Patient Card issued by Govt. Medical College Hospital,
Jammu (Ophthalmology Department), the opinion rendered by
the Review Medical Board can be discarded or doubted.
11.
While
analyzing
the
legal
position
on
the
aforesaid issue, Allahabad High Court in the case of Vivek
Kumar Vs. State of U.P, 2020 ADJ Online 0073 has held
that subsequent medical examination reports submitted by a
candidate cannot override or set at naught the opinion of the
medical board. Para Nos. 7, 8, 11 and 12 of the said judgment
are relevant to the context and the same are reproduced as
under:
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
“7. The scope of interference in matters relating to
assessment of fitness by a Medical Board constituted
under the statutory rules in exercise of powers under
writ jurisdiction, in our opinion, would be extremely
limited.
8. The Courts have, time and again, emphasized the
need for caution when candidates seek to assail the
correctness of the findings of a Medical Board
constituted under a recruitment process adopted by
the State authorities, on the basis of some medical
report obtained by them.
11. In a case where a recruitment process has been
carried out as per prescribed statutory rules where
under a procedure has been prescribed for testing the
medical fitness of candidates by a duly constituted
Medical Board, the report of the Medical Board is not
to be normally interfered with, and that too, solely on
the basis of a claim sought to be set up by a
candidate on the basis of some subsequent report(s)
procured by him from a private practitioner(s).
12. It is not the case of the petitioner that the
decision of the Medical Board was arbitrary,
capricious or not in accordance with the procedure
under the relevant statutory recruitment rules.”
12.
Again in the case of Diwakar Paswan Vs. State of
U.P, 2021 (0) Supreme (All) 47, Allahabad High Court has
held that opinion of the medical board and experts should not
be lightly interfered with unless it is shown to be contrary to
the standards prescribed or smacks of malafides. Paragraphs
8 and 9 of the said judgment are relevant to the context and
same are extracted hereinbelow:
“8. It becomes pertinent to note that the opinions
formed by the Medical and Review Boards have not
been assailed by the petitioner on the ground of mala
fides. A review of those decisions is sought solely on
the basis of a contrary opinion rendered by a doctor
of a government hospital. Permitting a reopening of a
medical examination conducted by the respondents
solely on that basis would set a dangerous precedent
especially when the Court by virtue of its inherent
limitations would be wholly unequipped to undertake
a comparative analysis or evaluation of competing
medical opinions. Medical fitness is a subject best
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
left for determination by experts and should not be
lightly interfered with unless it be shown to be
contrary to the standards prescribed or otherwise be
liable to be assailed on other judicially manageable
parameters.
9. Quite apart from the consistent view taken by
Courts on this question regard must also be had to
the fact that the medical examination in the present
case was undertaken in accordance with the
provisions made in the statutory rules. Those Rules
confer finality upon the opinions formed by the
Medical Boards subject to an appeal against the same
before a Review Medical Board. Those Rules do not
envisage or contemplate a challenge to those reports
based upon reports and opinions privately obtained
by candidates. Permitting such a course of action
would not only be contrary to the Rules which apply
and bind the candidate but also result in derailing
the recruitment process itself.”
13.
From the foregoing analysis of legal position on the
subject, it comes to the fore that generally the Review Medical
Board’s decision in CAPFs selection process is final and cannot
be subjected to further review or re-examination by the courts
except in exceptional circumstances such as procedural
violations or malafides. In fact, the Ministry of Home Affairs
vide its memo dated 24.08.2005 has reiterated that there shall
be no appeal against the decision of the Review Medical Board.
Thus, the opinion of the Medical Board once formed in
accordance with the prescribed procedure is conclusive and as
such cannot be lightly interfered with. The legal frame work
for medical examination in CAPFs recruitment clearly provides
that medical board’s assessment is final and no appeal can be
entertained
against
the
finding
of
the
second
medical
examination.
14.
In the face of the aforesaid legal position, there is
hardly any ground for setting aside the opinion rendered by
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
the Review Medical Board vide its report dated 05.11.2024.
Merely on the basis of opinion recorded by Registrar,
Department of Ophthalmology, Government Medical College
Hospital, Jammu on the Out Patient Card indicating that the
petitioner does not suffer from Squint in his eye is not
sufficient material to discard the opinion of the Review Medical
Board which constitutes three specialist doctors.
15.
The petitioner has not pleaded any procedural
irregularities or any malafides on the part of the respondents
while conducting his medical examination or the review
medical examination. In the absence of any such assertion or
any cogent material on record that would throw doubt upon
the report of the Review Medical Board, there is hardly any
scope for this Court to undertake a judicial review of the
findings of the Review Medical Board.
16.
For the foregoing reasons, I do not find any merit in
this petition. The same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
13.02.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
Naresh Kumar
2026.01.29 03:47
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
WP(C) No. 2820/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review