The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. Consequently, it is the view of this Court that a case has been make out by the petitioner warranting the interference of this Court and therefore, the impugned order dated
05. 08.2024 passed by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Aalo in Execution Case No. 06/2023 is quashed and set aside. Petition is allowed. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC040011592024
2026:GAU-AP:46
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP/34/2024
Yomto Jini
Son of Late Rayom Jini, resident of Paktu, PO and PS Aalo, West Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
Smti Dongam Jini
Wife of Late Rayom Jini, resident of Old Market, Aalo, PO and PS Aalo, West Siang
District, Arunachal Pradesh.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Duge Soki, Topi Jini
Advocate for the Respondent : Marto Kato, Nyali Sora,Mepe Ete
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
ORDER
20/01/2026
The present petition has been filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India praying for setting aside the impugned order dated 05.08.2024 passed by
the Additional Deputy Commissioner, West Siang District, Aalo, Arunachal
Pradesh in Execution case No. 06/2023.
Page No.# 2/8
2. Heard learned counsel Mr. D. Soki for the petitioner and learned counsel Mr.
M. Ete for the respondent.
3. The case of the petitioner is that there was a Keba between the petitioner
and the respondent on 16.07.2023 to settle the dispute regarding a commercial
building at Aalo. The Keba decision on 16.07.2023 settled the dispute by making
a partition of the building between the petitioner and the respondent.
Thereafter, the respondent filed a Letter of Administration case before the
District Judge Aalo. In the meantime, since, the respondent was not allowing
the petitioner to collect the rent from his portion of building, the petitioner again
lodged a complaint before the Keba and accordingly a parwana was issued for
holding a Keba. In this connection the respondent filed an application before the
District Judge, Aalo praying for stay of the parwana and procured an ex-parte
order staying the conduct of the Keba.
4. At this juncture, the petitioner preferred Civil Revision Petition No. 61/2023
before this Court. After hearing the parties, this Court disposed of the CRP No.
61/2023 by setting aside the ex-parte order passed by the District Judge, Aalo,
vide order Dated 29.04.2024.
5. This Court, by order dated 29.04.2024, also held that the Keba decision
dated 16.07.2023 had attained finality and therefore, cannot be re-opened and
that the Keba order dated 16.07.2023 is required to be carried out in full spirit.
6. It is also the case of the petitioner that during the pendency of the CRP No.
61/2023 before this Court an order dated 31.01.2024 had been passed by the
Assistant Commissioner, Aalo for compliance of the Keba order dated 16.07.2023
Page No.# 3/8
in an execution petition filed by the petitioner.
7. After the disposal of the Civil Revision Petition No. 61/2023, a subsequent
Keba was held on 29.06.2024 wherein the earlier decision of the Keba dated
16.07.2023 was reiterated.
8. The petitioner further submits that the respondent also preferred a Civil
Revision Petition before this Court numbered as CRP No. 21/2024 challenging
the Keba decision dated 16.07.2023 and the execution order dated 31.01.2024
with an interim prayer for staying both the orders. However, this Court declined
to grant any interim relief in CRP No. 21/2024. After the interim prayer for stay
was declined by this Court, the respondent approached the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Aalo for recall of the execution order dated 31.01.2024.
Thereafter the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Aalo recalled the execution
order dated 31.01.2024 by the impugned order dated 05.08.2024.
9. Being aggrieved by the order dated 05.08.2024, passed by the Additional
Deputy Commissioner, Aalo the petitioner has approached this Court primarily
on the ground that the Keba decision of 16.07.2023 has attained finality and
there is no appeal against the order of the Keba dated 16.07.2023. The learned
counsel for the petitioner further submits that the respondents have also been
preferred any appeal against the order dated 29.04.2024 passed in CRP No.
61/2023 by which a Coordinate Bench of this Court had held that the Keba
decision on 16.07.2023 has attained finality, cannot be re-opened and is
required to be carried out in full spirit. And hence the executing court could not
have recalled the execution order dated 31.01.2024.
Page No.# 4/8
10. It is further submitted that the Civil Revision Pettion filed by the respondent
against the Keba decision dated 16.07.2023 and the execution order dated
31.01.2024 has already been withdrawn by the respondent on 17.09.2024.
Further the Letter of Administration Case No. 06/2023 which was pending
before the District Judge, Aalo has also been dismissed on 07.08.2024 basing on
the order passed by this Court in CRP No. 61/2023.
11. It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
respondent did not approach the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Aalo with
clean hands, as the full facts of the case were not disclosed.
12. The learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. D. Soki has also submitted that
the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Aalo has dealt with the matter in a very
mechanical manner and has treated the recall petition like a review petition and
has recalled the order dated 31.01.2024 on the premise that the case is
subjudice before other courts and forums, whereas the actual fact was that this
Court in CRP No. 61/2023 had already held that the Keba decision on
16.07.2023 had attained finality and there was no interim order in favor of the
respondent before any court of forum.
13. Another contention of the petitioner is that the Additional Deputy
Commissioner being the executing court had no power to review its own order,
it is submitted that in the absence of any statutory provisions the executing
court could not have reviewed or recalled its own order as the power to review
is not an inherent power. The power must be conferred by law and in the
absence of any provision in the relevant act/ rules, review of an earlier order is
impermissible as review is a creation of statute. In support of this contention
Page No.# 5/8
the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on the case of KALABHARATI
ADVERTISING
Versus
HEMANT
VIMALNATH
NARICHANIA
AND
OTHERS reported in (2010) 9 SCC 437.
14. In view of the submission made herein above, the learned counsel for the
petitioner prays that the impugned order dated 05.08.2024 passed by the
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Aalo is Execution Case No. 06/2023 may be
quashed and set aside.
15. The learned counsel for the respondent, Mr. M. Ete at the outset submits
that the observations of this Court in order dated 29.04.2024 passed in CRP No.
61/2023 is not a ratio decidendi but merely an obiter dicta. Learned counsel
submits that this Court had only made an observation that the Keba decision
16.07.2023 had not been assailed by the respondent and that it has attained
finality, however, this cannot be a binding decision. Another contention of the
learned counsel for the respondent is that the second Keba decision dated
29.06.2024 has superseded the first Keba decision on 16.07.2023 and therefore,
all the proceedings which are filed after the first Keba is now infructuous and
the present petition which has been filed subsequent to the second Keba is also
not maintainable.
16. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that the first Keba dated
16.07.2023 was actually a family meeting and not a proper Keba decision as it
was held in the house of the respondent and not at the proper venue where the
Keba is to be held, the members present in the keba were also all family
members and therefore the decision dated 16.07.2023 cannot be held to be a
Keba decision.
Page No.# 6/8
17. Another contention of the learned counsel for the respondent is that she
had filed a petition for recall of the execution order dated 31.01.2024 and not
for a review and that the execution order could have been recalled by the
executing court under the inherent power conferred by Section 151 of the Civil
Procedure Court. Therefore, the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Aalo was
within his powers to recall the executing order dated 31.01.2024.
In view of the submission made, the learned counsel submits that the
petitioner has not been able to make out a case for the interference of this
Court in the present petition.
18. This Court has given due consideration to the submission of the learned
counsel for the parties and has perused the records available before the court.
19. It is an admitted fact that no appeal has been preferred against the order
dated 29.04.2024 passed in CRP No. 61/2023. In CRP No. 61/2023, this Court
had considered the matter in its entirety and had dealt with the legality of the
first Keba which was held on 16.07.2023 between the petitioner and the
respondent exhaustively. This Court after hearing the parties came to a finding
that the Keba decision dated 16.07.2023 has not been appealed against during
the stipulated period and has therefore attained finality and cannot be
reopened. This Court also held that the dispute between the respondent and the
petitioner had been settled by the Keba proceedings dated 16.07.2023 and the
same is required to be carried out in full spirit. Such a finding cannot be held to
be an obiter dicta.
20. The recall petition filed by the respondent before the Additional Deputy
Page No.# 7/8
Commissioner, Aalo was preferred after the disposal of CRP No. 61/2023.
However, in the impugned order dated 05.08.2024 it is seen that no reference
at all has been made to the decision of this Court passed in CRP No. 61/2023.
The learned executing court has failed to consider that there were no interim
orders in favor of the respondent before any court or forum. It is also seen that
the executing court had taken up the matter of recall as a review application
and the same is barred by law as the executing court has no inherent power to
review it’s own order unless the same is necessitated by exceptional situations.
The recall application of the respondent is disguised as a review application. The
Execution Court lacks power to recall its own order except when it is a case of
nullity, fraud or want of jurisdiction.
21. Be that as it may the executing order dated 31.01.2024 does not reflect
any coercive action against the respondent. The executing court had merely
directed the respondent to comply with the Keba decision of 16.07.2023. During
the course of hearing it has been submitted by the learned counsel for the
parties that the petitioners as well as the respondent are realising the rent from
the building concerned as directed by the Keba decision of 16.07.2023 as on
date. It is also an admitted fact that the respondent herein has subsequently
filed a Civil Appeal No. 23/2024 in the court of the Civil Judge, Senior Division
West Siang District, Aalo challenging the Keba decision of 29.06.2024 whether
the petitioner herein has also been impleaded as respondent and the matter is
pending adjudication.
22. This Court is therefore of the view that the executing court/ Additional
Deputy Commissioner, Aalo could not have recalled/reviewed its own order,
primarily due to the fact that the executing court does not possess inherent
Page No.# 8/8
powers under the CPC except in exceptional circumstances as mentioned above
and moreover, due to the fact that a coordinate bench of this Court in CRP No.
61/2023 had already held that the Keba decision on 16.07.2023 had obtained
finality and cannot be re-opened and required to be carried out in full spirit. In
the opinion of this Court, the respondent was not able to make out any
exceptional circumstance for recall/ review of the execution order dated
31.01.2024.
23. Consequently, it is the view of this Court that a case has been make out by
the petitioner warranting the interference of this Court and therefore, the
impugned
order
dated
05.08.2024
passed
by
the
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner, Aalo in Execution Case No. 06/2023 is quashed and set aside.
Petition is allowed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review