Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 20th February, 2020
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
:
Petitioners
Yogen Ghatani and Others
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim and Others
Application under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate, for the Petitioners.
Mr. Vivek Kohli, Advocate General with Mr. Thinlay Dorjee
Bhutia, Government Advocate, for the Respondents.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners No.1 to 15 are the grandchildren of
Government Servants to the Government of Sikkim prior to
31.12.1969. The Petitioners No.16 to 21 are the children of
Government Servants to the Government of Sikkim on or before
31.12.1969. The Petitioners are aggrieved by the state action,
by which an insertion was made in Notification No.66/Home/95,
dated 22.11.1995 (for brevity, “Notification of 1995”), in Item
No.5
therein,
Identification
qualifying
(for
the
short,
issuance
“COI”),
to
of
Certificate
persons
of
whose
father/husband has or had been in the Sikkim Government
Service
on
or
before
31.12.1969,
“for
the
purpose
of
employment only”, by superseding Memorandum No.5(92)5/
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
GEN/EST., dated 09.04.1981 (for short, “Memorandum of
1981”) . They also assail Item No.5 appearing in Notification
No.57/Home/96, dated 27.09.1996 (for short, “Notification of
1996”), which further qualified the sentence supra by insertion
of the words “and for no other purpose” causing the sentence to
read as follows;
“………………….. Certificate of Identification
obtained by such persons shall be for the purpose
of employment only and for no other purpose”
Their grievance further extends to letter bearing No.
GOS/Home-II/94/14(Part)/2687, dated 02.06.2006 (for short,
“Letter dated 02.06.2006”), issued by the Respondent No.2, to
the effect that Item No.5 of the Notification of 1995 does not
entitle the third generation, i.e., the grandchildren of persons
who were initially issued COI on the basis of Government
employment before 31.12.1969, to obtain COI. Insertion of Item
No.4A by Notification No.119/Home/2010, dated 26.10.2010 (for
short,
“Notification
of
2010”),
below
Notification of 1995, is also impugned.
Item
No.4
of
the
The insertion it is
averred is discriminatory, inasmuch as descendants of persons
falling under Item Nos.1 to 4 of the Notification would always be
eligible for obtaining COIs to the exclusion of persons in Item
No.5. That, the Petitioners by such exclusion are being treated
as “non-locals” in Sikkim, whereas, they have always considered
themselves as „locals‟ and „Sikkimese‟. That, the discrimination
strikes at the Petitioners‟ right to live with dignity in their own
land besides subjecting them to an identity crisis, hence the
reliefs claimed.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
2.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
The facts may be briefly traversed to comprehend
the dispute with clarity. By the Constitution (Thirty-Sixth)
Amendment Act, 1975, on 26.04.1975 (Appointed day), Sikkim
became a State in the Indian Union. Article 371F was inserted in
the Constitution of India (for short “Constitution”) as a special
provision for the State of Sikkim. Clause (l) of Article 371F inter
alia provides that the President may extend any law to the State
or repeal any law existing in the State, within two years from the
appointed day. Prior to Sikkim joining the Indian Union, the
Monarch
(Chogyal)
of
the
erstwhile
Kingdom
of
Sikkim
promulgated the Sikkim Subjects Regulation, 1961 (for brevity
“Regulation of 1961”) enumerating criteria for persons to
become Sikkim Subjects inter alia by virtue of birth in Sikkim
immediately preceding the Regulation and by ordinarily being a
resident of Sikkim for not less than fifteen years prior to the
Regulation of 1961. In addition to the above, under Regulation
8(iii)(a), a person could become a naturalized Subject if he was
in the service of the Government of Sikkim for a period of not
less than ten years immediately preceding the date of his
application, and under Regulation 8(iii)(b) if he had rendered
meritorious service to the State and Certificate thereof was
granted to him. The Sikkim Government Establishment Rules,
1974 (hereinafter, “Establishment Rules, 1974”) also came to be
promulgated
by
the
Chogyal
to
govern
recruitment
and
conditions of service for persons appointed in Government
service then. Under these Rules preference was given to Sikkim
Subjects for recruitment in Government service.
Only in the
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
absence
of
requisite
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
qualified
„Sikkimese‟
personnel
appointments were offered to non-Sikkimese. Post merger the
Establishment Rules, 1974 came to be adopted by the State of
Sikkim under Article 309 of the Constitution.
The validity of
those Rules were upheld by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the
ratiocination of State of Sikkim vs. Surendra Prasad Sharma and
Others1.
3.
Thereafter, vide the Extraordinary Gazette No.41,
dated 16.05.1975, of the Home Department “The Adaptation of
Sikkim Laws (Number I) Order, 1975” (for short, “Adaptation
Laws, 1975”) was published for general information, whereby,
the Regulation of 1961 stood repealed from the appointed day.
The Home Department, Government of Sikkim, vide Notification
No.995/H/75,
dated
Gangtok
21.06.1975,
re-published
Notifications of the Government of India, Ministry of Home
Affairs, bearing various numbers, dated 16.05.1975, for general
information. It was notified therein inter alia that the Citizenship
Act, 1955 (57 of 1955) was extended and enforced in the State
of Sikkim w.e.f. 16.05.1975. Vide an Order called “The Sikkim
(Citizenship) Order, 1975” of 16.05.1975 every person who
immediately before 26.04.1975 (Appointed day) was a Sikkim
Subject under the Regulation of 1961, was deemed to have
become a citizen of India on that day.
4.
On 25.09.1976, the Respondent No.3 issued a
Memorandum
(1994) 5 SCC 282
bearing
No.5(92)229/GEN/Est.
(for
short,
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
“Memorandum
of
vs.
1976”),
State of Sikkim and Others
requiring
persons
seeking
employment to inform whether their parents‟ name had been
recorded in the relevant Government Register on or before
15.05.1975. In continuation of this Memorandum, Notification
bearing
No.285(GEN)/EST.,
dated
28.01.1980
(for
short,
“Notification of 1980”) was issued by the Respondent No.3
notifying that Domicile/Residential Certificate issued by sources
other than the District Collector would not be accepted as valid.
Vide
the
Memorandum
of
District
Collectors
were
authorized to issue Certificates to persons in the following
categories, to enable them to “apply for employment” in the
State;
5(a).
“1.
A person whose name is found recorded in
the Old Sikkim Subject Register prior to
1975.
2.
A person whose name is not found registered
in the Old Sikkim Subject Register but
he/she has established beyond doubt that
name of his/her father/husband/paternal
grandfather/brother from same father has
been recorded in the Old Sikkim Subject
Register.
3.
A person who has agricultural land in the
rural areas and has been ordinarily residing
in the State of Sikkim.
4.
A person whose father/husband had been in
the service of the State Government on or
before 31st December, 1969.”
It is the Petitioners‟ case that the Memorandum of
1981 (supra) placed the persons at Item No.4 (supra) at par
with persons belonging to Items No.1, 2 and 3 (supra) by
embodying the spirit of the Regulation of 1961. That, infact
rights
conferred
upon
such
Government
servants
by
the
Regulation of 1961 stood at a higher pedestal than even those
born in the territory of Sikkim, as the requirement for the latter
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
was their birth in Sikkim before the commencement of the
Regulation of 1961 and for others the requirement was residence
in Sikkim for a period of fifteen years preceding the Regulation
of 1961. No such fetters were imposed for Government servants,
the only eligibility criteria being of Government service for a
period of ten years even after the commencement of the
Regulation of 1961.
That, at the time of promulgation of the
Regulation of 1961, due to dearth of educated Sikkimese,
educated non-Sikkimese took up Government service, with the
legitimate
expectation
of
becoming
Sikkim
Subjects
on
completion of ten years service and the circumstance of merger
was unforeseen. That, although the Memorandum of 1981 was
issued basically for the purposes of employment it was accepted
for myriad purposes, such as sale and purchase of land in
Sikkim, obtaining relevant caste, tribe and class certificate sans
discrimination amongst the four categories.
(b)
That, on an application moved in the Lok Sabha in
1988, an amendment to the Sikkim (Citizenship) Order 1975
was made being the Sikkim Citizenship (Amendment) Order,
1989 [for short, “Amendment Order of 1989”]. A proviso came
to be inserted in Paragraph 2 of the Sikkim (Citizenship) Order of
1975, vide which, any person whose name was eligible to be
entered in the register under the Regulation of 1961 but was left
out due to genuine omission were deemed to have become
Citizen of India on that day, i.e., 26.04.1975, if so determined
by the Central Government. A Committee was constituted
accordingly on 03.04.1989 by the Central Government for this
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
purpose. Item No.(d) of the Annexure to the Amendment Order
of 1989 therein included amongst others, the criteria of persons
in regular government service in Sikkim before 26.04.1975 to be
considered for grant of Indian Citizenship, provided that the
appointment had not been made under the “exception clause”
pertaining to non-Subjects.
His natural descendants were also
eligible for Citizenship. It is averred that this criteria was
adopted in the spirit of the provision in Regulation 8(iii)(a) of the
Regulation of 1961. That, although the cut-off date was taken as
31.12.1969 in the Memorandum of 1981 without any justification
but that is not the subject of challenge in the instant Writ
Petition. Pursuant thereto, vide the Government of India Orders
dated 07.08.1990 and 08.04.1991 a total number of 73,431
persons were granted Indian Citizenship. Thus, a new category
of persons other than the categories included in Item No.1 to
Item No.4 of Memorandum of 1981 were eligible for enumeration
as locals.
(c)
issued
By an executive order, Notification of 1995 was
in
supersession
of
all
previous
Memoranda
and
Notifications. The earlier Item No.4 was renumbered as Item
No.5. The new Item 4 included persons granted Citizenship as
detailed supra.
Item No.5 (viz., previously 4) witnessed an
arbitrary insertion of the second sentence which provided that
“Certificate obtained by such persons shall be for the purpose of
employment only”, thereby restricting the utility of the COI of the
Petitioners. No such restrictions came to be in place for Items
No.1 to 4 of the Notification of 1995. On 27.09.1996, Notification
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
of 1996 was brought out substituting the contents of the
previous Item No.5 by imposing a further restriction to the effect
that Certificate for Item No.5 shall be for the purpose of
employment only and “for no other purpose”. That, the treatment
of persons obtaining COIs under Item No.5 vis-à-vis those
belonging to the categories In Item Nos.1 to 4 is arbitrary,
discriminatory and in violation of Articles 14 and 21 of the
Constitution. Compounding this situation was the interpretation
of the District Collectors based on a letter issued by the
Respondent No.,2 dated 02.06.2006, interpreting Item No.5 of
the Notification of 1995 to mean that the third generation of COI
holders based on Government service before 31.12.1969 were
not eligible to obtain COI under the said Notification. No such
interpretation however was made for the third generation or
subsequent generations of persons belonging to the other items
in the Notification of 1995.
That although the aforestated
Memoranda and Notifications are not based on any statutory,
legislative enactments or codified laws and are policy decisions
of the Government of Sikkim, such decisions cannot be bereft of
rationality.
(d)
In the year 2006, another Notification bearing
No.04/Home/2006, dated 25.01.2006, authorized the District
Collectors to issue COI only to the direct descendants of the COI
holders and all the other cases were to be referred to the Head
Office. This was followed by a Notification of 2010 which vide
Clause (2), inserted Item No.4A after Item No.4 and before Item
No.5, to the Notification of 1995 to read as follows;
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
“(2)
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
After item 4 the following shall be inserted,
namely:
4A.
A person whose father/husband is/was
eligible for grant of the Certificate of
Identification under any of the categories
listed under items 1 to 4 above, …………”
This perpetuated the issuance of COIs to categories in
Item Nos. 1 to 4 but excluded Item No.5. That, the classification
in
the
Notifications
are
motivated
and
wholly
arbitrary,
discriminatory, unreasonable and unjustified violating Article 14
of the Constitution. The classification is also violative of Article
15 of the Constitution as it does not fall within any of the
exemptions envisaged therein. That, even Regulation 6 of the
Regulation of 1961 provides that children of a Sikkim Subject
father would be Sikkim Subjects. That, on account of the
impugned Notifications the Petitioners have become stateless in
their own State.
(e)
The Petitioners therefore seek a Writ of Mandamus
or a Writ in the nature of Mandamus or any other appropriate
Writ, direction or order, quashing and setting aside and striking
down the second sentence to Item No.5 appearing in Notification
of 1995 vide which the words “for the purpose of employment”
were inserted. Quashing and setting aside Item No.5 appearing
in Notification of 1996 (Annexure P-13), which substituted Item
No.5 of Notification of 1995, which inserted the words “for no
other purpose”.
Quashing and setting aside Letter dated
02.06.2006 (Annexure P-14), issued by the Respondent No.2,
denying issuance of COI to the third generation, i.e., the children
of the
persons
who
were
issued
COIs on the
basis of
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
employment of their father in the Government of Sikkim before
31.12.1969.
Quashing and setting aside Item No.4A to
Notification of 1995 below Item No.4 and above Item No.5,
inserted by Notification of 2010 (Annexure P-16).
That, the
Respondents be prohibited by issuance of appropriate writ to
give
effect
to
the
Notification of 2010.
Letter
dated
02.06.2006
(supra)
An appropriate writ be issued
and
declaring
that the COIs obtained by the persons on the basis of such
persons‟ father being in the service of Government of Sikkim is
not restricted for the purpose of employment alone but for all
purposes.
An appropriate writ declaring that descendants of
persons who have obtained COI on the basis of service of their
father being in Government service prior to 31.12.1969, falling
under Item No.5 of the Notification of 1995, are entitled to
obtain COI.
6(a).
The State-Respondents by filing a joint return while
admitting the historical facts and averments of the Petitioners
based on records, denied and disputed the allegations of
arbitrariness and the averment of the Petitioners that they were
ever placed at par with persons at Item Nos.1 to 3 of the
Memorandum of 1981. That, under the Memorandum of 1981 a
one time concession had been conferred to persons categorized
in Item No.4, despite them not being „Sikkimese‟ or „locals‟ and
ineligible for Government service in terms of Rule 4(4) of the
Establishment Rules, 1974.
That, the concession was not
envisaged to be in perpetuity and such concession could not be
deemed as a right or as one extending to future generations.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
Neither
does
it
entitle
vs.
them
State of Sikkim and Others
to
identify
themselves
as
„Sikkimese‟, who are infact a different category as their names
having been registered in the Sikkim Subject Register.
They
sought to clarify that Clause (k) of Article 371F of the
Constitution provides that all laws in force immediately before
the appointed day in the territories comprised in the State of
Sikkim or any part thereof shall continue to be in force until
amended or repealed by a competent legislature or other
competent authority. Consequently, the Establishment Rules,
1974 which governs the appointment and service conditions of
Government employees is a valid and protected law being a pre
merger Rule, the constitutional validty of which has been upheld
by the Supreme Court in Surendra Prasad Sharma (supra). Rule
4(4) of the said Rules provides inter alia that „non-Sikkimese‟
nationals may be appointed only when suitably qualified and
experienced „Sikkimese‟ nationals are not available.
replacement
of
such
appointees
by
suitable
That,
„Sikkimese‟
candidates may be made as and when available.
(b)
After the merger of Sikkim and repeal of the
Regulation of 1961, in order to identify the Sikkim Subjects the
Memorandum
dated
25.09.1976
was
issued,
to
enable
appointment of „Sikkimese‟ in the Government sector as per
safeguards
provided
in
the
Establishment
Rules,
1974.
Notification of 1995 was specific that COI for category in Item
No.5 was limited to the purposes of employment. Moreover, the
Finance Act, 2006 introduced Clause 26AAA in Section 10 of the
Income Tax Act, 1961 and the said amendment also defined
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
„Sikkimese‟ as a distinct class. That, in order to consider whether
the third generation of the State Government employees who
have been issued COI based on their service in the State
Government on or before 31.12.1969 were eligible for COI, a
High Level Committee was constituted by the State Government
under the Chairmanship of the Chief Secretary which observed
that, the grandchildren of those persons who were in Sikkim
Government service on or before 31.12.1969 are not entitled to
COIs.
Besides,
persons
seeking
Citizenship
even
under
Regulation 8 of the Regulation of 1961 were required to take
oath of allegiance and renounce their former nationality neither
is it the Petitioners‟ case that their parents had been conferred
with Sikkimese Citizenship by the then Maharaja of Sikkim in
exercise of powers under Regulation 8(iii) of the Regulation of
1961. Thus, in view of the provisions contained in Regulation of
1961 the claim of the Petitioners‟ are misconceived and
misplaced. The issue was also examined by the Law Commission
of Sikkim. The Hon‟ble Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim
inter alia opined that “special privilege conferred in Clause 5 of
the above notification should not be extended any further to the
grandchildren of the former employees mentioned therein”.
(c)
It is denied that the Memorandum of 1981 was for
other purposes besides employment in the Government of
Sikkim, as purchase and sale of land and other government
benefits and entitlements are governed by their respective Acts
and Rules. The Respondents deny that Item (d) of the Annexure
dated 03.04.1989 was issued in terms of or in consideration of
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
the provisions contained in Regulation 8(iii)(a) of the Regulation
of 1961. That, granting of Indian Citizenship to 73,431 persons
were those who had been genuinely excluded and it was not an
exercise in granting Citizenship to those persons who were in
Sikkim Government employment at the time of merger.
It is
denied that the impugned Notifications are violative of Articles
14 and 21 of the Constitution and discriminatory and not based
on valid classification. That, Regulation 12 of the Regulation of
1961 prescribes the maintenance of the Register of Sikkim
Subjects
also
known
as
the
Sikkim
Subject
Register
or
Government Register and the name of those who are granted
citizenship under various provisions were recorded in the said
Sikkim Subject Register.
That, the Petition for the aforestated
reasons deserves a dismissal.
7.
While reiterating the facts as made out in the Writ
Petition, in Rejoinder the Petitioners added that the High Level
Committee
ignored
the
appointments
made
by
particular
the
then
distinctness
Chogyal
on
of
or
the
before
31.12.1969 and that they were continuously residing in Sikkim
prior to the merger and treated as „Sikkimese‟.
Besides, the
Committee‟s opinion is influenced by non-consideration of the
entire context in which the COIs were issued by the State. The
opinion of Hon‟ble Justice Bhaskar Bhattacharya the Chairman,
Law Commission of Sikkim is devoid of examination of the
Memorandum of 1981, the provisions relating to Regulation 8(iii)
of the Regulation of 1961 and the opinion given by his
predecessor
in
Office,
Hon‟ble
Justice
R.K.
Patra
dated
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
05.03.2012.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
That, Hon‟ble Justice R.K. Patra after examining
the matter had inter alia sought clarification from the authority
on the point as to how a son whose father is having a COI could
not be considered for issuance of a COI irrespective of whether
he is of third or fourth generation.
It is thus prayed that the
reliefs be granted.
8.
Advancing his arguments for the Petitioners, learned
Counsel stated that insertion of the impugned sentence in Item
No.5 of the Notification of 1995 and in Item No.5 of Notification
of 1996 are violative of the provisions of Articles 14 and 21 of
the Constitution and fails to satisfy the tests laid down by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court under Article 14 of the Constitution.
That, the classification is required to be reasonable and must
have a nexus with the object sought to be achieved, however in
the present case the classification is motivated and is wholly
arbitrary, discriminatory, unreasonable and unjustified. That, in
fact the Regulation of 1961 had placed all „Sikkimese‟ at par with
each other, however the assailed Notifications have treated
„Sikkimese‟ differently by denying benefits that accrue to the
Petitioners. That, Article 15 of the Constitution under Clause (4)
provides for special provisions to be made for the advancement
of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens
and for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, however
these exceptions are not applicable in the present circumstances.
By denying issuance of COI to the grandchildren of persons
employed before 31.12.1969, their rights of sale and purchase of
land and other government benefits are being denied and is
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
socially divisive. While reiterating the facts as averred in the
Petition, it was contended that the Memorandum of 1981 placed
the Petitioners at par with persons belonging to other categories.
9.
Adverting to the constitution of the Committee in
1989 by the Government of India, it was contended that a bare
perusal of the Guidelines to the Committee clearly indicates that
a person holding a regular Government job before 26.04.1975
and his natural descendants were found to be eligible to have
their names included in the Register maintained under the
Regulation of 1961, thereby making such person‟s eligibility at
par with persons under Items (a), (b), (c) and (e) of the
Guidelines. By the same logic it would imply that the Petitioners
were also eligible for inclusion as Sikkim Subjects.
That,
interpreting the provisions of the Notification of 1995 to mean
that the children of those who have obtained COIs on the basis
of the employment of their father in Government service prior to
31.12.1969 would not be entitled to obtain COI would lead to
absurdity and such interpretation would be unacceptable. That,
even Regulation 6 of the Regulation of 1961 provides that
children of a Sikkim Subject father would also be a Sikkim
Subject. That, the insertion of Item No.4A is an effort to
overcome the grammatical difficulties created by Notification of
1995 for children of those persons belonging to Items No.1 to 4
but excludes children of persons belonging to Item No.5 without
any reasoning. Infact, agricultural land was not even a criteria
for issuance of Sikkim Subject Certificate but was subsequently
inserted by way of Memorandum of 1981. Contending that the
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
interpretation made by the Notifications of 1995, 1996 and 2010
(supra), leads to absurdity, he relied on H.S. Vankani and Others
vs. State of Gujarat and Others2, Afcons Infrastructure Limited and
Another vs. Cherian Varkey Construction Company Private Limited
and Others3
and Sarah Mathew vs. Institute of Cardio Vascular
Disease and Others4.
It was next urged that the Government
cannot make policy decisions which are illegal. Towards this
submission, reliance was placed on State of Madhya Pradesh and
Others
vs. Mala Banerjee5 and Delhi Development Authority and
Another vs. Joint Action Committee, Allottee of SFS Flats and Others 6.
That, the ratio in R.K. Garg vs. Union of India and Others7 lays
down that classification cannot be arbitrary. Further, in D.S.
Nakara and Others vs. Union of India8 the Courts have been vested
with powers to widen the scope of the petitions by reading down
the provisions. That, the interpretation of Notification of 1995 is
untenable as fetters were created by such interpretation only for
the third generation of persons belonging to Item No.5 of the
Notification and not for the third or subsequent generation of
persons belonging to Items No.1 to 4 of the said Notification. No
explanation emerges as to why the third generation of persons
belonging to Item No.5 alone have been denied COIs and not
others. That, policy decisions cannot be arbitrary and there is no
justification as to why the son or daughter of a father who is a
(2010) 4 SCC 301
(2010) 8 SCC 24
(2014) 2 SCC 62
(2015) 7 SCC 698
(2008) 2 SCC 372
(1981) 4 SCC 675
(1983) 1 SCC 305
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
COI holder could not be considered for grant of COI whether he
is of a third generation or fourth generation. That, in view of the
averments in the Writ Petition and the foregoing arguments the
prayers be granted.
10.
Learned Advocate General repudiating the stand of
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners contended that Article 14 of
the Constitution is not applicable in the instant case. That, only
those persons whose parents‟ names had been recorded in the
Sikkim Subject Register on or before 15.05.1975 qualified as
„Sikkimese‟ or „locals‟. That, as per the Regulation of 1961
persons were naturalized as subjects on giving up of their Indian
Citizenship and taking an oath of allegiance to the King. The
forefathers of the Petitioners did not give up their Indian
Citizenship neither did they claim allegiance to the then Kingdom
and its Monarch and continued to be Indian Citizens, thus
becoming ineligible for subjecthood.
That, the letter dated
02.06.2006 by the Additional Secretary/Home to the District
Collector, East District, Gangtok (Annexure-P14) unequivocally
states the position that the grandchildren of persons who were
issued with the COI being in regular Government service prior to
31.12.1969 were not entitled to obtain COI. Relying on the
decision in State of Haryana and Others vs. Mahabir Vegetable Oils
Private Limited9 it was contended that there is no law which can
force the hand of the Government to extend benefits to the
Petitioners. That, the Notification of 26.10.2010 extends the
(2011) 3 SCC 778
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
issuance of COI to the father but does not perpetuate it. The
Learned
Advocate
General
urged
that
Rule
4(4)
of
the
Establishment Rules, 1974 is protected under Clause (k) of
Article 371F of the Constitution whereby employment is reserved
only for the „Sikkimese‟ or the locals. To safeguard the spirit of
this provision, the Notifications have been issued by the
Government of Sikkim from time to time and in 1981 the
Government categorized various groups so as to enable them to
take up employment in the State.
By way of concession and as
a one time measure this was offered also to persons whose
father/husband had been in the service of the State on or before
31.12.1969. The Memorandum of 1981 also clearly stipulated
that it was only for the purpose of employment. Thus, this
concession was extended only to the wife or children of those
persons who had been in Government service on or before
31.12.1969 and not to their children or other future generations.
Later, by issuance of the Notification of 1995, the Government
decided
to
issue
Certificate
of
Identification.
Vide
the
Notification, a concession was extended or continued to those
persons whose father/husband had been in Sikkim Government
service on or before 31.12.1969 on account of the State having
newly merged into the Indian Union. A clarification ensued
therein that COI would be only for the purpose of employment,
thus manifesting the interpretation of the State Government to
give the concession or benefit of COI to such category of persons
despite them being non-locals. It was next contended that the
grant of such concession does not however entitle them to claim
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
the status of being a Sikkim Subject or a „Sikkimese‟ which is a
distinct class as law grants certain rights and privileges to the
Sikkim Subjects. Consequently, the District Collectors vide
Notification of 2006 have been authorized to issue COI only to
the direct descendants of such persons, this distinction is
reinforced
by
the
amendment
in
the
Finance
Act,
recognising „Sikkimese‟ as a distinct class. Drawing the attention
of this Court to the ratio in Surendra Prasad Sharma (supra), it
was contended that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has upheld the
constitutional validity of the Establishment Rules, 1974. That,
the High Level Committee constituted on 03.03.2014 concluded
that the benefits to category in Item No.5 of Notification of 1995
as amended in 1996, was admissible only to the son/daughter
and the wife of a person who was in the Sikkim Government
service on or before 31.12.1969 and permanently lived in Sikkim
after retirement and that too for the purpose of employment
only and for no other purpose. That, the grandchildren of such
persons are not entitled to COIs (Annexure R-5) and the
Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim Hon‟ble Justice Bhaskar
Bhattacharjee
was
also
of
the
same
view.
That,
the
Memorandum of 1981 was not issued in terms of Regulation
8(iii) of the Regulation of 1961 neither was the Memorandum of
1981 for any other purpose besides employment contrary to the
stand of the Petitioners. That, even under Clause 8 of the
Regulation of 1961 persons who had been granted „Sikkimese‟
citizenship were required to enter their names in the Sikkim
Subject Register hence in the absence of such entry the claims
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
of the Petitioners are misconceived. That, considering the
historical background of Sikkim, the third generation of persons
falling under category in Item No.4 of the Memorandum of 1981
and category in Item No.5 of the Notification of 1995 are not
entitled to be treated in the same distinct class as Sikkim
Subjects in terms of Article 371F of the Constitution and only
one generation following was to be granted COI. Such nonentitlement is neither discriminatory nor arbitrary. It was
clarified that before the appointed day there were many persons
including citizens of India residing in the State for the purposes
of employment or business. Such persons did not opt for
„Sikkimese‟ citizenship and continued to remain Indian citizens,
hence after the merger it is only Sikkim Subjects or „Sikkimese‟
nationals who were granted Indian citizenship. The other
category of persons who are Indian Citizens were not required to
be granted Indian citizenship afresh as they were already
citizens of India even prior to the appointed day. That, at this
belated stage the Petitioners cannot take the plea that under the
Regulation of 1961 they are also
entitled to „Sikkimese‟
Citizenship. The Petitioners are thus not entitled to any of the
reliefs sought for in the Writ Petition, which deserves a
dismissal.
11.
The rival submissions put forth by Learned Counsel
were heard at length. I have carefully perused and considered
the pleadings, the entire documents appended, as well as the
Judgments cited at the Bar.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
12.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
The questions that fall for consideration before this
Court are ─
(i)
Whether the impugned insertions in Notification
No.66/Home/95, dated 22.11.1995 in Item No.5
qualifying the use of Certificate of Identification to
persons
in
that
category
“for
the
purpose
of
employment only” and the insertion in Notification
No.57/Home/96, dated 27.09.1996, substituting the
provisions of Item No.5 and further qualifying the
utility of the COI of that category by insertion of the
words “for no other purpose” and the Letter dated
02-06-2006 and Notification of 2010 are violative of
Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution;
(ii)
Whether
the
Petitioners
No.1
to
being
grandchildren of persons who were Government
Servants in the Government of Sikkim on or before
31.12.1969 are entitled to obtain Certificate of
Identification and as a corollary whether children of
Petitioners No.16 to 21 are entitled to the same as
also their subsequent generations; and
(iii)
Whether such COI is to be limited to the purposes of
employment only for persons in Item No.5 of the
Notification of 1995 as amended by Notification of
1996.
13.
A brief discussion on the relevant provisions of the
Regulation of 1961 would lend assistance in delineating the
issues raised in the Petition. In the erstwhile Kingdom of Sikkim,
under
Sikkim
domiciled
in
Subjects
the
Regulation
territory
at
the
1961,
certain
persons
commencement
of
the
Regulation and others contingent upon certain caveats, could be
Sikkim
Subjects.
hereinbelow;
The
relevant
portions
are
extracted
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
“3.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Certain persons domiciled in Sikkim Territory
at the commencement of the Regulation to be
Sikkim subjects -
1. Every person who has his domicile in the
territory of Sikkim immediately before the
commencement of this Regulation shall be a
Sikkim subject if he:
(a) Was born in the territory of Sikkim and is
resident therein, or
(b) Has been ordinarily resident in the territory
of Sikkim period not less than fifteen years
immediately
preceding
such
commencement; provided that in the said
period of fifteen years any absence from
the said territory on account of service
under the Government of India shall be
disregarded; or
………………………………………………………………………………..
5.
Sikkim Subject by Descent:
Every person born after the commencement
of this Regulation shall be a Sikkim Subject if
at-the time of his birth his father is a Sikkim
subject under this Regulation, whether or
not the birth takes place in the territory of
Sikkim.
…………………………………………………………………………………
8.
Naturalised subjects:
(i) ……………………………..….
(ii) …………………………………
(iii)
The Government to the-Chogyal shall also
have the power to naturalise a person upon
application made therefore in the manner
prescribed by the rules, provided that the
Government of the Chogyal are satisfied that;
(a)
He has been in the service of the
Government of Sikkim for a period of not
less
than
ten
years
immediately
preceding the date of his application, or
(b) He has rendered meritorious service to
the state; and the person to whom such a
certificate is granted shall, on taking oath of
allegiance, and upon his name being entered in the
Register of Subjects, be a naturalized Sikkim
subject from the date on which the certificate was
granted; ……………..….”
14.
A bare perusal of these provisions reveal that once
the contingencies in Regulation 8 were fulfilled persons applying
for Sikkim Subjecthood would be granted the same.
The
Regulations do not envisage any differential benefit or treatment
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
to any category once they are Sikkim Subjects, whether by birth,
descent or naturalisation. The Sikkim Subjects Regulation, 1961
stood repealed by the Adaptation Laws, 1975, which defines
“Existing Law” as any law in force immediately before the
Appointed day in the whole or any part of the territories
comprised in the State of Sikkim. “Law includes any enactment,
Proclamation, Regulation, Rule, Notification or other instrument
having, immediately before the Appointed day, the force of Law
in the whole or any part of the territories now comprised in the
State of Sikkim.” Hence, the Establishment Rules, 1974, being
covered by the ambit of the above definitions is a protected law
in terms of Article 371F(k) of the Constitution.
15.
Rule 4(4) of the Establishment Rules, 1974, provides
as follows;
“4.
Establishment : General principles.………………………………………………………..
(A) Appointment to
service under the Government shall be by one or
both the method indicated below;(4)
Appointment.-
(a)
Direct recruitment;
(b)
Promotion from one grade to another.
(B)
Direct
recruitment
shall
include
appointment on contract and appointment on
deputation:
Provided
these
two
types
of
appointment shall be made having due regard to
the
exact nature
of specific duties
and
responsibilities and the qualification required for
the post, and further provided that (i) NonSikkimese nationals may be appointed only when
suitably qualified and experienced Sikkimese
nationals are not available, and (ii) replacement of
such appointees by suitable Sikkimese candidates
may be made as and when available.
…………………………………….”
[emphasis supplied]
As pointed out by the Respondents, the constitutional
validity of Rule 4(4) of the Establishment Rules, 1974 has been
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
upheld by the Supreme Court in Surendra Prasad Sharma (supra).
It is evident that under the Regulation of 1961 there was no cutoff year for submission of application by any person to become a
Sikkim Subject by naturalization. In this context, it cannot but
be noticed that the records furnished before this Court do not
provide for reasons as to why the Government has specified that
31.12.1969
would
be
the
relevant
year
for
issuance
of
Certificates to Item No.4 of the Memorandum of 1981 and Item
No.5 of the Notification of 1995 partially modified in 1996. Be
that as it may, this date is not assailed in the instant Petition and
therefore further discussions on this aspect stand truncated
here.
16.
Post merger, Memorandum bearing No.5(92)229/
GEN/Est. came to be issued on 25.09.1976 which reads as
follows;
“OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY
ESTABLISHMENT DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
Memorandum No.5(92)229/GEN/Est.
Dated Gangtok, the September 25th 1976.
In order to ascertain the residential qualification of
candidates who claim to be Locals on the view of
seeking employment, it has been decided that the
candidates should be able to maintain whether
their parents name have been recorded on or
before 15.5.1975 in the relevant Government
Register.
Sd/-T.Chhopel
Secretary
Establishment Department
1. Secretary/Head of Department.
2. Additional Secretary, Home Department.
3. District Office East/West/North/South.
4. File and
5. Guard File
[Emphasis supplied]”
As per this Notification, locals who sought employment
(impliedly Government employment) were to establish entry of
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
their parents‟ name in the Sikkim Subject Register on or before
15.05.1975.
This is a day before the date on which the
Citizenship Act, 1955 (57 of 1955) came into force in the State
of
Sikkim,
i.e.,
on
16.05.1975,
vide
Notification
in
the
Extraordinary Gazette No.995/H/75, dated Gangtok 21.06.1975.
17.
Notification
bearing
No.285
(GEN)/EST.
dated
28.01.1980 was issued in continuation of the Notification of 1976
supra and provided that Domicile/Residential Certificate issued by
sources other than the District Collector, shall not be accepted as
valid.
It is worthwhile noticing that the Notification of 1976
made no mention of a “Certificate”.
The Notification of 1980
came to provide for “Domicile/Residential Certificate” but carved
out no distinction between the two.
18.
In 1981 for the first time the Government of Sikkim
categorised persons into four different groups to enable them to
obtain Certificates, issued by the District Collectors, for the
“purposes of employment” in the State, vide Memorandum bearing
No.5(92)5/GEN/EST,
dated
09.04.1981.
This
Memorandum
provides as follows;
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
ESTABLISHMENT DEPARTMENT
NO.5(92)5/GEN/EST
Dated Gangtok the 9.4.81
MEMORANDUM
In modification of this Department Notification
No:5(92)229/GEN/EST
dated:
25.9.76
and
Notification No:285/Gen/EST dated:28.1.1980 the
Governor has been pleased to authorize the
District Collectors within their respective districts
to issue certificates to persons identifying them in
the following groups to enable them to apply for
employment in the State.
1. A person whose name is found recorded in
the Old Sikkim Subject Register prior to
1975.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
2. A person whose name is not found
registered in the Old Sikkim Subject
Register but he/she has established beyond
doubt that name of his/her father/
husband/paternal
grandfather/
brother
from same father has been recorded in the
Old Sikkim Subject Register.
3. A person who has agricultural land in the
rural areas and has been ordinarily residing
in the State of Sikkim.
4. A person whose father/husband had been
in the service of the State Government on
or before 31st December, 1969.
Sd/L.T. Tonyot
Joint Secretary to Govt. of Sikkim
Establishment Department
[emphasis supplied]”
Apart from „locals‟ as mentioned in the Memorandum of
1976 and categorized at Item Nos.1 and 2 of the Memorandum
of 1981, Item No.3 saw the inclusion of persons who had
agricultural land in rural areas and ordinarily residing in Sikkim
as being eligible to apply for and obtain Domicile/Residential
Certificate for employment in the State. For this category there
was no requirement of proving lineage or ancestry in Sikkim.
Item No.4 included persons whose father/husband had been in
the service of the State Government on or before 31.12.1969
and they too were found to be eligible to apply for employment
in the State. Thus, all four categories in the Memorandum were
eligible to apply for and obtain Certificates, to enable them to
apply for employment in the State.
As apparent, all four
categories have been placed at par by this Memorandum for the
said purpose, viz., employment.
19.
Thereafter,
vide
Notification
No.56(9)H/88-89/35
(Annexure P8) dated 03.04.1989, the Sikkim (Citizenship)
Order,
was
amended
by
the
Sikkim
(Citizenship)
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Amendment Order, 1989 and the following proviso was inserted
in Paragraph 2;
“Provided that any person whose name was
eligible to be entered in the register maintained
under the said regulation but was not so entered
because of any genuine omission shall also be
deemed to have become a citizen of India on that
day if so determined by the Central Government”.
A Committee comprising of Central and State Government
Officers was constituted by the Central Government vide
Notification No.56(9)/H88-89/36, dated 03.04.1989, for the
aforestated object. The Notification bore an Annexure being
“Annexure
to
M.H.A.
ORDER
NO.26030/69/88-IC.I
dated
20.3.89. GUIDELINES” which reads as follows;
“a.
b.
c.
Natural descendants of a person whose
names is in the Sikkim Subject Register.
Person having recorded ownership or
tenancy rights on agricultural land or of rural
property within Sikkim before 26th April,
1975, and his natural descendants.
Persons, whose name is included in the
earliest available voters-list prior to the 26th
April, 1975, and his natural descendants.
d.
Person holding a regular government job
before 26th April, 1975 provided that the
appointment has not been a made (sic)
under the „exception‟ clause pertaining to
non-subjects; and his natural descendants.
e.
Holder of trade license outside notified
bazaar areas prior to 26th April, 1975 and
his natural descendants.
He must not have entered the territory of
Sikkim on the basis of work-permit.
He must not have acquired citizenship of any
other country.
He must not be holding the status of refugee
on the basis of a registration certificate
issued by the competent authority.
f.
g.
h.
(The criteria laid down from (a) to (e) singly
or collectively are by themselves not be taken as
conclusive evidence for granting citizenship, but
would have to be scrutinized in the light of those at
(f), (g) & (h).
[Emphasis supplied]”
The contention of the Petitioners is that the guidelines
supra prescribed the category in „d‟ for inclusion as Sikkim
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Subjects, hence by the same logic all other persons who were
Government employees then but not Sikkim Subjects were also
eligible to be considered as „Sikkimese‟. In this context, it may
be
clarified
that
the
forefathers
of
the
Petitioners
were
admittedly Indian Citizens, hence this exercise was not relevant
for them, as they were not left out persons. The exercise was
only for the conferment of citizenship to persons for the
aforestated reason, although evidently the guidelines at „d‟ was
prompted by Regulation 8 of the Regulation of 1961.
The
State-Respondents could not enlighten this Court as to what the
“exception clause” as mentioned in Item „d‟ pertained to.
20.
Consequent thereto, the Central Government vide its
Order No.26030/36/90-I.C.I. of the Ministry of Home Affairs
dated 07.08.1980, republished
Gazette
Extraordinary
vide
in
the
Notification
Sikkim Government
No.56(9)Home/88-
89/108, dated 16.08.1990, provided Citizenship to 40,083
persons w.e.f. 26.04.1975. This was followed by a second Order
bearing No.26030/36/90-I.C.I., dated 08.04.1991, of the Central
Government, republished in the Sikkim Government Gazette
Extraordinary
vide
Notification
No.56(9)Home/88/7,
dated
15.04.1991, the Central Government conferred Citizenship on an
additional number of 33,348 persons. A total of 73,431 persons
who were found to have been left out due to genuine omissions
and conferred Indian Citizenship.
21.
On 22.11.1995 the State Government then issued
the Memorandum which reads as follows;
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
HOME DEPARTMENT
No.66/Home/95.
Dated:22nd November, 1995.
NOTIFICATION
In supersession of the Memorandum No.5
(92) 229/GEN/EST, dated 25th September 1976,
Notification No. 285/GEN/EST, dated 28th January,
1980, Memorandum No5 (92) 5/GEN/EST, dated
9th April, 1981 and Circular No. 339/HS/87, dated
17th March, 1987, the State Government is hereby
pleased to authorize the District Collectors, SubDivisional Officers and Revenue Officers within
their respective jurisdiction to issue Certificate of
Identification to the persons falling in the different
categories
as
indicated
below
on
the
recommendations Of (sic) the Gram Panchayat and
being duly satisfied with such recommendation:1. A person whose name is found recorded in the
Old Sikkim Subject Register or
2. A person whose name is not found registered in
the Old Sikkim Subject Register but he/she has
established beyond doubt that the name of
his/her father/husband/paternal grandfather/
brother from the same father has been recorded
in the Old Sikkim Subject Register or
3. A person who has or had agricultural land in
rural areas and has been ordinarily residing in
the State of Sikkim or
4. A person who is holder of Indian Citizenship
Certificate issued by the District Collector,
Government of Sikkim under the Sikkim
(Citizenship) Order, 1975 as amended vide the
Sikkim (Citizenship) Amendment order, 1989 or
5. A person whose father/husband has/had been
in Sikkim Government Service on or before
31.12.1969. Certificate or Indentification (sic)
obtained by such persons shall be for the
purpose of employment only.
………………………………………………………………………
By order and in the name of the Governor,
K.A.VARADAN
CHIEF SECRETARY
(F.No. 103/90-91/L.R.)
[emphasis supplied]”
22.
earlier
Vide this Notification it is evident that the Certificates
called
“Domicile/Residential
Certificates”
by
the
Notification of 1980 was given the nomenclature of “Certificate of
Identification” (COI, for short) and the “left out” persons who
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
were included by the Orders supra, as Indian Citizens, were
inserted in Item No.4 as persons eligible to receive COI. The
previous Item No.4 was now renumbered as Item No.5 and it
was specified therein that the COI obtained by persons at Item
No.5 shall be “for the purposes of employment only”.
It is
pertinent to notice that in contrast to the Notification of 1976
which
provides
that
“In
order
to
ascertain
residential
qualification of candidates who claim to be Locals on the view of
seeking employment” and Memorandum of 1981 which provided
that Certificates will be issued to persons as categorized therein
to enable them to “apply for employment”, no specific mention
of “employment” is made in the introduction to the Notification
of
as
the
purpose
for
obtaining
COI.
The
word
„employment‟ only finds mention in Item No.5, by way of
qualifying the use of COI for that category for the “purpose of
employment only”. Hence, there appears to be substance in the
submissions of the Petitioners that the utility of the COI is not
confined to employment but is for myriad purposes within the
State.
23.
The Notification of 1995 came to be modified by the
Notification of September, 1996, extracted hereunder;
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
HOME DEPARTMENT
No. 57/Home/96
Dated: 27th September, 1996
NOTIFICATION
In partial modification of Notification No.
66/Home/95 dated 22nd November, 1995, the State
Government
hereby
makes
the
following
amendments with immediate effect: In the said Notification for the words,
“Sub-Divisional Officers and Revenue
Officers” wherever they occur, the words
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
“Additional District Collectors” shall be
substituted.
For item 5, the following shall be
substituted, namely:
“5. A person whose father/husband has/had
been in Sikkim Government Service on or
before 31.12.1969 and permanently settled
in Sikkim after his retirement. Certificate of
Identification obtained by such persons shall
be for the purpose of employment only and
for no other purpose”
By order and in the name of the Governor.
CHIEF SECRETARY
(F.NO. 103/90-91/L.R.)
[Emphasis supplied]”
The sentenced added in Item No.5 (supra) further qualified
the sentence of the Notification of 1995 to confine the utility of
COIs obtained by persons at Item No.5 to be for the purpose of
employment
“and
for
no
other
purpose”.
Although
the
Notification of 1981 was confined to Certificates for employment
it treated persons in the categories alike but in the Notification of
1995 which superseded the Memorandum of 1981 no reasons
emanated as to why the utility of the COI has to be limited to
employment for category in Item No.5.
24.
The Home Department vide Notification bearing No.
04/Home/2006, dated 25.01.2006, partially modified Notification
of 1995 as amended in 1996 and authorized the District
Collectors to issue COI only to “direct descendants” of Sikkim
Subject Certificate/COI holders appearing in the present updated
list. That “all other” requests for issuance of COI was to be
forwarded to the Head Office for consideration after completing
field verification as usual.
25.
Following
the
above
actions,
the
Additional
Secretary, Home Department, Government of Sikkim in a
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
communication to the District Collector, East District at Gangtok
while referring to the Office letter of the said Official, bearing
No.861/DCE, dated 10.05.2006, would clarify as follows;
“HOME DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
No:Gos/Home-II/94/14(Part)/2687
Dated:02/06/2006
To,
The District Collector,
East District,
Gangtok.
Sir,
Kindly refer to your office letter No.861/DCE
dated 10/05/2006 seeking clarification as to
whether the Certificate of Identification can be
issued to the grand children of the persons who
were issued with the Certificate of Identification
being in regular Government service prior to
31/12/1969.
I am directed to convey that the third
generation is not covered for issue of COI under
Notification No.66/Home/1995 dated 22/11/1995
and
No.57/Home/1996
dated
27/09/1996.
Therefore, the present practice may continue.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/(D.P. SHARMA)
ADDITIONAL SECRETARY/HOME
[emphasis supplied]”
26.
Another Notification bearing No.119/Home/ 2010,
dated 26.10.2010, partially modified the Notification of 1995
dated 22.11.1995, as amended in 1996. The relevant portion is
extracted below;
“GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
HOME DEPARTMENT
GANGTOK
No. 119/Home/2010
Dated: 26/10/2010
NOTIFICATION
In partial modification of Notification No.
66/Home/95 dated 22nd November, 1995 as
amended vide Notification No. 57/Home/96 dated
27th September, 1996 the State Government
hereby makes the following amendments with
immediate effect:
(1) ……………………………………………………………………….
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
(2) After item 4 the following shall be inserted,
namely:
“4A. A person whose father/husband is/was
eligible for grant of the Certificate of
Identification under any of the categories
listed under items 1 to 4 above, or”
(3) After item 5 the following shall be inserted,
namely:
“Provided that no such Certificate shall be
issued or deemed to have been validly issued
for further issue of COI:(a) On the basis of relationship of father
unless the applicant is or at the
relevant time was the natural legal
descendant of such person.
(b) On the basis of relationship of
husband unless the applicant has
established beyond all reasonable
doubt that she is or at the relevant
time was a citizen of India.
(c)
On the basis of relationship of paternal
grandfather/brother from the same
father unless the applicant has
established beyond all reasonable
doubt that he/she is or at the relevant
time was a citizen of India and
has/had been a resident of the State.”
(4) …………………………………………………………………”
BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE GOVERNOR.
TT Dorji, IAS
Chief Secretary
File No.Home/Confdl./158/1994/2/Part
[emphasis supplied]”
The insertion of 4A supra as canvassed by the Petitioners
perpetuated the eligibility of Item Nos.1 to 4 but excluded Item
No.5.
27.
While carefully walking through the report of the
High Level Committee referred to by the parties, Annexure R-5,
comprising of the Chief Secretary, Director General of Police,
Principal Secretary, Law Department, Principal Secretary, Home
Department, Secretary, Department of Personnel, Administrative
Reforms and Training, Secretary, Land Revenue and Disaster
Management Department, it appears at Paragraph 6 of the
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Report that the Committee had examined all the relevant
Circulars, Memoranda, Notifications and related documents and
arrived at conclusions as detailed in Paragraph 6(a) to 6(d).
convenience,
Paragraph
6(c)
and
6(d)
are
For
extracted
hereinbelow;
“6.
(c)
……………………………………………………………………….
Persons granted COIs under categories 1 to
4 would be classified as „locals‟ and entitled
to various other rights and privileges.
Persons claiming under category 5 have
been given a particular benefit on the basis
of their father or husband having served the
Sikkim government on or before 31.12.1969
and have permanently settled in Sikkim after
retirement. The Notification No.66/Home/95
dated 22nd November, 1995 has created a
distinct category under category 5 which
says “A person whose father/husband has
/had been in Sikkim Government Service on
or before 31.12.1969 and permanently
settled in Sikkim after retirement. ……….”. It
clearly restricts the eligibility to a person
whose father/husband has / had been in
Sikkim Government Service on or before
31.12.1969 and permanently settled in
Sikkim after his retirement and that the
Certificate of Identification obtained by such
persons shall be for the purpose of
employment only for no other purpose.
Therefore, from a plain and simple reading of
the words of the Notification No.66/Home/95
dated 22nd November 1995 as amended,
there is no ambiguity at all and it is very
clearly evident that only the son/daughter
(natural legal descendant) and the wife of a
person who was in Sikkim Government
Service on or before 31.12.1969 and
permanently
settled
in
Sikkim
after
retirement is entitled to get a Certificate of
Identification under category 5 of the said
notification for the purpose of employment
only and for no other purpose. There is
nothing in the official records to suggest or
give
any
indication
that
the
State
Government had any intention whatsoever at
any point of time to extend the benefit of
category 5 to the grandchildren or further
generations of those who were in Sikkim
Government
Service
on
or
before
31.12.1969 and permanently settled in
Sikkim after retirement.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
(d)
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
The Committee has thoroughly examined all
relevant Memoranda, Notifications and other
documents and has come to the conclusion
that the benefits under category 5 of
Notification No 66/Home/95 dated 22nd
November, 1995 as amended are admissible
only to the son/daughter (natural legal
descendant) and the wife of a person who
was in Sikkim Government Service on or
before 31.12.1969 and permanently settled
in Sikkim after retirement and that too for
the purpose of employment only and for no
other purpose. The grandchildren of those
persons who were in Sikkim Government
Service on or before 31.12.1969 are not
entitled for Certificates of Identifications.
[emphasis supplied]”
Evidently, the Committee has looked into the relevant
Memoranda, Notifications and the contents prima facie and from
a “plain and simple” reading of the Notifications arrived at their
decision. They have however failed to examine the reasons for
inclusion of Item No.4 in the Memorandum of 1981 and their
continued inclusion in the Notification of 1995 at Item No.5 and
Notification of 1996 both of which proceeded to limit the utility of
their COI to employment only, while no such restrictions were
introduced for other categories, although in Memorandum of
1981 they were all placed on the same footing, limited as the
purpose was to employment.
No reasons have been given for
the conclusions arrived by the Committee at Paragraph 6(d) of
their Report.
They appear to have per se examined the
documents but their consideration was bereft of examination of
any
relevant
File
or
notings
of
the
various
Government
Departments and the reason for the policy decision of the
Government pertaining to the Memorandum of 1981 and its
supersession by the Notification of 1995.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
28.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Annexure P20 (collectively) an application submitted
by one Motiyas Rai, S/o Shri Meshak Rai, pertaining to issue of
Certificate may relevantly be examined. The note of the Under
Secretary – I (C)/Home after receiving the application reads as
follows;
“……………………………………………………………..
This is regarding representation submitted
by Motiyash Rai of West Sikkim for grant of
Certificate of Identification to the Chief Minister
vide his application placed below at Fag- (sic) A.
Here the following points are submitted for
consideration:
1.
Motiyash Rai is the son of Shri Meshak Rai of
Tinzerbong Block, West Sikkim who is in possession
of Certificate of Identification (COI) issued to him
on the basis of his father‟s COI under provision laid
by Sl. No.5 of the Notification No.66/Home/95
Dated 22nd November, 1995 placed at Flag B
below, read with the amendment notified vide
Notification
No.57/Home/96,
Dated
27th
September, 1996 which provides that COI may be
issued to “A person whose father/husband has/had
been in Sikkim Government Service on or before
31.12.1969 and permanently settled in Sikkim
after retirement. COI obtained by such persons
shall be for the purpose of employment only and
for no other purpose.”
His father was the second generation to be issued
COI under the said provision.
2.
In this connection a letter written by the
then Additional Secretary, Home to the District
Collector, East may be perused at Flag- C which
clearly mentions that the third generation is not
covered for issue of COI under Notification
No.66/Home/95, Dated 22nd November, 1995.
Which means Shri Motiyash Rai, who is the third
generation in this case is also not covered.
3.
The Notification No.66/Home/95 Dated 22nd
November, 1995 was again amended vide
Notification
No.119/Home/
2010,
Dated
26.10.2010 placed below at Flag D which vide sl.
No.3 (c) provides that “On the basis of relationship
of paternal grandfather/ brother from same father
unless the applicant has established beyond all
reasonable doubt that he/ she is or at the relevant
time was a citizen of India and has/had been a
resident of State.”
This has included the third generation;
however it is not clear whether it is application for
the category 5 of the Notification No.66/Home/95
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Dated 22nd November, 1995 as it spells that : “COI
obtained by such persons shall be for the purpose
of employment only and for no other purpose.”
…………………………………………………………………
4.
The application was also examined by the
Law Department vide notes at Nsp 8 ante/-,
whereby they have stated that “While going
through the above clause, it may perhaps be
impliedly inferred that third generation may be
covered under category-5 of the Notification
No.66/Home/95 Dated 22nd November, 1995”. If
this is the case, Motiyash Rai‟s application may be
considered, but it will also entitle all the other such
third generation who may approach the office of
the District Collector for issue of COI on the basis
of their grandfather‟s COI issued under clause 5 of
Notification
No.66/Home/95
Dated
22nd
November, 1995.
Submitted for perusal of higher authorities
and further appropriate action, please.
…………………………………………”
The matter was placed before the Additional Secretary
(C)/Home who has recorded as follows;
“………………………………………………………………..
2.
The question for consideration here is
whether 3rd generation of a person whom COI has
been issued under clause 5 of the Notification
referred to above are eligible for issue of COI
similar to that of his father. It is clarified that COI
under the said clause is issued to those who were
in the regular service of the State Government
prior to 31st December, 1969.
3.
In this connection it is apprised that clause 5
provides for grant of COI to a person whose
father/husband
has/had
been
in
Sikkim
Government service on or before 31.12.1969 and
permanently settled in Sikkim after his retirement.
The point to be understood here is that this clause
does not make mention of paternal grandfather or
the brother from the same father etc. as in clause
2 of the above Notification.
4.
This notification was partially amended vide
Notification NO.119/Home/2010 dated 26.10.2010
whereby a proviso was inserted after clause 5 to
make the first notification more specific and clear
(clause 3 of the said notification may be seen at
flag „c‟).
Sub-clause (c) of the clause 3 of
notification (flag „c‟ below) also speaks of
relationship of paternal grandfather/brother from
the same father etc.
5.
Therefore, the provision of the proviso of
notification (flag „c‟) is not applicable to person who
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
are eligible for grant of COI under clause 5, as the
said clause speaks of father and husband only and
not the paternal grandfather or the brother from
the same father.
6.
In the light of the above interpretation the
3rd generation of a person whom COI has been
issued under clause 5 is not entitle for further issue
of COI.
However, Law Department may kindly see
and advice, please.
………………………………………… [emphasis supplied]”
It thus emerges that varying opinions of Officers of various
Departments interpreted the provisions of the Notification of
1995 and Notification of 2010 as reflected hereinabove, with the
Home Department being opposed to the issuance of COI to the
third generation while the Law Department was of the opinion
that “it may perhaps be impliedly inferred that third generation
may
be
covered
under
category-5
of
the
No.66/Home/95 Dated 22nd November, 1995”.
Notification
The differing
opinions compounded the conundrum whereby it was deemed
essential to seek the views of the Hon‟ble Chairman, Law
Commission, Sikkim.
29.
Hon‟ble Justice R. K. Patra, the then Chairman, Law
Commission opined inter alia as follows on 05.03.2012;
“……………………………………….
However, a policy decision cannot be
arbitrary and must have a rational basis. The point
that needs to be clarified by the authority is on the
point as to how a son whose father is having a
C.O.I. could not be considered for issue of C.O.I.
irrespective of whether he is of third or fourth
generation. If the rule has been designed to put a
stop to such issue of C.O.I. reasons in support of it
must be indicated. The requirement of law is that
there must be reasonable nexus between the
object sought to be achieved and the device or
methodology adopted. In other words it must be
reasonable and not arbitrary.
The authority may clarify the above point.
Based on the clarification if it so warrants the
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
existing provisions may require to be suitably
modified.
For further examination, the querry (sic)
made above be answered.
………………………………………… [emphasis supplied]”
30.
No information was forthcoming to the query made
by the Chairman, Law Commission instead the File meandered in
its path to the Office of the then Learned Advocate General, who
required the Additional Chief Secretary, Home Department to
provide all Notifications along with the relevant File to enable
him to determine the object and intention of the impugned
amendment.
This request too met the fate of stonewalling
inasmuch as the Under Secretary to the Department informed
the Additional Chief Secretary that the File in which the matter
was dealt with in 1995, being F. No.103/90-91/L.R., of the Land
Revenue and Disaster Management was untraceable in the
Department.
The failure or reluctance of the Government to
furnish the File undoubtedly leads to an adverse inference.
Following
this
Bhattacharjee
development,
gave
an
opinion
Hon‟ble
Justice
Bhaskar
divergent
to
of
that
his
predecessor in Office Hon‟ble Justice Patra. Strong reliance was
placed by the State Government on the opinion rendered by
Hon‟ble Shri Justice Bhaskar Bhattacharjee, Chairman, Law
Commission of Sikkim.
However, on careful perusal of his
opinion which was reproduced in the Counter-Affidavit of the
State-Respondents, it contains no reference or specifics as to
why he was of the opinion that the third generation of COI
holder based on Government service should not be issued COI.
He opined as follows;
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
“In order to appreciate the above question,
it will be profitable to refer to the above clause 5
which is quoted below:
5.
A
person
whose
father/husband
has/had been in Government Service on or before
31.12.1969 and permanently settled in Sikkim
after his/her retirement.
On a plain reading of the above clause
manifestly expresses the intention of the State to
give a special type benefit of COI only for seeking
employment in Sikkim Government Service even
though a person does not come within the clause 1
to 4 of the said notification after taking into
consideration the fact that the applicant‟s
father/husband rendered service
to Sikkim
Government on or before 31/12/1969 and after
his/her retirement has permanently settled in
Sikkim.
In the opinion of this Commission, such
special benefit of right to apply for employment in
the Sikkim Government Service notwithstanding
the fact that such person is not otherwise entitled
to have COI should not be extended from
generation to generation. Thus, this Commission is
of the view that the special privilege conferred in
Clause 5 of the above notification should not be
extended any further to the grandchildren of the
former employees mentioned herein.
Let the above view of this Commission be
immediately be communicated to the State
Government.”
It is evident that here too a “plain reading” of the Clauses
was resorted to but with due respect he has not taken into
consideration the Memorandum of 1981 and the subsequent
impugned insertion made in Item No.5 of the Notification of
1995, and Notification of 1996. No details of reasons unfolded as
to why he differed from the opinion of Hon‟ble Justice Patra or
whether
the
reasons
for
prescribing
limitations
vide
the
impugned sentences of the Notifications of 1995 and 1996 were
furnished for his perusal.
31.
From the entirety of facts and circumstances supra
and the discussions hereinabove, although it is submitted by the
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
State-Respondents that insertion of the category in Item No.4 of
the Memorandum of 1981 and Item No.5 of the Notification of
1995 was not prompted by the provisions of the Regulation of
1961, silence resounds on the reasons for such insertion.
No
documents, File notings revealing the reasons for the policy of
the State Government or any other evidence was forthcoming for
the perusal and consideration of this Court. Indubitably after the
merger of Sikkim, the Regulation of 1961 came to be repealed,
despite this circumstance the category in Item No.4 was inserted
in the Memorandum of 1981. In other words, post merger there
was indeed no requirement to include the category but the
State-Respondents in its wisdom did include them.
Once they
have been so included it is indicative of an implied acceptance of
the Petitioners by the Respondent as „Sikkimese‟ and thereby a
legitimate expectation on the part of the Petitioners to be
treated as such.
The State-Respondents‟ contention that it was
a one time concession to that category is unfathomable, since
Rule 4(4) of the Establishment Rules, 1974 already provides for
employment to outsiders if competent candidates were not
available amongst the „Sikkimese‟. It is not the Petitioners‟ case
that the Chogyal had granted them Citizenship nonetheless it
was only their legitimate expectation based on the Regulations of
1961 of becoming „Sikkimese‟, a promise writ large in the
Regulations, the circumstance of merger being unforeseen. Post
merger therefore, it was incumbent upon the State Government
to have addressed the specific case of the non-Sikkimese
Government servants and their status, instead as already stated
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
they were included in the Memorandum of 1981, devoid of any
caveat, which led to an assurance and affirmation of their status
as „Sikkimese‟.
The Memorandum of 1981 is the result of a
Government policy which nowhere elucidates that a one time
concession was extended to the category in Item No.4 of 1981
thereby preparing them for the eventuality of the Notifications of
1995, 1996 and 2010.
The Notification of 1995 being in
supersession of the Memorandum of 1981 effectively replaced its
contents and was a bolt from the blue for the Petitioners who, I
am of the considered opinion, cannot now be short changed by
insertion of qualifying sentences.
It was the argument of the
State-Respondents that in any event the Memorandum of 1981
was only for employment. True that, but when the superseding
Notification was issued no reason emanates for placing Item
No.5 differently from other categories by limiting the use of their
COI to employment while no such restrictions emerge for other
categories.
The argument of Learned Advocate General that
only those persons whose parent‟s names were recorded on or
before 15.05.1975 were „Sikkimese‟, stands belied by the
introduction of the category in Item No.3 in the Memorandum of
1981 for whom neither birth or descent, is mentioned as a
criteria, neither did any cut-off date exist, the only requirement
being possession of agricultural land.
32.
The Supreme Court in Kailash Chand Sharma vs. State
of Rajasthan and Others
expounded that a policy decision should
be free from the ills of arbitrariness and conform to the well10
(2002) 6 SCC 562
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
settled norms both positive and negative underlying Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution which together with Article 15 of the
Constitution form part of the constitutional code of equality.
From the above stated ratio it concludes that a policy decision is
not beyond the pale of judicial review if the policy decision is
taken arbitrarily and fails to satisfy the test of reasonableness.
Concomitant to this principle is the doctrine of legitimate
expectation which is an aspect of Article 14 of the Constitution in
dealing with Citizens in a non-arbitrary matter.
Hotels Private Limited vs. State of Kerala and Others
In Manuelsons
the Supreme
Court held that where an exemption from payment of property
tax was promised by the Government and a consequent
amendment was made in the Statute enabling the Government
to issue an exemption Notification but no such exemption was
granted, non-issuance of the exemption notice is arbitrary and
contrary to the principle of estoppels.
33.
Equality before the law as provided in Article 14 of
the Constitution is a declaration of equality of all persons within
the territory of India, implying thereby the absence of any
special privilege in favour of any individual. The State has the
obligation to take necessary steps so that every individual is
given equal respect and concern which he is entitled to as a
human being [Amita vs. Union of India and Another12].
The
requirement thus is of a nexus between the basis of classification
and the object of the legislation eschewing irrationality.
(2016) 6 SCC 766
(2005) 13 SCC 721
There
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
cannot be undisclosed and unknown reasons for subjecting
individuals to hostile and discriminatory policy.
Although good
faith and knowledge of existing conditions are presumed to be
reasons for State action, it cannot be cloaked with some
undisclosed reasons for discrimination. I hasten to add that the
guarantee of equal protection of law and equality does not
prohibit
the
State
from
creating
classification
but
such
classification is to be founded on intelligible differentia and a
rational relation to the object sought to be achieved. The onus
for this is upon the Respondent, which unfortunately they have
failed to discharge.
This Court is conscious and aware that
policy decisions of the Government are to be tread upon warily
and with circumspection but a policy decision which is subversive
of the doctrine of equality cannot sustain.
This observation
stands augmented by the ratio in Kailash Chand Sharma (supra).
34.
We may now consider the ratio relied on by Learned
Advocate General in Mahabir Vegetable Oils Private Limited
(supra). While buttressing his submissions with the above ratio
Learned Advocate General canvassed that the beneficiary of a
concession has no legally enforceable rights.
It may be
remarked here that the Supreme Court in the said ratiocination
has exposited at Paragraph 29 as follows;
“29. Furthermore, in the fact of the instant
case, it cannot be said that the respondent had
altered its position relying on the promise
inasmuch as even before steps were taken by the
respondent for laying the solvent extraction plant,
the petitioner had made its intention clear through
its notice dated 3-1-1996 that it was likely to
amend the law/Rules in respect whereof a draft
was circulated for information of persons likely to
be affected thereby so as to enable them to file
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
objections and suggestions thereto. Amendments
in the terms of the said draft Rules were notified on
16-12-1996 substituting Schedule III appended to
the Rules whereby and whereunder the solvent
extraction plant was included therein.”
[emphasis supplied]
35.
It
thus
emerges
that
affected
persons
in
the
ratiocination above were sounded about the intention of the
Respondents therein and thereby the claim of prejudice was a
nullity.
In the instant case no notice of intention by the
Government to supersede the Memorandum of 1981 and
thereafter to insert the qualifying sentences in the Notification of
1995, Notification of 1996, interpretation vide Letter dated 0206-2006 and Notification of 2010, was ever made to the
Petitioners or their predecessors. Article 14 of the Constitution
requires the Rule of audi alteram partem, a facet of natural
justice to be adhered to and is the antithesis of arbitrariness.
The maxim mandates that no person shall be condemned
unheard which unfortunately has been given a go-by by the
State-Respondents.
36.
In Smt. Indira Nehru Gandhi vs. Shri Raj Narain13 the
Supreme Court observed as follows;
“564. ………………………….. Indeed, there are
judicial dicta to the effect that God Himself
considered Himself bound by those elementary
principles of justice whose love was planted in man
by Him. In Cooper v. Wandsworth Board of
Works [(1863) 4 CB (NS) 180] Byles, J. observed:
“The laws of God and man both give the
party an opportunity to make his defence, if he has
any. I remember to have heard it observed by a
very learned man, upon such an occasion, that
even God himself did not pass sentence upon Adam
before he was called upon to make his defence.
„Adams‟ (says God), „where art thou? Has thou not
1975 (Supp.) SCC 1
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
eaten of the tree whereof I commanded thee that
thou shouldst not eat?‟ And the same question was
put to Eve also.”
In E. P. Royappa vs. State of Tamil Nadu and Another14 for the
first time a new dimension to Article 14 of the Constitution was
pointed out. The Supreme Court while doing so held as follows;
“85. ……………. The basic principle which,
therefore, informs both Articles 14 and 16 is
equality and inhibition against discrimination. Now,
what is the content and reach of this great
equalising principle? It is a founding faith, to use
the words of Bose. J., “a way of life”, and it must
not be subjected to a narrow pedantic or
lexicographic approach. We cannot countenance
any attempt to truncate its all-embracing scope
and meaning, for to do so would be to violate its
activist magnitude. Equality is a dynamic concept
with many aspects and dimensions and it cannot be
“cribbed, cabined and confined” within traditional
and doctrinaire limits. From a positivistic point of
view, equality is antithetic to arbitrariness. In fact
equality and arbitrariness are sworn enemies; one
belongs to the rule of law in a republic while the
other, to the whim and caprice of an absolute
monarch. Where an act is arbitrary, it is implicit in
it that it is unequal both according to political logic
and constitutional law and is therefore violative of
Article 14, and if it effects any matter relating to
public employment, it is also violative of Article 16.
Articles 14 and 16 strike at arbitrariness in State
action and ensure fairness and equality of
treatment. …………………….”
This view was reiterated in the ratio of Maneka Gandhi vs.
Union of India
of India
and R. D. Shetty vs. International Airport Authority
.
37.
and Others
In Ajay Hasia and Others vs. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi
the Supreme Court held as follows;
“16. …………………………………………..
…………………….. It must therefore now be taken to
be well settled that what Article 14 strikes at is
arbitrariness because any action that is arbitrary,
(1974) 4 SCC 3
(1978) 1 SCC 248
(1979) 3 SCC 489
(1981) 1 SCC 722
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
must necessarily involve negation of equality. The
doctrine of classification which is evolved by the
courts is not paraphrase of Article 14 nor is it the
objective and end of that article. It is merely a
judicial formula for determining whether the
legislative or executive action in question is
arbitrary and therefore constituting denial of
equality. If the classification is not reasonable and
does not satisfy the two conditions referred to
above, the impugned legislative or executive action
would plainly be arbitrary and the guarantee of
equality under Article 14 would be breached.
Wherever therefore there is arbitrariness in State
action whether it be of the legislature or of the
executive or of an “authority” under Article 12,
Article 14 immediately springs into action and
strikes down such State action. In fact, the concept
of reasonableness and non-arbitrariness pervades
the entire constitutional scheme and is a golden
thread which runs through the whole of the fabric
of the Constitution.”
38.
The Government turned a Nelsons eye to the
requirement of Article 14 of the Constitution when arbitrarily
inserting the assailed sentences sans rationale. The casualness
with which a File of importance being F. No.103/90-91/L.R. of
the Land Revenue and Disaster Management which could have
thrown light on the policy decisions and the changes envisaged
has been dealt with by the Government department with
astounding callousness. If, as urged, the Memorandum of 1981
extended a one time concession, the records do not bear out
reasons for extension of such magnanimity nor does the
arbitrary stand in Notification of 1995, Notification of 1996 and
Notification of 2010 stand the test of equity, justice and fair
play.
A belated realization by the State Government of
unintended altruism to the persons by inclusion in Item No.4 of
the Memorandum of 1981, and in Notification of 1995 cannot be
a ground for the qualifying the use of the COI by subsequent
Notifications, bereft of specific reasons. Indeed the inclusions of
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Item No.4 and Item No.5 in 1981 and 1995 respectively appears
to have been made rather late in the day, viz., years after the
appointed day. Nevertheless, can they now cease to be locals by
sleight of an interpretation of a Government servant or for that
matter the High Level Committee who have failed to shed light
on the grounds for the Government policy either way. The State
Government is entitled to amend or rescind a policy decision in
public interest but what the public interest is cannot be shrouded
in mystery.
39.
In conclusion, in consideration of the facts and
circumstances and documents on record and the gamut of
discussions hereinabove, the questions raised supra stand
answered.
40.
In conclusion, it is it is observed and ordered as
follows;
(i)
The
insertion
of
the
sentence
“Certificate
of
Identification obtained by such persons shall be for
the purpose of employment only” appearing in
Notification No.66/Home/95, dated 22.11.1995, and
insertion of the sentence “Certificate of Identification
obtained by such persons shall be for the purpose of
employment
only
appearing
Notification
in
and
for
no
other
purpose”
No.57/Home/96,
dated
27.09.1996, which substituted Item No.5 of the
Notification
No.66/Home/95,
dated
22.11.1995,
being irrational is violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India and deserve to be and are
hereby quashed.
(ii)(a) Letter bearing No.GOS/Home-II/94/14(Part)/2687,
dated 02.06.2006, issued by the Respondent No.2,
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
to
the
effect
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
that,
Item
No.5
of
Notification
No.66/Home/95, dated 22.11.1995 does not entitle
the third generation, i.e., the children of the persons
who were issued Certificate of Identification on the
basis
of
employment
of
their
father
in
the
Government of Sikkim before 31.12.1969 to obtain
COIs, is unconstitutional, abridging the fundamental
rights of the Petitioners guaranteed under Articles 14
and 21 of the Constitution of India and is accordingly
quashed.
(b)
The State-Respondents, their agents and servants
are prohibited from giving effect to letter bearing No.
GOS/Home-II/94/14(Part)/2687, dated 02.06.2006.
(iii)
Insertion
of
Item
No.4A
to
Notification
No.66/Home/95, dated 22.11.1995, below Item No.
and
above
Item
No.5
by
Notification
No.119/Home/ 2010, dated 26.10.2010 which reads;
“4A. A person whose father/husband is/was
eligible for grant of the Certificate of
Identification under any of the categories listed
under items 1 to 4 above, or”
is ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution of India to
the extent that it excludes Item No.5 from the same
benefits as extended to categories in Item Nos. 1 to
4 of the Notification. This being unreasonable and
unconstitutional deserves to be and is accordingly
quashed and set aside.
(iv)
That, descendants of persons who have obtained COI
on the basis of their father being Government
servants in the Government of Sikkim prior to
31.12.1969,
falling
under
Item
No.5
of
the
Notification No.66/Home/95, dated 22.11.1995 and
substituted Item No.5 of Notification of 1996 are
entitled to obtain COI. This also includes the third
generation and their subsequent generations.
WP(C) No.66 of 2016
Yogen Ghatani and Others
(v)
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
The COI obtained by such persons shall have the
same utility and benefits as it does for categories
listed
in
Item
No.66/Home/95,
Nos.1
dated
to
of
the
22.11.1995,
Notification
and
the
Notification No.119/Home/2010, dated 26.10.2010,
sans discrimination on any count.
41.
The State-Respondents shall take necessary steps in
accordance with the aforestated observations.
42.
The Writ Petition stands disposed of accordingly.
43.
No order as to costs.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
20-02-2020
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review