Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010558272007
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3396]
MONDAY, THE 27th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 593/2007
Between:
1. YERASI LAKSHMI DEVI, W/O LATE RAMACHANDRA REDDY
R/O.NATLAKOTTURU VILLAGE, SANJAMALA MANDAL. PRESENTLY
R/O.KOILKUNTA TOWN,
2. YERASI SUDHAKAR REDDY, S/O.LATE RAMACHANDRA REDDY
STUDENT R/O.NATLAKOTTURU VILLAGE, SANJAMALA MANDAL.
PRESENTLY R/O.KOILKUNTA TOWN,
3. YERASI VENKATESWARA REDDY, S/O.LATE RAMACHANDRA
REDDY STUDENT R/O.NATLAKOTTURU VILLAGE, SANJAMALA
MANDAL. PRESENTLY R/O.KOILKUNTA TOWN,
4. YERASI VENKATA SUBBAMMA, W/O.LATE CHINNA VENKATA
REDDY [P2&3 MINORS REP BY THEIR NEXT FRIEND,
GUARDIAN&MOTHER
P1
R/O.NATLAKOTTURU
VILLAGE,
SANJAMALA MANDAL. PRESENTLY R/O.KOILKUNTA TOWN,
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. Y SREENIVASA REDDY, S/OY.VENKATA REDDY OWNER OF
TRACTOR AND TAILER NO.AP 04 B 6286 & 6287 R/O.16/74,
KOILKUNTA TOWN, KURNOOL DISTRICT.
2. M/S ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANGER THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, M/S.ORIENTAL
INSURANCE COMPANY LTD., KURNOOL.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court
IA NO: 2 OF 2007(MACMAMP 11856 OF 2007
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. K NAGA PHANINDRA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. V RAGHU
2. .
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 593/2007
JUDGMENT:
The appellants herein, being the dependents of the deceased, Mr.
Yeresi Rama Chandra Reddy, who died in a motor vehicle accident, filed the
present appeal aggrieved by the award dated 08.11.2006 passed in
M.V.O.P.No.346 of 2004 on the file of the learned Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum-V Additional District Judge, Kurnool at Nandyal (hereinafter
referred to as “the Tribunal”), whereby their claim petition was dismissed.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they were
arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The case of the claimants, in brief, is that on 14.10.2004, at about 6.00
a.m., the deceased and other coolies went to the mines near Kasipuram
Sunkesula and loaded stones into the tractor-trailer and started to return to
Koilkuntla town. When the tractor-trailer bearing No. AP 04 B 6286 and 6287
(hereinafter referred to as “the offending vehicle”) reached near Pedda Kalva
at about 2.00 p.m., the driver of the offending vehicle drove the same in a rash
and negligent manner. In that process, the tyre of the trailer burst and the
trailer got separated, due to which the coolies travelling in the trailer fell down.
The deceased fell in front of the trailer and died on the spot as the rod of the
trailer pressed against him. It is further pleaded that the deceased was aged
about 30 years and was working as a coolie, earning Rs.3,000/- per month.
The 1st petitioner is the wife, petitioners Nos.2 and 3 are the minor children
and the 4th petitioner is the mother of the deceased. Hence, the claimants filed
the claim petition seeking compensation of Rs.2,50,000/- for the death of the
deceased in the said motor vehicle accident.
4.
Respondent No.1, being the owner of the offending vehicle, remained
ex parte before the Tribunal. Respondent No.2-Insurance Company filed its
counter denying the manner of the accident, the rash and negligent driving on
the part of the driver, the age and occupation of the deceased and calling
upon the claimants to prove the same by adducing cogent and reliable
evidence. It was further contended that there was contributory negligence on
the part of the deceased and, therefore, the liability, if any, cannot be fastened
entirely on the respondents. It was also contended that the driver of the
offending vehicle was not holding a valid and effective driving license at the
time of the accident and that the offending vehicle was being used on hire for
transportation of stones, in violation of the terms and conditions of the
insurance policy. It was further contended that the deceased was an
employee of the owner of the offending vehicle and, therefore, the Insurance
Company is not liable to indemnify the owner in respect of the alleged
accident. On the above grounds, respondent No.2 sought for dismissal of the
claim petition.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the learned Tribunal framed the
following issues:
i.
Whether the accident occurred due to rash or negligent driving of
the tractor and trailer bearing No. AP 04 B 6286 and 6287?
ii.
Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation? If so, to
what amount and from which of the respondents?
iii.
6.
To what relief?
Trial went on, during the course of enquiry before the Tribunal, on
behalf of the petitioners, P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.A1 to A5 were
marked. On behalf of the 2nd respondent, its Branch Manager was examined
as R.W.1 and the copy of the policy was marked as Ex.B.1.
7.
The Tribunal, after considering the oral and documentary evidence on
record, dismissed the claim petition, holding that the accident occurred without
any fault on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
8.
Aggrieved by this finding and the dismissal of the claim petition, the
claimants have preferred the present appeal, contending that the Tribunal
failed to appreciate the oral and documentary evidence in proper perspective,
and erroneously concluded that there was no fault on the part of the driver of
the offending vehicle.
9.
Heard Sri K. Naga Phanindra, learned counsel for the appellants, and
Sri V. Raghu, learned Standing Counsel for the respondent-Insurance
Company.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the claimants are the
wife, minor children aged about 11 and 10 years, and the mother of the
deceased; that the deceased, aged about 30 years, was, on 14.10.2004, at
about 6:00 a.m., travelling with other coolies in the tractor bearing No.AP 04 B
6286 and trailer bearing No. AP 04 B 6287; that the driver of the offending
vehicle drove it rashly and negligently, causing the trailer's tyre to burst and
the trailer to detach, throwing the coolies to the ground, the deceased falling in
front of the trailer and dying on the spot; that P.W.2, an eyewitness travelling
in the trailer with the deceased, was the same person who informed the police
of the accident.
11.
Learned counsel further submits that a discrepancy between the F.I.R.
and the petition as to whether the deceased was engaged by one
Bommireddy Chinna Bali Reddy for the tractor belonging to Respondent No.1,
Y. Srinivasa Reddy, or engaged directly by Respondent No.1, as P.Ws.1 and
2 deposed cannot justify dismissal of the claim, though this discrepancy
formed the Tribunal's basis for dismissal. Learned counsel further submits that
the Tribunal observed, based on the charge sheet, that after the trailer
detached, the driver entrusted the task of replacing the tyre to the deceased,
and, while he was doing so, the jack slipped and the trailer fell on him, causing
death; and that the Tribunal dismissed the claim on the ground that the
claimants were not entitled to compensation under Section 163-A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, their own case being that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving, nor under Section 166, on account of the discrepancy noted
above.
12.
Learned counsel further submits that no one was examined to prove the
contents of Ex.A.3, the charge sheet, whereas P.W.2, an eyewitness who
travelled with the deceased, deposed that the trailer detached due to the
driver's negligence in proceeding at high speed, causing them to fall and the
deceased to die; and that the claimants restrict their claim to fastening liability
on the Insurance Company, having received no compensation to date. The
Tribunal,
having
reassessed
just
and
reasonable
compensation
at
Rs.2,16,000/-, nonetheless dismissed the claim, for the reasons stated.
13.
Per contra, learned Standing Counsel for Respondent No.2/Insurance
Company submits that, as per the charge sheet, the accident occurred due to
a negligent act of the driver, but not rash and negligent driving; that, per the
F.I.R., the deceased was engaged by one Bommireddy Chinna Bali Reddy,
not by Respondent No.1; that Respondent No.1, the owner, violated the policy
terms by using the vehicle for commercial purposes, though it was meant for
agricultural and private use; and that, if this Court is inclined to favour the
claimants, pay and recovery may be ordered without fixing liability on the
Insurance Company.
14.
Having regard to the submissions, and on perusal of the material
on record, the burden of proof on claimants in a motor accident claim rests
only on the preponderance of probabilities. P.W.2, the eyewitness present
with the deceased in the offending vehicle, and the F.I.R., given at the earliest
point in time, disclose that the deceased was engaged by Bommireddy Chinna
Bali Reddy, and, as directed by him, was returning with P.W.2 and others at
about 2:00 p.m. when the driver of the tractor drove it rashly and negligently at
high speed, causing the accident; the F.I.R. also identifies Respondent No.1
as the owner of the tractor and trailer, consistent with P.W.2's testimony
before the Tribunal.
15.
The Tribunal discarded the evidence of P.W.2 in light of Ex.A.3, the
charge sheet, though no one was examined to prove its contents. R.W.1, from
the Insurance Company, is not an eyewitness to the accident; P.W.1, the wife
of the deceased, though also not an eyewitness, testified as to his age and
income.
16.
In Raj Kumar Das (D) Thr. Lrs. v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd., 1 the Hon'ble Supreme Court categorically held that a claim under
beneficial legislation cannot be discarded on account of minor procedural
discrepancies, such as delay in reporting to the police, or an incorrect
registration number for the offending vehicle.
17.
In light of this legal position, not every discrepancy in a motor vehicle
claim is fatal to the claimants' case, only a discrepancy going to the root of the
case warrants such treatment, the Motor Vehicles Act being beneficial
legislation intended for the benefit of victims and bereaved families rendered
2026 INSC 541
helpless by the loss of a sole earning member. The discrepancies noted by
the Tribunal do not go to the root of the case, it remains a fact that the
accident occurred and the deceased died in it, as borne out by the police
record, the post-mortem report, and the M.V.I. report, with no suggestion of
mechanical defect, and a police report was filed against the driver of the
tractor.
18.
As rightly pointed out by learned Standing Counsel for the Insurance
Company, there is a clear violation, committed by the owner, regarding the
purpose for which the vehicle was used. The owner did not appear before the
Tribunal or file any counter; his silence would tend to suggest that the vehicle
was meant for agricultural and private use, though the F.I.R. itself shows it
was being used commercially, for loading stone slabs. Ex.B.1 policy, in force
as on the date of the accident, was, accordingly, breached by the owner's
commercial use of the vehicle. In these circumstances, it is appropriate to
direct the Insurance Company to pay the compensation determined by the
Tribunal, as accepted by the appellants, and thereafter recover the same from
the owner, by filing an execution petition directly.
19.
In the result, the MACMA is partly allowed. The award dated 08.11.2006
passed in M.V.O.P.No.346 of 2004 by the learned Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum-V Additional District Judge, Kurnool at Nandyal is set aside to
the extent of dismissal of the claim petition. The claimants are entitled to the
compensation of Rs.2,16,000/- as arrived at by the learned Tribunal, together
with interest at the rate of interest at 7.5% from the date of petition till the date
of realization. Respondent No.2/Insurance Company is directed to pay the
said compensation amount to the claimants in the first instance and thereafter
recover the same from respondent No.1/owner of the offending vehicle in
accordance with law. The claimants shall pay the deficit Court fee, if any.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
_________________________________________
DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
Date: 27.07.2026
UPS
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 593/2007
Dt.27.07.2026
UPS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review