Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Letters Patent Appeal No.9 of 2026
In
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.13946 of 2025
CNR No. BRHC011357392025
======================================================
Yashvant Kumar Choudhary S/o Late Phul Kumar Choudhary, a resident of
Nehara, Darbhanga presently residing at Village- Azraqube Govindpur, P.S.Biraul, District- Darbhanga, State- Bihar, Pin- 847233.
1.
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of
Panchayati Raj, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.
The District Magistrate, Darbhanga.
3.
Senior Deputy Collector-cum-Nodal Officer in the Janta Durbar Programme
of District Magistrate Darbhanga.
4.
The District Panchayati Raj Officer, Darbhanga.
5.
The Sub Divisional Officer, Biraul, District- Darbhanga.
6.
The Anchal Adhikari, Biraul, District- Darbhanga.
7.
The Block Development Officer, Biraul, District- Darbhanga.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Appellant/s
For the Respondent/s
:
:
Mr. Rajni Kant Jha, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR VERMA
ORAL ORDER
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHIR SINGH)
09-10-2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. The present intra court appeal has been preferred
against the judgment dated 02.09.2025 passed in C.W.J.C. No.
13946 of 2025, whereby the writ petition filed by the writpetitioner (appellant herein) came to be dismissed.
3. The appellants preferred the writ petition against
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
2/13
the action of the respondent authorities in undertaking
construction of a Panchayat Bhawan for Dumri Gram Panchayat
over the land claimed by the appellant to be his raiyati land,
appertaining to old Plot No. 6/135 under C.S. Khata No. 48,
corresponding to new Plot No. 40 under R.S. Khata No. 109,
situated at Mauza Azraqbe Gobindpur, Thana No. 273, Anchal
Biraul, District Darbhanga. The appellant claims right and title
over the land through his grandfather, Bhupati Narain
Choudhary, who, along with Mahipat Narain Choudhary, Raj
Kishore Narain Choudhary, Brij Kishore Narain Choudhary and
Nathuni Choudhary, was a co-proprietor of 148 Bigha 4 Kattha
6 Dhur of land of Mahal Azraqbe Gobindpur. It is the case of the
appellant that the land in question formed part of the aforesaid
estate and was the subject matter of Partition Case No. 342 of
1923–24, wherein, by order dated 15.12.1924, the Revenue
Officer, upon local inspection, categorised the land as Bakasht
land and assessed rent at the rate of Rs. 10 per bigha. The
appellant further asserts that, during the revisional survey, the
said land was assigned new Plot No. 40 under R.S. Khata No.
109, wherein it was recorded as “Anabad Bihar Sarkar”,
although its nature was described as Dhanhar and the remarks
column recorded the possession of the appellant’s father, Phul
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
3/13
Kumar Choudhary.
4. It is further the case of the appellant that the State
authorities, pursuant to the order passed in R.F. Case No. 12 of
1990–91, opened Jamabandi No. 70 in the name of his father,
Phul Kumar Choudhary, in respect of 16 Bigha 3 Kattha 7 Dhur
of land situated at Mauza Azraqbe Gobindpur, which included 2
Bigha 3 Kattha 9 Dhur 8 Dhurki of the land appertaining to old
Plot No. 6/135. Subsequently, during the year 2000–01, the
aforesaid jamabandi was divided, resulting in the creation of
Jamabandi No. 70/72 in the name of the appellant’s father and
Jamabandi No. 71/73 in the name of the appellant, each
comprising 8 Bigha 1 Kattha 13.5 Dhur of land, including 1
Bigha 1 Kattha 14 Dhur 12 Dhurki of the disputed plot. The
appellant claims that his father had been paying rent since
16.03.1991 and that he himself had been paying rent since
25.08.2000, with rent receipts having been issued by the State
authorities up to the financial year 2024–25.
5. The grievance of the appellant is that, upon
learning that the respondent authorities had demarcated the
disputed land for construction of a Panchayat Bhawan for
Dumri Gram Panchayat, he submitted a representation dated
03.06.2025 before the District Collector, Darbhanga, seeking
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
4/13
protection of his alleged raiyati land. Thereafter, on 23.06.2025,
he submitted an online application before the Janta Durbar of
the District Magistrate, Darbhanga, but was advised by the
Nodal Officer, by letter dated 03.07.2025, to institute a partition
suit. The appellant further alleges that, on 24.06.2025, the
Anchal Adhikari, Biraul, accompanied by police personnel,
arrived at the disputed land while he was carrying out
agricultural
activities
and
threatened
him
with
dire
consequences unless he vacated the land. According to the
appellant, he was thereby compelled to leave the land, following
which construction of the Panchayat Bhawan commenced
thereon. It is contended that the respondent authorities neither
issued any prior notice to him nor initiated any land acquisition
proceedings or other appropriate legal proceedings before
dispossessing him and commencing construction.
6. Aggrieved by the aforesaid action, the appellant
approached this Court by filing the writ petition, which came to
be dismissed by observing as follow:
"8. Now, I come to the present matter.
The main relief which the petitioner has sought
for is to restrain the construction of the building
of Panchayat Bhawan upon his land pertaining
to Khata No. 48 (old)/109 (new), Khesra No.
6/135 (old)/40 (new), Raqba 1 acre 76 decimal,
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
5/13
Mauza - Azraqbe Govindpur, Anchal - Biraul,
District - Darbhanga, and restore his possession
over the land in question. In view of these
prayers, it is prima facie evident that the
petitioner has no possession over the land in
question. The petitioner has based his claim
mainly on the basis of the land in question being
recorded as Gairmajarua Khas in C.S. Khatiyan
and deeming the land in the category of Bakasht
land by the Revenue Officer. However, it is a
settled proposition of law that revenue records
are not considered documents of title, and mere
entries in the revenue records or issuance of
rent receipts do not create one's title nor divest
the real title owner of a land of his right, title,
and interest in the land. It is an admitted
position that the land in question is presently
recorded as Anabad Bihar Sarkar in RS
Khatiyan, which was prepared several years
ago, and the nature of the said land is described
as Dhanhar, and in the remarks column, the said
land has been shown to be in illegal possession
of Phul Kumar Choudhary, the father of the
petitioner. The petitioner has not satisfied this
Court as to why he has not taken steps to get the
land in question entered in his name in the
revenue records by using the legal recourse.
However, such complex question which requires
evidences should be examined by the concerned
revenue court/civil court if the petitioner
approaches them. Accordingly, I am of the view
that the petitioner has not made out a case for
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
6/13
invoking the writ jurisdiction of this Court, and
the circumstances pointed out by him are not
persuading this Court to invoke the writ
jurisdiction to decide the main issue raised by
the petitioner by bypassing the efficacious legal
remedies
which
are
available
to
him.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands
rejected.
9. The petitioner will have the liberty
to approach the concerned court/forum for
redressing his grievance relating to the alleged
civil wrong/wrong. If the petitioner avails of the
liberty, then the concerned court/forum will
decide his prayer without being prejudiced by
this judgment according to merit. It is clarified
that the aforesaid observations made by this
Court in respect of the petitioner's issue will not
affect the merit of the issue if he raises the same
before any competent court/forum."
7. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant submits that the learned Single Judge has failed to
appreciate that the appellant was forcibly dispossessed from the
land in question on 24.06.2025 by the Anchal Adhikari, Biraul,
with the assistance of the police force, without any authority of
law or adherence to the due process of law, thereby violating his
constitutional right to property guaranteed under Article 300A of
the Constitution of India. It is submitted that the appellant’s title
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
7/13
and possession over the land are supported by the order passed
in Partition Case No. 342 of 1923–24, the relevant revisional
survey khatiyan, and the jamabandis created in the names of the
appellant and his predecessor-in-interest, pursuant to which rent
has been regularly paid to and accepted by the State authorities.
Learned counsel further submits that, despite the State having
accepted rent and issued rent receipts in respect of the land in
question, the respondent authorities could not have dispossessed
the appellant or commenced construction of the Panchayat
Bhawan without issuing prior notice or initiating appropriate
legal proceedings for acquisition or eviction. It is submitted that
the learned Single Judge has rejected the writ petition by
misreading the materials on record and misapplying the settled
principles of law, and that the impugned order, as well as the
action of the respondent authorities, is arbitrary, illegal and
unsustainable in law. Learned counsel, therefore, prays that the
impugned order be set aside and appropriate relief be granted to
the appellant.
8. The limited issue which arises for consideration
before this Court is as to whether the order passed by the
learned Single Judge suffers from any illegality, perversity or
infirmity warranting interference in the appellate jurisdiction of
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
8/13
this Court.
9. Having considered the submissions advanced on
behalf of the party and upon perusal of the materials available
on record, we find that the learned Single Judge has declined to
entertain the writ petition primarily on the ground that the
dispute raised by the appellant involves disputed questions of
title and possession which cannot appropriately be adjudicated
in the exercise of writ jurisdiction. While the appellant relies
upon the order passed in Partition Case No. 342 of 1923–24, the
jamabandis standing in the names of the appellant and his
predecessor-in-interest, and the rent receipts issued by the State
authorities, the revisional survey khatiyan records the land in
question as “Anabad Bihar Sarkar”, with its nature described as
“Dhanhar” and the possession of the appellant’s father recorded
in the remarks column as illegal. In these circumstances, the
determination
of
the
appellant’s
claim
would
require
examination of the relevant revenue records and other evidence
to ascertain the nature of his right, title and possession over the
disputed land, including the legality of the possession claimed
by him.
10. It is well settled that entries in revenue records
and the payment or acceptance of rent, by themselves, do not
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
9/13
confer title to immovable property. In Jitendra Singh v. State of
Madhya Pradesh, reported in. 2021 SCC OnLine SC 802, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated that mutation entries do not
create or extinguish title and that disputes concerning title are
required to be adjudicated by the competent civil court. The
relevant portion of the said order reads as follows:
“6. ..Be that as it may, as per the settled
proposition of law, mutation entry does
not confer any right, title or interest in
favour of the person and the mutation
entry in the revenue record is only for
the fiscal purpose. …”
11. Similarly, in State of Rajasthan v. Bhawani
Singh, reported in 1993 Supp (1) SCC 306, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court recognised that disputed questions of title
ordinarily cannot be satisfactorily determined in proceedings
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The relevant
portion of the said order reads as follows:
“7. Having heard the counsel for the
parties, we are of the opinion, that the
writ petition was misconceived insofar
as it asked for, in effect, a declaration
of writ petitioner's title to the said
plot. It is evident from the facts stated
hereinabove that the title of the writ
petitioner is very much in dispute.
Disputed question relating to title
cannot be satisfactorily gone into or
adjudicated in a writ petition.”
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
10/13
12. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of
the present case, we find that the appellant’s claim to ownership
and lawful possession cannot be conclusively determined
merely on the basis of the documents relied upon by him in the
writ proceedings, particularly when the revenue records
themselves raise a question regarding the nature and legality of
such possession.
13. We are, however, conscious of the settled position
of law that the State cannot deprive a person of his property
except by authority of law. In Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal
Pradesh, reported in (2020) 2 SCC 569, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that forcible dispossession from private property
without following due process of law violates the constitutional
protection guaranteed under Article 300A. The relevant portion
of the said order reads as follows:
“12.2. The right to property ceased to
be a fundamental right by the
Constitution
(Forty-Fourth
Amendment) Act, 1978, however, it
continued to be a human right
[Tukaram Kana Joshi v. MIDC] in a
welfare State, and a constitutional
right under Article 300-A of the
Constitution. Article 300-A provides
that no person shall be deprived of his
property save by authority of law. The
State cannot dispossess a citizen of his
property except in accordance with
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
11/13
the procedure established by law. The
obligation to pay compensation,
though not expressly included in
Article 300-A, can be inferred in that
Article.
12.3. To forcibly dispossess a person
of his private property, without
following due process of law, would
be violative of a human right, as also
the constitutional right under Article
300-A of the Constitution. ..”
14. Nevertheless, the applicability of this principle in
the present case would depend upon the determination of the
appellant’s legally enforceable rights over the disputed land and
the circumstances in which possession was allegedly taken.
Equally, the appellant cannot claim a legal right to retain
possession merely on the basis of the jamabandis or rent
receipts if such possession is ultimately found to be
unauthorised. The competing claims regarding title and the
legality of possession would, therefore, require adjudication by
the competent court or forum on the basis of the evidence
available.
15. We further find that the learned Single Judge has
not adjudicated the appellant’s claim on its substantive merits or
returned any conclusive finding negating his alleged right, title
or possession over the disputed land. Rather, the appellant has
expressly been granted liberty to approach the competent court
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
12/13
or forum for redressal of his grievance, with a specific
clarification that the observations made in the impugned order
shall not prejudice the adjudication of his claim on merits.
16. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances,
we find that the learned Single Judge has adopted a legally
permissible course in declining to adjudicate the disputed
questions of title and possession in the exercise of writ
jurisdiction. No illegality, perversity or infirmity is made out in
the impugned order warranting interference by this Court in its
appellate jurisdiction. The issue framed is therefore, answered
against the appellant.
17. Accordingly, the present intra court appeal stands
dismissed.
18. It goes without saying that the appellant would be
at liberty to avail himself of the remedy so reserved, and the
competent court or forum shall independently examine his
claim, including the nature and legality of his possession and the
legality of the action taken by the respondent authorities, in
accordance with law and on the basis of the evidence placed
before it, uninfluenced by the observations made in the
impugned order.
19. It is clarified that, for the purpose of availing the
Patna High Court L.P.A No.9 of 2026(3) dt.09-10-2026
13/13
appropriate remedy before the competent court or forum, the
period of limitation shall commence from the date of the present
order, in view of the fact that the appellant has been bona fide
pursuing his grievance before this Court. The aforesaid
clarification is made keeping in view the principle underlying
Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which provides for
exclusion of the period spent in bona fide prosecution of
proceedings before a court unable to entertain the same on
account of a defect of jurisdiction or other cause of a like nature.
20. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(Sudhir Singh, J)
( Rajesh Kumar Verma, J)
Gaurav
Sinha/RajeshU
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review