Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010425772025
2026:CGHC:39210
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 11957 of 2025
Yashashvi Pansari S/o Ramkrishna Pansari, Aged About 30 Years R/o
Malsay Talab Road, Near Veer Chhatrapati Shivaji School, Dantehwari
Kirana Store, Kushalpur, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.) 492001
... Petitioner
versus
1 - The State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of
Skill Development, Technical Education And Employment, Nawa
Raipur, Atal Nagar, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Director, Employment And Training, (Training Side) Directorate,
Indrawati Bhawan, Block-4, First Floor, Nawa Raipur, Atal Nagar,
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Chhattisgarh Professional Examination Board, Through Controller
Of Examination, Vyapam Bhawan, North Block, Sector-19, Nawa
Raipur, Atal Nagar, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Rishikant Mahobia, Advocate.
For Respondents No.1 & 2/State :
Mr. DR Minj, Dy. Advocate General.
For Respondent No.3
Mr. Avinash Singh, Advocate.
:
Hon’ble Shri Justice Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi, J
Order on Board
(03rd September, 2026)
The petitioner has filed the instant petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India seeking the following relief:
“10.1 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to quash
the impugned order dated 04.09.2025 (Annexure P/1)
passed by the respondent No. 2.
10.2 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to direct the
respondent authorities specifically respondent No. 2 to
consider the experience certificate of the petitioner as
submitted by the petitioner according to eligibility criteria
mentioned in the advertisement for the post of Training
Officer, Mechanic Motor Vehicle (Trade).
10.3 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to direct the
respondent authorities specifically respondent No. 2 to
give appointment to the petitioner for the post of Training
Officer, Mechanic Motor Vehicle (Trade) in the OBC,
Category.
10.4 That, Hon'ble Court may kindly be further direct the
respondent No. 2, not to issue offer letter/recruitment
letter/appointment order to the OBC Candidate for
appointment to the post of Training Officer, Mechanic
Motor Vehicle (Trade) in the OBC, Category.
10.5 Any other relief, deem fit in the present facts and
circumstances of this case may also be awarded to the
petitioner.”
2.
Facts of the case, in brief, are that respondent No.2/Director,
Employment and Training, Raipur issued an advertisement dated
5.5.2023, which was published in the daily newspaper on 6.5.2023, for
filling up various posts of Training Officers in Govt. Industrial Training
Institutes including five posts of Training Officer, Mechanic Motor
Vehicle. Subsequently, amended advertisement was issued on
13.5.2023 wherein the total post of Training Officer, Mechanic Motor
Vehicle, was enhanced from five to seven, out of which one was
reserved for OBC category candidate. The petitioner, who possessed
Bachelor of Engineering degree in Mechanical Branch from CG Swami
Vivekanand Technical University, Bhilai and belongs to OBC category,
submitted his application for the post of Training Officer, Mechanic
Motor Vehicle. Since the petitioner was a degree holder, therefore, as
per the advertisement, he was required to have at least one year
teaching experience in the concerned trade/faculty. The petitioner
accordingly submitted the experience certificate also which shows that
he had 22 months teaching experience in Shri Sai Polytechnic,
Nandini, Durg in the required Trade. The petitioner successfully
participated in the written examination and secured 94.5 marks out of
100. He thereafter appeared in the counseling and was issued
appointment letter dated 18.8.2023 by respondent No.2. However,
during the course of further documents verification, the petitioner’s
appointment was cancelled on the ground that his experience
certificate is not as per requirement of the advertisement.
2.1
Being aggrieved, the petitioner preferred a writ petition i.e. WPS
No.6847/2023, challenging cancellation of his appointment by
respondent No.2 on the post of Training Officer, Mechanic Motor
Vehicle. This Court vide order dated 14.9.2023 disposed of the said
petition permitting the petitioner to submit a detailed representation
before respondent No.2/Director, within two days, which, in turn, shall
be decided by respondent No.2 within seven days from the date of
receipt of copy of such representation. Accordingly, the petitioner
submitted a representation with all the relevant documents including
the experience certificate before respondent No.2 on 15.9.2023.
However, vide order/memo dated 21.9.2023 his representation was
rejected. The petitioner then filed a writ petition i.e. WPS No.8069/2023
before this Court which, along with other connected writ petitions, was
disposed of and the impugned order was quashed vide order dated
13.11.2024. This Court granted 30 days time to the respondent
authorities to scrutinize the candidature of the petitioners with regard to
their suitability. In compliance of the said order, the petitioner submitted
a representation on 21.11.2024 and when the same was not decided
as per order dated 13.11.2024, he filed a contempt petition i.e.
Contempt Case (C) No.1167/2025. However, during pendency of the
contempt petition, the petitioner was served with the impugned order
dated 4.9.2025 by which his representation has been rejected on the
ground that in the said college/institution where the petitioner was
teaching, there were total 20 employees and therefore, the institution
should have deducted EPF of the employees but no such document
has been placed on record by the petitioner before the Committee.
Hence this petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that candidature
of the petitioner was earlier rejected by the respondent authorities on
the ground that the petitioner failed to produce online salary slip but the
said objection raised by the department has been rejected by this
Court vide order dated 13.11.2024 passed in WPS No.8069/2023 filed
by the petitioner and other connected cases. In the earlier rejection
order, the respondent authorities did not raise objection that the
petitioner has not submitted EPF certificate issued by the concerned
college/institution. He submits that non-production of EPF certificate
will not affect the case of the petitioner because there is no fault of the
petitioner/employee and it is the duty of the employer to deduct EPF.
He submits that the experience certificate submitted by the petitioner
was duly verified by the respondent authorities and they raised this
issue only after this Court quashed the earlier rejection order in WPS
No.8069/2023 vide order dated 13.11.2024 wherein it is held that the
mode of payment of salary cannot be a ground for rejecting the
candidature of the petitioner.
He submits that the action of the
respondent authorities in rejecting the candidature of the petitioner on
successive, irrelevant grounds amounts to arbitrariness and hostile
discrimination, violating Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.
Neither the advertisement nor the recruitment Rules of 2014 (amended
Rules, 2019) stipulate EPF deduction as a condition for recognition of
experience. Hence the said ground is arbitrary and contrary to the
recruitment scheme. Learned counsel further submits that since the
petitioner has obtained degree of Bachelor of Engineer (Mechanical)
vide Annexure P/2, therefore, as per Chhattisgarh Industrial Training
(Non-Gazetted) Class-III Service Recruitment Rules, 2014 (in short
“Recruitment Rules”) and amendment made in the rules vide
Notification
dated
15.5.2019
(Annexure
P/18),
the
experience
certificate submitted by the petitioner (pages 66 & 71 of the petition)
issued by Shri Sai Polytechnic, Nandini Road, Durg, is valid for the
purpose of teaching experience required for the post of Training Officer,
Mechanic Motor Vehicle. Therefore, he prays that this petition may be
allowed and the relief sought for be granted to the petitioner.
4.
The respondents/State has filed its reply. Learned counsel for the
State, referring to its reply, would submit that though the petitioner
obtained decree of Bachelor of Engineer (Mechanical) but the
Committee while considering the experience certificate (Annexure P/8,
pages 66 & 71 of the petition), found that the petitioner applied for the
post of Training Officer, Mechanic Motor Vehicle whereas his
experience certificate is not of the relevant Trade. Therefore, in the first
round of counseling, the candidature of the petitioner was rightly
rejected by the Committee. Thereafter, in compliance of the order
passed by this Court, respondent No.2 initiated proceeding for deciding
the representation of the petitioner. The meeting of the Selection
Committee was held on 7.4.2025 where upon examination of the
testimonials/documents of the petitioner, it was found that the petitioner
did not submit the EPF certificate along with experience certificate.
Therefore, by the impugned order (Annexure P/1), his representation
has rightly been rejected. He submits that the present petition has no
substance at all and therefore, the same is liable to be dismissed.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.3 has supported
the contention raised by learned State counsel.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
7.
Undisputedly, the petitioner possessed decree of Bachelor of
Engineer (Mechanical). As per contention of the State counsel, the
Selection Committee found that the Trade of the petitioner is Mechanic
Tractor. When a specific question was posed to the State as to from
which document, on the basis of degree or experience certificate filed
by the petitioner, his experience was treated as of Mechanic Tractor
Trade, the State counsel could not apprise the Court from the record as
to on which basis the experience of the petitioner was held to be of
Mechanic Tractor Trade whereas the experience certificate (Annexure
P/8, pages 66 & 71 of the petition) filed by the petitioner shows that he
has teaching experience in Mechanical Engineering Trade from
6.1.2020 to 30.11.2021 i.e. for more than one year, as has been
required by the respondents in the advertisement from the candidates
having degree, which the petitioner has.
8.
As per Table – Relevancy of the Branches (Academic
Qualification) Government Industrial Training Institutes, appended to
Schedule III (See rule 8) of the Chhattisgarh Industrial Training (NonGazetted) Class-III Service Recruitment Rules, 2014, published in
Chhattisgarh Gazette on 15.10.2014, the relevant branches for
recruitment of Training Officer in Govt. ITI, have been contemplated.
Sl.No.9 of the said Table prescribes the relevant core branch, relevant
branch for Degree Engineering/Technology and relevant branch for
Diploma Engineering/Technology for the post of Training Officer
(Mechanic Motor Vehicle, Mechanic Diesel, Mechanic Tractor, Drivercum-mechanic), which reads as under:
Relevant Branches for Recruitment of Training Officer in Government Industrial
Training Institutes
S.N. Name of Service
or Post
(1)
9.
(2)
Relevant
Relevant Branch for
Relevant Branch for
Core Branch
Degree Engineering/
Diploma Engineering/
Technology
Technology
(4)
(5)
(3)
Training Officer Mechanical
Mechanical
in
Mechanical
(Mechanic Motor Engineering
Engineering (Industry Engineering,
Mechanical
Vehicle,
Integrated),
Engineering
(Industry
Mechanic Diesel,
Mechanical
Integrated),
Mechanical
Mechanic
Engineering
Engineering
(Sandwich
Tractor,
Driver-
cum-mechanic
(Sandwich
Diploma
Pattern), Pattern),
Mechanical
Engineering,
Engineering
(Repair Engineering
Mechanical
Mechanical
and Maintenance)
(Maintenance),
Mechanical
Engineering
(Repair and Maintenance)
9.
The
Recruitment
Rules
specifically
prescribe
Mechanical
Engineering as the relevant core branch/trade for the post of Training
Officer
(Mechanic
Motor
Vehicle/Mechanic
Diesel/Mechanic
Tractor/Driver-cum-Mechanic). The petitioner admittedly possesses a
bachelor degree in Mechanical Engineering branch. Therefore, the
basic academic qualification possessed by the petitioner satisfies the
prescribed requirement.
10.
So far as the experience certificate of the petitioner is concerned,
the same could not have been rejected merely by describing it as
experience certificate of "Mechanic Tractor" Trade. The petitioner's
experience certificate records teaching experience in Mechanical
Engineering from 06.01.2020 to 30.11.2021, i.e. for more than one
year, which satisfies the one-year teaching experience requirement
mentioned in the advertisement. The respondents have failed to
demonstrate from any provision of the Recruitment Rules or the
advertisement as to why such experience should be treated as
experience only in the "Mechanic Tractor" trade. In fact, when
specifically questioned by the Court, the State could not identify the
document or provision on the basis of which the petitioner's experience
was so classified. The respondents cannot, by introducing successive
conditions, impose a requirement that was neither stipulated in the
advertisement nor prescribed under the applicable Recruitment Rules.
EPF deduction/EPF certificate was not prescribed either in the
advertisement or in the applicable Recruitment Rules as a mandatory
condition for recognition of teaching experience. The petitioner,
therefore, could not have been disqualified for non-production of an
EPF certificate when such requirement was not part of the notified
eligibility criteria. The petitioner's case records that the respondents
themselves had earlier rejected him on a different ground and, after
that rejection was set aside, proceeded to raise the EPF issue.
11.
The conduct of the respondents in rejecting the candidature on
successive grounds assumes significance. Initially, the petitioner's
candidature was questioned on the issue of salary slip/payment;
thereafter, another ground concerning EPF was introduced. If the
experience certificate had already been verified and no such
requirement was stipulated in the governing recruitment scheme, the
respondents could not adopt a shifting stand to defeat the petitioner's
candidature. Such action would amount to gross arbitrariness and
unfairness in the recruitment process, offending Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution. Even assuming that the institution employed 20 or
more persons and was required to comply with EPF law, any failure on
the part of the employer to make EPF deductions cannot, by itself, lead
to the conclusion that the petitioner did not actually render teaching
service. The relevant question for recruitment purposes is whether the
petitioner possesses the requisite teaching experience in the relevant
branch, and not whether his employer complied with its statutory EPF
obligations.
12.
For the aforesaid reasons, the impugned order dated 04.09.2025
(Annexure P/1) is hereby set aside/quashed. The petitioner’s teaching
experience in Mechanical Engineering from 06.01.2020 to 30.11.2021
shall be treated as relevant experience and cannot be rejected merely
for want of an EPF certificate. The respondents shall reconsider the
petitioner’s candidature for the post of Training Officer (Mechanic Motor
Vehicle), OBC category, in accordance with the Recruitment Rules, his
merit and available vacancy, and if found otherwise eligible,
appointment order for the said post shall be issued in his favour. This
exercise shall be completed expeditiously, preferably within a period of
two months from the date of passing of this order. No order as to costs.
13.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands allowed to the extent
indicated herein-above.
14.
Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
Digitally signed
MOHD
MOHD by
AKHTAR KHAN
AKHTAR Date:
2026.09.09
KHAN
16:31:52
+0530
Khan
Sd/
(Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review