Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:11110
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ORDER RESERVED ON 06.02.2026
ORDER DELIVERED ON 03.03.2026
ORDER UPLOADED ON 03.03.2026
MCRC No. 10536 of 2025
1 - Yash Purohit S/o Nitesh Purohit Aged About 31 Years R/o B-1, Mukta
Sadan, In Front Of Goyal Nursing Home, Samta Colony, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Applicant (s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through ACB/ EOW, District Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Applicant (s)
:
Shri Manoj Paranjape, Sr. Counsel
assisted by Shri Gagan Tiwari, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Shri Praveen Das, Dy. GA
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Arvind Kumar Verma)
C A V Order
The instant application has been preferred by the applicant under
Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, seeking
the grant of regular bail in connection with Crime No. 04/2024,
registered at the Anti-Corruption Bureau/Economic Offences Wing,
Raipur, pertaining to offences punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468,
471, and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, as well as Sections 7 and 12
of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The applicant impugns the legality
and propriety of the order dated 15.12.2025 passed by the learned
Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption Act), Raipur, whereby his bail
application was rejected, prompting the filing of the present first bail
application before this Hon'ble Court.
FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
In brief, the prosecution's case stems from search and seizure
operations conducted by the Income Tax Department from 26.02.2020
to 01.03.2020 at multiple premises across the State of Chhattisgarh.
During the ensuing inquiry, statements of several individuals were
recorded, leading to allegations of an organized "liquor syndicate"
operating within the State. This syndicate is alleged to have illicitly
collected funds through manipulation of the excise administration and
unauthorized liquor sales. Consequently, on 18.11.2022, the Directorate
of Enforcement registered an ECIR invoking scheduled offences.
Following communication from the Enforcement Directorate dated
11.07.2023 under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, the
Economic Offences Wing, Raipur, registered FIR No. 04/2024 dated
17.01.2024 against several accused, including the present applicant, for
offences under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, and 120-B of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860, and Sections 7 and 12 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988.The prosecution alleges the existence of a criminal
syndicate involving public servants, private persons, and intermediaries,
which purportedly generated illegal gains from the liquor trade through
modalities such as commissions from suppliers, off-the-record sales via
State-run outlets and annual payments for operational permits. These
proceeds are claimed to have been laundered through layered
channels, including associates and linked business establishments.
3.
The present applicant's name figures in the FIR as one among
several accused persons, albeit without attribution of any specific role in
the initial registration. During the course of investigation, however, the
prosecution asserts to have unearthed material ostensibly indicating that
illicit funds emanating from the alleged syndicate's operations were
channelized,
managed,
and
dissimulated
through
entities
and
establishments associated with the applicant's family business. It is
further alleged that the applicant played a facilitative role in the storage,
transportation, and handling of such proceeds linked to the purported
illegal activities.
4.
The investigation into the matter has been protracted and
multifaceted. The prosecution agency submitted its inaugural final report
before the learned Special Court on 01.07.2024, arraigning a multitude
of accused persons and proposing an extensive roster of witnesses.
This was followed by successive supplementary final reports at varied
intervals, incrementally broadening the ambit of the case by impleading
additional accused, including excise officials and private individuals
purportedly complicit in the scheme, alongside an ever-expanding list of
prosecution witnesses.
5.
Notably, the process of filing supplementary charge-sheets
persisted unabated, with further reports tendered on 27.06.2025,
30.06.2025, 07.07.2025, and as recently as 24.08.2025. These iterative
filings have progressively amplified the scope of the prosecution
narrative, incorporating fresh accused persons and witnesses, thereby
underscoring the evolving and expansive nature of the investigation
even at this advanced stage.
6.
The applicant had earlier assailed the very registration of the FIR
before this Court, wherein interim protection from coercive action was
graciously granted vide order dated [Cr.M.P. No. 1286 of 2024 dated
20.05.2024]. Though the said petition was ultimately dismissed, the
applicant thereafter approached the Apex Court by way of Special
Leave Petition (Criminal) Nos 14901-14904 of 2024, wherein interim
protection was extended, safeguarding him from arrest during the
pendency of those proceedings. The Apex Court, in its wisdom,
dismissed the SLP while reserving liberty to the applicant to seek
appropriate remedies in accordance with law, explicitly directing that no
prejudice shall be occasioned by any observations made in the earlier
proceedings. This underscores the absence of any adverse finding
against the applicant at the highest judicial forum, thereby reinforcing
the prima facie tenability of his present plea. Pursuant to the directions
emanating from these superior court proceedings, the applicant dutifully
presented himself before the investigating agency in January 2025 and
extended full cooperation throughout the inquiry process. Subsequently,
summons under Section 160 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 (corresponding to Section 160 Cr.P.C.) were issued,
mandating his appearance. In compliance therewith, the applicant
appeared before the investigating officer on 19.09.2025, at which
juncture he was abruptly taken into custody in connection with the
instant crime, despite his unwavering cooperation and absence of any
flight risk or tampering propensity.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT
7.
Shri Paranjape, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
applicant, while assailing the impugned order dated 15.12.2025 passed
by the learned Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption Act), Raipur,
submits that the rejection of bail suffers from non-consideration of
settled principles governing grant of bail, particularly in cases involving
prolonged
investigation,
voluminous
charge-sheets
and
delayed
commencement of trial. The submissions advanced on behalf of the
applicant are summarized hereunder.
I. Prolonged Incarceration and Violation of Article 21 of the
Constitution
8.
It is submitted that the applicant was arrested on 19.09.2025,
and has since remained in judicial custody. Investigation insofar as the
present applicant is concerned stands completed, and the 6 th
Supplementary Final Report dated 24.11.2025 has already been filed
before the learned Special Court arraying him as an accused.
9.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the prosecution
case now stands crystallized through one main final report and
multiple supplementary final reports, involving
52 accused
persons, reliance on nearly one thousand documents, and citation
of more than eleven hundred witnesses. In such circumstances,
commencement and conclusion of trial in the near future is practically
inconceivable. It is emphasized that till date charges have not been
framed, and proceedings remain at the stage of scrutiny of voluminous
records. The delay in trial is wholly institutional and cannot be attributed
to the present applicant. Therefore, continued incarceration of the
applicant, without likelihood of early trial, amounts to punitive detention
prior to conviction, offending the constitutional mandate of personal
liberty under Article 21.
10.
It is argued that the criminal justice system does not permit
indefinite detention pending trial, particularly where investigation is
complete and the accused is no longer required for custodial
interrogation. Reliance is placed upon judicial precedents wherein the
Apex Court has consistently held that prolonged incarceration and delay
in trial are relevant and weighty considerations for grant of bail, even in
serious economic offences, once investigation is complete.
II.
Parity with Co-Accused Granted Bail
11.
A substantial plank of the applicant’s case rests on the doctrine of
parity. He submits that a large number of co-accused persons, against
whom allegations are either similar or substantially graver, have already
been granted bail either by the Apex Court or by this Court. It is pointed
out that persons alleged to have played pivotal roles in the alleged
syndicate
operations,
including
those
entrusted
with
collection,
distribution and management of funds, as well as officials and private
intermediaries allegedly instrumental in execution of the scheme, have
already been enlarged on bail.
12.
Illustratively, bail has been granted to several accused persons
who were alleged to have been involved in collection of illegal
commissions, transportation of liquor, procurement and distribution of
duplicate holograms, financial routing of funds, and manipulation of
licensing processes. Even persons described in the prosecution material
as key actors or integral components of the alleged syndicate have
been granted bail.
13.
It is further submitted that in certain cases bail has been granted
even where recovery of large sums or documentary material was
allegedly linked to the accused persons, whereas in the present case,
no such recovery is attributed to the applicant. He emphasizes that
denial of bail to the present applicant, despite grant of bail to several coaccused having comparable or more serious allegations, results in
unequal treatment and violates settled principles of parity applied in bail
jurisprudence.
14.
Learned senior counsel for the applicant further submits that the
principle of parity squarely operates in favour of the present applicant
inasmuch as a large number of co-accused persons, against whom
allegations are either identical or more serious in nature, have already
been enlarged on bail by the Apex Court as well as by this Court.
15.
It is submitted that when principal actors, intermediaries, and
persons allegedly responsible for operational and financial aspects of
the alleged syndicate have been granted bail, continued incarceration of
the present applicant, against whom no recovery is attributed and
whose role is comparatively limited, becomes legally unsustainable.
16.
It is submitted that many of the above co-accused persons are
alleged to have played central roles in collection of illegal proceeds,
distribution operations, procurement logistics, financial routing, and
licensing arrangements forming part of the prosecution narrative.
Despite the gravity of allegations attributed to them, they have been
granted bail by constitutional courts. In contrast, the present applicant is
not alleged to have been a policy maker, financial controller, or
beneficiary of the alleged proceeds, and no recovery has been made
from him.
17.
Thus, continued detention of the applicant, when similarly or more
seriously implicated co-accused stand enlarged on bail, results in
unequal treatment and violates settled principles governing bail on
grounds of parity.
III.
No Recovery or Direct Evidence Against the Applicant
18.
Learned counsel for the applicant contends that no incriminating
recovery whatsoever has been made from the applicant, nor has any
property belonging to him been attached by the investigating agency.
According to the prosecution version, the applicant is alleged to have
provided logistical assistance by allowing use of premises connected
with his family business for storage or movement of funds allegedly
generated through illegal activities. However, counsel submits that
despite prolonged investigation, no money, documents or incriminating
material has been seized from the applicant linking him directly with
alleged illegal collections.
19.
It is argued that the entire case against the applicant rests upon
inferential assumptions and statements recorded during investigation,
rather than direct evidence demonstrating personal involvement in any
illegal act. He submits that continued incarceration in absence of
recovery or concrete evidence directly connecting the applicant to
commission of offences militates against settled principles that bail is the
rule and jail an exception, particularly where investigation is already
complete.
IV.
Allegations Based on WhatsApp Chats are Inadmissible
20.
Learned Sr. Counsel for the applicant further submits that the
prosecution seeks to rely upon certain WhatsApp communications
allegedly exchanged between co-accused persons, including the
applicant’s father and other individuals. However, there is no direct
communication involving the present applicant in those chats. It is
contended that such electronic records have neither been properly
seized nor accompanied by certification compliant with Section 65B of
the Indian Evidence Act, nor has the chain of custody or forensic
verification been established.
21.
It is submitted that the alleged chats are incomplete, selectively
extracted, and taken out of context, and even otherwise do not disclose
any specific criminal act attributable to the applicant. Thus, the
prosecution material presently relied upon lacks evidentiary reliability
and cannot justify continued detention of the applicant.
V. Applicant Has Cooperated with Investigation
22.
It is contended that the applicant has throughout cooperated with
investigative proceedings. Pursuant to directions issued in earlier
proceedings before constitutional courts, he appeared before the
investigating agency on multiple occasions and participated in inquiry.
Even at the stage when summons were issued, the applicant presented
himself before the investigating agency, whereupon he was taken into
custody. There is no allegation of non-cooperation, evasion, or attempt
to abscond. The applicant has no criminal antecedents, has deep roots
in society, and is not a flight risk. It is therefore submitted that continued
detention is unnecessary for purposes of investigation or trial.
VI. Nature of Allegations and Role Attributed
23.
It is contended that the applicant’s name appears at a later stage
in the investigation and that initially no specific role was attributed to him
in the FIR. His implication has emerged subsequently on the basis of
statements and alleged financial linkages connected with family
business operations. He submits that the allegations at best suggest
peripheral involvement in transactions without demonstrating that the
applicant was part of any decision-making or operational mechanism of
the alleged syndicate. Given the magnitude of the case involving
numerous accused persons and complex financial allegations, the
applicant cannot be singled out for prolonged incarceration where
investigation has concluded and trial is yet to begin.
VII. Bail not to be denied as Pre-trial punishment
24.
It is argued that criminal law presumes innocence until guilt is
established through trial. Pre-trial detention cannot assume the
character of punishment. In economic offences involving voluminous
evidence and large number of accused persons, trial invariably takes
considerable time. Therefore, courts have consistently balanced societal
interest with persona liberty by granting bail subject to conditions
ensuring presence of accused and fairness of trial.
VIII. Prosecution
reliance
on
whatsapp
chats
is
legally
unsustainable
25.
It is submitted that the prosecution seeks to build its case
substantially on certain Whatsapp chat that communications allegedly
exchanged between co-accused persons, particularly involving the
applicant’s father and other accused individuals. However, it is
emphasized that no chats directly involving the present applicant have
been recovered or produced.. He submits that the investigating agency
has neither seized nor examined the mobile phone or electronic device
of the applicant from which any such communication could be shown to
have originated. Even the device of the applicant’s father, from whom
communications are alleged, was not seized by the investigating
agency.
26.
As per the prosecution’s own case, the alleged chat data was
obtained from a mobile phone seized by the Income Tax Department
belonging to a co-accused person. Thus, the alleged chats are not
recovered from the applicant or any device under his control. It is further
contended that the prosecution has failed to establish the chain of
custody of electronic data, the method of extraction,
preservation
protocols,
the
forensic
verification
or
authenticity
of
alleged
communications.
27.
No forensic laboratory report certifying integrity or originality of
data has been filed. There exists an unexplained break in custody
regarding transfer of electronic material from the Income Tax
Department to the present investigating agency.
28.
In absence of proof of lawful seizure and secure custody, the
electronic material is susceptible to tampering, thereby rendering it
unreliable. Further, mandatory compliance with Section 65B of the
Indian Evidence Act has not been satisfied. No valid certificate
authenticating electronic records has been produced.
Reliance is
placed upon the judgment of the Apex Court in Anvar P.V. v. P.K.
Basheer (2014) 10 SCC 473, wherein it has been authoritatively held
that electronic evidence is admissible only upon strict compliance with
Section 65B requirements. In absence of such certification, electronic
records cannot be relied upon. Thus, reliance upon such inadmissible
material cannot justify denial of bail.
IX.
No Prima Facie Offence Made Out Against the Applicant at
Bail Stage
29.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the evidence relied
upon by the prosecution against the applicant is weak and inferential in
nature. No direct material establishes participation of the applicant in
any alleged criminal conspiracy or illegal transaction. It is submitted that
detailed examination of evidence and documentary material is a matter
for trial and ought not to be undertaken at the stage of bail
consideration. Reliance is placed on the principle reiterated by the Apex
Court in Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote (1980) 2 SCC
559, wherein it has been held that detailed appreciation of evidence is
not required while deciding bail applications. Further reliance is placed
upon P. Chidambaram v. Central Bureau of Investigation (2020) 13
SCC 337, wherein the Apex Court held that at bail stage, courts are not
to conduct meticulous examination of evidence and that liberty cannot
be curtailed solely on seriousness of allegations when investigation is
complete. Hence, counsel submits that elaborate scrutiny of merits at
this stage would amount to pre-judging issues reserved for trial.
X. Absence of Mens Rea or Meeting of Minds
30.
It is further submitted that even assuming prosecution allegations
at their face value, there is no material demonstrating conscious
participation or meeting of minds on the part of the applicant with other
accused persons. He submits that the applicant is sought to be
implicated merely on account of business associations or familial
connections, which cannot substitute proof of criminal intent. Reliance
is placed upon judicial precedents emphasizing that criminal conspiracy
requires proof of agreement or intentional participation, and mere
association is insufficient Reference is made to decisions including
Rohit Tandon v. Directorate of Enforcement (2018) 11 SCC 46,
where the Apex Court stressed the necessity of establishing deliberate
involvement for sustaining prosecution. Thus, absence of demonstrable
mens rea further weakens the prosecution case against the applicant at
this stage.
XI. Investigation Completed — Continued Custody Serves No
Purpose
31.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that investigation
insofar as the present applicant is concerned stands concluded and the
supplementary charge-sheet has already been filed. The applicant is no
longer required for custodial interrogation. The prosecution has not
shown as to how continued incarceration would advance the
investigation or trial. It is submitted that the Apex Court has consistently
reiterated that detention after completion of investigation must be
justified by compelling reasons. Reliance is placed upon Gurcharan
Singh v. State (Delhi Administration) (1978) 1 SCC 118, wherein it
has been observed that bail is the rule and jail an exception, particularly
when investigation is complete.
Thus, continued custody becomes
punitive rather than preventive.
XII. Applicant Fully Satisfies the Triple Test for Bail
32.
Learned counsel
for the applicant submits that the applicant
satisfies the well-settled triple test governing grant of bail:
•
No flight risk — The applicant is a permanent resident with deep
roots in society and business interests within the jurisdiction of the
Court.
•
No possibility of tampering with evidence — Investigation is
complete and evidence already stands collected by the agency.
•
No likelihood of influencing witnesses — No specific allegation of
interference has been made.
33.
It is further submitted that mere apprehension, unsupported by
material, cannot justify continued detention. Reliance is again placed
upon P. Chidambaram v. CBI (2020) 13 SCC 337, wherein the Apex
Court emphasized that denial of bail must be based on concrete
reasons relating to the triple test. The applicant undertakes to abide by
any stringent condition imposed by this Court.
XIII.
Applicant’s
Conduct
Demonstrates
Cooperation
with
Investigation
34.
Counsel
further
submits
that
allegations
regarding
non-
appearance before investigating authorities are factually incorrect.
Replies to summons were duly furnished and the agency was informed
regarding medical condition of the applicant’s father. Subsequently,
pursuant to directions issued in proceedings before constitutional courts,
the applicant appeared before the investigating agency on several dates
in January 2025. After dismissal of earlier proceedings by the Apex
Court with liberty to seek regular bail, the applicant again complied with
summons dated 17.09.2025 and appeared before the investigating
authority on 19.09.2025, whereupon he was arrested.
These facts
establish consistent cooperation rather than evasion.
XIV.
Earlier
Proceedings
Cannot
Prejudice
Present
Bail
Consideration
35.
It is further contended that the Apex Court, while dismissing
earlier proceedings, specifically granted liberty to the applicant to seek
regular bail and directed that such applications be considered
independently on their own merits. Therefore, prior observations or
orders cannot influence present bail adjudication. Thus, reliance upon
dismissal of earlier petitions to oppose bail is legally impermissible.
XV. Large Majority of Accused Already Enlarged on Bail
36.
Learned counsel submits that out of the large number of accused
persons arrayed in the case, a substantial majority have already been
granted bail either by the Apex Court or this Hon’ble Court. Persons
alleged to be key actors, intermediaries, officials and beneficiaries of
alleged illegal transactions are already on bail. Denial of bail to the
present applicant, alleged to have played a lesser role and against
whom no recovery is made, results in discriminatory treatment. Parity
principle, therefore, squarely operates in favour of the applicant.
XVI. Cumulative Effect of Circumstances Favors Bail
37.
It is submitted that cumulative factors, namely, completion of
investigation,
absence
of
recovery,
weak
evidentiary
basis,
inadmissibility of electronic material, grant of bail to co-accused,
cooperation of applicant, absence of flight risk and delay in trial,
collectively justify grant of bail. It is therefore contended that the
applicant is entitled to the concession of regular bail on the principle of
parity alone, wholly apart from the manifold other grounds advanced
hereinabove.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
38.
On behalf of the State/Non-Applicant, the present bail application
is strongly opposed. He submits that the applicant seeks enlargement
on bail in connection with Crime No. 04/2024 registered by Economic
Offences Wing/ACB, Raipur, concerning offences punishable under
Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 120-B IPC and Sections 7 and 12 of the
Prevention of Corruption Act. He therefore submits as under:
I. Case Reveals a Deep-Rooted and Organized Criminal Conspiracy
39.
The investigation conducted so far discloses existence of a well-
structured criminal syndicate operating within the State machinery
relating to liquor policy and distribution, involving influential private
individuals, government functionaries, transporters, suppliers, and
intermediaries. The conspiracy was not an isolated act but a systematic
manipulation of the State liquor distribution system, resulting in illegal
enrichment through:
•
Collection of illegal commissions from distilleries and suppliers,
•
Sale of unaccounted liquor through State-run outlets,
•
Use of fake holograms and manipulated distribution channels,
•
Forced illegal gratification from suppliers and transporters,
•
Systematic routing and distribution of proceeds of crime.
•
The investigation shows that proceeds of crime were collected,
stored, moved and distributed through trusted associates and
controlled premises forming part of a coordinated criminal
mechanism.
40.
The applicant is not a peripheral participant but a trusted
operative entrusted with custody and operational handling of tainted
cash, thereby becoming a crucial link in execution of the conspiracy.
II.
Applicant’s Active Role in Custody and Movement of Illegal
Cash
41.
Investigation reveals that large amounts of cash were brought and
stored in premises connected with the applicant and his family network,
including hotel premises where tainted money was stored and
subsequently distributed as per instructions of principal conspirators.
The material collected during investigation shows that the cash collected
by associates was brought in bags and stored in hotel premises, the
applicant and his family members facilitated storage of money,
movement and delivery of cash to beneficiaries were undertaken
through this controlled mechanism and the applicant acted under direct
instructions of principal accused persons and played an operational role
in cash distribution.
Thus, the applicant acted not merely as an observer but as a
custodian and facilitator in movement and concealment of illegal
proceeds.
III. Digital Evidence Establishes Applicant’s Direct Involvement
42.
A consolidated technical analysis of WhatsApp communications
exchanged between principal accused persons and the applicant during
the relevant period discloses a structured mechanism for illegal cash
distribution. The Chats include coded instructions and ledger-like entries
correlating with movement of large sums of money. These entries
contain references to coded persons and locations corresponding to
beneficiaries and distribution points. The chats and correlated digital
analysis demonstrate:
•
Structured distribution of illegal funds,
•
Use of coded references to conceal identity,
•
Repeated
instructions
corresponding
with
actual
cash
movements,
•
Entries indicating payment scheduling and distribution channels.
•
The extracted material establishes a continuous digital trail
showing the applicant’s involvement in operational aspects of
illegal cash handling.
Thus, the prosecution case is not based on mere suspicion but
supported by digital and circumstantial evidence forming a cogent chain
linking the applicant with proceeds of crime.
IV. Massive Financial Impact on State Revenue
43.
Investigation conducted so far reveals a massive financial impact
upon State revenue, demonstrating seriousness of the offence. The
investigation has established:
•
Illegal
commission
collected
from
distilleries
approximates
₹319.32 Crores.
•
Sale of unaccounted country liquor resulted in revenue loss
approximating ₹2,174.60 Crores.
•
Additional
illegal
collections
under
various
supply
heads
approximate ₹52 Crores.
Thus, from country liquor operations alone, illegal proceeds amount to
approximately ₹2,545.93 Crores. Further investigation in foreign liquor
segment reveals:
•
Illegal commission from FL/IMFL and beer approximating ₹88.69
Crores,
•
Additional illegal collections of about ₹21.56 Crores,Further illegal
gains approximating ₹171.64 Crores traced through license
arrangements.
•
Collectively, illegal commission from foreign liquor operations
amounts to approximately ₹281.89 Crores.
44.
Thus, overall illegal commission traced so far approximates
₹2,827.82 Crores. Additionally, misuse of licensing policy resulted in
undue profits of approximately ₹248.50 Crores, directly constituting loss
to State revenue. Consequently, cumulative financial impact identified
during investigation approximates ₹3,076 Crores, with strong likelihood
of total impact exceeding ₹4,000 Crores, as investigation into additional
layers continues. The magnitude of economic impact itself demonstrates
the seriousness of the offence and the need for strict judicial scrutiny
while considering bail.
V. Investigation is Continuing and Further Layers Are Being
Uncovered
45.
Learned State counsel submits that the investigation is still
ongoing due to the multi-layered nature of the conspiracy. Though
charge-sheets have been filed against multiple accused persons,
supplementary investigations continue to uncover:
•
Additional money trails,
•
Beneficiary chains,
•
Further intermediaries,
•
Additional illegal revenue streams.
•
Eight charge-sheets have already been filed and investigation
continues in respect of additional accused persons and financial
transactions.
Thus, mere filing of charge-sheet does not conclude investigation,
and custodial presence of key operatives remains necessary to prevent
obstruction and tampering.
VI. Applicant’s Capacity to Influence Witnesses and Evidence
46.
The applicant, being part of a network handling distribution
channels and custodial operations, is connected with multiple witnesses
and operational persons involved in the conspiracy. If released on bail,
there exists a real and substantial likelihood that:
•
Witnesses may be influenced,
•
Evidence chains may be disrupted,
•
Financial trails may be obstructed,
•
Further investigation may be hampered.
Given the applicant’s operational role and influence within the
network, release on bail at this stage poses serious risk to fair trial and
investigation.
VII. Economic Offences Require Strict Approach in Bail Matters
47.
It is respectfully submitted that economic offences involving
organized corruption and massive public revenue loss stand on a
different footing than ordinary offences. The Apex Court has repeatedly
held that economic offences having deep-rooted conspiracies and
causing serious loss to public funds require a strict approach in bail
matters, as such offences affect the entire economic fabric of society.
Given the magnitude and organized nature of the present offence, the
applicant does not deserve discretionary relief of bail.
VIII. Parity Not Applicable in Present Case
48.
The applicant seeks bail on parity with co-accused. However,
parity is not automatic and must depend upon role and material against
each accused. In the present case, investigation shows applicant’s
direct operational involvement in custody and distribution of proceeds of
crime. His role is distinct and significant. Therefore, bail granted to other
accused persons cannot automatically entitle the present applicant to
bail.
IX. Real and Grave Possibility of Influencing Witnesses and
Tampering with Evidence
49.
It is respectfully submitted that the investigation has disclosed that
the applicant occupied a position of operational trust within the illegal
cash collection and distribution mechanism. Several material witnesses,
including departmental officials, transport intermediaries, hotel staff, and
persons connected with custody and delivery of illegal cash, are directly
or indirectly connected with the applicant. If enlarged on bail at this
stage, there exists a grave and real likelihood of the applicant
influencing or intimidating key witnesses, particularly those connected
with cash handling operations and distribution channels.
50.
There is also a serious apprehension that the applicant may
interfere with documentary and digital evidence forming part of the
banking trail, registry records and annexure-linked material, or may
facilitate alteration or destruction of records necessary for effective
investigation. Further, the applicant is in a position to obstruct ongoing
investigation by shifting assets, creating benami layers, or otherwise
frustrating tracing and attachment proceedings relating to proceeds of
crime. Thus, continued custody is necessary to ensure a fair and
uninfluenced investigation and trial.
X.
Parity Plea is Misconceived and Inapplicable
51.
The applicant seeks to claim parity with certain co-accused
persons who may have been granted bail. However, it is respectfully
submitted that parity cannot be claimed mechanically. The role attributed
to the present applicant is distinct and graver in nature. He was not a
peripheral participant but was entrusted with custody, supervision and
delivery of tainted cash and functioned as an operational link between
principal conspirators and end beneficiaries. Parity must necessarily be
role-based and cannot be determined merely on the basis of filing of
charge-sheet or duration of custody. Consequently, no benefit of parity
accrues to the present applicant.
XI. Absence of Recovery Does Not Dilute Prosecution Case
52.
The defence seeks to rely upon absence of direct recovery from
the applicant at the time of arrest. It is submitted that in organized
economic offences involving conspiracy and money-trail management,
culpability is not established solely on physical recovery. In the present
case, involvement of the applicant stands supported by digital evidence,
WhatsApp
communications,
ledger-like
“hisab-sheet”
entries,
coordinated conduct of accused persons, and corroborative witness
statements forming part of the charge-sheet. Therefore, absence of
recovery from physical possession of the applicant does not dilute the
prosecution case.
XII. Findings of Hon’ble Division Bench Have Persuasive Value
53.
It is submitted that the Division Bench of this Court, while
considering connected matters involving several co-accused persons
including the present applicant, has already recorded categorical
observations regarding organized nature of the crime and involvement
of accused persons. The Court has observed that the matter pertains to
organized criminal activity involving persons occupying influential
positions and that there exists real likelihood of influencing witnesses
and tampering with evidence. These findings, though rendered in
connected proceedings, carry strong persuasive value and are directly
relevant to the present bail consideration.
XIII. Enormity of Financial Impact Justifies Continued Custody
54.
The Court has earlier recorded that the nature of offences has
resulted in massive loss to the State exchequer, with proceeds of crime
then
estimated
at
approximately
₹2,161
Crores.
Subsequent
investigation and consolidation of financial material have further
expanded the quantification, and updated computations incorporated in
continuing investigation and supplementary charge-sheets reveal that
the total financial impact, including illegal commission and revenue loss,
now approximates ₹3,076 Crores.
55.
Thus, the updated figure does not contradict but supplements
earlier estimates as investigation has uncovered additional layers and
streams of illegal gain. The magnitude of economic loss reinforces
seriousness of offence and justifies cautious judicial approach in bail
matters.
XIV. Applicant’s Proximity to Principal Conspirators
56.
Investigation further shows that the applicant functioned within a
trusted inner circle of the syndicate and maintained operational
proximity with principal conspirators. By virtue of familiarity with
operational details, custody arrangements and persons connected with
transportation and storage of illegal cash, the applicant possesses
capacity to influence witnesses or coordinate alteration of narratives,
thereby posing serious threat to fairness of investigation and trial.
57.
The offence under investigation is not an isolated criminal act but
represents systematic subversion of public revenue mechanisms and
institutional processes. Such offences erode public confidence in
governance and rule of law. Grant of bail at a stage when investigation
continues and substantial material indicates involvement of the applicant
would send an adverse signal and undermine public interest, particularly
in matters involving large-scale economic offences and organized
corruption.
XV. Possibility of Obstruction in Tracing Proceeds of Crime
58.
The conspiracy under investigation is continuing in nature, with
proceeds of crime layered and concealed through complex financial
structures. Release of the applicant at this stage may facilitate
concealment or obstruction in tracing and securing proceeds of crime
and in identifying ultimate beneficiaries. Thus, custodial restraint
remains necessary for effective continuation of investigation.
XVI. Bail Application Deserves Rejection
59.
Considering the organized nature of offence, magnitude of
financial impact, operational role of applicant, existence of digital and
documentary evidence, ongoing investigation, and possibility of
interference with evidence and witnesses, the present bail application is
devoid of merit and deserves dismissal.
60.
Thus, the applicant’s operational role in handling illegal proceeds,
existence of digital and documentary evidence, magnitude of economic
loss exceeding ₹3,000 Crores, ongoing investigation, risk of influencing
witnesses and obstruction, seriousness and organized nature of offence,
the prosecution respectfully submits that no case for grant of bail is
made out.
FINDINGS:
61.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length. Case diary,
charge-sheets filed, documents placed on record and rival submissions
have been carefully examined.
62.
The present application concerns Crime No. 04/2024 registered
by the Economic Offences Wing alleging commission of offences
punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B IPC along with
provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The prosecution case
pertains to alleged manipulation in liquor trade operations resulting in
generation and circulation of illegal proceeds, presently forming subject
matter of a large-scale economic offence investigation.
63.
While the seriousness of the allegations cannot be understated,
the scope of consideration at the stage of bail is limited and does not
involve a detailed appreciation of evidence which is the domain of trial.
I. Principles Governing Grant of Bail
64.
The law governing bail is well settled. The Apex Court has
consistently held that grant or refusal of bail must be governed by
judicial discretion exercised on settled parameters balancing individual
liberty with societal interest. In State of Rajasthan v. Balchand (1977)
4 SCC 308, the Apex Court laid down the foundational principle that
“bail is the rule and jail is the exception.” This principle was reiterated
and elaborated in Gudikanti Narasimhulu v. Public Prosecutor
(1978) 1 SCC 240, wherein the Court emphasized that deprivation of
liberty pending trial must be justified by compelling reasons and cannot
be mechanical.
65.
Similarly, in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI (2012) 1 SCC 40, dealing
with economic offences involving large financial implications, the
Supreme Court observed that seriousness of allegation alone cannot
justify prolonged pre-trial incarceration, particularly when investigation is
complete and trial is likely to take considerable time.
66.
The Court observed that detention pending trial should not
assume punitive character. Further, in Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar
Pradesh (2018) 3 SCC 22, it was reiterated that grant of bail is a
general rule and refusal an exception, and presumption of innocence
continues until conviction.
67.
Likewise, in P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement
(2020) 13 SCC 791, the Apex Court held that gravity of offence is an
important factor, but it cannot be the sole ground to deny bail when the
triple test — flight risk, possibility of tampering with evidence and
likelihood of influencing witnesses is satisfied. Thus, judicial approach
must balance societal interest and personal liberty without pre-judging
guilt.
II. Completion of Investigation and Evidentiary Nature of Material
68.
In the present matter, investigation has substantially progressed
and charge-sheets have been filed. The prosecution case largely rests
upon documentary, digital and financial records which already stand
collected and preserved. Custodial interrogation of the applicant is not
shown to be presently required. Once evidence is documentary in
nature and already secured, continued custody does not materially
advance investigation. The Supreme Court in Sanjay Chandra (supra)
observed that when prosecution relies upon documentary evidence
already in possession of investigating agency, prolonged detention loses
justification.
III. Parity with Co-Accused
69.
A significant factor pressed into service by the applicant is that
several co-accused persons, including those alleged to be principal
actors or beneficiaries of the conspiracy, have already been granted bail
by competent courts. Though parity cannot be mechanically applied,
consistency in judicial approach is necessary to avoid discriminatory
treatment among similarly placed accused.
70.
It is also significant to note that a large number of co-accused
persons, including those alleged to have played principal or more
dominant roles in the alleged conspiracy, have already been enlarged
on bail either by this Court or by the Supreme Court. Illustratively,
Sanjay Mishra and Manish Mishra were granted bail by this Court in
MCRC No. 7093 of 2025 (order dated 23.09.2025); Vijay Bhatia in
MCRC No. 5601 of 2025 (order dated 25.09.2025); Sunil Dutt in
MCRC No. 188 of 2025 (order dated 12.03.2025); Abhishek Singh in
MCRC No. 7790 of 2025 (order dated 11.11.2025); Chaitanya Baghel
in MCRC No. 8224 of 2025; Atul Singh in MCRC No. 8857 of 2025
(order dated 13.01.2026); and Mukesh Manchanda in MCRC No.
8849 of 2025 (order dated 23.09.2025). Similarly, the Apex Court has
granted bail to co-accused Arvind Singh (SLP (Crl.) No. 2608 of 2025,
order dated 19.05.2025), Amit Singh (SLP (Crl.) No. 2545 of 2025,
order dated 19.05.2025), Deepak Duary (SLP (Crl.) No. 298 of 2025,
order dated 07.03.2025), Anurag Dwivedi (SLP (Crl.) No. 18386 of
2024, order dated 07.03.2025) and Arunpati Tripathi (SLP (Crl.) No.
14466 of 2024, order dated 07.03.2025).
71.
In view of the aforesaid orders, continued detention of the present
applicant, whose role is not shown to be graver than those already
released, would be inconsistent with the principle of parity governing bail
jurisprudence.
72.
In Ravindra Saxena v. State of Rajasthan (2010) 1 SCC 684,
the Apex Court held that when co-accused with similar or graver
allegations have been granted bail, denial of bail to another accused
without distinguishing circumstances would be unjustified.
73.
From the material on record, it emerges that co-accused
occupying more dominant roles in the alleged conspiracy have already
been granted bail. The role ascribed to the present applicant remains
primarily operational—confined to the alleged handling and facilitation of
funds, rather than policy formulation or financial decision-making. In
such circumstances, the applicant's continued incarceration demands
compelling justification, which remains wholly unforthcoming.
IV.
Absence of name in FIR and lack of Direct Recovery
74.
The applicant's name admittedly does not figure in the original
FIR, emerging solely during investigation. Though this circumstance
alone does not negate culpability, it constitutes a material factor in
evaluating prima facie involvement at the bail stage. Further no Direct
Recovery has been effected from the applicant. The prosecution's case
rests primarily on digital communications and investigative statements—
evidence documentary in nature, secure against tampering irrespective
of the applicant's custody. In Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram
Kharote, (1980) 2 SCC 559, the Apex Court held that detailed evidence
evaluation is impermissible at the bailstage; courts must confine
themselves to broad probabilities, eschewing a mini-trial.
V. Length of Custody and Delay in Trial
75.
The applicant has remained in custody for a considerable period.
Considering the volume of documentary evidence, multiplicity of
accused persons and complexity of financial transactions, the trial is
unlikely to conclude in the near future. In Sanjay Chandra (supra), the
Apex Court held that detention pending trial should not become
punishment before conviction, particularly when trial is likely to take
substantial time. Personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution
mandates that pre-trial detention should not be unnecessarily
prolonged.
VI. Triple Test Consideration
76.
The prosecution apprehends that release of the applicant may
result in influencing witnesses or obstruction of investigation. However,
no specific instance of such conduct is pointed out. Conditions can
adequately safeguard investigation and trial interests. The Supreme
Court in P. Chidambaram (supra) emphasized that bail conditions can
address concerns relating to tampering or non-cooperation. There is no
material to indicate that the applicant is a flight risk or would evade trial.
Appropriate restrictions can ensure his presence and cooperation.
VII. Balance Between Gravity and Liberty
77.
Undoubtedly, economic offences involving public revenue are
serious in nature. However, seriousness alone cannot eclipse
constitutional mandate of personal liberty. In Sanjay Chandra (supra), it
was clearly held that even in economic offences, detention must be
justified by necessity, not by moral indignation or gravity alone. Thus,
balancing seriousness of allegations with factors such as completion of
investigation, parity, absence of recovery, and prolonged custody,
continued detention of the applicant does not appear necessary.
78.
In view of the totality of circumstances, this Court is of the
considered view that the Investigation qua the applicant stands
substantially
concluded;
Prosecution
evidence
is
predominantly
documentary, amenable to preservation; Several co-accused in more
dominant roles have already secured enlargement on bail; The
applicant's name does not figure in the original FIR; No recovery stands
effected from or attributed to him; Detention has endured for a
considerable duration; Trial commencement and conclusion appear
appreciably distant; and apprehended risks to prosecution can be
adequately circumscribed through stringent conditions.
79.
Accordingly, continued incarceration of the applicant is rendered
untenable at this juncture. Without venturing any opinion on merits
reserved exclusively for trial adjudication, the applicant is ordered to be
enlarged on bail subject to furnishing personal bond and surety to the
satisfaction of the Trial Court, besides complying with the following
conditions:
(i) The applicant shall not, directly or indirectly,
tamper with evidence or contact prosecution
witnesses;
(ii) The applicant shall regularly attend court
proceedings and mark presence as directed;
(iii) The applicant shall not, in any manner,
threaten or influence any person connected
with the case; and
(iv) Violation of any condition shall entail
immediate cancellation of bail.
80.
The application stands allowed in the above terms. The
observations made herein are confined to adjudication of bail and shall
not influence trial proceedings.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Digitally signed
SUGUNA
SUGUNA by
DUBEY
DUBEY Date: 2026.03.03
17:30:26 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review