Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 31 of 2016
Shri Yam Prasad Pradhan,
S/o late Sri Prasad Pradhan,
Resident of Melli Payong,
South Sikkim,
Presently residing at Sichey,
East Sikkim.
… Petitioner/ Defendant.
versus
Mr. Sonam Pradhan,
Resident of Melli Payong,
P.O. & P.S. Melli,
South Sikkim.
… Respondent/ Plaintiff.
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. A.K. Upadhyaya, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Aruna
Chhetri, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Advocate with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(17.03.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The instant petition, preferred under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India, is directed against the order dated
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
15.06.2016 rendered in Title Suit No. 40 of 2013, wherein and
whereunder the Civil Judge, South at Namchi directed the
plaintiff, the defendant, against whom the paternity is claimed by
the plaintiff and mother of the plaintiff for the Deoxyribonucleic
acid test (for short, „DNA test‟). The defendant, as aforestated,
has come up with this instant petition questioning the legality
and validity of the impugned order on several grounds, inter alia,
the direction to undergo DNA test for examining claim of
paternity is per se illegal and violative of constitutional and legal
rights of the defendant/ petitioner herein.
2.
Mr.
A.K.
Upadhyaya,
learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing for the petitioner, would contend that the petitioner
herein has a reputation in the society, undergoing a DNA test
may undermine his reputation and name. Thus, undergoing a
DNA test, as directed by the Civil Court, is violative of
fundamental, constitutional, legal and natural rights. It is further
contended that the Civil Court ought to have decided the Title
Suit for declaration, on examination of other witnesses instead of
directing the DNA test.
It is lastly argued that the evidences
adduced by both the parties are sufficient to decide the dispute
raised in the suit.
3.
On the other hand, Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Senior
Counsel, who was appointed by the Sikkim State Legal Services
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
Authority, to help the plaintiff/respondent herein and assist the
Court, submits that if the defendant undergoes the DNA test, the
truth will come out and the claim of the respondent herein of
being the son of the petitioner herein will be clearly examined
with stronger and cogent reasons. In the facts of the case, other
oral evidences adduced by the parties may not be substantial and
conclusive. Mr. Thinlay relied on a decision of the Supreme Court
in Narain Dutt Tiwari vs. Rohit Shekhar and Another1.
4.
Heard learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
parties.
Examined the pleadings and documents appended
thereto carefully.
5.
The respondent herein filed a suit for declaration/
determination of paternity against the petitioner herein, on
30.11.2013, claiming that the defendant/petitioner herein is the
biological father of the respondent herein. The Civil Court, after
hearing
both
the
parties
framed
the
following
issues
on
23.09.2014: “1.
2.
3.
4.
Whether there was a relationship between the mother of the
plaintiff and the defendant?
Whether the plaintiff is the biological son of the defendant born
through his relationship with Pavitra Darjee (Mother of the
plaintiff)?
Whether the birth certificate filed by the plaintiff is genuine?
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any relief(f), if any?”
Thereafter, the respondent herein preferred an application under
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short,
---------------------------------1
(2012) 12 SCC 554
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
“CPC”) seeking a direction for DNA test of the plaintiff as well as
the defendant. The learned Civil Judge considering all aspects of
the matter initially declined to undergo for a DNA test observing
that “if at a later stage the Court is of the view that the evidence
placed forth by the parties is not sufficient to arrive at a just
determination of the issues, then by invoking the power under
Section 151 CPC, the Court may allow the parties to undergo a
DNA test” vide order dated 04.08.2015.
Thereafter, it appears
that the Civil Court, after examination of the evidences, thought
it appropriate to direct the DNA test of the plaintiff and defendant
to arrive at a conclusive finding, vide the impugned order.
6.
The question which arises for consideration in this
petition is as to whether the DNA test is essential in a suit for
declaration/ determination of paternity when the biological father
is not legally wedded husband of the mother of the petitioner and
whether the same can be denied on the ground of purported dent
in the image of the alleged biological father.
The issue is no
longer res integra.
7.
In Goutam Kundu vs. State of West Bengal and
another2, wherein the petitioner disputed the paternity of the
child and prayed for blood grouping test to determine parentage
------------------------------2
(1993) 3 SCC 418
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
as he was not the father of the child. The Supreme Court held as
under: “18.
Blood grouping test is a useful test to determine the
question of disputed paternity. It can be relied upon by
courts as a circumstantial evidence which ultimately
excludes a certain individual as a father of the child.
However, it requires to be carefully noted no person can be
compelled to give sample of blood for analysis against
his/her will and no adverse inference can be drawn against
him/her for this refusal.”
and observed that the Court must make out a strong prima facie
case before ordering to blood test.
8.
In Sharda vs. Dharmpal3, wherein divorce was
claimed on the basis of mental illness, the medical examination
was directed which was opposed on the ground that it would be
violative of personal liberty granted under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. The Supreme Court laying emphasis on the
fact that it is the primary duty of the Court to see the truth is
arrived at, observed as under: “32.
Yet again the primary duty of a court is to see that
truth is arrived at.
A party to a civil litigation, it is
axiomatic, is not entitled to constitutional protections under
Article 20 of the Constitution of India. Thus, the civil court
although may not have any specific provisions in the Code
of Civil Procedure and the Evidence Act, has an inherent
power in terms of Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
to pass all orders for doing complete justice to the parties to
the suit.
33.
Discretionary power under Section 151 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, it is trite, can be exercised also on an
application filed by the party.”
-------------------------------3
(2003) 4 SCC 493
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
9.
In Bhabani Prasad Jena vs. Convenor Secretary,
Orissa State Commission for Women and another4, wherein
the issue involved was as to whether DNA test in a matter
relating to paternity of the child be directed by the Court, the
Supreme Court observed as under: “21.
In a matter where paternity of a child is in issue
before the court, the use of DNA test is an extremely
delicate and sensitive aspect.
One view is that when
modern science gives the means of ascertaining the
paternity of a child, there should not be any hesitation to
use those means whenever the occasion requires. The
other view is that the court must be reluctant in the use of
such scientific advances and tools which result in invasion of
right to privacy of an individual and may not only be
prejudicial to the rights of the parties but may have
devastating effect on the child. Sometimes the result of
such scientific test may bastardise an innocent child even
though his mother and her spouse were living together
during the time of conception.
22.
In our view, when there is apparent conflict between
the right to privacy of a person not to submit himself
forcibly to medical examination and duty of the court to
reach the truth, the court must exercise its discretion only
after balancing the interests of the parties and on due
consideration whether for a just decision in the matter, DNA
test is eminently needed. DNA test in a matter relating to
paternity of a child should not be directed by the court as a
matter of course or in a routine manner, whenever such a
request is made. The court has to consider diverse aspects
including presumption under Section 112 of the Evidence
Act; pros and cons of such order and the test of “eminent
need” whether it is not possible for the court to reach the
truth without use of such test.”
10.
In yet another decision in Narayan Dutt Tiwari
(supra), the Supreme Court while upholding the direction of the
High Court to undergo DNA test, observed as under:“39.
We, in this context find the judgment of the Court of
Appeal (Civil Division) in G. (Parentage : Blood Sample), In
re : (1997) 1 FLR 360 holding that the court should find
proven forensically what the person by his refusal had
prevented from being established scientifically, to be
apposite. It was further held therein:
“Justice is best served by truth. Justice is not served
by impeding the establishment of truth. No injustice
--------------------------------4
(2010) 8 SCC 633
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
is done to him by conclusively establishing paternity.
If he is the father, his position is put beyond doubt
by the testing, and the justice of his position is
entrenched by the destruction of the mother‟s doubts
and aspersions. If he is not the father, no injustice
is done by acknowledging him to be a devoted
stepfather to a child of the family. Justice to the
child, a factor not to be ignored, demands that the
truth be known when truth can be established, as it
undoubtedly can. Whilst, therefore, I do not in any
way wish to undermine the sincerity of the father‟s
belief that contact is of a continuing good to the child
and that it will be reduced if the mother‟s beliefs
prevail, that contact is best when taking place
against the reality of fact, and fact can be
established by these tests being undertaken.”
(emphasis supplied)
Thorpe, L.J. in his opinion, agreeing with Waite, L.J. that the
appeal should be allowed, said:
“A putative father may seek to avoid his paternity
which science could prove; alternatively, to cling on
to a status that science could disprove. In both
cases selfish motives or emotional anxieties and
needs may drive the refusal to cooperate in the
scientific tests which the court has directed.””
11.
In the case on hand, initially the learned Judge
declined to direct the DNA test, however, after having examined
all the available evidences, it appears that she had come to a
strong prima facie conclusion that the DNA test was essential to
determine the truth in respect of the paternity and accordingly
directed the same by the impugned order.
12.
In the light of aforestated principles of law as laid
down by the Supreme Court, it is well established that the DNA
test may not be directed on the drop of a hat. In a case like this,
where the plaintiff/respondent herein is seeking declaration/
determination
of
parentage
and
also
on
examination
of
evidences, learned Civil Judge found strong prima facie case in
favour of direction of DNA test, the impugned order is proper.
W.P.(C) No. 31 of 2016
Yam Pd. Pradhan vs. Sonam Pradhan
The other factor of reputation of the petitioner being damaged as
stated by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner
is concerned, the DNA test will establish the reputation of the
petitioner, if the claim of the plaintiff/respondent herein is not
established.
13.
In such view of the matter, I am of the considered
view that the impugned order directing DNA test of the
defendant/petitioner
mother
of
the
herein,
plaintiff/respondent
plaintiff/respondent
herein,
herein
after
and
proper
examination, is neither erroneous nor illegal and also not
violative of the petitioner‟s fundamental, legal or natural rights.
14.
As a result, interference is not warranted and the writ
petition is dismissed
However, I make it clear that the State
Authorities, Doctors and Forensic Laboratory Experts dealing with
the DNA test shall maintain the confidentiality and the report be
submitted in a sealed cover to the Court.
15.
No order as to costs.
Sd/Chief Justice
17.03.2017
jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review