Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
‘C.R.’
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BECHU KURIAN THOMAS
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
PETITIONERS :
XAVIER J. PONNEZHATH,AGED 51 YEARS
S/O. LATE P.V. JOSEPH, PONNEZHATH HOUSE,
VAYALAR JUNCTION, PATTANAKAD P.O.,
CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA, PIN – 686 531.
JOSE J. PONNEZHATH, AGED 58 YEARS
S/O. LATE P.V. JOSEPH, PONNEZHATH HOUSE, CMC-11,
CHERTHALA P.O., ALAPPUZHA-688524, PIN – 688 524.
BY ADVS. NIRMAL.S
GINI GEORGE
VEENA HARI
RIA ELIZABETH JOSEPH
IRENE ELZA SOJI
K. REMIYA RAMACHANDRAN
VARUN MURALEEDHARAN
RESPONDENTS :
STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
TAXES DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695 001.
THE REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER AND SUB COLLECTOR,
DISTRICT COURT WAY ROAD, KIDANGAMPARAMP,
THODANKULANGARA, THATHAMPALLLY,
ALAPPUZHA-688 013.
THE TAHASILDAR,
CHERTHALA TALUK OFFICE,
CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA- 688524.
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
THE ADDL. TAHASILDAR,
CHERTHALA THALUK OFFICE, CHERTHALA,
ALAPPUZHA-688 524.
BY ADV PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
SR.GP DR.THUSHARA JAMES
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
19.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
“C.R.”
BECHU KURIAN THOMAS, J.
......….............................................
W.P.(C) No.31404 of 2022
…................................................
Dated this the 19th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
Petitioners challenge an order of assessment dated 30.08.2022, assessing
petitioners’ building to tax under the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975.
2. Petitioners’ commercial building having an extent of 1328 sq.m, was
subjected to an assessment on 01.01.2016 under Section 5 of the Kerala
Building Tax, 1975 [for short, ‘the Act’] imposing an amount of
Rs.6,01,200/-. The date of completion of the said building was shown as
28.10.2015. While so, on 06.05.2016, petitioners obtained permission to
construct a trusswork over the roof of the building. After completion of the
trusswork, Ext.P6 order of assessment was issued on 01.03.2018, imposing
building tax of Rs.2,80,800/- due to the increase in the plinth area of the
building on account of the trusswork. The total area was thus calculated as
2604.08 sq.m, including an addition of 1276.08 sq.m.
3. Petitioners challenged the order of assessment dated 01.03.2018 before
this Court in W.P(C) No.9660/2018, pointing out the absence of any notice
given to them before issuing the said order of assessment. Petitioners had
also, in the meantime, preferred an appeal to the appellate authority,
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
against the order of assessment dated 01.03.2018. By judgment dated
07.06.2018 in W.P(C) No. 9660/2018, the assessment order was set aside
and a fresh consideration was directed. In the meantime, the appeal was
taken up for consideration, and despite noticing the judgment of this Court
in W.P.(C) No.9660/2018, the appellate authority confirmed the order of
assessment. It is curious to note that the order of assessment dated
01.03.2018 which had already been set aside by this Court, was confirmed
by the appellate authority, even after noticing that judgment. Petitioners
were thus compelled to approach this Court once again, in W.P.(C)
No.25557/2020, and by judgment dated 20.11.2020, the order of the
appellate authority was set aside and the assessing officer was directed to
consider the matter as directed in the judgment in W.P.(C) No.9660/2018.
4. Pursuant to the above direction, the assessing officer reconsidered the
matter and issued the impugned order dated 30.08.2022, assessing
petitioners’ building to tax under the Act calculating the plinth area as
2610.18 sq.m by including the area under the trusswork also as part of the
plinth area. Without preferring any appeal, petitioners have approached
this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
5. Petitioners contended that the area under the roof cannot be included in
the plinth area and it cannot be subject to assessment under the Act as it
is not fully enclosed. Petitioners have also claimed the benefit of levy of
only 50% of the rate of tax for the building due to the rain water
harvesting facility and solar panel installations provided on the building on
the basis of Note (3) to Schedule I of the Act.
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
6. A counter affidavit has been filed by the third respondent, stating that the
area under the trusswork is also liable to be taxed and further that
petitioners are not entitled for any reduction in the rate of tax at 50% due
to rain water harvesting facility and solar panel installations since the
Government has not yet notified, the measurements and specifications in
the Gazette.
7. I have heard Adv. Gini George, on behalf of Adv.Nirmal S., the learned
counsel for the petitioners and Dr.Thushara James, the learned Senior
Government Pleader.
8. The question that requires resolution is whether the assessment of
building tax under the Act is liable to be interfered with or not.
The
contention raised by the petitioners regarding the entitlement for
reduction in rate of tax at 50% on the basis of Note (3) to Schedule I of the
Act, will arise only if there is any construction work carried out after
installation of the solar panels. Concededly, petitioners carried out
installation of the solar panels only on 10.08.2017 as per Ext.P11. The
claim for benefit of reduced rate of tax based on the installation of the
solar panels and water harvesting facility will arise only if there is any
additional construction, compelling the building to be subjected to tax
under the Act as on 10.08.2017.
9. The building was already subjected to tax under the Act treating the date
of completion as 28.10.2015. On that day, the solar panel installations or
water harvesting facility was not in existence and hence the question of
any reduced rate of tax did not arise in that assessment. Petitioners had
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
not claimed such a reduced rate as well at that time. The question of
reduced rate of tax arose due to the unilateral assessment of the building
to tax under the Act, after a roof was constructed as a trusswork pursuant
to the permission obtained on 06-05-2016.
10. Concededly, the roof is constructed as a trusswork and it is not fully
enclosed. The impugned order itself observes that the area where the
trusswork has been put up is not fully enclosed though some materials are
kept on the terrace portion. A trusswork constructed over the terrace of a
building, is intended to protect the building from the harmful effects of
weather. Such a roofing by itself, cannot result in the portion underneath
the roof being assessed to tax under the Act as a residential or commercial
building. The purpose of such a roof is to reduce the effects of sweltering
heat hitting the concrete roof or as a protection from incessant rains. The
situation would however be different if, after constructing the roof, the
terrace portion is completely enclosed enabling that area to be used as a
residential portion or for some commercial purpose. In such situations, the
plinth area of the terrace portion should also be included for assessment.
11. In the decision in Padmanabhan K. v. State of Kerala and Others
[2009 (1) KLT 295], it was held that, unless the roof of the terrace is
completely enclosed, it cannot be treated as part of the plinth area for the
purpose of assessment under the Act. This Court went on to hold that a
mere covering of a roof to protect the building from rain and sun does not
make the terrace part of the plinth area, to be assessed to tax irrespective
of whether the building is residential or commercial. The observations in
the said decision being relevant are extracted below:
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
“In other words, an open area with roof cannot be treated as part of the
residential building as it is unfit for residential purpose. Even though the
terrace covered with roof may be used for several purposes such as
drying of clothes, for recreational purposes, etc., such use cannot be
treated as use for residential purpose. Therefore, open terrace even after
giving roof to it does not become part of plinth area used for residential
purpose…….. A roof cover prevents absorption of heat by the building
and therefore, unnecessary air conditioning is avoided. Similarly when
the building is protected from heat and rain, maintenance cost is reduced
and it's life is also extended. In fact, concrete buildings absorbing heat in
the day time and radiating the heat to the atmosphere in the night
causes increase in atmosphere temperature even in the night causing
discomfort not only to the occupants but to the neighbours. .………A roof
cover on top of the terrace, whether it be made of metal, fibre, or tile,
makes collection of clean rain water easy. Therefore, in public interest,
construction of roof cover over concrete buildings is something which
should be encouraged by providing all incentives by the Government.
However, I make it clear that if such terrace in full or part is enclosed with
bricks, walls, grills, wood or the like, such enclosed area will become part
of the residential area of the building for the purpose of assessment of
building tax and luxury tax under the Act.”
12. Yet again, a Division Bench of this Court had, in State of Kerala and
Others v. M/s.Southern Fisheries Corporation 2011 (1) KHC 794
considered a similar issue and held that mere covering of roof to protect
the building from sun and rain will not make the plinth area of the terrace
a part of the building for assessment under the Act.
13. In the instant case, as noted earlier, it is evident from the order of the
assessing officer itself, that the area beneath the trusswork is not fully
enclosed. The assessing officer has come to a finding that the area is only
partially enclosed [ഭാഗികമായി ചുറ്റും മറച്ചിട്ടുള്ളതാണ് ]. It is noticed from
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
the photographs produced by the petitioners that the partial enclosure
referred to is the parapet, which forms part of the terrace portion. A
parapet or a railing on the terrace portion of a building is a safety
requirement and for some types of constructions, it is mandatory under
the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, 2019. Merely because the terrace
portion is covered by a roofing sheet and has a parapet, the said portion
cannot be included as part of the plinth area of the building. Further, if the
area under the roof is not fully enclosed and used either for residential or
for commercial purposes, such an area cannot be assessed to building tax.
14. From a reading of the impugned order, it is evident that the area beneath
the trusswork has not been included as part of the plinth area for the
purpose of assessing tax since it was not fully enclosed. The assessing
authority has no case that the terrace portion is being used for residential
purposes or for any commercial activity, directly or indirectly. Petitioners
in the instant case, have contended that the materials kept in the terrace
portion of the building are only batteries and other materials required for
the solar panels and that the said portion is not utilized for the convenient
enjoyment of the building.
15. Considering the observations and findings in the impugned order, I am of
the view that since the area under the roof is concededly not fully
enclosed, it cannot be subjected to tax under the Act. Further, merely
because some materials are kept in the terrace portion of the building,
unless those materials are connected to the commercial activity being
carried on in the remaining portion of the building like the stock-in-trade or
otherwise, that cannot result in the area under the trusswork to be treated
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
2025:KER:23364
as plinth area to be assessed to tax under the Act. Similarly, if the building
is residential in nature, unless the area is made habitable, it cannot be
treated as part of the plinth area.
16. In this context, it is relevant to refer to the observations of a learned Single
Judge in Geomon Joseph v. State of Kerala (W.P.(C) No.10217 of 2023)
that an area which is not used for habitation, but used only for drying
clothes and storage purposes, cannot be included for calculating the plinth
area under the Act. It was also observed that even future use cannot be
taken into consideration while determining the building tax and if the area
is made habitable and used for habitation in future, building tax can be
revised at that time.
17. In the instant case, though the learned Government Pleader vehemently
contended that the matter be remitted to the assessing authority for a
fresh consideration, I am of the view that in the light of the specific finding
that the area below the trusswork is not fully enclosed, no purpose will be
achieved by a remand, especially when, if any change is effected at any
time in the future, the authority is empowered to revise the building tax
based on the changes brought about.
Accordingly, Ext.P15 order of
assessment dated 30.08.2022 is set aside.
The writ petition is allowed as above.
Sd/BECHU KURIAN THOMAS
JUDGE
AMV/20/03/2025
WP(C) NO. 31404 OF 2022
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 31404/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
2025:KER:23364
TRUE COPY OF THE OCCUPANCY CERTIFICATE
ISSUED BY CHERTHALA MUNICIPALITY.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY
01/01/2016
OF
THE
ASSESSMENT
ORDER
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE CHALLAN RECEIPT ISSUED FROM
THE TREASURY BANK DATED 14/01/2016.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE PERMIT DATED 06/05/2016
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE APPROVED SITE PLAN
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
PROCEEDING
NO.
23661/15/G2
DATED
01/03/2018
ISSUED
RESPONDENT
NO.2
AND
FORM
V
ORDER
ASSESSMENT DATED 01/03/2018.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT, DATED 07/06/2018,
IN W.P (C) NO.9660 OF 2018
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL, DATED 07/04/2018,
SUBMITTED BEFORE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.: K 2189/18, DATED
21/10/2020, ISSUED BY 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
JUDGEMENT
25557/2020 DATED 20/11/2020
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. T1-934/17/EIA
DATED
10/08/2017
SANCTIONING
THE
ENERGIZATION
EXHIBIT P12
TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE TRUSS
AREA
EXHIBIT P13
TRUE COPY OF THE BUILDING PLAN EVIDENCING
THE RAIN WATER HARVESTING PLANT
EXHIBIT P14
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION PREFERRED
BEFORE THE 3RD RESPONDENT DATED 25/02/2022
EXHIBIT P15
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
G2-23661/2015/B.T. DATED 30/08/2022
BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
IN
DATED
G2
BY
OF
WP(C)
NO.
ISSUED
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review