Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
WEDNESDAY, THE 31ST DAY OF JULY 2024 / 9TH SRAVANA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 18689 OF 2023
PETITIONER:
DR. VALSAMMA CHACKO
PROFESSOR OF OBSTETRICS & GYNAECOLOGY (RETD),
SENIOR CONSULTANT, OBSTETRICS AND GYNAECOLOGY,
KERALA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695029.
BY ADVS.
AJIT JOY
ANEESH JAMES
SAYUJYA
RESPONDENTS:
LEELAMMA JOSEPH
WIFE OF JOSEPH. J.,
SAROYA, LINK VALLEY KUSUMAGIRI P O,
EDACHIRA ROAD, KAKKANAD, KOCHI, PIN – 682030.
G.G. HOSPITAL, MEDICAL COLLEGE ROAD,
THIRUVANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695011,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
*(DR.SASIKUMAR
SENIOR UROLOGIST, GG HOSPITAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695011)
*(CORRECTED AS PER ORDER DATED 10/10/2023 IN IA
1/23 IN WP(C))
DR.SASIKUMAR, SENIOR UROLOGIST, GG HOSPITAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695011, PRESENTLY WORKING AS
SENIOR COUNSULTANT UROLOGIST, S.P FORT HOSPITAL,
TRIVANDRUM, RESIDING AT T.C. 14/420-3, SASIGIRI,
POONTHI ROAD, KUMARAPURAM, TRIVANDRUM - 695011.
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
*(DR. VIKRAMAN K.R.
UROLOGIST, KIMS HOSPITAL, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM)
*(CORRECTED AS PER ORDER DATED 10/10/2023 IN IA
1/23 IN WP(C))
DR.VIKRAMAN.K.R, UROLOGIST, KIMS HOSPITAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695029, PRESENTLY WORKING AS
SENIOR CONSULTANT UROLOGIST, ANANTHAPURI HOSPITAL
& RESEARCH INSTITUTE, TRIVANDRUM, RESIDING AT
DEEPAM, No.28, NAVARANGAM LANE, MEDICAL COLLGE
P.O., TRIVANDRUM - 695011.
BY ADVS.
SHYAM PADMAN
A.AHZAR
ALEX M SCARIA
JOHNSON GOMEZ
C.M.ANDREWS
BOBY M.SEKHAR
LAYA MARY JOSEPH
HARISH ABRAHAM
NICHU WILLINGTON
ASHWATHI SHYAM
S.BIJU (KIZHAKKANELA)
SANJAY JOHNSON
JOHN GOMEZ
ABIN JACOB MATHEW
ARUN JOHNY
DEEBU R.
ARAVIND PRAKASH
KRISHNADEV K.
SARITHA THOMAS
PAVAN ROSE JOHNSON
ALEN J. CHERUVIL
SAHL ABDUL KADER
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON
23.07.2024,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
31.07.2024
DELIVERED
THE
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
[CR]
A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE, Acg.C.J. & S.MANU, J.
----------------------------------------------------------------W.P.(C.)No.18689 of 2023
----------------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 31st day of July, 2024
JUDGMENT
S.MANU, J.
Brief facts
Appellant in First Appeal No.383/2013 of the National
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) at New
Delhi has preferred this writ petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution. Her appeal was rejected by the NCDRC. The
appeal was directed against judgment of the Kerala State
Consumer
Disputes
C.C.No.10/2005.
filed
by
the
1st
Redressal
Commission
in
The State Commission, in the complaint
respondent
herein,
alleging
medical
negligence, found that the 1st respondent is eligible for
compensation
to
the
tune
of
Rs.22,00,000/-
for
the
negligence and deficiency in service on the part of the
petitioner herein and cost of the treatment undergone by
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
the 1st respondent. As the NCDRC refused to interfere with
the judgment of the State Commission, the petitioner is
seeking interference by this court in exercise of the
supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227.
2.
Preliminary objection
The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the 1 st
respondent raised an objection that a writ petition under
Article 227 will not lie before this court against the order
passed by the NCDRC at New Delhi. He contended that the
jurisdiction vested with the High Court under Article 227 has
to be exercised within the territorial limits of the High Court
and a court or tribunal situated outside the territorial limits
is not amenable to the supervisory jurisdiction vested with
the High Court.
He argued that the NCDRC, as a tribunal
functioning at New Delhi, is not amenable to the supervisory
jurisdiction of this Court. He hence submitted that the writ
petition is to be dismissed as not maintainable. Per contra,
the learned counsel for the petitioner Sri.Ajit Joy submitted
that the matter arose from a judgment of the Kerala State
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission situated within
the territorial limits of this Court and the cause of action
arose within the jurisdiction of this Court.
He therefore
submitted that for the purpose of exercising jurisdiction
under Article 227 this Court is the concerned court and
consequently the writ petition is perfectly maintainable.
Since counsel on both sides relied on various judgments of
the Apex Court and also of a recent judgment of the
Rajasthan High Court and made elaborate submissions on
the issue of maintainability, we find it essential to address
the said issue first.
3.
Submissions of the learned Senior Counsel for the
1st respondent in detail
Sri.Syam Padman, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the 1st respondent argued that a bench of seven Judges
of the Apex Court in L. Chandrakumar v. Union of India
reported in [(1997) 3 SCC 261] considered the scope of
jurisdiction of the High Courts under Article 227 of the
Constitution over tribunals.
Supreme Court held that the
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
jurisdiction conferred upon the High Courts under Articles
226/227 are part of the inviolable basic structure of the
Constitution
and
therefore
this
jurisdiction
cannot
be
ousted. All decisions of the tribunals created under Articles
323A and 323B of the Constitution will be subject to
scrutiny before a Division Bench of the High Court within
whose jurisdiction the tribunal is situated. He stressed that
declaration of law by the constitution bench is emphatic that
the scrutiny by the High Court under Article 227 is
permitted only if the concerned tribunal falls within the
jurisdiction of the High Court. He pointed out a judgment of
a Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in Rajeev
Chaturvedi
v.
Commissioner,
Jaipur
Development
Authority & another [2024 SCC Online Raj 365]. The
Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court considered an
appeal arising from the judgment of a Single Judge by
which
orders
passed
by
the
NCDRC
were
quashed.
Appellant contended that the learned Single Judge wrongly
entertained
the
writ
petition
under
Article
227.
The
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
argument was that the impugned orders challenged in the
writ petition were passed by the NCDRC situated at New
Delhi over which the Rajasthan High Court does not have
superintendence under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Heavy reliance was placed on the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Union
of
India
v.
Alapan
Bandyopadhyay [(2022) 3 SCC 133]. The Division Bench
accepted the contention and held that the writ petition filed
before the Rajasthan High Court against the orders passed
by the NCDRC was not maintainable.
The learned Senior
Counsel argued that the view of the Rajasthan High Court is
eminently correct and we may also follow the same view
and reject this writ petition.
4.
Counter submissions of the learned counsel for
the petitioner
Sri.Ajit
Joy,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner made the following submissions:In Ibrat Faizan v. Om axe Buildhome Private
Limited [2022 SCC OnLine SC 620] the Apex Court has
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
upheld the jurisdiction of the concerned High Court under
Article 227 against orders of the NCDRC. The Apex Court in
Universal Sompo General Insurance Company Limited
v. Suresh Chand Jain & another [AIR 2023 SC 3699]
ruled that parties may approach the jurisdictional High
Court either by way of a writ application under Article 226
or by invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 227. He also submitted that the law laid down
in Union of India v. Alapan Bandyopadhyay (supra)
cannot be applied in the present case as the Apex Court, in
it, was dealing with a case arising from order passed by the
Principal Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal in
exercise of the power under Section 25 of the Administrative
Tribunal Act for transfer of cases. He further submitted that
arising of cause of action within it’s jurisdiction is the basic
factor to determine the jurisdiction of the High Court under
Articles 226 and 227.
He relied on M/s.Kusum Ingots
and Alloys v. Union of India [AIR 2004 SC 2321] in this
regard.
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
5.
Article 227
Article 227 of the Constitution is a replica of S.224
of the Government of India Act, 1935. The provision is akin
to the provisions of the Charter Act, 1861 and the
Government of India Act, 1915 and 1935. The Apex Court in
Waryam Singh v. Amarnath [AIR 1954 SC 215] explained
the
legislative
superintendence
history
on
of
conferment
High
Courts,
of
power
culminating
of
with
incorporation Article 227 in the Constitution. The power of
superintendence
is
judicial
as
well
as
administrative.
Primarily, the power is conferred to ensure that courts and
tribunals within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court
discharge their duties and obligations in accordance with
law.
There are many common features in the matter of
exercising the jurisdiction under Article 226 and supervisory
jurisdiction under Article 227.
However, the jurisdictions
under these Articles have fine distinctions.
We are
concerned in this case, only about the extent of jurisdiction
under Article 227, as the petitioner has specifically invoked
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
the same to institute this writ petition. Therefore, to be
precise, the question to be deliberated is as to whether the
High Court can exercise supervisory jurisdiction under
Article 227 over a tribunal situated outside its territorial
limits.
6.
Indications regarding jurisdiction, in the plain
language of Articles 226 &227.
Comparative reading of Articles 226 and 227,
focusing on the jurisdictional facet, shows that there is
substantial difference between Articles 226 and 227. Article
226(1) confers every High Court with power to issue
directions, orders or writs to any person or authority,
including in appropriate cases, any Government throughout
the territories in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction.
There is a specific mention about “territories in relation to
which it exercises jurisdiction” in this provision. However,
Article 226(2) broadens the jurisdiction by empowering the
Court to exercise jurisdiction when cause of action, wholly
or in part, arises within its territories notwithstanding that
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
seat of Government or Authority or the residence of such
person mentioned in Article 226(1) is not within its
territories. It is to be noted that accrual of cause of action
was added as an additional ground to confer jurisdiction in
Article 226 by way of 15th Amendment Act of 1963. Article
227(1) confers superintendence to the High Court over all
courts and tribunals “throughout the territories in relation to
which
it
exercises
jurisdiction”.
Article
was
not
noticeably
chosen
for
broad
conferment
of
such
a
jurisdiction on the basis of cause of action, as was provided
to Article 226 through the 15 th Amendment Act. Therefore,
plain reading of the provision gives us the impression that
when the High Court exercises power under Article 227, it
can be only over courts and tribunals situated within the
territorial limits of the High Court and whether the cause of
action has arisen within its jurisdiction is not a germane
consideration. Of course, normally, the courts and tribunals
situated within the jurisdiction of a High Court would be
entertaining cases in which the cause of action arose within
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
their respective jurisdictions and in that sense, within the
jurisdiction, correspondingly of the High Court too. However,
the pertinent consideration, revealed from the language of
the Article appears as to whether the situs of the court or
tribunal is within the territories of the High Court.
7.
A)
Relevant case law
L.Chandrakumar v. Union of India [(1997) 3 SCC
261] :Regarding the jurisdiction under Article 227 over
tribunals, judgment of the Apex Court in L.Chandrakumar
v. Union of India [(1997) 3 SCC 261] is the leading
authority. A bench of seven Judges of the Apex Court
considered the realm of power of judicial review conferred
on the High Court under Articles 226/227 in relation to
tribunals constituted either under Article 323A or Article
323B of the Constitution,
in this case.
The Apex Court,
unequivocally held that power of judicial review vested in
the High Court and in the Supreme Court under Articles
226/227 and 32 is part of the basic structure of the
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Constitution. It was held that the power vested in the High
Courts
to
exercise
judicial
superintendence
over
the
decisions of all courts and tribunals within their respective
jurisdictions is also part of the basic structure of the
Constitution.
Apex Court further held that all decisions of
tribunals will be subject to the jurisdiction of the High
Courts under Article 226/227 of the Constitution, before a
Division Bench of the High Court within whose jurisdiction
the
tribunal
concerned
falls.
Thus,
the
judgment
in
Chandrakumar settled the proposition that all decisions of
the tribunals will be subject to scrutiny before a Division
Bench of the High Court within whose jurisdiction the
concerned
tribunal
is
situated.
We
will
extract
the
conclusions in Chandrakumar available in paragraph 99 of
the judgment as reported in SCC :“99. In view of the reasoning adopted by us, we
hold that clause 2(d) of Article 323-A and clause
3(d) of Article 323-B, to the extent they exclude the
jurisdiction of the High Courts and the Supreme
Court
under
Articles
226/227
and
of
the
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Constitution, are unconstitutional. Section 28 of the
Act and the "exclusion of jurisdiction" clauses in all
other
legislations
enacted
under
the
aegis
of
Articles 323-A and 323-B would, to the same
extent,
be
unconstitutional.
The
jurisdiction
conferred upon the High Courts under Articles
226/227 and upon the Supreme Court under Article
32 of the Constitution is a part of the inviolable
basic structure of our Constitution. While this
jurisdiction cannot be ousted, other courts and
Tribunals may perform a supplemental role in
discharging
the
powers
conferred
by
Articles
226/227 and 32 of the Constitution. The Tribunals
created under Article 323-A and Article 323-B of the
Constitution are possessed of the competence to
test
the
constitutional
validity
of
statutory
provisions and rules. All decisions of these Tribunals
will, however, be subject to scrutiny before a
Division Bench of the High Court within whose
jurisdiction
the
Tribunal
concerned
falls.
The
Tribunals will, nevertheless, continue to act like
courts of first instance in respect of the areas of law
for which they have been constituted.
It will not,
therefore, be open for litigants to directly approach
the High Courts even in cases where they question
the vires of statutory legislations (except where the
legislation which creates the particular Tribunal is
challenged) by overlooking the jurisdiction of the
Tribunal concerned. Section 5(6) of the Act is valid
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
and constitutional and is to be interpreted in the
manner we have indicated.”
(Emphasis added)
B)
Union of India v. Alapan Bandyopadhyay [(2022)
3 SCC 133]:(i)
In this case, the Apex Court examined the legality
of a judgment passed by the High Court at Calcutta by
which the High Court set aside an order of the Central
Administrative
Tribunal
(Principal
Bench),
New
Delhi,
transferring an original application which was pending
before the Kolkata Bench to the Principal Bench (New
Delhi).
The Calcutta High Court interfered with the order
passed by the Principal Bench of the Administrative Tribunal.
The Apex Court examined the propriety and legality of the
interference made by the Calcutta High Court. Supreme
Court considered the question as to whether the Calcutta
High Court enjoyed jurisdiction to interfere with the order of
the Principal Bench of the Tribunal situated at New Delhi,
even though the proceeding was originally pending before
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
the Kolkata Bench of the tribunal.
Apex Court specifically
noticed that bundle of facts constituting cause of action for
filing the O.A. before the tribunal conferred jurisdiction on
the Kolkata Bench of the tribunal.
Apex Court held that the
High Court should have confined its consideration firstly to
decide its own territorial jurisdiction for exercising the power
of judicial review. Reference was made to the law laid down
in Chandrakumar's case. Thereafter, it was held thus:“When once a Constitution Bench of this Court
declared the law that “all decisions of Tribunals
created under Article 323A and Article 323B of the
Constitution will be subject to the scrutiny before a
Division Bench of the High Court within whose
jurisdiction the concerned Tribunal falls”, it is
impermissible to make any further construction on
the said issue.”
(ii)
It was further held as follows:“The law thus declared by the Constitution Bench
cannot be revisited by a Bench of lesser quorum or for
that matter by the High Courts by looking into the
bundle of facts to ascertain whether they would
confer territorial jurisdiction to the High Court within
the ambit of Article 226(2) of the Constitution. We are
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
of the considered view that taking another view would
undoubtedly result in indefiniteness and multiplicity in
the matter of jurisdiction in situations when a decision
passed under Section 25 of the Act is to be called in
question especially in cases involving multiple parties
residing within the jurisdiction of different High Courts
albeit aggrieved by one common order passed by the
Chairman at the Principal Bench at New Delhi.”
(iii)
Apex Court applied the above principles and held with
respect to the factual issues arising for consideration as
follows:“On applying the said factual position to the legal
exposition in L.Chandra Kumar's case (supra) it is
crystal clear that the Principal Bench of the Central
Administrative Tribunal at New Delhi, which passed
the order transferring O.A.No.1619/2021 vide order
in
P.T.No.215/2021
falls
within
the
territorial
jurisdiction of High Court of Delhi at New Delhi.
Needless to say, that the power of judicial review of
an
order
transferring
an
Original
Application
pending before a Bench of the Tribunal to another
Bench under Section 25 of the Act can be judicially
reviewed only by a Division Bench of the High Court
within
whose
territorial
passing the same falls.”
jurisdiction
the
Bench
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
(iv)
The order passed by High Court at Calcutta was found
to be without jurisdiction and the same was hence declared
as ab initio void.
(v)
We note that the Apex Court has held in unmistakable
terms that the High Court of Calcutta, within whose
jurisdiction the bench of the tribunal which originally
considered the O.A. was situated, was not correct in
exercising its jurisdiction under Article 227 to interfere with
the order of transfer passed by the Principal Bench situated
at New Delhi.
Hence, despite the part of cause of action
arising within the jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, it
was found that only the High Court within whose jurisdiction
the bench which passed the impugned order could exercise
the jurisdiction under Article 227.
(vi)
Another bench of two judges of the Apex Court, in
Union of India v. Sanjiv Chaturvedi and others [(2023)
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
5 SCC 706], has referred the issue of territorial jurisdiction
of the High Court, with reference to the law laid down in
Alapan Bandyopadhyay for consideration by a larger
bench. However, as far as we are concerned, the law as
explained in Alapan Bandyopadhyay is binding as the
precedential efficacy would not erode on account of a
reference, unless it is varied by a larger bench of the Apex
Court on the basis of the reference.
relevant to note that
In this regard it is
another bench of two judges of the
Apex Court, in Rajnish Kumar Rai v Union of India and
others [(2023) SCC OnLine SC 1222] upheld the judgment
of the High Court of Gujarat, by which it rejected a challenge
against an order passed by the Principal Bench of the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Delhi relying on Alapan
Bandyopadhyay. The Bench of two judges of the Apex
Court noticed the reference in
Sanjiv Chaturvedi and
others and held that judicial propriety demands following
the law laid down in Alapan Bandyopadhyay as no
decision has come from the larger Bench.
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
C)
Ibrat Faizan v. Om axe Buildhome Private Ltd.
[2022 SCC OnLine SC 620]
(i)
In this case an order of stay passed by a learned
Single Judge of the High Court of Delhi in a writ petition filed
under Article 227 of the Constitution against an order of the
NCDRC was under challenge before the Apex Court. The
specific issue considered by the Apex Court was the
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution against the order passed by NCDRC in an
appeal
under
Protection
Act.
Section
After
58(1)(a)(iii)
of
the
Consumer
referring to the judgment of a
Constitution bench of the Apex Court in
Associated
Cement Companies Ltd. v. P.N.Sharma [AIR 1965 SC
1595] and L.Chandrakumar's case (supra) the Apex Court
held as follows:“22. Therefore, the National Commission can be
said to be a 'Tribunal' which is vested by Statute the
powers to determine conclusively the rights of two
or more contending parties with regard to any
matter in controversy between them. Therefore, as
observed herein above in the aforesaid decision, it
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
satisfies the test of an authority vested with the
judicial powers of the State and therefore may be
regarded as a 'Tribunal' within the meaning of
Article 227 and/or 136 of the Constitution of India.
Also, in a given case, this Court may not exercise its
powers under Article 136 of the Constitution of
India, in view of the remedy which may be available
to the aggrieved party before the concerned High
Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
as it is appropriate that aggrieved party approaches
the concerned High Court by way of writ petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.”
(ii) About the propriety of entertaining the writ petition
and exercising jurisdiction under Article 227, which was
under challenge in the case, the Apex Court held thus:“27. In view of the above, in the present case, the High
Court has not committed any error in entertaining the
writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India
against
the
order
passed
by
the
National
Commission which has been passed in an appeal under
Section 58(1)(a)(iii) of the 2019 Act. We are in complete
agreement with the view taken by the High Court.
However, at the same time, it goes without saying that
while exercising the powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, the High Court subjects itself to
the rigor of Article 227 of the Constitution and the High
Court has to exercise the jurisdiction under Article 227
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
within the parameters within which such jurisdiction is
required to be exercised.”
(iii)
While understanding the law laid down by the Apex
Court in this case, it is to be kept in mind that the challenge
was against an order passed by a learned Single Judge of
the Delhi High Court within whose territorial jurisdiction the
NCDRC
falls.
The
expression
'concerned
High
Court'
employed by the Apex Court in this judgment, as it seems to
us, is a reference to the High Court which enjoys the
jurisdiction under Article 227 in the particular case.
D)
Universal
Sompo
General
Insurance
Company
Limited v. Suresh Chand Jain & another [AIR 2023 SC
3699]
(i) Apex Court considered a petition seeking leave to
appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution by the party
who sought to challenge the order of the NCDRC in a first
appeal.
The Supreme Court made extensive reference to
the judgment in the case of Ibrat Faizan v. Om axe
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Buildhome Private Limited [2022 SCC OnLine SC 620].
Finally, the Apex Court concluded as follows:“38. In the aforesaid view of the matter, we have
reached to the conclusion that we should not adjudicate
this petition on merits.
We must ask the petitioner
herein to first go before the jurisdictional High Court
either by way of a writ application under Article 226 of
the
Constitution
or
by
invoking
the
supervisory
jurisdiction of the jurisdictional High Court under Article
227 of the Constitution. Of course, after the High Court
adjudicates and passes a final order, it is always open
for either of the parties to thereafter come before this
Court by filing special leave petition, seeking leave to
appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution,”
(ii) Concerning the factual matrix, it is to be noted that
the original proceedings in this case arose before the State
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi.
E)
Rajeev
Chaturvedi
v.
Commissioner,
Development Authority & another
Jaipur
[2024 SCC OnLine
Raj 365].
In this case, a learned Single Judge of the Rajasthan
High Court, in a writ petition filed under Article 227 of the
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Constitution, set aside an order of the NCDRC. In the intra
court appeal challenging the judgment of the Single Bench,
the
Division
Bench,
mainly
relying
on
Alapan
Bandyopadhyay, held that the Rajasthan High Court
lacked jurisdiction under Article 227 to review orders passed
by the NCDRC seated at Delhi. Judgment of the learned
Single Judge was set aside and the writ petition was
dismissed on the ground of lack of jurisdiction.
8.
Analysis of the contentions
(i) We shall now deal with the contentions raised by
Sri.Ajit Joy, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
regarding maintainability. He placed reliance over the
judgment of the Apex Court in M/s.Kusum Ingots and
Alloys Limited v. Union of India & another [(2004) 6
SCC 254] to contend that even if a part of cause of action
arises within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court, the
same would confer jurisdiction to issue writs. He referred to
the extensive discussion on “cause of action” available in the
judgment. However, the opening paragraph of the judgment
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
shows that the specific question considered by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in M/s.Kusum Ingots and Alloys Limited
(supra) is as to whether the seat of the parliament or
legislature of a State would be a relevant factor for
determining the territorial jurisdiction of a High Court to
entertain a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India. The entire analysis in the case proceeds with
reference to clause (2) of Article 226. Therefore, we are of
the view that the principles discussed and laid down in
M/s.Kusum Ingots and Alloys Limited
(supra) cannot
be considered as an authority to understand the scope and
ambit of the jurisdiction, precisely under Article 227. As we
noted in the beginning, there is substantial difference
between the jurisdictional features of Articles 226 and 227
as revealed from a comparative reading of the provisions.
Arising of cause of action wholly or in part within the
jurisdiction is a factor which enables a High Court to
exercise the jurisdiction under Article 226 by virtue of clause
(2) of Article 226. Conspicuously, such a provision is absent
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
in Article 227. Therefore, arising of cause of action wholly
or in part within the jurisdiction is not the decisive factor to
determine the jurisdiction under Article 227.
The only
aspect relevant is the situs of the court or tribunal
concerned, within the territorial jurisdiction of the High
Court, as discernible from the plain language of the Article.
(ii)
The next contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner is on the basis of the judgment in Ibrat Faizan
(supra). The learned counsel argued that the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held that the orders passed by the
NCDRC can be challenged before the 'concerned High Court'.
However, after scanning the judgment thoroughly, we do not
find anything to the effect that the expression 'concerned
High Court' is used by the Apex Court in relation to ‘any
High Court’ within whose jurisdiction
the cause of action
arose, as canvassed by the learned Counsel. On the other
hand, as we pointed out earlier, the facts of the case would
show that the Apex Court was considering a case arising
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
from Delhi High Court within whose jurisdiction the NCDRC
is situated.
Therefore, we are of the view that the Apex
Court, in Ibrat Faizan (supra) has upheld the jurisdiction of
the Delhi High Court over the NCDRC and no further
inference in this regard is possible. Observations of courts
are to be read and understood in context in which they have
been stated.
Context of the reference to 'concerned High
Court’ in this judgment has to be understood, keeping in
mind that the Hon'ble Supreme Court was considering a
case arising from Delhi High Court.
(iii)
In Universal Sompo cited by Sri.Ajit Joy, the Apex
Court made elaborate reference to Ibrat Faizan and
relegated the parties to go before the jurisdictional High
Court. As already noticed, that was a case arising from the
proceedings
before
the
NCDRC,
Delhi.
In,
Universal
Sompo the Apex Court has followed the principles laid down
in Ibrat Faizan, which we have discussed already.
This
judgment is also not helpful to the petitioner to contend that
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
the writ petition under Article 227 is maintainable before
this Court.
(iv)
The learned Counsel further submitted that the
Rajasthan High Court in Rajeev Chaturvedi has decided
the case relying on Alapan Bandyopadhyay. According to
the learned counsel, the issue considered in
Alapan
Bandyopadhyay was arising from an order of transfer
passed under the provisions of the Administrative Tribunal
Act and the principles laid down cannot be imported and
applied in deciding the issue of exercising jurisdiction over
the NCDRC and its proceedings which are governed by
another Act. We cannot agree with the attempt of the
learned Counsel to distinguish Alapan Bandyopadhyay on
such a ground. Principles laid down in the judgment are
clear and apply in the case of all Tribunals. As we stated
supra, despite the fact that the same is under a reference
for consideration by a larger bench, its precedential value
does not fade and we are bound to follow the same. We are
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
of the view that the Rajasthan High Court has rightly
followed it in Rajeev Chaturvedi.
(v)
We therefore find worth in the contentions raised
by learned Senior Counsel
Sri.Syam Padman on the basis
of the law laid down by the Apex Court in L.Chandrakumar
and by the Rajasthan High Court in Rajeev Chaturvedi.
9.
Conclusions
On an analysis of the above precedents, we find
that
the
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Alapan
Bandyopadhyay (supra)
has categorically held that the
law
the
laid
down
by
Constitution
Bench
in
L.Chandrakumar's case is to the effect that the power
under Article 227 can be exercised only over the courts and
tribunals
situated
within
the
territorial
limits
of
the
respective High Courts. True, another bench of two judges of
the Apex Court has made a reference to larger bench about
the conclusions in Alapan Bandyopadhyay as we find in
Union of India v. Sanjiv Chaturvedi and others (supra).
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Nevertheless,
the
proposition
laid
down
in
Alapan
Bandyopadhyay is still binding on us despite the reference.
Nothing contrary to the said proposition is laid down either
in Ibrat Faizan or Universal Sompo General Insurance
Company Limited. Obviously, Apex Court, in the judgment
in
Alapan
Bandyopadhyay
cautions
that
when
a
Constitution Bench lays down the law it is impermissible to
make any further construction on the said issue. This was
said after specifically referring to the following elucidation by
the Constitution Bench in Chandrakumar – “All decisions of
these Tribunals will, however, be subject to scrutiny before a
Division Bench of the High Court within whose jurisdiction
the concerned Tribunal falls.” As we have referred above, in
Ibrat Faizan it has been held that NCDRC can be regarded
as a tribunal within the meaning of Article 227.
Hence, a
close reading and comprehensive analysis of the precedents
leads us to the conclusion that this Court can exercise the
jurisdiction under Article 227 only over those courts and
tribunals situated within the territorial limits of this Court.
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Hence,
over
the
NCDRC,
falling
within
jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court,
the
territorial
this Court has no
supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227.
Therefore, the writ petition, filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India is dismissed as not maintainable.
Sd/A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE,
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/S.MANU,
JUDGE
skj
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 18689/2023
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
JUDGMENT OF THE HON'BLE SUPREME COURT IN
IBRAT FAIZAN V. OMAXE BUILDHOME PVT.
LTD. 2022 SCC ONLINE SC 620.
Exhibit P2
CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE NCDRC
DATED 27.03.2023.
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 22.02.2013
PASSED BY THE KERALA STATE CONSUMER
DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION.
Exhibit P4
REFERENCE LETTER OF THE
SURGEON DATED 02.09.2003.
MUMBAI
BASED
Exhibit P5 (a)
CASE RECORD OF TREATMENT
RESPONDENT GG HOSPITAL.
AT
2ND
Exhibit P5 (b)
REPORT
OF
THE
PHYSICIAN
OF
2ND
RESPONDENT HOSPITAL DATED 16.09.2003.
Exhibit P6
CASE
RECORD
OF
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Exhibit P7
COPY OF THE COMPLAINT FILED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT IN THE SCDRC.
Exhibit P8
COPY OF THE VERSION FILED
PETITIONER IN THE SCDRC.
Exhibit P9
COPY OF THE VERSION FILED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT IN THE SCDRC.
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE VERSION FILED BY 3RD
RESPONDENT IN THE SCDRC.
Exhibit P11
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
PW1 MRS.LEELAMMA JOSEPH BEFORE THE SCDRC
AS PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
Exhibit P12
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
PW2 SRI. JOSEPH J BEFORE THE SCDRC AS
PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
Exhibit P13
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
DW1 DR. HARIDAS BEFORE THE SCDRC AS
PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
KIMS
THE
HOSPITAL,
BY
THE
W.P.(C).No.18689 of 2023
Exhibit P14
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
DW2 DR. VALSAMMA CHACKO BEFORE THE SCDRC
AS PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
Exhibit P15
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
DW3 DR. N.P. SASIKUMAR BEFORE THE SCDRC
AS PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
Exhibit P16
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
DW4 DR. NAZEEMA BEFORE THE SCDRC AS
PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
Exhibit P17
ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE DEPOSITION OF
DW5 DR. VIKRAMAN K.R. BEFORE THE SCDRC
AS PRODUCED BEFORE THE NCDRC.
Exhibit P18
TRUE COPY OF THE FIRST APPEAL FA. 383 OF
2013 FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE
NCDRC.
Exhibit P19
TRUE
WEB
COPY
OF
ARTICLE
TITLED
"LAPAROSCOPIC HYSTERECTOMY VERSUS TOTAL
ABDOMINAL HYSTERECTOMY: A RETROSPECTIVE
STUDY AT A TERTIARY HOSPITAL" BY MAHMOUD
ELMORSI
ABOULFOTOUH
ET
AL
IN
GYNECOLOGICAL SURGERY (2020).
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review