The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The Managing Director, at Ext.P4, had imposed a punishment of barring of three increments with cumulative effect, which was confirmed -9- throughout. The Managing Director also ordered recovery of Rs.1,14,104/- from the petitioner's salary and on any outstanding remaining, at the time of retirement, from the DCRG. The petitioner, as was noticed above, filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Civil Supplies as per Ext.P5. The Commissioner of Civil Supplies, by Ext.P6, concurred with the findings of the Managing Director and the recovery was reduced to Rs.57,697.93. The punishment of barring of three increments with cumulative effect was confirmed by Ext.P6 by the Commissioner and in Ext.P8 by the Government. The Government too, at Ext.P8, reduced the recovery to a further amount of Rs.31,262.93.
11. The enquiry proceedings having been found to be totally vitiated for reason of absolute violation of principles of natural justice, Ext.P4 order would stand set aside, so also would Exts.P6 and P8 orders. The -10- petitioner, as is indicated from the records (Ext.P9 - Gratuity Payment Order by the Office of the Accountant General (A&E), Kerala), has already retired. It is trite that if a disciplinary enquiry is set aside on the ground of procedural irregularity, the employer be given an opportunity to continue the enquiry from the stage at which it occurred. Herein, there is no question of such opportunity being given since the petitioner employee has already Corporation. retired from the services of the Further, the incidents which led to the disciplinary enquiry itself is prior to 1996 and there would be no purpose served in now remanding the matter to the employer.
12. In such circumstance, disciplinary authority having the orders of the been set aside, the petitioner's increments would be restored and any recovery made also would be paid back to the -11- petitioner. The pay and allowance shall be computed by restoring the increments at the proper time and the arrears due shall be paid within a period of four months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this judgment. The DCRG and other retirement benefits, including pension, if eligible, shall be revised and arrears on that count shall also be paid within the time afore mentioned. The writ petition would stand allowed, setting aside Exts.P4, P6 and P8. The Registry shall send a copy of the judgment to the petitioner and the 1st respondent Corporation, free of cost. jjj Sd/K.VINOD CHANDRAN, 29/3/16
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT:
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.VINOD CHANDRAN
MONDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2016/8TH CHAITHRA, 1938
WP(C).No. 30610 of 2004 (R)
---------------------------PETITIONER:
-------------------A.ABDUL SALIM, ASST. TALUK SUPPLY OFFICER
THIRUVALLA.
BY ADVS. SRI.KKM.SHERIF
SRI.P.M.KUNJIMOIDEENKUTTY
SRI.P.A.MOHAMMED ASHROF
SRI.LAL K.JOSEPH
SRI.A.A.ZIYAD RAHMAN
SMT.K.K.RATNALATHA
RESPONDENTS:
----------------------1. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
KERALA STATE CIVIL SUPPLIES CORPORATION,, MAVELI BHAVAN,
GANDHI NAGAR, ERNAKULAM.
2. THE REGIONAL MANAGER,
KERALA STATE CIVIL SUPPLIES CORPORATION,, KOTTAYAM.
3. THE COMMISSIONER & THE DIRECTOR OF CIVIL SUPPLIES,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
4. THE STATE OF KERALA, REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
FOOD AND CIVIL SUPPLIES DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADV. SRI.GEORGE POONTHOTTAM,SC, KSCSC
R4 BY GOVERNMENT PLEADER
R1 & 2 BY ADV. SRI.LAKSHMI NARAYAN, SC, SUPPLYCO
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 28-03-2016,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C).No. 30610 of 2004 (R)
APPENDIX
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
P1:
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS NO.E-4 6845/95 DATED 15.01.1996
P2:
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO OF CHARGES NO.E4-6845/95 DATED 26.6.1996
P3:
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 02.07.1996
P4:
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS NO.E4-6845/95 DATED 14.8.1997
P5:
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMORANDUM OF APPEAL DATED 5.10.1997
P6:
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.(CS) C8-42742/97 DATED 30.05.2001
P7:
TRUE COPY OF THE REVISION PETITION DAED 10.01.2002
P8:
TRUE COPY OF THE NO. G.O.(RT) NO.159/04/PCS & CAD, DATED 7.6.2004
P9:
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER GPO NO.P-02/DC/G/36527107
P10:
TRUE COPY OF THE MARRIAGE PERMISSION STATEMENT DATED 16.08.2005
ISSUED BY THAMARAKULAM MUSLIM JAMATH COMMITTEE
RESPONDENT'S EXHIBITS
NIL
//TRUE COPY//
P.A. TO JUDGE
JJJ
K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.
-----------------------------------------W.P.(C) No. 30610 of 2004 (R)
-----------------------------------------Dated this the 28th day of March, 2016
JUDGMENT
Despite the above writ petition of 2004 being
shown as Targeted For Disposal (TFD), none appears
for the petitioner or the respondent Corporation when
the matter was called.
Considering the fact that the
writ petition has been pending here for the last 12
years, it was deemed fit that the matter be disposed of
after looking into the records.
I have also heard the
learned Government Pleader.
2.
The challenge raised is against Ext.P4 order of
the Managing Director of the respondent Corporation,
acting as the disciplinary authority of the petitioner, an
employee of the Corporation.
The petitioner, while
working as a Senior Assistant Grade-I, was suspended
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-2-
from service as per Ext.P1, on detection of irregularity
in the stock maintained by the Corporation.
The
irregularities were noticed in an enquiry conducted by
the Internal Audit Wing of the Corporation, which
included
damage
to
commodities
for
reason
of
negligence, failure to obey the instructions of the
superior officer, misappropriation of stocks, forgery of
records and large scale diversion of commodities on the
cover of it being damaged stock. The petitioner was
proceeded against since he was the custodian of stock
during the said period and, hence, the suspension of the
petitioner.
3.
The memo of charges was issued at Ext.P2,
which detailed specifically nine charges of misconduct;
viz: dereliction of duty, gross negligence and utter
irresponsibility. Explanation was sought for by Ext.P2,
which also contained detailed statement of allegations.
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-3-
The petitioner filed his explanation; produced at Ext.P3.
The order passed against the petitioner is seen at
Ext.P4.
One need not look into the facts or the
allegations raised, since the primary ground raised
against the order, as seen at Ext.P5 appeal filed before
the Commissioner of Civil Supplies, is the following:
“It is
respectfully
submitted that the
impugned order is not legally sustainable
as it is issued in gross violation of the
principles
of
natural
justice.
The
Managing Director did not conduct any
enquiry in respect of memo of charge
served on the appellant.
If an enquiry had been accorded all the
allegations
could
be
negatived
in
corroboration with the relevant records
and evidence by the witness.
Hence, on
this ground also, the order is liable to be
nullified.”
4.
It is trite that this Court would not sit in
appeal of the disciplinary proceedings and the order
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-4-
passed by the disciplinary authority nor could there be
a fresh appreciation of facts. This Court, under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, would only interfere
when there is a procedural irregularity inter alia on
account of violation of principles of natural justice or
the findings having been entered into without any
materials on record as substantiating evidence.
This
Court could also interfere if the findings of the enquiry
authority and the disciplinary authority are perverse
and does not reasonably or necessarily emanate from
the evidence on record.
5.
In the present case, suffice it to notice that
Ext.P4 proceedings was a unilateral decision taken by
the Managing Director, after hearing the petitioner.
Apposite would be reference to the 'Subject', as noticed
in Ext.P4, which is extracted herein under:
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-5-
“KSCSC - IAW - Audit Report on the
accounts
of
Taluk
Depot,
Changanacherry - Irregularities detected
- Disciplinary action against Sri. A. Abdul
Salim, S.A.I - suspended from service Memo of charges issued - explanation
obtained - Personal hearing conducted Reinstated into service - Punishment
proposed - concurrence obtained - final
orders issued -”
6.
audit
What is revealed is that on the basis of the
report,
irregularities
were
disclosed
and
disciplinary action against the petitioner was initiated,
suspended him from service and then issued a memo of
charges.
Explanation was also obtained and after
personal hearing the petitioner was reinstated into
service
and
punishment
proposed,
concurrence is obtained and orders passed.
for
which
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-6-
7.
Essentially,
it
is
to
be
noticed
that
no
disciplinary enquiry was carried out wherein the
petitioner was first called upon to answer the charges
and
then
evidence
being
laid
on
behalf
of
the
management; wherein the delinquent employee, was
given sufficient opportunity to peruse the documents
relied on and cross examine the witnesses.
After
completion of the management evidence, it was also
incumbent upon the enquiry officer, whether it be a
person authorised by the disciplinary authority or the
disciplinary authority itself, to proffer an opportunity
for the delinquent employee to offer his defence with
witnesses and documents and the procedure so having
completed, it was also incumbent on the enquiry officer
to submit a report to the disciplinary authority, which
had to be supplied to the delinquent employee before
findings are entered and punishment is proposed, as
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-7-
has been laid down in Managing Director, ECIL v. B.
Karunakar - (1993) 4 SCC 727. A hearing as to the
objections of the petitioner against the report also
would be a necessary requirement for full compliance of
the principles of natural justice.
8.
In the present case, none of the formalities
were carried out by the disciplinary authority.
The
disciplinary authority itself could carry out the enquiry
without authorising a third party, as has been done in
this case. But the explanation having been called for by
the Managing Director, the disciplinary authority, the
delinquent was called upon for a personal hearing and
then a punishment proposed, concurrence obtained,
presumably from the Board and final orders passed.
The enquiry report at Ext.P4 shows that the disciplinary
authority listed out the charges, the explanation to each
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-8-
of such charges and then the findings. The findings are
on the basis of the registers and the statement made by
the Junior Manager (QC) reporting the irregularities.
Neither were any witnesses examined nor were the
documents produced in the manner required in a
disciplinary enquiry.
The findings recorded were, at
best, a subjective opinion of the Managing Director and
in such circumstance the order at Ext.P4 cannot at all
be sustained.
9.
The
counter
affidavit
of
the
respondent
Corporation also does not speak of any proper enquiry
having
been
affording
conducted
adequate
by
taking
opportunity
to
evidence
the
and
delinquent
employee to put forward his defence.
10. The
Managing
Director,
at
Ext.P4,
had
imposed a punishment of barring of three increments
with
cumulative
effect,
which
was
confirmed
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-9-
throughout.
The Managing Director also ordered
recovery of Rs.1,14,104/- from the petitioner's salary
and on any outstanding remaining, at the time of
retirement, from the DCRG.
The petitioner, as was
noticed above, filed an appeal before the Commissioner
of Civil Supplies as per Ext.P5.
The Commissioner of
Civil Supplies, by Ext.P6, concurred with the findings of
the Managing Director and the recovery was reduced to
Rs.57,697.93.
The punishment of barring of three
increments with cumulative effect was confirmed by
Ext.P6 by the Commissioner and in Ext.P8 by the
Government. The Government too, at Ext.P8, reduced
the recovery to a further amount of Rs.31,262.93.
11. The enquiry proceedings having been found to
be totally vitiated for reason of absolute violation of
principles of natural justice, Ext.P4 order would stand
set aside, so also would Exts.P6 and P8 orders.
The
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-10-
petitioner, as is indicated from the records
(Ext.P9 -
Gratuity Payment Order by the Office of the Accountant
General (A&E), Kerala), has already retired. It is trite
that if a disciplinary enquiry is set aside on the ground
of procedural irregularity, the employer be given an
opportunity to continue the enquiry from the stage at
which it occurred. Herein, there is no question of such
opportunity being given since the petitioner employee
has
already
Corporation.
retired
from
the
services
of
the
Further, the incidents which led to the
disciplinary enquiry itself is prior to 1996 and there
would be no purpose served in now remanding the
matter to the employer.
12. In such circumstance,
disciplinary
authority
having
the orders of the
been
set
aside,
the
petitioner's increments would be restored and any
recovery
made
also would
be
paid
back
to
the
W.P.(C) No. 30610/2004
-11-
petitioner. The pay and allowance shall be computed by
restoring the increments at the proper time and the
arrears due shall be paid within a period of four months
from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this
judgment.
The DCRG and other retirement benefits,
including pension, if eligible, shall be revised and
arrears on that count shall also be paid within the time
afore mentioned.
The writ petition would stand allowed, setting aside
Exts.P4, P6 and P8. The Registry shall send a copy of
the judgment to the petitioner and the 1st respondent
Corporation, free of cost.
jjj
Sd/K.VINOD CHANDRAN,
JUDGE
29/3/16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review